Effects of biochar on the transformation and earthworm bioaccumulation of organic pollutants in soil

The interaction between biochar and earthworms: Revealing the potential ecological risks of biochar application and the feasibility of their co-application

Biochar's interaction with soil-dwelling organisms, particularly earthworms, is crucial in ensuring the effective and secure utilization of biochar in the soil. This review introduces the application of biochar in soil, summarizes how earthworms respond to biochar-amended soil and the underlying factors that can influence their response, discusses the synergistic and antagonistic impacts of earthworm activity on the efficacy of biochar, and considers the feasibility of applying them together. A review of existing research has identified uncertainty in the effect of biochar exposure on earthworms, with biochar derived from animal wastes, produced at higher pyrolysis temperatures, and used at higher doses of biochar having more negative effects on earthworms. Habitat modification, toxicity release, particle effects, and contaminant immobilization are underlying factors in how biochar affects earthworm indicators. While biochar in contaminated soils may alleviate the stress of pollutants on earthworms by decreasing their bioaccumulation, this remedial effect is not always effective. Additionally, earthworm bioturbation can enhance the migration, fragmentation, and oxidation of biochar, while also stimulating extracellular enzymes that convert biochar into 'vermichar'. Earthworms and biochar can synergize well to improve soil fertility and remediate soil organic pollution, yet exhibit contrasting roles in soil C sequestration and immobilizing heavy metals in soil. These findings highlight both the advantages and risks of their co-application. Therefore, when considering the use of biochar alone or with earthworms, it is crucial to thoroughly assess its potential ecotoxicity on earthworms and other soil organisms, as well as the influence of bioturbation, such as that caused by earthworms, on the effectiveness of biochar.

Biochar alters the soil fauna functional traits and community diversity: A quantitative and cascading perspective

With the widespread use of biochar, the cascading effects of biochar exposure on soil fauna urgently require deeper understanding. A meta-analysis quantified hierarchical changes in functional traits and community diversity of soil fauna under biochar exposure. Antioxidant enzymes (24.1 %) did not fully mitigate the impact of MDA (13.5 %), leading to excessive DNA damage in soil fauna (21.2 %). Concurrently, reproduction, growth, and survival rates decreased by 20.2 %, 8.5 %, and 21.2 %, respectively. Due to a 39.7 % increase in avoidance behavior of soil fauna towards biochar, species richness ultimately increased by 80.2 %. Compared to other feeding habits, biochar posed a greater threat to the survival of herbivores. Additionally, macrofauna were the most sensitive to biochar. The response of soil fauna also depended on the type, size, concentration, and duration of biochar exposure. It should be emphasized that as exposure concentration increased, the damage to soil fauna became more severe. Furthermore, the smaller the biochar sizes, the greater the damage to soil fauna. To mitigate the adverse effects on soil fauna, this study recommens applying biochar at appropriate times and selecting large sizes in low to medium concentrations. These findings confirm the threat of biochar to soil health from the perspective of soil fauna.

Biochar modulating soil biological health: A review

Biochar can be used for multifunctional applications including the improvement of soil health and carbon storage, remediation of contaminated soil and water resources, mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions and odorous compounds, and feed supplementation to improve animal health. A healthy soil preserves microbial biodiversity that is effective in supressing plant pathogens and pests, recycling nutrients for plant growth, promoting positive symbiotic associations with plant roots, improving soil structure to supply water and nutrients, and ultimately enhancing soil productivity and plant growth. As a soil amendment, biochar assures soil biological health through different processes. First, biochar supports habitats for microorganisms due to its porous nature and by promoting the formation of stable soil micro-aggregates. Biochar also serves as a carbon and nutrient source. Biochar alters soil physical and chemical properties, creating optimum soil conditions for microbial diversity. Biochar can also immobilize soil pollutants and reduce their bioavailability that would otherwise inhibit microbial growth. However, depending on the pyrolysis settings and feedstock resources, biochar can be comprised of contaminants including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and potentially toxic elements that can inhibit microbial activity, thereby impacting soil health.

Unlocking the potential of biochar in the remediation of soils contaminated with heavy metals for sustainable agriculture

Agricultural soils contaminated with heavy metals (HMs) impose a threat to the environmental and to human health. Amendment with biochar could be an eco-friendly and cost-effective option to decrease HMs in contaminated soil. This paper reviews the application of biochar as a soil amendment to immobilise HMs in contaminated soil. We discuss the technologies of its preparation, their specific properties, and effect on the bioavailability of HMs. Biochar stabilises HMs in contaminated soil, enhance the overall quality of the contaminated soil, and significantly reduce HM uptake by plants, making it an option in soil remediation for HM contamination. Biochar enhances the physical (e.g. bulk density, soil structure, water holding capacity), chemical (e.g. cation exchange capacity, pH, nutrient availability, ion exchange, complexes), and biological properties (e.g. microbial abundance, enzymatic activities) of contaminated soil. Biochar also enhances soil fertility, improves plant growth, and reduces the plant availability of HMs. Various field studies have shown that biochar application reduces the bioavailability of HMs from contaminated soil while increasing crop yield. The review highlights the positive effects of biochar by reducing HM bioavailability in contaminated soils. Future work is recommended to ensure that biochars offer a safe and sustainable solution to remediate soils contaminated with HMs.

