Origin of enhanced chiral selectivity by acidic additives for a polysaccharide-based stationary phase

Chiral chromatography method screening strategies: Past, present and future

Method screening is an integral part of chromatographic method development for the separation of racemates. Due to the highly complex retention mechanism of a chiral stationary-phase, it is often difficult, if not impossible, to device predefined method-development steps that can be successfully applied to a wide group of molecules. The standard approach is to evaluate or screen a series of stationary and mobile-phase combinations to increase the chances of detecting a suitable separation condition. Such a process is often the rate-limiting step for high-throughput analyses and purification workflows. To address the problem, several solutions and strategies have been proposed over the years for reduction of net method-screening time. Some of the strategies have been adopted in practice while others remained confined in the literature. The main objective of this review is to revisit, critically discuss and compile the solutions published over the last two decades. We expect that making the diverse set of solutions available in a single document will help assessing the adequacy of existing screening protocols in laboratories conducting chiral separation.

Tunable normal phase enantioselectivity of amino acid esters via mobile phase composition

The ability to tune chiral selectivity through mobile phase modifiers is a powerful tool in chiral separations. Beyond improving efficiency and/or resolution, some mobile phase systems can even invert elution order, a highly desirable result for trace analyses or preparative scale isolations. Previous work has demonstrated that acidic modifiers, such as ethanesulfonic acid (ESA), can greatly impact separations of enantiomers. However, prior studies were primarily performed on coated chiral stationary phases (CSPs), which limited the selection of the bulk mobile phase component. In this work, the effect of ESA modifier was studied for the enantioseparation of six pairs of amino acid esters on a CHIRALPAK^® IA column, an immobilized amylose-based CSP, with different combinations of standard solvents (hexane and ethanol) as well as "non-standard" solvents, such as methyl t-butyl ether, ethyl acetate, tetrahydrofuran, acetone, or 1,4-dioxane. ESA generally improved selectivity, and multiple instances of elution order reversal were observed. A Van Deemter plot study reveals that ESA exerts its effect by pulling the enantiomer deeper into the chiral cavity of the chiral polymer to increase the interactions between the analytes and the stationary phase, which is the main reason for the increased enantioselectivity.

Effective enantiomeric separations of racemic primary amines by the isopropyl carbamate-cyclofructan6 chiral stationary phase

A new chiral stationary phase (CSP) was developed by bonding isopropyl-carbamate functionalized cyclofructan6 (IP-CF6) to the silica gel. It was evaluated by injecting 119 racemic primary amine-containing compounds. This CSP showed pronounced enantioselectivity toward all types of primary amines, separating 93% of all tested compounds. Baseline separation was achieved even for some simple aliphatic racemic amines that contained no other functionality. The polar organic mode was shown to be the effective mobile phase owing to higher efficiency. This new chiral stationary phase showed great potential for preparative-scale separations. It is also interesting that the chiral selector, R-naphthylethyl-carbamate functionalized CF6 (RN-CF6), was found to provide complementary selectivity for the relatively few amine analytes that did not separate on IP-CF6. Thus between the two CSPs, 98% of attempted amine compounds were separated.

Enantioresolution of basic pharmaceuticals using cellulose tris(4-chloro-3-methylphenylcarbamate) as chiral stationary phase and polar organic mobile phases

A polysaccharide-based chiral stationary phase (Sepapak-4), with cellulose tris(4-chloro-3-methylphenylcarbamate) as chiral selector, has been investigated in liquid chromatography (LC). Its enantioresolution power was evaluated towards 13 basic amino-drugs with widely different structures and polarities, using polar organic mobile phases. After preliminary experiments, acetonitrile was selected as the main mobile phase component, to which a low concentration of diethylamine (0.1%) was systematically added in order to obtain efficient and symmetrical peaks. Different organic solvents were first added in small proportions (5-10%) to acetonitrile to modulate analyte retention. Polar organic modifiers were found to decrease retention and enantioresolution while hexane had the opposite effect, indicating normal-phase behaviour under these conditions. The addition of an organic acid (formic, acetic or trifluoroacetic acid) was found to strongly influence the retention of the basic amino drugs in these nonaqueous systems. The nature and proportion of the acidic additive in the mobile phase had also deep impact on enantioresolution. Therefore, the studied compounds could be subdivided in three groups in respect to the acidic additive used. All analytes could be enantioseparated in relatively short analysis times (10-20 min) using these LC conditions.

Effects of Backbone and Side Chain on the Molecular Environments of Chiral Cavities in Polysaccharide-Based Biopolymers

The effects of the backbone and side chain on the molecular environments in the chiral cavities of three commercially important polysaccharide-based chiral sorbents--cellulose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) (CDMPC), amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) (ADMPC), and amylose tris[(S)-alpha-methylbenzylcarbamate] (ASMBC)--are studied by attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy (ATR-IR), X-ray diffraction (XRD), 13C cross-polarization/magic-angle spinning (CP/MAS) and MAS solid-state NMR, and density functional theory (DFT) modeling. These sorbents are used widely in preparative-scale chiral separations. ATR-IR is used to determine how the H-bonding states of the C=O and NH groups of the polymer depend on the backbone and side chain. The changes in the polymer crystallinity are characterized with XRD. The changes in the polymer helicity and molecular mobility for polymer-coated silica beads (commercially called Chiralcel OD, Chirapak AD, and Chiralpak AS) are probed with 13C CP/MAS and MAS solid-state NMR. The IR wavenumbers and the NMR chemical shifts for the polymer backbone monomers and dimers and the side chains are predicted at the DFT/B3LYP/6-311+g(d,p) level of theory. It is concluded that the molecular environments of the C=O, NH, and phenyl groups show significant differences in intramolecular and intermolecular interactions and in the nanostructures of the chiral cavities of these biopolymers. These results have implications for understanding how the molecular environments of chiral cavities of these polymers affect their molecular recognition mechanisms.

