Influence of inoculum and anode surface properties on the selection of Geobacter-dominated biofilms

Inoculum source determines the stress resistance of electroactive functional taxa in biofilms: A metagenomic perspective

The inoculum has a crucial impact on bioreactor initialization and performance. However, there is currently a lack of guidance on selecting appropriate inocula for applications in environmental biotechnology. In this study, we applied microbial electrolysis cells (MECs) as models to investigate the differences in the functional potential of electroactive microorganisms (EAMs) within anodic biofilms developed from four different inocula (natural or artificial), using shotgun metagenomic techniques. We specifically focused on extracellular electron transfer (EET) function and stress resistance, which affect the performance and stability of MECs. Community profiling revealed that the family Geobacteraceae was the key EAM taxon in all biofilms, with Geobacter as the dominant genus. The c-type cytochrome gene imcH showed universal importance for Geobacteraceae EET and was utilized as a marker gene to evaluate the EET potential of EAMs. Additionally, stress response functional genes were used to assess the stress resistance potential of Geobacter species. Comparative analysis of imcH gene abundance revealed that EAMs with comparable overall EET potential could be enriched from artificial and natural inocula (P > 0.05). However, quantification of stress response gene copy numbers in the genomes demonstrated that EAMs originating from natural inocula possessed superior stress resistance potential (196 vs. 163). Overall, this study provides novel perspectives on the inoculum effect in bioreactors and offers theoretical guidance for selecting inoculum in environmental engineering applications.

Urban wastewater oxidation by bioelectrochemical systems: To what extent does the inoculum matter?

Bioelectrochemical systems offer an environmental-friendly alternative to activated sludge for future wastewater treatment but have not yet reached technological maturity. This study aims to assess the long-term influence of the inoculation strategy on real urban wastewater treatment by bioelectrochemical systems, focusing on both process performances and biofilm assembly dynamics. Four inoculation strategies were investigated in triplicates during six consecutive batches to treat primary clarifier effluent at lab scale. At the studied anodic potential (0.05 vs SHE), no long-term impact of the inoculation strategy on the performances was observed. Indeed, after three batches, electrochemical (88.0 ± 3.9 % coulombic efficiencies) and treatment performances (30.8 ± 3.9 % COD removals) converged for all inoculation strategies. Consistently, the microbial compositions of the different biofilms converged, with selection being the main assembly process. For larger scale bioelectrochemical reactors, the use of wastewater as both substrate and inoculum would be the most convenient choice, since the other inoculation strategies only displayed short-term effects.

Fe(III) oxide microparticles modulate extracellular electron transfer in anodic biofilms dominated by bacteria of the Pelobacter genus

Exo-electrogenic microorganisms have been extensively studied for their ability to transfer electrons with solid surfaces using a large variety of metabolic pathways. Most of the studies on these microorganisms consist in the replacement of solid electron acceptors such as Fe(III) oxides found in nature by electrodes with the objective of generating harvestable current in devices such as microbial fuel cells. In this study we show how the presence of solid ferric oxide (Fe₂O₃) particles in the inoculum during bio-anode development influences extracellular electron transfer to the electrode. Amplification and sequencing of the 16S rRNA (V4-V5 region) show bacteria and archaea communities with a large predominance of the Pelobacter genus, which is known to be phylogenetically close to the Geobacter genus, regardless of the presence or absence of ferric oxide in the inoculum. Data indicate that the bacteria at the bio-anode surface can preferentially utilize solid ferric oxide as terminal electron acceptors instead of the anode, though extracellular electron transfer to the anode can be restored by removing the particles. Mixed inoculum commonly used to develop bioanodes may produce similar bacterial communities with divergent electrochemical responses due to the presence of alternate electron acceptors, with direct implications for microbial fuel cell performance.

Evolution and interaction of microbial communities in mangrove microbial fuel cells and first description of Shewanella fodinae as electroactive bacterium

Understanding exoelectrogenic bacteria mechanisms and their interactions in complex biofilm is critical for the development of microbial fuel cells (MFCs). In this article, assumptions concerning the benefits of the complex sediment microbial community for electricity production were explored with both the complex microbial community and isolates identified as Shewanella. Analysis of the microbial community revealed a strong influence of the sediment community on anodes and electrolytes compared to that of only water. Moreover, while Pelobacteraceae-related genera were dominant in our MFCs instead of Desulfuromonas and Geobacter as usually reported, the electroactive Shewanella algae and Shewanella fodinae were isolated and cultivated from the anodic biofilm. S. fodinae, described for the first time as an electroactive bacterium to the best of our knowledge, led to a maximal current density of 3.6 A/m² set as 0.3 V/SCE in a three-electrode set-up fed with lactate. S. algae, in a complex medium containing several available substrates, showed several preferential oxidative behaviors including a diauxic behavior. In pure culture and under our conditions, S. fodinae and S. algae were not able to use acetate as a sole electron donor. However, their presence in our acetate-fed MFCs and the adaptive behavior of S. algae hint a syntrophic interaction between the bacteria to optimize the use of the substrate in a complex environment.

