Online stable carbon isotope ratio measurement in formic acid, acetic acid, methanol and ethanol in water by high performance liquid chromatography–isotope ratio mass spectrometry

Simultaneous observation of 2H and 13C enrichment of methyl phosphonic acid via Orbitrap-IRMS with applications to nerve agent forensics

Quantification of the stable isotopes within a compound aids forensic investigations as it provides a fingerprint which can determine that compound's source substrates, synthetic route, and possible mechanisms of degradation. Previous stable isotope studies have explored 13C and 2H measurements of the sarin precursors methylphosphonic dichloride (DC) and methylphosphonic difluoride (DF) as forensic signatures. However, these measurements required different sample preparations and measurement techniques. Orbitrap isotope ratio mass spectrometry (Orbitrap-IRMS) is a developing technique which can characterize multiple stable isotopes simultaneously. Here, we apply Orbitrap-IRMS to simultaneously observe the 13C and 2H content of methylphosphonic acid (MPA), the hydrolysis product of DC and DF, which can be used as a proxy for the isotopic content of DC and DF. Our method requires 20 min analyses and consumes ≈60 nmol of sample, with precisions of ≈0.9 ‰ (13C) and ≈3.6 ‰ (2H). We apply our method to both commercially acquired MPA and MPA obtained from the hydrolysis of commercially acquired DC. We validate our methods via comparison to elemental-analyzer isotope ratio mass spectrometry (EA-IRMS). The combined 13C and 2H measurement creates a more robust forensic tool than either isotope individually. Our results demonstrate the viability of Orbitrap-IRMS for chemical forensic measurements.

Bias estimation in the certification of steroid reference materials for carbon isotope delta measurements via elemental analyser and gas chromatography-combustion-isotope ratio mass spectrometry

RATIONALE

Two new certified reference materials (CRMs) have been prepared providing three steroids certified for stable carbon isotope delta values, δ(¹³ C) ‰. These materials have been designed to assist anti-doping laboratories in validating their calibration method or to be employed as calibrant for stable carbon isotope measurements of Boldenone, Boldenone Metabolite 1 and Formestane. These CRMs will allow for accurate and traceable analysis in compliance with World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) Technical Document TD2021IRMS.

METHODS

Certification was performed using an elemental analyser-isotope ratio mass spectrometry (EA-IRMS) primary reference method on the bulk carbon isotope ratios of nominally pure steroid starting materials. EA-IRMS analyses were carried out on a Flash EA Isolink CN coupled via a Conflo IV to a Delta V plus mass spectrometer. Confirmation analysis was performed by gas chromatography-combustion-isotope ratio mass spectrometry (GC-C-IRMS) using a Trace 1310 GC coupled to a Delta V plus mass spectrometer via GC Isolink II.

RESULTS

Based on the EA-IRMS analysis, the materials were certified with δ(¹³ C) values of -30.38‰ (Boldenone), -29.71‰ (Boldenone Metabolite 1) and 30.71‰ (Formestane). Noting that the assumption of 100% purity in the starting materials has the potential to introduce bias, this was investigated using GC-C-IRMS analysis and theoretical modelling based on purity assessment data.

CONCLUSIONS

Careful application of this theoretical model was shown to provide reasonable estimates of uncertainty while avoiding the introduction of errors associated with analyte-specific fractionation during GC-C-IRMS analysis.

New Concepts for the Determination of Oxidation Efficiencies in Liquid Chromatography-Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometry

In liquid chromatography coupled to isotope ratio mass spectrometry (LC-IRMS), analytes are separated on an LC system and consecutively oxidized to CO₂, which is required for the determination of compound-specific carbon isotope ratios. Oxidation is performed in an online reactor by sulfate radicals. Reaction conditions in the interface depend on the flow conditions determined by the LC method and the flow rates and concentrations of oxidation agent and phosphoric acid added in the interface. To determine accurate isotope ratios, a quantitative conversion of the carbon contained in the analyte to the CO₂ measurement gas is a prerequisite. Oxidation efficiencies are not commonly evaluated during method development, although certain analytes are known to be difficult to be oxidized by sulfate radicals. For the assessment of the oxidation efficiency of the LC-IRMS system, three different approaches were evaluated. (1) Residual organic carbon in the eluent stream of the interface was determined to calculate oxidation yields depending on the initial analyte concentration. (2) The IRMS response was calibrated to an inorganic carbon reference material to determine oxidation efficiencies with the help of the IRMS as a detector. (3) The oxidation temperature was deliberately reduced while monitoring the δ¹³C and signal intensity. The common assumption that a linear relation of IRMS signal to analyte concentration is an indicator for complete oxidation in LC-IRMS could be disproved. All three approaches can be applied for future method development in LC-IRMS, monitoring of existing flow injection applications, as well as for verification of complete oxidation in established LC-IRMS methods.

