Effects of interspecific competition on the growth of macrophytes and nutrient removal in constructed wetlands: A comparative assessment of free water surface and horizontal subsurface flow systems

Impacts of spatial expansion by Phragmites australis on spatiotemporal variation of sulfur fractions in marsh soils of the Min River estuary, Southeast China

To investigate the impacts of spatial expansion by Phragmites australis on spatiotemporal variations of sulfur (S) fractions in marsh soils of the Min River estuary (Southeast China), the contents of total sulfur (TS) and inorganic sulfur (IS) fractions (Water-Soluble-S, W-S-S; Adsorbed-S, A-S; HCl-Soluble-S, H-S-S; and HCl-Volatile-S, H-V-S) were determined in soils of Cyperus malaccensis marsh (before expansion, BE stage), P. australis-C. malaccensis marsh (during expansion, DE stage) and P. australis marsh (after expansion, AE stage) by space-for-time substitution method. Results showed that the expansion of P. australis greatly altered the spatiotemporal variations of TS and IS fractions in marsh soils. The TS contents in soils at AE stage were significantly lower than those at DE and BE stages throughout a year (p < 0.01). Higher levels of W-S-S, A-S, H-S-S and total inorganic sulfur (TIS) generally occurred in soils at DE and AE stages, whereas higher values of H-V-S were observed in soils at BE stage. Although P. australis expansion did not alter the temporal variations of TS stock in soils greatly, the values during autumn and winter were generally higher than those in spring and summer (p < 0.05). The highest TIS stocks in soils of different expansion stages were observed in spring, while the lowest values occurred in summer. The expansion of P. australis significantly increased the IS supply capacity of soils and, compared with the BE stage, stocks of W-S-S, A-S, H-S-S and TIS in soils of all sampling seasons at DE and AE stages increased by 51.40 %, 50.76 %, 63.35 %, 50.52 % and 20.00 %, 31.46 %, 42.93 %, 27.56 %, respectively. It was worth noting that stocks of H-V-S in soils at DE and AE stages showed a decreasing trend compared to the BE stage, implying that the expansion of P. australis might reduce the production of sulfides. This paper found that, compared with C. malaccensis, the increased available IS stocks in soils might be an effective strategy for P. australis to maintain its expansion advantage and the decreased volatile-S in soils might be more favorable for boosting its competitiveness. Our study provided valuable information for understanding the interspecific competition mechanism between P. australis and C. malaccensis. Next step, in order to protect the diversity of marsh vegetations in the Min River estuary, effective measures should be taken to suppress the rapid expansion of P. australis.

Inducing root redundant development to release oxygen: An efficient natural oxygenation approach for subsurface flow constructed wetland

Dissolved oxygen (DO) is a limiting factor affecting the purification efficiency of subsurface flow (SSF) constructed wetlands (CWs). To clarify the causes of oxygen environments and the response characteristics of plant oxygen release (POR) in SSF CWs, this study set three oxygen source treatments by limiting atmospheric reaeration (AR) and influent oxygen (IO) and compared the differences in plant physiological metabolism, DO distribution characteristics, and the purification effect of the SSF CWs at different depths. The results showed that limiting exogenous oxygen stimulated root redundancy of the wetland plants. The root volume and proportion of fibrous roots of the wetland plants increased significantly (p < 0.05). When only the POR existed, the root zone DO increased significantly to 2.05-4.37 mg/L (p < 0.05), and was positively correlated with the TN and TP removal rates (p < 0.05). Additionally, in the presence of POR only, the average removal rates of TN and TP in the top layer were 86.5% and 76.9%, respectively. The proportion of fibrous roots, root zone DO, and root-shoot ratio were key factors promoting the purification effect of the SSF CWs under limited exogenous oxygen sources. Enhancing POR by inducing root redundancy enhanced nitrification (hao, pmoABC-amoABC), plant absorption, and assimilation-related functional genes (nrtABC, nifKDH), and enriched nitrogen and phosphorus removal bacteria, such as Flavobacterium and Zoogloea. This consequently improved pollutant removal efficiency. Inducing root redundancy to strengthen POR produced an aerobic environment in the SSF CWs. This ensures the efficient and stable operation of the SSF CW and is an effective approach for natural oxygenation.

