Differential binding of monovalent cations to KcsA: Deciphering the mechanisms of potassium channel selectivity

pH-induced conformational changes in the selectivity filter of a potassium channel lead to alterations in its selectivity and permeation properties

The Selectivity Filter (SF) in tetrameric K+ channels, has a highly conserved sequence, TVGYG, at the extracellular entry to the channel pore region. There, the backbone carbonyl oxygens from the SF residues, create a stack of K+ binding sites where dehydrated K+ binds to induce a conductive conformation of the SF. This increases intersubunit interactions and confers a higher stability to the channel against thermal denaturation. Indeed, the fit of dehydrated K+ to its binding sites is fundamental to define K+ selectivity, an important feature of these channels. Nonetheless, the SF conformation can be modified by different effector molecules. Such conformational plasticity opposes selectivity, as the SF departs from the "induced-fit" conformation required for K+ recognition. Here we studied the KirBac1.1 channel, a prokaryotic analog of inwardly rectifying K+ channels, confronted to permeant (K+) and non-permeant (Na+) cations. This channel is pH-dependent and transits from the open state at neutral pH to the closed state at acidic pH. KirBac1.1 has the orthodox TVGYG sequence at the SF and thus, its behavior should resemble that of K+-selective channels. However, we found that when at neutral pH, KirBac1.1 is only partly K+ selective and permeates this ion causing the characteristic "induced-fit" phenomenon in the SF conformation. However, it also conducts Na+ with a mechanism of ion passage reminiscent of Na+ channels, i.e., through a wide-open pore, without increasing intersubunit interactions within the tetrameric channel. Conversely, when at acidic pH, the channel completely loses selectivity and conducts both K+ and Na+ similarly, increasing intersubunit interactions through an apparent "induced-fit"-like mechanism for the two ions. These observations underline that KirBac1.1 SF is able to adopt different conformations leading to changes in selectivity and in the mechanism of ion passage.

Steady-state and time-resolved fluorescent methodologies to characterize the conformational landscape of the selectivity filter of K+ channels

A variety of equilibrium and non-equilibrium methods have been used in a multidisciplinary approach to study the conformational landscape associated with the binding of different cations to the pore of potassium channels. These binding processes, and the conformational changes resulting therefrom, modulate the functional properties of such integral membrane properties, revealing these permeant and blocking cations as true effectors of such integral membrane proteins. KcsA, a prototypic K+ channel from Streptomyces lividans, has been extensively characterized in this regard. Here, we revise several fluorescence-based approaches to monitor cation binding under different experimental conditions in diluted samples, analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of each approach. These studies have contributed to explain the selectivity, conduction, and inactivation properties of K+ channels at the molecular level, together with the allosteric communication between the two gates that control the ion channel flux, and how they are modulated by lipids.

Conformational Dynamic Studies of Prokaryotic Potassium Channels Explored by Homo-FRET Methodologies

Fluorescence techniques have been widely used to shed light over the structure-function relationship of potassium channels for the last 40-50 years. In this chapter, we describe how a Förster resonance energy transfer between identical fluorophores (homo-FRET) approach can be applied to study the gating behavior of the prokaryotic channel KcsA. Two different gates have been described to control the K+ flux across the channel's pore, the helix-bundle crossing and the selectivity filter, located at the opposite sides of the channel transmembrane section. Both gates can be studied individually or by using a double-reporter system. Due to its homotetrameric structural arrangement, KcsA presents a high degree of symmetry that fulfills the first requisite to calculate intersubunit distances through this technique. The results obtained through this work have helped to uncover the conformational plasticity of the selectivity filter under different experimental conditions and the importance of its allosteric coupling to the opening of the activation (inner) gate. This biophysical approach usually requires low protein concentration and presents high sensitivity and reproducibility, complementing the high-resolution structural information provided by X-ray crystallography, cryo-EM, and NMR studies.

