A calibrated functional patch-clamp assay to enhance clinical variant interpretation in KCNH2-related long QT syndrome

Multisite Validation of a Functional Assay to Adjudicate SCN5A Brugada Syndrome-Associated Variants

BACKGROUND

Brugada syndrome is an inheritable arrhythmia condition that is associated with rare, loss-of-function variants in SCN5A. Interpreting the pathogenicity of SCN5A missense variants is challenging, and ≈79% of SCN5A missense variants in ClinVar are currently classified as variants of uncertain significance. Automated patch clamp technology enables high-throughput functional studies of ion channel variants and can provide evidence for variant reclassification.

METHODS

An in vitro SCN5A-Brugada syndrome automated patch clamp assay was independently performed at Vanderbilt University Medical Center and Victor Chang Cardiac Research Institute. The assay was calibrated according to ClinGen Sequence Variant Interpretation recommendations using high-confidence variant controls (n=49). Normal and abnormal ranges of function were established based on the distribution of benign variant assay results. Odds of pathogenicity values were derived from the experimental results according to ClinGen Sequence Variant Interpretation recommendations. The calibrated assay was then used to study SCN5A variants of uncertain significance observed in 4 families with Brugada syndrome and other arrhythmia phenotypes associated with SCN5A loss-of-function.

RESULTS

Variant channel parameters generated independently at the 2 research sites showed strong correlations, including peak INa density (R2=0.86). The assay accurately distinguished benign controls (24/25 concordant variants) from pathogenic controls (23/24 concordant variants). Odds of pathogenicity values were 0.042 for normal function and 24.0 for abnormal function, corresponding to strong evidence for both American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics/Association for Molecular Pathology benign and pathogenic functional criteria (BS3 and PS3, respectively). Application of the assay to 4 clinical SCN5A variants of uncertain significance revealed loss-of-function for 3/4 variants, enabling reclassification to likely pathogenic.

CONCLUSIONS

This validated high-throughput assay provides clinical-grade functional evidence to aid the classification of current and future SCN5A-Brugada syndrome variants of uncertain significance.

Multiplexed Assays of Variant Effect and Automated Patch-clamping Improve KCNH2-LQTS Variant Classification and Cardiac Event Risk Stratification

Background

Long QT syndrome (LQTS) is a lethal arrhythmia syndrome, frequently caused by rare loss-of-function variants in the potassium channel encoded by KCNH2. Variant classification is difficult, often owing to lack of functional data. Moreover, variant-based risk stratification is also complicated by heterogenous clinical data and incomplete penetrance. Here, we sought to test whether variant-specific information, primarily from high-throughput functional assays, could improve both classification and cardiac event risk stratification in a large, harmonized cohort of KCNH2 missense variant heterozygotes.

Methods

We quantified cell-surface trafficking of 18,796 variants in KCNH2 using a Multiplexed Assay of Variant Effect (MAVE). We recorded KCNH2 current density for 533 variants by automated patch clamping (APC). We calibrated the strength of evidence of MAVE data according to ClinGen guidelines. We deeply phenotyped 1,458 patients with KCNH2 missense variants, including QTc, cardiac event history, and mortality. We correlated variant functional data and Bayesian LQTS penetrance estimates with cohort phenotypes and assessed hazard ratios for cardiac events.

Results

Variant MAVE trafficking scores and APC peak tail currents were highly correlated (Spearman Rank-order ρ = 0.69). The MAVE data were found to provide up to pathogenic very strong evidence for severe loss-of-function variants. In the cohort, both functional assays and Bayesian LQTS penetrance estimates were significantly predictive of cardiac events when independently modeled with patient sex and adjusted QT interval (QTc); however, MAVE data became non-significant when peak-tail current and penetrance estimates were also available. The area under the ROC for 20-year event outcomes based on patient-specific sex and QTc (AUC 0.80 [0.76-0.83]) was improved with prospectively available penetrance scores conditioned on MAVE (AUC 0.86 [0.83-0.89]) or attainable APC peak tail current data (AUC 0.84 [0.81-0.88]).

Conclusion

High throughput KCNH2 variant MAVE data meaningfully contribute to variant classification at scale while LQTS penetrance estimates and APC peak tail current measurements meaningfully contribute to risk stratification of cardiac events in patients with heterozygous KCNH2 missense variants.

