A comparative study of arsenic(V), tetracycline and nitrate ions adsorption onto magnetic biochars and activated carbon

Physicochemical properties and performance of non-woody derived biochars for the sustainable removal of aquatic pollutants: A systematic review

Biochar is a carbon-rich material produced from the partial combustion of different biomass residues. It can be used as a promising material for adsorbing pollutants from soil and water and promoting environmental sustainability. Extensive research has been conducted on biochars prepared from different feedstocks used for pollutant removal. However, a comprehensive review of biochar derived from non-woody feedstocks (NWF) and its physiochemical attributes, adsorption capacities, and performance in removing heavy metals, antibiotics, and organic pollutants from water systems needs to be included. This review revealed that the biochars derived from NWF and their adsorption efficiency varied greatly according to pyrolysis temperatures. However, biochars (NWF) pyrolyzed at higher temperatures (400-800 °C) manifested excellent physiochemical and structural attributes as well as significant removal effectiveness against antibiotics, heavy metals, and organic compounds from contaminated water. This review further highlighted why biochars prepared from NWF are most valuable/beneficial for water treatment. What preparatory conditions (pyrolysis temperature, residence time, heating rate, and gas flow rate) are necessary to design a desirable biochar containing superior physiochemical and structural properties, and adsorption efficiency for aquatic pollutants? The findings of this review will provide new research directions in the field of water decontamination through the application of NWF-derived adsorbents.

The engineering of defect-modified boron nitride ribbons: an effective adsorbent to rapid capture for tetracycline

Antibiotics, the persistent organic pollutants, have brought serious pollution to the aquatic environment. Therefore, it is necessary to select rapid adsorbents to remove them from their long-term threat. Herein, the introduction of defects in BN was employed to enhance its surface chemical activity for rapid capture of tetracycline via hydrothermal and calcination methods. The defect content in BN can be controlled by adjusting the volume ratio of ethanol to water. Among them, when the volume ratio of H2O/ethanol is 4/1 (BN-3), BN-3 has the most N defects at 33%, which increases the adsorption rate of h-BN for TC and promotes the adsorption capacity to 302.15 mg g-1, which is due to the introduction of nitrogen defects significantly regulates the electronic structure of BN. The corresponding theoretical calculations confirm that BN with N defects decreases the absorption energy of BN for TC. Additionally, the adsorption removal rate of tetracycline still reached 95.5% after 5 cycles of TC adsorption by BN-3, indicating that the defect-modified BN has good reusability and is beneficial for its use in pollutant adsorption.

Tetracycline removal from soil by phosphate-modified biochar: Performance and bacterial community evolution

Since the remediation performance of soil tetracycline pollution by original biochar is not ideal, many modified methods have been proposed to improve its performance. Considering the cost, complex modification process and environmental friendliness, many modified biochar are difficult to be used in soil environments. In this work, biochar derived from corn stover was modified using phosphate to increase the adsorption ability of soil tetracycline and alleviate the negative effects caused by tetracycline. The results showed that pyrolysis temperatures and anion types of phosphate (PO43-, HPO42-, H2PO4-) played important roles in the performance of modified biochar. Compared with original biochar, phosphate modified biochar not only improved the adsorption capacity, but also changed the adsorption behavior of tetracycline. Via SEM, BET and FTIR techniques, the intrinsic reasons for the increase of adsorption capacity were explained by the change of morphological structures as well as functional groups of the modified biochar. K3PO4 and high temperature (800 °C) maximally improved the surface morphology, increased the pore structure, changed the surface functional groups of biochar, and then increased the adsorption capacity of tetracycline (124.51 mg/g). Subsequently, the optimal material (K3PO4-800) was selected and applied for tetracycline contaminated soil remediation. Compared to the soil without remediation, K3PO4-800 modified biochar effectively reduced the effective concentration of tetracycline in soil, and improved soil K and P nutrition, and reshaped microbial communities. Our study showed that K3PO4-800 modified biochar was not only a good tetracycline resistant material, but also a good soil amendment.

