Insights into selenate removal mechanism of hydrogen-based membrane biofilm reactor for nitrate-polluted groundwater treatment based on anaerobic biofilm analysis

Impact of Nitrate on the Removal of Pollutants from Water in Reducing Gas-Based Membrane Biofilm Reactors: A Review

The membrane biofilm reactor (MBfR) is a novel wastewater treatment technology, garnering attention due to its high gas utilization rate and effective pollutant removal capability. This paper outlines the working mechanism, advantages, and disadvantages of MBfR, and the denitrification pathways, assessing the efficacy of MBfR in removing oxidized pollutants (sulfate (SO4-), perchlorate (ClO4-)), heavy metal ions (chromates (Cr(VI)), selenates (Se(VI))), and organic pollutants (tetracycline (TC), p-chloronitrobenzene (p-CNB)), and delves into the role of related microorganisms. Specifically, through the addition of nitrates (NO3-), this paper analyzes its impact on the removal efficiency of other pollutants and explores the changes in microbial communities. The results of the study show that NO3- inhibits the removal of other pollutants (oxidizing pollutants, heavy metal ions and organic pollutants), etc., in the simultaneous removal of multiple pollutants by MBfR.

Coupling of selenate reduction and pyrrhotite oxidation by indigenous microbial consortium in natural aquifer

Pyrrhotite is ubiquitously found in natural environment and involved in diverse (bio)processes. However, the pyrrhotite-driven bioreduction of toxic selenate [Se(VI)] remains largely unknown. This study demonstrates that Se(VI) is successfully bioreduced under anaerobic condition with the participation of pyrrhotite for the first time. Completely removal of Se(VI) was achieved at initial concentration of 10 mg/L Se(VI) and 0.56 mL/min flow rate in continuous column experiment with indigenous microbial consortium and pyrrhotite. Variation in hydrochemistry and hydrodynamics affected Se(VI) removal performance. Se(VI) was reduced to insoluble Se(0) while elements in pyrrhotite were oxidized to Fe(III) and SO₄^2-. Breakthrough study indicated that biotic activity contributed 81.4 ± 1.07% to Se(VI) transformation. Microbial community analysis suggested that chemoautotrophic genera (e.g., Thiobacillus) could realize pyrrhotite oxidation and Se(VI) reduction independently, while heterotrophic genera (e.g., Bacillus, Pseudomonas) contributed to Se(VI) detoxification by utilizing metabolic intermediates generated through Fe(II) and S(-II) oxidation, which were further verified by pure culture tests. Metagenomic and qPCR analyses indicated genes encoding enzymes for Se(VI) reduction (e.g., serA, napA and srdBAC), S oxidation (e.g., soxB) and Fe oxidation (e.g., mtrA) were upregulated. The elevated electron transporters (e.g., nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide, cytochrome c) promoted electron transfer from pyrrhotite to Se(VI). This study gains insights into Se biogeochemistry under the effect of Fe(II)-bearing minerals and provides a sustainable strategy for Se(VI) bioremediation in natural aquifer.

Selenium in soil-plant system: Transport, detoxification and bioremediation

Selenium (Se) is an essential micronutrient for humans and a beneficial element for plants. However, high Se doses always exhibit hazardous effects. Recently, Se toxicity in plant-soil system has received increasing attention. This review will summarize (1) Se concentration in soils and its sources, (2) Se bioavailability in soils and influencing factors, (3) mechanisms on Se uptake and translocation in plants, (4) toxicity and detoxification of Se in plants and (5) strategies to remediate Se pollution. High Se concentration mainly results from wastewater discharge and industrial waste dumping. Selenate (Se [VI]) and selenite (Se [IV]) are the two primary forms absorbed by plants. Soil conditions such as pH, redox potential, organic matter and microorganisms will influence Se bioavailability. In plants, excessive Se will interfere with element uptake, depress photosynthetic pigment biosynthesis, generate oxidative damages and cause genotoxicity. Plants employ a series of strategies to detoxify Se, such as activating antioxidant defense systems and sequestrating excessive Se in the vacuole. In order to alleviate Se toxicity to plants, some strategies can be applied, including phytoremediation, OM remediation, microbial remediation, adsorption technique, chemical reduction technology and exogenous substances (such as Methyl jasmonate, Nitric oxide and Melatonin). This review is expected to expand the knowledge of Se toxicity/detoxicity in soil-plant system and offer valuable insights into soils Se pollution remediation strategies.

