Clinical-molecular correlation in 104 mild X-linked muscular dystrophy patients: characterization of sub-clinical phenotypes

Characterization of Phenotypic Variability in Becker Muscular Dystrophy for Clinical Practice and Towards Trial Readiness: A Two-Years Follow up Study

Background

Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) is a dystrophinopathy due to in-frame mutations in the dystrophin gene (DMD) which determines a reduction of dystrophin at muscle level. BMD has a wide spectrum of clinical variability with different degrees of disability. Studies of natural history are needed also in view of up-coming clinical trials.

Objectives

From an initial cohort of 32 BMD adult subjects, we present a detailed phenotypic characterization of 28 patients, then providing a description of their clinical natural history over the course of 12 months for 18 and 24 months for 13 of them.

Methods

Each patient has been genetically characterized. Baseline, and 1-year and 2 years assessments included North Star Ambulatory Assessment (NSAA), timed function tests (time to climb and descend four stairs), 6-minute walk test (6MWT), Walton and Gardner-Medwin Scale and Medical Research Council (MRC) scale. Muscle magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was acquired at baseline and in a subgroup of 9 patients after 24 months. Data on cardiac function (electrocardiogram, echocardiogram, and cardiac MRI) were also collected.

Results and conclusions

Among the clinical heterogeneity, a more severe involvement is often observed in patients with 45-X del, with a disease progression over two years. The 6MWT appears sensitive to detect modification from baseline during follow up while no variation was observed by MRC testing. Muscle MRI of the lower limbs correlates with clinical parameters.Our study further highlights how the phenotypic variability of BMD adult patients makes it difficult to describe an uniform course and substantiates the need to identify predictive parameters and biomarkers to stratify patients.

Clinical potential of microdystrophin as a surrogate endpoint

Accelerated approval based on a likely surrogate endpoint can be life-changing for patients suffering from a rare progressive disease with unmet medical need, as it substantially hastens access to potentially lifesaving therapies. In one such example, antisense morpholinos were approved to treat Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) based on measurement of shortened dystrophin in skeletal muscle biopsies as a surrogate biomarker. New, promising therapeutics for DMD include AAV gene therapy to restore another form of dystrophin termed mini- or microdystrophin. AAV-microdystrophins are currently in clinical trials but have yet to be accepted by regulatory agencies as reasonably likely surrogate endpoints. To evaluate microdystrophin expression as a reasonably likely surrogate endpoint for DMD, this review highlights dystrophin biology in the context of functional and clinical benefit to support the argument that microdystrophin proteins have a high probability of providing clinical benefit based on their rational design. Unlike exon-skipping based strategies, the approach of rational design allows for functional capabilities (i.e. quality) of the protein to be maximized with every patient receiving the same optimized microdystrophin. Therefore, the presence of rationally designed microdystrophin in a muscle biopsy is likely to predict clinical benefit and is consequently a strong candidate for a surrogate endpoint analysis to support accelerated approval.

Myalgic Becker Muscular Dystrophy Due to an Exon 15 Point Mutation: Case Series and Literature Review

ABSTRACT

Dystrophinopathies result from mutations to the DMD gene. We report 5 boys in 3 families with heterogenous phenotypes due to a point mutation in the DMD gene: a hemizygous tyrosine-to-cysteine change in exon 15 (c.1724T>C) resulting in an amino acid substitution of leucine to proline at codon 575. This mutation has been reported before, with at least 3 prior patients presenting with similar clinical findings of myalgia, myoglobinuria, and occasional muscle cramping. The mutation on DMD c.1724T>C (p.Leu575Pro) is listed in the Clinvar database as a variant of unknown significance. Our report provides contributing evidence that this alteration should be classified as pathogenic.

Muscle architecture is associated with muscle fat replacement in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies

INTRODUCTION/AIMS

Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies (DMD and BMD, respectively) are characterized by fat replacement of different skeletal muscles in a specific temporal order. Given the structural role of dystrophin in skeletal muscle mechanics, muscle architecture could be important in the progressive pathophysiology of muscle degeneration. Therefore, the aim of this study was to assess the role of muscle architecture in the progression of fat replacement in DMD and BMD.

