The landscape of autosomal-recessive pathogenic variants in European populations reveals phenotype-specific effects

Saturation mutagenesis-reinforced functional assays for disease-related genes

Interpretation of disease-causing genetic variants remains a challenge in human genetics. Current costs and complexity of deep mutational scanning methods are obstacles for achieving genome-wide resolution of variants in disease-related genes. Our framework, saturation mutagenesis-reinforced functional assays (SMuRF), offers simple and cost-effective saturation mutagenesis paired with streamlined functional assays to enhance the interpretation of unresolved variants. Applying SMuRF to neuromuscular disease genes FKRP and LARGE1, we generated functional scores for all possible coding single-nucleotide variants, which aid in resolving clinically reported variants of uncertain significance. SMuRF also demonstrates utility in predicting disease severity, resolving critical structural regions, and providing training datasets for the development of computational predictors. Overall, our approach enables variant-to-function insights for disease genes in a cost-effective manner that can be broadly implemented by standard research laboratories.

Constraining models of dominance for nonsynonymous mutations in the human genome

Dominance is a fundamental parameter in genetics, determining the dynamics of natural selection on deleterious and beneficial mutations, the patterns of genetic variation in natural populations, and the severity of inbreeding depression in a population. Despite this importance, dominance parameters remain poorly known, particularly in humans or other non-model organisms. A key reason for this lack of information about dominance is that it is extremely challenging to disentangle the selection coefficient (s) of a mutation from its dominance coefficient (h). Here, we explore dominance and selection parameters in humans by fitting models to the site frequency spectrum (SFS) for nonsynonymous mutations. When assuming a single dominance coefficient for all nonsynonymous mutations, we find that numerous h values can fit the data, so long as h is greater than ~0.15. Moreover, we also observe that theoretically-predicted models with a negative relationship between h and s can also fit the data well, including models with h = 0.05 for strongly deleterious mutations. Finally, we use our estimated dominance and selection parameters to inform simulations revisiting the question of whether the out-of-Africa bottleneck has led to differences in genetic load between African and non-African human populations. These simulations suggest that the relative burden of genetic load in non-African populations depends on the dominance model assumed, with slight increases for more weakly recessive models and slight decreases shown for more strongly recessive models. Moreover, these results also demonstrate that models of partially recessive nonsynonymous mutations can explain the observed severity of inbreeding depression in humans, bridging the gap between molecular population genetics and direct measures of fitness in humans. Our work represents a comprehensive assessment of dominance and deleterious variation in humans, with implications for parameterizing models of deleterious variation in humans and other mammalian species.

The Spectrum of Disease-Associated Alleles in Countries with a Predominantly Slavic Population

There are more than 260 million people of Slavic descent worldwide, who reside mainly in Eastern Europe but also represent a noticeable share of the population in the USA and Canada. Slavic populations, particularly Eastern Slavs and some Western Slavs, demonstrate a surprisingly high degree of genetic homogeneity, and, consequently, remarkable contribution of recurrent alleles associated with hereditary diseases. Along with pan-European pathogenic variants with clearly elevated occurrence in Slavic people (e.g., ATP7B c.3207C>A and PAH c.1222C>T), there are at least 52 pan-Slavic germ-line mutations (e.g., NBN c.657_661del and BRCA1 c.5266dupC) as well as several disease-predisposing alleles characteristic of the particular Slavic communities (e.g., Polish SDHD c.33C>A and Russian ARSB c.1562G>A variants). From a clinical standpoint, Slavs have some features of a huge founder population, thus providing a unique opportunity for efficient genetic studies.

Primary care professionals' views on population-based expanded carrier screening: an online focus group study

BACKGROUND

Population-based expanded carrier screening (ECS) involves screening for multiple recessive diseases offered to all couples considering a pregnancy or during pregnancy. Previous research indicates that in some countries primary care professionals are perceived as suitable providers for ECS. However, little is known about their perspectives. We therefore aimed to explore primary care professionals' views on population-based ECS.

METHODS

Four online focus groups with 14 general practitioners (GPs) and 16 community midwives were conducted in the Netherlands.

RESULTS

Our findings highlight various perspectives on the desirability of population-based ECS. Participants agreed that ECS could enhance reproductive autonomy and thereby prevent suffering of the child and/or parents. However, they also raised several ethical, societal, and psychological concerns, including a tendency towards a perfect society, stigmatization, unequal access to screening and negative psychosocial consequences. Participants believed that provision of population-based ECS would be feasible if prerequisites regarding training and reimbursement for providers would be fulfilled. most GPs considered themselves less suitable or capable of providing ECS, in contrast to midwives who did consider themselves suitable. Nevertheless, participants believed that, if implemented, ECS should be offered in primary care or by public health services rather than as hospital-based specialized care, because they believed a primary care ECS offer increases access in terms of time and location.

CONCLUSIONS

While participants believed that an ECS offer would be feasible, they questioned its desirability and priority. Studies on the desirability and feasibility of population-based ECS offered in primary care or public health settings are needed.

Discovery of a Novel Shared Variant Among RTEL1 Gene and RTEL1-TNFRSF6B lncRNA at Chromosome 20q13.33 in Familial Progressive Myoclonus Epilepsy

Background: Progressive myoclonus epilepsy (PME) is a neurodegenerative disorder marked by recurrent seizures and progressive myoclonus. To date, based on the phenotypes and causal genes, more than 40 subtypes of PMEs have been identified, and more remain to be characterized. Our study is aimed at identifying the aberrant gene(s) possibly associated with PMEs in two siblings born to asymptomatic parents, in the absence of known genetic mutations. Methods: Clinical assessments and molecular analyses, such as the repeat expansion test for CSTB; SCA1, 2, 3, 6, and 7; whole exome sequencing (WES); and mitochondrial genome sequencing coupled with computational analysis, were performed. Results: A family-based segregation analysis of WES data was performed to identify novel genes associated with PMEs. The potassium channel, KCNH8 [c.298T>C; (p.Tyr100His)], a DNA repair gene, regulator of telomere elongation helicase 1 (RTEL1) [c.691G>T; (p.Asp231Tyr)] and long noncoding RNA, RTEL1-TNFRSF6B [chr20:62298898_G>T; NR_037882.1, hg19] were among the candidate genes that were found to be associated with PMEs. These homozygous variations in siblings belong to genes with a loss-of-function intolerant (pLI) score of ≤ 0.86, expected to be detrimental by multiple computational analyses, and were heterozygous in parents. Additionally, computational analysis and the expression of RTEL1 and RTEL1-TNFRSF6B revealed that RTEL1-TNFRSF6B may modulate RTEL1 via hsa-miR-3529-3p. In the patient with the severe phenotype, a further deleterious mutation in SLC22A17 was identified. No de novo variants specific to these probands were identified in the mitochondrial genome. Conclusions: Our study is the first to report variants in KCNH8, RTEL1, and RTEL1-TNFRSF6B among PME cases. These genes when characterized fully may shed light on pathogenicity and have the potential to be used in the diagnosis of PME.

