Stabilization of arsenic and antimony Co-contaminated soil with an iron-based stabilizer: Assessment of strength, leaching and hydraulic properties and immobilization mechanisms

Stabilization of arsenic-cadmium co-contaminated soil with the iron-manganese sludge derived amendment: Effects and mechanisms

An iron-manganese sludge-derived amendment was proposed to remediate arsenic (As) and cadmium (Cd) co-contaminated soil, with a strong adsorptive capacity across pH 4 to 10. The Langmuir model defined maximum adsorption at 78.17 mg/g for As(III), 110.48 mg/kg for As(V), and 65.77 mg/g for Cd(II). The X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) spectra provided insights into the chemical interactions: As was predominantly complexed or ligand exchanged with iron(hydr)oxides. In contrast, cadmium exhibited a tendency to bond with acylamino and carboxyl groups, in addition to the ferric hydroxyl groups. Notably, 42.15% of the adsorbed As(III) was oxidized into As(V) by Mn(IV) oxides present in the amendment. The soil-verification experiment demonstrated that an amendment dosage of 40 g/kg was efficacious in reducing the leaching concentration of As and Cd to maintained below the safety thresholds of 0.1 mg/L and 0.01 mg/L, respectively, for pH levels 4 to 11, meeting the Chinese Surface Water Quality Standard V (GB3838-2002). After the stabilization, the exchangeable fractions of As and the acid-soluble fractions of Cd were significantly reduced, with these elements being transformed into more stable forms. The amendment maintained the soil's neutral pH and adjusted the soil physicochemical properties. This article presents a holistic approach by examining the organic-inorganic composite of iron-manganese oxides with polyacrylamide, modified as a stabilizing amendment for As and Cd co-contaminated soil. This innovative amendment adeptly navigates the previously conflicting stabilization mechanisms for anionic and cationic metals. Offering dual advantages, the amendment not only remediates soil but also addresses the disposal of waste, presenting a win-win solution for environmental management.

A state-of-the-art review on the application of lignosulfonate as a green alternative in soil stabilization

The utilization of lignosulfonate (LS) as a naturally derived biopolymer sourced from lignin in soil stabilization has gained significant attention in recent years. Its intermolecular interaction, hydrophobic and hydrophilic effects, adhesive and binding properties, erosion control abilities, compatibility with various soil types, and environmental sustainability make it a promising alternative to traditional soil stabilizers as well as highlighting its importance. By integrating LS into soil stabilization practices, soil properties can be enhanced, and an eco-friendlier approach can be adopted in the construction sector. This comprehensive review paper extensively examines the applications and structure of LS, as well as their efficacy and mechanisms on a micro-level scale. Afterward, it discusses the geotechnical characteristics of LS-treated soils, including consistency characteristics, dispersivity properties and erosion behavior, electrical conductivity, compaction parameters, permeability and hydraulic conductivity, compressibility characteristics, swelling potential, strength and stiffness properties, durability, and cyclic loading response. In general, LS incorporation into the soils could enhance the geotechnical properties. For instance, the Unconfined Compressive Strength (UCS) of fine-grained soils was observed to improve up to 105 %, while in the case of granular soils, the improvement can be as high as 450 %. This review also examines the economic and environmental efficiency, as well as challenges and ways forward related to LS stabilization. This can lead to economic and environmental benefits given the abundance of LS as a plant polymer for cleaner production and owing to its carbon neutrality and renewability.

Mechanisms of enhancing MgO for stabilization/solidification of Pb-contaminated red clay through CO2 sequestration