METHODS

We assessed the association between literature-based leg muscle architectural characteristics and muscle fat fraction from 22 DMD and 24 BMD patients. Dixon-based magnetic resonance imaging estimates of fat fractions at baseline and 12 (only DMD) and 24 months were related to fiber length and physiological cross-sectional area (PCSA) using age-controlled linear mixed modeling.

RESULTS

DMD and BMD muscles with long fibers and BMD muscles with large PCSAs were associated with increased fat fraction. The effect of fiber length was stronger in muscles with larger PCSA.

DISCUSSION

Muscle architecture may explain the pathophysiology of muscle degeneration in dystrophinopathies, in which proximal muscles with a larger mass (fiber length × PCSA) are more susceptible, confirming the clinical observation of a temporal proximal-to-distal progression. These results give more insight into the mechanical role in the pathophysiology of muscular dystrophies. Ultimately, this new information can be used to help support the selection of current and the development of future therapies.

The "Usual Suspects": Genes for Inflammation, Fibrosis, Regeneration, and Muscle Strength Modify Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), the most severe form of dystrophinopathy, is quite homogeneous with regards to its causative biochemical defect, i.e., complete dystrophin deficiency, but not so much with regards to its phenotype. For instance, muscle weakness progresses to the loss of independent ambulation at a variable age, starting from before 10 years, to even after 16 years (with glucocorticoid treatment). Identifying the bases of such variability is relevant for patient counseling, prognosis, stratification in trials, and identification of therapeutic targets. To date, variants in five loci have been associated with variability in human DMD sub-phenotypes: SPP1, LTBP4, CD40, ACTN3, and THBS1. Four of these genes (SPP1, LTBP4, CD40, and THBS1) are implicated in several interconnected molecular pathways regulating inflammatory response to muscle damage, regeneration, and fibrosis; while ACTN3 is known as “the gene for speed”, as it contains a common truncating polymorphism (18% of the general population), which reduces muscle power and sprint performance. Studies leading to the identification of these modifiers were mostly based on a “candidate gene” approach, hence the identification of modifiers in “usual suspect” pathways, which are already known to modify muscle in disease or health. Unbiased approaches that are based on genome mapping have so far been applied only initially, but they will probably represent the focus of future developments in this field, and will hopefully identify novel, “unsuspected” therapeutic targets. In this article, we summarize the state of the art of modifier loci of human dystrophin deficiency, and attempt to assess their relevance and implications on both clinical management and translational research.

Genotypes and Phenotypes of DMD Small Mutations in Chinese Patients With Dystrophinopathies

Dystrophinopathies are a group of neuromuscular disorders resulting from mutations in DMD, including Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), intermediate muscular dystrophy (IMD), and Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD). Herein, we present the characteristics of small mutations in Chinese patients with dystrophinopathies, and explore genotype–phenotype correlations. In our cohort, 115 patients with small mutations (18.49% of all patients) were included and DMD mutations were detected by either Sanger (53.91%) or next generation sequencing (46.09%). In total, 106 small mutations were detected, 28 of which (26.42%) had not been reported previously. The most common mutations were nonsense mutations (52.17%), followed by splicing (24.35%), frameshift (17.39%), and missense mutations (5.22%), in addition to a single untranslated region mutation (0.87%). We discovered distinct mutation characteristics in our patients, such as different positional distributions, indicating different exon skipping therapy strategies for small mutations in Chinese patients. Almost all patients (96.51%) with truncating or missense mutations, were covered by triple/double/single-exon skipping therapy; the most frequent single-exon skipping strategy was skipping exon 32, applicable for 8.51% of patients. Furthermore, splicing classification grades were correlated with phenotypes in nonsense mutations (P < 0.001), and serum creatinine levels differed significantly between DMD/IMD and BMD for patients ≤ 16 years old (P = 0.002). These observations can further aid prognostic judgment and guide treatment. In conclusion, the mutation characteristics and genotype–phenotype correlations in Chinese patients with dystrophinopathies and small mutations could provide insights into the molecular mechanisms of pathogenesis, diagnosis, and treatment designs.