Rare heterozygous variants in paediatric steroid resistant nephrotic syndrome - a population-based analysis of their significance

Genetic testing in nephrotic syndrome may identify heterozygous predicted-pathogenic variants (HPPVs) in autosomal recessive (AR) genes that are known to cause disease in the homozygous or compound heterozygous state. In such cases, it can be difficult to define the variant's true significance and questions remain about whether a second pathogenic variant has been missed during analysis or whether the variant is an incidental finding. There are now known to be over 70 genes associated with nephrotic syndrome, the majority inherited as an AR trait. Knowledge of whether such HPPVs occur with equal frequency in patients compared to the general population would assist interpretation of their significance. Exome sequencing was performed on 187 Steroid-Resistant Nephrotic Syndrome (SRNS) paediatric patients recruited to a UK rare disease registry plus originating from clinics at Evelina, London. 59 AR podocytopathy linked genes were analysed in each patient and a list of HPPVs created. We compared the frequency of detected HPPVs with a 'control' population from the gnomAD database containing exome data from approximately 50,000 individuals. A bespoke filtering process was used for both patients and controls to predict 'likely pathogenicity' of variants. In total 130 Caucasian SRNS patients were screened across 59 AR genes and 201 rare heterozygous variants were identified. 17/201 (8.5%) were assigned as 'likely pathogenic' (HPPV) using our bespoke filtering method. Comparing each gene in turn, for SRNS patients with a confirmed genetic diagnosis, in 57 of the 59 genes we found no statistically significant difference in the frequency of these HPPVs between patients and controls (In genes ARHGDIA and TP53RK, we identified a significantly higher number of HPPVs in the control population compared with the patients when filtering was performed with 'high stringency' settings only). In the SRNS patients without a genetics diagnosis confirmed, there was no statistically significant difference identified in any gene between patient and control. In children with SRNS, we propose that identification of HPPV in AR podocytopathy linked genes is not necessarily representative of pathogenicity, given that the frequency is similar to that seen in controls for the majority. Whilst this may not exclude the presence of genetic kidney disease, this type of heterozygous variant is unlikely to be causal and each result must be interpreted in its clinical context.

Next-generation phenotyping integrated in a national framework for patients with ultrarare disorders improves genetic diagnostics and yields new molecular findings

Individuals with ultrarare disorders pose a structural challenge for healthcare systems since expert clinical knowledge is required to establish diagnoses. In TRANSLATE NAMSE, a 3-year prospective study, we evaluated a novel diagnostic concept based on multidisciplinary expertise in Germany. Here we present the systematic investigation of the phenotypic and molecular genetic data of 1,577 patients who had undergone exome sequencing and were partially analyzed with next-generation phenotyping approaches. Molecular genetic diagnoses were established in 32% of the patients totaling 370 distinct molecular genetic causes, most with prevalence below 1:50,000. During the diagnostic process, 34 novel and 23 candidate genotype-phenotype associations were identified, mainly in individuals with neurodevelopmental disorders. Sequencing data of the subcohort that consented to computer-assisted analysis of their facial images with GestaltMatcher could be prioritized more efficiently compared with approaches based solely on clinical features and molecular scores. Our study demonstrates the synergy of using next-generation sequencing and phenotyping for diagnosing ultrarare diseases in routine healthcare and discovering novel etiologies by multidisciplinary teams.

Variant analysis and PGT-M of OTC gene in a Chinese family with ornithine carbamoyltransferase deficiency

BACKGROUND

Ornithine carbamoyltransferase deficiency (OTCD) is a kind of X-linked metabolic disease caused by a deficiency in ornithine transcarbamylase leading to urea cycle disorders. The main reason is that the OTC gene variants lead to the loss or decrease of OTC enzyme function, which hinders the ammonia conversion to urea, resulting in hyperammonemia and severe neurological dysfunction. Here, we studied one Chinese family of three generations who consecutively gave birth to two babies with OTCD. This study aims to explore the pathogenicity of two missense variants in the OTC gene and investigate the application of preimplantation genetic testing for monogenic (PGT-M) for a family troubled by Ornithine carbamoyltransferase deficiency (OTCD).

METHODS

The retrospective method was used to classify the pathogenicity of two missense variants in the OTC gene in a family tortured by OTCD. Sanger sequencing was used to validate the variants in the OTC gene, and then the pathogenicity of variants was confirmed through family analysis and bioinformatics software. We used PGT-M to target the OTC gene and select a suitable embryo for transplantation. Prenatal diagnosis was recommended to confirm previous results using Sanger sequencing and karyotyping at an appropriate gestational stage. Tandem mass spectrometry (MS-MS) and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) were used to detect fetal metabolism after birth. The number of the study cohort is ChiCTR2100053616.

RESULTS

Two missense variants, c.959G > C (p.Arg320Pro) and c.634G > A (p.Gly212Arg), were validated in the OTC gene in this family. According to the ACMG genetic variation classification criteria, the missense variant c.959G > C can be considered as "pathogenic", and the missense variant c.634G > A can be regarded as "likely benign." PGT-M identified a female embryo carrying the heterozygous variant c.959G > C (p.Arg320Pro), which was selected for transplantation. Prenatal diagnosis revealed the same variant in the fetus, and continued pregnancy was recommended. A female baby was born, and her blood amino acid testing and urine organic acid testing were regular. Follow-up was conducted after six months and indicated the girl was healthy.