Combined toxicity of Cd and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid on the earthworm Eisenia andrei under biochar amendment

Due to anthropogenic activities, various pollutants can be found in agricultural soil, such as cadmium (Cd) and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D). They are highly toxic and can have a negative impact on soil fertility. For remediation strategies, biochar has acquired considerable attention due to its benefits for agriculture. However, we should recognize the ecological risk posed by biochar use. In addition, little is known about its non-desirable effects on soil organisms such as earthworms, especially in the case of soil remediation. In this study, earthworms (Eisenia andrei) were exposed to soil contaminated with Cd (0.7 mg/kg), (2,4-D) (7 mg/kg), and a mixture of the two in the presence and absence of biochar (2%). A 7- and 14-day incubation experiment was carried out for this purpose. Cd and 2,4-D uptakes in earthworms' tissues, oxidative stress, cytotoxic response, DNA damage, histopathological changes, and gene expression level were assessed. Results suggested that biochar increased the bioavailability of Cd and 2,4-D and the frequency of micronuclei (MNi) and decreased the lysosomal membrane stability (LMS) in earthworms. Also, histopathological examination detected numerous alterations in animals exposed to the contaminants without any amelioration when biochar was added. The biochemical response of earthworms in terms of oxidative stress demonstrates that in the presence of biochar, animals tend to alleviate the toxicity of Cd and 2,4-D. This was also supported by transcriptomic analyses where expression gene levels related to oxidative stress were upregulated in earthworms exposed to Cd and 2,4-D + biochar. The present investigation brought new insights concerning the use of biochar in agriculture.

Performance and mechanisms of biochar-assisted vermicomposting in accelerating di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate biodegradation in farmland soil

Biochar and earthworms can accelerate di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP) degradation in soils. However, little is known regarding the effect of biochar-assisted vermicomposting on soil DEHP degradation and the underlying mechanisms. Therefore, the present study investigated DEHP degradation performance and bacterial community changes in farmland soils using earthworms, biochar, or their combination. Biochar-assisted vermicomposting significantly improved DEHP degradation through initial physical adsorption on biochar and subsequent rapid biodegradation in the soil, earthworm gut, and charosphere. Burkholderiaceae, Pseudomonadaceae, and Flavobacteriaceae were the potential DEHP degraders and were enriched in biochar-assisted vermicomposting. In particularly, Burkholderiaceae and Sphingomonadaceae were enriched in the earthworm gut and charosphere, possibly explaining the mechanism of accelerated DEHP degradation in biochar-assisted vermicomposting. Soil pH, soil organic matter, and humus (humic acid, fulvic acid, and humin) increased by earthworms or biochar enhanced DEHP degradation. These findings imply that biochar-assisted vermicomposting enhances DEHP removal not only through rapid physical sorption but also through the improvement of soil physicochemical characteristics and promotion of degraders in the soil, earthworm gut, and charosphere. Overall, biochar-assisted vermicomposting is a suitable method for the remediation of organic-contaminated farmland soils.

Biochar application for remediation of organic toxic pollutants in contaminated soils; An update

Bioremediation of organic contaminants has become a major environmental concern in the last few years, due to its bio-resistance and potential to accumulate in the environment. The use of diverse technologies, involving chemical and physical principles, and passive uptake utilizing sorption using ecofriendly substrates have drawn a lot of interest. Biochar has got attention mainly due to its simplicity of manufacturing, treatment, and disposal, as it is a less expensive and more efficient material, and has a lot of potential for the remediation of organic contaminants. This review highlighted the adverse impact of persistent organic pollutants on the environment and soil biota. The utilization of biochar to remediate soil and contaminated compounds i.e., pesticides, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, antibiotics, and organic dyes has also been discussed. The soil application of biochar has a significant impact on the biodegradation, leaching, and sorption/desorption of organic contaminants. The sorption/desorption of organic contaminants is influenced by chemical composition and structure, porosity, surface area, pH, and elemental ratios, and surface functional groups of biochar. All the above biochar characteristics depend on the type of feedstock and pyrolysis conditions. However, the concentration and nature of organic pollutants significantly alters the sorption capability of biochar. Therefore, the physicochemical properties of biochar and soils/wastewater, and the nature of organic contaminants, should be evaluated before biochar application to soil and wastewater. Future initiatives, however, are needed to develop biochars with better adsorption capacity, and long-term sustainability for use in the xenobiotic/organic contaminant remediation strategy.

Positive and negative effects of nanoscale zero-valent iron-enriched biochar on sulfamethoxazole remediation in contaminated soil

This study prepared surface-modified biochar, including acid washing biochar (HBC) and biochar supported with nanoscale zero-valent iron (nZVI-HBC). The surface-modified biochar was added to sulfamethoxazole (SMX)-contaminated soil with and without earthworms to examine the effects of surface-modified biochar and/or earthworms (Eisenia fetida) on the levels of SMX and its relevant genes (sul1, sul2, and intI1) in the soil. Additionally, the joint toxicity of these exogenous substances on earthworms was investigated. The results showed that although earthworms significantly enhanced the dissipation of SMX in the soils with and without HBC, this effect was not observed in the soil with nZVI-HBC. Among all treatments, nZVI-HBC most effectively accelerated SMX dissipation in the soil, regardless of coexisting earthworms. However, the presence of earthworms significantly increased the total relative abundances of sul1, sul2, and intI1 in the soil. A reasonable explanation for this is the shift in the bacterial community composition rather than the residual level of SMX. When earthworms coexisted, the richness of Proteobacteria evidently increased, which was the main host of the above genes. Both HBC and nZVI-HBC decreased these genes in the soil with earthworms, which was mainly due to the decrease in host genera from Proteobacteria, Actinobacteria, and Gemmatimonadetes. Although there was toxicity of single-surface-modified biochar or SMX on earthworms, the synergistic interaction of surface-modified biochar and SMX resulted in the most serious histopathological changes in earthworms and their highest superoxide dismutase activity.

Effects of biochar-based materials on the bioavailability of soil organic pollutants and their biological impacts

Motivated by the unique structure and superior properties, biochar-based materials, including pristine biochar and composites of biochar with other functional materials, are considered as new generation materials for diverse multi-functional applications, which may be intentionally or unintentionally released to soil. The influencing mechanism of biochar-based material on soil organisms is a key aspect for quantifying and predicting its benefits and trade-offs. This work focuses on the effects of biochar-based materials on soil organisms within the past ten years. 206 sources are reviewed and available knowledge on biochar-based materials' impacts on soil organisms is summarized from a diverse perspective, including the pollutant bioavailability changes in soil, and potential effects of biochar-based materials on soil organisms. Herein, effects of biochar-based materials on the bioavailability of soil organic pollutants are detailed, from the perspective of plant, microorganism, and soil fauna. Potential biological effects of pristine biochar (PBC), metal/metal compounds-biochar composites (MBC), clay minerals-biochar composites (CMBC), and carbonaceous materials-biochar composites (CBC) on soil organisms are highlighted for the first time. And possible mechanisms are presented based on the different characters of biochar-based materials as well as various environmental interactions. Finally, the bottleneck and challenges of risk assessment of biochar-based materials as well as future prospects are proposed. This work not only promotes the development of risk assessment system of biochar-based materials, but broadens the strategy for the design and optimization of environmental-friendly biochar materials.