Muscle MRI and functional outcome measures in Becker muscular dystrophy

Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) is a neuromuscular disorder allelic to Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), caused by in-frame mutations in the dystrophin gene, and characterized by a clinical progression that is both milder and more heterogeneous than DMD. Muscle magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has been proposed as biomarker of disease progression in dystrophinopathies. Correlation with clinically meaningful outcome measures such as North Star Ambulatory Assessment (NSAA) and 6 minute walk test (6MWT) is paramount for biomarker qualification. In this study, 51 molecularly confirmed BMD patients (aged 7-69 years) underwent muscle MRI and were evaluated with functional measures (NSAA and 6MWT) at the time of the MRI, and subsequently after one year. We confirmed a pattern of fatty substitution involving mainly the hip extensors and most thigh muscles. Severity of muscle fatty substitution was significantly correlated with specific DMD mutations: in particular, patients with an isolated deletion of exon 48, or deletions bordering exon 51, showed milder involvement. Fat infiltration scores correlated with baseline functional measures, and predicted changes after 1 year. We conclude that in BMD, skeletal muscle MRI not only strongly correlates with motor function, but also helps in predicting functional deterioration within a 12-month time frame.

Functional changes in Becker muscular dystrophy: implications for clinical trials in dystrophinopathies

We performed a 1-year longitudinal study of Six Minute Walk Test (6MWT), North Star Ambulatory Assessment (NSAA), and timed function tests in Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD). Skeletal muscle dystrophin was quantified by immunoblot. We grouped deletions ending on exon 45 ("del 45-x", n = 28) or 51 ("del x-51", n = 10); isolated exon 48 deletion ("del 48", n = 10); and other mutations (n = 21). Only patients in the "del 45-x" or "other" groups became non-ambulatory (n = 5, log-rank p = n.s.) or unable to run (n = 22, p < 0.001). All measures correlated positively with dystrophin quantity and negatively with age, and were significantly more impaired in the "del 45-x" and "other" groups. After one year, NSAA score decreased significantly (-0.9 ± 1.6, p < 0.001); in the "del 45-x" group, both NSAA (-1.3 ± 1.7, p = 0.001) and 6MWT (-12 ± 31 m, p = 0.059) decreased. We conclude that patients with "del x-51" or "del 48" mutations have mild or asymptomatic BMD, while "del 45-x" mutations cause comparatively severe weakness, and functional deterioration in 1 year. Furthermore, exon 51 skipping could be more effective than exon 45 skipping in Duchenne muscular dystrophy.

Metabolic Myoglobinuria

One large group of hereditary myopathies characterized by recurrent myoglobinuria, almost invariably triggered by exercise, comprises metabolic disorders of two main fuels, glycogen and long-chain fatty acids, or mitochondrial diseases of the respiratory chain. Differential diagnosis is required to distinguish the three conditions, although all cause a crisis of muscle energy. Muscle biopsy may be useful when performed well after the episode of rhabdomyolysis. Molecular genetics is increasingly the diagnostic test of choice to discover the underlying genetic basis.

Effect of Cellular Therapy in Progression of Becker's Muscular Dystrophy: A Case Study

Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) is an inherited disorder due to deletions of the dystrophin gene that leads to muscle weakness. Effects of bone marrow mononuclear cell (BMMNC) transplantation in Muscular Dystrophy have shown to be safe and beneficial. We treated a 20-year-old male suffering from BMD with autologous BMMNC transplantation followed by multidisciplinary rehabilitation. He presented with muscle weakness and had difficulty in performing his activities. The BMMNCs were transplanted via intrathecal and intramuscular routes. The effects were measured on clinical and functional changes. Over 9 months, gradual improvement was noticed in muscle strength, respiratory functions and North Star Ambulatory Assessment Scale. Functional Independence Measure, Berg Balance Score, Brooke and Vignos Scale remained stable indicating halting of the progression. The case report suggests that cellular therapy combined with rehabilitation may have possibility of repairing and regenerating muscle fibers and decreasing the rate of progression of BMD.

