Detection of ligand-induced CNTF receptor dimers in living cells by fluorescence cross correlation spectroscopy

Resolving Membrane Protein-Protein Interactions in Live Cells with Pulsed Interleaved Excitation Fluorescence Cross-Correlation Spectroscopy

The cell plasma membrane (PM) contains thousands of proteins that sense and respond to the outside environment. These proteins have evolved sensitivity to a wide variety of physical and chemical signals and act as a delivery system across the PM. Membrane proteins are critical for information flow and decision making in the cell and thus are important targets in drug development. A critical aspect of membrane protein function is the way they interact with other proteins, often through the formation of dimers or small oligomers that regulate function at the protein, cell, and organism levels. Resolving membrane protein interactions in a live cell environment is challenging because of the chemical diversity and spatial heterogeneity of the PM. In this Account, we describe a fluorescence technique called pulsed interleaved excitation fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (PIE-FCCS) that is ideally suited to quantify membrane associations in live cells. PIE-FCCS is a two-color fluorescence fluctuation method that can simultaneously measure the concentration, mobility, proximity, and oligomerization state of membrane proteins in situ. It has several advantages over two related approaches, single-molecule tracking (SMT) and Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), including that it measures all of the properties listed above in a single measurement. Another advantage is that PIE-FCCS is most sensitive at the physiological expression levels for many membrane proteins rather than the very low or high levels typical in other techniques. Here, we review the history of FCCS as it has been applied to study membrane protein interactions in cells. We also describe PIE-FCCS and the advantages it has over biochemical approaches like coimmunoprecipitation (co-IP) and proximity ligation assays (PLA). Finally, we review two classes of membrane proteins that have been studied with FCCS and PIE-FCCS: receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) and G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). For RTKs, ligand induced dimerization directly regulates the catalytic activity of the kinase, but higher order oligomerization and ligand-independent dimerization can complicate this historically simple paradigm. PIE-FCCS data have resolved a low population of EGFR dimers under basal conditions and assembly into multimers when stimulated with ligand. While GPCRs function primarily as monomers, dimerization has been hypothesized to regulate function for some receptors. PIE-FCCS data have established the dimerization potential of rhodopsin at low densities and were critical for the discovery of a novel dimerization interface in human cone opsins. This Account describes the how FCCS and PIE-FCCS can reveal the details of quaternary interactions in each of these receptor systems.

Quantifying membrane protein oligomerization with fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (FCCS) is an advanced fluorescence technique that can quantify protein-protein interactions in vivo. Due to the dynamic, heterogeneous nature of the membrane, special considerations must be made to interpret FCCS data accurately. In this study, we describe a method to quantify the oligomerization of membrane proteins tagged with two commonly used fluorescent probes, mCherry (mCH) and enhanced green (eGFP) fluorescent proteins. A mathematical model is described that relates the relative cross-correlation value (f_c) to the degree of oligomerization. This treatment accounts for mismatch in the confocal volumes, combinatoric effects of using two fluorescent probes, and the presence of non-fluorescent probes. Using this model, we calculate a ladder of f_c values which can be used to determine the oligomer state of membrane proteins from live-cell experimental data. Additionally, a probabilistic mathematical simulation is described to resolve the affinity of different dimeric and oligomeric protein controls.

Dynamics and interaction of interleukin-4 receptor subunits in living cells

It has long been established that dimerization of Interleukin-4 receptor (IL-4R) subunits is a pivotal step for JAK/STAT signal transduction. However, ligand-induced complex formation at the surface of living cells has been challenging to observe. Here we report an experimental assay employing trisNTA dyes for orthogonal, external labeling of eGFP-tagged receptor constructs that allows the quantification of receptor heterodimerization by dual-color fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy. Fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy analysis at the plasma membrane shows that IL-4R subunit dimerization is indeed a strictly ligand-induced process. Under conditions of saturating cytokine occupancy, we determined intramembrane dissociation constants (K(d,2D)) of 180 and 480 receptors per μm(2) for the type-2 complexes IL-4:IL-4Rα/IL-13Rα1 and IL-13:IL-13Rα1/IL-4Rα, respectively. For the lower affinity type-1 complex IL-4:IL-4Rα/IL-2Rγ, we estimated a K(d,2D) of ∼1000 receptors per μm(2). The receptor densities required for effective dimerization thus exceed the typical, average expression levels by several orders of magnitude. In addition, we find that all three receptor subunits accumulate rapidly within a subpopulation of early sorting and recycling endosomes stably anchored just beneath the plasma membrane (cortical endosomes, CEs). The receptors, as well as labeled IL-4 and trisNTA ligands are specifically trafficked into CEs by a constitutive internalization mechanism. This may compensate for the inherent weak affinities that govern ligand-induced receptor dimerization at the plasma membrane. Consistently, activated receptors are also concentrated at the CEs. Our observations thus suggest that receptor trafficking may play an important role for the regulation of IL-4R-mediated JAK/STAT signaling.