Effect of Tubifex tubifex on the purification function of saturated vertical flow constructed wetlands for effluents with varying C/N ratios

The improvement effect of Tubifex tubifex on the pollutant removal efficiencies (REs) of vertical flow constructed wetlands (VF-CWs) treating wastewater with various C/N ratios was explored. The experiment was conducted in pilot-scale saturated VF-CWs, being added different densities of T. tubifex and fed synthetic wastewater with successive C/N ratios of 0.5, 1.5, 3.0 and 6.0. The results suggest that T. tubifex addition and the influent C/N ratio had an interactive effect, i.e., T. tubifex addition improved NOx--N, NH4+-N, TN and COD REs by 36.7%, 56.5%, 22.6%, and 10.0%, respectively, under low C/N ratios, while high C/N ratios inhibited this improvement. Low-density T. tubifex addition significantly increased substrate dissolved oxygen (DO) by retarding excessive soil organic matter (OM) accumulation. With T. tubifex addition, an improvement in bacterial diversity, the relative abundance of N-cycle and fermentative bacteria, and N-cycle functional genes was only observed in substrates under low C/N ratios. T. tubifex can improve the purification function of saturated VF-CWs, but this strategy strongly depends on both the influent C/N ratio and density of T. tubifex addition.

Oxygen consumption and formation of recalcitrant organic carbon from the decomposition of free-floating macrophyte leachates

Aquatic macrophytes contain high levels of hydrosoluble compounds. These compounds disproportionately support microbial breakdown and affect biological oxygen demand in eutrophic waters. In this study, we investigated the fate of leachates from free-floating macrophytes (Pistia stratiotes and Eichhornia crassipes) usually present in eutrophic tropical lacustrine environments. After extraction, the leachates were fractioned into high and low molecular weight compounds and incubated under aerobic conditions, in the dark and at 20.0 ± 1.3 °C. The concentrations of dissolved oxygen and the total, dissolved, and particulate organic carbon (TOC, DOC, and POC) were determined during 60 days. The selected leachates supported the detritus trophic chain of the Barra Bonita Reservoir. High rates of carbon transfer were measured, which were ascribed to the temperature selected (20 °C), nutrient availability, and labile fractions of the leachates. Decomposition occurred mainly through catabolic pathways (mineralization), with the formation of POC (immobilization) being only minor. In the early stages of P. stratiotes and E. crassipes decomposition, the mineralization of leachates (mainly the low molecular weight) led to declines in dissolved oxygen. Owing to the low rates of mass loss, the recalcitrant fractions of these leachates should constitute the main forms of organic carbon exported from the reservoir.

Integrated environmental influences quantification of pilot-scale constructed wetlands based on modified ecological footprint assessment

Constructed wetlands (CWs) are widely used for non-point source pollution control and water environmental quality improvement. Though it is effective in water quality improvement under most conditions, the overall impacts on the ecological environment in terms of greenhouse gases (GHGs) emissions is a growing concern. Besides, large area requirement has limited further applications of the technology in urban areas. A novel assessment tool of integrating grey water footprint into the ecological footprint framework is established for the assessment of pilot-scale CWs. Findings are compared with a natural riparian wetland adjacent to the researched CWs which were monitored simultaneously. Results demonstrated the CWs had relatively good water quality polishing performance, especially for nitrogen removal. Nonetheless, a large amount of CO₂ and some CH₄ and N₂O emissions were recorded. Meanwhile, a substantial amount of CO₂ was also sequestrated by wetland plants via photosynthesis. The strong reducing environment of the CWs inhibited CO₂ and N₂O generation to a great extent. Calculation of all gaseous emissions and sequestration in CO₂ equivalents demonstrated that CWs are an efficient carbon sink. By contrast, the natural wetland was a carbon source because of the high emission of CO₂ and N₂O under its weak reducing environment conditions and low gross primary production. The carbon footprints of the constructed and natural wetlands were -24.24 and 12.99 gha respectively. Modified ecological footprint values were determined by integrating the carbon footprint, water footprint and build-up lands footprint, and a value of -24.36 gha was obtained for the CWs and 12.99 gha for the natural wetlands. The results indicated that the CWs had substantial beneficial impacts on the ecological environment. On account of the multifunctional service values provided by the CWs, a typical paradigm for water pollution remediation and carbon sequestration was presented for ecological and environmental governance, especially for riparian areas.

