Should direct measurements of tumor oxygenation relate to the radiobiological hypoxic fraction of a tumor?

Vascular abnormalities and development of hypoxia in microscopic melanoma xenografts

Background

Studies investigating the oxygenation status and the development of hypoxia in microscopic tumors are sparse. The purpose of this study was to measure the extent of hypoxia in microscopic melanoma xenografts and to search for possible mechanisms leading to the development of hypoxia in these tumors.

Methods

A-07, D-12, R-18, and U-25 human melanoma xenografts grown in dorsal window chambers or as flank tumors were used as preclinical tumor models. Morphologic and functional parameters of vascular networks were assessed with intravital microscopy, and the expression of angiogenesis-related genes was assessed with quantitative PCR. Microvessels, pericytes, and the extent of hypoxia were assessed by immunohistochemistry in microscopic tumors by using CD31, αSMA, and pimonidazole as markers, and the extent of radiobiological hypoxia was assessed in macroscopic flank tumors.

Results

Macroscopic R-18 and U-25 tumors showed extensive hypoxia, whereas macroscopic A-07 and D-12 tumors were less hypoxic. R-18 and U-25 tumors developed hypoxic regions before they reached a size of 2–3 mm in diameter, whereas A-07 and D-12 tumors of similar size did not show hypoxic regions. The development of hypoxic regions was not caused by low vessel density, but was rather a result of inadequate vascular function. Inadequate vascular function was not caused by low vessel diameters or long vessel segments, but was associated with poor vascular pericyte coverage. Poor pericyte coverage was associated with the expression of eight angiogenesis-related genes.

Conclusions

Two of the four investigated melanoma models developed hypoxic regions in microscopic tumors, and the development of hypoxia was associated with poor vascular pericyte coverage and inadequate vascular function.

Assessment of hypoxia and radiation response in intramuscular experimental tumors by dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Studies of intradermal melanoma xenografts have suggested that dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (DCE-MRI) may be a useful method for assessing the extent of hypoxia in tumors. Because the microvascular network of tumors is influenced significantly by the site of growth, we challenged this possibility in the present work by studying relationships between DCE-MRI-derived parameters and hypoxia in intramuscular melanoma xenografts.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Intramuscular R-18, U-25, and V-27 tumors were subjected to DCE-MRI and measurement of the fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells (HF(Rad)). Parametric images of K(trans) and v(e) were produced by pharmacokinetic analysis, and K(trans) and v(e) were related to HF(Rad) in individual tumors.

RESULTS

K(trans) decreased with increasing HF(Rad). The correlations between K(trans) and HF(Rad) were similar for the three tumor lines and were highly significant (P<0.00001). There was no correlation between v(e) and HF(Rad). However, v(e) decreased significantly with increasing cell survival after single dose irradiation.

CONCLUSION

Intramuscular melanoma xenografts show similar inverse correlations between K(trans) and HF(Rad) as intradermal tumors, which support the current clinical attempts to establish DCE-MRI as a method for detecting hypoxia and defining therapeutic targets in tumors.

Magnetic resonance imaging of tumor necrosis

BACKGROUND

The prognostic and predictive value of magnetic resonance (MR) investigations in clinical oncology may be improved by implementing strategies for discriminating between viable and necrotic tissue in tumors. The purpose of this preclinical study was to investigate whether the extent of necrosis in tumors can be assessed by dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (DCE-MRI) and/or T(2)-weighted MR imaging.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Three amelanotic human melanoma xenograft lines differing substantially in tumor necrotic fraction, necrotic pattern, extracellular volume fraction, and blood perfusion were used as experimental models of human cancer. MRI was performed at 1.5 T and a spatial resolution of 0.23 × 0.47 × 2.0 mm(3). Gadolinium diethylene-triamine penta-acetic acid (Gd-DTPA) was used as contrast agent. Plots of Gd-DTPA concentration versus time were generated for each voxel, and three parameters were calculated for each curve: the extracellular volume fraction (ν(e)), the final slope (a), and the Gd-DTPA concentration at one minute after the contrast administration (C(1min)). Parametric images of ν(e), a, C(1min), and the signal intensity in T(2)-weighted images (SI(T2W)) were compared with the histology of the imaged tissue.

RESULTS

The ν(e), a, and C(1min) frequency distributions were significantly different for necrotic and viable tissue in all three tumor lines. By using adequate values of ν(e), a, and C(1min) to discriminate between necrotic and viable tissue, significant correlations were found between the fraction of necrotic tissue assessed by MRI and the fraction of necrotic tissue assessed by image analysis of histological preparations. On the other hand, the SI(T2W) frequency distributions did not differ significantly between necrotic and viable tissue in two of the three tumor lines.

CONCLUSION

Necrotic regions in tumor tissue can be identified in parametric images derived from DCE-MRI series, whereas T(2)-weighted images are unsuitable for detection of tumor necrosis.

