Clinical consequences of an indeterminate CT pulmonary angiogram in cancer patients

Pulmonary CTA Reporting: AJR Expert Panel Narrative Review

Pulmonary CTA is a ubiquitous study interpreted by radiologists with different levels of experience in a variety of practice settings. Pulmonary embolism (PE) can range from an incidental and clinically insignificant finding to a clinically significant thrombus that can be managed on an outpatient basis to a potentially fatal condition requiring immediate medical or invasive management. Accordingly, a clear and concise pulmonary CTA report should effectively communicate the most pertinent findings to help the treating medical team diagnose or exclude the diagnosis of PE and provide information to guide appropriate management. In this expert panel narrative review, we discuss the purpose of the radiology report for pulmonary CTA, the optimal report format, the relevant findings that need to be addressed and their clinical significance.

Weight-Adjusted Contrast Administration in the Computed Tomography Evaluation of Pulmonary Embolism

INTRODUCTION

Computed tomography pulmonary angiogram (CTPA) is widely considered the gold standard for diagnosis of pulmonary embolism (PE) with previous studies demonstrating high sensitivity and specificity. Despite this, nondiagnostic and indeterminate CTPA rates of 5%-26% remain a concern. As part of a continuing quality assurance program, a new weight-adjusted contrast dose and increased administration rate CTPA protocol was studied with an aim to improve diagnostic accuracy of PE evaluation.

METHODS

A total of 2,398 CTPA examinations were reviewed to assess pulmonary arterial enhancement and PE yield in this retrospective study. Between 1 August 2014 and 1 August 2015, 1,133 patients received a fixed-volume (60 mL) contrast dose technique at 4 mL/s (protocol A). A new protocol was then implemented as part of a continuing quality assurance program. Between 15 September 2015 and 15 September 2016, 1,265 patients received a weight-adjusted contrast dose (1 mL/kg) and increased administration rate (5 mL/s) CTPA technique (protocol B). Studies were classed into categories based on quality of study; diagnostic: HU > 211, nondiagnostic: HU < 211 and PE yield; positive, negative, and indeterminate. These variables were compared with cross-sectional surface area to assess the relationship between patient habitus, CTPA diagnostic quality, and PE yield.

RESULTS

A weight-adjusted contrast dose and increased administration rate CTPA protocol (protocol B) resulted in a significant increase in mean PA enhancement (P < .0001), 55.23% decrease in nondiagnostic studies and 43.04% decrease in indeterminate studies. Protocol B demonstrated increased positive and negative CTPA rates with decreased indeterminate rates from 12.38% to 7.04%. Comparison with cross-sectional area demonstrated significant increase in proportion of diagnostic studies and reduction in nondiagnostic and indeterminate CTPAs using protocol B in obese patients.

CONCLUSIONS

A weight-adjusted contrast dose and increased administration rate CTPA protocol can significantly increase PA enhancement, especially in obese patients, resulting in greater high-quality and fewer nondiagnostic and indeterminate CTPA examinations. A CTPA protocol with a higher rate of conclusive examinations can provide greater confidence in PE evaluation for reporting radiologists and accurate clinical decision-making pathways for referring physicians.

Evaluation of CTPA interpreted as limited in pregnant patients suspected for pulmonary embolism

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to determine the rates of CT pulmonary angiography (CTPA) interpreted as limited and severely limited in pregnant patients suspected for pulmonary embolism (PE), and to evaluate factors that influence these rates.

METHODS

This is a retrospective study with CTPA for evaluation of PE in pregnancy across a large health system from 2006 to 2017. CTPA was classified as limited from the radiology report with a subset of those studies classified as severely limited. Bivariate and multivariate analysis was performed for limited and severely limited rates with maternal age and patient size as a continuous variable and race, trimester, patient location study priority status, and result of chest radiograph before CTPA as categorical variables.

RESULTS

874 patients with 33% of studies limited and 4% of studies severely limited. Multivariate logistic regression of CTPA studies revealed decreasing patient age (OR 0.967, p = 0.0129) and increasing patient size (OR 1.013, p < 0.0001). Studies performed in the second trimester (OR 1.869, p = 0.0242) and third trimester (OR 2.314, p = 0.0021) were more likely to be reported as limited (each p < 0.05). Increasing patient size (OR 1.017, p = 0.0046) was the only significant predictor of severely limited versus non-severely limited studies.

CONCLUSION

CTPA interpreted as limited in pregnancy are common and may be associated with younger age, larger patient size, and second and third trimesters. However, severely limited interpretations are much less common, with patient size the only significant predictor.

