Single and combined effects of Zn, Mn and Fe on the Neotropical freshwater bivalve Anodontites trapesialis: Bioaccumulation and biochemical biomarkers

Toxic effects of trace metal(loid) mixtures on aquatic organisms

The co-occurrence of metal (loid)s in realistic aquatic environments necessitates the evaluation of their combined effects. However, the generality of the additive effect hypothesis is contentious, particularly due to metal(loid)-metal(loid) interactions. The absence of systematic evaluation approaches restricts our ability to draw overall conclusions and make reliable predictions. In this study, we reviewed 1473 effect sizes from 38 publications, and classified all responses into seven main categories (from molecular to individual levels) according to their toxicological significance. Our meta-analysis revealed that metal(loid) mixtures had significant effects on aquatic organisms (33 %, 95 % CI 28 %-39 %, P < 0.05), along with significant response heterogeneity (Qt = 690,319.62, P < 0.0001; I2 = 99.95 %). Concurrently, we developed a Random Forest machine learning model to predict adverse effects and identify key variables. These two methods demonstrated that the toxicity of metal(loid) mixtures is primarily linked to the choice of toxicity endpoints, and the characteristics of metal(loid) mixtures. Our findings underscore the potential of combining meta-analysis with machine learning, a more systematic approach, to enhance the understanding and prediction of the adverse effects of metal(loid) mixtures, and they offer guidance for risk assessment and policy-making in complex environmental scenarios.

From the cellular to tissue alterations induced by two rare earth elements in the mussel species Mytilus galloprovincialis: Comparison between exposure and recovery periods

The global effort to achieve carbon neutrality has led to an increased demand for renewable energy technologies and their raw materials, namely rare earth elements (REEs). These elements possess unique properties and are used in various applications. However, the increased use of REE-based technologies has resulted in higher amounts of electronic waste, leading to elevated REEs concentrations found in the aquatic environment, with poorly understood threats to wildlife. Praseodymium (Pr) and europium (Eu) are two REEs that, despite their potential environmental risks, have almost unknown effects on aquatic organisms. Therefore, the present study aimed to assess the impacts of different concentrations of Pr and Eu (0, 10, 20, 40, and 80 μg/L) in the mussel species Mytilus galloprovincialis, as well as their ability to recover from exposure to the highest concentration. Mussels accumulated both elements in a dose-dependent manner, with the accumulation of Pr being higher. Accompanying the increase of metabolism, mussels exposed to Pr not only enhanced the activity of the antioxidant enzymes superoxide dismutase (up to 40 μg/L) and glutathione reductase (at 80 μg/L) but also the activity of the biotransformation enzymes carboxylesterases (CbE's) and glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) (at 80 μg/L). Nevertheless, these defence mechanisms were not sufficient to prevent cellular damage. All the Eu concentrations induced cellular damage, despite an increase in the activity of biotransformation enzymes (CbE's and GSTs) in mussel tissue. According to the histopathology assessment, mussels were not able to recover after exposure to both elements and lower concentrations induced higher injuries in digestive tubules. This study highlights that exposure to Pr and Eu had adverse effects on M. galloprovincialis, even at the lowest tested concentration, which may eventually impact mussels' growth, reproductive capacity, and survival.

Settleable atmospheric particulate matter harms a marine invertebrate: Integrating chemical and biological damage in a bivalve model

Some atmospheric pollutants may affect aquatic ecosystems after settling, generating contamination, bioaccumulation, and threats to aquatic species. Metallurgical processes result in the emission of settleable atmospheric particulate matter (SePM), including metals and metalloids, along with rare earth elements (REE) that are considered emerging contaminants. We report the 30-day exposure of brown mussels (Perna perna) to SePM collected in a metallurgical area of southeast Brazil close to estuarine ecosystems, followed by a 30-day clearance period, to evaluate the toxic potential of SePM to this model mollusk. The bioaccumulation of 28 elements identified in SePM and the sublethal effects were evaluated. REEs were found in SePM (Ce, Y, and La). Significant bioaccumulation of eight metals (Fe, Ni, Cu, Zn, Rb, Sr, Cd, and Ba) was found in the bivalves and correlates with the cytotoxicity and genotoxicity, showing a dose-dependent mode and suggesting a pre-pathological condition that could lead to ecological disturbances over time. Conversely, the unchanged lipid-peroxidation level after SePM exposure could indicate the effectiveness of the antioxidant system in protecting gills and digestive glands. The clearance period was not enough to successfully reverse the negative effects observed. So far, the current results enhance the comprehension of the negative role of SePM on metal bioaccumulation and metal-induced toxicity to aquatic biota. Thus, this report adds innovative findings on the role of SePM in aquatic pollution in coastal areas affected by atmospheric pollution, which should be relevant for future public policies to verify and control the environmental pollution.