CONCLUSION

Our research first validated the segregation of both c.959G > C and c.634G > A variants in the OTC gene in a Chinese OTCD family. Then, we classified variant c.959G > C as "pathogenic" and variant c.634G > A as "likely benign", providing corresponding theoretical support for genetic counseling and fertility guidance in this family. PGT-M and prenatal diagnosis were recommended to help the couple receive a female baby successfully with a six-month follow-up.

Perceptions of reproductive healthcare providers regarding their involvement in offering expanded carrier screening in fertility clinics: a qualitative study

RESEARCH QUESTION

What are the main arguments of reproductive healthcare providers in favour or against their involvement in offering expanded carrier screening (ECS) for recessive disorders at fertility clinics in the Netherlands?

DESIGN

Semi-structured interview study with 20 reproductive healthcare providers between May 2020 and January 2021. Participants included 11 gynaecologists, seven fertility doctors, one nurse practitioner and one clinical embryologist, recruited from academic medical centres (n = 13), peripheral facilities associated with academic centres (n = 4), and independent fertility treatment centres (n = 3) in the Netherlands. An interview guide was developed, and thematic content analysis was performed using ATLAS.ti software.

RESULTS

Arguments of reproductive healthcare providers in favour of their potential involvement in offering ECS included: (i) opportunities offered by the setting; (ii) motivation to assist in reproduction and prevent suffering; and (iii) to counter unwanted commercialization offers. Arguments against involvement included: (i) lack of knowledge and familiarity with offering ECS; (ii) insufficient staff and resources, and potential high costs for clinics and/or couples; (iii) the emotional impact it may have on couples; (iv) perceived complexity of counselling and expected elongation of waiting lists; and (v) expected low impact on reducing the burden of diseases. Participants felt that more evidence and research on the costs-benefits, implications and demand are needed prior to their involvement.

CONCLUSION

While agreeing that the field of medically assisted reproduction provides a unique opportunity to offer ECS, reproductive healthcare workers feel a lack of capability and limited motivation to offer ECS to all or a selection of couples at their fertility clinics.

Estimation of carrier frequencies utilizing the gnomAD database for ACMG recommended carrier screening and Finnish disease heritage conditions in non-Finnish European, Finnish, and Ashkenazi Jewish populations

American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) recommends offering Tier 3 carrier screening to pregnant patients and those planning a pregnancy for conditions with a carrier frequency of ≥1/200 (96 genes for autosomal recessive [AR] conditions). Certain AR conditions referred to as Finnish disease heritage (FINDIS) have a higher prevalence in Finland than elsewhere. Data from gnomAD v2.1 were extracted to assess carrier frequencies for ACMG-recommended AR and FINDIS AR and X-linked genes in Finnish, non-Finnish European, and Ashkenazi Jewish populations. Following variants were considered: ClinVar pathogenic or likely pathogenic, loss-of-function, and Finnish founder variants. Gene carrier (GCR), cumulative carrier (CCR), and at-risk couple rates (ACR) were estimated. In Finnish population, 47 genes had a GCR of ≥0.5%. CCRs were 52.7% (Finnish), 48.9% (non-Finnish European), and 58.3% (Ashkenazi Jewish), whereas ACRs were 1.4%, 0.93%, and 2.3% respectively. Approximately 141 affected children with analyzed AR conditions are estimated to be born in Finland annually. Eighteen genes causing FINDIS conditions had a GCR of ≥0.5% in the Finnish population but were absent in the ACMG Tier 3 gene list. Two genes (RECQL4 and RMRP) had GCR of ≥0.5% either in non-Finnish Europeans or Ashkenazi Jewish populations. Results highlight the need for careful curation of carrier screening panels.

Deep Mutational Scanning in Disease-related Genes with Saturation Mutagenesis-Reinforced Functional Assays (SMuRF)

Interpretation of disease-causing genetic variants remains a challenge in human genetics. Current costs and complexity of deep mutational scanning methods hamper crowd-sourcing approaches toward genome-wide resolution of variants in disease-related genes. Our framework, Saturation Mutagenesis-Reinforced Functional assays (SMuRF), addresses these issues by offering simple and cost-effective saturation mutagenesis, as well as streamlining functional assays to enhance the interpretation of unresolved variants. Applying SMuRF to neuromuscular disease genes FKRP and LARGE1, we generated functional scores for all possible coding single nucleotide variants, which aid in resolving clinically reported variants of uncertain significance. SMuRF also demonstrates utility in predicting disease severity, resolving critical structural regions, and providing training datasets for the development of computational predictors. Our approach opens new directions for enabling variant-to-function insights for disease genes in a manner that is broadly useful for crowd-sourcing implementation across standard research laboratories.

Two rare autosomal recessive neurological disorders identified by combined genetic approaches in a single consanguineous family with multiple offspring

INTRODUCTION

Neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs) refer to a broad range of diseases including developmental delay, intellectual disability, epilepsy, autism spectrum disorders, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder caused by dysfunctions in tightly controlled brain development. The genetic backgrounds of NDDs are quite heterogeneous; to date, recessive or dominant variations in numerous genes have been implicated. Herein, we present a large consanguineous family from Turkiye, who has been suffering from NDDs with two distinct clinical presentations.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Combined in-depth genetic approaches led us to identify a homozygous frameshift variant in NALCN related to NDD and expansion of dodecamer repeat in CSTB related to Unverricht-Lundborg disease (ULD). Additionally, we sought to functionally analyze the NALCN variant in terms of mRNA expression level and current alteration. We have both detected a decrease in the level of premature stop codon-bearing mRNA possibly through nonsense-mediated mRNA decay mechanism and also an increased current in patch-clamp recordings for the expressed truncated protein.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, increased consanguinity may lead to the revealing of distinct rare neurogenetic diseases in a single family. Exome sequencing is generally considered the first-tier diagnostic test in individuals with NDD. Yet we underline the fact that customized approaches other than exome sequencing may be used as in the case of ULD to aid diagnosis and better genetic counseling.

