Effects of humic matter on the anaerobic digestion of sewage sludge: New insights from sludge structure

Natural flocculant chitosan inhibits short-chain fatty acid production in anaerobic fermentation of waste activated sludge

Chitosan (CTS) serves as an excellent natural flocculant in wastewater purification and sludge conditioning, but its potential impact on anaerobic fermentation of waste-activated sludge is unclear. The current study investigated the role of CTS in short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) generation via sludge alkaline anaerobic fermentation. The results showed a drastic reduction in SCFA production with CTS, showing a maximum inhibition of 33 % at 6 mg/g of total suspended solids. CTS hindered sludge solubilization through flocculation, and acted as a humus precursor, promoting humus formation, and consequently reduced the amount of available substrates. Further, CTS promoted free ammonia production, posing a challenge to enzymes and cell viability. Additionally, CTS increased the population of Rikenellaceae sp. and weakened the dominance of hydrolyzing and acidifying bacteria. This study deepens the understanding of the potential impact of CTS on anaerobic fermentation and provides a theoretical basis for reducing the risk of polymeric flocculants.

Effect of total solids content on anaerobic digestion of waste activated sludge enhanced by high-temperature thermal hydrolysis

Total solids (TS) content may provide a regulatory strategy for optimizing anaerobic digestion enhanced by high-temperature thermal hydrolysis, but the role of TS content is not yet clear. In this study, the effect of TS content on the high-temperature thermal hydrolysis and anaerobic digestion of sludge and its mechanism were investigated. The results showed that increasing the TS content from 2% to 8% increased the sludge solubility and methane production potential, reaching peak values of 26.6% and 336 ± 6 mL/g volatile solids (VS), respectively. With a further increase in TS content to 12%, the strong Maillard reaction increased the aromaticity and structural stability of extracellular polymer substances, decreasing sludge solubility to 18.6%. Furthermore, the decrease in sludge biodegradability and the formation of inhibitory by-products resulted in a reduction in methane production to 272 ± 4 mL/g VS. This article provides a new perspective to understand the role of TS content in the thermal hydrolysis of sludge and a novel approach to regulate the Maillard reaction.

Relation between hydrophilic/hydrophobic characteristics of sludge extracellular polymeric substances and sludge moisture-holding capacity in hot-pressing drying

Sludge poses a serious threat to the environmental health. Hot-pressing drying has been proven efficient in sludge treatment because of the reduced thermal contact resistance, rapid increase in sludge temperature, and high drying rate. Sludge extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) significantly influence moisture transfer. However, whether in hot-pressing or traditional thermal drying, the effect of EPS on sludge moisture-holding capacity is rarely reported. Thereby, this study investigated the relationship between hydrophilic/hydrophobic characteristics of EPS and sludge moisture-holding capacity at various drying time and mechanical compression using XAD resin fractionation. Thermodynamic analysis indicated that sludge moisture desorption isotherms, net isosteric heat of desorption, and differential entropy presented a downward trend with the increase in drying time and mechanical compression, suggesting reduced sludge moisture-holding capacity. EPS analysis showed that at the same drying time, applying 25 kPa mechanical compression increased sludge temperature by 16 % and protein content by 13.8 %. At the same sludge temperature, protein content rose by 7.3 % compared to the drying without mechanical compression. It was concluded that the fast rise in sludge temperature and the mechanical extrusion facilitated the destruction of sludge microbial flocs, accelerating the release of intracellular and EPS-bound moisture and contributing to the decrease in moisture-holding capacity. Besides, tryptophan protein-like substances were the major source of hydrophilic/hydrophobic organic matter, compared to polysaccharide and humic acid-like substances. The gradually reduced sludge moisture-holding capacity was divided into three stages. Below 67 °C, the moisture desorption was dominated by the release of intracellular moisture. Below 85 °C, the increase in protein and the enhanced exposure of hydrophobic functional groups in protein improved the hydrophobicity of EPS. Above 85 °C, protein consumption due to thermal decomposition and browning reaction facilitated the desorption of EPS-bound moisture. Hence, this study provided novel insights into the mechanism of sludge drying.

