Effective isolation of RNA aptamer through suppression of PCR bias

Selection of aptamers using β-1,3-glucan recognition protein-tagged proteins and curdlan beads

RNA aptamersare nucleic acids that are obtained using the systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) method. When using conventional selection methods to immobilize target proteins on matrix beads using protein tags, sequences are obtained that bind not only to the target proteins but also to the protein tags and matrix beads. In this study, we performed SELEX using β-1,3-glucan recognition protein (GRP)-tags and curdlan beads to immobilize the acute myeloid leukaemia 1 (AML1) Runt domain (RD) and analysed the enrichment of aptamers using high-throughput sequencing. Comparison of aptamer enrichment using the GRP-tag and His-tag suggested that aptamers were enriched using the GRP-tag as well as using the His-tag. Furthermore, surface plasmon resonance analysis revealed that the aptamer did not bind to the GRP-tag and that the conjugation of the GRP-tag to RD weakened the interaction between the aptamer and RD. The GRP-tag could have acted as a competitor to reduce weakly bound RNAs. Therefore, the affinity system of the GRP-tagged proteins and curdlan beads is suitable for obtaining specific aptamers using SELEX.

SELEX: Critical factors and optimization strategies for successful aptamer selection

Within the last decade, the application range of aptamers in biochemistry and medicine has expanded rapidly. More than just a replacement for antibodies, these intrinsically structured RNA- or DNA-oligonucleotides show great potential for utilization in diagnostics, specific drug delivery, and treatment of certain medical conditions. However, what is analyzed less frequently is the process of aptamer identification known as systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) and the functional mechanisms that lie at its core. SELEX involves numerous singular processes, each of which contributes to the success or failure of aptamer generation. In this review, critical steps during aptamer selection are discussed in-depth, and specific problems are presented along with potential solutions. The discussed aspects include the size and molecule type of the selected target, the nature and stringency of the selection process, the amplification step with its possible PCR bias, the efficient regeneration of RNA or single-stranded DNA, and the different sequencing procedures and screening assays currently available. Finally, useful quality control steps and their role within SELEX are presented. By understanding the mechanisms through which aptamer selection is influenced, the design of more efficient SELEX procedures leading to a higher success rate in aptamer identification is enabled.

Non-Invasive Delivery of Therapeutics into the Brain: The Potential of Aptamers for Targeted Delivery

The blood-brain barrier (BBB) is a highly specialised network of blood vessels that effectively separates the brain environment from the circulatory system. While there are benefits, in terms of keeping pathogens from entering the brain, the BBB also complicates treatments of brain pathologies by preventing efficient delivery of macromolecular drugs to diseased brain tissue. Although current non-invasive strategies of therapeutics delivery into the brain, such as focused ultrasound and nanoparticle-mediated delivery have shown various levels of successes, they still come with risks and limitations. This review discusses the current approaches of therapeutic delivery into the brain, with a specific focus on non-invasive methods. It also discusses the potential for aptamers as alternative delivery systems and several reported aptamers with promising preliminary results.

Capillary Electrophoresis Involving in High Efficiency Screening for Aptamers

Systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) is a universal technology for aptamer' screening. Accurate and efficient screening methods and strategy design are the key to success. This review briefly summarizes capillary electrophoresis (CE) involving in the efficient screening for aptamers in our group since 2007, including the application of CE in pre-screening, screening and post-screening process, classification and screening strategies against different protein targets, multiple screening modes, and screening for multi-scale targets. Finally, combined with the current progresses of aptamer screening, some remaining issues are discussed and the development prospects are proposed.

Selection and Characterization of a Novel DNA Aptamer, Apt-07S Specific to Hepatocellular Carcinoma Cells

Background

The efficacy of traditional therapeutic methods for liver cancer is unsatisfying because of the poor targeting, and inefficient drug delivery system. A recent study has proven that aptamers, developed through cell-SELEX, could specifically recognize cancer cells and show great potential in the development of a delivery system for anticancer drugs.