Biological selenate and selenite reduction by waste activated sludge using hydrogen as electron donor

Biological reduction of selenium oxyanions is widely used for selenium removal from wastewater. The process is, however, limited by the availability of a suitable, efficient and low cost electron donor. In this study, selenite and selenate reduction by waste activated sludge using hydrogen as the electron donor was investigated. Both selenite and selenate (80 mg/L) were completely removed using H₂ within 8 days of incubation. In the presence of sulfate in the medium, the Se removal efficiency decreased to 77.8-95.4% (for selenite) and 88.2-99.4% (for selenate) at different temperatures and initial sulfate concentrations. Thermophilic conditions (50 °C) were better suited for both selenite and selenate reduction using H₂ as electron donor with a 0.8-13.5% increase in overall Se removal. Similarly, sulfate reduction also increased from 69.1- 88% at 30 °C to 72-94.6% at 50 °C. Most of the H₂ utilized was diverted towards Se and sulfate reduction with minimal production of byproducts such as methane (<0.32 mM) or volatile fatty acids (<0.92 mg/L). The elemental Se produced from selenite and selenate reduction ranged between 33.9 and 52.1 mg/L. The elemental selenium nanoparticles produced as a result of selenite and selenate reduction were characterized using transmission electron microscopy (TEM), energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) and dynamic light scattering (DLS) spectroscopy. Furthermore, characterization of the biomass using Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) and excitation emission matrix (EEM) spectra of the extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) produced by the waste activated sludge were performed to elucidate the mechanism of selenium oxyanion reduction to elemental selenium nanoparticles.

Recent advances in the source identification and remediation techniques of nitrate contaminated groundwater: A review

Researchers have long been committed to identify nitrate sources in groundwater and to develop an advanced technique for its remediation because better apply remediation solution and management of water quality is highly dependent on the identification of the NO₃^- sources contamination in water. In this review, we systematically introduce nitrate source tracking tools used over the past ten years including dual isotope and multi isotope techniques, water chemistry profile, Bayesian mixing model, microbial tracers and land use/cover data. These techniques can be combined and exploited to track the source of NO₃^- as mineral or organic fertilizer, sewage, or atmospheric deposition. These available data have significant implications for making an appropriate measures and decisions by water managers. A continuous remediation strategy of groundwater was among the main management strategies that need to be applied in the contaminated area. Nitrate removal from groundwater can be accomplished using either separation or reduction based process. The application of these processes to nitrate removal is discussed in this review and some novel methods were presented for the first time. Moreover, the advantages and limitations of each approach are critically summarized and based on our own understanding of the subject some solutions to overcomes their drawbacks are recommended. Advanced techniques are capable to attain significantly higher nitrate and other co-contaminants removal from groundwater. However, the challenges of by-products generation and high energy consumption need to be addressed in implementing these technologies for groundwater remediation for potable use.

Long-term effects of Cu(II) on denitrification in hydrogen-based membrane biofilm reactor: Performance, extracellular polymeric substances and microbial communities

Divalent copper (Cu(II)) frequently coexists with nitrate (NO₃^-) in industrial wastewater and the effect of Cu(II) on the autotrophic denitrification system using H₂ as the electron donor remains unknown. In this study, the hydrogen-based membrane biofilm reactor (H₂-MBfR) was operated continuously over 150 days to explore the effect of Cu(II) on the performance of autotrophic denitrification system and understand the key roles of EPS and microbial community. More than 95% of 20 mg-N/L NO₃^- was removed at 1-5 mg/L Cu(II), and the removal rate of NO₃^--N was stabilized to 82% at 10 mg/L Cu(II) after a short period, while NH₄⁺ and NO₂^- in effluent were hardly detected, indicated that high concentration of Cu(II) did not permanently inhibit the denitrification performance in H₂-MBfR. Colorimetric determination showed that Cu(II) stimulated the secretion of EPS, in which the protein (PN) content was much higher than polysaccharide (PS). The PN/PS ratios increased from 0.93 to 1.99, and the PN was more sensitive to copper invasion. The results of three-dimensional excitation-emission matrix illustrated that tryptophan was the main component of EPS chelating Cu(II) to reduce toxicity. The results of Fourier-transform infrared demonstrated that hydroxyl, carboxyl, and protein amide groups bound and reduced Cu(II). Furthermore, Cu(II) was effectively removed (>80%), and the results of distribution and morphology analysis of Cu(II) show that the electron-dense deposits of monovalent copper (Cu(I)) were found in EPS and biofilms and the reduction of Cu(II) to Cu(I) was an obvious self-defense reaction of biofilm to copper stress. The microbial richness and diversity decreased with the long-term exposure to Cu(II), while the relative abundance of denitrifiers Azospira and Dechloromonas increased. This study provides a scientific basis for the optimal design of treatment system for removal of nitrate and recovery of heavy metals simultaneously.