Recent advances in the synthesis and application of magnetic biochar for wastewater treatment

Magnetic biochar (MBC) is a novel bio-carbon material with both desired properties as adsorbent and magnetic characteristics. This review provides an up-to-date summary and discussion on the latest development of MBC, which covers the progress on its synthesis, application, and techno-economic analysis. The review indicates that the direct hydrothermal synthesis has been catching more research attention to produce MBC due to its mild reaction conditions. Instead of the Fe-loaded MBC, there is a trend of using Mn for the magnetization. For the MBC application, how to improve its adsorption performance for water decontamination, ideally to match that of the biochar (BC) or activated carbon, is important. In addition, more studies on the environmental impacts of MBC and life-cycle assessment decoding the process optimization options are necessary. This review will provide valuable references for the development of MBC and MBC-based materials for wastewater treatment.

Activation methods increase biochar's potential for heavy-metal adsorption and environmental remediation: A global meta-analysis

Removal of heavy metals (HMs) by adsorption on biochar's surface has shown promising results in the remediation of contaminated soil and water. The adsorption capacity of biochar can be altered by pre- or post-pyrolysis activation; however, the effect of activation methods on biochar's adsorption capacity varies widely. Here, we conducted a meta-analysis to identify the most effective methods for activation to enhance HM removal by biochar using 321 paired observations from 50 published articles. Activation of biochar significantly improves the adsorption capacity and removal efficiency of HMs by 136 and 80 %, respectively. This study also attempts to find suitable feedstocks, pyrolysis conditions, and physicochemical properties of biochar for maximizing the effect of activation of biochar for HMs adsorption. Activation of agricultural wastes and under pyrolysis temperatures of 350-550 °C produces biochars that are the most effective for HM adsorption. Activation of biochars with a moderate particle size (0.25-0.80 mm), low N/C (<0.01) and H/C ratios (<0.03), and high surface area (> 100 m² g^-1) and pore volume (> 0.1 cm³ g^-1) are the most desirable characteristics for enhancing HM adsorption. We conclude that pre-pyrolysis activation with metal salts/oxides was the most effective method of enhancing biochar's potential for adsorption and removal of a wide range of HMs. The results obtained from this study can be helpful in choosing appropriate methods of activations and the suitable choice of feedstocks and pyrolysis conditions. This will maximize HM adsorption on biochar surfaces, ultimately benefiting the remediation of contaminated environments.

Optimal preparation of a core-shell structural magnetic nanoadsorbent for efficient tetracycline removal

As emerging contaminants, tetracyclines pose a severe threat to aquatic environments and human health. Therefore, developing efficient approaches to remove tetracyclines from water has attracted a large amount of interest. Herein, a novel core-shell structural magnetic nanoadsorbent (FSMAS) was facilely prepared by graft copolymerization of acrylamide (AM) and sodium p-styrene sulfonate (SSS) monomers on the surface of vinyl-modified Fe₃O₄@SiO₂ (FSM). From single factor experiments, the optimal graft copolymerization conditions were concluded to be the following: initiator concentration = 1.2‰, reaction pH = 9, monomer molar ratio = 7 : 3. The surface morphology, microstructure and physicochemical properties of as-prepared FSMAS were fully evaluated by different characterization techniques, including SEM, TEM, FTIR, XPS, XRD and VSM. The adsorption performance of FSMAS towards tetracycline hydrochloride (TCH) was systematically studied by batch adsorption experiments. Results showed that the adsorption capability of the adsorbent was largely enhanced after graft copolymerization. The removal rate of TCH by FSMAS reached 95% at solution pH = 4.0, almost 10 times higher than FSM. Besides, the adsorption process of TCH by FSMAS was very efficient, 75% of pollutant could be adsorbed after only 10 minutes, attributed to the stretch of polymer chains and the strong affinity provided by abundant functional groups. Furthermore, TCH-loaded FSMAS was easily regenerated with HCl solution, the regeneration rate was higher than 80% after five adsorption-desorption cycles. Superior adsorption capability, fast solid-liquid separation speed and satisfactory reusability demonstrated the great potential of FSMAS in practical tetracycline removal.

