In vitro evaluation of co-exposure of arsenium and an organic nanomaterial (fullerene, C₆₀) in zebrafish hepatocytes

Alleviative effects of C60 fullerene nanoparticles on arsenate transformation and toxicity to Danio rerio

Widely-used C60 fullerene nanoparticles (C60) result in their release into the aquatic environment, which may affect the distribution and toxicity of pollutants such as arsenic (As), to aquatic organism. In this study, arsenate (As(V)) accumulation, speciation and subcellular distribution was determined in Danio rerio (zebrafish) intestine, head and muscle tissues in the presence of C60. Meanwhile we compared how single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs), multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs), graphene oxide (GO) and graphene (GN) nanoparticles alter the behaviors of As(V). Results showed that C60 significantly inhibited As accumulation and toxicity in D. rerio, due to a decrease in total As and monomethylarsonic acid (MMA) and As(V) species concentrations, a lower relative distribution in the metal-sensitive fraction (MSF). It was attributed that C60 may coat As(V) ion channels and consequently, affect the secretion of digestive enzymes in the gut, favoring As excretion and inhibiting As methylation. Similarly, MWCNTs reduced the species concentration of MMA and As(V) in the intestines, low GSH (glutathione) contents in the intestine. Due to the disparity of other carbon-based nanomaterial morphologies, SWCNTs, GO and GN exhibited the various effects on the toxicity of As(V). In addition, the possible pathway of arsenobetaine (AsB) biosynthesis included migration from the intestine to muscle in D. rerio, with the precursor of AsB likely to be 2-dimethylarsinylacetic acid (DMAA). The results of this study suggest that C60 is beneficial for controlling As(V) pollution and reducing the impact of As(V) biogeochemical cycles throughout the ecosystem.

Accumulation, transformation and subcellular distribution of arsenite associated with five carbon nanomaterials in freshwater zebrafish specific-tissues

Although carbon nanomaterials (CNMs) commonly exist throughout the aquatic environment, their effect on arsenic (As) distribution and toxicity is unclear. In this study, arsenite accumulation, transformation, subcellular distribution, and enzyme activity were assessed in adult zebrafish (Danio rerio) intestines, heads and muscles, following co-exposure to arsenite and CNMs with different structures (single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs), multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs), fullerene (C₆₀), graphene oxide (GO), and graphene (GN)). Results show that GN and GO promoted As toxicity in D. rerio, as carriers increasing total As accumulation in the intestine, resulting in arsenite adsorbed by GO and GN being released and transformed mainly into moderately-toxic monomethylarsonic acid (MMA), which was mostly distributed in organelles and metallothionein-like proteins (MTLPs). Moreover, GO and GN influenced As species distribution in D. rerio due to the excellent electron transfer ability. However, the effect was marginal for SWCNT, MWCNT and C₆₀, because of the different structure and suspension stability in fish-culture water. In addition, in the muscle and head tissues, As was mainly distributed in cellular debris in the forms of dimethylarsinic acid (DMA) and arsenobetaine (AsB). These findings help better understand the influence of CNMs on the mechanism of As toxicity in natural aquatic environments.

Status Quo in Data Availability and Predictive Models of Nano-Mixture Toxicity

Co-exposure of nanomaterials and chemicals can cause mixture toxicity effects to living organisms. Predictive models might help to reduce the intensive laboratory experiments required for determining the toxicity of the mixtures. Previously, concentration addition (CA), independent action (IA), and quantitative structure–activity relationship (QSAR)-based models were successfully applied to mixtures of organic chemicals. However, there were few studies concerning predictive models for toxicity of nano-mixtures before June 2020. Previous reviews provided comprehensive knowledge of computational models and mechanisms for chemical mixture toxicity. There is a gap in the reviewing of datasets and predictive models, which might cause obstacles in the toxicity assessment of nano-mixtures by using in silico approach. In this review, we collected 183 studies of nano-mixture toxicity and curated data to investigate the current data and model availability and gap and to derive research challenges to facilitate further experimental studies for data gap filling and the development of predictive models.

