Benchmarker: An Unbiased, Association-Data-Driven Strategy to Evaluate Gene Prioritization Algorithms

TWAS-GKF: a novel method for causal gene identification in transcriptome-wide association studies with knockoff inference

MOTIVATION

Transcriptome-wide association study (TWAS) aims to identify trait-associated genes regulated by significant variants to explore the underlying biological mechanisms at a tissue-specific level. Despite the advancement of current TWAS methods to cover diverse traits, traditional approaches still face two main challenges: (i) the lack of methods that can guarantee finite-sample false discovery rate (FDR) control in identifying trait-associated genes; and (ii) the requirement for individual-level data, which is often inaccessible.

RESULTS

To address this challenge, we propose a powerful knockoff inference method termed TWAS-GKF to identify candidate trait-associated genes with a guaranteed finite-sample FDR control. TWAS-GKF introduces the main idea of Ghostknockoff inference to generate knockoff variables using only summary statistics instead of individual-level data. In extensive studies, we demonstrate that TWAS-GKF successfully controls the finite-sample FDR under a pre-specified FDR level across all settings. We further apply TWAS-GKF to identify genes in brain cerebellum tissue from the Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) v8 project associated with schizophrenia (SCZ) from the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium (PGC), and genes in liver tissue related to low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) from the UK Biobank, respectively. The results reveal that the majority of the identified genes are validated by Open Targets Validation Platform.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

The R package TWAS.GKF is publicly available at https://github.com/AnqiWang2021/TWAS.GKF.

A novel method for multiple phenotype association studies based on genotype and phenotype network

Joint analysis of multiple correlated phenotypes for genome-wide association studies (GWAS) can identify and interpret pleiotropic loci which are essential to understand pleiotropy in diseases and complex traits. Meanwhile, constructing a network based on associations between phenotypes and genotypes provides a new insight to analyze multiple phenotypes, which can explore whether phenotypes and genotypes might be related to each other at a higher level of cellular and organismal organization. In this paper, we first develop a bipartite signed network by linking phenotypes and genotypes into a Genotype and Phenotype Network (GPN). The GPN can be constructed by a mixture of quantitative and qualitative phenotypes and is applicable to binary phenotypes with extremely unbalanced case-control ratios in large-scale biobank datasets. We then apply a powerful community detection method to partition phenotypes into disjoint network modules based on GPN. Finally, we jointly test the association between multiple phenotypes in a network module and a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP). Simulations and analyses of 72 complex traits in the UK Biobank show that multiple phenotype association tests based on network modules detected by GPN are much more powerful than those without considering network modules. The newly proposed GPN provides a new insight to investigate the genetic architecture among different types of phenotypes. Multiple phenotypes association studies based on GPN are improved by incorporating the genetic information into the phenotype clustering. Notably, it might broaden the understanding of genetic architecture that exists between diagnoses, genes, and pleiotropy.

PheSeq, a Bayesian deep learning model to enhance and interpret the gene-disease association studies

Despite the abundance of genotype-phenotype association studies, the resulting association outcomes often lack robustness and interpretations. To address these challenges, we introduce PheSeq, a Bayesian deep learning model that enhances and interprets association studies through the integration and perception of phenotype descriptions. By implementing the PheSeq model in three case studies on Alzheimer's disease, breast cancer, and lung cancer, we identify 1024 priority genes for Alzheimer's disease and 818 and 566 genes for breast cancer and lung cancer, respectively. Benefiting from data fusion, these findings represent moderate positive rates, high recall rates, and interpretation in gene-disease association studies.

Leveraging polygenic enrichments of gene features to predict genes underlying complex traits and diseases

Genome-wide association studies (GWASs) are a valuable tool for understanding the biology of complex human traits and diseases, but associated variants rarely point directly to causal genes. In the present study, we introduce a new method, polygenic priority score (PoPS), that learns trait-relevant gene features, such as cell-type-specific expression, to prioritize genes at GWAS loci. Using a large evaluation set of genes with fine-mapped coding variants, we show that PoPS and the closest gene individually outperform other gene prioritization methods, but observe the best overall performance by combining PoPS with orthogonal methods. Using this combined approach, we prioritize 10,642 unique gene-trait pairs across 113 complex traits and diseases with high precision, finding not only well-established gene-trait relationships but nominating new genes at unresolved loci, such as LGR4 for estimated glomerular filtration rate and CCR7 for deep vein thrombosis. Overall, we demonstrate that PoPS provides a powerful addition to the gene prioritization toolbox.

