Assembly of bacterial cell division protein FtsZ into dynamic biomolecular condensates

Versatility of vimentin assemblies: From filaments to biomolecular condensates and back

Cytoskeletal structures shape and confer resistance to cells. The intermediate filament protein vimentin forms versatile structures that play key roles in cytoskeletal crosstalk, in the integration of cellular responses to a variety of external and internal cues, and in the defense against stress. Such multifaceted roles can be fulfilled thanks to the vast variety of vimentin proteoforms, which in turn arise from the combinations of a myriad of tightly regulated posttranslational modifications. Diverse vimentin proteoforms will differentially shape its polymeric assemblies, underlying vimentin ability to organize in filaments, bundles, squiggles, droplets, cell surface-bound and/or various secreted forms. Interestingly, certain vimentin dots or droplets have been lately categorized as biomolecular condensates. Biomolecular condensates are phase-separated membraneless structures that are critical for the organization of cellular components and play important roles in pathophysiology. Recent findings have unveiled the importance of low complexity sequence domains in vimentin filament assembly. Moreover, several oxidants trigger the transition of vimentin filaments into phase-separated biomolecular condensates, a reversible process that may provide clues on the role of condensates as seeds for filament formation. Revisiting previous results in the light of recent knowledge prompts the hypothesis that vimentin condensates could play a role in traffic of filament precursors, cytoskeletal crosstalk and cellular responses to stress. Deciphering the "vimentin posttranslational modification code", that is, the structure-function relationships of vimentin proteoforms, constitutes a major challenge to understand the regulation of vimentin behavior and its multiple personalities. This will contribute to unveil essential cellular mechanisms and foster novel opportunities for drug discovery.

Evidence for biomolecular condensates formed by the Escherichia coli MatP protein in spatiotemporal regulation of the bacterial cell division cycle

An increasing number of proteins involved in bacterial cell cycle events have been recently shown to form biomolecular condensates important for their functions that may play a role in development of antibiotic-tolerant persister cells. Here we report that the E. coli chromosomal Ter macrodomain organizer MatP, a division site selection protein coordinating chromosome segregation with cell division, formed biomolecular condensates in crowding cytomimetic systems preferentially localized at the membrane of microfluidics droplets. Condensates were antagonized and partially dislodged from the membrane by DNA sequences recognized by MatP (matS), which partitioned into them. FtsZ, core component of the division machinery previously described to phase-separate, unexpectedly enhanced MatP condensation. Our biophysical analyses uncovered direct interaction between both proteins, disrupted by matS. This may have potential implications for midcell FtsZ ring positioning by the Ter-linkage, which comprises MatP and two other proteins bridging the canonical MatP-FtsZ interaction. FtsZ/MatP condensates interconverted with GTP-triggered bundles, suggesting that local fluctuations of GTP concentrations may regulate FtsZ/MatP phase separation. Consistent with discrete MatP foci previously reported in cells, phase separation might influence MatP-dependent chromosome organization, spatiotemporal coordination of cytokinesis and DNA segregation, which is potentially relevant for cell entry into dormant states that can resist antibiotic treatments.

Evidence for biomolecular condensates of MatP in spatiotemporal regulation of the bacterial cell division cycle

An increasing number of proteins involved in bacterial cell cycle events have been recently shown to undergo phase separation. The resulting biomolecular condensates play an important role in cell cycle protein function and may be involved in development of persister cells tolerant to antibiotics. Here we report that the E. coli chromosomal Ter macrodomain organizer MatP, a division site selection protein implicated in the coordination of chromosome segregation with cell division, forms biomolecular condensates in cytomimetic systems. These condensates are favored by crowding and preferentially localize at the membrane of microfluidics droplets, a behavior probably mediated by MatP-lipid binding. Condensates are negatively regulated and partially dislodged from the membrane by DNA sequences recognized by MatP ( matS ), which partition into them. Unexpectedly, MatP condensation is enhanced by FtsZ, a core component of the division machinery previously described to undergo phase separation. Our biophysical analyses uncover a direct interaction between the two proteins, disrupted by matS sequences. This binding might have implications for FtsZ ring positioning at mid-cell by the Ter linkage, which comprises MatP and two other proteins that bridge the canonical MatP/FtsZ interaction. FtsZ/MatP condensates interconvert with bundles in response to GTP addition, providing additional levels of regulation. Consistent with discrete foci reported in cells, MatP biomolecular condensates may facilitate MatP's role in chromosome organization and spatiotemporal regulation of cytokinesis and DNA segregation. Moreover, sequestration of MatP in these membraneless compartments, with or without FtsZ, could promote cell entry into dormant states that are able to survive antibiotic treatments.