Natural heavy metal concentrations in seawater as a possible cause of low survival of larval mussels

BACKGROUND

A period of seismic activity starting in 2010 coincided with a decline in commercial catches of wild seed mussels in a major aquaculture production region of New Zealand. Analyses of over 40 years of mussel seed catch data from in the Pelorus and Kenepuru Sounds, confirmed a marked decline since 2010 in catches of the preferred, green-lipped mussel (Perna canaliculus), the larvae of which is known to have low tolerance of heavy metals in seawater.

METHODS

Heavy metal mean concentrations were measured throughout the Pelorus and Kenepuru Sounds. The concentrations ranged from < 0.60-3.24, < 16.94-74.35, < 1.47-4.00, 2.23-19.02, 1.86-3.29 and 0.12-0.52 µg L^-1 for Cr, Fe, Cu, Zn, As, and Cd, respectively. Seawater from six locations in the Sounds, historically associated with high commercial catches of settling mussel larvae, was used for experimental rearing of green-lipped mussel larvae.

RESULTS

No mussel embryos survived when incubated in these seawater samples. The mean concentrations of Cr, Fe, As, and Cd were significantly higher in the seawater from the Sounds than in the hatchery seawater. A higher concentration of one or a combination of these heavy metals could be the cause of the poor larval survival. These findings could be crucial for the sustainability of mussel farming in the area.

Biogenic metallic nanoparticles (Ag, TiO2, Fe) as potential fungicides for agriculture: are they safe for the freshwater mussel Anodontites trapesialis?

Silver (Ag), titanium dioxide (TiO₂), and iron (Fe) nanoparticles (NPs) synthesized using the fungus Trichoderma harzianum are effective against the agriculture pathogen Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. However, their effects should be evaluated in aquatic organisms, as agriculture practices can contaminate the aquatic environment. Thus, this work evaluated sublethal effects of acute exposure (24 h) to AgNP, TiO₂NP and FeNP, synthesized with T. harzianum, on the Neotropical freshwater bivalve Anodontites trapesialis, considering the hypothesis that suspension-feeding bivalves are susceptible to NPs toxicity. Individuals of A. trapesialis were divided into four groups (n = 8/group): a control group, kept in water only; a group exposed to AgNP; a group exposed to TiO₂NP; and a group exposed to FeNP. The bioaccumulation of Ag, Ti, and Fe was evaluated in the gills, hemolymph, mantle, digestive gland, and muscle (foot). Lipoperoxidation, activities of the glutathione S-transferase, catalase, and superoxide dismutase, and glycogen concentration were quantified in the gills, mantle, and digestive gland. Ions (Na⁺, K⁺, Cl^-, Ca²⁺, and Mg⁺²) and glucose concentrations were quantified in the hemolymph. Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase, H⁺-ATPase, Ca²⁺-ATPase, and carbonic anhydrase activities were assessed in the gills and mantle. Acetylcholinesterase activity was determined in the foot and adductor muscle. The mussels exposed to AgNP accumulated Ag in the gills, hemolymph, and foot, and showed a decrease in hemolymph concentrations of Na⁺ and Cl^-, which was associated with the action of Ag ion (Ag⁺). The exposures to TiO₂NP and FeNP led to the accumulation of Ti and Fe in the hemolymph, respectively, but did not promote additional effects. Accordingly, A. trapesialis showed bioaccumulation potential and susceptibility to AgNP, but was not susceptible to TiO₂NP and FeNP. Thus, the preferential agricultural use of TiO₂NP and FeNP over AgNP is highlighted.

