Tricuspid Annular Geometry and Strain After Suture Annuloplasty in Acute Ovine Right Heart Failure

A tissue-silicone integrated simulator for right ventricular pulsatile circulation with severe functional tricuspid regurgitation

There is a great demand for development of a functional tricuspid regurgitation (FTR) model for accelerating development and preclinical study of tricuspid interventional repair devices. This study aimed to develop a severe FTR model by creating a tissue-silicone integrated right ventricular pulsatile circulatory simulator. The simulator incorporates the porcine tricuspid annulus, valve leaflets, chordae tendineae, papillary muscles, and right ventricular wall as one continuous piece of tissue, thereby preserving essential anatomical relationships of the tricuspid valve (TV) complex. We dilated the TV annulus with collagenolytic enzymes under applying stepwise dilation, and successfully achieved a severe FTR model with a regurgitant volume of 45 ± 9 mL/beat and a flow jet area of 15.8 ± 2.3 cm2 (n = 6). Compared to a normal model, the severe FTR model exhibited a larger annular circumference (133.1 ± 8.2 mm vs. 115.7 ± 5.5 mm; p = 0.009) and lower coaptation height (6.6 ± 1.0 mm vs. 17.7 ± 1.3 mm; p = 0.003). Following the De-Vega annular augmentation procedure to the severe FTR model, a significant reduction in regurgitant volume and flow jet area were observed. This severe FTR model may open new avenues for the development and evaluation of transcatheter TV devices.

Impact of prophylactic donor heart tricuspid valve annuloplasty on outcomes in heart transplantation

BACKGROUND

Tricuspid regurgitation(TR) following heart transplantation could adversely affect clinical outcomes. In an effort to reduce the incidence of TR, prophylactic donor heart tricuspid valve annuloplasty has been performed during heart transplantation in our institution. We assessed early and long-term outcomes.

METHODS

Between August 2011 and August 2021, 349 patients who underwent prophylactic tricuspid valve annuloplasty were included. Tricuspid valve annuloplasty was performed using the DeVega annuloplasty technique. The clinical outcomes of the interests included complete atrioventricular block requiring pacemaker implantation, the occurrence of significant TR(defined as moderate or greater), and survival. Long-term survival was compared in patients with and without significant TR using the Kaplan-Meier method. The Cox proportional hazards regression with time-dependent covariate analysis was used to see if significant TR affected the long-term survival.

RESULTS

There was one patient(0.3%) who required pacemaker implantation for complete atrioventricular block. No patients developed tricuspid valve stenosis that required intervention. Significant TR developed in 31 patients(8.9%) during the follow-up period. The survival rate of patients who developed significant TR was significantly lower than that of those who did not(log rank < 0.01). Significant TR was associated with the long-term mortality(HR2.92, 95%CI 1.47-5.82, p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Prophylactic donor heart tricuspid valve annuloplasty has the potential to reduce the occurrence of significant TR and can be performed safely. The significant TR that developed in patients with prophylactic annuloplasty negatively affected survival and was an independent predictor of long-term mortality.

Texas TriValve 1.0 : a reverse‑engineered, open model of the human tricuspid valve

Nearly 1.6 million Americans suffer from a leaking tricuspid heart valve. To make matters worse, current valve repair options are far from optimal leading to recurrence of leakage in up to 30% of patients. We submit that a critical step toward improving outcomes is to better understand the "forgotten" valve. High-fidelity computer models may help in this endeavour. However, the existing models are limited by averaged or idealized geometries, material properties, and boundary conditions. In our current work, we overcome the limitations of existing models by (reverse) engineering the tricuspid valve from a beating human heart in an organ preservation system. The resulting finite-element model faithfully captures the kinematics and kinetics of the native tricuspid valve as validated against echocardiographic data and others' previous work. To showcase the value of our model, we also use it to simulate disease-induced and repair-induced changes to valve geometry and mechanics. Specifically, we simulate and compare the effectiveness of tricuspid valve repair via surgical annuloplasty and via transcatheter edge-to-edge repair. Importantly, our model is openly available for others to use. Thus, our model will allow us and others to perform virtual experiments on the healthy, diseased, and repaired tricuspid valve to better understand the valve itself and to optimize tricuspid valve repair for better patient outcomes.