Pb-contaminated soil poses significant environmental and health risks as well as soil stability issues. Research on sandy soils highlights CO2-enhanced reactive MgO as a promising solution for improving the solidification of Pb-contaminated soils. However, carbonation effects can differ markedly between soil types owing to varying soil properties. In this study, we evaluated the effects of CO2-enhanced reactive MgO on the engineering and environmental characteristics of Pb-contaminated red clay and explored its mechanism of carbonation solidification. The results showed that CO2-enhanced reactive MgO increased the strength of Pb-contaminated red clay to over 3 MPa within 1 h, which was approximately 25 times the strength of untreated soil (0.2 MPa) and significantly higher than that of reactive MgO-treated, uncarbonated soil (0.8 MPa). The pH of the carbonated soil (9-10) facilitated Pb2+ immobilization, and the increase over the initial parameter elevated the electrical conductivity value. Moreover, CO2-enhanced reactive MgO reduced the Pb2+ leaching concentration to below 0.1 mg/L, even at high Pb concentrations (10,000 mg/kg). Pb2+ transformed into lead carbonates during the carbonation process, with the hydrated magnesium carbonates forming a dense internal structure. This solidification mechanism included chemical precipitation, physical adsorption, and encapsulation. Notably, the carbonation time should be controlled within 1 h to prevent soil expansion. Together, these findings support the potential of CO2-enhanced reactive MgO for efficient and low-carbon application in the solidification of Pb-contaminated red clay.

Insights into the biogeochemical transformation, environmental impacts and biochar-based soil decontamination of antimony

Every year, a significant amount of antimony (Sb) enters the environment from natural and anthropogenic sources like mining, smelting, industrial operations, ore processing, vehicle emissions, shooting activities, and coal power plants. Humans, plants, animals, and aquatic life are heavily exposed to hazardous Sb or antimonide by either direct consumption or indirect exposure to Sb in the environment. This review summarizes the current knowledge about Sb global occurrence, its fate, distribution, speciation, associated health hazards, and advanced biochar composites studies used for the remediation of soil contaminated with Sb to lessen Sb bioavailability and toxicity in soil. Anionic metal(loid) like Sb in the soil is significantly immobilized by pristine biochar and its composites, reducing their bioavailability. However, a comprehensive review of the impacts of biochar-based composites on soil Sb remediation is needed. Therefore, the current review focuses on (1) the fundamental aspects of Sb global occurrence, global soil Sb contamination, its transformation in soil, and associated health hazards, (2) the role of different biochar-based composites in the immobilization of Sb from soil to increase biochar applicability toward Sb decontamination. The review aids in developing advanced, efficient, and effective engineered biochar composites for Sb remediation by evaluating novel materials and techniques and through sustainable management of Sb-contaminated soil, ultimately reducing its environmental and health risks.

Effect of freeze-thaw frequency plus rainfall on As and Sb metal(loid)s leaching from the solidified/stabilized soil remediated with Fe-based composite agent

The composite agent of ferrous sulfate, fly ash, and calcium lignosulfonate (FFC) can remediate the soil contaminated by As and Sb under cyclic freeze-thaw (F-T) via stabilization/solidification (S/S). However, the impact of high-frequency F-T cycles on the leaching behavior and migration of As and Sb in FFC-treated soils remains unclear. Here the leaching concentrations, heavy metal speciation (Wenzel's method), and Hydrus-1d simulations were investigated. The results showed that FFC effectively maintained the long-term S/S efficiency of arsenic remediation subject to an extended rainfall and freeze-thaw cycles, and stabilized the easily mobile form of As. The short-term S/S effect on Sb in the remediated soils suffering from F-T cycles was demonstrated in the presence of FFC. In a 20-year span, the mobility of Sb was affected by the number of F-T cycles (FT60 > FT20 > FT40 > FT0) in soil with a depth of 100 cm. As leaching progressed, FFC slowed the upward proportion of adsorbed As fractions but converted parts of the residual Sb to the form of crystalline Fe/Al (hydro) oxide. Moreover, the adsorption rate and capacity of As also preceded that of Sb. Long-term curative effects of FFC could be observed for As, but further development of agents capable of remedying Sb under cyclic F-T and long-term rainfall was needed. The predictive results on the migration and leaching behavior of heavy metals in S/S remediated soils may provide new insight into the long-term assessment of S/S under natural conditions.