Bioaccumulation and toxicokinetics of polycyclic aromatic compounds and metals in giant floater mussels (Pyganodon grandis) exposed to a simulated diluted bitumen spill

Oil spills constitute a major risk to the environment and the bioaccumulation potential of the derived oil constituents will influence their impact on aquatic biota. Here we determined the bioaccumulation potential and toxicokinetic parameters of polycyclic aromatic compounds (PACs) and various selected metals in the giant floater mussels (Pyganodon grandis) following experimental oil spills in a freshwater lake. Specifically, these mussels were exposed ex situ for 25 days to water contaminated with naturally weathered diluted bitumen (dilbit), a form of oil commonly transported through pipelines. We detected greater concentrations of total PAC in mussels (∑PAC₄₄) exposed to dilbit-contaminated water (25.92-27.79 μg g^-1 lipid, n = 9, at day 25 of the uptake phase) compared to mussels from a control with no exposure to dilbit (average of 2.62 ± 1.95 μg g^-1 lipid; ±SD, n = 17). This study demonstrates the importance of including alkylated PACs when assessing the impacts of an oil spill as the concentration of alkylated PACs in mussel tissue were an order of magnitude higher than their parent counterparts. However, metal accumulation in dilbit-exposed mussels did not exceed the unexposed controls, suggesting no excess metal accumulation by mussels from a 25-day dilbit exposure. From first-order one-compartment models, mean uptake rate constants (0.78-18.11 L g^-1 day^-1, n = 29) and bioconcentration factors (log values from 4.02 to 5.92 L kg^-1, n = 87) for the 29 individual PACs that accumulated in mussels demonstrated that some alkylated PACs had greater bioaccumulation potential compared to their parent PAC counterpart but for the most part, alkylated and parent PACs had comparable BCF values. Results from this study also demonstrated that giant floater mussels could be used to biomonitor PAC contamination following oil spills as PACs accumulated in mussel tissue and some were still detectable following the 16-day depuration phase. This study provides the largest, most comprehensive set of toxicokinetic and bioaccumulation parameters for PACs and their alkylated counterparts (44 analytes) in freshwater mussels obtained to date.

Spatio-Temporal Variation of Elemental Contamination and Health of Mya arenaria Clam in the Saguenay–St. Lawrence Marine Park

The impacts of pollution and long-term effects of local clam populations are misunderstood in estuaries. The purpose of this study was to follow inorganic contamination in tissues, changes of physiological health indicators, such as condition factor (CF), growth index (GI), resistance in air emersion and dehydration rate, for 5 years in Mya arenaria clams. The sampling scheme comprised one reference site, two sites impacted by human activity (thereafter polluted) and one site recognized as a Saint-Lawrence Estuary (SLE) beluga whale feeding area without known pollution source (Baie Sainte-Marguerite (BSM)). This study revealed that the elemental contamination profiles in clams were increased but differed between the polluted and BSM compared to the reference site. At polluted sites, clams were contaminated by Ag (2.4-fold of reference site), Mn (2.5-fold) and V (6.3-fold). With respect to BSM, clams were mainly contaminated by Ce (2.5-fold), Co (2-fold), Ga (2-fold), La (2.8-fold), Hg (2.5-fold), Ni (2.2-fold), Sm (2-fold) and V (20-fold). This contamination profile suggests sources of pollution from particulate combustion products of gasoline/diesel, crude oil and urban inputs of pollution. The CF, GI and air survival time were all reduced in clams at the polluted sites, while only the CF and dehydration rates were decreased and increased, respectively, at BSM. Long-term analysis revealed that CF and GI tended to decrease over time with episodes of strong amplitude changes and became more resilient to air survival time. In conclusion, the long-term contamination of clams towards metals and elements could compromise the health status of local clam populations. The increased contamination of clams at BSM could represent a risk to the endangered SLE beluga whale population.

Understanding the influence of multiple pollutant stressors on the decline of freshwater mussels in a biodiversity hotspot