Genome-wide CRISPR screening of chondrocyte maturation newly implicates genes in skeletal growth and height-associated GWAS loci

Alterations in the growth and maturation of chondrocytes can lead to variation in human height, including monogenic disorders of skeletal growth. We aimed to identify genes and pathways relevant to human growth by pairing human height genome-wide association studies (GWASs) with genome-wide knockout (KO) screens of growth-plate chondrocyte proliferation and maturation in vitro. We identified 145 genes that alter chondrocyte proliferation and maturation at early and/or late time points in culture, with 90% of genes validating in secondary screening. These genes are enriched in monogenic growth disorder genes and in KEGG pathways critical for skeletal growth and endochondral ossification. Further, common variants near these genes capture height heritability independent of genes computationally prioritized from GWASs. Our study emphasizes the value of functional studies in biologically relevant tissues as orthogonal datasets to refine likely causal genes from GWASs and implicates new genetic regulators of chondrocyte proliferation and maturation.

Identifying genes targeted by disease-associated non-coding SNPs with a protein knowledge graph

Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have identified many single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) that play important roles in the genetic heritability of traits and diseases. With most of these SNPs located on the non-coding part of the genome, it is currently assumed that these SNPs influence the expression of nearby genes on the genome. However, identifying which genes are targeted by these disease-associated SNPs remains challenging. In the past, protein knowledge graphs have often been used to identify genes that are associated with disease, also referred to as “disease genes”. Here, we explore whether protein knowledge graphs can be used to identify genes that are targeted by disease-associated non-coding SNPs by testing and comparing the performance of six existing methods for a protein knowledge graph, four of which were developed for disease gene identification. We compare our performance against two baselines: (1) an existing state-of-the-art method that is based on guilt-by-association, and (2) the leading assumption that SNPs target the nearest gene on the genome. We test these methods with four reference sets, three of which were obtained by different means. Furthermore, we combine methods to investigate whether their combination improves performance. We find that protein knowledge graphs that include predicate information perform comparable to the current state of the art, achieving an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) of 79.6% on average across all four reference sets. Protein knowledge graphs that lack predicate information perform comparable to our other baseline (genetic distance) which achieved an AUC of 75.7% across all four reference sets. Combining multiple methods improved performance to 84.9% AUC. We conclude that methods for a protein knowledge graph can be used to identify which genes are targeted by disease-associated non-coding SNPs.

Predicting causal genes from psychiatric genome-wide association studies using high-level etiological knowledge

Genome-wide association studies have discovered hundreds of genomic loci associated with psychiatric traits, but the causal genes underlying these associations are often unclear, a research gap that has hindered clinical translation. Here, we present a Psychiatric Omnilocus Prioritization Score (PsyOPS) derived from just three binary features encapsulating high-level assumptions about psychiatric disease etiology - namely, that causal psychiatric disease genes are likely to be mutationally constrained, be specifically expressed in the brain, and overlap with known neurodevelopmental disease genes. To our knowledge, PsyOPS is the first method specifically tailored to prioritizing causal genes at psychiatric GWAS loci. We show that, despite its extreme simplicity, PsyOPS achieves state-of-the-art performance at this task, comparable to a prior domain-agnostic approach relying on tens of thousands of features. Genes prioritized by PsyOPS are substantially more likely than other genes at the same loci to have convergent evidence of direct regulation by the GWAS variant according to both DNA looping assays and expression or splicing quantitative trait locus (QTL) maps. We provide examples of genes hundreds of kilobases away from the lead variant, like GABBR1 for schizophrenia, that are prioritized by all three of PsyOPS, DNA looping and QTLs. Our results underscore the power of incorporating high-level knowledge of trait etiology into causal gene prediction at GWAS loci, and comprise a resource for researchers interested in experimentally characterizing psychiatric gene candidates.

Genes and Diseases: Insights from Transcriptomics Studies

Results of expression studies can be useful to clarify the genotype-phenotype relationship. However, according to data from recent literature, there is a large group of genes that are revealed as differentially expressed (DE) in many studies, regardless of the biological context. Additional analyses could shed more light on the relationships between genes, their differential expression, and diseases. We generated a set of 9972 disease genes from five gene-phenotype databases (OMIM, ORPHANET, DDG2P, DisGeNet and MalaCards) and a report of the International Union of Immunological Societies. To study transcriptomics of disease and non-disease genes in healthy tissues, we obtained data from the Human Protein Atlas (HPA) website. We analyzed the dependency between expression in healthy tissues and gene occurrence in Gene Expression Omnibus series using tools within the Enrichr libraries. The results of expression studies were annotated with Gene Ontology (GO) and Human Phenotype Ontology (HPO) terms. Using transcriptomics analysis of healthy tissues, we validated the previous findings of higher expression levels of disease genes in pathologically linked tissues compared to other tissues. Preferentially DE genes were generally highly expressed in one or multiple tissues and were enriched for disease genes. According to the results of GO enrichment analyses, both down- and up-regulated DE genes most often took part in immune response, translation and tissue-specific processes. A connection between DE-related pathology and the diversity of HPO terms was found. Investigating a link between expression and phenotype contributes to understanding the mode of development and progression of human diseases.