Search for chromosomal instability aiding variants reveal naturally occurring kinetochore gene variants that perturb chromosome segregation

Chromosomal instability (CIN) is a hallmark of cancers, and CIN-promoting mutations are not fully understood. Here, we report 141 chromosomal instability aiding variant (CIVa) candidates by assessing the prevalence of loss-of-function (LoF) variants in 135 chromosome segregation genes from over 150,000 humans. Unexpectedly, we observe both heterozygous and homozygous CIVa in Astrin and SKA3, two evolutionarily conserved kinetochore and microtubule-associated proteins essential for chromosome segregation. To stratify harmful versus harmless variants, we combine live-cell microscopy and controlled protein expression. We find the naturally occurring Astrin p.Q1012∗ variant is harmful as it fails to localize normally and induces chromosome misalignment and missegregation, in a dominant negative manner. In contrast, the Astrin p.L7Qfs∗21 variant generates a shorter isoform that localizes and functions normally, and the SKA3 p.Q70Kfs∗7 variant allows wild-type SKA complex localisation and function, revealing distinct resilience mechanisms that render these variants harmless. Thus, we present a scalable framework to predict and stratify naturally occurring CIVa, and provide insight into resilience mechanisms that compensate for naturally occurring CIVa.

Constraining models of dominance for nonsynonymous mutations in the human genome

Dominance is a fundamental parameter in genetics, determining the dynamics of natural selection on deleterious and beneficial mutations, the patterns of genetic variation in natural populations, and the severity of inbreeding depression in a population. Despite this importance, dominance parameters remain poorly known, particularly in humans or other non-model organisms. A key reason for this lack of information about dominance is that it is extremely challenging to disentangle the selection coefficient (s) of a mutation from its dominance coefficient (h). Here, we explore dominance and selection parameters in humans by fitting models to the site frequency spectrum (SFS) for nonsynonymous mutations. When assuming a single dominance coefficient for all nonsynonymous mutations, we find that numerous h values can fit the data, so long as h is greater than ~0.15. Moreover, we also observe that theoretically-predicted models with a negative relationship between h and s can also fit the data well, including models with h=0.05 for strongly deleterious mutations. Finally, we use our estimated dominance and selection parameters to inform simulations revisiting the question of whether the out-of-Africa bottleneck has led to differences in genetic load between African and non-African human populations. These simulations suggest that the relative burden of genetic load in non-African populations depends on the dominance model assumed, with slight increases for more weakly recessive models and slight decreases shown for more strongly recessive models. Moreover, these results also demonstrate that models of partially recessive nonsynonymous mutations can explain the observed severity of inbreeding depression in humans, bridging the gap between molecular population genetics and direct measures of fitness in humans. Our work represents a comprehensive assessment of dominance and deleterious variation in humans, with implications for parameterizing models of deleterious variation in humans and other mammalian species.

Consanguineous couples' experiences and views regarding expanded carrier screening: Barriers and facilitators in the decision-making process

Expanded carrier screening (ECS) entails a screening offer for multiple recessive disorders at the same time, and allows testing of individuals or couples regardless of ancestry or geographic origin. Children of consanguineous couples have a higher-than-average risk of manifesting autosomal recessive disorders. This study aims to contribute to the responsible implementation of ECS for consanguineous couples. Seven semi-structured interviews were conducted with consanguineous couples who had recently participated in Whole Exome Sequencing (WES)-based ECS at Maastricht University Medical Center (MUMC+), the Netherlands. The test offered at MUMC+ covers a large number of disease-related genes (~2000), including severe, relatively mild, early- and late-onset disorders. Respondents were interviewed about their views on, and experiences with participation in WES-based ECS. Overall, participation was experienced as worthwhile: it enabled respondents to make informed choices with regard to family planning as well as to take on the presumed parental responsibility to deliver their children as healthy as possible. Furthermore, our findings suggest that (1) true consent for having this test requires timely information about the possible implications of a positive test result for specific categories of findings, as well as about the success rates of the available reproductive options; (2) the clinical geneticist can play a pivotal part in informing participants as well as providing clear information about autosomal recessive inheritance; (3) more research is needed to explore what type of genetic risk information is considered 'meaningful' by participants and actually contributes to reproductive decision-making.

Increased homozygosity due to endogamy results in fitness consequences in a human population

Recessive alleles have been shown to directly affect both human Mendelian disease phenotypes and complex traits. Pedigree studies also suggest that consanguinity results in increased childhood mortality and adverse health phenotypes, presumably through penetrance of recessive mutations. Here, we test whether the accumulation of homozygous, recessive alleles decreases reproductive success in a human population. We address this question among the Namibian Himba, an endogamous agro-pastoralist population, who until very recently practiced natural fertility. Using a sample of 681 individuals, we show that Himba exhibit elevated levels of "inbreeding," calculated as the fraction of the genome in runs of homozygosity (FROH). Many individuals contain multiple long segments of ROH in their genomes, indicating that their parents had high kinship coefficients. However, we do not find evidence that this is explained by first-cousin consanguinity, despite a reported social preference for cross-cousin marriages. Rather, we show that elevated haplotype sharing in the Himba is due to a bottleneck, likely in the past 60 generations. We test whether increased recessive mutation load results in observed fitness consequences by assessing the effect of FROH on completed fertility in a cohort of postreproductive women (n = 69). We find that higher FROH is significantly associated with lower fertility. Our data suggest a multilocus genetic effect on fitness driven by the expression of deleterious recessive alleles, especially those in long ROH. However, these effects are not the result of consanguinity but rather elevated background identity by descent.