Molecular and cellular context influences SCN8A variant function

Pathogenic variants in SCN8A, which encodes the voltage-gated sodium (NaV) channel NaV1.6, associate with neurodevelopmental disorders, including developmental and epileptic encephalopathy. Previous approaches to determine SCN8A variant function may be confounded by use of a neonatally expressed, alternatively spliced isoform of NaV1.6 (NaV1.6N) and engineered mutations rendering the channel tetrodotoxin (TTX) resistant. We investigated the impact of SCN8A alternative splicing on variant function by comparing the functional attributes of 15 variants expressed in 2 developmentally regulated splice isoforms (NaV1.6N, NaV1.6A). We employed automated patch clamp recording to enhance throughput, and developed a neuronal cell line (ND7/LoNav) with low levels of endogenous NaV current to obviate the need for TTX-resistance mutations. Expression of NaV1.6N or NaV1.6A in ND7/LoNav cells generated NaV currents with small, but significant, differences in voltage dependence of activation and inactivation. TTX-resistant versions of both isoforms exhibited significant functional differences compared with the corresponding WT channels. We demonstrated that many of the 15 disease-associated variants studied exhibited isoform-dependent functional effects, and that many of the studied SCN8A variants exhibited functional properties that were not easily classified as either gain- or loss-of-function. Our work illustrates the value of considering molecular and cellular context when investigating SCN8A variants.

Clinical interpretation of KCNH2 variants using a robust PS3/BS3 functional patch-clamp assay

Long QT syndrome (LQTS), caused by the dysfunction of cardiac ion channels, increases the risk of sudden death in otherwise healthy young people. For many variants in LQTS genes, there is insufficient evidence to make a definitive genetic diagnosis. We have established a robust functional patch-clamp assay to facilitate classification of missense variants in KCNH2, one of the key LQTS genes. A curated set of 30 benign and 30 pathogenic missense variants were used to establish the range of normal and abnormal function. The extent to which variants reduced protein function was quantified using Z scores, the number of standard deviations from the mean of the normalized current density of the set of benign variant controls. A Z score of -2 defined the threshold for abnormal loss of function, which corresponds to 55% wild-type function. More extreme Z scores were observed for variants with a greater loss-of-function effect. We propose that the Z score for each variant can be used to inform the application and weighting of abnormal and normal functional evidence criteria (PS3 and BS3) within the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics variant classification framework. The validity of this approach was demonstrated using a series of 18 KCNH2 missense variants detected in a childhood onset LQTS cohort, where the level of function assessed using our assay correlated to the Schwartz score (a scoring system used to quantify the probability of a clinical diagnosis of LQTS) and the length of the corrected QT (QTc) interval.

Improved classification and pathogenicity assessment by comprehensive functional studies in a large data set of KCNQ2 variants

AIMS

The paucity of functional annotations on hundreds of KCNQ2 variants impedes the diagnosis and treatment of KCNQ2-related disorders. The aims of this work were to determine the functional properties of 331 clinical KCNQ2 variants, interpreted the pathogenicity of 331 variants using functional data，and explored the association between homomeric channel functions and phenotypes.

MAIN METHODS

We collected 145 KCNQ2 variants from 232 epilepsy patients and 186 KCNQ2 missense variants from the ClinVar database. Whole-cell patch-clamp recording was used to classify the function of 331 variants. Subsequently, we proposed 24 criteria for the pathogenicity interpretation of KCNQ2 variants and used them to assess pathogenicity of 331 variants. Finally, we analyzed the clinical phenotypes of patients carrying these variants, and explored the correlations between functional mechanisms and phenotypes.

KEY FINDINGS

In the homozygous state, 287 were classified as loss-of-function and 14 as gain-of-function. In the more clinically relative heterozygous state, 200 variants exhibited functional impairment, 121 of which showed dominant-negative effects on wild-type KCNQ2 subunits. After introducing functional data as strong-level evidence to interpret pathogenicity, over half of variants (169/331) were reclassified and 254 were classified as pathogenic/likely pathogenic. Moreover, dominant-negative effect and haploinsufficiency were identified as primary mechanisms in DEE/ID and SeLNE, respectively. The degree of impairment of channel function correlated with the phenotype severity.