Zebrafish as an Emerging Model System in the Global South: Two Decades of Research in Brazil

The zebrafish (Danio rerio) is an emerging model system in several research areas worldwide, especially in the Global South. In this context, the present study revised the historical use and trends of zebrafish as experimental models in Brazil. The data concerning the bibliometric parameters, research areas, geographic distribution, experimental design, zebrafish strain, and reporter lines, as well as recent advances were revised. In addition, the comparative trends of Brazilian and global research were discussed. Revised data showed the rapid growth of Brazilian scientific production using zebrafish as a model, especially in three main research areas (Neuroscience &and Behavior, Pharmacology and Toxicology, and Environment/Ecology). Studies were conducted in 19 Brazilian states (70.37%), confirming the wide geographic distribution and importance of zebrafish research. Results indicated that research related to toxicological approaches are widespread in Global South countries such as Brazil. Studies were performed mainly using in vivo tests (89.58%) with adult fish (59.75%) and embryos (30.67%). Moreover, significant research gaps and recommendations for future research are presented. The present study shows that the zebrafish is a suitable vertebrate model system in the Global South.

Carbon Nanotubes Modulate Activity of Cytotoxic Compounds via a Trojan Horse Mechanism

Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) are an emerging drug delivery system, but their success is thwarted by potential toxicity concerns. In vitro and in vivo studies imply toxic potential of CNTs, but their potential to influence toxicity of coadministered compounds still remains elusive. Therefore, the present study was conducted to determine the effect of multiwalled CNTs (MWCNTs) on the toxicity of cytotoxic compounds in macrophage (RAW 264.7), lung epithelial (A549), and breast cancer (MCF-7) cell lines. The results suggest that hydrophilicity/lipophilicity of the compounds is a critical parameter. The correlation between log P and enhanced cytotoxic activity followed an inverted U-shaped curve and log P close to 1 exhibited the highest increase in cytotoxicity. Further, the increase in cytotoxicity of drug/MWCNT combinations was proportional to the degree of cellular uptake of MWCNTs. A mathematical model was developed and validated with a test set of compounds. These results suggest that MWCNTs act as a "Trojan horse" for increased intracellular delivery of drugs resulting in enhanced cytotoxic activity.

Bioconcentration and bioaccumulation of C60 fullerene and C60 epoxide in biofilms and freshwater snails (Radix sp.)

Fullerenes are carbon nanomaterials that have awaken a strong interest due to their adsorption properties and potential applications in many fields. However, there are some gaps of information about their effects and bioconcentration potential in the aquatic biota. In the present work, freshwater biofilms and snails (Radix sp.) were exposed to fullerene C₆₀ aggregates, at concentrations in the low μg/L order, in mesocosms specifically designed to mimic the conditions of a natural stream. The bioconcentration factors of C₆₀ fullerene and its main transformation product, [6,6]C₆₀O epoxide, were studied to the mentioned organisms employing analyses by liquid chromatography coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry. Our results show that C₆₀ fullerene and its [6,6]C₆₀O present a low bioconcentration factor (BCF) to biofilms: BCF_C60 = 1.34 ± 0.95 L/kg_dw and BCF_C60O = 1.43 ± 0.72 L/kg_dw. This suggests that the sorption of these aggregates to biota may be less favoured than it would be suggested by its hydrophobic character. According to our model, the surface of fullerene aggregates is saturated with [6,6]C₆₀O molecules, which exposes the polar epoxide moieties in the surface of the aggregates and decreases their affinity to biofilms. In contrast, freshwater snails showed a moderate capacity to actively retain C₆₀ fullerenes in their organism (BAF_C60 = 2670 ± 3070 L/kg_dw; BAF_C60O = 1330 ± 1680 L/kg_dw), probably through ingestion. Our results indicate that the bioaccumulation of these carbon nanomaterials can be hardly estimated using their respective octanol-water partition coefficients, and that their colloidal properties, as well as the feeding strategies of the tested organism, play fundamental roles.