Purpose

To develop a hepatocellular carcinoma specific aptamer using two kinds of hepatocellular carcinoma cell lines, HepG₂ and SMMC-7721, as double targets and a normal hepatocyte, L02, as a negative control cell.

Methods

Hepatocellular carcinoma specific aptamer was developed via cell-SELEX. The enrichment of the library was monitored by flow cytometric analysis. The specificity, affinity, and distribution of the candidate aptamer were explored. Further study was carried to assess its potential in drug delivery.

Results

The library was enriched after 14 rounds of screening. Candidate aptamer Apt-07S can recognize four kinds of hepatocellular carcinoma cells and show little cell-binding ability to normal cells and four cell lines of different cancer types, revealing a high specificity of Apt-07S. Confocal imaging showed that Apt-07S distributed both on the surface and in the cytoplasm of the two target cells. Moreover, an anti-sense nucleotide to gene Plk1 (ASO-Plk1) was connected at the 3' end of Apt-07S to form an integrated molecule (Apt-07S-ASO-Plk1); the functional analysis indicated that the structure of Apt-07S may help ASO-Plk1 enter the cancer cells.

Conclusion

The study indicates that Apt-07S can specifically target HCC and may have potential in the delivery of anticancer drugs.

Inside the Black Box: What Makes SELEX Better?

Aptamers are small oligonucleotides that are capable of binding specifically to a target, with impressive potential for analysis, diagnostics, and therapeutics applications. Aptamers are isolated from large nucleic acid combinatorial libraries using an iterative selection process called SELEX (Systematic Evolution of Ligands by EXponential enrichment). Since being implemented 30 years ago, the SELEX protocol has undergone many modifications and improvements, but it remains a laborious, time-consuming, and costly method, and the results are not always successful. Each step in the aptamer selection protocol can influence its results. This review discusses key technical points of the SELEX procedure and their influence on the outcome of aptamer selection.

NMR monitoring of the SELEX process to confirm enrichment of structured RNA

RNA aptamers are RNA molecules that bind to a target molecule with high affinity and specificity using uniquely-folded tertiary structures. RNA aptamers are selected from an RNA pool typically comprising up to 1015 different sequences generated by iterative steps of selection and amplification known as Systematic Evolution of Ligands by EXponential enrichment (SELEX). Over several rounds of SELEX, the diversity of the RNA pool decreases and the aptamers are enriched. Hence, monitoring of the enrichment of these RNA pools is critical for the successful selection of aptamers, and several methods for monitoring them have been developed. In this study, we measured one-dimensional imino proton NMR spectra of RNA pools during SELEX. The spectrum of the initial RNA pool indicates that the RNAs adopt tertiary structures. The structural diversity of the RNA pools was shown to depend highly on the design of the primer-binding sequence. Furthermore, we demonstrate that enrichment of RNA aptamers can be monitored using NMR. The RNA pools can be recovered from the NMR tube after measurement of NMR spectra. We also can monitor target binding in the NMR tubes. Thus, we propose using NMR to monitor the enrichment of structured aptamers during the SELEX process.

Kinetic and Thermodynamic Analyses of Interaction between a High-Affinity RNA Aptamer and Its Target Protein

AML1 (RUNX1) protein is an essential transcription factor involved in the development of hematopoietic cells. Several genetic aberrations that disrupt the function of AML1 have been frequently observed in human leukemia. AML1 contains a DNA-binding domain known as the Runt domain (RD), which recognizes the RD-binding double-stranded DNA element of target genes. In this study, we identified high-affinity RNA aptamers that bind to RD by systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment. The binding assay using surface plasmon resonance indicated that a shortened aptamer retained the ability to bind to RD when 1 M potassium acetate was used. A thermodynamic study using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) showed that the aptamer-RD interaction is driven by a large enthalpy change, and its unfavorable entropy change is compensated by a favorable enthalpy change. Furthermore, the binding heat capacity change was identified from the ITC data at various temperatures. The aptamer binding showed a large negative heat capacity change, which suggests that a large apolar surface is buried upon such binding. Thus, we proposed that the aptamer binds to RD with long-range electrostatic force in the early stage of the association and then changes its conformation and recognizes a large surface area of RD. These findings about the biophysics of aptamer binding should be useful for understanding the mechanism of RNA-protein interaction and optimizing and modifying RNA aptamers.