Plant species compositions alleviate toxicological effects of bisphenol A by enhancing growth, antioxidant defense system, and detoxification

Bisphenol A (BPA), a broadly disseminated endocrine disturbing chemicals in environment, is harmful to creatures and plants. Plants can uptake and metabolize BPA, but a single plant species ability is limited. Undeniably, plant species compositions have a more vital ability to remove pollutants than a single plant species. However, the mechanisms of plant species compositions alleviating toxicological effects of bisphenol A are poorly understood. Here, we administered plant species compositions, which based on a full-factorial design of Phragmites australis (A), Typha latifolia (B), and Arundo donax (C), to unveil their role in BPA exposure. The results illustrated that the root activity, biomass, and photosynthetic pigment contents of the mixed hydroponic group (e.g., sp(ABC)) were significantly increased under concentration of BPA(1.5, 5, and 10 mg L^-1), which showed that the root activity, fresh weight, dry weight, chlorophyll a, and total chlorophyll contents of shoots were increased. While mixed-hydroponic culture groups (e.g., sp(AB), sp(ABC)) significantly increased antioxidant enzyme activity and antioxidant substances under concentration of BPA(5 and 10 mg L^-1), it astoundingly diminished responsive oxygen species (ROS) and malondialdehyde (MDA) substance, proposing that mixed-hydroponic culture groups calmed oxidative stress. Further analysis revealed that mixed-hydroponic culture groups (e.g., sp(AB), sp(AC), sp(ABC)) of 1.5, 5, and 10 mg L^-1 BPA exposure significantly increased detoxification enzyme activity of NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase (CPR), glutathione S-transferase (GST), and glycosyltransferase (GT). Moreover, mixed-hydroponic culture groups (e.g., sp(AB), sp(AC), sp(ABC)) decreased the BPA substance in leaves, proposing that mixed-hydroponic culture groups advanced BPA metabolism by improving CPR, GST, and GT enzyme activities. These results demonstrated that a mixed-hydroponic culture strategy can alleviate BPA phytotoxicity and possibly offer natural and potential phytoremediation methods for BPA.

Assessment of plants radial oxygen loss for nutrients and organic matter removal in full-scale constructed wetlands treating municipal effluents

Bidirectional cross flow wetlands with different plant species were set to investigate seasonal variation in radial oxygen loss (ROL) and its effects on COD and NH₄⁺-N removal. Findings demonstrated a strong seasonal effect on the rate of ROL, with Arundo donax var.versicolor showing the highest ROL of 2.99 μmol·h^-1·g^-1. Additionally, ROL showed strong positive correlations with plant total biomass (P < 0.01), aboveground biomass (P < 0.01), height, maximum root length (P < 0.01), root porosity (P < 0.01), and removal efficiency of COD and NH₄⁺-N (P < 0.01). Furthermore, high-throughput sequencing analysis of substrate samples from three wetland units planted with Thalia dealbata, Canna indica and Arundo donax var. versicolor revealedProteobacteria as the predominant rhizospheric phylum. Relative abundance of Alpha- and Gamma-Proteobacteria were higher in the Arundo donax var.versicolor samples due to its higher oxygen transport capacity. These results demonstrate that root properties are important determinants for selecting appropriate plants for constructed wetland.

Distribution coefficients of nitrogen pollutants between water and sediment and their environmental risks in Lingang hybrid constructed wetland fed by industrial tailwater, Tianjin, China

Exploring the fate of nitrogen pollutants in constructed wetlands (CWs) fed by industrial tailwater is significant to strengthen its pollution control and promoting the development of CWs in the field of micro-polluted water treatment. In this study, the distribution coefficients and the environmental risks of nitrogen pollutants between water and sediment of the hybrid CW in Tianjin were systematically investigated. From a spatial perspective, the nitrogen pollutants could be removed in this hybrid CW, and subsurface flow wetland played a key role in nitrogen pollutant removal. From a temporal perspective, the concentration of nitrogen pollutants was largely affected by the dissolved oxygen (DO) and temperature. The distribution coefficient of nitrogen pollutants between water and sediment was further clarified, suggesting that NH₄⁺-N was more likely to be enriched in sediments due to microbial process. The overall level of pollution in hybrid CW was moderate according to the nutritional pollution index (NPI) analysis. The risk assessment indicated that timely dredging control measures should be considered to maintain the performance of hybrid CW.