Macromolecular Crowding, Phase Separation, and Homeostasis in the Orchestration of Bacterial Cellular Functions

Macromolecular crowding affects the activity of proteins and functional macromolecular complexes in all cells, including bacteria. Crowding, together with physicochemical parameters such as pH, ionic strength, and the energy status, influences the structure of the cytoplasm and thereby indirectly macromolecular function. Notably, crowding also promotes the formation of biomolecular condensates by phase separation, initially identified in eukaryotic cells but more recently discovered to play key functions in bacteria. Bacterial cells require a variety of mechanisms to maintain physicochemical homeostasis, in particular in environments with fluctuating conditions, and the formation of biomolecular condensates is emerging as one such mechanism. In this work, we connect physicochemical homeostasis and macromolecular crowding with the formation and function of biomolecular condensates in the bacterial cell and compare the supramolecular structures found in bacteria with those of eukaryotic cells. We focus on the effects of crowding and phase separation on the control of bacterial chromosome replication, segregation, and cell division, and we discuss the contribution of biomolecular condensates to bacterial cell fitness and adaptation to environmental stress.

Insights into the assembly and regulation of the bacterial divisome

The ability to split one cell into two is fundamental to all life, and many bacteria can accomplish this feat several times per hour with high accuracy. Most bacteria call on an ancient homologue of tubulin, called FtsZ, to localize and organize the cell division machinery, the divisome, into a ring-like structure at the cell midpoint. The divisome includes numerous other proteins, often including an actin homologue (FtsA), that interact with each other at the cytoplasmic membrane. Once assembled, the protein complexes that comprise the dynamic divisome coordinate membrane constriction with synthesis of a division septum, but only after overcoming checkpoints mediated by specialized protein-protein interactions. In this Review, we summarize the most recent evidence showing how the divisome proteins of Escherichia coli assemble at the cell midpoint, interact with each other and regulate activation of septum synthesis. We also briefly discuss the potential of divisome proteins as novel antibiotic targets.

RNase E biomolecular condensates stimulate PNPase activity

Bacterial Ribonucleoprotein bodies (BR-bodies) play an essential role in organizing RNA degradation via phase separation in the cytoplasm of bacteria. BR-bodies mediate multi-step mRNA decay through the concerted activity of the endoribonuclease RNase E coupled with the 3'-5' exoribonuclease Polynucleotide Phosphorylase (PNPase). In vivo, studies indicated that the loss of PNPase recruitment into BR-bodies led to a significant build-up of RNA decay intermediates in Caulobacter crescentus. However, it remained unclear whether this is due to a lack of colocalized PNPase and RNase E within BR-bodies or whether PNPase's activity is stimulated within the BR-body. We reconstituted RNase E's C-terminal domain with PNPase towards a minimal BR-body in vitro to distinguish these possibilities. We found that PNPase's catalytic activity is accelerated when colocalized within the RNase E biomolecular condensates, partly due to scaffolding and mass action effects. In contrast, disruption of the RNase E-PNPase protein-protein interaction led to a loss of PNPase recruitment into the RNase E condensates and a loss of ribonuclease rate enhancement. We also found that RNase E's unique biomolecular condensate environment tuned PNPase's substrate specificity for poly(A) over poly(U). Intriguingly, a critical PNPase reactant, phosphate, reduces RNase E phase separation both in vitro and in vivo. This regulatory feedback ensures that under limited phosphate resources, PNPase activity is enhanced by recruitment into RNase E's biomolecular condensates.

