Levels and distribution of synthetic musks in farmland soils from the Three Northeast Provinces of China

Synthetic musks in the natural environment: Sources, occurrence, concentration, and fate-A review of recent developments (2010-2023)

Synthetic musks (SMs) have served as cost-effective substitutes for natural musk compounds in personal care and daily chemical products for decades. Their widespread use has led to their detection in various environmental matrices, raising concerns about potential risks. Despite numerous studies on SM levels in different natural environments, a systematic review of their contemporary presence is lacking. This review aims to address this gap by summarising recent research developments on SMs in diverse natural environments, including river water, lake water, seawater, estuarine water, groundwater, snow, meltwater, sediments, aquatic suspended matter, soils, sands, outdoor air, and atmospheric particulate matter. Covering the period from 2010 to 2023, the review focuses on four SM categories: nitro, polycyclic, macrocyclic, and alicyclic. It systematically examines their sources, occurrences, concentrations, spatial and temporal variations, and fate. The literature reveals widespread detection of SMs in the natural environment (freshwater and sediments in particular), with polycyclic musks being the most studied group. Both direct (e.g., wastewater discharges) and indirect (e.g., human recreational activities) sources contribute to SM presence. Levels of SMs vary greatly among studies with higher levels observed in certain regions, such as sediments in Southeast Asia. Spatial and temporal variations are also evident. The fate of SMs in the environment depends on their physicochemical properties and environmental processes, including bioaccumulation, biodegradation, photodegradation, adsorption, phase exchange, hydro-dilution effects. Biodegradation and photodegradation can decrease SM levels, but may produce more persistent and eco-toxic products. Modelling approaches have been employed to analyse SM fate, especially for indirect processes like photodegradation or long-distance atmospheric transport. Future studies should further investigate the complex fate if SMs and their environmental influence. This review enhances understanding of SM status in the natural environment and supports efforts to control environmental contamination.

A critical review of distribution, toxicological effects, current analytical methods and future prospects of synthetic musks in aquatic environments

Synthetic musks (SMs) have gained widespread utilization in daily consumer products, leading to their widespread dissemination in aquatic environments through various pathways. Over the past few decades, the production of SMs has consistently risen, prompting significant concern over their potential adverse impacts on ecosystems and human health. Although several studies have focused on the development of analytical techniques for detecting SMs in biological samples and cosmetic products, a comprehensive evaluation of their global distribution in diverse aquatic media and biological matrices remains lacking. This review aims to provide an up-to-date overview of the occurrence of SMs in both aquatic and various biological matrices, investigating their worldwide distribution trends, assessing their ecological toxicity, and comparing different methodologies for processing and analysis of SMs. The findings underscore the prevalence of polycyclic musks as predominant SMs, with consumption of various products in different countries leading to contrasting distribution of contaminants. Furthermore, the migration of SMs from sediments to the water phase is investigated, indicating the role of solid-phase reservoirs. Incomplete degradation of SMs in the environment could contribute to their accumulation in aquatic systems, impacting the growth and oxidative stress of aquatic organisms, and having a possibility of genotoxicity to them. Human exposure data highlight substantial risks for vulnerable populations such as pregnant women and infants. Moreover, contemporary methods for SMs analysis are presented in this review, particularly focusing on advancements made in the last five years. Finally, research enhancement and critical questions regarding the analysis of SMs are provided, offering suggestions for future research endeavors.

Global distribution and ecological risk assessment of synthetic musks in the environment

Synthetic musks, as an alternative product of natural musks, are widely used in almost all fragrances of consumer products, such as perfumes, cosmetics and detergents. During the past few decades, the production of synthetic musks has been increasing year by year, subsequently followed by large concern about their adverse effects on ecosystems and human beings. Until now, several studies have reviewed the latest development of analytical methods of synthetic musks in biological samples and cosmetics products, while there is still lack of a systematic analysis of their global distribution in different environmental media. Thus, this review summarizes the occurrence of synthetic musks in the environment including biota around the world and explores their global distribution patterns. The results show that galaxolide (HHCB), tonalide (AHTN), musk xylene (MX) and musk ketone (MK) are generally the most frequently detected synthetic musks in different samples with HHCB and AHTN being predominant. Higher concentrations of HHCB and AHTN are normally found in western countries compared to Asian countries, indicating more consumptions of these musks in western countries. The persistence, bioaccumulation and toxicity (PBT) of synthetic musks (mainly for polycyclic musks and nitro musks) are also discussed. The risk quotients (RQs) of HHCB, AHTN, MX and MK in most waters and sediments are below 0.1, reflecting a low risk to aqueous and sediment-dwelling species. In some sites, e.g., close to STPs, high risks (RQs>1) are characterized. Currently, limited data are available for macrocyclic musks and alicyclic musks in terms of either occurrence or PBT properties. More studies with an expanded scope of chemical type, geographical distribution and (synergic) toxicological effects especially from a long-term point of view are needed.