The Clinch River watershed of the upper Tennessee River Basin of Virginia and Tennessee, USA supports one of North America's greatest concentrations of freshwater biodiversity, including 46 extant species of native freshwater mussels (Order Unionida), 20 of which are protected as federally endangered. Despite the global biological significance of the Clinch River, mussel populations are declining in some reaches, both in species richness and abundance. The aim of this study was to evaluate the exposure of adult resident mussels to a suite of inorganic and organic contaminant stressors in distinct sections of the Clinch River that encompassed a range of mussel abundance and health. To provide insight into the potential role of pollutants in the decline of mussels, including within a previously documented "zone of mussel decline", the mainstem Clinch River (8 sites) and its tributaries (4 sites) were examined over two consecutive years. We quantified and related metals and organic contaminant concentrations in mussels to their associated habitat compartments (bed sediment, suspended particulate sediment, pore water, and surface water). We found that concentrations of organic contaminants in resident mussels, particularly the suite of 42 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) analyzed, were related to PAH concentrations in all four habitat (media) compartments. Further, PAH concentrations in mussel tissue (range 37.8-978.1 ng/g dry weight in 2012 and 194.3-1073.7 ng/g dry weight in 2013) were negatively related to the spatial pattern in mussel densities (r_s = -0.64, p ≤ 0.05 in 2012 and r_s = -0.83, p ≤ 0.05 in 2013) within the river, and were highest in the "zone of mussel decline". In contrast, the suite of 22 metals analyzed in resident mussels were largely unrelated to the spatial pattern of variation of metals in the four habitat compartments except for Manganese (Mn; range 3630.5-23,749.2 μg/g dry weight in 2012 and 1540.4-12,605.8 μg/g dry weight in 2013) in surface water (r_s = 0.58, p < 0.1) and pore water (r_s = 0.76, p ≤ 0.05). This study revealed that PAHs and Mn are important pollutant stressors to mussels in the Clinch River and that they are largely being delivered through the Guest River tributary watershed. Accordingly, future conservation and management efforts would benefit by identifying, and ideally mitigating, the sources of PAHs, Mn, and other current or legacy mining-associated pollutants to the mainstem river and its tributaries.

Can severe drought periods increase metal concentrations in mangrove sediments? A case study in eastern Brazil

Mangrove ecosystems are essential to society, providing ecological and economic services, and play a crucial role in the geochemical land-ocean interface as a sink for potentially toxic metals. This study assessed metals (Al, Ba, Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb, Sr and Zn) and arsenic in sediments from three mangrove zones (Tidal Flat, Rhizophora mangle L. and Avicennia schaueriana Stapf & Leechman ex Moldenke forests) during two seasons: spring of 2015 and autumn of 2016, with the latter being a severe drought year. Overall results suggest that Fe/Mn oxyhydroxides and clay minerals control the distribution of metal and arsenic in the Tidal Flat zone. In the mangrove forest however, sulfur and organic matter dominate complexation, with Fe mainly present as insoluble sulfide, and As, Cd, Cu and Zn as metal sulfides or organometallic complexes. In the autumn of 2016, all elements except Cd and Pb had lower concentrations compared to the spring of 2015. Cd and Pb were probably transferred from sources other than mangrove sediments, due to increased saline water intrusion, a consequence of reduced riverine flow, and precipitated in the Rhizophora mangle and Avicennia schaueriana mangrove forests. This increase of Cd and Pb in the mangrove forest suggests potential storage of metal contaminants in the organic rich areas, a change in availability and potential toxicity to fauna and flora and a need for regulatory responses to sediment quality. These results indicate a change in sediment metal contaminant dynamics with the increasing occurrence of extreme weather events - an increased risk to the ecosystem.

Oxidative Stress and Damage Biomarkers in Clam Ruditapes decussatus Exposed to a Polluted Site: The Reliable Biomonitoring Tools in Hot and Cold Seasons

In the present study, a multi-biomarker approach was used to assess the biological effects of metal pollution in the southern lagoon of Tunis, on clam Ruditapes decussatus both in "hot" (in summer) and "cold" (in winter) seasons. Clams were collected in August 2015 and February 2016 from three sites of the lagoon and from Louza considered a reference site. The concentrations of five trace metals (cadmium, copper, iron, lead, and zinc) in the soft tissues of R. decussatus were evaluated at the sampling sites. A core of biomarkers indicative of (a) neurotoxicity (acetylcholinesterase, AChE); (b) biotransformation (glutathione S-transferase, GST); (c) oxidative stress (catalase, CAT; total glutathione peroxidase, T-GPx; total glutathione peroxidase, T-GPx; selenium-dependent glutathione peroxidase, Se-GPx; glutathione reductase, GR; superoxide dismutase, SOD) (d) lipid peroxidation (malondialdhyde, MDA level), and (e) apoptotic process (caspase 3-like, CSP3) was selected for measurements of environmental effects on the populations of clams collected from the different sampling sites. The results of metal bioaccumulation in soft tissues of Ruditapes decussatus revealed a high pollution in the South Lagoon of Tunis with spatial variation and relatively high levels at the navigation channel. Anthropogenic pollutants in the lagoon led to the activation of antioxidant defense and biotransformation enzymes to oxidative damage of the membrane and activation of apoptosis, and revealed neurotoxicity. Among this core of biomarkers, the antioxidants enzymes (CAT, SOD, GR, and GPx) were very sensitive, allowing the discrimination among sites and pointing to the navigation channel as the most impacted site in the southern lagoon of Tunis. Moreover, a significant effect of season was recorded on biomarkers responses (e.g., CAT, GR, SOD, AChE, and CSP3 activities and MDA levels) with higher levels in winter than in summer, probably influenced by the reproductive stage and food availability. Finally, the measurement of the selected core of biomarkers in the whole soft tissues of clams was considered as an integrated indicator of environmental stress. Moreover, R. decussatus proved to be a remarkable sentinel species capable to establish a reliable diagnosis of the health status of the marine environment in different areas of the southern lagoon of Tunis, both in "hot" and "cold" seasons.