Aptamers: A New Technological Platform in Cancer Immunotherapy

The renaissance of cancer immunotherapy is, nowadays, a reality. In the near future, it will be very likely among the first-line treatments for cancer patients. There are several different approaches to modulate the immune system to fight against tumor maladies but, so far, monoclonal antibodies may currently be the most successful immuno-tools used to that end. The number of ongoing clinical trials with monoclonal antibodies has been increasing exponentially over the last few years upon the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval of the first immune-checkpoint blockade antibodies. In spite of the proved antitumor effect of these reagents, the unleashing of the immune system to fight cancer cells has a cost, namely auto-inflammatory toxicity. Additionally, only a small fraction of all patients treated with immune-checkpoint antibodies have a clinical benefit. Taking into account all this, it is urgent new therapeutic reagents are developed with a contained toxicity that could facilitate the combination of different immune-modulating pathways to broaden the antitumor effect in most cancer patients. Based on preclinical data, oligonucleotide aptamers could fulfill this need. Aptamers have not only been successfully used as antagonists of immune-checkpoint receptors, but also as agonists of immunostimulatory receptors in cancer immunotherapy. The simplicity of aptamers to be engineered for the specific delivery of different types of cargos to tumor cells and immune cells so as to harvest an efficient antitumor immune response gives aptamers a significant advantage over antibodies. In this review all of the recent applications of aptamers in cancer immunotherapy will be described.

Improvement of the VEGF binding ability of DNA aptamers through in silico maturation and multimerization strategy

Aptamers are mainly selected by in vitro selection using random nucleic acid libraries. These aptamers have often shown insufficient affinity for biomedical applications. We improved DNA aptamer binding affinity for vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) through in silico maturation (ISM) and aptamer multimerization. ISM is one of a number of evolutionary approaches and aptamer multimerization is one of several semi-rational strategies to improve function. We first reselected VEGF-binding aptamers using a partially randomized DNA library and identified two aptamers with higher binding ability than that of a known aptamer. We conducted ISM using the re-selected aptamers to optimize the key loop sequences created by a three-way junction structure. After five ISM rounds, we identified aptamer 2G19 [dissociation constant (Kd), 52 nM] as a local optimum of the defined search space. We characterized the aptamer and found that a specific stem-loop structure was involved in aptamer VEGF recognition. To further improve its affinity for VEGF, we multimerized 2G19 or its stem-loop structure. The designed SL5-trivalent aptamer (Kd, 0.37 nM) with three binding motifs significantly increased binding affinity, representing a 500-fold improvement from systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment-selected aptamers.

Cell-SELEX based selection and optimization of DNA aptamers for specific recognition of human cholangiocarcinoma QBC-939 cells

Cholangiocarcinoma (CCA) is a very aggressive biliary tract malignancy with no efficient early diagnosis and therapeutics available, so there is a call for effective molecular probes. Herein, we performed cell-based systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (cell-SELEX) to obtain aptamers for the specific recognition of human cholangiocarcinoma QBC-939 cells. By coordinating sequence homology analysis and secondary structure analysis, we successfully obtained two aptamers with dissociation constants (Kd) in the low nanomolar range. A 23 nt truncated sequence was identified after further analysis on the secondary structure. More importantly, because hepatocellular carcinoma SMMC-7721 cells were employed as the control in the counter selection, the obtained aptamers demonstrated excellent specificity to the target cells, and no binding to several other hepatocellular carcinoma cell lines was observed. Moreover, the aptamers were initially found to recognize membrane proteins, giving them great potential in the field of biomarker discovery. These newly generated aptamers may play a key role in the early diagnosis and clinical treatment of CCA.