Alleviative Effects of C60 on the Trophic Transfer of Cadmium along the Food Chain in Aquatic Environment

C₆₀ could enhance the accumulation of pollutants in organisms, but their effects on higher trophic levels remain unknown. In the present study, the transfer of C₆₀ from Daphnia magna to zebrafish (Danio rerio) and its effects on Cd transfer were investigated. The results showed that C₆₀ could be transferred from D. magna to zebrafish through dietary exposure and accumulate mainly in the intestines, but biomagnification was not observed. The presence of C₆₀ promoted accumulation of Cd in D. magna. However, it decreased Cd burden in the higher trophic level (zebrafish), displaying an alleviative effect on the trophic transfer of Cd along the food chain. To explore the underlying mechanisms, the release of Cd from D. magna in digestive fluids and changes in zebrafish digestive physiology were further investigated. The results showed that C₆₀ did not inhibit Cd release from D. magna, but stimulated the digestive tracts of zebrafish to excrete Cd earlier and in a greater amount, which consequently lowered assimilation efficiency of Cd in zebrafish. Overall, the present study showed the trophic transfer of C₆₀ in the aquatic food chain and revealed the effects of C₆₀ on trophic transfer of Cd along the food chain in aquatic environment.

Environmental mixtures of nanomaterials and chemicals: The Trojan-horse phenomenon and its relevance for ecotoxicity

The usage of engineered nanomaterials (NM) offers many novel products and applications with advanced features, but at the same time raises concerns with regard to potential adverse biological effects. Upon release and emission, NM may interact with chemicals in the environment, potentially leading to a co-exposure of organisms and the occurrence of mixture effects. A prominent idea is that NM may act as carriers of chemicals, facilitating and enhancing the entry of substances into cells or organisms, subsequently leading to an increased toxicity. In the literature, the term 'Trojan-horse effect' describes this hypothesis. The relevance of this mechanism for organisms is, however, unclear as yet. Here, a review has been performed to provide a more systematic picture on existing evidence. It includes 151 experimental studies investigating the exposure of various NM and chemical mixtures in ecotoxicological in vitro and in vivo model systems. The papers retrieved comprised studies investigating (i) uptake, (ii) toxicity and (iii) investigations considering both, changes in substance uptake and toxicity upon joint exposure of a chemical with an NM. A closer inspection of the studies demonstrated that the existing evidence for interference of NM-chemical mixture exposure with uptake and toxicity points into different directions compared to the original Trojan-horse hypothesis. We could discriminate at least 7 different categories to capture the evidence ranging from no changes in uptake and toxicity to an increase in uptake and toxicity upon mixture exposure. Concluding recommendations for the consideration of relevant processes are given, including a proposal for a nomenclature to describe NM-chemical mixture interactions in consistent terms.

Insight into the Mechanisms of Combined Toxicity of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes and Nickel Ions in Macrophages: Role of P2X7 Receptor

Coexistence of nanomaterials and environmental pollutants requires in-depth understanding of combined toxicity and underlying mechanism. In this work, we found that coexposure to the mixture of noncytotoxic level of single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) (10 μg/mL) and Ni²⁺ (20 μM) induced significant cytotoxicity in macrophages. However, almost equal amount of intracellular Ni²⁺ was detected after Ni²⁺/SWCNT coexposure or Ni²⁺ single exposure, indicating no enhanced cellular uptake of Ni²⁺ occurred. SDS-PAGE analysis revealed 50% more SWCNTs retained in Ni²⁺/SWCNT exposed cells than that with SWCNT exposure alone, regardless of the exposure sequence (coexposure, Ni²⁺ pre- or post-treatment), suggesting inhibited SWCNT exocytosis by Ni²⁺. The increased cellular dose of SWCNTs could quantitatively account for the elevated toxicity of Ni²⁺/SWCNT mixture to cells. It was then found that agonist (ATP) and antagonist (o-ATP) of P2X₇R could regulate intracellular SWCNT amount and the cytotoxicity accordingly. In addition, inhibition of P2X₇R by P2X₇-targeting siRNA diminished the inhibitory effect of Ni²⁺. It was therefore concluded that Ni²⁺ impeded SWCNT exocytosis by inhibiting P2X₇R, leading to higher intracellular retention of SWCNTs and elevated cytotoxicity. Our work identified exocytosis inhibition as an important mechanism for SWCNT/Ni²⁺ toxicity, and revealed the crucial role of P2X₇R in mediating such inhibitory effect.