A pilot investigation of the tricuspid valve annulus in newborns with hypoplastic left heart syndrome

Objective

Hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) is a congenital disease characterized by an underdevelopment of the anatomical components inside the left heart. Approximately 30% of newborns with HLHS will develop tricuspid regurgitation, and it is currently unknown how the valve annulus mechanics and geometry are associated with regurgitation. Thus, we present an engineering mechanics-based analysis approach to quantify the mechanics and geometry of the HLHS-afflicted tricuspid valve (TV), using 4-dimensional echocardiograms.

Methods

Infants born with HLHS (n = 8) and healthy newborns (n = 4) had their TVs imaged, and the data were imported to 3D Slicer. The annular curves were defined at 5 points in the cardiac cycle. The geometry and deformation (strain) of the TV annulus were calculated to elucidate the mechanics of this critical structure and to compare them between neonates with and without HLHS.

Results

For the annular geometry, HLHS-afflicted newborns had significantly larger annular circumferences (20%-30%) and anteroposterior diameters (35%-45%) than the healthy patients. From a biomechanics' perspective, the HLHS patients had significantly smaller strains in the anterior segments (–0.1 ± 2.6%) during end-diastolic and end-isovolumetric relaxation (1.7 ± 3.0%) compared with the healthy counterparts (–13.3 ± 2.9% and 6.8 ± 0.9%, respectively).

Conclusions

The image-based analysis presented in this study may provide novel insights into the geometric and mechanistic differences in the TV annulus between the healthy and HLHS newborns. Future longitudinal studies of the biomechanics of TV annulus and other subvalvular structures may inform our understanding of the initiation and development of tricuspid regurgitation and the design of optimal repairs in this challenging population.

Midterm comparison between different annuloplasty techniques for functional tricuspid regurgitation

BACKGROUND

Several tricuspid annuloplasty (TA) techniques are used for concomitant repair of functional tricuspid regurgitation. This study aims to compare the midterm clinical and valvular outcome between 3 annuloplasty techniques.

METHODS

TA was performed in 307 patients (age 75.9±10.4y) with a rigid ring (RA=184), a flexible band(FA=80) and a suture annuloplasty(SA=43). Study endpoints were survival and recurrence of TR > grade 2 at 5 years.

RESULTS

TA was performed concomitantly to mitral valve surgery (n=136, 44.3%), aortic valve surgery(n=18, 5.9%), CABG(n=13, 4.2%) or a combined procedure(n=140, 45.6%). The majority had TR>grade 2(78.5%) without significant differences between TA groups(p=0.878). Within a median follow-up of 3.4 y(IQR 2.2-5.0) the 5-year survival was 80.1±3.4% for RA, 83.5±4.7% for FA and 85.1±6.5% for SA(p=0.471). Independent risk factors for late mortality were renal impairment(HR 2.83, CI 1.16-6.89, p=0.022), diabetes(HR 2.10, CI 1.07-4.11, p=0.030) and severe RV dysfunction by TAPSE <10 mm(HR 11.52, CI 4.98-26.66, p<0.001). Pulmonary hypertension was nearly significant(HR 1.92, CI 0.98-3.74, p=0.057). The cumulative incidence of TR recurrence at 5 years was 15.9%, 19.4% and 21.1% for respectively RA, FA and SA(p=0.342). Severe pulmonary hypertension(HR 2.64, 95%CI 1.38-5.07, p=0.003) preoperative TR grade(HR 1.82, 95%CI 1.01-3.27, p=0.046) and residual TR>grade 2 at discharge(HR 3.38, 95%CI 1.64-6.96, p=0.001) were predictive for later TR recurrence, regardless of the annuloplasty technique.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that advanced pathophysiological right circulatory impairment like severe pulmonary hypertension and RV dysfunction affects the midterm survival as well as TR recurrence rate more than the annuloplasty technique used for concomitant repair of functional tricuspid regurgitation.