Revealing How Polyvinyl Chloride Microplastic Physicochemically Affect the Anaerobic Digestion of Waste Activated Sludge

Recent studies have shown that the microplastics in waste activated sludge (WAS) can directly reduce the microbial activity and influence the performance of anaerobic digestion. Unfortunately, few studies paid attention on the interactions between WAS and MPs, since MPs could impact the contact between sludge flocs and microorganisms. We found that PVC-MP changed the interfacial energy properties of the WAS surface and affected methane production. Low concentration (40 mg/L) of PVC-MP changed the water affinity and greatly reduced the energy barrier of interfacial reaction. Simultaneously, WAS surface charge characteristics changed with increasing MPs concentration, which made the sludge difficult to contact with microorganisms. The change process of WAS surface functional groups also indicated that PVC-MP first cover the sludge surface to prevent from being utilized by microorganisms, and then affect the surface protein structure before toxic substances leaching. Our study provides new insights into how MPs affect anaerobic digestion.

Behavior of organic components and the migration of heavy metals during sludge dewatering by different advanced oxidation processes via optical spectroscopy and molecular fingerprint analysis

A comparative study of the different advanced oxidation processes (Fe(II)-Oxone, Fe(II)-H2O2, and Fe(II)-NaClO) was carried out herein to analyze the characteristics of organic components and the migration of heavy metals in waste activated sludge. With the Fe(II)-Oxone and Fe(II)-H2O2 treatments, sludge dewaterability was significantly improved, however, sludge dewaterability was deteriorated by the Fe(II)-NaClO treatment. The enhanced sludge dewaterability by the Fe(II)-Oxone and Fe(II)-H2O2 treatments was strongly correlated with the shifted organic components, particularly proteins, in soluble extracellular polymeric substances (S-EPS), while the deteriorated sludge dewaterability by the Fe(II)-NaClO treatment was strongly correlated with the over release of organic components from bound EPS (B-EPS) to S-EPS. For both the Fe(II)-Oxone and Fe(II)-H2O2 treatments, the radicals preferentially attacked humic acid-like organic components over the protein-like organic components in S-EPS, while for the Fe(II)-NaClO treatment, interestingly, the radicals preferentially attacked the protein-like organic components in both S-EPS and B-EPS. The hydrophilic functional groups like phenolic OH and CO of polysaccharides may be more preferentially migrated to S-EPS of sludge by the Fe(II)-NaClO treatment compared to the other two treatments. With the Fe(II)-Oxone and Fe(II)-H2O2 treatments, the proportion of aliphatic compounds as well as the much oxygenated organic components with a low desaturation and a low molecular weight increased. While with the Fe(II)-NaClO treatment, the proportion of low oxygenated organic components with a high desaturation and a high molecular weight increased. The concentration of total organic carbon, particularly the concentration of proteins, may be the key factor determining the shift of Zn and Cu from sludge solid to liquid phase, along with the high oxidation extent of organic components and close binding to CHOS and CHON compounds as indicated by density functional theory (DFT) calculation. This study systematically revealed the simultaneous sludge dewatering and migration of heavy metals when the role of organic components was factored into herein.

Low-rate ferrate dosing damages the microbial biofilm structure through humic substances destruction and facilitates the sewer biofilm control