Attitudes of professional stakeholders towards implementation of reproductive genetic carrier screening: a systematic review

Reproductive genetic carrier screening (RGCS) for hundreds of different genetic conditions is technically available for prospective parents, but these tests have not been integrated in a public health policy except for specific sub-groups. We aimed to provide an overview of the perspectives of multiple professional stakeholder groups in order to enhance a responsible implementation of population-based reproductive genetic carrier screening. We conducted a systematic literature search using eight online databases focussing on studies that were published from January 2009 to January 2021. We selected articles dealing with attitudes and opinions from different professional stakeholders, in particular healthcare professionals and policymakers, on how to implement a policy about carrier screening for a reproductive purpose. We identified 18 studies that met our inclusion criteria. Based on our inductive analysis, we identified ten themes categorized in both clinical and program management challenges: ensuring availability of RGCS to all couples who request the test, embedding RGCS as a test offer before pregnancy, providing clear and reliable information, ensuring voluntary participation, developing genetic counselling pre- and post-testing (after positive or negative result), avoiding psychological harm, ensuring equal access, avoiding social pressure, educating and involving a broad spectrum of non-genetic health care professionals, and promoting an independent non-commercial organisational structure. We highlight one major stumbling block on how to responsibly inform couples about hundreds different genetic conditions within constraints regarding time and ability of non-genetic professionals. We promote further research to tackle the issues brought up by this systematic review through pilot studies. Trial Registration: PROSPERO International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews PROSPERO 2021 # CRD42021233762; https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=233762 .

Societal implications of expanded universal carrier screening: a scoping review

Carrier screening aims to identify couples at risk of conceiving children with a recessive condition. Until recently, carrier screening was primarily offered ancestry-based. Technological advances now facilitate expanded universal carrier screening (EUCS). This scoping review aimed to map EUCS's potential societal implications based on both theoretical studies and empirical evidence. To this aim, we performed a CoCites search to find relevant articles, including articles describing carrier screening for at-risk populations, based on five selected query articles. Forty articles were included. Three main potential societal implications were identified: (1) unwanted medicalization, (2) stigmatization and discrimination of carriers and people affected with the conditions screened and (3) challenges in achieving equitable access. Within these themes, potential positive implications are reduction of ethnic stigmatization in ancestry-based offers and increased equity. Potential negative implications are reinforcement of disability-based stigmatization, less possibility for developing expertise in healthcare and societal pressure to partake in screening. Empirical evidence on all these implications is however scarce. In conclusion, both positive and negative potential societal implications of implementing EUCS, primarily theoretical, were identified, even in at-risk groups where evidence is mostly lacking. Empirical research in EUCS pilots is needed to identify which societal implications are likely to occur and therefore should be overcome when implementing EUCS.

Analysis of clinically relevant variants from ancestrally diverse Asian genomes

Asian populations are under-represented in human genomics research. Here, we characterize clinically significant genetic variation in 9051 genomes representing East Asian, South Asian, and severely under-represented Austronesian-speaking Southeast Asian ancestries. We observe disparate genetic risk burden attributable to ancestry-specific recurrent variants and identify individuals with variants specific to ancestries discordant to their self-reported ethnicity, mostly due to cryptic admixture. About 27% of severe recessive disorder genes with appreciable carrier frequencies in Asians are missed by carrier screening panels, and we estimate 0.5% Asian couples at-risk of having an affected child. Prevalence of medically-actionable variant carriers is 3.4% and a further 1.6% harbour variants with potential for pathogenic classification upon additional clinical/experimental evidence. We profile 23 pharmacogenes with high-confidence gene-drug associations and find 22.4% of Asians at-risk of Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Tier 1 genetic conditions concurrently harbour pharmacogenetic variants with actionable phenotypes, highlighting the benefits of pre-emptive pharmacogenomics. Our findings illuminate the diversity in genetic disease epidemiology and opportunities for precision medicine for a large, diverse Asian population.

Mendelian gene identification through mouse embryo viability screening

BACKGROUND

The diagnostic rate of Mendelian disorders in sequencing studies continues to increase, along with the pace of novel disease gene discovery. However, variant interpretation in novel genes not currently associated with disease is particularly challenging and strategies combining gene functional evidence with approaches that evaluate the phenotypic similarities between patients and model organisms have proven successful. A full spectrum of intolerance to loss-of-function variation has been previously described, providing evidence that gene essentiality should not be considered as a simple and fixed binary property.

METHODS

Here we further dissected this spectrum by assessing the embryonic stage at which homozygous loss-of-function results in lethality in mice from the International Mouse Phenotyping Consortium, classifying the set of lethal genes into one of three windows of lethality: early, mid, or late gestation lethal. We studied the correlation between these windows of lethality and various gene features including expression across development, paralogy and constraint metrics together with human disease phenotypes. We explored a gene similarity approach for novel gene discovery and investigated unsolved cases from the 100,000 Genomes Project.

RESULTS

We found that genes in the early gestation lethal category have distinct characteristics and are enriched for genes linked with recessive forms of inherited metabolic disease. We identified several genes sharing multiple features with known biallelic forms of inborn errors of the metabolism and found signs of enrichment of biallelic predicted pathogenic variants among early gestation lethal genes in patients recruited under this disease category. We highlight two novel gene candidates with phenotypic overlap between the patients and the mouse knockouts.

CONCLUSIONS

Information on the developmental period at which embryonic lethality occurs in the knockout mouse may be used for novel disease gene discovery that helps to prioritise variants in unsolved rare disease cases.

Fgf8 dosage regulates jaw shape and symmetry through pharyngeal-cardiac tissue relationships

BACKGROUND

Asymmetries in craniofacial anomalies are commonly observed. In the facial skeleton, the left side is more commonly and/or severely affected than the right. Such asymmetries complicate treatment options. Mechanisms underlying variation in disease severity between individuals as well as within individuals (asymmetries) are still relatively unknown.

RESULTS

Developmental reductions in fibroblast growth factor 8 (Fgf8) have a dosage dependent effect on jaw size, shape, and symmetry. Further, Fgf8 mutants have directionally asymmetric jaws with the left side being more affected than the right. Defects in lower jaw development begin with disruption to Meckel's cartilage, which is discontinuous. All skeletal elements associated with the proximal condensation are dysmorphic, exemplified by a malformed and misoriented malleus. At later stages, Fgf8 mutants exhibit syngnathia, which falls into two broad categories: bony fusion of the maxillary and mandibular alveolar ridges and zygomatico-mandibular fusion. All of these morphological defects exhibit both inter- and intra-specimen variation.

CONCLUSIONS

We hypothesize that these asymmetries are linked to heart development resulting in higher levels of Fgf8 on the right side of the face, which may buffer the right side to developmental perturbations. This mouse model may facilitate future investigations of mechanisms underlying human syngnathia and facial asymmetry.