Metastasis in melanoma xenografts is associated with tumor microvascular density rather than extent of hypoxia

The development of metastases has been shown to be associated with the microvascular density of the primary tumor in some clinical studies and with the extent of hypoxia in others. The aim of this study was to investigate the validity of these apparently inconsistent observations and to reveal possible links between them. Xenografted tumors of nine melanoma cell lines established from patients with diseases differing in aggressiveness were studied. The aggressiveness of the cell lines was assessed by measuring their lung colonization potential, invasiveness, angiogenic potential, and tumorigenicity. Spontaneous metastasis was assessed in untreated mice and mice treated with neutralizing antibody against vascular endothelial growth factor A (VEGF-A) or interleukin 8 (IL-8). Microvascular density was scored in histologic preparations. Hypoxic fractions were measured by using a radiobiologic assay and a pimonidazole-based immunohistochemical assay. The aggressiveness of the melanoma lines reflected the aggressiveness of the donor patients' tumors. The metastatic propensity was associated with the microvascular density but not with the hypoxic fraction. Anti-VEGF-A and anti-IL-8 treatments resulted in decreased microvascular density and reduced incidence of metastases in all lines. Large hypoxic fractions were not a secondary effect of high cellular aggressiveness, whereas the microvascular density was associated with the cellular aggressiveness. The metastatic propensity was governed by the angiogenic potential of the tumor cells. The differences in microvascular density among the lines were most likely a consequence of differences in the constitutive angiogenic potential rather than differences in hypoxia-induced angiogenesis. VEGF-A and IL-8 may be important therapeutic targets for melanoma.

Limitations of dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI in monitoring radiation-induced changes in the fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells in human melanoma xenografts

PURPOSE

To investigate the potential of gadopentetate dimeglumine (Gd-DTPA)-based dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (DCE-MRI) in detecting radiation-induced changes in the fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells in A-07 human melanoma xenografts.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A-07 tumors were randomly assigned to an unirradiated control group or a group given a single radiation dose of 20 Gy. DCE-MRI and measurement of fraction of hypoxic cells were performed immediately before and 24 h after the radiation exposure. Tumor images of E . F (E is the initial extraction fraction of Gd-DTPA and F is blood perfusion) and lambda (lambda is proportional to extracellular volume fraction) were produced by subjecting DCE-MRI series to Kety analysis. Fraction of hypoxic cells was measured by using a radiobiological assay based on the paired survival curve method.

RESULTS

Fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells was higher in irradiated tumors (26.2+/-5.8%) than in unirradiated tumors (7.5+/-2.7%) by a factor of 3.5+/-1.5 (P=0.0093), whereas only minor radiation-induced changes in E . F and lambda could be detected.

CONCLUSION

DCE-MRI does not seem to offer insight into the changes in fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells occurring in A-07 tumors within 24 h after irradiation with 20 Gy.

The addition of AG-013736 to fractionated radiation improves tumor response without functionally normalizing the tumor vasculature

Although antiangiogenic strategies have proven highly promising in preclinical studies and some recent clinical trials, generally only combinations with cytotoxic therapies have shown clinical effectiveness. An ongoing question has been whether conventional therapies are enhanced or compromised by antiangiogenic agents. The present studies were designed to determine the pathophysiologic consequences of both single and combined treatments using fractionated radiotherapy plus AG-013736, a receptor tyrosine kinase inhibitor that preferentially inhibits vascular endothelial growth factor receptors. DU145 human prostate xenograft tumors were treated with (a) vehicle alone, (b) AG-013736, (c) 5x2 Gy/wk radiotherapy fractions, or (d) the combination. Automated image processing of immunohistochemical images was used to determine total and perfused blood vessel spacing, overall hypoxia, pericyte/collagen coverage, proliferation, and apoptosis. Combination therapy produced an increased tumor response compared with either monotherapy alone. Vascular density progressively declined in concert with slightly increased alpha-smooth muscle actin-positive pericyte coverage and increased overall tumor hypoxia (compared with controls). Although functional vessel endothelial apoptosis was selectively increased, reductions in total and perfused vessels were generally proportionate, suggesting that functional vasculature was not specifically targeted by combination therapy. These results argue against either an AG-013736- or a combination treatment-induced functional normalization of the tumor vasculature. Vascular ablation was mirrored by the increased appearance of dissociated pericytes and empty type IV collagen sleeves. Despite the progressive decrease in tumor oxygenation over 3 weeks of treatment, combination therapy remained effective and tumor progression was minimal.

Fluctuating and Diffusion-Limited Hypoxia in Hypoxia-Induced Metastasis

PURPOSE

Most tumors develop regions with hypoxic cells during growth, owing to permanent limitations in oxygen diffusion (chronic or diffusion-limited hypoxia) and/or transient limitations in blood perfusion (acute or fluctuating hypoxia). The aim of this study was to investigate the relative significance of chronic and acute hypoxia in the development of metastatic disease.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

D-12 and R-18 human melanoma xenografts were used as models of human cancer. D-12 tumors metastasize to the lungs, whereas R-18 tumors develop lymph node metastases. Fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells (HF(Rad)) was measured in individual primary tumors by using a radiobiological assay based on the paired survival curve method. Fraction of immunohistochemically hypoxic cells (HF(Imm)) was assessed in the same tumors by using a pimonidazole-based immunohistochemical assay optimized with respect to achieving selective staining of chronically hypoxic cells. HF(Imm) and the difference between HF(Rad) and HF(Imm), HF(Rad) - HF(Imm), were verified to be adequate variables for fraction of chronically hypoxic cells and fraction of acutely hypoxic cells, respectively.