Studying the role of dystrophin-associated proteins in influencing Becker muscular dystrophy disease severity

Becker muscular dystrophy is characterized by a variable disease course. Many factors have been implicated to contribute to this diversity, among which the expression of several components of the dystrophin associated glycoprotein complex. Together with dystrophin, most of these proteins anchor the muscle fiber cytoskeleton to the extracellular matrix, thus protecting the muscle from contraction induced injury, while nNOS is primarily involved in inducing vasodilation during muscle contraction, enabling adequate muscle oxygenation. In the current study, we investigated the role of three components of the dystrophin associated glycoprotein complex (beta-dystroglycan, gamma-sarcoglycan and nNOS) and the dystrophin homologue utrophin on disease severity in Becker patients. Strength measurements, data about disease course and fresh muscle biopsies of the anterior tibial muscle were obtained from 24 Becker patients aged 19 to 66. The designation of Becker muscular dystrophy in this study was based on the mutation and not on the clinical severity. Contrary to previous studies, we were unable to find a relationship between expression of nNOS, beta-dystroglycan and gamma-sarcoglycan at the sarcolemma and disease severity, as measured by muscle strength in five muscle groups and age at reaching several disease milestones. Unexpectedly, we found an inverse correlation between utrophin expression at the sarcolemma and age at reaching disease milestones.

Dystrophin levels and clinical severity in Becker muscular dystrophy patients

OBJECTIVE

Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) is characterised by broad clinical variability. Ongoing studies exploring dystrophin restoration in Duchenne muscular dystrophy ask for better understanding of the relation between dystrophin levels and disease severity. We studied this relation in BMD patients with varying mutations, including a large subset with an exon 45-47 deletion.

METHODS

Dystrophin was quantified by western blot analyses in a fresh muscle biopsy of the anterior tibial muscle. Disease severity was assessed using quantitative muscle strength measurements and functional disability scoring. MRI of the leg was performed in a subgroup to detect fatty infiltration.

RESULTS

33 BMD patients participated. No linear relation was found between dystrophin levels (range 3%-78%) and muscle strength or age at different disease milestones, in both the whole group and the subgroup of exon 45-47 deleted patients. However, patients with less than 10% dystrophin all showed a severe disease course. No relation was found between disease severity and age when analysing the whole group. By contrast, in the exon 45-47 deleted subgroup, muscle strength and levels of fatty infiltration were significantly correlated with patients' age.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study shows that dystrophin levels appear not to be a major determinant of disease severity in BMD, as long as it is above approximately 10%. A significant relation between age and disease course was only found in the exon 45-47 deletion subgroup. This suggests that at higher dystrophin levels, the disease course depends more on the mutation site than on the amount of the dystrophin protein produced.

Clinical characterisation of Becker muscular dystrophy patients predicts favourable outcome in exon-skipping therapy

OBJECTIVE

Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD/BMD) are both caused by mutations in the DMD gene. Out-of-frame mutations in DMD lead to absence of the dystrophin protein, while in-frame BMD mutations cause production of internally deleted dystrophin. Clinically, patients with DMD loose ambulance around the age of 12, need ventilatory support at their late teens and die in their third or fourth decade due to pulmonary or cardiac failure. BMD has a more variable disease course. The disease course of patients with BMD with specific mutations could be very informative to predict the outcome of the exon-skipping therapy, aiming to restore the reading-frame in patients with DMD.

METHODS

Patients with BMD with a mutation equalling a DMD mutation after successful exon skipping were selected from the Dutch Dystrophinopathy Database. Information about disease course was gathered through a standardised questionnaire. Cardiac data were collected from medical correspondence and a previous study on cardiac function in BMD.

RESULTS

Forty-eight patients were included, representing 11 different mutations. Median age of patients was 43 years (range 6-67). Nine patients were wheelchair users (26-56 years). Dilated cardiomyopathy was present in 7/36 patients. Only one patient used ventilatory support. Three patients had died at the age of 45, 50 and 76 years, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides mutation specific data on the course of disease in patients with BMD. It shows that the disease course of patients with BMD, with a mutation equalling a 'skipped' DMD mutation is relatively mild. This finding strongly supports the potential benefit of exon skipping in patients with DMD.