Quantitative relationship between earthworms' sensitivity to organic pollutants and the contaminants' degradation in soil: A meta-analysis

Using earthworms to remove soil organic pollutants is a common bioremediation method. However, it remains challenging to evaluate and predict their effect on removing soil organic pollutants based on earthworm toxicology and pollutant degradation rates. Peer-reviewed journal articles on ecotoxicology and bioremediation from the years 1974-2020 (cutoff date September 2020) were selected for meta-analysis to quantify the effect size of earthworms on organic pollutant degradation. The meta-analysis shows that the average effect size of earthworms on organic pollutant degradation is 128.5% (p < 0.05). Soils with high soil organic matter or clay textures are more conducive to earthworm-mediated removal of organic pollutants. Structural equation modeling reveals that earthworms' sensitivity to contaminant exposure may be a greater limiting factor on pollutant degradation than environmental factors. In addition, the quantitative relationship existed between LC50 and the pollutants' degradation that an elevated LC50 threshold resulted in at least 1.5 times increase in the pollutants' degradation size. This correlation was dually confirmed via meta-analysis and the validation trial. The results of this study contribute to a more profound understanding of the potential to use earthworms to mitigate organic pollution in soils and develop earthworm-based soil remediation techniques on a global scale.

Production and beneficial impact of biochar for environmental application: A comprehensive review

This review focuses on a holistic view of biochar, production from feedstock's, engineering production strategies, its applications and future prospects. This article reveals a systematic emphasis on the continuation and development of biochar and its production methods such as Physical engineering, chemical and bio-engineering techniques. In addition, biochar alternatives such as nutrient formations and surface area made it a promising cheap source of carbon-based products such as anaerobic digestion, gasification, and pyrolysis, commercially available wastewater treatment, carbons, energy storage, microbial fuel cell electrodes, and super-capacitors repair have been reviewed. This paper also covers the knowledge blanks of strategies and ideas for the future in the field of engineering biochar production techniques and application as well as expand the technology used in the circular bio-economy.

Phytotoxicity of petroleum hydrocarbons: Sources, impacts and remediation strategies

Extraction and exploration of petroleum hydrocarbons (PHs) to satisfy the rising world population's fossil fuel demand is playing havoc with human beings and other life forms by contaminating the ecosystem, particularly the soil. In the current review, we highlighted the sources of PHs contamination, factors affecting the PHs accumulation in soil, mechanisms of uptake, translocation and potential toxic effects of PHs on plants. In plants, PHs reduce the seed germination andnutrients translocation, and induce oxidative stress, disturb the plant metabolic activity and inhibit the plant physiology and morphology that ultimately reduce plant yield. Moreover, the defense strategy in plants to mitigate the PHs toxicity and other potential remediation techniques, including the use of organic manure, compost, plant hormones, and biochar, and application of microbe-assisted remediation, and phytoremediation are also discussed in the current review. These remediation strategies not only help to remediate PHs pollutionin the soil rhizosphere but also enhance the morphological and physiological attributes of plant and results to improve crop yield under PHs contaminated soils. This review aims to provide significant information on ecological importance of PHs stress in various interdisciplinary investigations and critical remediation techniques to mitigate the contamination of PHs in agricultural soils.

Reduction of chlordecone environmental availability by soil amendment of biochars and activated carbons from lignocellulosic biomass

Chlordecone (kepone or CLD) was formerly used in French West Indies as an insecticide. Despite its formal ban in 1993, high levels of this pesticide are still found in soils. As such, sequestering matrices like biochars or activated carbons (ACs) may successfully decrease the bioavailability of halogenated compounds like CLD when added to contaminated soils. The present study intends (i) to produce contrasted sequestering matrices in order to (ii) assess their respective efficiency to reduce CLD environmental availability. Hence, the work was designed following two experimental steps. The first one consisted at producing different sequestering media (biochars and ACs) via pyrolysis and distinct activation processes, using two lignocellulosic precursors (raw biomass): oak wood (Quercus ilex) and coconut shell (Cocos nucifera). The chemical activation was carried out with phosphoric acid while physical activation was done with carbon dioxide and steam. In the second step, the CLD environmental availability was assessed either in an OECD artificial soil or in an Antillean contaminated nitisol (i.e., 2.1^-1μg CLD per g of soil dry matter, DM), both amended with 5 wt% of biochar or 5 wt% of AC. These both steps aim to determine CLD environmental availability reduction efficiency of these media when added (i) to a standard soil material or (ii) to a soil representative of the Antillean CLD contamination context. Textural characteristics of the derived coconut and oak biochars and ACs were determined by nitrogen adsorption at 77 K. Mixed microporous and mesoporous textures consisting of high pore volume (ranging from 0.38 cm³.g^-1 to 2.00 cm³.g^-1) and specific (BET) surface areas from 299.9 m².g^-1 to 1285.1 m².g^-1 were obtained. Overall, soil amendment with biochars did not limit CLD environmental availability (environmental availability assay ISO/DIS 16751 Part B). When soil was amended with ACs, a significant reduction of the environmental availability in both artificial and natural soils was observed. AC soil amendment resulted in a reduced CLD transfer by at least 65% (P < 0.001) for all lignocellulosic matrices (excepted for coconut sample activated with steam, which displayed a 47% reduction). These features confirm that both pore structure and extent of porosity are of particular importance in the retention process of CLD in aged soil. Owing to its adsorptive properties, AC amendment of CLD-contaminated soils appears as a promising approach to reduce the pollutant transfer to fauna and biota.