RESULTS

Chronic as well as acute hypoxia were found to promote spontaneous metastasis of D-12 and R-18 tumors. Acute hypoxia influenced metastasis to a greater extent than chronic hypoxia, partly because the fraction of acutely hypoxic cells was larger than the fraction of chronically hypoxic cells in most tumors and partly because acutely hypoxic cells showed a higher metastatic potential than chronically hypoxic cells.

CONCLUSIONS

It may be beneficial to focus on fluctuating hypoxia rather than diffusion-limited hypoxia when searching for hypoxia-related prognostic variables and predictive assays.

Assessment of microvascular density, extracellular volume fraction, and radiobiological hypoxia in human melanoma xenografts by dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI

PURPOSE

To investigate whether gadopentetate dimeglumine (Gd-DTPA)-based dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (DCE-MRI) may be a useful method for assessing fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells in tumors.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A-07 and R-18 human melanoma xenografts were used as preclinical tumor models. DCE-MRI was performed at a voxel size of 0.23 x 0.47 x 2.0 mm(3). Tumor images of E . F (E is the initial extraction fraction of Gd-DTPA and F is blood perfusion) and lambda (the partition coefficient of Gd-DTPA) were produced by subjecting DCE-MRI series to Kety analysis. Microvascular density and extracellular volume fraction (ECVF) were determined by analysis of histological preparations. The fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells was measured by the paired survival curve method.

RESULTS

E . F correlated with microvascular density, and lambda correlated with ECVF. The fraction of hypoxic cells was approximately 6.5-fold higher in R-18 tumors than in A-07 tumors, consistent with the observation that A-07 tumors showed higher values for E . F and microvascular density and lower cell density (i.e., higher values for lambda and ECVF) than R-18 tumors.

CONCLUSION

E . F and lambda images obtained by Kety analysis of DCE-MRI series contain information that may be utilized to estimate the extent of radiobiological hypoxia in tumors.

Tumor-dependent kinetics of partial pressure of oxygen fluctuations during air and oxygen breathing

The primary purpose of this study was to examine the kinetics of partial pressure of oxygen (pO2) fluctuations in fibrosarcoma (FSA) and 9L tumors under air and O2 breathing conditions. The overall hypothesis was that key factors relating to oxygen tension fluctuations would vary between the two tumor types and as a function of the oxygen content of the breathing gas. To assist in the interpretation of the temporal data, spatial pO2 distributions were measured in 10 FSA and 8 9L tumors transplanted into the subcutis of the hind leg of Nembutal-anesthetized (50 mg/kg) Fischer 344 rats. Recessed-tip oxygen microelectrodes were inserted into the tumor, and linear pO2 measurements were recorded in 50-microm steps along a 3-mm path, and blood pressure was simultaneously measured via femoral arterial access. Additionally, pO2 was measured at a single location for 90 to 120 minutes in FSA (n=11) or 9L tumors (n=12). Rats were switched from air to 100% O2 breathing after 45 minutes. Temporal pO2 records were evaluated for their potential radiobiological significance by assessing the number of times they crossed a 10-mm-Hg threshold. In addition, the data were subjected to Fourier analysis for air and O2 breathing. FSA and 9L tumors had spatial median pO2 measurements of 4 and 1 mm Hg, respectively. 9L had more low pO2 measurements < or =2.5 mm Hg than did FSA, whereas between 2.5 and 10 mm Hg this pattern was reversed. Pimonidazole staining patterns in FSA and 9L tumors supported these results. Temporal pO2 instability was observed in all experiments during air and O2 breathing. Threshold analyses indicated that the 10 mm Hg threshold was crossed 2 to 5 times per hour, independent of tumor type. However, the magnitude of 9L pO2 fluctuations was approximately eight times greater than FSA fluctuations, as assessed with Fourier transform analysis (Wilcoxon, P < 0.005). O2 breathing significantly increased median pO2 in FSA from 3 to 8 mm Hg (P < 0.005) and caused a significant increase in frequency and magnitude of pO2 fluctuations. One hundred percent O2 breathing had no effect on 9L tumor pO2, and it decreased the magnitude of pO2 fluctuations with borderline significance. These results show that these two tumors differ significantly with respect to spatial and temporal oxygenation conditions under air and O2 breathing. Fluctuations of pO2 of the type reported herein are predicted to significantly affect radiotherapy response and could be a source for genetic instability, increased angiogenesis, and metastases.