The microbial activities in sewer biofilms are recognized as a major reason for sewer pipe corrosion, malodor, and greenhouse gas emissions. However, conventional methods to control sewer biofilm activities were based on the inhibitory or biocidal effect of chemicals and often required long exposure time or high dosing rates due to the protection of sewer biofilm structure. Therefore, this study attempt to use ferrate (Fe(VI)), a green and high-valent iron, at low dosing rates to damage the sewer biofilm structure so as to enhance sewer biofilm control efficiency. The results showed the biofilm structure started to crush when the Fe(VI) dosage was 15 mg Fe(VI)/L and the damage enhanced with the increasing dosage. The determination of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) showed that Fe(VI) treatment at 15-45 mgFe/L mainly decreased the content of humic substances (HS) in biofilm EPS. This is because the functional groups, such as C-O, -OH, and C=O, which held the large molecular structure of HS, were the primary target of Fe(VI) treatment as suggested by 2D-Fourier Transform Infrared spectra. As a result, the coiled chain of EPS maintained by HS was turned to extended and dispersed and consequently led to a loosed biofilm structure. The XDLVO analysis suggested that both the microbial interaction energy barrier and secondary energy minimum were increased after Fe(VI) treatment, suggesting that the treated biofilm was less likely to aggregate and easier to be removed by the shear stress caused by high wastewater flow. Moreover, combined Fe(VI) and free nitrous acid (FNA) dosing experiments showed for achieving 90% inactivation, the FNA dosing rate could be reduced by 90% with the exposure time decreasing by 75% at a low Fe(VI) dosing rate and the total cost was substantially decreased. These results suggested that applying low-rate Fe(VI) dosing for sewer biofilm structure destruction is expected to be an economical way to facilitate sewer biofilm control.

Artificial humic acid regulates the impact of fungal community on soil macroaggregates formation

Artificial humic acid (A-HA), which is synthesized from agricultural wastes and has high similarity to a natural humic substance (HS) extracted from soil, has been proven by our group to have potential for biological carbon sequestration in black soils. However, the mechanism involves in the application of A-HA on soil aggregation processes resulting from microbial activity stimulation and modifications to microbial communities remains unclear. This study investigates the correlation between the formation and stability of soil aggregates and fungal communities with various amounts of A-HA added to the rhizosphere and non-rhizosphere soil. A-HA can increase the total organic carbon (TOC) and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentrations in soil, promoting macroaggregate formation and increasing the mean weight diameter (MWD). In addition, soil aggregate binding agents such as polysaccharides, protein, extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), and glomalin-related soil protein (GRSP) are significantly increased by the addition of A-HA. A-HA can drive microaggregate to assemble into macroaggregate by increasing the abundance of beneficial fungi (e.g., Trichoderma and Mortierella). The co-occurrence network supports that A-HA shifted the key species and increased interactions of fungal taxa. This study will lay a solid foundation for sustainable agricultural development of A-HA application for soil fertility restoration in the future.

The effect of repeated energy inputs on the release profiles of extracellular organic substances in sewage sludge

Organic matter (OM) recovery from sewage sludge is critical for sustainable development. Extracellular organic substances (EOS) are the main organic components of sludge, and the release of EOS from sludge is usually the rate-limiting step for OM recovery. However, a poor understanding of the intrinsic characteristics of binding strength (BS) of EOS usually restricts the release of OM from sludge. To reveal the underlying mechanism that how the intrinsic characteristics of EOS limit its release, in this study, the BS of EOS in sludge was quantitatively characterised by 10 rounds of energy input (E_in) with the same magnitude per round; the corresponding changes in the main components, floc structures and rheological properties of sludge after different numbers of E_in were also explored. Results showed that relationships between the release of EOS and the main multivalent metals, median diameters, fractal dimensions, elastic modulus and viscous modulus in the linear viscoelastic region of sludge versus the number of E_in, highlighted that the power-law distribution of BS in EOS was responsible for the occurrence state of organic molecules, stability of floc structures and maintenance of rheological properties. The result of hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) further revealed three BS levels of the EOS in sludge, indicating that the release or recovery of OM from sludge occurred in three stages. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study that explores the release profiles of EOS in sludge by repeated E_in for assessing the BS. Our findings may provide an important theoretical basis for the development target methods about the release and recovery of OM from sludge.