Bioaccumulation, physiological distribution, and biotransformation of tetrabromobisphenol a (TBBPA) in the geophagous earthworm Metaphire guillelmi - hint for detoxification strategy

The mechanisms underlying the bioaccumulation and detoxification of tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) by terrestrial invertebrates are poorly understood. We used uniformly ring-¹⁴C-labelled TBBPA to investigate the bioaccumulation kinetics, metabolites distribution, and subsequent detoxification strategy of TBBPA in the geophagous earthworm Metaphire guillelmi in soil. The modeling of bioaccumulation kinetics showed a higher biota-soil-accumulation-factor of total ¹⁴C than that of the parent compound TBBPA, indicating that most of the ingested TBBPA was transformed into metabolites or sequestered as bound residues in the earthworms. Bound-residue formation in the digestive tract may hinder the accumulation of TBBPA in other parts of the body. Nonetheless, via the circulatory system, TBBPA was transferred to other tissues, especially the clitellum region, where sensitive organs are located. In the clitellum region, TBBPA was quickly transformed to less toxic dimethyl TBBPA ether and rapidly depurated through feces. We conclude that the detoxification of TBBPA in M. guillelmi occurred via bound-residue formation in the digestive tract as well as the generation and depuration of O-methylation metabolites. Our results provided direct evidence of TBBPA detoxification in earthworms. Further researches are needed to confirm whether O-methylation coupled with depuration is a common detoxification strategy for phenolic xenobiotics in other soil organisms needs to be determined.

Preparation, environmental application and prospect of biochar-supported metal nanoparticles: A review

Biochar is a low-cost, porous, and carbon-rich material and it exhibits a great potential as an adsorbent and a supporting matrix due to its high surface activity, high specific surface area, and high ion exchange capacity. Metal nanomaterials are nanometer-sized solid particles which have high reactivity, high surface area, and high surface energy. Owing to their aggregation and passivation, metal nanomaterials will lose excellent physiochemical properties. Carbon-enriched biochar can be applied to overcome these drawbacks of metal nanomaterials. Combining the advantages of biochar and metal nanomaterials, supporting metal nanomaterials on porous and stable biochar creates a new biochar-supported metal nanoparticles (MNPs@BC). Therefore, MNPs@BC can be used to design the properties of metal nanoparticles, stabilize the anchored metal nanoparticles, and facilitate the catalytic/redox reactions at the biochar-metal interfaces, which maximizes the efficiency of biochar and metal nanoparticles in environmental application. This work detailedly reviews the synthesis methods of MNPs@BC and the effects of preparation conditions on the properties of MNPs@BC during the preparation processes. The characterization methods of MNPs@BC, the removal/remediation performance of MNPs@BC for organic contaminants, heavy metals and other inorganic contaminants in water and soil, and the effect of MNPs@BC properties on the remediation efficiency were discussed. In addition, this paper summarizes the effect of various parameters on the removal of contaminants from water, the effect of MNPs@BC remediation on soil properties, and the removal/remediation mechanisms of the contaminants by MNPs@BC in water and soil. Moreover, the potential directions for future research and development of MNPs@BC have also been discussed.

Dissipation, transformation and accumulation of triclosan in soil-earthworm system and effects of biosolids application

Triclosan (TCS), widely used as an antimicrobial ingredient, is usually introduced into soil by biosolids application, and has presented potential risk in agro-ecosystem. The dissipation pathways of TCS in soil were analyzed in the presence and absence of earthworms (including Metaphire guillelmi and Eisenia fetida). Meanwhile the accumulation and transformation potentials of TCS in the two earthworms were evaluated. Results indicated that about 44% of initial TCS amount dissipated in sterile soil after 56-day incubation, which may mainly result from the bound-residues formation. In contrast, TCS in non-sterile soil dissipated more quickly with a t_1/2 of 12 days, suggesting that microbial degradation was responsible for TCS dissipation. Triclosan was methylated to methyl triclosan (MTCS) in soil, which however contributed little for TCS dissipation. The presence of M. guillelmi accelerated TCS dissipation with the reduced t_1/2 to 8 days, and inhibited MTCS formation in soil, while E. fetida had no significant (P > 0.05) effects on the fate of TCS. E. fetida accumulated more TCS than M. guillelmi, with bioaccumulation factors up to 11 vs. 0.6. It was also proved that methylation metabolism occurred in earthworms (including gut microorganisms), and M. guillelmi had higher metabolic efficiency compared to E. fetida. Even though eliminations of TCS and MTCS were rapid (except for TCS in M. guillelmi), the residues of the two compounds in both earthworms remained at high levels, having the potential to transfer in the terrestrial food web. In addition, results showed that biosolids application changed TCS persistence, as well as bioavailability dependent on earthworm species. When biosolids at 1% added, more residual TCS and MTCS in soil were observed, while TCS accumulation in E. fetida decreased, however, methylation metabolism in both earthworm species was not affected. The findings provide important information for a more precise risk assessment of biosolids land-application. CAPSULE: Triclosan dissipation, methylation and bioavailability in soils were affected by biosolids amendment and dependent on earthworm species with different accumulation and metabolic potentials.