Recent applications of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy in live systems

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is a widely used technique in biophysics and has helped address many questions in the life sciences. It provides important advantages compared to other fluorescence and biophysical methods. Its single molecule sensitivity allows measuring proteins within biological samples at physiological concentrations without the need of overexpression. It provides quantitative data on concentrations, diffusion coefficients, molecular transport and interactions even in live organisms. And its reliance on simple fluorescence intensity and its fluctuations makes it widely applicable. In this review we focus on applications of FCS in live samples, with an emphasis on work in the last 5 years, in the hope to provide an overview of the present capabilities of FCS to address biologically relevant questions.

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy analysis of serotonin, adrenergic, muscarinic, and dopamine receptor dimerization: the oligomer number puzzle

The issue of G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) oligomer status has not been resolved. Although many studies have provided evidence in favor of receptor-receptor interactions, there is no consensus as to the exact oligomer size of class A GPCRs. Previous studies have reported monomers, dimers, tetramers, and higher-order oligomers. In the present study, this issue was examined using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) with photon counting histogram (PCH) analysis, a sensitive method for monitoring diffusion and oligomer size of plasma membrane proteins. Six different class A GPCRs were selected from the serotonin (5-HT2A), adrenergic (α1b-AR and β2-AR), muscarinic (M1 and M2), and dopamine (D1) receptor families. Each GPCR was C-terminally labeled with green fluorescent protein (GFP) or yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) and expressed in human embryonic kidney 293 cells. FCS provided plasma membrane diffusion coefficients on the order of 7.5 × 10(-9) cm(2)/s. PCH molecular brightness analysis was used to determine the GPCR oligomer size. Known monomeric (CD-86) and dimeric (CD-28) receptors with GFP and YFP tags were used as controls to determine the molecular brightness of monomers and dimers. PCH analysis of fluorescence-tagged GPCRs revealed molecular brightness values that were twice the monomeric controls and similar to the dimeric controls. Reduced χ(2) analyses of the PCH data best fit a model for a homogeneous population of homodimers, without tetramers or higher-order oligomers. The homodimer configuration was unaltered by agonist treatment and was stable over a 10-fold range of receptor expression level. The results of this study demonstrate that biogenic amine receptors freely diffusing within the plasma membrane are predominantly homodimers.

Dual-color fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy with continuous laser excitation in a confocal setup

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy evaluates local signal fluctuations arising from stochastic movements of fluorescent particles in solution. The measured fluctuating signal is correlated in time and analyzed with appropriate model functions containing the parameters that describe the underlying molecular behavior. The dual-color extension, fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (FCCS) allows for a comparison between spectrally well-separated channels to extract codiffusion events that reflect interactions between differently labeled molecules. In addition to solution measurements, FCCS can be applied with subcellular resolution and is therefore a very promising approach for a quantitative biochemical assessment of molecular networks in living cells. To derive thermodynamic and kinetic reaction parameters, the influence of a number of other factors like background noise, illumination intensity profiles, photophysical processes, and cross talk between the channels have to be treated. Here, we provide a roadmap to derive binding reaction data with dual-color FCCS using continuous wave laser excitation, as it is now accessible with many state-of-the-art confocal microscopes.

Oligomer size of the serotonin 5-hydroxytryptamine 2C (5-HT2C) receptor revealed by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy with photon counting histogram analysis: evidence for homodimers without monomers or tetramers