Direct Probing of Sorbent−Solvent Interactions for Amylose Tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) Using Infrared Spectroscopy, X-ray Diffraction, Solid-state NMR, and DFT Modeling

The sorbent-solvent interactions for amylose tris(3, 5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) (ADMPC) with five commonly used solvents, hexane, methanol, ethanol, 2-propanol (IPA), and acetonitrile (ACN), are studied using attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy (ATR-IR) of thin sorbent films, X-ray diffraction (XRD) of thin films, (13)C cross polarization/magic angle spinning (CP/MAS) and MAS solid state NMR of polymer-coated silica beads (commercially termed "Chiralpak AD"), and DFT modeling. The ADMPC-polymer-coated silica beads are used commercially for analytical and preparative scale separations of chiral enantiomers. The polymer forms helical rods with intra- and inter-rod hydrogen bonds (H-bonds). There are various nm-sized cavities formed between the polymer side-chains and rods. The changes in the H-bonding states of the C=O and NH groups of the polymer upon absorption of each of the five solvents at 25 degrees C are determined with ATR-IR. The IR wavenumbers, the H-bonding interaction energies, and the H-bonding distances of the polymer side-chains with each of the solvent molecules are predicted using the DFT/B3LYP/6-311+g(d,p) level of theory. The changes in the polymer crystallinity upon absorption of each solvent are characterized with XRD. The changes in the polymer crystallinity and the H-bonding states of C=O groups are also probed with (13)C CP/MAS solid-state NMR. The changes in the polymer side-chain mobility are detected using (13)C MAS solid-state NMR. The H-bonding states of the polymer change upon absorption of each polar solvent and usually result in an increase in the polymer crystallinity and the side-chain mobility. The polymer rods are reorganized upon solvent absorption, and the distance between the rods increases with the increase in the solvent molecular size. These results have implications for understanding the role of the solvent in modifying the structure and behavior of the polymer sorbents.

High-performance liquid chromatographic separation of imidazolinone herbicide enantiomers and their methyl derivatives on polysaccharide-coated chiral stationary phases

Many chiral pesticides exhibit enantioselectivity in biotransformation and ecotoxicity in the environment. A significant class of chiral pesticides is imidazolinone herbicides, of which enantioselectivity has not been well studied. Development of efficient chiral separation methods is the first step for allowing characterization of enantioselectivity in environmental processes. In this study, we attempted to resolve enantiomers of imidazolinone herbicides using reversed-phase and normal-phase high-performance liquid chromatography with polysaccharide-type chiral columns. Enantiomers of imazethapyr, imazaquin, and imazamox were separated on a Chiralcel OD-R column using 50mM phosphate buffer-acetonitrile as mobile phase. Enantiomers of imazapyr, imazapic, imazethapyr, imazamox and imazaquin were resolved on a Chiralcel OJ column using n-hexane (0.1% trifluoroacetic acid)-alcohol as mobile phase. The enantiomers of five methyl derivatives of imidazolinone herbicides were also resolved on the Chiralcel OJ column. The Deltak' values revealed a structure-enantioselectivity relationship for the separation behaviors of the enantiomers on the OJ column. The described method was successfully applied for chiral analysis of two imidazolinone herbicides (imazapyr and imazaquin) in spiked soil samples.

The effect of acidic and basic additives on the enantioseparation of basic drugs using polysaccharide-based chiral stationary phases

The enantioseparation of nine commercially available basic drugs was achieved on polysaccharide-based chiral stationary phases with the acidic additive ethanesulfonic acid and the basic additive butylamine. Seven different commercially available CSPs were used for the study (AD, AS, OD, OJ, OG, OB, and OC). Mobile phase additives have been proven to be essential in obtaining satisfactory enantio-resolution in terms of both efficiency and selectivity. Significantly improved selectivities were obtained for the basic probe drugs with the acidic additive, ethanesulfonic acid, rather than the basic additive, butylamine. This is best seen with Chiralpak AS CSP. No enantioseparation for the nine drugs was observed when butylamine was used as an additive; however, satisfactory enantioseparation for the nine drugs was achieved using ethanesulfonic acid. Higher column efficiencies were observed with the acidic additive, especially when isopropanol was used as a modifier. Higher sensitivity was also achieved with ethanesulfonic acid because of the significantly lower background at the UV detection wavelength. The acidic additive was demonstrated to be superior to the basic additive for the enantioseparation of basic drugs using seven different polysaccharide-based CSPs. These results are counterintuitive to the common "rule of thumb" in enantioseparation that states acidic additives work best for acidic analytes and basic additives work best for basic analytes. The beneficial effects of acidic additive in enantioseparations observed in this study could significantly improve the applicability of polysaccharide-based CSPs for the enantioseparation of basic analytes.

Chiral separation of amines by high-performance liquid chromatography using polysaccharide stationary phases and acidic additives

A dramatic and beneficial effect of ethanesulfonic acid (ESA) on the chiral HPLC separation of basic compounds was found. Using a single chiral column and a starting mobile phase, more than half of a diverse set of amines was baseline separated. Changing alcohol content and alcohol type increased the success rate. Methanesulfonic acid (MSA) proved even more successful. The mechanism of this unexpected finding appears to be a combination of ion-pair salt formation in the mobile phase and increased binding with the chiral stationary phase (CSP) arising from a localized decrease in pH.