Assessment of the immobilization effectiveness of several amendments on a cadmium-contaminated soil using Eisenia fetida

Proper protocols for assessing the remediation effectiveness of contaminated soils are an important part of remediation projects. In the present study, the residual immobilization effectiveness of hydrated lime (L), hydroxyapatite (H), biochar (B) and organic fertilizer (F) alone and in combination was assessed by Eisenia fetida. The results showed that the application of amendments had no significant effect on the death rate and average fresh weight loss of earthworms. The earthworm Cd concentration increased with prolonged exposure time, however, the significant immobilization efficacy of amendments observed on the 7th day nearly disappeared after 28 days of exposure. The immobilization efficiencies, estimated by the earthworms internal Cd concentration, of L, H and B on the 7th day were 38.6%, 37.8% and 20.7%, respectively. These values decreased to 4.9%, 19.8% and 15.1%, respectively, on the 28th day. The detoxification effect of amendments was confirmed by the Cd subcellular fractionation in earthworms with lower proportions of Cd distributed in the metal-sensitive fractions in L, H and B treatments. The level of oxidative stress response of earthworms increased with exposure duration and amendments alleviated the oxidative damage induced by Cd to the earthworms. In addition, the pH and CaCl₂-Cd in soils were both increased due to earthworm life activities and gut-related ingestion. In summary, the assessment of immobilization effectiveness of heavy metal-contaminated soils using Eisenia fetida was time-dependent. The immobilization efficacy of L and H performed better than B and F on the 7th day, while H and B performed better than L and F on the 28th day. Accordingly, the short-term earthworm exposure experiment (7 days) was recommended to be an alternative approach to time-consuming plant bioassays in assessment of reduced phytoavailability in chemical immobilization remediation. But the impact of earthworms on the immobilization effect of amendments needs to be considered in practical remediation.

Biochar Immobilizes and Degrades 2,4,6-Trichlorophenol in Soils

Soil contamination by chlorophenol compounds, such as 2,4,6-trichlorophenol (2,4,6-TCP), is of great concern because they are environmentally persistent, are difficult to degrade, and can lead to cancer. Thus, means of degrading these compounds in situ are desperately needed. Biochar was investigated as a material to sequester, reduce downward transport, and aid in soil 2,4,6-TCP degradation. In 2 column studies, wheat straw (Triticum aestivum L.)-derived biochar (pyrolyzed at 450 °C) application to soil (up to 5% by wt) improved soil water and soil organic carbon content. Biochar reduced 2,4,6-TCP downward transport, likely attributable to improved soil water mobility and retention, allowing 2,4,6-TCP to be more easily transported and sorbed to organic functional groups on biochar, leading to enhanced degradation. The 2,4,6-TCP was rapidly degraded into a combination of benzene derivatives and low-molecular weight organic compounds in the first 2 mo following biochar application. The present study provides evidence that biochars can be used to improve environmental quality by lessening the downward transport and enhancing the degradation of organochlorine compounds such as 2,4,6-TCP. Environ Toxicol Chem 2019;38:1364-1371. © 2019 SETAC.

Preparation and Modification of Biochar Materials and their Application in Soil Remediation

As a new functional material, biochar was usually prepared from biomass and solid wastes such as agricultural and forestry waste, sludge, livestock, and poultry manure. The wide application of biochar is due to its abilities to remove pollutants, remediate contaminated soil, and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. In this paper, the influence of preparation methods, process parameters, and modification methods on the physicochemical properties of biochar were discussed, as well as the mechanisms of biochar in the remediation of soil pollution. The biochar applications in soil remediation in the past years were summarized, such as the removal of heavy metals and persistent organic pollutants (POPs), and the improvement of soil quality. Finally, the potential risks of biochar application and the future research directions were analyzed.

Influence of bacterial community composition and soil factors on the fate of phenanthrene and benzo[a]pyrene in three contrasting farmland soils

The fate of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) determines their potential risk in soil, which may be directly affected by abiotic conditions and indirectly through the changes in decomposer communities. In comparison, the indirect effects on the fate remain largely elusive. In this study, the fate of phenanthrene and benzo[a]pyrene and the corresponding bacterial changes were investigated in three contaminated farmland soils using a ¹⁴C tracer method and Miseq sequencing. The results showed that most benzo[a]pyrene was consistently extractable with dichloromethane (DCM) after the 60-day incubation (60.4%-78.2%), while phenanthrene was mainly mineralized to CO₂ during the 30-day incubation (40.4%-58.7%). Soils from Guangzhou (GZ) showed a different distribution pattern of ¹⁴C-PAHs exemplified by low mineralization and disparate bound residue formation. The PAH fate in the Shenyang (SY) and Nanjing (NJ) soils were similar to each other than to that in the GZ soil. The fate in the GZ soil seemed to be linked to the distinct edaphic properties, such as organic matter content, however soil microbial community could have influenced the distribution pattern of PAHs. This potential role of microorganisms was reflected by the unique changes in the copy numbers of Gram positive RHD_α gene, and by the distinct shifts in bacterial community composition during the incubation. A quite different shift in bacterial communities was found in the GZ microcosms which may influence PAH mineralization and non-extractable residue (NER) formation.

Species-dependent effects of earthworms on the fates and bioavailability of tetrabromobisphenol A and cadmium coexisted in soils

The activity of e-waste recycling often causes the combined pollution of tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) and cadmium (Cd) in soils. In this study, the effects of their co-existence on each other's fate, further reflecting the bioavailability, were analyzed in the presence of two ecologically different earthworm species, endogeic Metaphire guillelmi and epigeic Eisenia fetida. Mineralization of ¹⁴C-TBBPA combined with 10 mg Cd kg^-1 was suppressed by the presence of M. guillelmi, whereas a facilitating effect was produced by the combination of 1 mg Cd kg^-1 in the soil-E. fetida system after a 14-day exposure. The uptake of ¹⁴C-TBBPA by M. guillelmi (17% of initial amount) and by E. fetida (10%) dominantly contributed to significant (P < 0.05) decrease of extractable (more bioavailable) ¹⁴C residues in soils both with and without Cd spiked, while the mineralization of ¹⁴C-TBBPA in the soils was negligible (<0.4%). Meanwhile the amendments of the two earthworm species exerted different impact on ¹⁴C distribution in bound residues. In general, co-exposure to Cd did not significantly (P > 0.05) influence the accumulation and metabolism of TBBPA in the earthworms. Both earthworms accumulated only ~7% of Cd in soil, however, the bioavailable Cd determined by the diffusive gradients in thin films technique declined by ~46% in the presence of M. guillelmi, and a much smaller decrease was determined in the presence of E. fetida. Amendment of TBBPA at environmental levels did not alter the accumulation and subcellular distribution of Cd in both earthworms unless that at high doses. The results highlighted the importance of considering the difference of the earthworm species and the interaction of pollutants in soil-risk assessments of such combined contamination. CAPSULE: M. guillelmi displayed greater effect on the fate of TBBPA and Cd co-existed in soils than E. fetida, while the accumulation, metabolism, or distribution of the two pollutants in earthworms did not significantly alter due to interactions between the two pollutants.