A new approach to evaluate toxic metal transport in a catchment

Competitive sorption and desorption of Cd²⁺, Pb²⁺, and Hg²⁺ onto riverbank and sediment samples of an area impacted by pyritic residue in a Southern Brazilian catchment were evaluated. Although these ions are considered poorly mobile, a new approach has been proposed to assess their behavior and associated risk. In this sense, factorial design and three-dimensional surface methodology are proposed to describe the competitive sorption behavior of the metal ion in the environmental matrix, as well as an innovative mobilization factor (MF) to describe the desorption rate from the integration of the normalized difference of sorption-desorption fluorescence peaks. Sorption was carried out with a central composite factorial design (2³) to estimate simultaneous effects of independent variables. Three-dimensional surface analysis indicated increasing Cd²⁺ equilibrium concentration (C_eq) with Hg²⁺ and Pb²⁺ initial concentration (C_i), showing synergistic effect and low Cd²⁺ affinity to the solid phase. Statistical analysis presented [Formula: see text] as a significant variable for cadmium and lead dynamics, although [Formula: see text] was also significant for Hg²⁺ releasing to the liquid phase. After integrating the sorption and desorption fluorescence peaks, the MF for Cd²⁺, Pb²⁺, and Hg²⁺ was around 0.2, 0.5, and 0.1 in riverbank sediment, and 0.3, 0.9, and 0.1 in sediment, respectively. Hence, consistent ion mobilization along the river was observed, with Pb²⁺ mobilizing 9 and 6 times more than Hg²⁺ and Cd²⁺, respectively. The transport of ions such as Pb²⁺ and Hg²⁺, usually considered immobile, has indeed occurred, causing contamination through the watershed and increasing environmental risk. Graphical Abstract A new approach to determine toxic metal mobilization factor in a river catchment.

How leachates from wasted cigarette butts influence aquatic life? A case study on freshwater mussel Anodontites trapesiali

There are several reports on the damage smoking causes to human health available in the literature, but little is known about the environmental and biological consequences from inappropriate cigarette butt (CB) disposal in urban and natural environments. The immunotoxic, morphotoxic and mutagenic potential of leachates from cigarette butts (LCB) diluted at environmentally relevant rates (LCB1x: 1.375%; LCB10x: 13.75%) was evaluated in adult representatives of the bivalve species Anodontites trapesialis, which was adopted as model organism. Type II hyalinocytes and granulocytes (phagocytic cells) frequency increased in the hemolymph of subjects exposed to the pollutant for 14 days. Based on this outcome, LCB chemical constituents did not induce immunotoxic effects. The treatments also did not seem to have any impact on the subjects' hemocitary morphometry parameters: diameter, area, perimeter, circularity and nucleus - cytoplasm ratio. However, subjects in groups LCB1x and LCB10x recorded a larger number of hyalinocytes with some nuclear abnormality such as micronucleus, blebbed nucleus, asymmetric constriction nucleus, and nuclear multilobulation and binucleation. The association between these abnormalities and the treatments was confirmed by the Cr, Ni, Pb, Zn, Mn and Na bioaccumulation in tissue samples of the bivalve models exposed to LCB. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report on LCB mutagenicity in representatives of a freshwater bivalve group. Given the chemical complexity of the addressed pollutants, it is imperative to develop further investigations about the topic.