Evaluation of exon-skipping strategies for Duchenne muscular dystrophy utilizing dystrophin-deficient zebrafish

Duchenne muscular dystophy (DMD) is a severe muscle wasting disease caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene. By utilizing antisense oligonucleotides, splicing of the dystrophin transcript can be altered so that exons harbouring a mutation are excluded from the mature mRNA. Although this approach has been shown to be effective to restore partially functional dystrophin protein, the level of dystrophin protein that is necessary to rescue a severe muscle pathology has not been addressed. As zebrafish dystrophin mutants (dmd) resemble the severe muscle pathology of human patients, we have utilized this model to evaluate exon skipping. Novel dmd mutations were identified to enable the design of phenotype rescue studies via morpholino administration. Correlation of induced exon-skipping efficiency and the level of phenotype rescue suggest that relatively robust levels of exon skipping are required to achieve significant therapeutic ameliorations and that pre-screening analysis of exon-skipping drugs in zebrafish may help to more accurately predict clinical trials for therapies of DMD.

Pseudometabolic presentation of dystrophinopathy due to a missense mutation

Exercise intolerance with myalgia, muscle stiffness, and recurrent rhabdomyolysis due to mutations in the DMD gene can mimic metabolic myopathies leading to delayed or inaccurate diagnoses. In this retrospective chart review, we report 3 unrelated boys with exertional myalgia, muscle stiffness, myoglobinuria, and normal neurological examination due to an identical point mutation in the DMD gene: a hemizygous T-to-C change in exon 15 (c.1724T>C) resulting in an amino acid substitution of leucine to proline at codon 575. Two of the 3 boys had normal dystrophin immunostaining and Western blot analysis in muscle. This missense mutation has been reported twice before, with at least 1 patient exhibiting rhabdomyolysis. Our report, however, is the first to describe in detail the clinical findings associated with this specific mutation. Further studies and clinical reports are needed to better understand the pathogenicity of the mutation.

Dose-dependent restoration of dystrophin expression in cardiac muscle of dystrophic mice by systemically delivered morpholino

We have earlier shown that antisense morpholino oligomers are able to restore dystrophin expression by systemic delivery in body-wide skeletal muscles of dystrophic mdx mice. However, the levels of dystrophin expression vary considerably and, more importantly, no dystrophin expression has been achieved in cardiac muscle. In this study, we investigate the efficiency of morpholino-induced exon skipping in cardiomyoblasts and myocytes in vitro, and in cardiac muscle in vivo by dose escalation. We showed that morpholino induces targeted exon skipping equally effectively in both skeletal muscle myoblasts and cardiomyoblasts. Effective exon skipping was achieved in cardiomyocytes in culture. In the mdx mice, morpholino rescues dystrophin expression dose dependently in both skeletal and cardiac muscles. Therapeutic levels of dystrophin were achieved in cardiac muscle albeit at higher doses than in skeletal muscles. Up to 50 and 30% normal levels of dystrophin were induced by single systemic delivery of 3 g kg(-1) of morpholino in skeletal and cardiac muscles, respectively. High doses of morpholino treatment reduced the serum levels of creatine kinase without clear toxicity. These findings suggest that effective rescue of dystrophin in cardiac muscles can be achieved by morpholino for the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy.

Theoretic applicability of antisense-mediated exon skipping for Duchenne muscular dystrophy mutations

Antisense-mediated exon skipping aiming for reading frame restoration is currently a promising therapeutic application for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). This approach is mutation specific, but as the majority of DMD patients have deletions that cluster in hotspot regions, the skipping of a small number of exons is applicable to relatively large numbers of patients. To assess the actual applicability of the exon skipping approach, we here determined for deletions, duplications and point mutations reported in the Leiden DMD mutation database, which exon(s) should be skipped to restore the open reading frame. In theory, single and double exon skipping would be applicable to 79% of deletions, 91% of small mutations, and 73% of duplications, amounting to 83% of all DMD mutations. Exon 51 skipping, which is being tested in clinical trials, would be applicable to the largest group (13%) of all DMD patients. Further research is needed to determine the functionality of different in-frame dystrophins and a number of hurdles has to be overcome before this approach can be applied clinically.