Simultaneous removal of pollutants from water using nanoparticles: A shift from single pollutant control to multiple pollutant control

The steady increase in population, coupled with the rapid utilization of resources and continuous development of industry and agriculture has led to excess amounts of wastewater with changes in its composition, texture, complexity and toxicity due to the diverse range of pollutants being present in wastewater. The challenges faced by wastewater treatment today are mainly with the complexity of the wastewater as it complicates treatment processes by requiring a combination of technologies, thus resulting in longer treatment times and higher operational costs. Nanotechnology opens up a novel platform that is free from secondary pollution, inexpensive and an effective way to simultaneously remove multiple pollutants from wastewater. Currently, there are a number of studies that have presented a myriad of multi-purpose/multifunctional nanoparticles that simultaneously remove multiple pollutants in water. However, these studies have not been collated to review the direction that nanoparticle assisted wastewater treatment is heading towards. Hence, this critical review explores the feasibility and efficiency of simultaneous removal of co-existing/multiple pollutants in water using nanomaterials. The discussion begins with an introduction of different classes of pollutants and their toxicity followed by an overview and highlights of current research on multipollutant control in water using different nanomaterials as adsorbents, photocatalysts, disinfectants and microbicides. The analysis is concluded with a look at the current attempts being made towards commercialization of multipollutant control/multifunctional nanotechnology inventions. The review presents evidence of simultaneous removal of pathogenic microorganisms, inorganic and organic compound chemical pollutants using nanoparticles. Accordingly, not only is nanotechnology showcased as a promising and an environmentally-friendly way to solve the limitations of current and conventional centralised water and wastewater treatment facilities but is also presented as a good substitute or supplement in areas without those facilities.

Effect of oil spill on compound-specific stable carbon isotope composition of amino acid in Nitzschia closterium and Heterosigma akashiwo

Marine microalgae, the most important primary producers in marine ecosystems, are susceptible to toxicants and usually selected as the promising organisms for chemical risk testing. The stable carbon isotope ratios (δ¹³C) of amino acids (AAs) were measured to determine if compound-specific stable isotope analysis could be used to provide insight into the toxic effects of oil spill on the marine microalgae. The water accommodated fractions (WAF) of #180 fuel oil were selected as the toxic targets with different concentrations in acute (96 h) toxic tests. Naphthalene, phenanthrene, anthracene, and fluoranthene were detected as the predominant congeners of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in the WAF, and may be the main toxic components. At the same WAF concentration, the δ¹³C values of leucine in Nitzschia closterium increased with the culture time, whereas decreased in Heterosigma akashiwo. However, with the increasing WAF concentrations, the δ¹³C values of glutamic acid exhibited the increasing trend in both of the two kinds of microalgae at the same culture time. The similar phenomenon was also observed for histidine in H. akashiwo, while opposite in N. closterium, but both enriching in δ¹³C compared to the controlled experiments without the WAF. Under the different culture times and WAF concentrations, the δ¹³C values of alanine and methionine showed unexpected trend. These findings indicated that the synthesis pathways of AA in microalgae cells were affected by the WAF, thus leading to the carbon isotopic fractionation in AAs. The present study provide a novel approach to explore the toxicity mechanism of primary producers under oil spill stress, and monitor and evaluate the marine ecological risk of oil spill pollution.

A concise review of biochar application to agricultural soils to improve soil conditions and fight pollution

Application of biochar to soil can play a significant role in the alteration of nutrients dynamics, soil contaminants as well as microbial functions. Therefore, strategic biochar application to soil may provide agronomic, environmental and economic benefits. Key environmental outcomes may include reduced availability of toxic metals and organic pollutants, reduced soil N losses and longer-term storage of carbon in soil. The use of biochar can certainly address key soil agronomic constraints to crop production including Al toxicity, low soil pH and may improve nutrient use efficiency. Biochar application has also demerits to soil properties and attention should be paid when using a specific biochar for a specific soil property improvement. This review provides a concise assessment and addresses impacts of biochar on soil properties.

Species-dependent toxicity, accumulation, and subcellular partitioning of cadmium in combination with tetrabromobisphenol A in earthworms

Cadmium (Cd) and tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) are two ubiquitous pollutants in soils and are often found together at electronic waste recycling sites. In this study, their toxicity as well as the accumulation and subcellular partitioning of Cd were determined in two ecologically different earthworms Eisenia fetida and Metaphire guillelmi exposed for 14 days to Cd (1 mg kg^-1) and TBBPA (10, 50, 100, and 500 mg kg^-1) alone and in combination. In general, Cd-TBBPA co-exposure resulted in synergistic effects in terms of acute toxicity, growth inhibition, histopathological changes in body walls, and oxidative stress responses to earthworms, moreover, M. guillelmi showed higher sensitivity than E. fetida. Principal component analysis showed that the two earthworm species differed in their biomarker expression patterns. In addition, Cd accumulation was significantly (P < 0.01) reduced in E. fetida co-exposed to TBBPA but significantly (P < 0.05 and 0.01) enhanced in M. guillelmi. The difference in bioaccumulation between the two earthworm species may be made by their different exposure routes despite the decrease of Cd bioavailability (assessed by the diffusive gradients in thin films technique) in the soils. High doses of TBBPA also altered the subcellular distribution of Cd in the earthworms. These findings demonstrate the need to include more ecologically relevant earthworm species, represented in this study by M. guillelmi, in soil risk assessments of Cd and TBBPA co-exposure.

