The reparative phenomena at the site of balloon angioplasty in humans and experimental models

Focused force angioplasty: theory and application

Focused force angioplasty is a technique in which the forces resulting from inflating an angioplasty balloon in a stenosis are concentrated and focused at one or more locations within the stenosis. While the technique has been shown to be useful in resolving resistant stenoses, its real value may be in minimizing the vascular trauma associated with balloon angioplasty and subsequently improving the outcome.

Peripheral vascular brachytherapy

Ongoing advances in peripheral endovascular technology have been met with disappointing results because of restenosis within the treated vessel. In particular, stent balloon angioplasty of peripheral vessels has yet to achieve patency rates that approximate conventional treatment in the long term. Recent advances in stent, balloon, and wire construction include the incorporation of radioactive substances in an attempt to ameliorate the inflammatory response provoked by typical endovascular manipulation, a technique termed vascular brachytherapy. gamma- and beta-isotopes and external beam radiation target the very cell population whose activity results in the development of neointimal hyperplasia. Although most clinical research examining the efficacy of vascular brachytherapy has emerged from the coronary artery literature, the use of vascular brachytherapy also has been examined in the peripheral arterial tree and has shown promising results. Current data indicate that vascular brachytherapy is a safe and accessible adjunctive endovascular maneuver that may improve the short-term patency rate of peripheral endovascular applications. The effects on long-term patency rates remain indeterminate compared to conventional therapy.

Rationale for coronary artery radiation therapy

Within the past decade, focus on radiation to prevent restenosis has moved from a concept developed in the animal laboratory to a clinical treatment. The initial evaluation of coronary artery radiation therapy focused on changes in the function of the artery or lesion formation following overstretch balloon injury in pigs. A number of concepts emerged from this work: (1) radiation inhibits neointima formation in a dose-dependent fashion, (2) radiation prevents negative remodeling, (3) radiation does not reverse established injury, (4) low dose irradiation in an injured area may be injurious, (5) radiation is a useful adjunct to stenting, (6) benefits of radiation in animal models at 6 months are less pronounced than at 1 month, (7) radiation delays healing, (8) permanent stents and radiation delivered from external sources may have very different effects on restenosis, and (9) radiation interferes with vessel wall function. More recent studies of irradiation have looked at the molecular biological effects of radiation in hopes of understanding how this therapy works, and how it may be improved. This article attempts to summarize the known animal and cellular work on radiation in preventing restenosis.

Fibrocellular tissue responses to endovascular and external beam irradiation in the porcine model of restenosis

PURPOSE

Endovascular radiation has reduced postangioplasty restenosis in preclinical and early clinical studies. External radiation treatment may have advantages over endovascular therapy. We examined vascular and perivascular tissue responses to endovascular and external irradiation in pig coronary arteries.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Ninety-one animals received endovascular or external radiation following balloon injury and were sacrificed at 14, 30, or 180 days. Injured segments of coronary vessels including perivascular and myocardial tissues were evaluated with histochemistry.

RESULTS

Endovascular radiation was associated with delayed arterial wound healing as late as 6 months, evidenced by paucity of smooth muscle alpha-actin in neointimal cells compared to control. External treatment was associated with increased collagen in neointima and adventitia, and focal interstitial necrosis in adjacent myocardium.

CONCLUSIONS

These investigations showed whole-heart 14 Gy external radiation treatment following coronary injury exacerbated certain aspects of arterial healing. In addition focal myocardial necrosis and fibrosis was observed following external but not endovascular irradiation. Endovascular radiation has some advantages over external irradiation; however the persistence of a synthetic smooth muscle cell phenotype in the neointima at 6 months suggests ionizing radiation in general may have profound effects on vessel architecture over the long term.

The American Brachytherapy Society perspective on intravascular brachytherapy

BACKGROUND

Recent clinical studies indicate that intravascular brachytherapy (IVB) can reduce the rate of restenosis substantially after angioplasty procedures. However, no clinical guidelines exist for optimal therapy.