Advances in pretreatment strategies to enhance the biodegradability of waste activated sludge for the conversion of refractory substances

Anaerobic digestion (AD) is a low-cost technology widely used to divert waste activated sludge (WAS) to renewable energy production, but is generally restricted by its poor biodegradability which mainly caused by the endogenous and exogenous refractory substances present in WAS. Several conventional methods such as thermal-, chemical-, and mechanical-based pretreatment have been demonstrated to be effective on organics release, but their functions on refractory substances conversion are overlooked. This paper firstly reviewed the presence and role of endogenous and exogenous refractory substances in anaerobic biodegradability of WAS, especially on their inhibition mechanisms. Then, the pretreatment strategies developed for enhancing WAS biodegradability by facilitating refractory substances conversion were comprehensively reviewed, with the conversion pathways and underlying mechanisms being emphasized. Finally, the future research needs were directed, which are supposed to improve the circular bioeconomy of WAS management from the point of removing the hindering barrier of refractory substances on WAS biodegradability.

"Humic substances" measurement in sludge dissolved organic matter: A critical assessment of current methods

The role of humic substances (HS) during sludge treatment has been the focus in recent years. Quantification of HS in sludge dissolved organic matter (DOM) and the chemical and structural characterization of HS data are the prerequisite for understanding their role during different sludge treatment processes. Currently, a number of published articles inadequately acknowledge fundamental principles of analysis methods both in terms of experimental approach and data analysis. Therefore, a more comprehensive and detailed description of the experimental methods and the data analysis are needed. In this study, the current used methods for HS quantification in DOM of sludge had been tested for different calibration and sludge DOM samples. The results indicated that the current methods showed overestimated and contradictory results for HS quantification in sludge DOM. To be specific, using the modified Lowry method, different values were obtained depending on the humic acids used for calibration, and false negative results were observed for some sludge samples. By using the relative amount of HS (based on dissolved organic carbon (DOC)) to total sludge DOM (based on DOC), variations among the results of different analysis methods for the same sample were high. According to the calculated Bray-Curtis dissimilarity indexes, the results for HS quantification obtained by three-dimensional excitation emission matrix (3D-EEM), either with spectra analysis methods by peak picking, fluorescence region integration (both region volume and area integration), or PARAllel FACtor analysis showed higher degrees of dissimilarity to those quantified by size exclusion liquid chromatography or XAD-8 method. The selection of fluorescence regions for HS seemed to be the determining factor for overestimation obtained by the 3D-EEM technique. In future work, strategies, like a consistent terminology of HS, the use of an internal standard sample, and the related standardized operation for HS quantification in sludge DOM need to be established.

Unveiling the dual faces of chitosan in anaerobic digestion of waste activated sludge

In this study, the roles of chitosan (CTS) in anaerobic digestion of Waste activated sludge (WAS) were investigated. The results show that the methane production potential of WAS is positively correlated with the CTS content. The presence of 30 g/kg total suspended solids CTS increased the cumulative methane production from 215 ± 1.52 to 272 ± 1.83 mL/g volatile suspended solids. The positively charged amino groups in CTS neutralize the hydroxyl and carboxyl groups of extracellular polymeric substances, which reduces the negative charge on the surface of sludge and promotes sludge agglomeration, thereby inhibiting the release of organic matter. CTS also inhibits hydrolysis and acidification by immobilizing hydrolases and acidulase enzymes. However, CTS flocculates humus to avoid its interference with electron transfer, thereby enhancing the activity of coenzyme F420 and methanogenesis. In addition, CTS increases the abundance of methanogens, which also contributes to methane production.

Performance and stability of biogas recirculation-driven anaerobic digestion system coupling with alkali addition strategy for sewage sludge treatment

Wastewater treatment plants are particularly challenging with the treatment and disposal of sewage sludge produced from the treatment units due to its high costs and environmental hazards. In this study, a biogas recirculation-driven anaerobic digestion (AD) system was developed with upward shear force being provided by biogas recirculation coupled with the alkali addition strategy, targeting biogas upgrading, sludge stabilization, and sludge flocculation simultaneously, thus reducing the sludge management costs. Compared to the conventional AD system, the novel biogas recirculation-driven AD system could achieve biogas upgrading with 10% higher CH₄ content. Besides, the combination of NaOH and Ca(OH)₂ addition strategy obviously improved sludge settleability and dewaterability compared to the single NaOH addition strategy. Owing to the attraction between negatively charged sludge particles and Ca²⁺ ions, the available Ca²⁺ in the former AD system may facilitate the re-flocculation and P immobilization in solid digestate, fix partial CO₂ with less CO₂ emission, and bridge with some sludge flocs. Moreover, 12.6% lower net cost for sludge management was achieved by this biogas recirculation-driven AD system together with the combination alkali addition strategy, which is regarded as a promising integrated multi-purpose system for sludge treatment.