Alkali metal cations modulate the geometry of different binding sites in HCN4 selectivity filter for permeation or block

Hyperpolarization-activated cyclic-nucleotide gated (HCN) channels are important for timing biological processes like heartbeat and neuronal firing. Their weak cation selectivity is determined by a filter domain with only two binding sites for K+ and one for Na+. The latter acts as a weak blocker, which is released in combination with a dynamic widening of the filter by K+ ions, giving rise to a mixed K+/Na+ current. Here, we apply molecular dynamics simulations to systematically investigate the interactions of five alkali metal cations with the filter of the open HCN4 pore. Simulations recapitulate experimental data like a low Li+ permeability, considerable Rb+ conductance, a block by Cs+ as well as a punch through of Cs+ ions at high negative voltages. Differential binding of the cation species in specific filter sites is associated with structural adaptations of filter residues. This gives rise to ion coordination by a cation-characteristic number of oxygen atoms from the filter backbone and solvent. This ion/protein interplay prevents Li+, but not Na+, from entry into and further passage through the filter. The site equivalent to S3 in K+ channels emerges as a preferential binding and presumably blocking site for Cs+. Collectively, the data suggest that the weak cation selectivity of HCN channels and their block by Cs+ are determined by restrained cation-generated rearrangements of flexible filter residues.

Anionic Phospholipids Shift the Conformational Equilibrium of the Selectivity Filter in the KcsA Channel to the Conductive Conformation: Predicted Consequences on Inactivation

Here, we report an allosteric effect of an anionic phospholipid on a model K⁺ channel, KcsA. The anionic lipid in mixed detergent-lipid micelles specifically induces a change in the conformational equilibrium of the channel selectivity filter (SF) only when the channel inner gate is in the open state. Such change consists of increasing the affinity of the channel for K⁺, stabilizing a conductive-like form by maintaining a high ion occupancy in the SF. The process is highly specific in several aspects: First, lipid modifies the binding of K⁺, but not that of Na⁺, which remains unperturbed, ruling out a merely electrostatic phenomenon of cation attraction. Second, no lipid effects are observed when a zwitterionic lipid, instead of an anionic one, is present in the micelles. Lastly, the effects of the anionic lipid are only observed at pH 4.0, when the inner gate of KcsA is open. Moreover, the effect of the anionic lipid on K⁺ binding to the open channel closely emulates the K⁺ binding behaviour of the non-inactivating E71A and R64A mutant proteins. This suggests that the observed increase in K⁺ affinity caused by the bound anionic lipid should result in protecting the channel against inactivation.

A bottom-up approach to the ion recognition mechanism of K+ channels from laser spectroscopy of hydrated partial peptide-alkali metal ion complexes

K⁺ channels allow selective permeation of K⁺, but not physiologically abundant Na⁺, at almost diffusion limit rates. The conduction mechanism of K⁺ channels is still controversial, with experimental and computation studies supporting two distinct conduction mechanisms: either with or without water inside the channel. Here, we employ a bottom-up approach on hydrated alkali metal complexes of a model peptide of K⁺ channels, Ac-Tyr-NHMe, to characterize metal-peptide, metal-water, and water-peptide interactions that govern the selectivity of K⁺ channels at a molecular level. Both the extension to the series of alkali metal ions and to temperature-dependent studies (approaching physiological values) have revealed the clear difference between permeable and non-permeable ions in the spectral features of the ion complexes. Furthermore, the impact of hydration is discussed in relation to the K⁺ channels by comparisons of the non-hydrated and hydrated complexes.

Molecular Events behind the Selectivity and Inactivation Properties of Model NaK-Derived Ion Channels

Y55W mutants of non-selective NaK and partly K⁺-selective NaK2K channels have been used to explore the conformational dynamics at the pore region of these channels as they interact with either Na⁺ or K⁺. A major conclusion is that these channels exhibit a remarkable pore conformational flexibility. Homo-FRET measurements reveal a large change in W55–W55 intersubunit distances, enabling the selectivity filter (SF) to admit different species, thus, favoring poor or no selectivity. Depending on the cation, these channels exhibit wide-open conformations of the SF in Na⁺, or tight induced-fit conformations in K⁺, most favored in the four binding sites containing NaK2K channels. Such conformational flexibility seems to arise from an altered pattern of restricting interactions between the SF and the protein scaffold behind it. Additionally, binding experiments provide clues to explain such poor selectivity. Compared to the K⁺-selective KcsA channel, these channels lack a high affinity K⁺ binding component and do not collapse in Na⁺. Thus, they cannot properly select K⁺ over competing cations, nor reject Na⁺ by collapsing, as K⁺-selective channels do. Finally, these channels do not show C-type inactivation, likely because their submillimolar K⁺ binding affinities prevent an efficient K⁺ loss from their SF, thus favoring permanently open channel states.