SIGNIFICANCE

Our study reveals the possible cause of KCNQ2-related disorders at the molecular level, provides compelling evidence for clinical classification of KCNQ2 variants, and expands the knowledge of correlations between functional mechanisms and phenotypes.

Multi-site validation of a functional assay to adjudicate SCN5A Brugada Syndrome-associated variants

Brugada Syndrome (BrS) is an inheritable arrhythmia condition that is associated with rare, loss-of-function variants in the cardiac sodium channel gene, SCN5A. Interpreting the pathogenicity of SCN5A missense variants is challenging and ~79% of SCN5A missense variants in ClinVar are currently classified as Variants of Uncertain Significance (VUS). An in vitro SCN5A-BrS automated patch clamp assay was generated for high-throughput functional studies of NaV1.5. The assay was independently studied at two separate research sites - Vanderbilt University Medical Center and Victor Chang Cardiac Research Institute - revealing strong correlations, including peak INa density (R2=0.86). The assay was calibrated according to ClinGen Sequence Variant Interpretation recommendations using high-confidence variant controls (n=49). Normal and abnormal ranges of function were established based on the distribution of benign variant assay results. The assay accurately distinguished benign controls (24/25) from pathogenic controls (23/24). Odds of Pathogenicity values derived from the experimental results yielded 0.042 for normal function (BS3 criterion) and 24.0 for abnormal function (PS3 criterion), resulting in up to strong evidence for both ACMG criteria. The calibrated assay was then used to study SCN5A VUS observed in four families with BrS and other arrhythmia phenotypes associated with SCN5A loss-of-function. The assay revealed loss-of-function for three of four variants, enabling reclassification to likely pathogenic. This validated APC assay provides clinical-grade functional evidence for the reclassification of current VUS and will aid future SCN5A-BrS variant classification.

Evaluating pro-arrhythmogenic effects of the T634S-hERG mutation: insights from a simulation study

A mutation to serine of a conserved threonine (T634S) in the hERG K+ channel S6 pore region has been identified as a variant of uncertain significance, showing a loss-of-function effect. However, its potential consequences for ventricular excitation and arrhythmogenesis have not been reported. This study evaluated possible functional effects of the T634S-hERG mutation on ventricular excitation and arrhythmogenesis by using multi-scale computer models of the human ventricle. A Markov chain model of the rapid delayed rectifier potassium current (IKr) was reconstructed for wild-type and T634S-hERG mutant conditions and incorporated into the ten Tusscher et al. models of human ventricles at cell and tissue (1D, 2D and 3D) levels. Possible functional impacts of the T634S-hERG mutation were evaluated by its effects on action potential durations (APDs) and their rate-dependence (APDr) at the cell level; and on the QT interval of pseudo-ECGs, tissue vulnerability to unidirectional conduction block (VW), spiral wave dynamics and repolarization dispersion at the tissue level. It was found that the T634S-hERG mutation prolonged cellular APDs, steepened APDr, prolonged the QT interval, increased VW, destablized re-entry and augmented repolarization dispersion across the ventricle. Collectively, these results imply potential pro-arrhythmic effects of the T634S-hERG mutation, consistent with LQT2.

Molecular and Cellular Context Influences SCN8A Variant Function

Pathogenic variants in SCN8A , which encodes the voltage-gated sodium (Na V ) channel Na V 1.6, are associated with neurodevelopmental disorders including epileptic encephalopathy. Previous approaches to determine SCN8A variant function may be confounded by the use of a neonatal-expressed alternatively spliced isoform of Na V 1.6 (Na V 1.6N), and engineered mutations to render the channel tetrodotoxin (TTX) resistant. In this study, we investigated the impact of SCN8A alternative splicing on variant function by comparing the functional attributes of 15 variants expressed in two developmentally regulated splice isoforms (Na V 1.6N, Na V 1.6A). We employed automated patch clamp recording to enhance throughput, and developed a novel neuronal cell line (ND7/LoNav) with low levels of endogenous Na V current to obviate the need for TTX-resistance mutations. Expression of Na V 1.6N or Na V 1.6A in ND7/LoNav cells generated Na V currents that differed significantly in voltage-dependence of activation and inactivation. TTX-resistant versions of both isoforms exhibited significant functional differences compared to the corresponding wild-type (WT) channels. We demonstrated that many of the 15 disease-associated variants studied exhibited isoform-dependent functional effects, and that many of the studied SCN8A variants exhibited functional properties that were not easily classified as either gain- or loss-of-function. Our work illustrates the value of considering molecular and cellular context when investigating SCN8A variants.