Evaluation of Virtual Monoenergetic Images on Pulmonary Vasculature Using the Dual-Layer Detector-Based Spectral Computed Tomography

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the ability of retrospectively generated virtual monoenergetic images (VMIs) from the detector-based spectral computed tomography (SDCT) to augment pulmonary artery enhancement in CT and if iodine map can predict the optimal monoenergetic level.

METHODS

The study included 79 patients with contrast-enhanced chest CT scans on an SDCT scanner. Conventional 120-kVp images and VMI from 40 to 80 keV were generated. Attenuation, noise, signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) were measured at 7 different locations in the pulmonary arterial system. The iodine concentration (in milligrams per milliliter) was calculated using the iodine-density images. The overall image quality was subjectively graded on a 5-point scale, with 1 being the worst and 5 the best. Fifty-four patients with suboptimal pulmonary enhancement (<200 Hounsfield units [HU]) were then identified. From the VMIs, an ideal set was chosen that maintained mean vascular attenuation greater than 200 HU while maintaining at least diagnostically acceptable quality (ie, IQ score ≥3). At this ideal energy level, quantitative and qualitative parameters were compared with the standard 120-kVp polyenergetic study. Average iodine concentrations were correlated with the optimal keV levels used for salvaging suboptimal studies.

RESULTS

The mean attenuation of all the measured pulmonary arterial regions in the suboptimal cases was 136.1 ± 18.1 HU in conventional 120-kVp images. Attenuations of the VMIs at 40, 50, and 60 keV were significantly higher than conventional images measuring 357.5 ± 19.5, 243.6 ± 16.7, and 176.6 ± 15.0 HU, respectively (P < 0.001). Similar results were seen with SNR and CNR. In total, 50 studies can be salvaged, with 50 keV being the optimal energy for 21, 60 keV optimal for 17, and 40 keV optimal for 12 studies. At the optimal energy level, there were improvements of attenuation, SNR, and CNR by 71%, 63%, and 137% compared with conventional images. There was a positive correlation between iodine value and optimal reconstruction energy with a linear equation y = 5.9539x + 27.434 and R = 0.8093.

CONCLUSIONS

Suboptimal enhanced pulmonary arterial CT studies can be salvaged using low-energy VMI generated from the SDCT scanner. There were significant improvements of attenuation, SNR, and CNR at the optimal monoenergetic level.

Ventilation perfusion single photon emission computed tomography: Referral practices and diagnosis of acute pulmonary embolism in the quaternary clinical setting

INTRODUCTION

Ventilation perfusion single photon emission computed tomography (V/Q SPECT) and CTPA are the two leading imaging studies used to investigate acute pulmonary embolism. V/Q SPECT is often the first line investigation for pregnant patients and young females. Historically, V/Q Planar studies have high rates of indeterminate findings resulting in a preference for CTPA studies. The purpose of this research is to examine current V/Q SPECT referral practices in the quaternary clinical setting and to confirm V/Q SPECT studies have low rates of equivocal findings.

METHODS

Retrospective study of a 6-month period of all completed V/Q SPECT studies (± LDCT) indicated for investigation of acute PE. V/Q SPECT studies were reported using the European Association of Nuclear Medicine guidelines. Patient demographic data and V/Q SPECT findings were recorded. CTPA and Doppler Ultrasound report findings were included if performed 48 hours prior to, or following V/Q SPECT study. Standard descriptive statistical analysis was undertaken.

RESULTS

Ninety-nine percent of V/Q SPECT studies had reports positive or negative for acute PE, with 1% inconclusive. Twenty-two percent of patients had either CTPA or Doppler Ultrasound studies within a 48- hour period prior to, or following V/Q SPECT, with the majority having a negative Doppler ultrasound prior to negative V/Q SPECT. Sixty-eight percent of patients referred for V/Q SPECT were females under the age of 55, 40% of whom were pregnant.

CONCLUSIONS

Ventilation perfusion single photon emission computed tomography has low rates of equivocal findings with referral practices indicating pregnant patients and young women are considered to most benefit from V/Q SPECT as a first line investigation for acute PE.

Diagnosis of Deep Venous Thrombosis and Pulmonary Embolism: New Imaging Tools and Modalities

Imaging continues to be the modality of choice for the diagnosis of venous thromboembolic disease, particularly when incorporated into diagnostic algorithms. Improvement in imaging techniques as well as new imaging modalities and processing methods have improved diagnostic accuracy and additionally are being leveraged in prognostication and decision making for choice of intervention. In this article, we review the role of imaging in diagnosis and prognostication of venous thromboembolism. We also discuss emerging imaging approaches that may in the near future find clinical usefulness in improving diagnosis and prognostication as well as differentiating disease phenotypes.