The influence of different referencing methods on the accuracy of δ(13) C value measurement of ethanol fuel by gas chromatography/combustion/isotope ratio mass spectrometry

RATIONALE

Brazil is the largest producer of sugar cane bioethanol in the world. Isotope ratio mass spectrometry (IRMS) is the technique of choice to certify the origin/raw materials for ethanol production, but the lack of certified reference materials (CRMs) for accurate measurements of δ(13) C values traceable to Vienna Pee Dee Belemnite (VPDB), the international zero point for (13) C/(12) C measurements, certified and compatible with gas chromatography (GC)/IRMS instruments may compromise the accuracy of δ(13) C determinations.

METHODS

We evaluated the influence of methods for the calibration and normalization of raw δ(13) C values of ethanol samples. Samples were analyzed by GC/C/IRMS using two different GC columns. Different substances were used as isotopic standards for the working gas calibration. The δ(13) C values obtained with the three methods of normalization were statistically compared with those obtained with elemental analyzer (EA)/IRMS, since the δ(13) C results obtained using EA are traceable to VPDB via the NBS 22 reference material.

RESULTS

It was observed that both the isotopic reference material for CO2 calibration and the GC column have a major effect on the δ(13) C measurements, leading to a bias of almost 2-3 ‰ in the δ(13) C values. All three methods of normalization were equivalent in performance, enabling an improvement in the GC/C/IRMS accuracy, compared with the EA/IRMS reference values for the samples.

CONCLUSIONS

All the methods of CO2 calibration, chromatography and normalization presented in this work demonstrated several sources of traceability and accuracy loss for the determination of δ(13) C values in ethanol fuel samples by GC/C/IRMS. This work has also shown the importance of using proper CRMs traceable to VPBD that should be compatible and certified using GC/C/IRMS, ideally in a wide range of δ(13) C values. This is important not only for bioethanol fuel samples, but also for many analytes commonly analyzed by IRMS.

A radical approach for fluorescent turn ‘on’ detection, differentiation and bioimaging of methanol

A Schiff base (RC) is presented herein as a smart fluorescent material for the selective detection and bioimaging of methanol. The key step behind same involves methanol induced opening of the cyclic control unit ofRCresulting in the formation of a highly fluorescent moiety,RO.

A novel high-temperature combustion based system for stable isotope analysis of dissolved organic carbon in aqueous samples. II: optimization and assessment of analytical performance

RATIONALE

Dissolved organic carbon (DOC) plays an important role in carbon cycling, making precise and routine measurement of δ(13)C values and DOC concentration highly desirable. A new promising system has been developed for this purpose. However, broad-scale application of this new technique requires an in-depth assessment of analytical performance, and this is described here.

METHODS

A high-temperature combustion Total Organic Carbon analyzer was interfaced with continuous flow isotope ratio mass spectrometry (TOC/IRMS) for the simultaneous analysis of the bulk DOC concentration and δ(13)C signature. The analytical performance (precision, memory effects, linearity, volume/concentration effects, accuracy) was thoroughly evaluated, including realistic and challenging conditions such as low DOC concentrations and natural DOC.

RESULTS

High precision (standard deviation, SD predominantly ≤ 0.15 ‰) and accuracy (R(2) = 0.9997) were achieved for the δ(13)C analysis of a broad diversity of DOC solutions. Simultaneously, good results were obtained for the measurement of DOC concentration. Assessment of natural abundance and slightly (13)C-enriched DOC, a wide range of concentrations (~0.2-150 mgC/L) and injection volumes (0.05-3 mL), demonstrated minor/negligible memory effects, good linearity and flexible usage. Finally, TOC/IRMS was successfully applied to determine low DOC concentrations (<2 mgC/L) and DOC from diverse terrestrial, freshwater and marine environments (SD ≤ 0.23 ‰).

CONCLUSIONS

TOC/IRMS enables fast and reliable measurement of DOC concentrations and δ(13)C values in aqueous samples, without pre-concentration and freeze-drying. Further investigations should focus on complex, saline matrices and very low DOC concentrations, to achieve a potential lower limit of 0.2 mgC/L. Thus, TOC/IRMS will give DOC research in terrestrial and aquatic environments a huge impulse with high-resolution, routine δ(13)C analysis.