Effects of biochar on the growth of Vallisneria natans in surface flow constructed wetland

To improve the nitrogen and phosphorus removal efficiency of surface flow constructed wetlands (SFCWs), biochar was added to an SFCW matrix. The effects of adding different amounts of biochar on water purification, the growth of Vallisneria natans (V. natans), and microbial mechanisms were explored through SFCW simulation experiments. The results showed that through the joint action of biochar and V. natans, the concentrations of total nitrogen, total phosphorus, and ammonia nitrogen in the effluent significantly decreased. The total biomass, relative growth rate, and chlorophyll content of V. natans were significantly reduced by adding biochar (≥20%, v/v), as the root activity and the root to leaf biomass ratio slightly increased at first and then decreased. The carbon and nitrogen contents of V. natans slightly increased with the addition of biochar (≥10%, v/v), but the phosphorus content slightly decreased. Moreover, the nitrogen content of the matrices decreased significantly over time (P<0.05), and the phosphorus content in the matrix showed an increasing trend in the same period. In addition, the microbial 16S rDNA sequencing results indicated that the diversity and abundance of the microbial community in the matrix of the biochar-added SFCW tended to decrease. Nevertheless, the abundance of functional bacteria related to nitrogen and phosphorus removal (i.e., Pseudomonas and Dechloromonas) slightly increased, which would benefit denitrification and dephosphorization in the SFCW. Hence, the addition of biochar to the SFCW matrix facilitated the improvement of effluent water quality, while excessive biochar addition (≥10%, v/v) restrained the growth of V. natans but did not cause death. This conclusion provides valid data support regarding the ability of biochar-added SFCW to purify lightly contaminated water.

Influent salinity affects substrate selection in surface flow constructed wetlands

To identify the effect of influent salinity on substrate selection, a study was conducted in pilot-scale surface flow constructed wetlands (SFCWs). Compared with gravel and sand SFCWs, soil SFCWs performed similarly or worse at low salinities, while at high salinities, soil SFCWs performed similarly or better in removal efficiency (RE) of salt, total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorous (TP), and chemical oxygen demand (COD). Soil generally increased macrophyte growth (especially at high salinity) in terms of biomass, leaf chlorophyll concentration, root activity, and root catalase and superoxide dismutase activities. A general decrease in bacterial α-diversity in the rhizosphere was observed at high salinity, while compared with gravel or sand, soil improved rhizosphere bacterial community stability at varying salinities. At high salinity, compared with that of gravel or sand, the soil support of macrophytes and rhizosphere microorganisms increased pollutant RE in SFCWs. This finding highlights the necessity of varying substrate selection in SFCWs with influent salinities for both increasing pollutant RE and reducing input cost, with soil recommended at high influent salinity.

An integrated migration and transformation model to evaluate the occurrence characteristics and environmental risks of Nitrogen and phosphorus in constructed wetland

In this study, an integrated migration and transformation (IMT) model based on microbial action, plant absorption, sediment release and substrate adsorption was firstly established to evaluate the temporal-spatial distribution of N and P in Lingang hybrid constructed wetland (CW), Tianjin. Compared to the conventional transformation model that only considers the microbial action, the IMT model could accurately predict the occurrence characteristics of N and P. In Lingang CW, NO₃^--N (0.56-3.63 mg/L) was the most important form of N, and the TP was at a relatively low concentration level (0.04-0.07 mg/L). The spatial distribution results showed that a certain amount of N and P could be removed by CW. Form the temporal perspective, the N and P concentrations were greatly affected by the dissolved oxygen (DO). The simulated values obtained by IMT model indicated that the distribution of N and P was more affected by the temporality compared with the spatiality, which was consistent with measured values. Besides, the PCA indicated that TN, NO₃^--N and DO were important factors, which affected the water quality of CW. The Nemerow pollution index method based on the simulated values indicated that Lingang CW was overall moderately polluted, and the subsurface area was the main functional unit of pollutants removal in CW. This work provides a new model for accurately predicting the occurrence characteristics of N and P pollutants in CW, which is of great significance for identifying its environmental risks and optimizing the construction of wetlands.