A Bibliometric Analysis of Research on Selenium in Drinking Water during the 1990-2021 Period: Treatment Options for Selenium Removal

A bibliometric analysis based on the Scopus database was carried out to summarize the global research related to selenium in drinking water from 1990 to 2021 and identify the quantitative characteristics of the research in this period. The results from the analysis revealed that the number of accumulated publications followed a quadratic growth, which confirmed the relevance this research topic is gaining during the last years. High research efforts have been invested to define safe selenium content in drinking water, since the insufficient or excessive intake of selenium and the corresponding effects on human health are only separated by a narrow margin. Some important research features of the four main technologies most frequently used to remove selenium from drinking water (coagulation, flocculation and precipitation followed by filtration; adsorption and ion exchange; membrane-based processes and biological treatments) were compiled in this work. Although the search of technological options to remove selenium from drinking water is less intensive than the search of solutions to reduce and eliminate the presence of other pollutants, adsorption was the alternative that has received the most attention according to the research trends during the studied period, followed by membrane technologies, while biological methods require further research efforts to promote their implementation.

Selenium (Se) recovery for technological applications from environmental matrices based on biotic and abiotic mechanisms

Selenium (Se) is an essential element with application in manufacturing from food to medical industries. Water contamination by Se is of concern due to anthropogenic activities. Recently, Se remediation has received increasing attention. Hence, different types of remediation techniques are listed in this work, and their potential for Se recovery is evaluated. Sorption, co-precipitation, coagulation and precipitation are effective for low-cost Se removal. In photocatalytic, zero-valent iron and electrochemical systems, the above mechanisms occur with reduction as an immobilization and detoxification process. In combination with magnetic separation, the above techniques are promising for Se recovery. Biological Se oxyanions reduction has been widely recognized as a cost-effective method for Se remediation, simultaneously generating biosynthetic Se nanoparticles (BioSeNPs). Increasing the extracellular production of BioSeNPs and controlling their morphology will benefit its recovery. However, the mechanism of the microbial production of BioSeNPs is not well understood. Se containing products from both microbial reduction and abiotic methods need to be refined to obtain pure Se. Eco-friendly and cost-effective Se refinery methods need to be developed. Overall, this review offers insight into the necessity of shifting attention from Se remediation to Se recovery.

Microbial selenate detoxification linked to elemental sulfur oxidation: Independent and synergic pathways

Elevated selenium levels in the environment, with soluble selenate [Se(VI)] as the common chemical species, pose a severe threat to human health. Anaerobic Se(VI) bioreduction is a promising approach for selenium detoxification, and various organic/inorganic electron donors have proved effective in supporting this bioprocess. Nevertheless, autotrophic Se(VI) bioreduction driven by solid inorganic electron donors is still not fully understood. This work is the first to employ elemental sulfur [S(0)] as electron donor to support Se(VI) bioreduction. A batch trial with mixed culture demonstrated the feasibility of this bioprocess, with Se(VI) removal efficiency of 92.4 ± 0.7% at an initial Se(VI) concentration of 10 mg/L within 36 h. Continuous column tests showed that increased initial concentration, flow rate, and introduction of NO₃^--N depressed Se(VI) removal. Se(VI) was mainly bioreduced to solid elemental Se with trace selenite in the effluent, while S(0) was oxidized to SO₄^2-. Enrichment of Thiobacillus, Desulfurivibrio, and Sulfuricurvum combined with upregulation of genes serA, tatC, and soxB indicated Se(VI) bioreduction was coupled to S(0) oxidation. Thiobacillus performed S(0) oxidation and Se(VI) reduction independently. Intermediate metabolites as volatile fatty acids, hydrogen and methane from S(0) oxidation were utilized by heterotrophic Se(VI) reducers for Se(VI) detoxification, indicative of microbial synergy.

Microbial reduction and resistance to selenium: Mechanisms, applications and prospects

Selenium is an essential trace element for humans, animals and microorganisms. Microbial transformations, in particular, selenium dissimilatory reduction and bioremediation applications have received increasing attention in recent years. This review focuses on multiple Se-reducing pathways under anaerobic and aerobic conditions, and the phylogenetic clustering of selenium reducing enzymes that are involved in these processes. It is emphasized that a selenium reductase may have more than one metabolic function, meanwhile, there are several Se(VI) and/or Se(IV) reduction pathways in a bacterial strain. It is noted that Se(IV)-reducing efficiency is inconsistent with Se(IV) resistance in bacteria. Moreover, we discussed the links of selenium transformations to biogeochemical cycling of other elements, roles of Se-reducing bacteria in soil, plant and digestion system, and the possibility of using functional genes involved in Se transformation as biomarker in different environments. In addition, we point out the gaps and perspectives both on Se transformation mechanisms and applications in terms of bioremediation, Se fortification or dietary supplementation.