Machine learning-assisted evaluation of potential biochars for pharmaceutical removal from water

A popular approach to select optimal adsorbents is to perform parallel experiments on adsorbents based on an initially decided goal such as specified product purity, efficiency, or binding capacity. To screen optimal adsorbents, we focused on the max adsorption capacity of the candidates at equilibrium in this work because the adsorption capacity of each adsorbent is strongly dependent on certain conditions. A data-driven machine learning tool for predicting the max adsorption capacity (Q_m) of 19 pharmaceutical compounds on 88 biochars was developed. The range of values of Q_m (mean 48.29 mg/g) was remarkably large, with a high number of outliers and large variability. Modified biochars enhanced the Q_m and surface area values compared with the original biochar, with a statistically significant difference (Chi-square value = 7.21-18.25, P < 0.005). K- nearest neighbors (KNN) was found to be the most optimal algorithm with a root mean square error (RMSE) of 23.48 followed by random forest and Cubist with RMSE of 26.91 and 29.56, respectively, whereas linear regression and regularization were the worst algorithms. KNN model achieved R² of 0.92 and RMSE of 16.62 for the testing data. A web app was developed to facilitate the use of the KNN model, providing a reliable solution for saving time and money in unnecessary lab-scale adsorption experiments while selecting appropriate biochars for pharmaceutical adsorption.

Adsorption of pollutants in wastewater via biosorbents, nanoparticles and magnetic biosorbents: A review

Adsorption has gained much attention as one of the efficient approaches to remediate the contaminants in wastewater. Herein, this critical review focuses on the preparation, modification, application and regeneration of the biosorbents, nanoparticles and magnetic biosorbents for the wastewater treatment in recent 5 years (2017-2021). Among these materials, the development of magnetic biosorbents is attractive owing to their variable active sites, high specific surface area, easy separation and low cost. To improve the adsorption performance of biosorbents, the chemical activations such as acid, alkali and salt activations of biosorbents are discussed. In general, the oxidation reaction in acid, alkali and salt activations increases the porosity of biosorbents. The surface characteristics, surface chemistry of the biosorbents and magnetic biosorbents such as electrostatic interaction, π-π interaction and hydrogen bonding are highlighted. Ionic compounds are separated through ion exchange, surface charge and electrostatic interactions while the organic pollutants are removed via hydrophobicity, π-π interactions and hydrogen bonding. The effect of solution pH, adsorbent dosage, initial concentration of pollutants, adsorption duration and temperature on the adsorption capacity, and removal efficiency are discussed. Generally, an increase in adsorbent dosage resulted in a decrease in adsorption capacity due to the excessive active sites. On the other hand, a higher initial concentration or an increase in contact time of adsorbent increased the driving force, subsequently enhancing the adsorption capacity. Finally, this review will be concluded with a summary, challenges and future outlook of magnetic biosorbents. It is anticipated that this review will provide insights into engineering advanced and suitable materials to achieve cost-effective and scalable adsorbents for practical and sustainable environmental remediation.

Removal of ammonia nitrogen, nitrate, and phosphate from aqueous solution using biochar derived from Thalia dealbata Fraser: effect of carbonization temperature

Thalia dealbata Fraser-derived biochar was prepared at different carbonization temperatures to remove nutrients in aqueous solution. Thermogravimetry/differential thermogravimetry (TG/DTG) was used to analyze the carbonization and decomposition procedure of Thalia dealbata Fraser. X-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscope (SEM), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), zeta potential, and N₂ adsorption-desorption isotherms were employed to characterize the prepared biochar. The carbonization temperature obviously effected the physical and chemical properties of biochar. The adsorption efficiency of ammonia (NH₄⁺-N), nitrate (NO₃^--N), and phosphate (PO₄^3-) adsorption on biochar was tested. Pseudo-first-order kinetic, pseudo-second-order kinetic, and intra-particle diffusion kinetic models were used to fit adsorption kinetic. Langmuir and Freundlich models were used to fit adsorption isotherms. The theoretical adsorption capacity of NH₄⁺-N, NO₃^--N, and PO₄^3- on biochar was 5.8 mg/g, 3.8 mg/g, and 1.3 mg/g, respectively. This study provides the insights for effect of carbonization temperature on biochar preparation and application.

Biochars and activated carbons as adsorbents of inorganic and organic compounds from multicomponent systems - A review

Biochars are obtained by biomass pyrolysis, whereas activated carbon is a biochar that has undergone chemical or physical activation. Owing to the large surface area and easy surface modification both solids are widely applied as adsorbents. They are low-costs materials, they could be regenerated and their disposal is not troublesome. Adsorption of heavy metals, dyes, pharmaceuticals on the surface of biochars and activated carbons, from simple systems of adsorbate containing only one compound, are described extensively in the literature. The present paper provides an overview of reports on adsorption of inorganic and organic compounds onto these two types of adsorbents from the mixed adsorbate systems. The described adsorbate systems have been divided into those consisting of: two or more inorganic ions, two or more organic compounds and both of them (inorganic and organic ones). The research of this type is carried out much less frequently due to the more complicated description of interactions in the mixed adsorbate systems.