Interspecific competition and their impacts on the growth of macrophytes and pollutants removal within constructed wetland microcosms treating domestic wastewater

Eight free water surface constructed wetland microcosm (CWM) units are designed with single as well as mixed planting of Pistia stratiotes, Phragmites karka, and Typha latifolia with control to assess their competitive value (CV), relative growth rates (RGR), and pollutants removal efficiency. Further, the total dry biomass production and other growth parameters such as number of macrophytes, above-ground biomass, below-ground biomass, and root length were also measured to understand the dominant characteristics of the macrophytes. The CWM units with species mixture out-performed species monocultures. Removal of BOD, TP, SRP, NH₄⁺-N, NO₃^--N, and NO₂^--N by mixed planting of P. stratiotes and P. karka was higher at most of the time. Typha latifolia was the superior competitor against both P. stratiotes and P. karka due to its aggressive characteristics that inhibits the growth of neighboring macrophytes. However, P. karka was the superior competitor against P. stratiotes. The RGR of T. latifolia in all experimental units was almost two times more than that of P. karka. Novelty Statement The CWM units with species mixture out-performed species monocultures. CWMs with more than one macrophytic species are less vulnerable to seasonal fluctuations and more effective in contaminants removal as compared to single macrophyte wetlands. Removal of BOD, TP, SRP, NH₄⁺-N, NO₃^--N, and NO₂^--N by mixed planting of P. stratiotes and P. karka was higher at most of the time. The CWMs with P. stratiotes and P. karka are superior choice due to their higher wastewater nutrients removal capacity. The application of these three macrophytes in mixed cultures in free water surface constructed wetland is rare. The results are useful in designing large-scale multi-species wetlands which are less susceptible to seasonal variation and more effective in pollutants removal than single-species wetlands.

Microbial abundance and community in constructed wetlands planted with Phragmites australis and Typha orientalis in winter

The microbial abundance and communities were characterized in CWs with different plant species during winter. Better removal efficiency with high microbial abundance and diversified microbial community were found in CWs planted with Phragmites australis. This study confirmed that in winter, withered plants in CWs can effectively remove NH₄⁺-N and COD by affecting microbial abundance and community structure.

The improvement of pollutant removal efficiency in saturated vertical flow constructed wetlands by tubifex tubifex

Pilot-scale saturated vertical flow constructed wetlands (VF-CWs) were established to identify whether T. tubifex has the similar performance in saturated VF-CWs to that in surface flow CWs in improving pollutant removal efficiency (RE). The saturated VF-CWs with T. tubifex achieved REs of 67.3% total nitrogen (TN) and 39.8% chemical oxygen demand (COD), which were significantly higher than treatments without T. tubifex (42.2% TN and 31.4% COD). There existed significant interactions between macrophytes and T. tubifex. T. tubifex greatly improved the dissolved oxygen by increasing the connectivity between layers, and enhanced dehydrogenase activity and fluorescein diacetate. Adding T. tubifex improved the bacterial diversity and relative abundance of both N-cycle bacteria and fermentation bacteria in the biofilms. The improvements of ammonia oxidation and anammox were the main pathways for the increased nitrogen removal by T. tubifex. Therefore, T. tubifex is a useful tool for improving pollutant REs in saturated VF-CWs.

Design, Operation and Optimization of Constructed Wetland for Removal of Pollutant

Constructed wetlands (CWs) are affordable and reliable green technologies for the treatment of various types of wastewater. Compared to conventional treatment systems, CWs offer an environmentally friendly approach, are low cost, have fewer operational and maintenance requirements, and have a high potential for being applied in developing countries, particularly in small rural communities. However, the sustainable management and successful application of these systems remain a challenge. Therefore, after briefly providing basic information on wetlands and summarizing the classification and use of current CWs, this study aims to provide and inspire sustainable solutions for the performance and application of CWs by giving a comprehensive review of CWs' application and the recent development of their sustainable design, operation, and optimization for wastewater treatment. To accomplish this objective, thee design and management parameters of CWs, including macrophyte species, media types, water level, hydraulic retention time (HRT), and hydraulic loading rate (HLR), are discussed. Besides these, future research on improving the stability and sustainability of CWs are highlighted. This article provides a tool for researchers and decision-makers for using CWs to treat wastewater in a particular area. This paper presents an aid for informed analysis, decision-making, and communication. The review indicates that major advances in the design, operation, and optimization of CWs have greatly increased contaminant removal efficiencies, and the sustainable application of this treatment system has also been improved.