Single and Combined Effects of Zinc and Manganese on the Bivalve Anodontites trapesialis: Complementary Endpoints to Support the Hypothesis of Manganese Promoting Metabolic Suppression in Gills

Manganese (Mn) might stimulate the valve closure reflex in the freshwater bivalve Anodontites trapesialis, leading to metabolic suppression, whereas zinc (Zn) is not able to modify this behavior. To investigate this particular response, we exposed A. trapesialis specimens to Mn (0.5 mg L^-1 ) and Zn (1.0 mg L^-1 ) alone, and to their mixture, to measure further endpoints in different clam tissues: glycogen level in gills, and calcium (Ca²⁺ ), sodium (Na⁺ ), and chloride (Cl^- ) concentrations in the hemolymph. Furthermore, we used cutting-edge technology, proteomics, to evaluate modifications in protein patterns under the 3 exposure tests. The main results highlighted that only Mn caused a clear drop in glycogen levels in gills, an increase in Ca²⁺ and Na⁺ , and a simultaneous decrease in Cl^- concentration in the hemolymph. The proteomic analysis confirmed that Mn promoted more effects in A. trapesialis than the other tested conditions, because the number of proteins modulated was higher than the results obtained after exposure to Zn and the mixture. Moreover, 11 of the 12 modulated proteins were down-expressed. These results consolidate the hypothesis that Mn might suppress gill metabolic rate in A. trapesialis. Environ Toxicol Chem 2019;38:2480-2485. © 2019 SETAC.

Comparison of the General Threshold Model of Survival and Dose-Response Models in Simulating the Acute Toxicity of Metals to Danio rerio

We exposed zebrafish (Danio rerio) to different concentrations of lead and cadmium, and monitored them for survival at 24, 48, 72, and 96 h. Metal toxicity was predicted and compared using the dose-response and general threshold survival models in terms of required data sets, fit performance, and applicability. Environ Toxicol Chem 2019;38:2169-2177. © 2019 SETAC.

Seasonal variations of multi-biomarker responses to metals and pesticides pollution in M. galloprovincialis and T. decussatus from Homa Lagoon, Eastern Aegean Sea

Biomarkers (CAT, SOD, GPx, and AChE) were investigated in hepatopancreas and soft tissues of mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis) and clams (Tapes decussatus) in response to metal and pesticide pollutions in Homa Lagoon. Mussel and clam samples were seasonally collected in January, May, August and November 2015. According to the results, higher metal concentrations determined in the soft tissues of both species in January. Hepatopancreas was found to accumulate higher levels of metals than soft tissue. Metal deposition potential in clams were higher than mussels. Pesticide levels were below detection limits in clams. In mussels, only 4,4'-DDE was detected in soft tissues and hepatopancreas in November. Highest AChE, CAT, SOD and GPx activities in mussels were determined in January. On the other hand, maximum AChE and CAT activities in clams were found in November. Seasonal variations of metals and biomarker levels might be related to species-specific physiology and environmental conditions.

Toxicokinetic and toxicodynamic (TK-TD) modeling to study oxidative stress-dependent toxicity of heavy metals in zebrafish

Adverse outcome pathways (AOP) have been proposed as a new method to improve the ecological risk assessment of pollutants, but it requires quantitation linkage between exposure, biomarker response and toxicity of pollutants. A toxicokinetic and toxicodynamic (TK-TD) model was used to quantify AOP of the toxicity of Cd and Pb to zebrafish, including the quantitative relationship between Cd and Pb accumulation in gill and oxidative damage level based on ROS or MDA, and LC₅₀ values at different times. Significant relationships were found between the oxidative damage level characterized by ROS and MDA content and Cd or Pb accumulation in gill (R² > 0.60), and the TK model could better simulate the Pb accumulation in the gills (R² > 0.60) than Cd. The increasing of Cd or Pb concentrations induced the generation of ROS and the formation of ROS initiated the fluctuation of MDA level in the cells as compared to controls (p < 0.05). For the individual level effect, the Damage Assessment Model (DAM) could successfully explain the change of LC_50-ROS and LC_50-MDA values at different times (R² > 0.99). Our findings suggested that the TK-TD model based on ROS and MDA could be used as a quantitative AOP to predict toxicity of metals to zebrafish.