Bacterial division ring stabilizing ZapA versus destabilizing SlmA modulate FtsZ switching between biomolecular condensates and polymers

Cytokinesis is a fundamental process for bacterial survival and proliferation, involving the formation of a ring by filaments of the GTPase FtsZ, spatio-temporally regulated through the coordinated action of several factors. The mechanisms of this regulation remain largely unsolved, but the inhibition of FtsZ polymerization by the nucleoid occlusion factor SlmA and filament stabilization by the widely conserved cross-linking protein ZapA are known to play key roles. It was recently described that FtsZ, SlmA and its target DNA sequences (SlmA-binding sequence (SBS)) form phase-separated biomolecular condensates, a type of structure associated with cellular compartmentalization and resistance to stress. Using biochemical reconstitution and orthogonal biophysical approaches, we show that FtsZ-SlmA-SBS condensates captured ZapA in crowding conditions and when encapsulated inside cell-like microfluidics microdroplets. We found that, through non-competitive binding, the nucleotide-dependent FtsZ condensate/polymer interconversion was regulated by the ZapA/SlmA ratio. This suggests a highly concentration-responsive tuning of the interconversion that favours FtsZ polymer stabilization by ZapA under conditions mimicking intracellular crowding. These results highlight the importance of biomolecular condensates as concentration hubs for bacterial division factors, which can provide clues to their role in cell function and bacterial survival of stress conditions, such as those generated by antibiotic treatment.

Lipid Surfaces and Glutamate Anions Enhance Formation of Dynamic Biomolecular Condensates Containing Bacterial Cell Division Protein FtsZ and Its DNA-Bound Regulator SlmA

Dynamic biomolecular condensates formed by liquid-liquid phase separation can regulate the spatial and temporal organization of proteins, thus modulating their functional activity in cells. Previous studies showed that the cell division protein FtsZ from Escherichia coli formed dynamic phase-separated condensates with nucleoprotein complexes containing the FtsZ spatial regulator SlmA under crowding conditions, with potential implications for condensate-mediated spatiotemporal control of FtsZ activity in cell division. In the present study, we assessed formation of these condensates in the presence of lipid surfaces and glutamate ions to better approximate the E. coli intracellular environment. We found that potassium glutamate substantially promoted the formation of FtsZ-containing condensates when compared to potassium chloride in crowded solutions. These condensates accumulated on supported lipid bilayers and eventually fused, resulting in a time-dependent increase in the droplet size. Moreover, the accumulated condensates were dynamic, capturing protein from the external phase. FtsZ partitioned into the condensates at the lipid surface only in its guanosine diphosphate (GDP) form, regardless of whether it came from FtsZ polymer disassembly upon guanosine triphosphate (GTP) exhaustion. These results provide insights into the behavior of these GTP-responsive condensates in minimal membrane systems, which suggest how these membraneless assemblies may tune critical bacterial division events during the cell cycle.

In vitro assembly, positioning and contraction of a division ring in minimal cells

Constructing a minimal machinery for autonomous self-division of synthetic cells is a major goal of bottom-up synthetic biology. One paradigm has been the E. coli divisome, with the MinCDE protein system guiding assembly and positioning of a presumably contractile ring based on FtsZ and its membrane adaptor FtsA. Here, we demonstrate the full in vitro reconstitution of this machinery consisting of five proteins within lipid vesicles, allowing to observe the following sequence of events in real time: 1) Assembly of an isotropic filamentous FtsZ network, 2) its condensation into a ring-like structure, along with pole-to-pole mode selection of Min oscillations resulting in equatorial positioning, and 3) onset of ring constriction, deforming the vesicles from spherical shape. Besides demonstrating these essential features, we highlight the importance of decisive experimental factors, such as macromolecular crowding. Our results provide an exceptional showcase of the emergence of cell division in a minimal system, and may represent a step towards developing a synthetic cell.