ParSE-seq: A Calibrated Multiplexed Assay to Facilitate the Clinical Classification of Putative Splice-altering Variants

Background

Interpreting the clinical significance of putative splice-altering variants outside 2-base pair canonical splice sites remains difficult without functional studies.

Methods

We developed Parallel Splice Effect Sequencing (ParSE-seq), a multiplexed minigene-based assay, to test variant effects on RNA splicing quantified by high-throughput sequencing. We studied variants in SCN5A, an arrhythmia-associated gene which encodes the major cardiac voltage-gated sodium channel. We used the computational tool SpliceAI to prioritize exonic and intronic candidate splice variants, and ClinVar to select benign and pathogenic control variants. We generated a pool of 284 barcoded minigene plasmids, transfected them into Human Embryonic Kidney (HEK293) cells and induced pluripotent stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes (iPSC-CMs), sequenced the resulting pools of splicing products, and calibrated the assay to the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics scheme. Variants were interpreted using the calibrated functional data, and experimental data were compared to SpliceAI predictions. We further studied some splice-altering missense variants by cDNA-based automated patch clamping (APC) in HEK cells and assessed splicing and sodium channel function in CRISPR-edited iPSC-CMs.

Results

ParSE-seq revealed the splicing effect of 224 SCN5A variants in iPSC-CMs and 244 variants in HEK293 cells. The scores between the cell types were highly correlated (R2=0.84). In iPSCs, the assay had concordant scores for 21/22 benign/likely benign and 24/25 pathogenic/likely pathogenic control variants from ClinVar. 43/112 exonic variants and 35/70 intronic variants with determinate scores disrupted splicing. 11 of 42 variants of uncertain significance were reclassified, and 29 of 34 variants with conflicting interpretations were reclassified using the functional data. SpliceAI computational predictions correlated well with experimental data (AUC = 0.96). We identified 20 unique SCN5A missense variants that disrupted splicing, and 2 clinically observed splice-altering missense variants of uncertain significance had normal function when tested with the cDNA-based APC assay. A splice-altering intronic variant detected by ParSE-seq, c.1891-5C>G, also disrupted splicing and sodium current when introduced into iPSC-CMs at the endogenous locus by CRISPR editing.

Conclusions

ParSE-seq is a calibrated, multiplexed, high-throughput assay to facilitate the classification of candidate splice-altering variants.

Automated Patch-Clamp and Induced Pluripotent Stem Cell-Derived Cardiomyocytes: A Synergistic Approach in the Study of Brugada Syndrome

The development of high-throughput automated patch-clamp technology is a recent breakthrough in the field of Brugada syndrome research. Brugada syndrome is a heart disorder marked by abnormal electrocardiographic readings and an elevated risk of sudden cardiac death due to arrhythmias. Various experimental models, developed either in animals, cell lines, human tissue or computational simulation, play a crucial role in advancing our understanding of this condition, and developing effective treatments. In the perspective of the pathophysiological role of ion channels and their pharmacology, automated patch-clamp involves a robotic system that enables the simultaneous recording of electrical activity from multiple single cells at once, greatly improving the speed and efficiency of data collection. By combining this approach with the use of patient-derived cardiomyocytes, researchers are gaining a more comprehensive view of the underlying mechanisms of heart disease. This has led to the development of more effective treatments for those affected by cardiovascular conditions.

Reclassification of a likely pathogenic Dutch founder variant in KCNH2; implications of reduced penetrance

BACKGROUND

Variants in KCNH2, encoding the human ether a-go-go (hERG) channel that is responsible for the rapid component of the cardiac delayed rectifier K+ current (IKr), are causal to long QT syndrome type 2 (LQTS2). We identified eight index patients with a new variant of unknown significance (VUS), KCNH2:c.2717C > T:p.(Ser906Leu). We aimed to elucidate the biophysiological effect of this variant, to enable reclassification and consequent clinical decision-making.