Double Ion Trap Laser Spectroscopy of Alkali Metal Ion Complexes with a Partial Peptide of the Selectivity Filter in K+ Channels─Temperature Effect and Barrier for Conformational Conversions

Potassium ion channels selectively permeate K⁺, as well as Rb⁺ and Cs⁺ to some degree, while excluding Na⁺ and Li⁺. Conformations of alkali metal complexes of Ac-Tyr-NHMe, a model peptide of the selectivity filter in a K⁺ channel, were previously found to correlate with the permeability of alkali metal ions to a K⁺ channel by cold ion trap infrared spectroscopy. With an additional temperature-controlled ion trap, we examined the conformations of the alkali metal complexes, allowing the ions to collide with a He buffer gas at different temperatures, prior to spectroscopic investigation. The conformational distribution of the K⁺-peptide complex shows the most significant variation with temperature, which suggests that this complex has more flexibility when complexed with K⁺ and suggests lower barrier heights than other metal-peptide complexes. The variability of the conformational distribution with temperature for the ions follows the same order of ion permeability of a K⁺ channel. This work demonstrates that the additional temperature-controlled ion trap is a powerful tool to explore the conformational landscape of flexible molecular systems.

Thermodynamics of ion binding and occupancy in potassium channels

Potassium channels modulate various cellular functions through efficient and selective conduction of K⁺ ions. The mechanism of ion conduction in potassium channels has recently emerged as a topic of debate. Crystal structures of potassium channels show four K⁺ ions bound to adjacent binding sites in the selectivity filter, while chemical intuition and molecular modeling suggest that the direct ion contacts are unstable. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations have been instrumental in the study of conduction and gating mechanisms of ion channels. Based on MD simulations, two hypotheses have been proposed, in which the four-ion configuration is an artifact due to either averaged structures or low temperature in crystallographic experiments. The two hypotheses have been supported or challenged by different experiments. Here, MD simulations with polarizable force fields validated by ab initio calculations were used to investigate the ion binding thermodynamics. Contrary to previous beliefs, the four-ion configuration was predicted to be thermodynamically stable after accounting for the complex electrostatic interactions and dielectric screening. Polarization plays a critical role in the thermodynamic stabilities. As a result, the ion conduction likely operates through a simple single-vacancy and water-free mechanism. The simulations explained crystal structures, ion binding experiments and recent controversial mutagenesis experiments. This work provides a clear view of the mechanism underlying the efficient ion conduction and demonstrates the importance of polarization in ion channel simulations.

Polarization shapes the energy landscape of ion conduction in potassium channels.

Tetraoctylammonium, a Long Chain Quaternary Ammonium Blocker, Promotes a Noncollapsed, Resting-Like Inactivated State in KcsA

Alkylammonium salts have been used extensively to study the structure and function of potassium channels. Here, we use the hydrophobic tetraoctylammonium (TOA⁺) to shed light on the structure of the inactivated state of KcsA, a tetrameric prokaryotic potassium channel that serves as a model to its homologous eukaryotic counterparts. By the combined use of a thermal denaturation assay and the analysis of homo-Förster resonance energy transfer in a mutant channel containing a single tryptophan (W67) per subunit, we found that TOA⁺ binds the channel cavity with high affinity, either with the inner gate open or closed. Moreover, TOA⁺ bound at the cavity allosterically shifts the equilibrium of the channel's selectivity filter conformation from conductive to an inactivated-like form. The inactivated TOA⁺-KcsA complex exhibits a loss in the affinity towards permeant K⁺ at pH 7.0, when the channel is in its closed state, but maintains the two sets of K⁺ binding sites and the W67-W67 intersubunit distances characteristic of the selectivity filter in the channel resting state. Thus, the TOA⁺-bound state differs clearly from the collapsed channel state described by X-ray crystallography and claimed to represent the inactivated form of KcsA.