Zonal image analysis of tumour vascular perfusion, hypoxia, and necrosis

A number of laboratories are utilising both hypoxia and perfusion markers to spatially quantify tumour oxygenation and vascular distributions, and scientists are increasingly turning to automated image analysis methods to quantify such interrelationships. In these studies, the presence of regions of necrosis in the immunohistochemical sections remains a potentially significant source of error. In the present work, frozen MCa-4 mammary tumour sections were used to obtain a series of corresponding image montages. Total vessels were identified using CD31 staining, perfused vessels by DiOC(7) staining, hypoxia by EF5/Cy3 uptake, and necrosis by haematoxylin and eosin staining. Our goal was to utilise image analysis techniques to spatially quantitate hypoxic marker binding as a function of distance from the nearest blood vessel. Several refinements to previous imaging methods are described: (1) hypoxia marker images are quantified in terms of their intensity levels, thus providing an analysis of the gradients in hypoxia with increasing distances from blood vessels, (2) zonal imaging masks are derived, which permit spatial sampling of images at precisely defined distances from blood vessels, as well as the omission of necrotic artifacts, (3) thresholding techniques are applied to omit holes in the tissue sections, and (4) distance mapping is utilised to define vascular spacing.

Effects of radiation on tumor intravascular oxygenation, vascular configuration, development of hypoxia, and clonogenic survival

The underlying physiological mechanisms leading to tumor reoxygenation after irradiation have elicited considerable interest, but they remain somewhat unclear. The current study was undertaken to determine the effects of a single dose of 10 Gy gamma radiation on both tumor pathophysiology and radiobiologically hypoxic fraction. Immunohistochemical staining and perfusion markers were used to quantify tumor vasculature, uptake of the hypoxia marker EF5 to assess the distribution of hypoxia, and intravascular HbO(2) measurements to determine oxygen availability. Tumor radiosensitivity was measured by a clonogenic assay. At 24 h postirradiation, oxygen availability increased, perfused vessel numbers decreased, EF5 uptake decreased, and the radiobiologically hypoxic fraction was unchanged. Together, these results demonstrate that tumor hypoxia develops at an increased distance from perfused blood vessels after irradiation, suggesting a decrease in oxygen consumption at 24 h. By 72 h postirradiation, all physiological parameters had returned to the levels in volume-matched, nonirradiated controls. These studies clearly show that single measures of either tumor oxygenation or vascular structure are inadequate for assessing the effects of radiation on tumor clonogenicity. Although such direct measurements have previously proven valuable in predicting tumor response to therapy or oxygen manipulation, a combination of parameters is required to adequately describe the mechanisms underlying these changes after irradiation.

Changes in tumor hypoxia measured with a double hypoxic marker technique

PURPOSE

Development of a double hypoxic cell marker assay, using the bioreductive nitroimidazole derivatives CCI-103F and pimonidazole, to study changes in tumor hypoxia after treatments that modify tumor oxygenation.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Both hypoxic markers were visualized by immunohistochemical techniques to detect changes in hypoxic fraction induced by carbogen breathing (95% O(2) and 5% CO(2)) or hydralazine injection. The protocol was tested in a human laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma xenograft line. Quantitative measurements were derived from consecutive tissue sections that were analyzed by a semiautomatic image analysis system. Qualitative analysis was obtained by double staining of the two hypoxic markers on the same tissue section.

RESULTS

A significant correlation between the hypoxic fractions for the two markers, CCI-103F and pimonidazole, was found in air breathing animals. After carbogen breathing, the hypoxic fraction decreased significantly from 0.07 to 0.03, and after hydralazine treatment, the hypoxic fraction increased significantly. Reduction of hypoxia after carbogen breathing was most pronounced close to well-perfused tumor regions.

CONCLUSIONS

With this method, employing two consecutively injected bioreductive markers, changes in tumor hypoxia can be studied. A significant reduction in hypoxia after carbogen breathing and a significant increase in hypoxia after hydralazine administration was demonstrated.

Changes in blood perfusion and hypoxia after irradiation of a human squamous cell carcinoma xenograft tumor line

The effect of irradiation depends on the oxygenation status of the tissue, while irradiation itself also changes the oxygenation and perfusion status of tissues. A better understanding of the changes in tumor oxygenation and perfusion over time after irradiation will allow a better planning of fractionated radiotherapy in combination with modifiers of blood flow and oxygenation. Vascular architecture (endothelial marker), perfusion (Hoechst 33342) and oxygenation (pimonidazole) were studied in a human laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma tumor line grown as xenografts in nude mice. The effect of a single dose of 10 Gy X rays on these parameters was evaluated from 2 h to 11 days after irradiation. Shortly after irradiation, there was an 8% increase in perfused blood vessels (from 57% to 65%) followed by a significant decrease, with a minimum value of 42% at 26 h after irradiation, and a subsequent increase to control levels at 7 to 11 days after irradiation. The hypoxic fraction showed a decrease at 7 h after treatment from 13% to 5% with an increase to 19% at 11 days after irradiation. These experiments show that irradiation causes rapid changes in oxygenation and perfusion which may have consequences for the optimal timing of radiotherapy schedules employing multiple fractions per day and the introduction of oxygenation- and perfusion-modifying drugs.