A huge right ventricular hydatid cyst related to tricuspid valve causing severe pulmonary hypertension

Preserving tricuspid valve's function is the cornerstone in surgical excision of cardiac hydatid cysts present in the right side of the heart. The perfect surgical technique may not exist. However, further studies are needed to ensure the clear path.

Tricuspid Valve Annuloplasty Alters Leaflet Mechanics

Tricuspid valve regurgitation is associated with significant morbidity and mortality. Its most common treatment option, tricuspid valve annuloplasty, is not optimally effective in the long-term. Toward identifying the causes for annuloplasty's ineffectiveness, we have previously investigated the technique's impact on the tricuspid annulus and the right ventricular epicardium. In our current work, we are extending our analysis to the anterior tricuspid valve leaflet. To this end, we adopted our previous strategy of performing DeVega suture annuloplasty as an experimental methodology that allows us to externally control the degree of cinching during annuloplasty. Thus, in ten sheep we successively cinched the annulus and quantified changes to leaflet motion, dynamics, and strain in the beating heart by combining sonomicrometry with our well-established mechanical framework. We found that successive cinching of the valve enforced earlier coaptation and thus reduced leaflet range of motion. Additionally, leaflet angular velocity during opening and closing decreased. Finally, we found that leaflet strains were also reduced. Specifically, radial and areal strains decreased as a function of annular cinching. Our findings are critical as they suggest that suture annuloplasty alters the mechanics of the tricuspid valve leaflets which may disrupt their resident cells' mechanobiological equilibrium. Long-term, such disruption may stimulate tissue maladaptation which could contribute to annuloplasty's sub-optimal effectiveness. Additionally, our data suggest that the extent to which annuloplasty alters leaflet mechanics can be controlled via degree of cinching. Hence, our data may provide direct surgical guidelines.

Tricuspid Annuloplasty Rings: A Quantitative Comparison of Size, Nonplanar Shape, and Stiffness

BACKGROUND

Functional tricuspid regurgitation due to annular and ventricular dilatation is increasingly recognized as a significant source of morbidity and mortality. To repair the annulus, surgeons implant one of many annuloplasty devices that differ in size, 3-dimensional (3D) shape, and stiffness. However, there have been no quantitative comparisons between various available devices.

METHODS

Three-dimensional scanning, micro-computed tomography imaging, analytical methods, and mechanical tests were used to compare 3 Edwards Lifesciences (Irvine, CA) and 3 Medtronic (Minneapolis, MN) annuloplasty devices of all available sizes. We measured in-plane metrics of maximum diameter, perimeter, area, height, as well as elevation and curvature profiles. Furthermore, we computed bending stiffness as well as the maximum and minimum axes of the bending stiffness.

RESULTS

Most annular prostheses differed little in their in-plane geometries but varied significantly in height. In-plane properties deviated significantly from measurements of healthy human tricuspid annuli. Height of the Edwards' MC3 and Medtronic's Contour 3D resembled healthy human tricuspid valve annuli, whereas the Edwards' Physio and Classic, and Medtronic's TriAd, did not. Additionally, the elevation profiles of the MC3 and Contour 3D and curvature profiles between all devices were consistent and matched those of healthy human annuli. The tested devices also differed in their bending stiffness, both in terms of absolute values and their maximum and minimum axes.

CONCLUSIONS

Contoured devices, such as Edwards' MC3 and Medtronic's Contour 3D, most accurately resembled the healthy human tricuspid annulus but differed significantly in bending stiffness. To what extent prosthesis properties and shape affect tricuspid valve function remains to be determined.