Immobilisation remediation of arsenic-contaminated soils with promising CaAl-layered double hydroxide and bioavailability, bioaccessibility, and speciation-based health risk assessment

Arsenic (As)-contaminated soil poses great health risk to human mostly through inadvertent oral exposure. We investigated CaAl-layered double hydroxide (CaAl-LDH), a promising immobilising agent, for the remediation of As-contaminated Chinese soils. The effects on specific soil properties and As fractionation were analyzed, and changes in the health risk of soil As were accurately assessed by means of advanced in vivo mice model and in vitro PBET-SHIME model. Results showed that the application of CaAl-LDH significantly increased soil pH and concentration of Fe and Al oxides, and effectively converted active As fractions into the most stable residual fraction, guaranteeing long-term remediation stability. Based on in vivo test, As relative bioavailability was significantly reduced by 37.75%. Based on in vitro test, As bioaccessibility in small intestinal and colon phases was significantly reduced by 25.65% and 28.57%, respectively. Furthermore, As metabolism (reduction and methylation) by the gut microbiota inhabiting colon was clearly observed. After immobilisation with CaAl-LDH, the concentration of bioaccessible As(Ⅴ) in the colon fluid was significantly reduced by 61.91%, and organic As (least toxic MMA(V) and DMA(V)) became the main species, which further reduced the health risk of soil As. In summary, CaAl-LDH proved to be a feasible option for immobilisation remediation of As-contaminated soils, and considerable progress was made in relevant health risk assessment.

Management of arsenic-contaminated excavated soils: A review

Ongoing global sustainable development and underground space utilization projects have inadvertently exposed many excavated soils naturally contaminated with geogenic arsenic (As). Recent investigations have revealed that As in certain excavated soils, especially those originating from deep construction projects, has exceeded regulatory limits, threatening the environment and human health. While numerous remediation techniques exist for treating As-contaminated soil, the unique characteristics of geogenic As contamination in excavated soil require specific measures when leachable As content surpasses established regulatory limits. Consequently, several standard leaching tests have been developed globally to assess As leaching from contaminated soil. However, a comprehensive comparative analysis of these methods and their implementation in contaminated excavated soils remains lacking. Furthermore, the suitability and efficacy of most conventional and advanced techniques for remediating As-contaminated excavated soils remained unexplored. Therefore, this study critically reviews relevant literature and summarize recent research findings concerning the management and mitigation of geogenic As in naturally contaminated excavated soil. The objective of this study was to outline present status of excavated soil globally, the extent and mode of As enrichment, management and mitigation approaches for As-contaminated soil, global excavated soil recycling strategies, and relevant soil contamination countermeasure laws. Additionally, the study provides a concise overview and comparison of standard As leaching tests developed across different countries. Furthermore, this review assessed the suitability of prominent and widely accepted As remediation techniques based on their applicability, acceptability, cost-effectiveness, duration, and overall treatment efficiency. This comprehensive review contributes to a more profound comprehension of the challenges linked to geogenic As contamination in excavated soils.

Simultaneous stabilization of arsenic and antimony co-contaminated mining soil by Fe(Ⅱ) activated-Fenton sludge: Behavior and mechanisms

Fenton sludge (FS) with high iron contents that discharged from the Fenton process was rarely studied for soil remediation. Herein, a novel Fe(Ⅱ) activated-Fenton sludge (FS-FeSO4) was proposed to stabilize arsenic (As) and antimony (Sb) co-contaminated soil meanwhile disposing FS. Multiple characteristic analyses revealed that the porous structures and rich functional groups of FS-FeSO4 involved in As and Sb adsorption. Meanwhile, Fe (hydro)oxides played a key role in As and Sb stabilization. Under the optimal application parameters (stabilizers dosage: 5%, incubation time: 60 days), the available As and Sb content decreased by 88.6% and 83.3%, respectively, and the leachability of As and Sb was reduced by 100% and 72.6% for FS-FeSO4 stabilized soil. Moreover, the mobile As and Sb fractions (F1 and F2) were transformed into the most stable fraction (F5). The adsorption of As and Sb on FS-FeSO4 was well fitted by pseudo-second-order kinetic and Langmuir models, while FS-FeSO4 exhibited a better affinity for As than Sb under competition conditions. Poorly crystalline α-FeOOH and amorphous Fe (hydro)oxides provided sufficient active sites for As and Sb, and the generation of Fe-As/Sb and Ca-Sb chemical bonds promoted the stability of As and Sb. This study demonstrated that FS-FeSO4 was a potentially effective stabilizer for As and Sb co-contaminated soil remediation.