Cardiac involvement in Becker muscular dystrophy

The present review gives an overview of the clinical and subclinical manifestations of cardiac involvement (CI) in Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD), its pathophysiological background, diagnostic possibilities and therapeutic options for CI in BMD patients and carriers. CI may be subclinical or symptomatic. Up to 100% of patients develop subclinical CI. The onset of symptomatic CI is usually in the third decade of life, rarely in the first decade. One-third of patients develop dilative cardiomyopathy with concomitant heart failure. In BMD patients, CI manifests as electrocardiographic abnormalities, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, dilation of the cardiac cavities with preserved systolic function, dilative cardiomyopathy or cardiac arrest. There is no correlation between CI and the severity of myopathy. CI is more prominent in patients than carriers. As soon as the diagnosis of BMD is established, a comprehensive cardiac examination should be performed. Because CI in BMD is progressive and adequate therapy is available, cardiac investigations need to be regularly repeated. If CI in BMD is recognized early, appropriate therapy may be applied early, resulting in a more favourable outcome.

Genetic testing in cardiovascular disease

Genetic testing is increasingly becoming possible for diagnosis, susceptibility testing, and prognostication in cardiovascular medicine. The practicing cardiologist, therefore, needs to be familiar with the clinical utilities and limitations of genetic testing. This review explores the major approaches to genetic testing and issues in test interpretation. Specific applications to cardiovascular diseases, including coronary artery disease, cardiomyopathies, cardiac arrhythmias, and pulmonary arterial hypertension are discussed.

Entries in the Leiden Duchenne muscular dystrophy mutation database: an overview of mutation types and paradoxical cases that confirm the reading-frame rule

The severe Duchenne and milder Becker muscular dystrophy are both caused by mutations in the DMD gene. This gene codes for dystrophin, a protein important for maintaining the stability of muscle-fiber membranes. In 1988, Monaco and colleagues postulated an explanation for the phenotypic difference between Duchenne and Becker patients in the reading-frame rule: In Duchenne patients, mutations induce a shift in the reading frame leading to prematurely truncated, dysfunctional dystrophins. In Becker patients, in-frame mutations allow the synthesis of internally deleted, but largely functional dystrophins. Currently, over 4700 mutations have been reported in the Leiden DMD mutation database, of which 91% are in agreement with this rule. In this study we provide an update of the mutational variability in the DMD gene, particularly focusing on genotype-phenotype correlations and mutations that appear to be exceptions to the reading-frame rule.

The heart in human dystrophinopathies

Dystrophinopathies are due to mutations in the dystrophin gene on chromosome Xp21.1 and comprise the allelic entities Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) and X-linked dilative cardiomyopathy (XLDCM). In all three entities, the heart is affected to various degrees, depending on the stage of the disease and the type of the mutation (cardiac involvement, CI). The pathoanatomic evidence of CI in dystrophinopathies is the replacement of myocardium by connective tissue or fat. In DMD/BMD, the left ventricular posterobasal and lateral walls are most extensively affected, sparing the right ventricle and the atrium. Degree and dynamics of CI vary among the three entities. In DMD/BMD, CI usually remains subclinical in the early stages of the disease. Typical initial manifestations of CI in DMD/BMD are sinus tachycardia, tall R1 in V1, prominent Q in I, aVL, V6 or in II, III, and aVF, increased QT dispersion and possibly autonomic dysfunction. Initially, echocardiography is normal or shows regional wall motion abnormalities in areas of fibrosis. With spreading of fibrosis, left ventricular dysfunction and ventricular arrhythmias additionally occur. In the final stages of the disease, systolic function may lead to heart failure and sudden death. Subclinical or clinical CI is present in about 90% of the DMD/BMD patients but is the cause of death in only 20% of the DMD and 50% of the BMD patients. XLDCM is a rapidly progressive, almost exclusively myocardial disorder, starting in teenage males as heart failure due to dilative cardiomyopathy (CMP), leading to death from intractable heart failure within 1-2 years after diagnosis. Therapy of arrhythmias and CMP in all three disorders follows the established cardiological recommendations. Due to its protective effect, ACE inhibitors are recommended already at the early stages of the disease. Beta-blockers may be an additional option if indicated.