Mechanical and Structural Evaluation of Tricuspid Bicuspidization in a Porcine Model

INTRODUCTION

Tricuspid regurgitation (TR) affects approximately 1.6 million Americans and is associated with just a 63.9% 1-year survival rate in its moderate to severe forms due to its asymptomatic nature and late diagnosis and surgical referral. As a result, industrial fervor has begun to broach this topic, with several percutaneous treatment devices currently under development. As much remains unknown about the tricuspid apparatus, the mechanics of these procedures remain unquantified. In this study, a testing apparatus and technique for the evaluation of percutaneous tricuspid valve (TV) bicuspidization were developed for the evaluation of these parameters in twelve porcine hearts.

METHODS

The passive relaxed myocardial state and the active contracted state were each induced in six porcine hearts and the bicuspidization experiment was run twice, the second time after induction of TR. TV annular area, cinching force, static leakage through the TV annulus, and annular ellipticity were quantified and compared among the groups.

RESULTS

The use of phenol was effective to induce functional TR by increased annular area. Cinching force was not found to differ between any of the testing states, but the bicuspidization experiment was able to reduce the TR annular area to that of its healthy counterpart in addition to reducing static leakage through the TV annulus. Despite appropriately reducing the area, bicuspidization was found to induce a more circular TV annular shape.

CONCLUSION

Taken together, these results provide a first mechanical analysis of the TV bicuspidization mechanism and may serve as a point of reference for future clinical animal studies.

A pilot in silico modeling-based study of the pathological effects on the biomechanical function of tricuspid valves

Current clinical assessment of functional tricuspid valve regurgitation relies on metrics quantified from medical imaging modalities. Although these clinical methodologies are generally successful, the lack of detailed information about the mechanical environment of the valve presents inherent challenges for assessing tricuspid valve regurgitation. In the present study, we have developed a finite element-based in silico model of one porcine tricuspid valve (TV) geometry to investigate how various pathological conditions affect the overall biomechanical function of the TV. There were three primary observations from our results. Firstly, the results of the papillary muscle (PM) displacement study scenario indicated more pronounced changes in the TV biomechanical function. Secondly, compared to uniform annulus dilation, nonuniform dilation scenario induced more evident changes in the von Mises stresses (83.8-125.3 kPa vs 65.1-84.0 kPa) and the Green-Lagrange strains (0.52-0.58 vs 0.47-0.53) for the three TV leaflets. Finally, results from the pulmonary hypertension study scenario showed opposite trends compared to the PM displacement and annulus dilation scenarios. Furthermore, various chordae rupture scenarios were simulated, and the results showed that the chordae tendineae attached to the TV anterior and septal leaflets may be more critical to proper TV function. This in silico modeling-based study has provided a deeper insight into the tricuspid valve pathologies that may be useful, with moderate extensions, for guiding clinical decisions. NOVELTY STATEMENT: The novelties of the research are summarized below: A comprehensive in silico pilot study of how isolated functional tricuspid regurgitation pathologies and ruptured chordae tendineae would alter the tricuspid valve function; An extensive analysis of the tricuspid valve function, including mechanical quantities (eg, the von Mises stress and the Green-Lagrange strain) and clinically-relevant geometry metrics (eg, the tenting area and the coaptation height); and A developed computational modeling pipeline that can be extended to evaluate patient-specific tricuspid valve geometries and enhance the current clinical diagnosis and treatment of tricuspid regurgitation.

The Effect of Downsizing on the Normal Tricuspid Annulus

Tricuspid annuloplasty is a surgical procedure that cinches the valve's annulus in order to reduce regurgitant blood flow. One of its critical parameters is the degree of downsizing. To provide insight into the effect of downsizing, we studied the annulus of healthy sheep during suture annuloplasty. To this end, we implanted fiduciary markers along the annulus of sheep and subsequently performed a DeVega suture annuloplasty. We performed five downsizing steps in each animal while recording hemodynamic and sonomicrometry data in beating hearts. Subsequently, we used splines to approximate the annulus at baseline and at each downsizing step. Based on these approximations we computed clinical metrics of annular shape and dynamics, and the continuous field metrics height, strain, and curvature. With these data, we demonstrated that annular area reduction during downsizing was primarily driven by compression of the anterior annulus. Similarly, reduction in annular dynamics was driven by reduced contractility in the anterior annulus. Finally, changes in global height and eccentricity of the annulus could be explained by focal changes in the continuous height profile and changes in annular curvature. Our findings are important as they provide insight into a regularly performed surgical procedure and may inform the design of transcatheter devices that mimic suture annuloplasty.