Gene-based association tests using GWAS summary statistics and incorporating eQTL

Although genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have been successfully applied to a variety of complex diseases and identified many genetic variants underlying complex diseases via single marker tests, there is still a considerable heritability of complex diseases that could not be explained by GWAS. One alternative approach to overcome the missing heritability caused by genetic heterogeneity is gene-based analysis, which considers the aggregate effects of multiple genetic variants in a single test. Another alternative approach is transcriptome-wide association study (TWAS). TWAS aggregates genomic information into functionally relevant units that map to genes and their expression. TWAS is not only powerful, but can also increase the interpretability in biological mechanisms of identified trait associated genes. In this study, we propose a powerful and computationally efficient gene-based association test, called Overall. Using extended Simes procedure, Overall aggregates information from three types of traditional gene-based association tests and also incorporates expression quantitative trait locus (eQTL) information into a gene-based association test using GWAS summary statistics. We show that after a small number of replications to estimate the correlation among the integrated gene-based tests, the p values of Overall can be calculated analytically. Simulation studies show that Overall can control type I error rates very well and has higher power than the tests that we compared with. We also apply Overall to two schizophrenia GWAS summary datasets and two lipids GWAS summary datasets. The results show that this newly developed method can identify more significant genes than other methods we compared with.

Partitioning gene-mediated disease heritability without eQTLs

Unknown SNP-to-gene regulatory architecture complicates efforts to link noncoding GWAS associations with genes implicated by sequencing or functional studies. eQTLs are often used to link SNPs to genes, but expression in bulk tissue explains a small fraction of disease heritability. A simple but successful approach has been to link SNPs with nearby genes via base pair windows, but genes may often be regulated by SNPs outside their window. We propose the abstract mediation model (AMM) to estimate (1) the fraction of heritability mediated by the closest or kth-closest gene to each SNP and (2) the mediated heritability enrichment of a gene set (e.g., genes with rare-variant associations). AMM jointly estimates these quantities by matching the decay in SNP enrichment with distance from genes in the gene set. Across 47 complex traits and diseases, we estimate that the closest gene to each SNP mediates 27% (SE: 6%) of heritability and that a substantial fraction is mediated by genes outside the ten closest. Mendelian disease genes are strongly enriched for common-variant heritability; for example, just 21 dyslipidemia genes mediate 25% of LDL heritability (211× enrichment, p = 0.01). Among brain-related traits, genes involved in neurodevelopmental disorders are only about 4× enriched, but gene expression patterns are highly informative, as they have detectable differences in per-gene heritability even among weakly brain-expressed genes.

Construction and contextualization approaches for protein-protein interaction networks

Protein-protein interaction network (PPIN) analysis is a widely used method to study the contextual role of proteins of interest, to predict novel disease genes, disease or functional modules, and to identify novel drug targets. PPIN-based analysis uses both generic and context-specific networks. Multiple contextualization methodologies have been described, such as shortest-path algorithms, neighborhood-based methods, and diffusion/propagation algorithms. This review discusses these methods, provides intuitive representations of PPIN contextualization, and also examines how the quality of such context-specific networks could be improved by considering additional sources of evidence. As a heuristic, we observe that tasks such as identifying disease genes, drug targets, and protein complexes should consider local neighborhoods, while uncovering disease mechanisms and discovering disease-pathways would gain from diffusion-based construction.

Prioritization of disease genes from GWAS using ensemble-based positive-unlabeled learning

A primary challenge in understanding disease biology from genome-wide association studies (GWAS) arises from the inability to directly implicate causal genes from association data. Integration of multiple-omics data sources potentially provides important functional links between associated variants and candidate genes. Machine-learning is well-positioned to take advantage of a variety of such data and provide a solution for the prioritization of disease genes. Yet, classical positive-negative classifiers impose strong limitations on the gene prioritization procedure, such as a lack of reliable non-causal genes for training. Here, we developed a novel gene prioritization tool-Gene Prioritizer (GPrior). It is an ensemble of five positive-unlabeled bagging classifiers (Logistic Regression, Support Vector Machine, Random Forest, Decision Tree, Adaptive Boosting), that treats all genes of unknown relevance as an unlabeled set. GPrior selects an optimal composition of algorithms to tune the model for each specific phenotype. Altogether, GPrior fills an important niche of methods for GWAS data post-processing, significantly improving the ability to pinpoint disease genes compared to existing solutions.

Next-generation drug repurposing using human genetics and network biology

Drug repurposing has attracted increased attention, especially in the context of drug discovery rates that remain too low despite a recent wave of approvals for biological therapeutics (e.g. gene therapy). These new biological entities-based treatments have high costs that are difficult to justify for small markets that include rare diseases. Drug repurposing, involving the identification of single or combinations of existing drugs based on human genetics data and network biology approaches represents a next-generation approach that has the potential to increase the speed of drug discovery at a lower cost. This Pharmacological Perspective reviews progress and perspectives in combining human genetics, especially genome-wide association studies, with network biology to drive drug repurposing for rare and common diseases with monogenic or polygenic etiologies. Also, highlighted here are important features of this next generation approach to drug repurposing, which can be combined with machine learning methods to meet the challenges of personalized medicine.