Modulation of Function, Structure and Clustering of K+ Channels by Lipids: Lessons Learnt from KcsA

KcsA, a prokaryote tetrameric potassium channel, was the first ion channel ever to be structurally solved at high resolution. This, along with the ease of its expression and purification, made KcsA an experimental system of choice to study structure–function relationships in ion channels. In fact, much of our current understanding on how the different channel families operate arises from earlier KcsA information. Being an integral membrane protein, KcsA is also an excellent model to study how lipid–protein and protein–protein interactions within membranes, modulate its activity and structure. In regard to the later, a variety of equilibrium and non-equilibrium methods have been used in a truly multidisciplinary effort to study the effects of lipids on the KcsA channel. Remarkably, both experimental and “in silico” data point to the relevance of specific lipid binding to two key arginine residues. These residues are at non-annular lipid binding sites on the protein and act as a common element to trigger many of the lipid effects on this channel. Thus, processes as different as the inactivation of channel currents or the assembly of clusters from individual KcsA channels, depend upon such lipid binding.

Selectivity filter modalities and rapid inactivation of the hERG1 channel

The human ether-á-go-go-related gene (hERG1) channel conducts small outward K⁺ currents that are critical for cardiomyocyte membrane repolarization. The gain-of-function mutation N629D at the outer mouth of the selectivity filter (SF) disrupts inactivation and K⁺-selective transport in hERG1, leading to arrhythmogenic phenotypes associated with long-QT syndrome. Here, we combined computational electrophysiology with Markov state model analysis to investigate how SF-level gating modalities control selective cation transport in wild-type (WT) and mutant (N629D) hERG1 variants. Starting from the recently reported cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) open-state channel structure, multiple microseconds-long molecular-dynamics (MD) trajectories were generated using different cation configurations at the filter, voltages, electrolyte concentrations, and force-field parameters. Most of the K⁺ permeation events observed in hERG1-WT simulations occurred at microsecond timescales, influenced by the spontaneous dehydration/rehydration dynamics at the filter. The SF region displayed conductive, constricted, occluded, and dilated states, in qualitative agreement with the well-documented flickering conductance of hERG1. In line with mutagenesis studies, these gating modalities resulted from dynamic interaction networks involving residues from the SF, outer-mouth vestibule, P-helices, and S5-P segments. We found that N629D mutation significantly stabilizes the SF in a state that is permeable to both K⁺ and Na⁺, which is reminiscent of the SF in the nonselective bacterial NaK channel. Increasing the external K⁺ concentration induced "WT-like" SF dynamics in N629D, in qualitative agreement with the recovery of flickering currents in experiments. Overall, our findings provide an understanding of the molecular mechanisms controlling selective transport in K⁺ channels with a nonconventional SF sequence.

Queueing arrival and release mechanism for K+ permeation through a potassium channel

The mechanism underlying ion permeation through potassium channels still remains controversial. K+ ions permeate across a narrow selectivity filter (SF) in a single file. Conventional scenarios assume that K+ ions are tightly bound in the SF, and, thus, they are displaced from their energy well by ion-ion repulsion with an incoming ion. This tight coupling between entering and exiting ions has been called the "knock-on" mechanism. However, this paradigm is contradicted by experimental data measuring the water-ion flux coupling ratio, demonstrating fewer ion occupancies. Here, the results of molecular dynamics simulations of permeation through the KcsA potassium channel revealed an alternative mechanism. In the aligned ions in the SF (an ion queue), the outermost K+ was readily and spontaneously released toward the extracellular space, and the affinity of the relevant ion was ~ 50 mM. Based on this low-affinity regime, a simple queueing mechanism described by loose coupling of entering and exiting ions is proposed.

Conformational plasticity in the KcsA potassium channel pore helix revealed by homo-FRET studies

Potassium channels selectivity filter (SF) conformation is modulated by several factors, including ion-protein and protein-protein interactions. Here, we investigate the SF dynamics of a single Trp mutant of the potassium channel KcsA (W67) using polarized time-resolved fluorescence measurements. For the first time, an analytical framework is reported to analyze the homo-Förster resonance energy transfer (homo-FRET) within a symmetric tetrameric protein with a square geometry. We found that in the closed state (pH 7), the W67-W67 intersubunit distances become shorter as the average ion occupancy of the SF increases according to cation type and concentration. The hypothesis that the inactivated SF at pH 4 is structurally similar to its collapsed state, detected at low K⁺, pH 7, was ruled out, emphasizing the critical role played by the S2 binding site in the inactivation process of KcsA. This homo-FRET approach provides complementary information to X-ray crystallography in which the protein conformational dynamics is usually compromised.