Effects of plants competition on critical bacteria selection and pollutants dynamics in a long-term polyculture constructed wetland

The effects of mix planting on the functions of plants, microorganisms, and their interactions were studied in a CW planted with Phragmites australis and Typha orientalis over six years. Findings show notable competition among plant species, with excessive overgrowth of the dominant species (P. australis) over T. orientalis. The excessive outcompeting by P. australis resulted in significantly higher plant density and biomass of 20.1 times and 11.2 times, respectively than that of T. orientalis. Interspecific competition appeared to considerably intensify plants contributions to nitrogen and phosphorus removal, which increased from circa 9% in the first year up to 42% in the sixth year. High-throughput pyrosequencing and network analyses demonstrated that the dominant species stands harbor diverse bacterial communities that could enhance the wetland performance through carbon degradation, nutrient cycling, and supporting plant growth. These results provide useful insights into the interactive effects of plants and bacteria in polyculture constructed wetlands.

Evaluation of the long-term performance in a large-scale integrated surface flow constructed wetland-pond system: A case study

Limited information is available in regards to the long-term treatment performance of large-scale integrated surface flow constructed wetland-pond (ISFWP) system improving drinking water source. This study aimed to investigate the treatment performance of a large-scale ISFWP system for the improvement of drinking water source. During five years of operation, the average effluent water quality in the ISFWP system could comply with Chinese Environmental Quality Standards for Drinking Water Source. The average removal efficiencies of permanganate index (COD_Mn), ammonia nitrogen, total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorus, and fecal coliforms were 7.6%, 44.3%, 42.9%, 50.8%, and 88.6%, respectively. The treatment performance in the ISFWP system was stable during the operation time, while TN removal efficiency declined by 38.2% after five years of operation. Moreover, contaminants removal efficiencies were not subject to change of season, except for COD_Mn and TN. Consequently, efficient and sustainable contaminants removal in the large-scale ISFWP system still possessed challenges, especially for COD_Mn and TN.

Assessing the safe operating space of aquatic macrophyte biomass to control the terrestrialization of a grass-type shallow lake in China

As an important type of aquatic ecosystem, lake ecosystems play an irreplaceable role in providing water resources, controlling floods, regulating the regional climate, and maintaining the regional ecological balance. However, multiple lake ecosystems have been threatened by the expansion of aquatic macrophytes and the resulting bioaccumulation, which accelerates the process of lake terrestrialization. Therefore, it is necessary to identify the safe operating space of macrophyte biomass in order to control the terrestrialization of shallow lakes. In this study, we investigated the biomasses of dominant species and community types at different growth stages in different terrestrialized zones for a typical shallow lake in North China. Then, we developed a suitable method for estimating the safe operating space for the aquatic macrophyte biomass in different terrestrialization stages. Our results showed that the aquatic macrophyte biomass generally increased with the increasing terrestrialization stage. In addition, the biomass in September was lower than that in May. On the community scale, the biomass of Phragmites australis, Phragmites australis - Ceratophyllum demersum, and Nelumbo nucifera - Ceratophyllum demersum - Typha orientalis communities was significantly higher than that of Potamogeton pectinatus and Potamogeton pectinatus - Nelumbo nucifera communities. Terrestrialization exhibited lower impacts on plant biomass in May, whereas a greater impact of terrestrialization was observed in September. Generally, single-species communities had higher plant biomass than mixed communities. The target management years for different terrestrialized zones were established to calculate the safe operating space of macrophyte biomass. The current biomass values were much higher than those calculated for the safe operating space, especially in September and for the P. australis and P. australis - C. demersum communities, indicating that there is high pressure to manage these communities. The approach proposed in the study provides a scientific reference for macrophyte management to control the terrestrialization status of grass-type shallow lakes.

Superposition effect of floating and fixed beds in series for enhancing nitrogen and phosphorus removal in a multistage pond system

In order to improve the efficiency of nitrogen and phosphorus removal in a multistage pond system which receives polluted natural inflow and outflows to a landscape lake, ecological floating beds (EFBs) were installed along the flow-path of each pond and fixed beds (FBs) were embedded in between each pair of ponds. Such a simple modification of the MPS effectively enhanced the total nitrogen (TN) removal rate from 59.2% to 71.4% and the total phosphorus (TP) removal rate from 37.1% to 51.0%. It was identified that the EFBs mainly contributed to enhanced TN removal by the biomass growth in the stereo-elastic packing and attachment on the surface of ceramsite particles packed in the floating mat, while the FB filled with zeolites contributed to both TP adsorption and biological TN removal to certain extent, as indicated by the denitrification rate and adsorption function experimentally obtained for each part of the bed settings. The superposition effect of the installation of EFBs and FBs was estimated using a tank-in-series model. With a Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency higher than 0.75, calculation results of the model well fitted field measurements and showed that the EFBs (including plant uptake) contributed to the increase of TN and TP removal by 23.3% and 8.12%, respectively, and that contributed by FBs were 19.6% and 10.7%, respectively.