METHODS

The members of the IVB Subcommittee of the American Brachytherapy Society (ABS) identified the areas of consensus and controversies in IVB to issue the ABS perspective on IVB, based on analysis of published reports and the clinical experience of the members in brachytherapy.

RESULTS

IVB is still experimental. The long-term efficacy, toxicity, the target tissue, and dose required for IVB are not established. The ABS recommends that IVB procedures must be performed, with careful attention to radiation-related issues, in the context of controlled multidisciplinary clinical trials with the approval of the institutional review board, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, the Food and Drug Administration, and under an Investigational Device Exemption. The therapeutic radiologist, with a qualified radiation physicist, is responsible for dose prescription and delivery and needs to be present during the IVB procedure as part of this multidisciplinary team. The long-term outcome from these studies should be reviewed critically and published in peer-reviewed journals. The ABS endorsed the dosimetric guidelines of the American Association of Physicists in Medicine Task Group 60 (AAPM TG-60) report. The ABS recommends that dose specification be defined clearly; to allow comparisons between studies, the dose should be prescribed at 2 mm from the source for intracoronary brachytherapy and at an average luminal radius of +2 mm for peripheral vascular brachytherapy. The prescription doses at the above point is generally in the 12-18 Gy range. Comprehensive procedures for quality assurance, radiation protection, and emergencies should be in place before initiating an IVB program. Higher energy beta sources, lower energy gamma sources, dose-volume histograms, and correlation of three-dimensional reconstructions of delivered dose with patterns of failure are areas for further research.

CONCLUSION

The ABS perspective on IVB is presented to assist the interventional team in developing protocols for the use of IVB in the prevention of restenosis. Long-term outcome data with a standardized reporting system are needed to establish the role of brachytherapy in preventing vascular restenosis. Endovascular brachytherapy is a new and evolving modality, and these recommendations are subject to modifications as new data become available.

[Intravascular irradiation in the combined therapy and prevention of restenosis. Overview]

Despite numerous efforts in catheter technology and procedural approaches the problem of restenosis in interventional cardiology persists. Although the implantation of coronary stents has significantly reduced restenosis rates based on the inhibition of elastic recoil, intimal proliferation as the second major mechanism for postinterventional restenosis could not effectively be suppressed. Intimal proliferation is the response to vessel injury following interventional procedure, e.g. balloon angioplasty. It results in the adhesion of mono- and lymphocytes which themselves trigger the colonisation of myofibroblasts. Intracoronary irradiation seeks to prevent this proliferative process as it destroys or irreversibly alters DNA structures of cells at the site of balloon injury. The antiproliferative effect depends on the irradiation dosis, the timing and the cell cycle phase. Mainly beta- and gamma-radiation is used for intracoronary irradiation. Beta-emitters are characterized by a sharp decline of dose rate within millimeters from the actual source. The exposure to surrounding tissue as well the catheter staff can be kept to a minimum. The high intensity of beta-emitters allow a short treatment period of minutes to gain an effective radiation dose to the target. In contrast, gamma-emitters have a low radial dose distribution resulting in high dosage even centimeters away from the source. These emitters require additional shielding in the catheter laboratory and lead to excessive whole body doses. To achieve a sufficient dose in the target tissue, irradiation times of more than 20 minutes are necessary which prolongs the interventional procedure substantially. At present, catheter based systems or radioactive implantable stents are available to deliver the required dose. Catheter based systems seem more flexible in a number of considerations. On the other hand they require a substantial amount of hardware. Beta-emitting stents are implanted via a conventional stent delivery system with small shielding modifications. However, stents emit an inhomogeneous radiation profile due to the mesh-like structure. In addition, not every lesion can be reached by a stent nor does every lesion require a stent solely to deliver radiation. External irradiation is presently not recommended due to its ineffectiveness and the high rate of side effects. In the experimental setting the porcine model comes closest to the clinical situation in man. Animal experiments have demonstrated the effective reduction of intimal proliferation using beta- and gamma-sources in a wide dose range of 3 to 56 Gy. Although the initial and early results are convincing little is know about the long term results. Only few studies have been and are currently performed in patients. Some of these investigations demonstrate a significant reduction of restenosis rate after 6 months. Again, information on long-term results are lacking. It has to be considered that perivascular fibrosis, which may occur with a delay of 5 to 10 years depending on the dosage, could curtail the initial success. Intracoronary irradiation is a promising method for the prevention of restenosis. The dose finding with respect to the dose effect relation, the determination of the therapeutic window and the timing of irradiation have to be further defined in the clinical setting. Nevertheless, intracoronary irradiation remains high on the priority list in fighting restenosis.