Sediment-water distribution and potential sources of polyhalogenated carbazoles in a coastal river locating at a north metropolis, China

The fate and transformation of PHCZs in the coastal river environment are not yet comprehensively understood. Paired river water and surface sediment were collected, and 12 PHCZs were analyzed to find out their potential sources and investigate the distribution of PHCZs between river water and sediment. The concentration of ∑PHCZs varied from 8.66 to 42.97 ng/g (mean 22.46 ng/g) in sediment and 17.91 to 81.82 ng/L (mean 39.07 ng/L) in river water. 18-B-36-CCZ was the dominant PHCZ congener in sediment, while 36-CCZ was in water. Meanwhile, the logK_oc values for CZ and PHCZs were among the first calculated in the estuary and the mean logK_oc varied from 4.12 for 1-B-36-CCZ to 5.63 for 3-CCZ. The logK_oc values of CCZs were higher than those of BCZs, this may suggest that sediments have a higher capacity for accumulation and storage of CCZs than highly mobile environmental media.

Optimistic effects of galaxolide and polystyrene microplastic stress on the physio-biochemical characteristics and metabolic profiles of an ornamental plant

Galaxolide (HHCB) and polystyrene (PS) microplastics or nanoplastics have been widely recognized as emerging pollutants. However, very few efforts have been made to remove these contaminants from the environment using eco-friendly materials such as plant materials. Therefore, this study sought to investigate the physiological and biochemical effects and tolerance mechanisms of Mirabilis jalapa L. upon exposure to HHCB and PS. Our findings demonstrated that this ornamental plant was tolerant to HHCB and PS exposure. HHCB treatment increased antioxidant enzyme activity. However, superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity increased by 206.85% when the plants were treated with 0.5 mg L^-1 HHCB alone, whereas co-exposure to 0.5 mg L^-1 HHCB and 500 nm PS increased SOD activity by 93.82%. Contaminant exposure also affected photosynthetic parameters such as stomatal conductance and transpiration rate. In contrast, net photosynthetic rate and photosynthetic pigment content were not significantly affected. HHCB aggregated heavily in the roots of the plant. Moreover, 500 nm PS could be absorbed by the root and transported to the shoot, and 5 μm PS would be transferred to the shoot under the carrying effect of HHCB. Co-exposure to HHCB and PS significantly changed the glyoxylate and dicarboxylate metabolism, alanine, aspartate, and glutamate metabolism, and glycine, serine, and threonine metabolism pathways, thus affecting carbohydrate synthesis and energy metabolism in M. jalapa. These results provide a basis for the development of HHCB and PS remediation strategies using M. jalapa, an ornamental plant that is not only tolerant to organic contaminants but can also beautify the environment.

Synthesis of Synthetic Musks: A Theoretical Study Based on the Relationships between Structure and Properties at Molecular Scale

Synthetic musks (SMs), as an indispensable odor additive, are widely used in various personal care products. However, due to their physico-chemical properties, SMs were detected in various environmental media, even in samples from arctic regions, leading to severe threats to human health (e.g., abortion risk). Environmentally friendly and functionally improved SMs have been theoretically designed in previous studies. However, the synthesizability of these derivatives has barely been proven. Thus, this study developed a method to verify the synthesizability of previously designed SM derivatives using machine learning, 2D-QSAR, 3D-QSAR, and high-throughput density functional theory in order to screen for synthesizable, high-performance (odor sensitivity), and environmentally friendly SM derivatives. In this study, three SM derivatives (i.e., D52, D37, and D25) were screened and recommended due to their good performances (i.e., high synthesizability and odor sensitivity; low abortion risk; and bioaccumulation ability in skin keratin). In addition, the synthesizability mechanism of SM derivatives was also analyzed. Results revealed that high intramolecular hydrogen bond strength, electrostatic interaction, qH⁺ value, energy gap, and low E_HOMO would lead to a higher synthesizability of SMs and their derivatives. This study broke the synthesizability bottleneck of theoretically designed environment-friendly SM derivatives and advanced the mechanism of screening functional derivatives.