Recent advances in enrichment, isolation, and bio-electrochemical activity evaluation of exoelectrogenic microorganisms

Exoelectrogenic microorganisms (EEMs) catalyzed the conversion of chemical energy to electrical energy via extracellular electron transfer (EET) mechanisms, which underlay diverse bio-electrochemical systems (BES) applications in clean energy development, environment and health monitoring, wearable/implantable devices powering, and sustainable chemicals production, thereby attracting increasing attentions from academic and industrial communities in the recent decades. However, knowledge of EEMs is still in its infancy as only ~100 EEMs of bacteria, archaea, and eukaryotes have been identified, motivating the screening and capture of new EEMs. This review presents a systematic summarization on EEM screening technologies in terms of enrichment, isolation, and bio-electrochemical activity evaluation. We first generalize the distribution characteristics of known EEMs, which provide a basis for EEM screening. Then, we summarize EET mechanisms and the principles underlying various technological approaches to the enrichment, isolation, and bio-electrochemical activity of EEMs, in which a comprehensive analysis of the applicability, accuracy, and efficiency of each technology is reviewed. Finally, we provide a future perspective on EEM screening and bio-electrochemical activity evaluation by focusing on (i) novel EET mechanisms for developing the next-generation EEM screening technologies, and (ii) integration of meta-omics approaches and bioinformatics analyses to explore nonculturable EEMs. This review promotes the development of advanced technologies to capture new EEMs.

Controlling the Carbon-Bio Interface via Glycan Functional Adlayers for Applications in Microbial Fuel Cell Bioanodes

Surface modification of electrodes with glycans was investigated as a strategy for modulating the development of electrocatalytic biofilms for microbial fuel cell applications. Covalent attachment of phenyl-mannoside and phenyl-lactoside adlayers on graphite rod electrodes was achieved via electrochemically assisted grafting of aryldiazonium cations from solution. To test the effects of the specific bio-functionalities, modified and unmodified graphite rods were used as anodes in two-chamber microbial fuel cell devices. Devices were set up with wastewater as inoculum and acetate as nutrient and their performance, in terms of output potential (open circuit and 1 kΩ load) and peak power output, was monitored over two months. The presence of glycans was found to lead to significant differences in startup times and peak power outputs. Lactosides were found to inhibit the development of biofilms when compared to bare graphite. Mannosides were found, instead, to promote exoelectrogenic biofilm adhesion and anode colonization, a finding that is supported by quartz crystal microbalance experiments in inoculum media. These differences were observed despite both adlayers possessing thickness in the nm range and similar hydrophilic character. This suggests that specific glycan-mediated bioaffinity interactions can be leveraged to direct the development of biotic electrocatalysts in bioelectrochemical systems and microbial fuel cell devices.

Impact of Carbon Felt Electrode Pretreatment on Anodic Biofilm Composition in Microbial Electrolysis Cells

Sustainable technologies for energy production and storage are currently in great demand. Bioelectrochemical systems (BESs) offer promising solutions for both. Several attempts have been made to improve carbon felt electrode characteristics with various pretreatments in order to enhance performance. This study was motivated by gaps in current knowledge of the impact of pretreatments on the enrichment and microbial composition of bioelectrochemical systems. Therefore, electrodes were treated with poly(neutral red), chitosan, or isopropanol in a first step and then fixed in microbial electrolysis cells (MECs). Four MECs consisting of organic substance-degrading bioanodes and methane-producing biocathodes were set up and operated in batch mode by controlling the bioanode at 400 mV vs. Ag/AgCl (3M NaCl). After 1 month of operation, Enterococcus species were dominant microorganisms attached to all bioanodes and independent of electrode pretreatment. However, electrode pretreatments led to a decrease in microbial diversity and the enrichment of specific electroactive genera, according to the type of modification used. The MEC containing isopropanol-treated electrodes achieved the highest performance due to presence of both Enterococcus and Geobacter. The obtained results might help to select suitable electrode pretreatments and support growth conditions for desired electroactive microorganisms, whereby performance of BESs and related applications, such as BES-based biosensors, could be enhanced.