Intracoronary radiation decreases the second phase of intimal hyperplasia in a repeat balloon angioplasty model of restenosis

PURPOSE

Repeat balloon angioplasty is likely to induce intimal proliferation, which is associated with a higher restenosis rate. This study examined the effect of intracoronary ionizing radiation on restenotic lesions using repeat balloon injury in a normolipemic swine.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Eight domestic normolipemic pigs underwent overstretch balloon angioplasty with a 3.5 mm balloon in the LAD and LCX, followed by repeat balloon injury at the same sites 4 weeks after the initial injury. At that time a high activity 192Iridium source was introduced immediately after the angioplasty by random assignment to deliver 14 Gy at 2 mm in eight of the injured coronary arteries (LAD and LCX). One month later the animals were killed and the coronary arteries pressure perfusion fixed. Serial sections were stained with H&E and VVG, then evaluated by histopathologic and morphometric techniques. Maximal intimal thickness (MIT), intimal area (IA), and intimal area corrected for the extent of injury (IA/FL) were measured in the irradiated and control arteries and were compared to control arteries with single injuries from previous studies.

RESULTS

Repeat balloon injury induced significant additional medial damage, which was associated with marked intimal hyperplasia in a concentric pattern. Intracoronary irradiation significantly decreased the total of neointima area formation (IA 93 + 0.35 mm2 compared to control 1.38 + 0.33 mm2 p < 0.01) and the MIT was also significantly reduced in the irradiated vessels (0.57 + 0.18 mm vs. 0.71 + 0.08 mm, p = 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Intracoronary irradiation immediately after the second balloon dilatation inhibits the intimal hyperplasia due to that injury. However, there was no effect on the existing neointima from the initial injury.

Intracoronary Low-Dose Ionizing Irradiation (β or γ) for Prevention of Restenosis: Could It Succeed Where Pharmacotherapy Failed?

Although the precise pathogenesis of restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) remains somewhat elusive, our understanding about the reparative phenomena at the site of dilatation has been significantly improved in recent years. Thus, restenosis appears to be the result of migration, proliferation, and excessive matrix formation by smooth muscle cells plus vascular wall remodeling leading to chronic recoil (constriction). Proposed pharmacotherapies to prevent restenosis have been ineffective in humans, in spite of a relative success in certain experimental animals. The rationale for low-dose irradiation (either β or γ) in order to prevent restenosis is based on the known ability of ionizing irradiation to arrest cell division and, therefore, to reduce the number of clonal progenitors in situations like angioplasty.

Intracoronary low-dose beta-irradiation inhibits neointima formation after coronary artery balloon injury in the swine restenosis model