Enhancement of tumor perfusion and oxygenation by carbogen and nicotinamide during single- and multifraction irradiation

Numerous experimental and clinical studies have been completed regarding the effects of carbogen and nicotinamide on tumor oxygenation and radiosensitivity. The current study incorporates three physiological measurement techniques to further define spatial variations in oxygen availability and development of hypoxia after single- and multifraction irradiation in KHT murine fibrosarcomas. Distances to anatomical and perfused blood vessels were measured using immunohistochemical and fluorescent staining, intravascular oxygen levels were determined cryospectrophotometrically, and tumor hypoxia was quantified using uptake of EF5, a marker of hypoxia. Carbogen, nicotinamide, and the combination of both all increased intravascular oxygen availability compared to controls. While nicotinamide had no effect on the number of perfused blood vessels in nonirradiated tumors, carbogen produced a substantial closing of vessels. After a single dose of 4 Gy, only the combination of nicotinamide and carbogen produced significant improvements in oxygen availability, while numbers of perfused vessels were significantly increased for nicotinamide, unchanged for the combination of nicotinamide and carbogen, and significantly decreased for carbogen. After 4 x 4-Gy fractions, oxygen availability was increased substantially with the combination of nicotinamide and carbogen, somewhat with carbogen, and not at all with nicotinamide. Tumor oxygenation changes were estimated by EF5/Cy3 intensity distributions, which demonstrated that manipulative agents could produce disparate effects on tumor hypoxia when combined with either single- or multifraction irradiation.

Monitoring of tumor reoxygenation following irradiation by 31P magnetic resonance spectroscopy: an experimental study of human melanoma xenografts

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Inadequate tumor reoxygenation during radiation therapy may cause local treatment failure. This study was aimed at investigating the potential usefulness of 31P-MRS in monitoring tumor reoxygenation following radiation treatment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Tumors of two human melanoma xenograft lines (BEX-t and HUX-t) were exposed to 15.0 Gy, and then the fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells, measured by using the paired survival curve method, or tumor bioenergetic status, measured by 31P-MRS as the (PCr + NTPbeta)/Pi resonance ratio, was determined versus time after the radiation exposure.

RESULTS

Untreated BEX-t and HUX-t tumors showed similar fractions of radiobiologically hypoxic cells and similar bioenergetic status, whereas both parameters differed substantially between the lines in irradiated tumors. A close association was found between radiation-induced changes in tumor bioenergetic status and radiation-induced changes in the fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells.

CONCLUSION

31P-MRS is a potentially useful method for monitoring tumor reoxygenation following radiation treatment.

Detection of hypoxic cells in murine tumors using the comet assay: comparison with a conventional radiobiological assay

The comet (single-cell electrophoresis) assay has been developed as a method for measuring DNA damage in single cells after irradiation. We have developed our own methods and image analysis system for the comet assay to identify hypoxic fractions. In vitro, we tested our system using a cultured tumor cell line (SCCVII). In vivo, we compared the hypoxic fractions detected by this assay with those determined by the in vivo-in vitro clonogenic assay using two rodent tumors (SCCVII/ C3H, EMT6/KU/balb/c), which exhibit different types of hypoxia: acute and chronic. In vitro, our method could differentiate hypoxic cells from oxic cells, using the parameter of tail moment. In vivo, there were good correlations between the hypoxic fractions determined by the comet assay and by the clonogenic assay, in SCCVII/C3H (r=0.85) and in EMT6/KU/balb/c (r=0.75) tumors. By comparison of the two methods in chronically hypoxic and acutely hypoxic tumors, we further confirmed that the comet assay is clinically useful for estimating hypoxic fractions of solid tumors.

Comparison between the comet assay and the oxygen microelectrode for measurement of tumor hypoxia

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Hypoxic cells are present in some solid tumours and are known to limit radiocurability. To compare two measures of tumour hypoxia, 25 patients with locally advanced disease and accessible tumours or metastatic nodes were examined using an oxygen microelectrode and the alkaline comet assay.

MEASUREMENTS AND METHODS

For the comet assay, fine needle aspirate biopsies were taken immediately following a dose of 5-10 Gy. Single cells were examined for radiation-induced DNA strand breaks, and the percentage of radio-resistant hypoxic cells within the population was calculated from DNA damage histograms. For oxygen tension (pO2) measurements, multiple tracks were made using an Eppendorf oxygen microelectrode. The possibility that application of the first method might influence hypoxic fraction measurement by the second method was examined in a more controlled system by creating four tracks in murine SCC-VII tumours using an oxygen electrode, and measuring hypoxic fraction at subsequent times.