Particle swarm optimization algorithm with Gaussian exponential model to predict daily and monthly global solar radiation in Northeast China

Reliable global solar radiation (R_s) information is crucial for the design and management of solar energy systems for agricultural and industrial production. However, R_s measurements are unavailable in many regions of the world, which impedes the development and application of solar energy. To accurately estimate R_s, particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm integrating Gaussian exponential model (GEM) was proposed for estimating daily and monthly global R_s in Northeast China. The PSO-GEM was compared with four other machine learning models and two empirical models to assess its applicability using daily meteorological data from 1997 to 2016 from four stations in Northeast China. The results showed that in different stations, the PSO-GEM with full climatic data as inputs showed the highest accuracy to estimate daily R_s with RMSE, RRMSE, MAE, R², and E_ns values of 1.045-1.719 MJ m^-2 d^-1, 7.6-12.7%, 0.801-1.283 MJ m^-2 d^-1, 0.953-0.981, and 0.946-0.977, respectively. The PSO-GEM showed the highest accuracy to estimate monthly R_s with RMSE, RRMSE, MAE, R², and E_ns values of 0.197-0.575 MJ m^-2 d^-1, 1.5-7.0%, 0.137-0.499 MJ m^-2 d^-1, 0.999-1, and 0.992-0.999, respectively. Overall, the PSO-GEM had the highest accuracy under different inputs and is recommended for modeling daily and monthly R_s in Northeast China.

Uptake and translocation of synthetic musk fragrances by pea plant grown in sewage sludge-amended soils

Sewage sludges are rich in organic matter and several essential nutrients for plant growth, making them very appealing for application in agricultural soils. However, they may also contain a wide range of emerging pollutants, which has raised concerns about the potential risks of this practice to crops, the environment, and public health - accumulation in soils and/or plant uptake and translocation of contaminants. Therefore, there is a need to study plant-soil interactions and assess the uptake potential of these contaminants by food crops to better understand these risks. The main aim of this work was to assess the possible drawbacks of sludge application to cropland, by observing the impact on the growth and yield of a model crop (pea plant - Pisum sativum) grown over an 86-day greenhouse experiment and by assessing the uptake potential of synthetic musk fragrances. Different sewage sludge application rates (4-30-ton ha-1) and initial concentrations of contaminants were tested. The application of sludge yielded benefits to the cultivated plants, finding improved crop productivity with an application rate of 30-ton ha-1. At the end of the experiment, soil samples and plants separated into sections were analysed using a QuEChERS extraction methodology followed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) quantification. Galaxolide (HHCB) and tonalide (AHTN) underwent uptake by the plant roots, having been detected in concentrations up to 346 ng g-1 on a dry weight basis (dw), but only HHCB was detected in above ground tissues. At the end, a decrease in the levels of synthetic musks in the amended soils (>80% in several instances) was observed. Assuming the worst-case scenario, no risk to human health was observed from the ingestion of peas grown on sewage sludge-amended soils. However, a soil hazard quotient analysis yielded worryingly high quotient values for AHTN in nearly all tested conditions.

Occurrence of synthetic musks in the sediment-seawater system of the Yellow Sea and East China Sea during wet and dry seasons

Synthetic musks are aroma compounds used worldwide as substitutes for natural musks, which have become ubiquitous pollutants in the environment. The land-based input and partition behavior of synthetic musks in sediments and seawater are important for understanding their fate in the marine environment. In this study, a total of 292 seawater and sediment samples from 146 sites of the Yellow Sea and East China Sea were collected during wet and dry seasons and used to determine four synthetic musks, tonalide, galaxolide, musk xylene and musk ketone. Only tonalide was detectable in 10.6% and 17.8% of seawater samples at a concentration range of 23.7-38.2 ng/L and 19.0-24.8 ng/L in wet season and dry season, respectively. In sediments, both galaxolide and tonalide were detectable, with a sum total synthetic musks concentration ranging from 1.4 to 36.6 ng/g dry weight (dw) in wet season and 1.0 to 14.1 ng/g dw in dry season. The concentration of tonalide in seawater was significantly higher in wet season than in dry season and the concentration of synthetic musks in sediments of some coastal areas also exhibited higher concentrations in wet season than in dry season. Fugacity analysis showed that tonalide in the Yellow Sea exhibited a trend of diffusion from sediment to seawater or a state of equilibrium, while no diffusion trend was observed in the East China Sea. The hazard quotient values for tonalide and galaxolide in sediment and seawater samples were lower than 0.1, indicating that they present a low ecological risk. This research provides novel insights that help understand the pollution status, diffusion behavior and ecological risk of synthetic musks in marine environments.