Accessibility of Cations to the Selectivity Filter of KcsA in the Inactivated State: An Equilibrium Binding Study

Cation binding under equilibrium conditions has been used as a tool to explore the accessibility of permeant and nonpermeant cations to the selectivity filter in three different inactivated models of the potassium channel KcsA. The results show that the stack of ion binding sites (S1 to S4) in the inactivated filter models remain accessible to cations as they are in the resting channel state. The inactivated state of the selectivity filter is therefore “resting-like” under such equilibrium conditions. Nonetheless, quantitative differences in the apparent K_D’s of the binding processes reveal that the affinity for the binding of permeant cations to the inactivated channel models, mainly K⁺, decreases considerably with respect to the resting channel. This is likely to cause a loss of K⁺ from the inactivated filter and consequently, to promote nonconductive conformations. The most affected site by the affinity loss seems to be S4, which is interesting because S4 is the first site to accommodate K⁺ coming from the channel vestibule when K⁺ exits the cell. Moreover, binding of the nonpermeant species, Na⁺, is not substantially affected by inactivation, meaning that the inactivated channels are also less selective for permeant versus nonpermeant cations under equilibrium conditions.

Selective exclusion and selective binding both contribute to ion selectivity in KcsA, a model potassium channel

The selectivity filter in potassium channels, a main component of the ion permeation pathway, configures a stack of binding sites (sites S1-S4) to which K⁺ and other cations may bind. Specific ion binding to such sites induces changes in the filter conformation, which play a key role in defining both selectivity and permeation. Here, using the potassium channel KcsA as a model, we contribute new evidence to reinforce this assertion. First, ion binding to KcsA blocked by tetrabutylammonium at the most cytoplasmic site in the selectivity filter (S4) suggests that such a site, when in the nonconductive filter conformation, has a higher affinity for cation binding than the most extracellular S1 site. This filter asymmetry, along with differences in intracellular and extracellular concentrations of K⁺versus Na⁺ under physiological conditions, should strengthen selection of the permeant K⁺ by the channel. Second, we used different K⁺ concentrations to shift the equilibrium between nonconductive and conductive states of the selectivity filter in which to test competitive binding of Na⁺ These experiments disclosed a marked decrease in the affinity of Na⁺ to bind the channel when the conformational equilibrium shifts toward the conductive state. This finding suggested that in addition to the selective binding of K⁺ and other permeant species over Na⁺, there is a selective exclusion of nonpermeant species from binding the channel filter, once it reaches a fully conductive conformation. We conclude that selective binding and selective exclusion of permeant and nonpermeant cations, respectively, are important determinants of ion channel selectivity.

Hysteresis of KcsA potassium channel's activation- deactivation gating is caused by structural changes at the channel's selectivity filter

Mode-shift or hysteresis has been reported in ion channels. Voltage-shift for gating currents is well documented for voltage-gated cation channels (VGCC), and it is considered a voltage-sensing domain's (VSD) intrinsic property. However, uncoupling the Shaker K⁺ channel's pore domain (PD) from the VSD prevented the mode-shift of the gating currents. Consequently, it was proposed that an open-state stabilization of the PD imposes a mechanical load on the VSD, which causes its mode-shift. Furthermore, the mode-shift displayed by hyperpolarization-gated cation channels is likely caused by structural changes at the channel's PD similar to those underlying C-type inactivation. To demonstrate that the PD of VGCC undergoes hysteresis, it is imperative to study its gating process in the absence of the VSD. A back-door strategy is to use KcsA (a K⁺ channel from the bacteria Streptomyces lividans) as a surrogate because it lacks a VSD and exhibits an activation coupled to C-type inactivation. By directly measuring KcsA's activation gate opening and closing in conditions that promote or halt C-type inactivation, we have found (i) that KcsA undergoes mode-shift of gating when having K⁺ as the permeant ion; (ii) that Cs⁺ or Rb⁺, known to halt C-inactivation, prevented mode-shift of gating; and (iii) that, in the total absence of C-type inactivation, KcsA's mode-shift was prevented. Finally, our results demonstrate that an allosteric communication causes KcsA's activation gate to "remember" the conformation of the selectivity filter, and hence KcsA requires a different amount of energy for opening than for closing.