Genetic landscape of a large cohort of Primary Ovarian Insufficiency: New genes and pathways and implications for personalized medicine

Background

Primary Ovarian Insufficiency (POI), a public health problem, affects 1-3.7% of women under 40 yielding infertility and a shorter lifespan. Most causes are unknown. Recently, genetic causes were identified, mostly in single families. We studied an unprecedented large cohort of POI to unravel its molecular pathophysiology.

Methods

375 patients with 70 families were studied using targeted (88 genes) or whole exome sequencing with pathogenic/likely-pathogenic variant selection. Mitomycin-induced chromosome breakages were studied in patients’ lymphocytes if necessary.

Findings

A high-yield of 29.3% supports a clinical genetic diagnosis of POI. In addition, we found strong evidence of pathogenicity for nine genes not previously related to a Mendelian phenotype or POI: ELAVL2, NLRP11, CENPE, SPATA33, CCDC150, CCDC185, including DNA repair genes: C17orf53(HROB), HELQ, SWI5 yielding high chromosomal fragility. We confirmed the causal role of BRCA2, FANCM, BNC1, ERCC6, MSH4, BMPR1A, BMPR1B, BMPR2, ESR2, CAV1, SPIDR, RCBTB1 and ATG7 previously reported in isolated patients/families. In 8.5% of cases, POI is the only symptom of a multi-organ genetic disease. New pathways were identified: NF-kB, post-translational regulation, and mitophagy (mitochondrial autophagy), providing future therapeutic targets. Three new genes have been shown to affect the age of natural menopause supporting a genetic link.

Interpretation

We have developed high-performance genetic diagnostic of POI, dissecting the molecular pathogenesis of POI and enabling personalized medicine to i) prevent/cure comorbidities for tumour/cancer susceptibility genes that could affect life-expectancy (37.4% of cases), or for genetically-revealed syndromic POI (8.5% of cases), ii) predict residual ovarian reserve (60.5% of cases). Genetic diagnosis could help to identify patients who may benefit from the promising in vitro activation-IVA technique in the near future, greatly improving its success in treating infertility.

Funding

Université Paris Saclay, Agence Nationale de Biomédecine.

Assessing clinical utility of preconception expanded carrier screening regarding residual risk for neurodevelopmental disorders

The magnitude of clinical utility of preconception expanded carrier screening (ECS) concerning its potential to reduce the risk of affected offspring is unknown. Since neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs) in their offspring is a major concern of parents-to-be, we addressed the question of residual risk by assessing the risk-reduction potential for NDDs in a retrospective study investigating ECS with different criteria for gene selection and definition of pathogenicity. We used exome sequencing data from 700 parents of children with NDDs and blindly screened for carrier-alleles in up to 3046 recessive/X-linked genes. Depending on variant pathogenicity thresholds and gene content, NDD-risk-reduction potential was up to 43.5% in consanguineous, and 5.1% in nonconsanguineous couples. The risk-reduction-potential was compromised by underestimation of pathogenicity of missense variants (false-negative-rate 4.6%), inherited copy-number variants and compound heterozygosity of one inherited and one de novo variant (0.9% each). Adherence to the ACMG recommendations of restricting ECS to high-frequency genes in nonconsanguineous couples would more than halve the detectable inherited NDD-risk. Thus, for optimized clinical utility of ECS, screening in recessive/X-linked genes regardless of their frequency (ACMG Tier-4) and sensible pathogenicity thresholds should be considered for all couples seeking ECS.

Aggregated Genomic Data as Cohort-Specific Allelic Frequencies can Boost Variants and Genes Prioritization in Non-Solved Cases of Inherited Retinal Dystrophies

The introduction of NGS in genetic diagnosis has increased the repertoire of variants and genes involved and the amount of genomic information produced. We built an allelic-frequency (AF) database for a heterogeneous cohort of genetic diseases to explore the aggregated genomic information and boost diagnosis in inherited retinal dystrophies (IRD). We retrospectively selected 5683 index-cases with clinical exome sequencing tests available, 1766 with IRD and the rest with diverse genetic diseases. We calculated a subcohort’s IRD-specific AF and compared it with suitable pseudocontrols. For non-solved IRD cases, we prioritized variants with a significant increment of frequencies, with eight variants that may help to explain the phenotype, and 10/11 of uncertain significance that were reclassified as probably pathogenic according to ACMG. Moreover, we developed a method to highlight genes with more frequent pathogenic variants in IRD cases than in pseudocontrols weighted by the increment of benign variants in the same comparison. We identified 18 genes for further studies that provided new insights in five cases. This resource can also help one to calculate the carrier frequency in IRD genes. A cohort-specific AF database assists with variants and genes prioritization and operates as an engine that provides a new hypothesis in non-solved cases, augmenting the diagnosis rate.

Population-level deficit of homozygosity unveils CPSF3 as an intellectual disability syndrome gene

Predicting the pathogenicity of biallelic missense variants can be challenging. Here, we use a deficit of observed homozygous carriers of missense variants, versus an expected number in a set of 153,054 chip-genotyped Icelanders, to identify potentially pathogenic genotypes. We follow three missense variants with a complete deficit of homozygosity and find that their pathogenic effect in homozygous state ranges from severe childhood disease to early embryonic lethality. One of these variants is in CPSF3, a gene not previously linked to disease. From a set of clinically sequenced Icelanders, and by sequencing archival samples targeted through the Icelandic genealogy, we find four homozygous carriers. Additionally, we find two homozygous carriers of Mexican descent of another missense variant in CPSF3. All six homozygous carriers of missense variants in CPSF3 show severe intellectual disability, seizures, microcephaly, and abnormal muscle tone. Here, we show how the absence of certain homozygous genotypes from a large population set can elucidate causes of previously unexplained recessive diseases and early miscarriage.