Anode Surface Bioaugmentation Enhances Deterministic Biofilm Assembly in Microbial Fuel Cells

Microbial fuel cells (MFCs) generate energy while aiding the biodegradation of waste through the activity of an electroactive mixed biofilm. Metabolic cooperation is essential for MFCs' efficiency, especially during early colonization. Thus, examining specific ecological processes that drive the assembly of anode biofilms is highly important for shortening startup times and improving MFC performance, making this technology cost-effective and sustainable. Here, we use metagenomics to show that bioaugmentation of the anode surface with a taxonomically defined electroactive consortium, dominated by Desulfuromonas, resulted in an extremely rapid current density generation. Conversely, the untreated anode surface resulted in a highly stochastic and slower biofilm assembly. Remarkably, an efficient anode colonization process was obtained only if wastewater was added, leading to a nearly complete replacement of the bioaugmented community by Geobacter lovleyi Although different approaches to improve MFC startup have been investigated, we propose that only the combination of anode bioaugmentation with wastewater inoculation can reduce stochasticity. Such an approach provides the conditions that support the growth of specific newly arriving species that positively support the fast establishment of a highly functional anode biofilm.IMPORTANCE Mixed microbial communities play important roles in treating wastewater, in producing renewable energy, and in the bioremediation of pollutants in contaminated environments. While these processes are well known, especially the community structure and biodiversity, how to efficiently and robustly manage microbial community assembly remains unknown. Moreover, it has been shown that a high degree of temporal variation in microbial community composition and structure often occurs even under identical environmental conditions. This heterogeneity is directly related to stochastic processes involved in microbial community organization, similarly during the initial stages of biofilm formation on surfaces. In this study, we show that anode surface pretreatment alone is not sufficient for a substantial improvement in startup times in microbial fuel cells (MFCs), as previously thought. Rather, we have discovered that the combination of applying a well-known consortium directly on the anode surface together with wastewater (including the bacteria that they contain) is the optimized management scheme. This allowed a selected colonization process by the wastewater species, which improved the functionality relative to that of untreated systems.

Microorganisms in sediment microbial fuel cells: Ecological niche, microbial response, and environmental function

A sediment microbial fuel cell (SMFC) is a device that harvests electrical energy from sediments rich in organic matter. SMFCs have been attracting increasing amounts of interest in environmental remediation, since they are capable of providing a clean and inexhaustible source of electron donors or acceptors and can be easily controlled by adjusting the electrochemical parameters. The microorganisms inhabiting sediments and the overlying water play a pivotal role in SMFCs. Since the SMFC is applied in an open environment rather than in an enclosed chamber, the effects of the environment on the microbes should be intense and the microbial community succession should be extremely complex. Thus, this review aims to provide an overview of the microorganisms in SMFCs, which few previous review papers have reported. In this study, the anodic and cathodic niches for the microorganisms in SMFCs are summarized, how the microbial population and community interact with the SMFC environment is discussed, a new microbial succession strategy called the electrode stimulation succession is proposed, and recent developments in the environmental functions of SMFCs are discussed from the perspective of microorganisms. Future studies are needed to investigate the electrode stimulation succession, the environmental function and the electron transfer mechanism in order to boost the application of SMFCs for power generation and environmental remediation.

Characterization of Anaerobic Biofilms Growing on Carbon Felt Bioanodes Exposed to Air

The role of oxygen in anodic biofilms is still a matter of debate. In this study, we tried to elucidate the structure and performance of an electrogenic biofilm that develops on air-exposed, carbon felt electrodes, commonly used in bioelectrochemical systems. By simultaneously recording the current density produced by the bioanode and dissolved oxygen concentration, both inside and in the vicinity of the biofilm, it was possible to demonstrate the influence of a protective aerobic layer present in the biofilm (mainly formed by Pseudomonas genus bacteria) that prevents electrogenic bacteria (such as Geobacter sp.) from hazardous exposure to oxygen during its normal operation. Once this protective barrier was deactivated for a long period of time, the catalytic capacity of the biofilm was severely affected. In addition, our results highlighted the importance of the material’s porous structure for oxygen penetration in the electrode.

Microbial community composition and electricity generation in cattle manure slurry treatment using microbial fuel cells: effects of inoculum addition

Microbial fuel cell (MFC) is a sustainable technology to treat cattle manure slurry (CMS) for converting chemical energy to bioelectricity. In this work, two types of allochthonous inoculum including activated sludge (AS) and domestic sewage (DS) were added into the MFC systems to enhance anode biofilm formation and electricity generation. Results indicated that MFCs (AS + CMS) obtained the maximum electricity output with voltage approaching 577 ± 7 mV (~ 196 h), followed by MFCs (DS + CMS) (520 ± 21 mV, ~ 236 h) and then MFCs with autochthonous inoculum (429 ± 62 mV, ~ 263.5 h). Though the raw cattle manure slurry (RCMS) could facilitate electricity production in MFCs, the addition of allochthonous inoculum (AS/DS) significantly reduced the startup time and enhanced the output voltage. Moreover, the maximum power (1.259 ± 0.015 W/m²) and the highest COD removal (84.72 ± 0.48%) were obtained in MFCs (AS + CMS). With regard to microbial community, Illumina HiSeq of the 16S rRNA gene was employed in this work and the exoelectrogens (Geobacter and Shewanella) were identified as the dominant members on all anode biofilms in MFCs. For anode microbial diversity, the MFCs (AS + CMS) outperformed MFCs (DS + CMS) and MFCs (RCMS), allowing the occurrence of the fermentative (e.g., Bacteroides) and nitrogen fixation bacteria (e.g., Azoarcus and Sterolibacterium) which enabled the efficient degradation of the slurry. This study provided a feasible strategy to analyze the anode biofilm formation by adding allochthonous inoculum and some implications for quick startup of MFC reactors for CMS treatment.