Replacing antibodies with aptamers in lateral flow immunoassay

Aptamers have been identified against various targets as a type of chemical or nucleic acid ligand by systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) with high sensitivity and specificity. Aptamers show remarkable advantages over antibodies due to the nucleic acid nature and target-induced structure-switching properties and are widely used to design various fluorescent, electrochemical, or colorimetric biosensors. However, the practical applications of aptamer-based sensing and diagnostics are still lagging behind those of antibody-based tests. Lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA) represents a well established and appropriate technology among rapid assays because of its low cost and user-friendliness. The antibody-based platform is utilized to detect numerous targets, but it is always hampered by the antibody preparation time, antibody stability, and effect of modification on the antibody. Seeking alternatives to antibodies is an area of active research and is of tremendous importance. Aptamers are receiving increasing attention in lateral flow applications because of a number of important potential performance advantages. We speculate that aptamer-based LFIA may be one of the first platforms for commercial use of aptamer-based diagnosis. This review first gives an introduction to aptamer including the selection process SELEX with its focus on aptamer advantages over antibodies, and then depicts LFIA with its focus on aptamer opportunities in LFIA over antibodies. Furthermore, we summarize the recent advances in the development of aptamer-based lateral flow biosensing assays with the aim to provide a general guide for the design of aptamer-based lateral flow biosensing assays.

Emulsion PCR significantly improves nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures-based aptamer selection: allowing for efficient and rapid selection of aptamer to unmodified ABH2 protein

Nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures (NECEEM), a homogeneous approach to select DNA aptamers, is among the most efficient partitioning techniques. In contrast with surface-based systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) approaches, the ability of NECEEM to select aptamers to unmodified proteins in solution is preferable for identifying aptamers for eventual in vivo use. The high stringency and low sample volumes of NECEEM, although generally beneficial, can result in binding of very few aptamers, requiring highly efficient amplification to propagate them. When amplified with standard PCR, detectable library enrichment can fail due to the fast conversion of the aptamers into byproducts and preferential amplification of nonbinders. As an alternative, we proposed the use of emulsion PCR (ePCR), which is known to reduce byproduct formation, as a PCR mode for coupling with NECEEM partitioning. For the first time, we tested the advantages of ePCR in NECEEM-based aptamer selection to a medically relevant DNA repair enzyme, ABH2. We report that the combination of ePCR with NECEEM allowed for the selection of aptamers in the first three rounds of SELEX, while SELEX with conventional PCR failed in a number of attempts. Selected aptamers to an unmodified ABH2 protein have potential use in diagnostics and as leads for anticancer cotherapies, used as enhancements of alkylating agents in chemotherapy.

New Technologies Provide Quantum Changes in the Scale, Speed, and Success of SELEX Methods and Aptamer Characterization

Single-stranded oligonucleotide aptamers have attracted great attention in the past decade because of their diagnostic and therapeutic potential. These versatile, high affinity and specificity reagents are selected by an iterative in vitro process called SELEX, Systematic Evolution of Ligands by Exponential Enrichment. Numerous SELEX methods have been developed for aptamer selections; some that are simple and straightforward, and some that are specialized and complicated. The method of SELEX is crucial for selection of an aptamer with desired properties; however, success also depends on the starting aptamer library, the target molecule, aptamer enrichment monitoring assays, and finally, the analysis and characterization of selected aptamers. Here, we summarize key recent developments in aptamer selection methods, as well as other aspects of aptamer selection that have significant impact on the outcome. We discuss potential pitfalls and limitations in the selection process with an eye to aid researchers in the choice of a proper SELEX strategy, and we highlight areas where further developments and improvements are desired. We believe carefully designed multiplexed selection methods, when complemented with high-throughput downstream analysis and characterization assays, will yield numerous high-affinity aptamers to protein and small molecule targets, and thereby generate a vast array of reagents for probing basic biological mechanisms and implementing new diagnostic and therapeutic applications in the near future.