How Genetics Can Improve Clinical Practice in Chronic Kidney Disease: From Bench to Bedside

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is considered a major global health problem with high socio-economic costs: the risk of CKD in individuals with an affected first degree relative has been found to be three times higher than in the general population. Genetic factors are known to be involved in CKD pathogenesis, both due to the possible presence of monogenic pathologies as causes of CKD, and to the role of numerous gene variants in determining susceptibility to the development of CKD. The genetic study of CKD patients can represent a useful tool in the hands of the clinician; not only in the diagnostic and prognostic field, but potentially also in guiding therapeutic choices and in designing clinical trials. In this review we discuss the various aspects of the role of genetic analysis on clinical management of patients with CKD with a focus on clinical applications. Several topics are discussed in an effort to provide useful information for daily clinical practice: definition of susceptibility to the development of CKD, identification of unrecognized monogenic diseases, reclassification of the etiological diagnosis, role of pharmacogenetics.

Identification of recurrent pathogenic alleles using exome sequencing data: Proof-of-concept study of Russian subjects

Whole exome sequencing (WES) is a powerful tool for the cataloguing of population-specific genetic diseases. Within this proof-of-concept study we evaluated whether analysis of a small number of individual exomes is capable of identifying recurrent pathogenic alleles. We considered 106 exomes of subjects of Russian origin and revealed 13 genetic variants, which occurred more than twice and fulfilled the criteria for pathogenicity. All these alleles turned out to be indeed recurrent, as revealed by the analysis of 1045 healthy Russian donors. Eight of these variants (NAGA c.973G > A, ACADM c.985 A  >  C, MPO c.2031-2 A > C, SLC3A1 c.1400 T  >  C, LRP2 c.6160G > A, BCHE c.293 A  >  G, MPO c.752 T  >  C, FCN3 c.349delC) are non-Russian-specific, as their high prevalence was previously demonstrated in other European populations. The remaining five disease-associated alleles appear to be characteristic for subjects of Russian origin and include CLCN1 c.2680C  >  T (myotonia congenita), DHCR7 c.453G > A (Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome), NUP93 c.1162C  >  T (steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome, type 12), SLC26A2 c.1957T  >  A (multiple epiphyseal dysplasia) and EIF3F c.694 T  >  G (mental retardation). These recessive disease conditions may be of particular relevance for the Russian Federation and other countries with significant Slavic population.

Fine-scale population structure and demographic history of British Pakistanis

Previous genetic and public health research in the Pakistani population has focused on the role of consanguinity in increasing recessive disease risk, but little is known about its recent population history or the effects of endogamy. Here, we investigate fine-scale population structure, history and consanguinity patterns using genotype chip data from 2,200 British Pakistanis. We reveal strong recent population structure driven by the biraderi social stratification system. We find that all subgroups have had low recent effective population sizes (Ne), with some showing a decrease 15‒20 generations ago that has resulted in extensive identity-by-descent sharing and homozygosity, increasing the risk of recessive disorders. Our results from two orthogonal methods (one using machine learning and the other coalescent-based) suggest that the detailed reporting of parental relatedness for mothers in the cohort under-represents the true levels of consanguinity. These results demonstrate the impact of cultural practices on population structure and genomic diversity in Pakistanis, and have important implications for medical genetic studies.

A Protocol for Preconceptional Screening of Consanguineous Couples Using Whole Exome Sequencing

Genetic studies performed in consanguineous couples suggest that the reproductive risk that distinguish them from other couples in the general population is related to autosomal recessive (AR) diseases. This risk is scattered among the thousands of known and potential AR diseases. Thus, for effective preconceptional screening of consanguineous couples it is necessary a test that encompasses the largest number of genes possible. For that reason, we decided to create a protocol based on whole exome sequencing (WES). We sequenced completely the exomes of 39 consanguineous couples at high coverage (∼100×). Applying bioinformatics filters, we could detect genetic variants that were simultaneously present in both members of the couple in all genes listed in the Clinical Genomics Database as causally related to AR diseases. Shared variants were then assessed for pathogenicity. For non-truncating variants (missense and in-frame indels) we considered as pathogenic or likely pathogenic only the variants included as such in the ClinVar database. Shared truncating variants (frameshift, non-sense, and canonical splice variants) were considered likely pathogenic when loss-of-function was a known mechanism of disease. The 39 consanguineous cases included two couples with a coefficient of genetic relationship (CGR) of 0.25, 26 couples with a CGR of 0.125, three couples with a CGR of 0.0625 and eight couples with a CGR of 0.03125. In 21 of the 39 couples (53.8%) we ascertained sharing of heterozygosity for at least one variant considered pathogenic or likely pathogenic for an AR disease. In eight couples we found sharing of heterozygosity for at least two pathogenic variants. Once the specific pathogenic variant was identified, it became possible for the couple to undergo prenatal diagnosis or, if desired, preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) involving in vitro fertilization and embryo screening. In conclusion, our results demonstrate that preconceptional screening by WES is a useful new procedure that should be incorporated in the genetic counseling of all consanguineous couples.

Lessons learned from unsolicited findings in clinical exome sequencing of 16,482 individuals

Unsolicited findings (UFs) are uncovered unintentionally and predispose to a disease unrelated to the clinical question. The frequency and nature of UFs uncovered in clinical practice remain largely unexplored. We here evaluated UFs identified during a 5-year period in which 16,482 index patients received clinical whole-exome sequencing (WES). UFs were identified in 0.58% (95/16,482) of index patients, indicating that the overall frequency of UFs in clinical WES is low. Fewer UFs were identified using restricted disease-gene panels (0.03%) than when using whole-exome/Mendeliome analysis (1.03%). The UF was disclosed to 86 of 95 individuals, for reasons of medical actionability. Only 61% of these UFs reside in a gene that is listed on the “ACMG59”-list, representing a list of 59 genes for which the American College of Medical Genetics recommends UF disclosure. The remaining 39% were grouped into four categories: disorders similar to “ACMG59”-listed disorders (25%); disorders for which disease manifestation could be influenced (7%); UFs providing reproductive options (2%); and UFs with pharmacogenetic implications (5%). Hence, our experience shows that UFs predisposing to medically actionable disorders affect a broader range of genes than listed on the “ACMG59”, advocating that a pre-defined gene list is too restrictive, and that UFs may require ad hoc evaluation of medical actionability. While both the identification and disclosure of UFs depend on local policy, our lessons learned provide general essential insight into the nature and odds of UFs in clinical exome sequencing.