Getting Closer to Decrypting the Phase Transitions of Bacterial Biomolecules

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) of biomolecules has emerged as a new paradigm in cell biology, and the process is one proposed mechanism for the formation of membraneless organelles (MLOs). Bacterial cells have only recently drawn strong interest in terms of studies on both liquid-to-liquid and liquid-to-solid phase transitions. It seems that these processes drive the formation of prokaryotic cellular condensates that resemble eukaryotic MLOs. In this review, we present an overview of the key microbial biomolecules that undergo LLPS, as well as the formation and organization of biomacromolecular condensates within the intracellular space. We also discuss the current challenges in investigating bacterial biomacromolecular condensates. Additionally, we highlight a summary of recent knowledge about the participation of bacterial biomolecules in a phase transition and provide some new in silico analyses that can be helpful for further investigations.

Regulation of the activity of bacterial histidine kinase PleC by the scaffolding protein PodJ

Scaffolding proteins can customize the response of signaling networks to support cell development and behaviors. PleC is a bifunctional histidine kinase whose signaling activity coordinates asymmetric cell division to yield a motile swarmer cell and a stalked cell in the gram-negative bacterium Caulobacter crescentus. Past studies have shown that PleC’s switch in activity from kinase to phosphatase correlates with a change in its subcellular localization pattern from diffuse to localized at the new cell pole. Here we investigated how the bacterial scaffolding protein PodJ regulates the subcellular positioning and activity of PleC. We reconstituted the PleC-PodJ signaling complex through both heterologous expressions in Escherichia coli and in vitro studies. In vitro, PodJ phase separates as a biomolecular condensate that recruits PleC and inhibits its kinase activity. We also constructed an in vivo PleC-CcaS chimeric histidine kinase reporter assay and demonstrated using this method that PodJ leverages its intrinsically disordered region to bind to PleC’s PAS sensory domain and regulate PleC-CcaS signaling. Regulation of the PleC-CcaS was most robust when PodJ was concentrated at the cell poles and was dependent on the allosteric coupling between PleC-CcaS’s PAS sensory domain and its downstream histidine kinase domain. In conclusion, our in vitro biochemical studies suggest that PodJ phase separation may be coupled to changes in PleC enzymatic function. We propose that this coupling of phase separation and allosteric regulation may be a generalizable phenomenon among enzymes associated with biomolecular condensates.

FtsZ Interactions and Biomolecular Condensates as Potential Targets for New Antibiotics

FtsZ is an essential and central protein for cell division in most bacteria. Because of its ability to organize into dynamic polymers at the cell membrane and recruit other protein partners to form a “divisome”, FtsZ is a leading target in the quest for new antibacterial compounds. Strategies to potentially arrest the essential and tightly regulated cell division process include perturbing FtsZ’s ability to interact with itself and other divisome proteins. Here, we discuss the available methodologies to screen for and characterize those interactions. In addition to assays that measure protein-ligand interactions in solution, we also discuss the use of minimal membrane systems and cell-like compartments to better approximate the native bacterial cell environment and hence provide a more accurate assessment of a candidate compound’s potential in vivo effect. We particularly focus on ways to measure and inhibit under-explored interactions between FtsZ and partner proteins. Finally, we discuss recent evidence that FtsZ forms biomolecular condensates in vitro, and the potential implications of these assemblies in bacterial resistance to antibiotic treatment.

Interactions between Phase-Separated Liquids and Membrane Surfaces

Liquid-liquid phase separation has recently emerged as an important fundamental organizational phenomenon in biological settings. Most studies of biological phase separation have focused on droplets that "condense" from solution above a critical concentration, forming so-called "membraneless organelles" suspended in solution. However, membranes are ubiquitous throughout cells, and many biomolecular condensates interact with membrane surfaces. Such membrane-associated phase-separated systems range from clusters of integral or peripheral membrane proteins in the plane of the membrane to free, spherical droplets wetting membrane surfaces to droplets containing small lipid vesicles. In this review, we consider phase-separated liquids that interact with membrane surfaces and we discuss the consequences of those interactions. The physical properties of distinct liquid phases in contact with bilayers can reshape the membrane, and liquid-liquid phase separation can construct membrane-associated protein structures, modulate their function, and organize collections of lipid vesicles dynamically. We summarize the common phenomena that arise in these systems of liquid phases and membranes.