Aptamers and the next generation of diagnostic reagents

Antibodies have been extensively used as capture and detection reagents in diagnostic applications of proteomics-based technologies. Proteomic assays need high sensitivity and specificity, a wide dynamic range for detection, and accurate, reproducible quantification with small confidence values. However, several inherent limitations of monoclonal antibodies in meeting the emerging challenges of proteomics led to the development of a new class of oligonucleotide-based reagents. Natural and derivatized nucleic acid aptamers are emerging as promising alternatives to monoclonal antibodies. Aptamers can be effectively used to simultaneously detect thousands of proteins in multiplex discovery platforms, where antibodies often fail due to cross-reactivity problems. Through chemical modification, vast range of additional functional groups can be added at any desired position in the oligonucleotide sequence, therefore the best features of small molecule drugs, proteins, and antibodies can be brought together into aptamers, making aptamers the most versatile reagent in proteomics. In this review, we discuss the recent developments in aptamer technology, including new selection methods and the aptamers' application in proteomics.

Strategies for the discovery of therapeutic aptamers

IMPORTANCE OF THE FIELD

Therapeutic aptamers are synthetic, structured oligonucleotides that bind to a very broad range of targets with high affinity and specificity. They are an emerging class of targeting ligand that show great promise for treating a number of diseases. A series of aptamers currently in various stages of clinical development highlights the potential of aptamers for therapeutic applications.

AREAS COVERED IN THIS REVIEW

This review covers in vitro selection of oligonucleotide ligands, called aptamers, from a combinatorial library using the Systematic Evolution of Ligands by Exponential Enrichment process as well as the other known strategies for finding aptamers against various targets.

WHAT THE READER WILL GAIN

Readers will gain an understanding of the highly useful strategies for successful aptamer discovery. They may also be able to combine two or more of the presented strategies for their aptamer discovery projects.

TAKE HOME MESSAGE

Although many processes are available for discovering aptamers, it is not easy to discover an aptamer candidate that is ready to move toward pharmaceutical drug development. It is also apparent that there have been relatively few therapeutic advances and clinical trials undertaken due to the small number of companies that participate in aptamer development.

Survey of the 2009 commercial optical biosensor literature

We took a different approach to reviewing the commercial biosensor literature this year by inviting 22 biosensor users to serve as a review committee. They set the criteria for what to expect in a publication and ultimately decided to use a pass/fail system for selecting which papers to include in this year's reference list. Of the 1514 publications in 2009 that reported using commercially available optical biosensor technology, only 20% passed their cutoff. The most common criticism the reviewers had with the literature was that "the biosensor experiments could have been done better." They selected 10 papers to highlight good experimental technique, data presentation, and unique applications of the technology. This communal review process was educational for everyone involved and one we will not soon forget.

Finding aptamers and small ribozymes in unexpected places

The discovery of the catalytic properties of RNAs was a milestone for our view of how life emerged and forced us to reformulate many of our dogmas. The urge to grasp the whole spectrum of potential activities of RNA molecules stimulated two decades of fervent research resulting in a deep understanding of RNA-based phenomena. Most ribozymes were discovered by serendipity during the analysis of chemical processes, whereas RNA aptamers were identified through meticulous design and selection even before their discovery in nature. The desire to obtain aptamers led to the development of sophisticated technology and the design of efficient strategies. With the new notion that transcriptomes cover a major part of genomes and determine the identity of cells, it is reasonable to speculate that many more aptamers and ribozymes are awaiting their discovery in unexpected places. Now, in the genomic era with the development of powerful bioinformatics and sequencing methods, we are overwhelmed with tools for studying the genomes of all living and possibly even extinct organisms. Genomic SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) coupled with deep sequencing and sophisticated computational analysis not only gives access to unexplored parts of sequenced genomes but also allows screening metagenomes in an unbiased manner.

Emerging applications of riboswitches in chemical biology

Living systems use RNA sequences known as riboswitches to detect the concentrations of small-molecule metabolites within cells and to regulate the expression of genes that produce these metabolites. Like their natural counterparts, synthetic riboswitches also regulate gene expression in response to small molecules. Because synthetic riboswitches can be engineered to respond to nonendogenous small molecules, they are powerful tools for chemical and synthetic biologists interested in understanding and reprogramming cellular behavior. In this review, we present an overview of natural riboswitches, highlight recent studies toward developing synthetic riboswitches and provide an overview of emerging applications of these RNA switches in chemical biology.