Occurrence and distribution of polyhalogenated carbazoles in eastern Tibetan Plateau soils along the slope of Mt. Qionglai

Polyhalogenated carbazoles (PHCZs), are considered as potential persistent organic pollutants (POPs), which have been frequently detected in the environment. However, the altitudinal distribution characteristics and possible sources of PHCZs in high mountain soils are still unknown. The present study was the first to analyze PHCZs in soil samples collected along the eastern slope of Mt. Qionglai (MQ), the east edge of the Tibetan Plateau. The concentration of ΣPHCZs (based on dry weight) ranges from 14.4 to 107 ng/g (median value of 40.9), which was at high end of the range reported in soils and sediments to date in the literature. The composition profiles of PHCZs in the soils of MQ were dominated by 3,6-dichlorocarbazole (36-CCZ), 3-chlorocarbazole (3-CCZ), and 2-bromocarbazole (2-BCZ). The mean TOC-normalized concentrations of ΣPHCZs in soil samples from below-treeline (2092 ng/g TOC) were higher than those from alpine meadow (1124 ng/g TOC), probably due to the forest filter effect. The decreasing trend of the PHCZs TOC-normalized concentrations with altitude shows that accumulation of PHCZs from the alpine meadow samples was not affected by the mountain cold-trapping effect. Significantly positive correlations were observed between the concentrations of more than half of detected PHCZ congeners and TOC. In addition, PHCZs show the potential to represent a class of POPs with the frequent occurrence and wide distribution, as the abundance and environmental behavior of PHCZs are similar to some POPs in MQ.

Organophosphate esters and synthetic musks in the sediments of the Yangtze River Estuary and adjacent East China Sea: Occurrence, distribution, and potential ecological risks

Occurrence, distribution, and potential ecological risks of ten organophosphate esters (OPEs) and nine synthetic musks (SMs) were investigated in sediments from the Yangtze River Estuary (YRE) and adjacent East China Sea (ECS). The total concentrations of OPEs in the surface sediments ranged from 0.977 to 19.0 ng/g dry weight (dw) with tris(2-chloro-propyl) phosphate being the dominant component. Total concentrations of SMs ranged from 0.176 to 7.25 ng/g dw, with 1,3,4,6,7,8-hexahydro-4,6,6,7,8,8-hexamethylcyclopenta(g)-2-benzopyran and 7-acetyl-1,1,3,4,4,6-hexamethyl-1,2,3,4-tetrahydronaphthalene as the dominant SMs. Higher sedimentary concentrations of ΣOPEs and ΣSMs were found in the river mouths of the YRE, inter face of Hangzhou Bay, and mud area of the ECS; the results suggested that terrestrial discharge might be the main source of OPEs and SMs in the studied region. Risk assessment revealed that low ecological risks were posed by OPEs, and limited to low ecological risks were posed by SMs.

Derivation of predicted no effect concentration and ecological risk assessment of polycyclic musks tonalide and galaxolide in sediment

Polycyclic musks (PMs) have drawn increased attention in recent years because of their persistence, bioaccumulation and toxicity. As two typical PMs contaminants, tonalide (AHTN) and galaxolide (HHCB) are widely detected in sediment worldwide. Acute and chronic toxicity data of AHTN and HHCB to freshwater and seawater organisms in water and sediments are collected and screened. The predicted no effect concentrations (PNEC_sediment) for AHTN and HHCB is derived according to the equilibrium partitioning method recommended by the EU technical guidance document (TGD) and the species sensitivity distribution (SSD) method based on the measured sediment toxicity data. The concentration levels of AHTN and HHCB are investigated and evaluated in freshwater and seawater sediments. Results show the difference between native and non-native freshwater species is not statistically significant. AHTN is more toxic to freshwater and seawater organisms than HHCB, and seawater organisms are more sensitive to 2 musks than freshwater organisms. The chronic PNEC_sediment values of AHTN and HHCB are 194.48 and 416.47 ng/g in freshwater sediment, 88.93 and 128.34 ng/g in seawater sediment respectively. The AHTN and HHCB linear correlation analysis exhibited a strong positive linear correlation in both domestic (R²=0.9054) and foreign (R² = 0.9645) sediment. Preliminary risk assessment shows that the risks posed by AHTN and HHCB in sediment based on individual or combined concentrations of two musks are at medium to high levels in some regions. Further risk assessment results indicate that, for HHCB, 1.72% of foreign freshwater sediment may pose an ecological risk to 5% species; for AHTN, 8.06% of foreign freshwater sediment and 1.02% of domestic freshwater sediment may pose an ecological risk to 5% species, and 5.86% of seawater sediment may pose an ecological risk to 5% species. The above results indicate that there are some negligible risks in domestic and foreign sediments posed by these two musks, we should continue to pay attention to the toxic effects and pollution level of both musks in environment.