A detailed mechanical and microstructural analysis of ovine tricuspid valve leaflets

The tricuspid valve ensures unidirectional blood flow from the right atrium to the right ventricle. The three tricuspid leaflets operate within a dynamic stress environment of shear, bending, tensile, and compressive forces, which is cyclically repeated nearly three billion times in a lifetime. Ostensibly, the microstructural and mechanical properties of the tricuspid leaflets have mechanobiologically evolved to optimally support their function under those forces. Yet, how the tricuspid leaflet microstructure determines its mechanical properties and whether this relationship differs between the three leaflets is unknown. Here we perform a microstructural and mechanical analysis in matched ovine tricuspid leaflet samples. We found that the microstructure and mechanical properties vary among the three tricuspid leaflets in sheep. Specifically, we found that tricuspid leaflet composition, collagen orientation, and valve cell nuclear morphology are spatially heterogeneous and vary across leaflet type. Furthermore, under biaxial tension, the leaflets' mechanical behaviors exhibited unequal degrees of mechanical anisotropy. Most importantly, we found that the septal leaflet was stiffer in the radial direction and not the circumferential direction as with the other two leaflets. The differences we observed in leaflet microstructure coincide with the varying biaxial mechanics among leaflets. Our results demonstrate the structure-function relationship for each leaflet in the tricuspid valve. We anticipate our results to be vital toward developing more accurate, leaflet-specific tricuspid valve computational models. Furthermore, our results may be clinically important, informing differential surgical treatments of the tricuspid valve leaflets. Finally, the identified structure-function relationships may provide insight into the homeostatic and remodeling potential of valvular cells in altered mechanical environments, such as in diseased or repaired tricuspid valves. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Our work is significant as we investigated the structure-function relationship of ovine tricuspid valve leaflets. This is important as tricuspid valves fail frequently and our current approach to repairing them is suboptimal. Specifically, we related the distribution of structural and cellular elements, such as collagen, glycosaminoglycans, and cell nuclei, to each leaflet's mechanical properties. We found that leaflets have different structures and that their mechanics differ. This may, in the future, inform leaflet-specific treatment strategies and help optimize surgical outcomes.

Biomechanics of the Tricuspid Annulus: A Review of the Annulus' In Vivo Dynamics With Emphasis on Ovine Data

The tricuspid annulus forms the boundary between the tricuspid valve leaflets and their surrounding perivalvular tissue of the right atrioventricular junction. Its shape changes throughout the cardiac cycle in response to the forces from the contracting right heart myocardium and the blood-valve interaction. Alterations to annular shape and dynamics in disease lead to valvular dysfunctions such as tricuspid regurgitation from which millions of patients suffer. Successful treatment of such dysfunction requires an in-depth understanding of the normal shape and dynamics of the tricuspid annulus and of the changes following disease and subsequent repair. In this manuscript we review what we know about the shape and dynamics of the normal tricuspid annulus and about the effects of both disease and repair based on non-invasive imaging studies and invasive fiduciary marker-based studies. We further show, by means of ovine data, that detailed engineering analyses of the tricuspid annulus provide regionally-resolved insight into the kinematics of the annulus which would remain hidden if limiting analyses to simple geometric metrics.