Adsorption of As(III) and As(V) from aqueous solution by magnetic biosorbents derived from chemical carbonization of pea peel waste biomass: Isotherm, kinetic, thermodynamic and breakthrough curve modeling studies

The purpose of this research was to investigate the adsorption of arsenic (As) from aqueous solutions using MPAC-500 and MPAC-600 (magnetic-activated carbons synthesized from the peel of Pisum sativum (pea) pyrolyzed at 500 °C and 600 °C temperatures, respectively). The potential of both biosorbents for As adsorption was determined in batch and column mode. The characterization of both biosorbents was performed by energy dispersive spectroscopy, scanning electron microscope, pHZPC, particle size distribution, X-ray diffraction, zeta potential and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy. It was found that the efficiency of MPAC-600 was better than MPAC-500 for the adsorption of As(III) and As(V) ions. The adsorption capacities of MPAC-500 and MPAC-600 in removing As(III) were 0.7297 mg/g and 1.3335 mg/g, respectively, while the values of Qmax for As(V) on MPAC-500 and MPAC-600 were 0.4930 mg/g and 0.9451 mg/g, respectively. The Langmuir isotherm model was found to be the best fit for adsorption of As(III) by MPAC-500 and MPAC-600, as well as adsorption of As(V) by MPAC-500. The Freundlich isotherm model, on the other hand, was optimal for As(V) removal with MPAC-600. With R2 values close to unity, the pseudo-second-order kinetics were best fitted to the adsorption process of both As species. The Thomas model was used to estimate the breakthrough curves. The effects of coexisting oxyanions and regeneration studies were also carried out to examine the influence of oxyanions on As adsorption and reusability of biosorbents.

Synthesis and Characterization of Green ZnO@polynaniline/Bentonite Tripartite Structure (G.Zn@PN/BE) as Adsorbent for As (V) Ions: Integration, Steric, and Energetic Properties

A green ZnO@polynaniline/bentonite composite (G.Zn@PN/BE) was synthesized as an enhanced adsorbent for As (V) ions. Its adsorption properties were assessed in comparison with the integrated components of bentonite (BE) and polyaniline/bentonite (PN/BE) composites. The G.Zn@PN/BE composite achieved an As (V) retention capacity (213 mg/g) higher than BE (72.7 mg/g) and PN/BE (119.8 mg/g). The enhanced capacity of G.Zn@PN/BE was studied using classic (Langmuir) and advanced equilibrium (monolayer model of one energy) models. Considering the steric properties, the structure of G.Zn@PN/BE demonstrated a higher density of active sites (Nm = 109.8 (20 °C), 108.9 (30 °C), and 67.8 mg/g (40 °C)) than BE and PN/BE. This declared the effect of the integration process in inducing the retention capacity by increasing the quantities of the active sites. The number of adsorbed As (V) ions per site (1.76 up to 2.13) signifies the retention of two or three ions per site by a multi-ionic mechanism. The adsorption energies (from -3.07 to -3.26 kJ/mol) suggested physical retention mechanisms (hydrogen bonding and dipole bonding forces). The adsorption energy, internal energy, and free enthalpy reflected the exothermic, feasible, and spontaneous nature of the retention process. The structure is of significant As (V) uptake capacity in the existence of competitive anions or metal ions.

A critical review of various adsorbents for selective removal of nitrate from water: Structure, performance and mechanism

Nitrate is ubiquitous pollutant due to its high water solubility, usually contributing to eutrophication, and posing a threat to aquatic ecosystem and human health. Adsorption approach has been widely used for nitrate removal because of the simplicity, easy operation, and low cost. Adsorbent plays a key role in the adsorptive removal of nitrate. The adsorption performance and adsorption mechanism are determined by the structural feature of adsorbent that is dependent on the preparation method. In this review, various types of adsorbents for nitrate removal were systematically summarized, their preparation, characterization, and adsorption performance were evaluated; the factors influencing the nitrate adsorption performance were discussed; the adsorption isotherm models, kinetic models and thermodynamic parameters were examined; and the possible adsorption mechanisms responsible for nitrate adsorption were categorized; the possible correlation of adsorbent structure to adsorption performance and adsorption mechanism were explained; the potential applications of adsorbents were discussed; finally, the strategies for improving adsorption capacity and selectivity towards nitrate, the challenges and future perspectives for developing novel adsorbent were also proposed. This review will deepen the understanding of nitrate removal by adsorption process and help the development of high-performance adsorbents for selective nitrate removal from water and wastewater.