Gas chromatography/isotope ratio mass spectrometry: analysis of methanol, ethanol and acetic acid by direct injection of aqueous alcoholic and acetic acid samples

RATIONALE

Methanol, ethanol, and acetic acid are not easily extracted from aqueous samples and are susceptible to isotope fractionation in gas chromatography/isotope ratio mass spectrometry (GC/IRMS) analysis. Developing a direct dilution GC/IRMS method for aqueous samples, by adjusting the sample concentrations in common solvents to be similar to each other and using a fixed GC split ratio, is very convenient and important because any linearity effects caused by amount-dependent isotope fractionation can be avoided.

METHODS

The suitability of acetonitrile and acetone solvents for the GC/IRMS analysis of pure methanol, ethanol and acetic acid, and commercial liquor and vinegar samples was evaluated using n-hexane and water as control solvents. All the solvents including water were separated from the analyte on a HP-INNOWAX column and were diverted away from the combustion interface. The influence of liquor matrix on the ethanol GC/IRMS analyses was evaluated by adding pure ethanol to liquor samples.

RESULTS

Acetonitrile and acetone gave similar δ(13) C values for pure ethanol and pure acetic acid to those obtained in water and n-hexane, and also gave similar δ(13) C values of ethanol in liquor and acetic acid in white vinegar to that obtained in water. For methanol analysis, acetonitrile and refined acetone gave similar δ(13) C values to that obtained in water, but n-hexane was not a suitable solvent. In addition, isotopic fractionation caused by solvent and solute interactions was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

We recommend using acetonitrile for the GC/IRMS analysis of aqueous alcoholic samples, and acetone for the analysis of aqueous acetic acid samples. This direct dilution method can provide high accurate and precise GC/IRMS analysis of the relative changes in δ(13) C values of methanol, ethanol, and acetic acid.

Performance of the wet oxidation unit of the HPLC isotope ratio mass spectrometry system for halogenated compounds

The performance of liquid chromatography-isotope ratio mass spectrometry (LC-IRMS) for polar halogenated compounds was evaluated. Oxidation capacity of the system was tested with halogenated acetic acids and halogenated aromatic compounds. Acetic acid (AA) was selected as a reference compound for complete oxidation and compared on the molar basis to the oxidation of other analytes. The isotope values were proofed with calibrated δ(13)C values obtained with an elemental analyzer (EA). Correct isotope values were obtained for mono- and dichlorinated, fluorinated, and tribrominated acetic acids and also for aniline, phenol, benzene, bromobenzene, chlorobenzene, 1,2-dichlorobenzene, 2,4,6-trichlorophenol, pentafluorophenol, and nitrobenzene. Incomplete oxidation of trichloroacetic acid (TCA) and trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) resulted in lower recovery compared to AA (37% and 24%, respectively) and in isotopic shift compared to values obtained with EA (TCA Δδ(13)C(EA/LC-IRMS) = 8.8‰, TFA Δδ(13)C(EA/LC-IRMS) = 6.0‰). Improvement of oxidation by longer reaction time in the reactor and increase in the concentration of sulfate radicals did not lead to complete combustion of TCA and TFA needed for δ(13)C analysis. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time such highly chlorinated compounds were studied with the LC-IRMS system. This work provides information for method development of LC-IRMS methods for halogenated contaminants that are known as potential threats to public health and the environment.

Review: Current applications and challenges for liquid chromatography coupled to isotope ratio mass spectrometry (LC/IRMS)

High-precision isotope analysis is recognized as an essential research tool in many fields of study. Until recently, continuous flow isotope ratio mass spectrometry (CF-IRMS) was available via an elemental analyzer or a gas chromatography inlet system for compound-specific analysis of light stable isotopes. In 2004, however, an interface that coupled liquid chromatography with IRMS (LC/IRMS) became commercially available for the first time. This brought the capability for new areas of application, in particular enabling compound-specific δ(13)C analysis of non-volatile, aqueous soluble, compounds from complex mixtures. The interface design brought with it several analytical constraints, however, in particular a lack of compatibility with certain types of chromatography as well as limited flow rates and mobile phase compositions. Routine LC/IRMS methods have, however, been established for measuring the δ(13)C isotopic ratios of underivatized individual compounds for application in archeology, nutrition and physiology, geochemistry, hydrology, soil science and food authenticity. Seven years after its introduction, we review the technical advances and constraints, methodological developments and new applications of liquid chromatography coupled to isotope ratio mass spectrometry.