Myocardial involvement is very frequent among patients affected with subclinical Becker's muscular dystrophy

BACKGROUND

Several cases of Becker's muscular dystrophy (BMD) have been reported, which showed mild or subclinical skeletal muscle involvement with an overt dilated cardiomyopathy. Here, for the first time, a group of 28 patients with BMD who had a subclinical or benign myopathy have been studied through a thorough cardiological assessment.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Each patient underwent ECG and echocardiographic examinations. Molecular analyses of the dystrophin gene and protein were performed. An unexpectedly high incidence of myocardial involvement was observed among patients affected with subclinical (72%) or benign (60%) BMD. The cardiac involvement appears to develop early from the right ventricle. Both the increase in left ventricular end-diastolic volume and the reduction in the ejection fraction appeared to be age related. Severe left ventricular dilation with reduced ejection fraction, which could be complicated by life-threatening arrhythmias, may occur. Contrary to previous reports, which indicated the involvement of 5'-end mutations in cardiomyopathies as a result of dystrophin gene alterations, this study shows that despite the apparent concentration of deletions in two regions (5'-end and exons 47 through 49), no general conclusions can be drawn regarding the involvement of specific gene mutations in the development of cardiomyopathy.

CONCLUSIONS

Cardiomyopathy is the main clinical feature and complication in patients affected by subclinical or mild BMD. The cardiac manifestation is characterized by early right ventricular involvement and is later associated with left ventricular impairment. In mild BMD, myocardial damage may develop because the patients, who are unaware of a possible cardiac involvement, are still able to perform strenuous muscle exercise and, through pressure or volume overload, may induce mechanical stress, which is harmful for dystrophin-deficient myocardial cells.

Prognostic factors in mild dystrophinopathies

One hundred twenty five patients from 105 families were considered, showing in-frame intragenic deletion or duplication of the dystrophin gene and/or abnormal dystrophin on muscle biopsy. According to clinical status of patients, the affection was classified as subclinical, benign, moderate or severe. Significant decrease of dystrophin abundance was observed with increasing clinical severity (p < 0.05). Detailed clinical data were available in 68 patients in whom a long-term follow-up (6-39 years) was obtained. Functional performance at different ages and disease endpoints were recorded in order to analyze the rate of disease progression. We identified three different disease courses: stable, slow and rapid progression. We observed a significantly lower level of dystrophin and immunohistochemical score (p < 0.05 vs. the other courses) in patients with rapid course. Deletion or duplication in the 5' end of the gene was associated with poor prognosis. Prognosis was substantially better, showing a stable course, in patients with large deletions or duplications in the proximal rod region. These subjects often suffered from a cramps/myalgia syndrome or experienced rhabdomyolisis. Cardiac involvement was detected in 65% of cases. A significant increase of right ventricular volume was seen in all clinical groups (p < 0.05). A left ventricular dilation was observed in 25% and a decreased ejection fraction in 29% of our patients. The reduction of ejection fraction and the increase of left ventricular volume were age-related. Since sudden death may occur as a consequence of cardiomyopathy, severe left ventricular dysfunction in dystrophinopathic patients is another important adverse prognostic factor, although not always directly correlated with skeletal muscle impairment.

Clinical and histopathological features of abnormalities of the dystrophin-based membrane cytoskeleton

The majority (approximately 70%) of cases of childhood and adult onset muscular dystrophies in males, and approximately 10% of dystrophy in girls and women, show underlying primary abnormalities of dystrophin. Approximately 2% of childhood/adult onset muscular dystrophy patients have a primary defect of one of the three sarcoglycan proteins identified to date (alpha, beta, gamma). The finding of a sarcoglycan deficiency in muscle generally does not reflect the primary underlying defect, and thus testing of biopsies for sarcoglycans should be used only after normal dystrophin findings, and in conjunction with gene mutation testing. Approximately 30% of neonatal onset congenital muscular dystrophy has been shown to be due alpha 2-laminin (merosin) deficiency. alpha 2-laminin is a component of the myofiber basal lamina, and this protein interacts with the dystrophin-based membrane cytoskeleton. Due to the similar clinical and histopathological features of the different etiologies of muscular dystrophies, molecular testing of peripheral blood DNA and muscle biopsy protein are a critical part of the clinical work-up of dystrophy patients. Many patients carrying a Becker dystrophy or limb-girdle dystrophy diagnosis should be re-evaluated with molecular tests to provide accurate genetic counseling to their families.