A review on sources of soil antimony pollution and recent progress on remediation of antimony polluted soils

Antimony (Sb) is a serious toxic and non-essential metalloid for animals, humans, and plants. The rapid increase in anthropogenic inputs from mining and industrial activities, vehicle emissions, and shoot activity increased the Sb concentration in the environment, which has become a serious concern across the globe. Hence, remediation of Sb-contaminated soils needs serious attention to provide safe and healthy foods to humans. Different techniques, including biochar (BC), compost, manures, plant additives, phyto-hormones, nano-particles (NPs), organic acids (OA), silicon (Si), microbial remediation techniques, and phytoremediation are being used globally to remediate the Sb polluted soils. In the present review, we described sources of soil Sb pollution, the environmental impact of antimony pollution, the multi-faceted nature of antimony pollution, recent progress in remediation techniques, and recommendations for the remediation of soil Sb-pollution. We also discussed the success stories and potential of different practices to remediate Sb-polluted soils. In particular, we discussed the various mechanisms, including bio-sorption, bio-accumulation, complexation, and electrostatic attraction, that can reduce the toxicity of Sb by converting Sb-V into Sb-III. Additionally, we also identified the research gaps that need to be filled in future studies. Therefore, the current review will help to develop appropriate and innovative strategies to limit Sb bioavailability and toxicity and sustainably manage Sb polluted soils hence reducing the toxic effects of Sb on the environment and human health.

Investigating the use of Aspergillus niger fermentation broth as a washing treatment for arsenic and antimony co-contaminated soil

High concentrations of arsenic and antimony contamination in soil are a potential risk to the ecological environment and human health. Soil washing can effectively and permanently reduce the soil contamination. This study used Aspergillus niger fermentation broth as a washing agent to remove As and Sb from contaminated soil. Characterization of organic acids in the fermentation broth by high-performance liquid chromatographic (HPLC) and chemically simulated leaching experiments revealed that oxalic acid played a significant role in removing As and Sb from the soil. The effect of washing conditions on the metal removal rate of Aspergillus niger fermentation broth was investigated by batch experiments, and the optimal conditions were determined: no dilution, pH 1, L/S ratio 15:1, and leaching at 25 °C for 3 h. The soils were washed three times under optimal conditions, with 73.78%, 80.84%, and 85.83% removal of arsenic and 65.11%, 76.39%, and 82.06% removal of antimony, respectively. The results of metal speciation distribution in the soil showed that the fermentation broth could effectively remove As and Sb on amorphous Fe/Al hydrous oxides in soil. The analysis of X-ray diffraction (XRD) and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) of soils before and after washing showed that the washing of Aspergillus niger fermentation broth had a minor effect on the structural changes of soils. After washing, soil organic matter and soil enzyme activity were increased. Thus, Aspergillus niger fermentation broth shows excellent potential as a washing agent for removing As and Sb from soils.

Antimony and naphthalene can be simultaneously leached from a combined contaminated soil using carboxymethyl-β-cyclodextrin as a biodegradable eluant

In this study, we have investigated the removal efficiency of antimony (Sb) and naphthalene (Nap) from a combined contaminated soil by carboxymethyl-β-cyclodextrin (CMCD) leaching and reveal its remediation mechanisms by FTIR and ¹H NMR analyses. The results show that the highest removal efficiencies of Sb and Nap were 94.82% and 93.59%, respectively, with a CMCD concentration of 15 g L^-1 at a pH of 4 and a leaching rate of 2.00 mL min^-1 over an interval-time of 12 h. The breakthrough curves show that CMCD had a stronger inclusion capacity of Nap than Sb, and Sb could enhance the adsorption capacity of Nap, while Nap weakened the adsorption of Sb during CMCD leaching. Furthermore, the FTIR analysis suggests that the removal of Sb from combined contaminated soil involved complexation with the carboxyl and hydroxyl groups on CMCD, and the NMR analysis suggests that the inclusion of Nap occurred. These results indicate that CMCD is a good eluant for remediating soil contaminated by a combination of heavy metals and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and its remediation mechanisms depend on the complexation reactions between the surface functional groups and inclusion reactions in the internal cavities.