Temporal changes in arsenic and lead pools in a contaminated sediment amended with biochar pyrolyzed at different temperatures

Globally, tons of soils and sediments are experiencing degradation due to the presence of high concentrations of potentially toxic elements (PTEs), such as arsenic (As) and lead (Pb), in areas in the vicinity of metal mining activities. The addition of biochar to contaminated sediments is a promising in situ remediation approach, and the effects of pyrolysis temperature and biochar aging are important factors for the immobilization and fate of PTEs. In this study, we evaluated the temporal changes in pools of As and Pb in sediment amended with biochars produced from sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum) pyrolyzed at 350 (BC350), 550 (BC550), and 750 °C (BC750). Biochars were aged by natural process (without additional acid or heat), and changes in As and Pb pools were evaluated every 45 days until completing 180 days of incubation. Changes in the As and Pb pools were extracted with water (bioavailable), magnesium chloride (exchangeable), nitric acid (active geochemical fraction), and exchangeable Mehlich-3 (associated with organic matter). As and Pb available contents have increased over time. BC750 was more effective in reducing the bioavailable and exchangeable As contents, while BC550 and BC350 were more effective in reducing the contents of bioavailable and exchangeable Pb.

Engineered Magnetic Carbon-Based Adsorbents for the Removal of Water Priority Pollutants: An Overview

This review covers the preparation, characterization, and application of magnetic adsorbents obtained from carbon-based sources and their application in the adsorption of both inorganic and organic pollutants from water. Different preparation routes to obtain magnetic adsorbents from activated carbon, biochar, hydrochar, graphene, carbon dots, carbon nanotubes, and carbon nanocages, including the magnetic phase incorporated on the solid surface, are described and discussed. The performance of these adsorbents is analyzed for the removal of fluoride, arsenic, heavy metals, dyes, pesticides, pharmaceuticals, and other emerging and relevant water pollutants. Properties of these adsorbents and the corresponding adsorption mechanisms have been included in this review. Overall, this type of magnetic adsorbents offers an alternative for facing the operational problems associated to adsorption process in water treatment. However, some gaps have been identified in the proper physicochemical characterization of these adsorbents, the development of green and low-cost preparation methods for their industrial production and commercialization, the regeneration and final disposal of spent adsorbents, and their application in the multicomponent adsorption of water pollutants.

Arsenic removal via a novel hydrochar from livestock waste co-activated with thiourea and γ-Fe2O3 nanoparticles

Arsenic (As) contaminants post tremendous threats to environment safety. Pristine hydrochar (PHC), thiourea-activated hydrochar (THC), and thiourea-Fe(NO₃)₃-activated hydrochar (Fe₂O₃@THC) were fabricated from dairy cattle manure via one-pot hydrothermal carbonization at 250 ℃ and applied for aqueous As(V) removal. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) were conducted to characterize hydrochars and As(V) adsorption. Thiourea increased N and S functional groups (-NH₂, C-N, C=S and S=O). Fe(NO₃)₃ introduced γ-Fe₂O₃ nanoparticles and provided Fe₂O₃@THC with Fe-O. The combination of thiourea and Fe(NO₃)₃ granted Fe₂O₃@THC with the largest surface area (33.45 m²/g), and the highest total pore volume (0.095 cm³/g) among three hydrochars. As(V) adsorption was a physicochemical process involving electrostatic attraction, complexation, ion exchange and H-bond interaction. The maximum As(V) adsorption capacities and partition coefficients decreased as follows: Fe₂O₃@THC (44.80 mg/g; 38.44 L/g) > THC (38.77 mg/g; 5.94 L/g) > PHC (19.05 mg/g; 1.17 L/g). Three hydrochars exhibited preferable reusability in NaOH solution with only 24.2%, 11.8% and 14.1% decrease in adsorption rates after four cycles for PHC, THC and Fe₂O₃@THC, respectively. Fe₂O₃@THC is a promising adsorbent for efficient As(V) removal. This study explored the efficient As(V) removal by activated hydrochars with future research potential.