DMD and BMD in the same family due to distinct mutations

We report on a family with a boy affected by Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) and an asymptomatic cousin with a Becker-type dystrophin abnormality, diagnosed by chance. Dystrophin gene analysis showed that these conditions were caused by two distinct deletions with breakpoints in different exons. In Xp21 families, DNA analysis and dystrophin testing of asymptomatic males with high CK plasma levels might detect different dystrophin mutations in separate haplotypes as in our family, although we stress there should be clear clinical or familial indications for such testing.

Dystrophin characterization in BMD patients: correlation of abnormal protein with clinical phenotype

We have investigated protein expression and genotype in 59 Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) patients. The aim was to identify possible causes of the marked variability in phenotype in patients with similar deletions/mutations. The patients were examined neurologically and functionally and underwent Manual Muscle Testing. Dystrophin expression was analysed by immunohistochemistry and western blot using antibodies against six different segments of the protein. DNA mutations were investigated by PCR amplification of 30 exons. Based on dystrophin expression at the sarcolemma, two groups of patients were identified: group A (29 patients) with the classic patchy distribution of dystrophin and group B (30 patients) with absence or reduction of one or more dystrophin portions and variable, although mostly normal, expression of the other portions of the protein. Dystrophin molecular weight was normal or slightly reduced in group A and was variably reduced, generally conspicuously so, in group B. The quantity of dystrophin expressed varied markedly in both groups. The pattern of immunohistochemical staining in group B patients correlated with milder clinical phenotype, suggesting that small dystrophin molecules lacking a portion in the N-terminus or in the rod domain, are more functional than proteins with normal or slightly reduced molecular weight that display the BMD-typical patchy distribution at the sarcolemma.

Dystrophin-positive fibers in Duchenne dystrophy: origin and correlation to clinical course

In 132 DMD muscle biopsies we investigated the presence of dystrophin-positive fibers and the relationship of dystrophin immunohistochemical pattern to the clinical severity of the disease. Reverted fibers were detected in 37% of patients; their prevalence increased significantly in each biopsy with age of patients. We suggest that reversion occurs in satellite cells, when muscle differentiation is completed. The longitudinal extent of dystrophin-positive domain spans a maximum length of 900 microns. No correlation was found between the presence of reverted fibers and the clinical severity of DMD, whereas a milder form of Duchenne dystrophy was observed in patients showing a faint reaction in all fibers. The occurrence of reverted fibers is independent of the type of gene mutation; however, a higher proportion of cases with reverted fibers was found among patients with gene duplications.

Absence of dystrophin and spectrin in regenerating muscle fibers from Becker dystrophy patients

We studied muscle biopsies from 36 Becker muscular dystrophy patients, and correlated dystrophin negative fibers with regenerating and degenerating myofibers. Dystrophin immunohistochemistry was used to identify dystrophin-negative and dystrophin-positive fibers. Immunohistochemical staining for fetal myosin and acid ATPase identified regenerating fibers, and calcium glioxalate and beta-spectrin staining identified necrotic fibers. All Becker biopsies contained detectable dystrophin in the majority of muscle fibers. 13 cases (36%) showed no dystrophin negative fibers, 9 cases (25%) showed a generalized, markedly decreased immunostaining pattern, and 14 cases (39%) showed a subset of dystrophin negative fibers (0.3-8% of total). Most dystrophin-negative fibers in Becker muscle were judged to be in the process of regeneration, and not in degeneration. No correlation was observed between the age of the patients and number of dystrophin negative fibers. We conclude that the absence of dystrophin and spectrin labeling in some BMD myofibers is associated with regeneration, probably due to incomplete expression of dystrophin secondary to myofibers immaturity. Our results might be explained by a developmental delayed expression of these two proteins, or by abnormal assembling in membrane's components during regeneration in dystrophy. Furthermore, our results rationalize the recently reported finding of some dystrophin-negative fibers in polymyositis.