Multiphasic assessment of effects of design configuration on nutrient removal in storing multiple-pond constructed wetlands

As an important technology for purifying and recycling agricultural wastewater, storing multiple-pond constructed wetlands (SMCWs) are widely used in the treatment of non-point source pollution. However, the influences of design configuration (surface area, volume, flow path, aspect ratio, water depth, percent vegetation cover and planting pattern) on pollution mitigation in SMCWs are still underexplored. To improve the sustainability of constructed wetlands, the removal performances of four groups of SMCWs were assessed through multiphasic analyses. The maximum removal efficiencies of nitrogen and phosphorus were 63.7% and 64.0%, respectively. Higher mass removal rates per square meter (MRR) and mass removal rates per cubic meter (MRR_V) were observed in ecological floating treatment wetlands (EFTWs). Compared with RE, the interception performances of deep-water SMCWs were more clearly described by using MRR and MRR_V. EFTWs with good plant configurations (mixed planting, 60-80% plant cover) were recommended in deep-water SMCWs (water depth > 1.5 m).

Improved test to determine design parameters for optimization of free surface flow constructed wetlands

Orthogonal tests were performed to assess the effect of design parameters on hydraulic and treatment performances of constructed wetlands. The results showed that water depth, layout of in- and outlet, flow rate, and aspect ratio mainly affected hydraulic performance, and water depth, plant spacing, and layout of in- and outlet mainly affected treatment performance. Optimal integrated performance was achieved with combination of 20-30 cm water depth, five evenly distributed inlets and one middle outlet, a flow rate of 0.4-0.55 m³/h, 20-cm plant spacing, a 1.125:1 aspect ratio, and planted with Scripus tabernaemontani. The average treatment performances of 27.2%, 16.3%, and 30.7% removal rates were received for total nitrogen, total phosphorus, and total suspended solid, respectively. The design parameters that significantly influenced hydraulic performance did not significantly influence treatment performance. Various hydraulic and purification indicators displayed extremely significant correlations. There was a significant correlation between hydraulic performance and mass removal capacity.

Influence of vegetation type and temperature on the performance of constructed wetlands for nutrient removal

In this study, the influence of vegetation type and environmental temperature on performance of constructed wetlands (CWs) was investigated. Results of vegetation types indicated that the removal of most nutrients in polyculture was greater than those in monoculture and unplanted control. The greatest removal percentages of NH₄⁺-N, total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) in polyculture were 98.7%, 98.5%, and 92.6%, respectively. In experiments of different temperatures, the removal percentages of NH₄⁺-N, NO₃^--N, TN and TP in all CWs tended to decrease with the decline of temperature. Especially, a sharp decline in the removal percentages of NO₃^--N (decreased by above 13.8%) and TN (decreased by above 7.9%) of all CWs was observed at low temperature (average temperature of 8.9 °C). Overall, the performance of CWs was obviously influenced by temperature, and the polyculture still showed best performance in the removal of nitrogen when the average temperature dropped to 19.8 °C. Additionally, the variations of urease activities in rhizosphere soil tended to decrease with the decreasing temperature. Overall, a substantial enhancement for nitrogen and TP removal in polyculture (Canna indica + Lythrum salicaria) was observed. In conclusion, CW cultivated with polyculture was a good strategy for enhancing nutrient removal when temperature was above 19.8 °C.

Test study of the optimal design for hydraulic performance and treatment performance of free water surface flow constructed wetland

Orthogonal tests with mixed levels of design parameters of a free water surface flow constructed wetland were performed to assess their effect on hydraulic and treatment performance, and discover the relationship between the design parameters and the two performances. The results showed that water depth, plant spacing, and layout of in- and outlet mainly affected the two performances. Under 40cm depth, central pass of in- and outlet, 1.8m³/h flow rate, 20cm plant spacing, 2:1 aspect ratio, and Scripus tabernaemontani as the plant species, treatment performance of 5.3% TN, 6.1% TP and 15.6% TSS removal efficiencies and a high hydraulic performance of 0.854e, 0.602MI were achieved. There was no significant correlation between the design parameters and the two performances. The relationship among various hydraulic indicators and that among the purification indicators displayed extremely significant correlation. However, there was no significant correlation between hydraulic and treatment performance.