High-temperature reversed-phase liquid chromatography coupled to isotope ratio mass spectrometry

Compound-specific isotope analysis (CSIA) by liquid chromatography coupled to isotope ratio mass spectrometry (LC/IRMS) has until now been based on ion-exchange separation. In this work, high-temperature reversed-phase liquid chromatography was coupled to, and for the first time carefully evaluated for, isotope ratio mass spectrometry (HT-LC/IRMS) with four different stationary phases. Under isothermal and temperature gradient conditions, the column bleed of XBridge C(18) (up to 180 °C), Acquity C(18) (up to 200 °C), Triart C(18) (up to 150 °C), and Zirchrom PBD (up to 150 °C) had no influence on the precision and accuracy of δ(13) C measurements, demonstrating the suitability of these columns for HT-LC/IRMS analysis. Increasing the temperature during the LC/IRMS analysis of caffeine on two C(18) columns was observed to result in shortened analysis time. The detection limit of HT-RPLC/IRMS obtained for caffeine was 30 mg L(-1) (corresponding to 12.4 nmol carbon on-column). Temperature-programmed LC/IRMS (i) accomplished complete separation of a mixture of caffeine derivatives and a mixture of phenols and (ii) did not affect the precision and accuracy of δ(13)C measurements compared with flow injection analysis without a column. With temperature-programmed LC/IRMS, some compounds that coelute at room temperature could be baseline resolved and analyzed for their individual δ(13)C values, leading to an important extension of the application range of CSIA.

Strong anion-exchange liquid chromatography coupled with isotope ratio mass spectrometry using a Liquiface interface

The introduction of liquid chromatography coupled with isotope ratio mass spectrometry (LC/IRMS) as an analytical tool for the measurement of isotope ratios in non-volatile analytes has somewhat simplified the analytical cycle from sample collection to analysis mainly due to the avoidance of the extensive sample processing and derivatisation that were necessary for gas chromatography/combustion/isotope ratio mass spectrometry (GC/C/IRMS). Here we test the performance of coupling strong anion exchange to IRMS using only the second commercially available interface; the Liquiface. The system was modified from installation specification to improve peak resolution in the interface and maintain peak separation from the column to the mass spectrometer. The system performance was assessed by the determination of sensitivity, accuracy and precision attained from carbohydrate separations. The system performed satisfactorily after modifications, resulting in maintenance of peak resolution from column to mass spectrometer. The sensitivity achieved suggested that approximately 150 ng carbon could be analysed with acceptable precision (<0.3 per thousand). Accuracy was maintained in the interface as determined by correlation with offline techniques, resulting in regression coefficient of r(2) = 0.98 and a slope of 0.99. The average precision achieved for the separation of seven monosaccharides was 0.36 per thousand. The integration of a carbonate removal device limited the effect of background carbon perturbations in the mass spectrometer associated with eluent gradients, and the coupling of strong anion-exchange chromatography with IRMS was successfully achieved using the Liquiface.

Flow injection analysis-isotope ratio mass spectrometry for bulk carbon stable isotope analysis of alcoholic beverages

A new method for bulk carbon isotope ratio determination of water-soluble samples is presented that is based on flow injection analysis-isotope ratio mass spectrometry (FIA-IRMS) using an LC IsoLink interface. Advantages of the method are that (i) only very small amounts of sample are required (2-5 microL of the sample for up to 200 possible injections), (ii) it avoids complex sample preparation procedures such as needed for EA-IRMS analysis (only sample dilution and injection,) and (iii) high throughput due to short analysis times is possible (approximately 15 min for five replicates). The method was first tested and evaluated as a fast screening method with industrially produced ethanol samples, and additionally the applicability was tested by the measurement of 81 alcoholic beverages, for example, whiskey, brandy, vodka, tequila, and others. The minimal sample concentration required for precise and reproducible measurements was around 50 microL L(-1) ethanol/water (1.71 mM carbon). The limit of repeatability was determined to be r=0.49%. FIA-IRMS represents a fast screening method for beverage authenticity control. Due to this, samples can be prescreened as a decisive criterion for more detailed investigations by HPLC-IRMS or multielement GC-IRMS measurements for a verification of adulteration.