RESULTS

For 28 tumours from 25 patients, hypoxic fraction measured by comet assay correlated with the percentage of PO2 values < 5 mmHg (r2 = 0.46, P < 0.001). The mean comet hypoxic fraction was 0.36 for five tumours with a median PO2 < 10 mmHg. For the remaining 23 tumours with a median PO2 > 10 mmHg, the mean hypoxic fraction was 0.09. Advancement of an oxygen electrode through SCCVII tumours had no significant effect on hypoxic fraction measured 5 min to 24 h later using the alkaline comet assay.

CONCLUSIONS

Tumours defined as hypoxic based on a median pO2 < 10 mmHg appear to contain more than 20% radio-biologically hypoxic cells as estimated by the comet assay. In an animal tumour model, puncture of the tumour with an oxygen electrode did not influence hypoxic fraction measured using the comet assay, in agreement with the clinical data that the order in which the two methods were performed was not important.

Changes in head and neck tumor hypoxic fraction during split-course radiochemotherapy

This study explored patterns of oxygen distribution in human tumors during primary radiochemotherapy. Patients with positive nodes from head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (n = 15) were investigated before therapy, before and after a 2-week respite, and at the end of the treatment. Intratumoral tissue oxygen tension (pO2) was measured with sterile polarographic needle electrodes and a computerized histography system. The 2 lowest pO2 classes, ie, 0 and 5 mm Hg, were designated the hypoxic fraction, and the mean and median pO2 were evaluated for each tumor. In the beginning, a marked variability in tissue pO2 was found. The initial size of the hypoxic fraction ranged from 0% to 61% of measured values. At the end of treatment, 4 tumors showed an increase in mean pO2, and 7 tumors a lower mean pO2 in comparison to the initial values. However, an impressive finding was that the hypoxic fraction of 9 tumors became smaller during the pause, 1 tumor showed no change, and 1 showed an increase in hypoxic fraction. The results show that there is a widely distributed tissue oxygenation with marked hypoxic zones in human neck nodes. During radiochemotherapy, tissue oxygenation changed, with great intertumor variability. A tendency toward a decrease of the hypoxic fraction after the respite could be seen. This change in tumor oxygenation during therapy needs further evaluation.

Regional tumor oxygen tension: fluorine echo planar imaging of hexafluorobenzene reveals heterogeneity of dynamics

PURPOSE

Therapeutic success could be enhanced if therapy were tailored to the characteristics of specific tumors. We have been developing novel approaches to measuring tumor oxygen tension in vivo, and recently reported a method based on 19F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spin lattice echo planar imaging (EPI) relaxometry of hexafluorobenzene (HFB). We have now examined the feasibility of monitoring dynamic changes in regional tumor oxygenation in response to respiratory challenge. Preliminary data in one tumor show distinct differences before and subsequent to irradiation.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Dunning prostate adenocarcinoma R3327-AT1 was grown in the form of pedicles on the foreback of male Copenhagen rats. When the tumors reached approximately 1 cm diameter, HFB (40 microl) was administered by direct intratumoral injection deliberately dispersed to interrogate both central and peripheral regions. Local pO2 was determined using pulse burst saturation recovery 19F NMR EPI on the basis of the spin lattice relaxation rate.

RESULTS

Interrogation of both central and peripheral regions of tumors showed bimodal distribution for oxygenation, including many voxels with pO2 < 15 torr. Altering the inspired gas to 100% O2 produced significant elevation for regions with initially high pO2 (P < 0.01), but the temporal course of dynamic changes varied for each voxel. Many voxels with low pO2 showed little response. Following irradiation (20 Gy), tumor oxygenation was significantly elevated and remained high for at least 10 h.

CONCLUSION

We believe this method provides a valuable new approach to investigate tumor oximetry that may extend our understanding of tumor physiology, and could have prognostic value.

Fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells in human melanoma xenografts measured by using single-cell survival, tumour growth delay and local tumour control as end points

Four human melanoma xenograft lines (A-07, D-12, R-18, U-25) grown orthotopically in Balb/c nu/nu mice were characterized with respect to the fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic cells. The purpose of the study was to establish a firm radiobiological basis for future use of the lines in the development and evaluation of non-invasive assays of tumour hypoxia. The hypoxic fractions were assessed using three different assays, the single cell survival assay, the tumour growth delay assay and the local tumour control assay, and the means +/- s.e. were found to be 6 +/- 3%, 3 +/- 1% and 5 +/- 2% respectively (A-07), 26 +/- 5%, 25 +/- 6% and 22 +/- 6% respectively (D-12), 55 +/- 9%, 65 +/- 8% and 48 +/- 7% respectively (R-18) and 52 +/- 8%, 59 +/- 7% and 47 +/- 7% respectively (U-25). The three assays gave numerical values for the hypoxic fraction that were not significantly different for any of the lines. The hypoxic fraction differed significantly among the lines; the R-18 and U-25 lines showed higher hypoxic fractions than the D-12 line (P < 0.05), which in turn showed a higher hypoxic fraction than the A-07 line (P < 0.05), regardless of the assay. The wide range of the hypoxic fractions and the significant differences among the lines suggest that A-07, D-12. R-18 and U-25 tumours should be useful models in future studies attempting to develop non-invasive assays of tumour hypoxia.