Utility of virtual monoenergetic images derived from a dual-layer detector-based spectral CT in the assessment of aortic anatomy and pathology: A retrospective case control study

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the ability of the retrospectively generated virtual monoenergetic images (VMIs) from a dual-layer detector-based spectral computed tomography (SDCT) to augment aortic enhancement for the evaluation of aortic anatomy and pathology.

METHODS

98 patients with suboptimal aortic enhancement (≤200 HU) were retrospectively identified from SDCT scans. VMI from 40 to 80 keV were generated. Attenuation, noise, SNR, and CNR were measured at seven levels in the aorta. Image quality was graded on a 5-point scale, 5 being the best. From the VMI, an ideal set was chosen with mean vascular attenuation above 200 HU while maintaining diagnostic quality. Image parameters and quality of this ideal-set were compared to the standard 120-kVp images.

RESULTS

The mean attenuation of all seven measured anatomical regions was 156.6 ± 61.7 HU in the 120-kVp images. Attenuation of the VMI from 40 to 70 keV were higher than the 120-kVp image, measuring 439.2 ± 215.3 HU, 298.5 ± 140.6 HU, 213.4 ± 94.3 HU, and 164.7 ± 90.2 HU, for 40 keV, 50 keV, 60 keV, and 70 keV, respectively (p value <0.01 for 40, 50, 60 keV; 0.07 for 70 keV). SNR and CNR showed similar trends. The 50 keV VMI had the best image quality (4.48 ± 0.84 vs. 2.24 ± 0.92 on 120-kVp images, p < 0.001). Attenuation, CNR, and SNR increased by 90.6%, 85.0%, and 108.1% at 50 keV compared to 120-kVp.

CONCLUSIONS

A contrast-enhanced CT study can be optimized for the assessment of the aorta by using low-energy VMI obtained using SDCT. At the optimal monoenergetic level, attenuation, SNR, CNR and image quality were significantly higher than that of conventional polyenergetic images.

Improved Delineation of Pulmonary Embolism and Venous Thrombosis Through Frequency Selective Nonlinear Blending in Computed Tomography

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that a novel frequency selective nonlinear blending (NLB) algorithm increases the delineation of pulmonary embolism and venous thrombosis in portal-venous phase whole-body staging computed tomography (CT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A cohort of 67 patients with incidental pulmonary embolism and/or venous thrombosis in contrast-enhanced oncological staging CT were retrospectively selected. Computed tomography data sets were acquired 65 to 90 seconds after intravenous iodine contrast administration using state-of-the-art multi-detector CT scanners. A novel frequency selective NLB postprocessing technique was applied to reconstructed standard CT images. Two readers determined the most suitable settings to increase the delineation of pulmonary embolism and venous thrombosis. Outcome measure included region of interest and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) analyses, image noise, overall image quality, subjective delineation, as well as number and size of emboli and thrombi. Statistical testing included quantitative comparisons of Hounsfield units of thrombus and vessel, image noise and related CNR values and subjective image analyses of image noise, image quality and thrombus delineation, number and size in standard, and NLB images.

RESULTS

Using frequency selective NLB settings with a center of 100 HU, delta of 40 HU, and a slope of 5, CNR values of pulmonary embolism (StandardCNR, 10 [6, 16]; NLBCNR, 22 [15, 30]; P < 0.001) and venous thrombosis (StandardCNR, 8 [5, 15]; NLBCNR, 12 [7, 19]; P = 0.0007) increased. Mean vascular enhancement using NLB was significantly higher than in standard images for pulmonary arteries (Standard, 138 [118, 191] HU; NLB, 269 [176, 329] HU; P < 0.0001) and veins (Standard, 120 [103, 162] HU; NLB, 169 [132, 217] HU; P < 0.0001), respectively. Image noise was not significantly different between standard and NLB images (P = 0.64-0.88). There was substantial to almost perfect interrater agreement as well as a significant increase of overall image quality (P < 0.004) and subjective delineation of the thrombotic material (P < 0.0001) in both subgroups. Nonlinear blending images revealed 8 additional segmental and 13 subsegmental emboli. Thrombus sizes were not significantly different, but subjective accuracy of the measurement could be significantly increased using NLB (P = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Postprocessing of standard whole-body staging CT images with frequency selective NLB improves image quality and the delineation of pulmonary embolism and venous thrombosis.