Effect of plant species compositions on performance of lab-scale constructed wetland through investigating photosynthesis and microbial communities

This study focused on the effects of plant compositions on removal rates of pollutants in microcosms through investigating rhizosphere microbial populations, photosynthetic efficiency and growth characteristics. Mixed-culture groups improved the removal efficiency of TN and TP significantly but exhibited lower COD removal rates. Total plant biomasses were improved as the species richness increased, but the N/P content in the plants was mainly affected by the type of species. The mixed-culture groups showed lower photosynthesis rates and oxygen supply generated from roots under high irradiation. Microbial communities of the cultured groups in the rhizosphere exhibited significant differences. According to principal component analysis (PCA), the fungi were the typical microbes of SPA, SPAB, and SPABC, resulted in improvement in nutrient accumulation. These results demonstrated that a mixed culture strategy can represent the overyielding of biomass, promote the photo-protection mechanism, and will further increase the removal rates of pollutants in a constructed wetland.

Halophytes as vertical-flow constructed wetland vegetation for domestic wastewater treatment

Recent findings show that halophytes have the ability to accumulate salts in their tissues, making them a very interesting group of plants for domestic wastewater treatment in constructed wetlands (CWs). In that case, it might be possible to reduce the salinity of the final effluent, which is a crucial parameter for wastewater reuse in agriculture. During this study three halophytes, Atriplex halimus, Juncus acutus and Sarcocornia perennis, were tested for phyto-desalination of domestic wastewater in a vertical flow constructed wetland (VFCW) and compared with common reeds (Phragmites australis). In addition, the effect of this alternative vegetation on the overall performance of the system regarding organic matter, nutrients, boron and pathogen removal was monitored. The organic loading rate (OLR) was about 21gCOD/m²/d and the hydraulic loading rate (HLR) was 95mm/d in both cases. Promising results were obtained for A. halimus, which shows high biomass productivity and significant capability to accumulate salts, mainly Na, in its tissues. A positive effect on pathogen removal efficiency was also recorded. However, nitrogen concentration in the effluent of the VFCW planted with halophytes was found to be higher than in the effluent of the VFCW planted with reeds. Finally, no significant effect on organic matter and phosphorus removal efficiency was observed from the use of halophytes in place of reeds.

Enhanced nutrient removal and mechanisms study in benthic fauna added surface-flow constructed wetlands: The role of Tubifex tubifex

This study designed a combined benthic fauna-T. orientalis-substrate-microbes surface-flow constructed wetlands (SFCWs) through the addition of T. tubifex. Results showed that, the removal efficiencies of nitrogen and phosphorus in the tested SFCWs achieved 81.14±4.16% and 70.49±7.60%, which were 22.27% and 27.35% higher than that without T. tubifex. Lower nitrate (2.11±0.79mg/L) and ammonium (0.75±0.64mg/L) were also observed in the tested SFCWs, which were 3.46mg/L and 0.52mg/L lower than that without T. tubifex. Microbial study confirmed the increased denitrifiers with T. tubifex. The lower nitrogen in effluent was also attributed to higher contents of nitrogen storage in sediment and T. orientalis due to the bioturbation of T. tubifex. Furthermore, with T. tubifex, higher proportions of particulate (22.66±3.96%) and colloidal phosphorus (20.57±3.39%) observed promoted phosphorus settlement and further absorption by T. orientalis. The outcomes of this study provides an ecological and economical strategy for improving the performance of SFCWs.

Optimizations on supply and distribution of dissolved oxygen in constructed wetlands: A review

Dissolved oxygen (DO) is one of the most important factors that can influence pollutants removal in constructed wetlands (CWs). However, problems of insufficient oxygen supply and inappropriate oxygen distribution commonly exist in traditional CWs. Detailed analyses of DO supply and distribution characteristics in different types of CWs were introduced. It can be concluded that atmospheric reaeration (AR) served as the promising point on oxygen intensification. The paper summarized possible optimizations of DO in CWs to improve its decontamination performance. Process (tidal flow, drop aeration, artificial aeration, hybrid systems) and parameter (plant, substrate and operating) optimizations are particularly discussed in detail. Since economic and technical defects are still being cited in current studies, future prospects of oxygen research in CWs terminate this review.