Electrical impedance spectroscopy as a potential tool to investigate the structure and size of aggregates during water and wastewater treatment

Microscopic structure and size are important metrics for estimating aggregates environmental behaviors during water and wastewater treatment. However, in-situ determination of these characteristics is still a challenge. Here, we drew inspiration from a block disassembly process to propose an electrical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) method and constructed a generalized framework to associate macroscale electrical properties with microscopic structure and size-related characteristics of aggregates of different hierarchies. Extracted via EIS, the proposed models were verified to be capable of describing the self-similarity of aggregates and capturing the fractal and size information. Further, the proposed models exhibited a wide range of applications, which agrees well with the data gathered from various activated sludges, other colloids, and microgels in water and wastewater treatment. Finally, the EIS method was achieved online monitoring of fractal dimension and floc size during a sludge pre-oxidation conditioning process, which was elected as an example to illustrate the potential online applications of this EIS method in real water and wastewater environment. The obtained on-line data were used to indicate the potential suitable oxidation time during sludge pre-oxidation conditioning. These observations may inspire new methods of quantifying the aggregate structure and promote intelligent and dynamic decision-making during water and wastewater treatment.

Underestimated humic acids release and influence on anaerobic digestion during sludge thermal hydrolysis

Humic-like acids (HAs) are abundant in sewage sludge but mainly bonded with solids. Thus, their influences are often neglected in conventional digestion processes. Currently thermal hydrolysis pretreatment (THP) has been widely adopted in sludge anaerobic digestion (AD) to enhance hydrolysis of complex matters and further to improve methane production. However, the impacts of enhanced release of HAs and the mechanisms involved are not well understood and need to be further investigated because the substantial amounts of HAs present in AD could severely threaten the sludge AD processes. Results in the present study indicated that the concentration of soluble HAs in sludge was elevated by 90 times due to the THP, from 8 mg/L in raw sludge to 727 mg/L in the pretreated sludge hydrolyzed at 180 °C. Moreover, the structural characteristics of soluble HAs, including aromatic condensation degree, elemental composition and functional group, also showed substantial differences with the increased temperature of the THP. Furthermore, the release of HAs presented significant influences on sludge digestion. Acidification rate was inhibited by over 50% with 0.4 g/L of HAs, whereas methanogenesis was improved by nearly 200% with 0.8 g/L HAs and inhibited about 50% with 2.0 g/L. The activities of proteinase and co-enzyme F₄₂₀ were decreased by 20% and increased by 19%, respectively, under HAs stress at 0.6 g/L for 5 days. Moreover, molecular structural changes of soluble HAs also contributed to the influences. Especially, the E4/E6 value representing the degree of HAs aromatic condensation and C/N ratio of soluble HAs were closely correlated with their inhibition degree to sludge hydrolysis. The findings of this study demonstrate that the influences of HAs are evident and also vary to the different steps of anaerobic digestion processes, which shall not be negligible during the sludge digestion that is with THP. Due to the rate-limiting step was methanogenesis in the AD process of pretreated sludge by thermal hydrolysis, HAs concentration was recommended at low level, for example around 1.0 g/L, to accelerate or not limit methanogenesis.