Amendment of soil by biochars and activated carbons to reduce chlordecone bioavailability in piglets

Chlordecone (Kepone or CLD) is a highly persistent pesticide formerly used in French West Indies. Nowadays high levels of this pesticide are still found in soils which represent a subsequent source of contamination for outdoor-reared animals. In that context, sequestering matrices like biochars or activated carbons (ACs) are believed to efficiently decrease the bioavailability of such compounds when added to contaminated soils. The present study intends to test the respective efficiency of soil amendment strategies using commercial ACs or biochars (obtained by a 500 °C or 700 °C pyrolysis of 4 distinct type of wood). This study involved three experimental steps. The first one characterized specific surface areas of biochars and ACs. The second one assessed CLD-availability of contaminated artificial soils (50 μg g^-1 of Dry Matter) amended with 5% of biochar or AC (mass basis). The third one assessed CLD bioavailability of those artificial soils through an in vivo assay. To limit ethically the number of animals, selections of the most promising media were performed between each experimental steps. Forty four castrated male 40-day-old piglets were exposed during 10 day by amended artificial soils according to their group (n = 4). Only treatment groups exposed through amended soil with AC presented a significant decrease of concentrations of CLD in liver and adipose tissue in comparison with the control group (p < 0.001). A non-significant decrease was obtained by amending artificial soil with biochars. This decrease was particularly high for a coconut shell activated carbon were relative bioavailability was found lower than 3.2% for both tissues. This study leads to conclude that AC introduced in CLD contaminated soil should strongly reduce CLD bioavailability.

The environmental characteristics and applications of biochar

The environmental deterioration is in a grave situation, and it is urgent to restore the environment. Biochar is a carbon-rich pyrolysis product of feedstock, which has aroused extensive concern due to its broad application potential for getting rid of pollutants and rehabilitating environment. This review generalizes three aspects on biochar, including production and properties, applications and mechanisms, and its modifications. Firstly, the production and characteristics have been summarized, because the practical applications of biochar are highly related to the special characteristics of biochar. Secondly, this paper outlines the latest applications of biochar for environmental remediation, and further provides a critical review on the application mechanisms in environmental restoration. Thirdly, the modification methods and applications of modified biochar are summarized, and all of the ways can be classified into two types: pretreatment of feedstock and modification of primitive biochar. Furthermore, the possible improvements and outlooks of applying biochar in environmental remediation are proposed. This review provides useful information for the application of biochar in environmental restoration.

Sorption, bioavailability and ecotoxic effects of hydrophobic organic compounds in biochar amended soils

This work addresses the effect of biochar amendment to soil on contaminant sorption, bioavailability, and ecotoxicity. A distinction between positive primary amendment effects caused by reduced toxicity resulting from contaminant sorption, and negative secondary amendment effects of the biochars themselves was seen. Two biochars (one from high technology and one from low technology production processes) representing real world biochars were tested for the adsorption of pyrene, polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) 52), and dichlorodiphenyldichloroethylene (p,p'-DDE). Sorption by both biochars was similar, both for compounds in single and mixed isotherms, in the presence and absence of soil. p,p'-DDE natively contaminated and spiked soils were amended with biochar (0, 1, 5, and 10%) and bioavailability, operationally defined bioaccessibility and ecotoxicity were assessed using polyethylene (PE), polymeric resin (XAD) and Folsomia candida, respectively. At the highest biochar dose (10%), bioavailability and bioaccessibility decreased by >37% and >41%, respectively, compared to unamended soils. Mortality of F. candida was not observed at any biochar dose, while reproductive effects were dose dependent. F. candida benefited from the reduction of p,p'-DDE bioavailability upon 1% and 5% biochar addition to contaminated soils while at 10% dose, these positive effects were nullified by biochar-induced toxicity. p,p'-DDE toxicity corrected for such secondary effects was predicted well by both PE uptake and XAD extraction.

Effects of earthworm casts on sorption-desorption, degradation, and bioavailability of nonylphenol in soil

Up to hundreds of milligrams per kilogram (dry weight) of nonylphenol (NP) reportedly entered the soil and sediment through the agricultural reuse of biosolids, pesticide application, etc. Organic pollutants in soil could not only further trigger groundwater contamination via leaching (that highly depends upon sorption-desorption and degradation phenomena) but also harm food safety by crop uptake (that mainly rests with the bioavailability of pollutants in soil). Thus, we first investigated the effects of earthworm casts (EWCs) on the sorption-desorption, degradation, and bioavailability of NP in soil under laboratory microcosm conditions, and then, analyzed the FT-IR spectra of EWC and soil samples (with and without EWC). The application of EWC could notably increase the sorption capacity of soils for NP and in turn significantly inhibited the desorption of NP from soil; responsively lengthened the half-time of NP in the soil; and reduced the uptake and translocation of NP in tomato seedlings and promoted their growth during the first 3 weeks. Finally, FT-IR spectra of EWC and soil samples indicated that the application of EWC increased the content of N, P, and organic matter in soil.

Effects of the earthworm Metaphire guillelmi on the mineralization, metabolism, and bound-residue formation of tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) in soil

Tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) is one of the most widely used brominated flame retardants worldwide. The degradation and fate of this organic pollutant of soils is of great concern and can be strongly affected by geophagous earthworms through ingestion and burrowing activities. Using ¹⁴C-tracers, we studied the effects of the geophagous earthworm Metaphire guillelmi on the mineralization, metabolism, and bound-residue formation of TBBPA in a typical Chinese rice paddy soil during 30days of incubation in the laboratory. Earthworms significantly decreased both mineralization (from 3.9±0.3% of the initial amount to 2.6±0.2%) and dissipation (from 90.6±0.6% to 84.1±1.2%) of TBBPA in the soil, and stimulated the generation of O-methylation metabolites (TBBPA methyl ethers; from 1.4±0.4% to 15.4±0.6%). This resulted in a strong decrease in bound-residue formation of TBBPA and its metabolites in the soil (from 80.3±0.4% to 41.8±3.1%). Results from a first-order, two-compartment model that describes the fate of TBBPA in soil indicated that the TBBPA-derived bound residues were mainly attributed to the binding of metabolites to the soil matrix and not to the binding of TBBPA, and that earthworms reduced the kinetic rates of both polar metabolite generation and their bound-residue formation. Our results suggested that the geophagous earthworm Metaphire guillelmi strongly influenced the fate of TBBPA by altering the composition of metabolites and therefore bound-residue formation. The increased persistence of TBBPA and the formation of persistent O-methylation metabolites by M. guillelmi would increase the environmental risk of TBBPA.