Multidisziplinäre Diagnostik von Entwicklungsstörungen: Grundlage der „personalized precision medicine“

Das Spektrum der Entwicklungsstörungen gehört zum Alltag des Facharztes für Kinder- und Jugendmedizin. Durch den zunehmenden Einsatz von „Next-generation sequencing“-Methoden in den letzten 10 Jahren werden die genetischen Hintergründe besser verstanden. Hiermit eröffnen sich Möglichkeiten in der Routinediagnostik und auch für pathomechanismusbasierte individuelle Therapieansätze („personalized precision medicine“). Dieser Beitrag beschreibt die patientenzentrierte Einbettung einer multidisziplinären Tagesklinik („Murmeltiersprechstunde“) zu zeit- und ressourcensparender Diagnostik und Behandlung von Entwicklungsstörungen. Bei 43 an der Murmeltiersprechstunde teilnehmenden Kindern (Durchschnittsalter 4,9 Jahre) mit einer Entwicklungsstörung konnte in 24 Fällen (56 %) eine pathogene Variante in einem bereits bekannten Krankheitsgen, in 4 weiteren Fällen (12 %) in einem Kandidatengen gefunden werden und somit eine Diagnose gestellt werden. Hierdurch konnte in 6 Fällen (14 %) eine pathomechanismusbasierte Therapie erfolgreich eingeleitet werden. Die durchschnittliche Dauer zwischen der Aufnahme in der Tagesklinik und der Befundmitteilung betrug 6 Monate. Die Murmeltiersprechstunde zeigt, wie „personalized precision medicine“ in den Alltag einer Kinderklinik eingebaut werden kann und direkten Einfluss auf die Behandlung hat.

From late fatherhood to prenatal screening of monogenic disorders: evidence and ethical concerns

BACKGROUND

With the help of ART, an advanced parental age is not considered to be a serious obstacle for reproduction anymore. However, significant health risks for future offspring hide behind the success of reproductive medicine for the treatment of reduced fertility associated with late parenthood. Although an advanced maternal age is a well-known risk factor for poor reproductive outcomes, understanding the impact of an advanced paternal age on offspring is yet to be elucidated. De novo monogenic disorders (MDs) are highly associated with late fatherhood. MDs are one of the major sources of paediatric morbidity and mortality, causing significant socioeconomic and psychological burdens to society. Although individually rare, the combined prevalence of these disorders is as high as that of chromosomal aneuploidies, indicating the increasing need for prenatal screening. With the help of advanced reproductive technologies, families with late paternity have the option of non-invasive prenatal testing (NIPT) for multiple MDs (MD-NIPT), which has a sensitivity and specificity of almost 100%.

OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE

The main aims of the current review were to examine the effect of late paternity on the origin and nature of MDs, to highlight the role of NIPT for the detection of a variety of paternal age-associated MDs, to describe clinical experiences and to reflect on the ethical concerns surrounding the topic of late paternity and MD-NIPT.

SEARCH METHODS

An extensive search of peer-reviewed publications (1980-2021) in English from the PubMed and Google Scholar databases was based on key words in different combinations: late paternity, paternal age, spermatogenesis, selfish spermatogonial selection, paternal age effect, de novo mutations (DNMs), MDs, NIPT, ethics of late fatherhood, prenatal testing and paternal rights.

OUTCOMES

An advanced paternal age provokes the accumulation of DNMs, which arise in continuously dividing germline cells. A subset of DNMs, owing to their effect on the rat sarcoma virus protein-mitogen-activated protein kinase signalling pathway, becomes beneficial for spermatogonia, causing selfish spermatogonial selection and outgrowth, and in some rare cases may lead to spermatocytic seminoma later in life. In the offspring, these selfish DNMs cause paternal age effect (PAE) disorders with a severe and even life-threatening phenotype. The increasing tendency for late paternity and the subsequent high risk of PAE disorders indicate an increased need for a safe and reliable detection procedure, such as MD-NIPT. The MD-NIPT approach has the capacity to provide safe screening for pregnancies at risk of PAE disorders and MDs, which constitute up to 20% of all pregnancies. The primary risks include pregnancies with a paternal age over 40 years, a previous history of an affected pregnancy/child, and/or congenital anomalies detected by routine ultrasonography. The implementation of NIPT-based screening would support the early diagnosis and management needed in cases of affected pregnancy. However, the benefits of MD-NIPT need to be balanced with the ethical challenges associated with the introduction of such an approach into routine clinical practice, namely concerns regarding reproductive autonomy, informed consent, potential disability discrimination, paternal rights and PAE-associated issues, equity and justice in accessing services, and counselling.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS

Considering the increasing parental age and risks of MDs, combined NIPT for chromosomal aneuploidies and microdeletion syndromes as well as tests for MDs might become a part of routine pregnancy management in the near future. Moreover, the ethical challenges associated with the introduction of MD-NIPT into routine clinical practice need to be carefully evaluated. Furthermore, more focus and attention should be directed towards the ethics of late paternity, paternal rights and paternal genetic guilt associated with pregnancies affected with PAE MDs.

Homozygous PLA2G6 (PARK 14) gene mutation associated neuropsychiatric phenotypes from southern India

PLA2G6 gene associated neurodegenerative disorders resulting from homozygous c. 2222G > A (p.Arg741Gln) mutation were detected in two cases having variable neuropsychiatric phenotypic and imaging findings. Exome analysis helped identification of rare alleles, reinforcing ethnographic antecedents to geographical clustering of rare mutations and, essential to understanding biology of neurodegenerative disorders.

[Our hidden genetic defects]

A systematic study analysing the exomes of several thousand individuals indicates that each of them carries at least one strongly deleterious mutation that is innocuous in a heterozygote but results in a severe phenotype in the homozygous state. Most of these mutations are very rare, while a few are present in 1 or 2% of the population. The frequency of at-risk couples is approximately 1.5%, but increases dramatically to 25% if the partners of the couple are first cousins. This work has important implications for carrier screening and population genetics in general.