Bacterial community shift and incurred performance in response to in situ microbial self-assembly graphene and polarity reversion in microbial fuel cell

In this work, bacterial community shift and incurred performance of graphene modified bioelectrode (GM-BE) in microbial fuel cell (MFC) were illustrated by high throughput sequencing technology and electrochemical analysis. The results showed that Firmicutes occupied 48.75% in graphene modified bioanode (GM-BA), while Proteobacteria occupied 62.99% in graphene modified biocathode (GM-BC), both were dominant bacteria in phylum level respectively. Typical exoelectrogens, including Geobacter, Clostridium, Pseudomonas, Geothrix and Hydrogenophaga, were counted 26.66% and 17.53% in GM-BA and GM-BC. GM-BE was tended to decrease the bacterial diversity and enrich the dominant species. Because of the enrichment of exoelectrogens and excellent electrical conductivity of graphene, the maximum power density of MFC with GM-BA and GM-BC increased 33.1% and 21.6% respectively, and the transfer resistance decreased 83.8% and 73.6% compared with blank bioelectrode. This study aimed to enrich the microbial study in MFC and broaden the development and application for bioelectrode.

Electroactive Biofilms for Sensing: Reflections and Perspectives

Microbial electrochemistry has from the onset been recognized for its sensing potential due to the microbial ability to enhance signals through metabolic cascades, its relative selectivity toward substrates, and the higher stability conferred by the microbial ability to self-replicate. The greatest challenge has been to achieve stable and efficient transduction between a microorganism and an electrode surface. Over the past decades, a new kind of microbial architecture has been observed to spontaneously develop on polarized electrodes: the electroactive biofilm (EAB). The EAB conducts electrons over long distances and performs quasi-reversible electron transfer on conventional electrode surfaces. It also possesses self-regenerative properties. In only a few years, EABs have inspired considerable research interest for use as biosensors for environmental or bioprocess monitoring. Multiple challenges still need to be overcome before implementation at larger scale of this new kind of biosensors can be realized. This perspective first introduces the specific characteristics of the EAB with respect to other electrochemical biosensors. It summarizes the sensing applications currently proposed for EABs, stresses their limitations, and suggests strategies toward potential solutions. Conceptual prospects to engineer EABs for sensing purposes are also discussed.

The performance of microbial anodes in municipal wastewater: Pre-grown multispecies biofilm vs. natural inocula

In this study, different inoculation strategies for continuously operated microbial anodes are analyzed and compared. After 20daysof operation with municipal wastewater anodes pre-incubated with a biofilm of the exoelectrogenic species Geobacter and Shewanella showed current densities of (65±8) μA/cm². This is comparable to the current densities of non-inoculated anodes and anodes inoculated with sewage sludge. Analysis of the barcoded pre-grown multispecies biofilms reveal that 99% of the original biofilm was detached after 20daysof operation with municipal wastewater. This is in contrast to previous experiments where a pre-grown biofilm of exoelectrogens was operated in batch mode. To implement pre-grown biofilms in continuous systems it will thus be necessary to reveal a window of process parameters in which typical exoelectrogenic microorganisms including model organisms can be kept and/or enriched on anodes.

Effect of Graphene-Graphene Oxide Modified Anode on the Performance of Microbial Fuel Cell

The inferior hydrophilicity of graphene is an adverse factor to the performance of the graphene modified anodes (G anodes) in microbial fuel cells (MFCs). In this paper, different amounts of hydrophilic graphene oxide (GO) were doped into the modification layers to elevate the hydrophilicity of the G anodes so as to further improve their performance. Increasing the GO doped ratio from 0.15 mg·mg⁻¹ to 0.2 mg·mg⁻¹ and 0.25 mg·mg⁻¹, the static water contact angle (θ_c) of the G-GO anodes decreased from 74.2 ± 0.52° to 64.6 ± 2.75° and 41.7 ± 3.69°, respectively. The G-GO_0.2 anode with GO doped ratio of 0.2 mg·mg⁻¹ exhibited the optimal performance and the maximum power density (P_max) of the corresponding MFC was 1100.18 mW·m⁻², 1.51 times higher than that of the MFC with the G anode.