Referral Patterns and Diagnostic Yield of Lung Scintigraphy in the Diagnosis of Acute Pulmonary Embolism

Introduction. The purpose of this study is to assess referral patterns and the yield of ventilation-perfusion (V/Q) scintigraphy in patients referred for acute pulmonary embolism (PE). Methods. We retrospectively reviewed the charts of all patients who underwent V/Q studies between April 1, 2008, and March 31, 2010. Patients were subdivided into 4 groups based on their referral source: emergency department (ED), hospital inpatient ward, outpatient thrombosis clinic, and all other outpatient sources. Results. A total of 1008 patients underwent V/Q scintigraphy to exclude acute PE. The number of ED, inpatient, thrombosis clinic, and outpatient studies was 43 (4.3%), 288 (28.6%), 351 (34.8%), and 326 (32.3%). Proportion of patients with contrast contraindication varied significantly among the different groups. Of the 1,008 studies, 331 (32.8%) were interpreted as normal, 408 (40.5%) as low, 158 (15.7%) as intermediate, and 111 (11.0%) as high probability for PE. 68 (6.7%) patients underwent CTPA within 2 weeks following V/Q. Conclusion. The rate of nondiagnostic studies is lower than that reported in previously published data, with a relatively low rate of intermediate probability studies. Only a small fraction of patients undergoing a V/Q scan will require a CTPA.

Indeterminate CT pulmonary angiogram: Why and does it matter?

INTRODUCTION

This study assessed the rate of indeterminate CT pulmonary angiogram (CTPA) in a general hospital and evaluated potential contributing factors to an indeterminate CTPA and patients' eventual clinical outcome.

METHODS

Four hundred and three consecutive CTPA and their finalised report from 01/08/2012 to 05/12/2012 at Waitemata DHB were reviewed retrospectively. Patient demographics, scan parameters and average Hounsfield unit (HU) of the main pulmonary trunk (PT) and likely cause of indeterminate study were documented. Studies were categorised into diagnostic, suboptimal or non-diagnostic studies. Univariate and multiple regression analyses were employed.

RESULTS

Six per cent (n = 24) of the studies were deemed indeterminate which included suboptimal and non-diagnostic studies. Seven pregnant patients were scanned during the study period and four of the seven studies were deemed indeterminate. In univariate analysis, predictors of indeterminate studies included 'weight' (P = 0.022), 'average HU of PT' (P < 0.0001) and 'effective dose' (P = 0.0003). In the multivariate logistic regression model, only 'average HU of PT' was associated with indeterminate studies (OR = 0.99, 95%CI: 0.99, 1.00). Twelve of 24 indeterminate studies had suboptimal pulmonary enhancement with causes including suboptimal timing of contrast bolus, hyperdynamic state due to pregnancy and transient interruption of contrast. Three patients had excessive noise due to body habitus. Eight studies had motion artefacts and one patient had left lower lobe pneumonia which decreased the accuracy. A third of the indeterminate studies were clinically considered as negative by referring clinicians.

CONCLUSIONS

Pulmonary trunk average Hounsfield unit is a predictor of indeterminate CT pulmonary angiogram.

Association Between Confidence Level of Acute Pulmonary Embolism Diagnosis on CTPA images and Clinical Outcomes

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

The purpose was to evaluate clinical characteristics associated with low confidence in diagnosis of acute pulmonary embolism (PE) as expressed in computed tomography pulmonary angiography (CTPA) reports and to evaluate the effect of confidence level in PE diagnosis on patient clinical outcomes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study included radiology reports from 1664 consecutive CTPA considered positive for acute PE (8/2003-5/2010). All reports were retrospectively assessed for the level of confidence in diagnosis. Baseline characteristics and outcomes (therapies related to PE and short-term mortality) were compared between high and low confidence groups. Multivariable logistic and Cox regression analyses were used to analyze the relationship between the confidence level and outcomes.

RESULTS

One-hundred sixty of 1664 (9.6%) reports had language that reflected a low confidence in PE diagnosis. The low confidence group had smaller (segmental and subsegmental) suspected emboli (prevalence, 72.5% vs. 50.7%; P < .001) and more comorbidities. The low confidence group had a lower likelihood of receiving PE-related therapies (adjusted odds ratio [OR], 0.18; 95% confidence interval, 0.10-031, P < .001), but there was no change in the all-cause and PE-related 30-day and/or 90-day mortality (OR of death for low confidence, 0.81-1.13, P values > .5).

CONCLUSIONS

Roughly 10% of positive CTPA reports had uncertainty in PE findings, and patients with reports categorized as low confidence had smaller emboli and more comorbidities. Although the low confidence group was less likely to receive PE-related therapies, patients in this group were not associated with higher probability of short-term mortality.