Simultaneous Partial Nitrification and Denitrification Maintained in Membrane Bioreactor for Nitrogen Removal and Hydrogen Autotrophic Denitrification for Further Treatment

Low C/N wastewater results from a wide range of factors that significantly harm the environment. They include insufficient carbon sources, low denitrification efficiency, and NH4+-N concentrations in low C/N wastewater that are too high to be treated. In this research, the membrane biofilm reactor and hydrogen-based membrane biofilm reactor (MBR-MBfR) were optimized and regulated under different operating parameters: the simulated domestic sewage with low C/N was domesticated and the domestic sewage was then denitrified. The results of the MBR-MBfR experiments indicated that a C/N ratio of two was suitable for NH4+-N, NO2−-N, NO3−-N, and chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal in partial nitrification-denitrification (PN-D) and hydrogen autotrophic denitrification for further treatment. The steady state for domestic wastewater was reached when the MBR-MBfR in the experimental conditions of HRT = 15 h, SRT = 20 d, 0.04 Mpa for H₂ pressure in MBfR, 0.4–0.8 mg/L DO in MBR, MLSS = 2500 mg/L(MBR) and 2800 mg/L(MBfR), and effluent concentrations of NH4+-N, NO3−-N, and NO2−-N were 4.3 ± 0.5, 1.95 ± 0.04, and 2.05 ± 0.15 mg/L, respectively. High-throughput sequencing results revealed the following: (1) The genus Nitrosomonas as the ammonia oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and Denitratisoma as potential denitrifiers were simultaneously enriched in the MBR; (2) at the genus level, Meiothermus,Lentimicrobium, Thauera,Hydrogenophaga, and Desulfotomaculum played a dominant role in leading to NO3−-N and NO2−-N removal in the MBfR.

Optimization of nitrate and selenate reduction in an ethanol-fed fluidized bed reactor via redox potential feedback control

Electron donors are a major cost-factor in biological removal of oxyanions, such as nitrate and selenate from wastewater. In this study, an online ethanol dosing strategy based on feedback control of oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) was designed to optimize the performance of a lab-scale fluidized bed reactor (FBR) in treating selenate and nitrate (5 mM each) containing wastewater. The FBR performance was evaluated at various ORP setpoints ranging between -520 mV and -240 mV (vs. Ag/AgCl). Results suggested that both nitrate and selenate were completely removed at ORPs between -520 mV and -360 mV, with methylseleninic acid, selenocyanate, selenosulfate and ammonia being produced at low ORPs between -520 mV and -480 mV, likely due to overdosing of ethanol. At ORPs between -300 mV and -240 mV, limited ethanol dosing resulted in an apparent decline in selenate removal whereas nitrate removal remained stable. Resuming the ORP to -520 mV successfully restored complete selenate reduction. An optimal ORP of -400 mV was identified for the FBR, whereby selenate and nitrate were nearly completely removed with a minimal ethanol consumption. Overall, controlling ORP via feedback-dosing of the electron donor was an effective strategy to optimize FBR performance for reducing selenate and nitrate in wastewater.

Microbial consortia capable of reducing selenate in the presence of nitrate enriched from coalmining-impacted environments

Biological treatment to remove dissolved selenium from mine-impacted water is often inhibited by the co-contaminant nitrate. In this work, we enriched microbial consortia capable of removing dissolved selenium in the presence of nitrate from native bacteria at sites influenced by coalmine seepages with elevated concentrations of Se, nitrate, and sulfate. Enrichments were collected from sediments in different vegetated or non-vegetated seepage collection ponds, and all demonstrated the potential for dissolved selenium removal. Nitrate inhibited dissolved selenium removal rates in four of these enrichments. However, microorganisms enriched from a mine seepage influenced natural vegetated marsh removed dissolved Se and nitrate simultaneously. Additionally, enrichments from one seepage collection pond achieved enhanced dissolved selenium removal in the presence of nitrate. Based on functional metagenomics, the dominant species with the metabolic capacity for selenate reduction were classified in Orders Enterobacterales and Clostridiales. Most putative selenate reductases identified as either ygfK, associated with selenoprotein synthesis or production of methylated organoselenium compounds, and narG, nitrate reductases with an affinity also for selenate.Key points• Enriched mine influenced sediment bacteria have the capacity for removal of dissolved Se species.• Consortia from a vegetated natural marsh reduced Se without inhibition from nitrate.• Nitrate stimulated the removal of Se by consortia from a disused tailing pond.