BACKGROUND

Neointima formation contributing to recurrent stenosis remains a major limitation of percutaneous transluminal angioplasty. Endovascular low-dose gamma-irradiation has been shown to reduce intimal thickening (hyperplasia) after balloon overstretch injury in pig coronary arteries, a model of restenosis. The objective of this study was to determine whether the use of a beta-emitting radioisotope for this application would have similar effects and to examine the dose-response relations with this approach.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Normal domestic pigs underwent balloon overstretch injury in the left anterior descending and left circumflex and coronary arteries. A flexible catheter was introduced by random assignment into one of these arteries and was afterloaded with a 2.5-cm ribbon of encapsulated 90Strontium/90Yttrium sources (90Sr/Y, a pure beta-emitter). It was left in place for a period of time sufficient to deliver one of four doses: 7, 14, 28, or 56 Gy, to a depth of 2 mm. Animals were killed 14 days after balloon injury, the coronary vasculature was pressure-perfusion fixed, and histomorphometric analysis of arterial cross sections was performed. All arteries treated with radiation demonstrated significantly decreased neointima formation compared with control arteries. The ratio of intimal area to medial fracture length was inversely correlated with increasing radiation dose: control (no radiation), 0.47; 7 Gy, 0.34; 14 Gy, 0.20; 28 Gy, 0.08; and 56 Gy, 0.02 (r = -.78, P < .000001). Scanning electron microscopy demonstrated a confluent layer of endothelium-like cells both in control and in 14 Gy-irradiated arteries. There was neither evidence of significant necrosis nor excess fibrosis in the media, adventitia, or perivascular space of the coronary arteries or adjacent myocardium in the irradiated groups. Furthermore, the exposure to the staff and the total body exposure to the pig with the beta source was a small fraction of the dose previously measured and calculated with 192Ir, a gamma-emitting radioisotope.

CONCLUSIONS

Administration of endovascular beta-radiation to the site of coronary arterial overstretch balloon injury in pigs with 90Sr/Y is technically feasible and safe. Radiation doses between 7 and 56 Gy showed evidence of inhibition of neointima formation. A dose-response relation was demonstrated, but no further inhibitory effect was seen beyond 28 Gy. These data suggest that intracoronary beta-irradiation is practical and feasible and may aid in preventing clinical restenosis.

Endovascular low-dose irradiation inhibits neointima formation after coronary artery balloon injury in swine. A possible role for radiation therapy in restenosis prevention

BACKGROUND

Restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty remains a major limitation of the long-term success of this procedure. Restenosis is a form of wound healing. Low-dose ionizing radiation has been effective in inhibiting exuberant wound healing responses in a variety of clinical situations.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Vascular neointimal lesions resembling human restenosis were created in the coronary arteries of normal pigs by overstretch balloon angioplasty injury. To test the effect of low-dose endovascular gamma radiation on lesion formation, a high-activity 192Ir source was introduced into one of the injured arteries in each animal and left in place for a period sufficient to deliver one of three doses: 350, 700, or 1400 cGy. To test potential benefits of delayed irradiation, 700 cGy was given in another group 2 days after injury. Animals were killed 14 days after balloon injury and the coronary vasculature was pressure-perfusion fixed. To test the late effect and safety of endovascular low-dose irradiation, 700 or 1400 cGy was given in miniswine coronary arteries after injury as well as in noninjured carotid arteries; this group was followed up for 6 months. Tissue sections were measured by computer-assisted planimetry. All arteries treated with radiation demonstrated significantly decreased neointima formation compared with control arteries. The ratio of intimal area-to-medial fracture length (IA/FL) was inversely correlated with the different radiation doses: control, 0.59; 350 cGy, 0.38; 700 cGy, 0.42; and 1400 cGy, 0.17 (r = -0.75, P < .0001). Delay of 700-cGy irradiation for 2 days after injury significantly decreased neointima formation compared with the same dose given immediately after injury. Analysis of long-term specimens showed reduction of IA/FL in the arteries irradiated with 700 cGy (0.3, P = .009) and 1400 cGy (0.31, P = .001) compared with control arteries (0.50). There was no excess fibrosis in the media, adventitia, or perivascular space of the coronary arteries or adjacent myocardium in pigs that received radiation compared with control animals.

CONCLUSIONS

Low-dose intracoronary irradiation delivered to the site of coronary arterial overstretch balloon injury in pigs inhibited subsequent intimal thickening (hyperplasia). A dose-response relationship was demonstrated, and delay of treatment for 48 hours appeared to augment the inhibitory effect. Six months of follow-up without fibrosis or arteriosclerosis demonstrated the durability of the beneficial effect in the treated group. These data suggest that intracoronary irradiation therapy may aid in preventing clinical restenosis.