Immobilizing arsenic in soil via amine metal complex: a case study using iron-ethylenediamine

Fe-based nanomaterials have been extensively investigated for their application in mitigating arsenic (As) pollution in groundwater, sediment, and soils. Here, an iron-ethylenediamine (Fe-EDA) complex was synthesized and characterized using Fourier transform-infrared spectroscopy and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy before its use as an amendment to ameliorate As-polluted soils. Column leaching tests at three Fe-EDA application rates (1%, 3%, and 5%) were conducted, and their results were compared with those acquired after using nano zerovalent iron (nZVI) and Fe₃O₄, to assess their efficiency to amend As-contaminated paddy soils. After leaching, stabilization efficiency and soil chemical characteristics were determined. Additionally, As fractions were measured using inductively coupled plasma-mass spectroscopy by employing a sequential extraction procedure to evaluate the performance of the treatments and understand the underlying their mechanisms. Compared with the control treatment, the Fe-EDA treatment reduced As release by more than 35.33% in the 2nd leaching cycle, whereas nZVI and Fe₃O₄ decreased the As release by 11.84% and 24.60%, respectively. Moreover, the optimal addition of the Fe-EDA chelate was 5%, which stabilized more than 50% As in the soil from the 7th to 11th leaching cycles. After sequential extraction, the Fe-Mn oxide binding fraction, which was originally 12.65%, increased to 21.5%, 18.23%, and 21.71% after the application of nZVI, Fe₃O₄, and Fe-EDA amendments, respectively. Furthermore, our treatments promoted the binding of the As fraction with crystalline Fe (III) (oxyhydr)oxide (F3); however, other fractions did not increase considerably, suggesting that the Fe-EDA complex could effectively stabilize As through electrostatic attraction between the arsenate anion and EDA, as well as As-O-Fe bond formation via a coordinating reaction. Overall, Fe-EDA was found to be a potent amendment for mitigating As-polluted soil.

Effect of goethite-loaded montmorillonite on immobilization of metal(loid)s and the micro-ecological soil response in non-ferrous metal smelting areas

In this work, the immobilization stabilization and mechanism of heavy metal(loid)s by goethite loaded montmorillonite (GMt) were investigated, and the soil microbial response was explored. The simulated acid rain leaching experiment showed that GMt had a higher acid tolerance and the more stable heavy metal(loid)s fixation ability. The soil incubation demonstrated that GMt significantly decreased the available Cd, Zn, Pb and As concentration. Interestingly, higher immobilization of heavy metals was observed by GMt in highly acid leached and acidic soils. The richness and diversity of bacterial communities improved after the addition of GMt. GMt induced the enrichment of the excellent functional bacteria of the phylum Proteobacteria as well as the genus Massilia and Sphingomonas. The main immobilization mechanisms of heavy metal(loid)s by GMt include electrostatic interaction, complexation, precipitation and oxidation. The addition of the GMt also optimizes the soil bacterial community structure, which further facilitates the immobilization of heavy metal(loid)s. Our results confirm that the novel GMt has a promising application in the immobilization and stabilization of heavy metal(loid)s contaminated soils in non-ferrous metal smelting areas.