Fate and O-methylating detoxification of Tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) in two earthworms (Metaphire guillelmi and Eisenia fetida)

Tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) is the world's most widely used brominated flame retardant but there is growing concern about its fate and toxicity in terrestrial organisms. In this study, two ecologically different earthworms, Metaphire guillelmi and Eisenia fetida, were exposed to soil spiked with ¹⁴C-labeled TBBPA for 21 days. M. guillelmi accumulated more TBBPA than E. fetida, evidenced by a 2.7-fold higher ¹⁴C-uptake rate and a 1.3-fold higher biota-soil accumulation factor. Considerable amounts of bound residues (up to 40% for M. guillelmi and 18% for E. fetida) formed rapidly in the bodies of both earthworms. ¹⁴C accumulated mostly in the gut of M. guillemi and in the skin of E. fetida, suggesting that its uptake by M. guillelmi was mainly via gut processes whereas in E. fetida epidermal adsorption predominated. The TBBPA transformation potential was greater in M. guillelmi than in E. fetida, since only 5% vs. 34% of extractable ¹⁴C remained as the parent compound after 21 days of exposure. Besides polar metabolites, the major metabolites in both earthworms were TBBPA mono- and dimethyl ethers (O-methylation products of TBBPA). Acute toxicity assessments using filter paper and natural soil tests showed that the methylation metabolites were much less toxic than the parent TBBPA to both earthworms. It indicated that earthworms used O-methylation to detoxify TBBPA, and M. guillelmi exhibited the higher detoxification ability than E. fetida. These results imply that if only the free parent compound TBBPA is measured, not only bioaccumulation may be underestimated but also its difference between earthworm species may be misestimated. The species-dependent fate of TBBPA may provide a better indicator of the differing sensitivities of earthworms to this environmental contaminant.

Fate of phenanthrene and mineralization of its non-extractable residues in an oxic soil

The fate of organic pollutants in the environment, especially the formation and stability of non-extractable (i.e., bound) residues (NERs) determines their environmental risk. Using ¹⁴C-tracers, we studied the fate of the carcinogen phenanthrene in active or sterilized oxic loamy soil in the absence and presence of the geophagous earthworm Metaphire guillelmi and characterized the NERs derived from phenanthrene. After incubation of ¹⁴C-phenanthrene in active soil for 28 days, 40 ± 3.1% of the initial amount was mineralized and 70.1 ± 1.9% was converted to NERs. Most of the NERs (>92%) were bound to soil humin. Silylation of the humin-bound residues released 45.3 ± 5.3% of these residues, which indicated that they were physically entrapped, whereas the remainder of the residues were chemically bound or biogenic. By contrast, in sterilized soil, only 43.4 ± 12.6% of the phenanthrene was converted to NERs and all of these residues were completely released upon silylation, which underlines the essential role of microbial activity in NER formation. The presence of M. guillelmi in active soil significantly inhibited phenanthrene mineralization (24.4 ± 2.6% mineralized), but NER formation was not significantly affected. Only a small amount of phenanthrene-derived residues (1.9-5.3% of the initial amount) accumulated in the earthworm body. When humin-bound residues were mixed with fresh soil, 33.9% (humin recovered from active soils) and 12.4% (humin recovered from sterilized soils) of the residues were mineralized after 75 days of incubation, respectively, which indicated a high bioavailability of NERs, albeit lower than the initial addition of phenanthrene. Our results indicated that many phenanthrene-derived NERs, especially those physically entrapped, are still bioavailable and may pose a toxic threat to soil organisms.

Oxidative stress responses and insights into the sensitivity of the earthworms Metaphire guillelmi and Eisenia fetida to soil cadmium

Soil toxicological tests are commonly performed using Eisenia fetida as the standard earthworm species, but it is tolerant to a wide range of pollutants. Therefore, the inclusion of susceptible species is crucial for the accurate estimation of soil contamination. In this study, we examined the sensitivity to soil cadmium (Cd) of anecic Metaphire guillelmi and epigeic E. fetida by measuring multiple indexes of oxidative stress. Using subcellular partitioning analysis, we further elucidated the inherent mechanism underlying the species-specific sensitivity of the two earthworm species. Among the battery of biochemical indexes, reactive oxygen species and protein carbonyl groups served as sensitive biomarkers. According to their respective response thresholds, M. guillelmi was more sensitive than E. fetida and they differed in their dose-response relationships. In E. fetida, the activities of three antioxidant enzymes, superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase (CAT) and glutathione S-transferase (GST), exhibited a hormesis-like U-shaped dose-response relationship, while in M. guillelmi SOD, glutathione peroxidase (an analogue of CAT) and GST showed an inverted U-shaped relationship. The concentrations of Cd in the subcellular fractions and whole body of the earthworms well fit (R²>0.9) a saturation model versus bioavailable Cd concentrations determined by the diffusive gradients in thin films technique. Despite the lower accumulation capacity of M. guillelmi, the Cd-binding capacity (C_max) of its subcellular heat-stable protein fraction, the so-called biologically detoxified metal pool, was 2.7 times lower than that of E. fetida, whereas the Cd binding affinity (logK) of its heat-denatured protein fraction, i.e. the metal-sensitive fraction, was 3.0 times higher, which accounted for the high susceptibility of M. guillelmi to soil Cd. Our results suggest that because of their sensitivity, as exemplified by M. guillelmi, native earthworm species should be taken into account in soil risk assessments to avoid underestimation of the toxicity of various pollutants.