Simulating reference crop evapotranspiration with different climate data inputs using Gaussian exponential model

Obtaining accurate data on reference crop evapotranspiration (ET₀) is important for agricultural water management. A novel Gaussian exponential model (GEM) was developed in this study to predict ET₀ with limited climatic data. The GEM was further compared with the M5 model tree (M5T), extreme learning machine (ELM), and boosted trees (BT) model under local and regional scenarios. Daily meteorological data during 1997-2016 from four stations in Northeast China were used to develop and validate the model. The results showed that the models considering solar radiation and relative humidity demonstrated considerably higher accuracy than those using other inputs. The GEM demonstrated higher accuracy among the four machine learning models for different stations. The accuracy of GEM under local scenarios was higher than that under regional scenarios with the root mean square error (RMSE) reducing by 0.025-0.046 mm/d, relative root mean square error (RRMSE) reducing by 0.879-2.022%, coefficient of efficiency (E_ns) increasing by 0.008-0.026, the coefficients of determination (R²) increasing by 0.008-0.026, and mean absolute error (MAE) reducing by 0.015-0.033 mm/d. The GEM considering solar radiation had the highest accuracy with the global performance indicator (GPI) of 1.876. It can also be seen from the Taylor diagrams that the GEM has the the lowest standard deviation and mean square error and the highest correlation coefficient with the standard values. In general, the GEM considering solar radiation had the lowest error and the highest consistency and could be recommended for ET₀ simulation for Northeast China.

Modified dispersive solid-phase extraction and cleanup followed by GC-MS/MS analysis to quantify ultraviolet filters and synthetic musk compounds in soil samples

A simple method for the analysis of 13 synthetic musk compounds and six ultraviolet filters in soil samples was developed using a modified dispersive solid-phase methodology known as "Quick, Easy, Cheap, Effective, Rugged and Safe," followed by gas chromatography-triple quadrupole mass spectrometry. The methodology was validated by assessing linearity ranges, detection limits, precision, and accuracy. The method detection limit ranged between 0.01 and 10.00 ng/g dry weight and accuracy from 81 to 122%. A good precision was achieved, with relative standard deviation <10%. The applicability of the methodology was tested using different types of soils. Both synthetic musks and ultraviolet filters were detected in all soil samples. The most frequently detected compounds were benzophenone, octocrylene, 2-ethylhexyl 4-dimethylaminobenzoate, 2-ethylhexyl 4-methoxycinnamate, and galaxolide. Higher levels were detected for benzophenone (maximum value of 158 ng/g dry weight) and octocrylene (137 ng/g dry weight). In comparison with conventional techniques, this method uses lower amounts of solvents and sorbents, producing less waste ("greener" technique) and comparable performances. In addition, it presents as main advantages the simplicity, speed (short extraction/cleaning time), low cost, and minimum handling of extracts, which can minimize the possibility of samples cross-contamination.

Synthetic musk fragrances in sediments from a subtropical river-lake system in eastern China: occurrences, profiles, and ecological risks

Synthetic musk fragrances (SMFs) in aquatic environments have been of increasing concern because of their potential characteristic of persistent, bioaccumulated, and ecological harm. However, little is known about the distribution of SMFs in river-lake systems. In this study, the occurrence and risks of six SMFs measured in sediments from Lake Chaohu (eastern China) and the rivers flowing into it were investigated. The total sedimentary SMF concentrations ranged from 2.43 to 15.5 ng/g in Lake Chaohu (median = 5.17 ng/g), and 2.34-104 ng/g in the rivers (median = 10.6 ng/g). Overall, moderate levels of SMFs were found in comparison with previous results from other areas. Galaxolide and tonalide dominated in the rivers whereas cashmeran was dominant in Lake Chaohu. A source assessment indicated that the discharge from industries contributed importantly to the pollution of SMFs in the studied waters, in addition to the inputs from domestic sewage. Our estimates suggested that the current sedimentary SMF concentrations were likely to pose extremely low ecological risk to aquatic organisms. However, more studies are needed to focus on the spatial and temporal trends in distribution as well as the ecotoxicological implications of SMFs in the Lake Chaohu area because there is a general lack of relevant information.