Performance and mechanisms for Cd(II) and As(III) simultaneous adsorption by goethite-loaded montmorillonite in aqueous solution and soil

A series of goethite-modified montmorillonite (GMt) materials was synthesized for the amelioration of cationic cadmium (Cd) and anionic arsenic (As) complex contaminants in soil and water bodies. The results showed that goethite (Gt) was successfully loaded onto the surface of montmorillonite (Mt), which possessed more functional groups (such as Fe-O, and Fe-OH) and a larger specific surface area. GMt-0.5 (Mt loaded with Gt at a ratio of 0.5:1) showed the highest adsorption capacity for Cd(II) and As(III) with the maximum of 50.61 mg/g and 57.58 mg/g, respectively. The removal rate of Cd(II) was highly pH dependent, while the removal rate of As(III) showed little dependence on pH. The goethite on montmorillonite might contribute to the formation of surface complexes with As(III) and oxidation of As(III) to As(V). In the binary system, both, synergistic and competitive adsorption existed simultaneously. Importantly, in the binary system, the removal of As(III) was more favorable because of the electrostatic interaction, formation of a ternary complex, and co-precipitation. In addition, the amendment of GMt-0.5 significantly reduced the availability of Cd and As in the soil. This study suggests that GMt-0.5 is a promising candidate for the simultaneous immobilization of metal (loid)s in both, aqueous solution and mine soil.

In Vitro Bioaccessibility and Health Risk Assessment of Arsenic and Zinc Contaminated Soil Stabilized by Ferrous Sulfate: Effect of Different Dietary Components

Iron-based materials have good stability in reducing the mobility and toxicity of heavy metals, but the behavior and human health risks of heavy metals could be affected by dietary components. This study investigated the effect of typical diets (lettuce, cooked rice and apples) on the bioaccessibility and morphological changes of arsenic (As) and zinc (Zn) in contaminated site after stabilization by ferrous sulfate (FeSO4). The results showed that the bioaccessibility of As and Zn were increased in a co-digestion system of food. The augmented effect on As bioaccessibility mainly occurred in the gastric phase: apple > lettuce > cooked rice (p < 0.05), while the augmented effect on Zn bioaccessibility mainly occurred in the intestinal phase: lettuce > apple > cooked rice (p < 0.05). FeSO4 weakened the dissolution effect of dietary components on As bioaccessibility, and reduced As bioaccessibility in the gastric and intestinal phases by 34.0% and 37.9% (p < 0.05), respectively. Dietary components and Fe fractions influenced the speciation and distribution of As and Zn. FeSO4 reduced the hazard quotient (HQ) and carcinogenic risk (CR) values of the contaminated soil by 33.97% and 33.59%, respectively. This study provides a reference for a better understanding of more realistic strategies to modulate exposure risks of heavy metal-contaminated sites.

Evaluation of the effectiveness of ex-situ stabilization for arsenic and antimony contaminated soil: Short-term and long-term leaching characteristics

Ex-situ stabilization for As and Sb co-contaminated soil was conducted through an iron-based stabilizer, PFSC (a mixture of polymerized ferric sulfate (PFS) and hydrated lime (Ca(OH₂)) with a dry mass ratio of 2:1). After field aging for one week, the stabilized contaminated soil was subjected to a horizontal vibration leaching test (HJ 557), Wenzel's sequential extraction, and a semi-dynamic leaching test (ANS 16.1). By assessing the cumulative fractions of As and Sb, the observed diffusion coefficients (D^obs) and leachability indices (LX) of metalloids released from the soil specimens were calculated. The PFSC ex-situ stabilization was effective to immobilize metalloids, and the As and Sb leached concentrations of stabilized contaminated soil samples were lower than remediation targets. Nonspecifically bound As and Sb in the stabilized contaminated soil samples decreased from 4.5 - 9.2 % to 1.5-2.5 % and from 2.2 - 5.8 % to 1.1-1.5 %, respectively. The mechanisms controlling the leaching behaviors of As and Sb included wash-off and diffusion and they were changed with the leaching interval. The mean D^obs of As and Sb released from stabilized contaminated soil specimen were 3.46 × 10^-12 and 2.99 × 10^-13 cm² s^-1, in the which were two orders of magnitude lower than that of untreated contaminated soil specimen. The mean LX of stabilized contaminated soil specimen for As and Sb releases were 11.40 and 12.83, respectively, indicating that the stabilized contaminated soil was acceptable for "controlled utilization".