METHODS

A genotype-phenotype overview of the patients and relatives was created. The biophysiological effects were assessed independently by manual-, and automated calibrated patch clamp. HEK293a cells expressing (i) wild-type (WT) KCNH2, (ii) KCNH2-p.S906L alone (homozygous, Hm) or (iii) KCNH2-p.S906L in combination with WT (1:1) (heterozygous, Hz) were used for manual patching. Automated patch clamp measured the variants function against known benign and pathogenic variants, using Flp-In T-rex HEK293 KCNH2-variant cell lines.

RESULTS

Incomplete penetrance of LQTS2 in KCNH2:p.(Ser906Leu) carriers was observed. In addition, some patients were heterozygous for other VUSs in CACNA1C, PKP2, RYR2 or AKAP9. The phenotype of carriers of KCNH2:p.(Ser906Leu) ranged from asymptomatic to life-threatening arrhythmic events. Manual patch clamp showed a reduced current density by 69.8 and 60.4% in KCNH2-p.S906L-Hm and KCNH2-p.S906L-Hz, respectively. The time constant of activation was significantly increased with 80.1% in KCNH2-p.S906L-Hm compared with KCNH2-WT. Assessment of KCNH2-p.S906L-Hz by calibrated automatic patch clamp assay showed a reduction in current density by 35.6%.

CONCLUSION

The reduced current density in the KCNH2-p.S906L-Hz indicates a moderate loss-of-function. Combined with the reduced penetrance and variable phenotype, we conclude that KCNH2:p.(Ser906Leu) is a low penetrant likely pathogenic variant for LQTS2.

A need for exhaustive and standardized characterization of ion channels activity. The case of KV11.1

hERG, the pore-forming subunit of the rapid component of the delayed rectifier K⁺ current, plays a key role in ventricular repolarization. Mutations in the KCNH2 gene encoding hERG are associated with several cardiac rhythmic disorders, mainly the Long QT syndrome (LQTS) characterized by prolonged ventricular repolarization, leading to ventricular tachyarrhythmias, sometimes progressing to ventricular fibrillation and sudden death. Over the past few years, the emergence of next-generation sequencing has revealed an increasing number of genetic variants including KCNH2 variants. However, the potential pathogenicity of the majority of the variants remains unknown, thus classifying them as variants of uncertain significance or VUS. With diseases such as LQTS being associated with sudden death, identifying patients at risk by determining the variant pathogenicity, is crucial. The purpose of this review is to describe, on the basis of an exhaustive examination of the 1322 missense variants, the nature of the functional assays undertaken so far and their limitations. A detailed analysis of 38 hERG missense variants identified in Long QT French patients and studied in electrophysiology also underlies the incomplete characterization of the biophysical properties for each variant. These analyses lead to two conclusions: first, the function of many hERG variants has never been looked at and, second, the functional studies done so far are excessively heterogeneous regarding the stimulation protocols, cellular models, experimental temperatures, homozygous and/or the heterozygous condition under study, a context that may lead to conflicting conclusions. The state of the literature emphasizes how necessary and important it is to perform an exhaustive functional characterization of hERG variants and to standardize this effort for meaningful comparison among variants. The review ends with suggestions to create a unique homogeneous protocol that could be shared and adopted among scientists and that would facilitate cardiologists and geneticists in patient counseling and management.

A massively parallel assay accurately discriminates between functionally normal and abnormal variants in a hotspot domain of KCNH2

Many genes, including KCNH2, contain "hotspot" domains associated with a high density of variants associated with disease. This has led to the suggestion that variant location can be used as evidence supporting classification of clinical variants. However, it is not known what proportion of all potential variants in hotspot domains cause loss of function. Here, we have used a massively parallel trafficking assay to characterize all single-nucleotide variants in exon 2 of KCNH2, a known hotspot for variants that cause long QT syndrome type 2 and an increased risk of sudden cardiac death. Forty-two percent of KCNH2 exon 2 variants caused at least 50% reduction in protein trafficking, and 65% of these trafficking-defective variants exerted a dominant-negative effect when co-expressed with a WT KCNH2 allele as assessed using a calibrated patch-clamp electrophysiology assay. The massively parallel trafficking assay was more accurate (AUC of 0.94) than bioinformatic prediction tools (REVEL and CardioBoost, AUC of 0.81) in discriminating between functionally normal and abnormal variants. Interestingly, over half of variants in exon 2 were found to be functionally normal, suggesting a nuanced interpretation of variants in this "hotspot" domain is necessary. Our massively parallel trafficking assay can provide this information prospectively.