Co-exposure with fullerene may strengthen health effects of organic industrial chemicals

In vitro toxicological studies together with atomistic molecular dynamics simulations show that occupational co-exposure with C₆₀ fullerene may strengthen the health effects of organic industrial chemicals. The chemicals studied are acetophenone, benzaldehyde, benzyl alcohol, m-cresol, and toluene which can be used with fullerene as reagents or solvents in industrial processes. Potential co-exposure scenarios include a fullerene dust and organic chemical vapor, or a fullerene solution aerosolized in workplace air. Unfiltered and filtered mixtures of C₆₀ and organic chemicals represent different co-exposure scenarios in in vitro studies where acute cytotoxicity and immunotoxicity of C₆₀ and organic chemicals are tested together and alone by using human THP-1-derived macrophages. Statistically significant co-effects are observed for an unfiltered mixture of benzaldehyde and C₆₀ that is more cytotoxic than benzaldehyde alone, and for a filtered mixture of m-cresol and C₆₀ that is slightly less cytotoxic than m-cresol. Hydrophobicity of chemicals correlates with co-effects when secretion of pro-inflammatory cytokines IL-1β and TNF-α is considered. Complementary atomistic molecular dynamics simulations reveal that C₆₀ co-aggregates with all chemicals in aqueous environment. Stable aggregates have a fullerene-rich core and a chemical-rich surface layer, and while essentially all C₆₀ molecules aggregate together, a portion of organic molecules remains in water.

Nanoparticle tracking analysis characterisation and parts-per-quadrillion determination of fullerenes in river samples from Barcelona catchment area

In the present work, the analysis of seven fullerenes (C60 and C70 fullerenes and five functionalised fullerenes) has been performed in river samples collected in the vicinities of Barcelona (Catalonia, NE of Spain). The results of 48 samples (25 river waters, 12 river sediments and 11 wastewater effluents) are presented. Extracts of river water, river sediments and wastewater effluents were analysed by liquid chromatography (LC), using a pyrenylpropyl group bonded silica based column, coupled to a high-resolution mass spectrometer (HRMS), using a dual ion source, atmospheric pressure photoionisation/atmospheric pressure chemical ionisation source (APPI/APCI). The novel methodology presents good chromatographic separation, excellent selectivity and instrumental limits of quantification (ILOQ) in the femtogram order. Method limits of quantification (MLOQ) ranged from 2.9 to 17 pg/l and from 3.2 to 31 pg/l in surface waters and wastewaters, respectively. In wastewater effluents, the sums of C60 and C70 ranged from 0.5 to 9.3 ng/l. In surface waters, C60 fullerene was the most ubiquitous compound, being detected in 100% of the samples in concentrations from 31 pg/l to 4.5 ng/l, while C70 concentrations ranged from less than the method limits of detection (MLOD) to 1.5 ng/l. The presence of fullerenes in both the large particulate (diameter Ø > 450 nm) and the colloidal (Ø < 450 nm) fractions of surface waters should be noticed. In sediments, the concentrations of fullerenes were between the MLOD and 34.4 pg/g. In addition, nanoparticle tracking analysis (NTA) was used for the characterisation of water samples in terms of nanoparticle number concentration and size distribution. As far as our knowledge is concerned, this is the first time that NTA has been used for the characterisation of complex river waters with an environmental focus.

Emergent Properties and Toxicological Considerations for Nanohybrid Materials in Aquatic Systems

Conjugation of multiple nanomaterials has become the focus of recent materials development. This new material class is commonly known as nanohybrids or "horizon nanomaterials". Conjugation of metal/metal oxides with carbonaceous nanomaterials and overcoating or doping of one metal with another have been pursued to enhance material performance and/or incorporate multifunctionality into nano-enabled devices and processes. Nanohybrids are already at use in commercialized energy, electronics and medical products, which warrant immediate attention for their safety evaluation. These conjugated ensembles likely present a new set of physicochemical properties that are unique to their individual component attributes, hence increasing uncertainty in their risk evaluation. Established toxicological testing strategies and enumerated underlying mechanisms will thus need to be re-evaluated for the assessment of these horizon materials. This review will present a critical discussion on the altered physicochemical properties of nanohybrids and analyze the validity of existing nanotoxicology data against these unique properties. The article will also propose strategies to evaluate the conjugate materials' safety to help undertake future toxicological research on the nanohybrid material class.