Tumor hypoxia in pelvic recurrences of cervical cancer

We have previously demonstrated in primary cancer of the uterine cervix that tumor hypoxia, as determined polarographically, is strongly associated with clinical malignant progression of the disease. Having applied a similar methodological approach to investigate loco-regional relapses, we found a pronounced shift to more hypoxic oxygenation profiles in the recurrent tumors than in the primary tumors. Median pO2 values in 53 pelvic recurrences were significantly lower than the median pO2 values of 117 primary tumors of comparable sizes (7.1 +/- 1.1 mmHg vs. 12.1 +/- 1.0 mmHg, p = 0.0013). The differences in tumor oxygenation between primary and recurrent tumors mirrored the differences in the patients' 5-year survival probabilities. In the cohort of patients with pelvic relapses, median tumor pO2 < 4 mmHg indicated a significantly shorter median survival time as compared to median tumor pO2 > or = 4 mmHg. Our results further support our thesis that in cervical cancer, tumor hypoxia and clinical aggressiveness in terms of resistance to therapy and tumor dissemination, are interrelated.

Changes in tumor oxygenation during combined treatment with split-course radiotherapy and chemotherapy in patients with head and neck cancer

PURPOSE

To evaluate the changes in tumor oxygenation during definitive split-course radiochemotherapy in locally advanced head and neck cancer (lymph nodes and primaries).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-four patients with locally advanced head and neck cancer were investigated pretherapeutically and during a defined course of radiochemotherapy (RCTh) with a total dose of 70 Gy given in 35 fractions over 9 weeks (2-week break after 30 Gy). In weeks 1 and 6, the patients received chemotherapy (5 FU and mitomycin C) concomitant with irradiation. The oxygen partial pressure measurements were carried out using polarographic needle probes in combination with a microprocessor-controlled device (pO2 histograph/KIMOC). Times of measurements were before therapy, at the end of week 3 (30 Gy), after a 2-week break (30 Gy) and at the end of therapy if measurable lesion was found (70 Gy).

RESULTS

There was a significant reduction in the median pO2 (P < 0.005, n = 18) and an increase in the hypoxic fraction (defined as the percentage of pO2 values of <5 mm Hg) after application of 30 Gy (P < 0.05, n = 18). This effect was partially reversed at the end of the 2-week break. During the break an increase in the median PO2 (P = 0.05, n = 12) and a decrease in the hypoxic fraction could be observed. Towards the end of therapy (70 Gy) a significant decrease (P = 0.02, n = 13) in the median pO2 occurred. Corresponding to this, the hypoxic fraction increased during the last 4 weeks of therapy (P = 0.06, n = 13).

CONCLUSION

Statistically significant changes in oxygenation in locally advanced head and neck cancer were found during a split-course radiochemotherapy. This information was obtained in a homogenous group of patients under well-defined therapeutic conditions. The decrease in the tumor oxygenation status at doses of 30 and 70 Gy are important findings because they are in contrast to the concept of continuous improvement of the oxygenation status during fractionated radiotherapy.

Oxygen tension in human tumours measured with polarographic needle electrodes and its relationship to vascular density, necrosis and hypoxia

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The use of polarographic needle electrodes for measurement of oxygen tension (pO2) in tumours requires documentation of the validity of the method. In the present work the pO2 values measured polarographically with the Eppendorf pO2 histograph in human tumours were compared with the histological appearance of the tumour tissue, i.e. vascular density, fraction of necrosis and fraction of hypoxic tissue, to investigate whether the measurements reflected the expected pO2.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The pO2 was measured in cervix tumours in patients and in human melanoma xenografted tumours in athymic mice. Vascular density was determined in the cervix tumours by histological analysis of biopsies from the pO2 measurement tracks. Fraction of necrosis and fraction of hypoxic tissue, i.e. tissue binding the hypoxia marker pimonidazole, were determined in the melanomas by analysis of histological sections from the tumour planes in which the pO2 measurements were performed.

RESULTS

The pO2 distributions showed large intratumour heterogeneity. In cervix tumours, tumour regions with vascular density (vascular length per unit tissue volume) in the range of 47-77 mm/mm3 showed higher pO2 than tumour regions with vascular density in the range of 20-47 mm/mm3, which in turn showed higher pO2 than tumour regions with vascular density in the range of 0-20 mm/mm3. In melanomas, tumour regions in which necrosis and hypoxia constituted more than 50% of the tissue showed lower pO2 than other tumour regions.

CONCLUSIONS

The pO2 measured in the tumours was consistent with the histological appearance of the tissue in which the measurements were performed, suggesting that reliable pO2 distributions of tumours can be obtained with polarographic needle electrodes.