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) and photon counting histogram (PCH) are techniques with single molecule sensitivity that are well suited for examining the biophysical properties of protein complexes in living cells. In the present study, FCS and PCH were applied to determine the diffusion coefficient and oligomeric size of G-protein-coupled receptors. FCS was used to record fluctuations in fluorescence intensity arising from fluorescence-tagged 5-hydroxytryptamine 2C (5-HT(2C)) receptors diffusing within the plasma membrane of HEK293 cells and rat hippocampal neurons. Autocorrelation analysis yielded diffusion coefficients ranging from 0.8 to 1.2 μm(2)/s for fluorescence-tagged receptors. Because the molecular brightness of a fluorescent protein is directly proportional to the number of fluorescent proteins traveling together within a protein complex, it can be used to determine the oligomeric size of the protein complex. FCS and PCH analysis of fluorescence-tagged 5-HT(2C) receptors provided molecular brightness values that were twice that of GFP and YFP monomeric controls, similar to a dimeric GFP control, and unaltered by 5-HT. Bimolecular fluorescence complementation of the N- and C-terminal halves of YFP attached to 5-HT(2C) receptors was observed in endoplasmic reticulum/Golgi and plasma membranes with a brightness equal to monomeric YFP. When GFP-tagged 5-HT(2C) receptors were co-expressed with a large excess of untagged, non-fluorescent 5-HT(2C) receptors, the molecular brightness was reduced by half. PCH analysis of the FCS data were best described by a one-component dimer model without monomers or tetramers. Therefore, it is concluded that 5-HT(2C) receptors freely diffusing within the plasma membrane are dimeric.

Factors affecting the quantification of biomolecular interactions by fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (FCCS) is used to determine interactions and dissociation constants (K(d)s) of biomolecules. The determination of a K(d) depends on the accurate measurement of the auto- and cross-correlation function (ACF and CCF) amplitudes. In the case of complete binding, the ratio of the CCF/ACF amplitudes is expected to be 1. However, measurements performed on tandem fluorescent proteins (FPs), in which two different FPs are linked, yield CCF/ACF amplitude ratios of ~0.5 or less for different FCCS schemes. We use single wavelength FCCS and pulsed interleaved excitation FCCS to measure various tandem FPs constituted of different red and green FPs and determine the causes for this suboptimal ratio. The main causes for the reduced CCF/ACF amplitude ratio are differences in observation volumes for the different labels, the existence of dark FPs due to maturation problems, photobleaching, and to a lesser extent Förster (or fluorescence) resonance energy transfer between the labels. We deduce the fraction of nonfluorescent proteins for EGFP, mRFP, and mCherry as well as the differences in observation volumes. We use this information to correct FCCS measurements of the interaction of Cdc42, a small Rho-GTPase, with its effector IQGAP1 in live cell measurements to obtain a label-independent value for the K(d).

A modified FCCS procedure applied to Ly49A-MHC class I cis-interaction studies in cell membranes

The activity of natural killer (NK) cells is regulated by a fine-tuned balance between activating and inhibitory receptors. Dual-color fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (FCCS) was used to directly demonstrate a so-called cis-interaction between a member of the inhibitory NK cell receptor family Ly49 (Ly49A), and its ligand, the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I, within the plasma membrane of the same cell. By a refined FCCS model, calibrated by positive and negative control experiments on cells from the same lymphoid cell line, concentrations and diffusion coefficients of free and interacting proteins could be determined on a collection of cells. Using the intrinsic intercellular variation of their expression levels for titration, it was found that the fraction of Ly49A receptors bound in cis increase with increasing amounts of MHC class I ligand. This increase shows a tendency to be more abrupt than for a diffusion limited - three dimensional bimolecular reaction, which most likely reflects the two-dimensional confinement of the reaction. For the Ly49A- MHC class I interaction it indicates that within a critical concentration range the local concentration level of MHC class I can provide a distinct regulation mechanism of the NK cell activity.

How to obtain labeled proteins and what to do with them

We review new and established methods for the chemical modification of proteins in living cells and highlight recent applications. The review focuses on tag-mediated protein labeling methods, such as the tetracysteine tag and SNAP-tag, and new developments in this field such as intracellular labeling with lipoic acid ligase. Recent promising advances in the incorporation of unnatural amino acids into proteins are also briefly discussed. We describe new tools using tag-mediated labeling methods including the super-resolution microscopy of tagged proteins, the study of the interactions of proteins and protein domains, the subcellular targeting of synthetic ion sensors, and the generation of new semisynthetic metabolite sensors. We conclude with a view on necessary future developments, with one example being the selective labeling of non-tagged, native proteins in complex protein mixtures.

Assembly and activation of neurotrophic factor receptor complexes

Neurotrophic factors play important roles in the development and function of both neuronal and glial elements of the central and peripheral nervous systems. Their functional diversity is in part based on their ability to interact with alternative complexes of receptor molecules. This review focuses on our current understanding of the mechanisms that govern the assembly and activation of neurotrophic factor receptor complexes. The realization that many, if not the majority, of these complexes exist in a preassembled form at the plasma membrane has forced the revision of classical ligand-mediated oligomerization models, and led to the discovery of novel mechanisms of receptor activation and generation of signaling diversity which are likely to be shared by many different classes of receptors.