Mechanics of the Tricuspid Valve-From Clinical Diagnosis/Treatment, In-Vivo and In-Vitro Investigations, to Patient-Specific Biomechanical Modeling

Proper tricuspid valve (TV) function is essential to unidirectional blood flow through the right side of the heart. Alterations to the tricuspid valvular components, such as the TV annulus, may lead to functional tricuspid regurgitation (FTR), where the valve is unable to prevent undesired backflow of blood from the right ventricle into the right atrium during systole. Various treatment options are currently available for FTR; however, research for the tricuspid heart valve, functional tricuspid regurgitation, and the relevant treatment methodologies are limited due to the pervasive expectation among cardiac surgeons and cardiologists that FTR will naturally regress after repair of left-sided heart valve lesions. Recent studies have focused on (i) understanding the function of the TV and the initiation or progression of FTR using both in-vivo and in-vitro methods, (ii) quantifying the biomechanical properties of the tricuspid valve apparatus as well as its surrounding heart tissue, and (iii) performing computational modeling of the TV to provide new insight into its biomechanical and physiological function. This review paper focuses on these advances and summarizes recent research relevant to the TV within the scope of FTR. Moreover, this review also provides future perspectives and extensions critical to enhancing the current understanding of the functioning and remodeling tricuspid valve in both the healthy and pathophysiological states.

Tricuspid Valve Annular Mechanics: Interactions with and Implications for Transcatheter Devices

In the interventional treatment of tricuspid valve regurgitation, the majority of prosthetic devices interact with or are implanted to the tricuspid valve annulus. For new transcatheter technologies, there exists a growing body of clinical experience, literature, and professional discourse related to the difficulties in delivering, securing, and sustaining the function of these devices within the dynamic tricuspid annulus. Many of the difficulties arise from circumstances not encountered in open-heart surgery, namely; a non-arrested heart, indirect visualization, and a reliance on non-suture-based methods. These challenges require the application of procedural techniques or system designs to account for tricuspid annular motion, forces, and underlying tissue strength. Improved knowledge in these interactions will support the goals of improving device systems, their procedures, and patient outcomes. This review aims to describe current concepts of tricuspid annular mechanics, key device and procedural implications, and highlight current knowledge gaps for future consideration.

Impact of tricuspid annular size reduction on right ventricular function, geometry and strain

OBJECTIVES

Restrictive tricuspid annuloplasty is a clinically accepted approach to treat functional tricuspid regurgitation. We set out to investigate the effect of varying degrees of tricuspid annular reduction on the right ventricular (RV) function, geometry and strain.

METHODS

Eight, healthy sheep (45 ± 4 kg) had 6 sonomicrometry crystals implanted around the tricuspid annulus and 20 onto the epicardium of the right ventricle defining 3 free wall regions: basal, mid and lower. A polypropylene annuloplasty suture was placed around the tricuspid annulus and externalized to an epicardial tourniquet. Simultaneous echocardiographic, haemodynamic and sonomicrometry data were acquired at baseline and during 5 consecutive annular reduction steps (TAR 1-5) with successive (5-7 mm) suture cinching. RV free wall circumferential, longitudinal and areal cardiac and interventional strains, RV radius of curvature (ROC), cross-sectional area and tricuspid annular dimensions were calculated from 3-dimensional crystal coordinates.

RESULTS

TAR 1-5 resulted in 19 ± 15%, 35 ± 15%, 51 ± 15%, 60 ± 15% and 68 ± 13% tricuspid annular area reduction, respectively. TAR 1 and 2 had minimal influence on the RV function, RV-ROC and strains. TAR 4 and 5 decreased RV-ROC in basal and mid-regions, but reduced the RV cross-sectional area change (from 19 ± 4% at baseline to 14 ± 3% and 13 ± 2%, respectively, P < 0.001) and circumferential and areal strains. TAR 3 significantly decreased free wall RV-ROC from 44.0 ± 1.5 to 42.6 ± 2.4 mm P < 0.001 at the RV base but maintained the regional ventricular function and strains.

CONCLUSIONS

In healthy ovine hearts, a tricuspid annular area reduction of ∼50% provides optimal conditions for reducing RV-ROC while maintaining regional RV function and strain patterns.