Fe(III) loaded chitosan-biochar composite fibers for the removal of phosphate from water

Excess phosphorous (P) in aquatic systems causes adverse environmental impacts including eutrophication. This study fabricated Fe(III) loaded chitosan-biochar composite fibers (FBC-N and FBC-C) from paper mill sludge biochar produced under N₂ (BC-N) and CO₂ (BC-C) conditions at 600 °C for adsorptive removal of phosphate from water. Investigations using SEM/EDX, XPS, Raman spectroscopy, and specific surface area measurement revealed the morphological and physico-chemical characteristics of the adsorbent. The Freundlich isotherm model well described the phosphate adsorption on BC-N, while the Redlich-Peterson model best fitted the data of three other adsorbents. The maximum adsorption capacities were 9.63, 8.56, 16.43, and 19.24 mg P g^-1 for BC-N, BC-C, FBC-N, and FBC-C, respectively, indicating better adsorption by Fe(III) loaded chitosan-biochar composite fibers (FBCs) than pristine biochars. The pseudo-first-order kinetic model suitably explained the phosphate adsorption on BC-C and BC-N, while data of FBC-N and FBC-C followed the pseudo-second-order and Elovich model, respectively. Molecular level observations of the P K-edge XANES spectra confirmed that phosphate associated with iron (Fe) minerals (Fe-P) were the primary species in all the adsorbents. This study suggests that FBCs hold high potential as inexpensive and green adsorbents for remediating phosphate in contaminated water, and encourage resource recovery via bio-based management of hazardous waste.

Oxytetracycline Adsorption from Aqueous Solutions on Commercial and High-Temperature Modified Activated Carbons

The aim of the work was to evaluate the possibility of using commercial and modified activated carbons for the removal of oxytetracycline from aqueous solutions. The kinetics and statics of adsorption as well as the effect of the activated carbon dose and solution pH on the efficiency of the oxytetracycline adsorption were analyzed. Based on the study of oxytetracycline adsorption isotherms, the activated carbons were ranked in the following order: F-300 > WG-12 > Picabiol > ROW08 > WACC 8 × 30 > F-100 > WAZ 0.6–2.4. The most effective activated carbons were characterized by large specific surfaces. The best matching results were obtained for: Redlich–Peterson, Thot and Jovanovic models, and lower for the most frequently used Freundlich and Langmuir models. The adsorption proceeded better from solutions with pH = 6 than with pH = 3 and 10. Two ways of modifying activated carbon were also assessed. A proprietary method of activated carbon modification was proposed. It uses the heating of activated carbon as a result of current flow through its bed. Both carbons modified at 400 °C in the rotary kiln and on the proprietary SEOW (Joule-heat) modification stand enabled to obtain adsorbents with higher and comparable monolayer capacities. The advantage of the proposed modification method is low electricity consumption.

Facile Designed Manganese Oxide/Biochar for Efficient Salinity Gradient Energy Recovery in Concentration Flow Cells and Influences of Mono/Multivalent Ions

Development of effective, environmentally friendly, facile large-scale processing, and low-cost materials is critical for renewable energy production. Here, MnO_x/biochar composites were synthesized by a simple pyrolysis method and showed high performance for salinity gradient (SG) energy harvest in concentration flow cells (CFCs). The peak power density of CFCs with MnO_x/biochar electrodes was up to 5.67 W m^-2 (ave. = 0.91 W m^-2) and stabilized for 500 cycles when using 1 and 30 g L^-1 NaCl, which was attributed to their high specific capacitances and low electrode resistances. This power output was higher than all other reported MnO₂ electrodes for SG energy harvest due to the synergistic effects between MnO_x and biochar. When using a mixture with a molar fraction of 90% NaCl and 10% KCl (or Na₂SO₄, MgCl₂, MgSO₄, and CaCl₂) in both feed solutions, the peak power density decreased by 2.3-40.1% compared to 100% NaCl solution with Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ showing the most pronounced negative effects. Our results demonstrated that the facile designed MnO_x/biochar composite can be used for efficient SG energy recovery in CFCs with good stability, low cost, and less environmental impacts. When using natural waters as the feed solutions, pretreatment would be needed.