Effects of carbogen plus fractionated irradiation on KHT tumor oxygenation

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Numerous studies have demonstrated improvements in the oxygenation of tumor cells following both irradiation and carbogen breathing. The current studies were initiated to measure the combined effects of carbogen inhalation plus single and multi-dose irradiation on tumor oxygen availability, to better define the underlying physiological relationships.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Using KHT murine sarcomas, radiation was delivered to the tumor-bearing legs of non-anesthetized mice. Tumors were quick-frozen prior to or following single or multifraction irradiation and carbogen breathing, and intravascular HbO2 saturation profiles were determined cryospectrophotometrically.

RESULTS

HbO2 levels for blood vessels located near the tumor surface initially decreased following 10 Gy irradiation, then increased and remained elevated. Interior HbO2 levels remained unchanged. Following 2.5 Gy, HbO2 changes were minimal. At 24 h following 10 Gy, HbO2 levels were significantly increased compared to non-irradiated controls, and carbogen breathing produced no additional benefit. At 24 h following five fractions of 2 Gy, HbO2 levels throughout the tumor volume were significantly higher in carbogen breathing animals than in air breathing controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Although peripheral blood vessels demonstrated substantial improvements in oxygenation following irradiation, oxygen availability nearer the tumor center remained at very low levels. The utility of carbogen in enhancing tumor oxygen availability was maintained following five clinically relevant fractions. At higher doses, radiation-induced enhancements in HbO2 levels overshadowed the carbogen effect. For either air or carbogen breathing, a decrease in the percentage of vessels with very low oxygen content did not appear to be a major factor in the reoxygenation of the KHT tumor.

Detection of hypoxic cells in a C3H mouse mammary carcinoma using the comet assay

The comet assay was used to estimate radiobiological hypoxic fraction across a full range of tumour oxygenations in C3H mammary tumours implanted into the feet of female CDF1 mice. Tumours were either clamped before irradiation or mice were allowed to breath air, 100% oxygen, carbogen or carbon monoxide for 5-35 min before and during exposure to 15 Gy. For the alkaline comet assay, tumours were excised after irradiation and individual tumour cells were analysed for DNA single-strand breaks. Hypoxic cells were defined as those cells with approximately three times fewer single-strand breaks than aerobic cells. Radiobiological hypoxic fraction was calculated by fitting DNA damage histograms to two normal distributions, representing the response of the aerobic and hypoxic populations. The percentage of hypoxic cells estimated using the comet assay was then compared with hypoxic fraction measured using a clamped tumour control assay. Carbogen and oxygen breathing reduced the normal hypoxic fraction from 14% to 2-3% in this tumour, whereas 75-660 p.p.m. carbon monoxide progressively increased the hypoxic fraction from 18% to 82%. The slope of the line comparing the two methods was 1.23 with 95% confidence limits of 1.12-1.33 (r2 = 0.994). In the SCCVII squamous cell carcinoma growing subcutaneously in C3H mice, a similar correlation was observed between hypoxic fraction measured using the comet assay and hypoxic fraction measured in the same tumour cells using the paired survival curve assay (slope = 1.20 with 95% confidence limits of 1.03-1.37). These results confirm the ability of the comet assay to provide an accurate estimate of radiobiological hypoxic fraction over a wide range of tumour oxygenations and between two tumour types.

Direct relationship between radiobiological hypoxia in tumors and monoclonal antibody detection of EF5 cellular adducts

While the potential importance of hypoxia in limiting the sensitivity of tumor cells to ionizing radiation has long been appreciated, methods for accurately quantifying the number of radiation-resistant hypoxic cells within tumors have been lacking. We have used the pentafluorinated derivative [2-(2-nitro-1H-imidazol-1-yl)-N-(2,2,3,3,3-pentafluoropropyl)-acet amide] of etanidazole (EF5), which binds selectively to hypoxic cells. The adducts formed between EF5 and cellular proteins in the hypoxic cells were detected using the specific monoclonal antibody (MAb), ELK3-51 conjugated to the flurochrome Cy3, and the number of hypoxic cells was quantified by flow cytometry. To verify the validity of this technique for the detection of hypoxic cells, mice bearing KHT sarcomas were treated with various agents to alter tumor oxygenation and hence vary the fraction of radiobiologically hypoxic tumor cells. The percentage of EF5 binding cells was then compared directly with the clonogenic survival of the tumor cells following radiation treatment under the various pretreatment conditions. The results showed that allowing the mice to breathe carbogen (5% CO2/95% O2) prior to irradiation reduced clonogenic cell survival approx. 6-fold and led to an absence of cells binding high levels of EF5. In contrast, pretreating the tumor-bearing animals with either hydralazine, which decreased tumor blood flow, or phenylhydrazine hydrochloride, which made the mice anemic, increased tumor cell survival following irradiation 2- to 4-fold, indicative of an increase in the fraction of hypoxic tumor cells. EF5 measurements made under identical conditions illustrated a shift in the cells in the tumor to high EF5 binding. Our results demonstrate that flow cytometric measurement by fluorescent MAb binding to EF5 adducts may relate directly to radiobiological hypoxia in KHT tumors measured by conventional methods.