Changes in the characteristics of dissolved organic matter during sludge treatment: A critical review

Dissolved organic matter (DOM) of sludge is a heterogeneous mixture of high to low molecular weight organic substances which is including proteinaceous compounds, carbohydrates, humic substances, lipids, lignins, organic acids, organic micropollutants and other biological derived substances generated during wastewater treatment. This paper reviews definition, composition, quantification, and transformation of DOM during different sludge treatments, and the complex interplay of DOM with microbial communities. In anaerobic digestion, anaerobic digestion-refractory organic matter, particularly compounds showing polycyclic steroid-like, alkane and aromatic structures can be generated after pretreatment. During dewatering, the DOM fraction of low molecular weight proteins (< 20,000 Dalton) is the key parameter deteriorating sludge dewaterability. During composting, decomposition and polymerization of DOM occur, followed by the formation of humic substances. During landfill treatment, the composition of DOM, particularly humic substances, are related with leachate quality. Finally, suggestions are proposed for a better understanding of the transformation and degradation of DOM during sludge treatment. Future work in sludge studies needs the establishment and implementation of definitions for sample handling and the standardization of DOM methods for analysis, including sample preparation and fractionation, and data integration. A more detailed knowledge of DOM in sludge facilitates the operation and optimization of sludge treatment technologies.

Suppression of Methane Generation during Methanogenesis by Chemically Modified Humic Compounds

The introduction of various concentrations of chemically modified humic compounds (HC) with different redox characteristics into the media with free and immobilized anaerobic consortia accumulating landfill gases was studied as approach to their functioning management. For this purpose, quinone (hydroquinone, naphthoquinone or methylhydroquinone) derivatives of HC were synthesized, which made it possible to vary the redox and antioxidant properties of HC as terminal electron acceptors in methanogenic systems. The highest acceptor properties were obtained with potassium humate modified by naphthoquinone. To control possible negative effect of HC on the cells of natural methanogenic consortia, different bioluminescent analytical methods were used. The addition of HC derivatives, enriched with quinonones, to nutrient media at concentrations above 1 g/L decreased the energetic status of cells and the efficiency of the methanogenesis. For the first time, the significant decrease in accumulation of biogas was reached as effect of synthetic HC derivatives, whereas both notable change of biogas composition towards increase in the CO₂ content and decrease in CH₄ were revealed. Thus, modification with quinones makes it possible to obtain low-potential HC derivatives with strongly pronounced acceptor properties, promising for inhibition of biogas synthesis by methanogenic communities.

Enhancing acidogenic fermentation of waste activated sludge via isoelectric-point pretreatment: Insights from physical structure and interfacial thermodynamics

The poor biodegradability of waste activated sludge (WAS) is widely regarded as one of the main bottlenecks in the fermentation of sludge and is attributed mainly to the complex nature of sludge. In this study, the physical structure and interfacial thermodynamics of sludge, which reflect its complex nature, were explored to reveal the effects of isoelectric-point (pI) pretreatment on enhancing the production of volatile fatty acids (VFA). It was observed that the maximum VFA production and the initial VFA production rate increased by 151.2% and 46.6%, respectively, after pI pretreatment, which indicates that pI pretreatment significantly improved the generation efficiency of VFA. The experimental results of 12-day acidogenic fermentation assays following pI pretreatment show that the maximum concentrations of soluble total organic carbon, soluble protein and soluble polysaccharide increased by 209.8%, 148.9% and 84.5%, respectively, and the maximal proportion of low molecular weight (<1 kDa) soluble organic substances increased by 92.4%, thus confirming that pI pretreatment can promote organic solubilisation and hydrolysis in sludge. The analyses of changes in the fractal dimension (D_f), the spatial configuration of extracellular polymeric substances, and the interfacial non-covalent interaction energy of sludge during the fermentation process reveal that pI pretreatment can loosen the physical structure, promote the spatial extension of biopolymer molecular chains, and increase the driving forces of solid-liquid interfacial enzymatic reactions. It is thus hypothesised that these changes could be responsible for the high degree of organic solubilisation, hydrolysis and acidification of WAS, which is further confirmed by correlation analyses of the D_f and interfacial free energy versus VFA production. These findings are expected to provide a possible means to improve the biodegradability of sludge via its pI to trigger dismantling of the sludge structure and increase the driving forces of interfacial enzymatic reactions.