Exploring applicability of end member mixing approach for predicting environmental reactivity of dissolved organic matter

Quantitative source tracking for organic foulants in ultrafiltration membrane using stable isotope probing approach

Quantitatively identifying the primary sources of organic membrane fouling is essential for the effective implementation of membrane technology and optimal water resource management prior to the treatment. This study leveraged carbon stable isotope tracers to estimate the quantitative contributions of various organic sources to membrane fouling in an ultrafiltration system. Effluent organic matter (EfOM) and aquatic natural organic matter (NOM), two common sources, were combined in five different proportions to evaluate their mixed effects on flux decline and the consequent fouling behaviors. Generally, biopolymer (BP) and low molecular weight neutral (LMWN) size fractions - abundantly present in EfOM - were identified as significant contributors to reversible and irreversible fouling, respectively. Fluorescence spectroscopy disclosed that a protein-like component notably influenced overall membrane fouling, whereas humic-like components were predominantly responsible for irreversible fouling rather than reversible fouling. Fluorescence index (FI) and biological index (BIX), common fluorescence source tracers, showed promise in determining the source contribution for reversible foulants. However, these optical indices were insufficient in accurately determining individual source contributions to irreversible fouling, resulting in inconsistencies with the observed hydraulic analysis. Conversely, applying a carbon stable isotope-based mixing model yielded reasonable estimates for all membrane fouling. The contribution of EfOM surpassed 60 % for reversible fouling and increased with its content in DOM source mixtures. In contrast, aquatic NOM dominated irreversible fouling, contributing over 85 %, regardless of the source mixing ratios. This study emphasizes the potential of stable isotope techniques in accurately estimating the contributions of different organic matter sources to both reversible and irreversible membrane fouling.

Novel insights into source apportionment of dissolved organic matter in aquifer affected by anthropogenic groundwater recharge: Applicability of end-member mixing analysis based optical indices

The composition and main sources of dissolved organic matter (DOM) in groundwater may change significantly under long-term anthropogenic groundwater recharge (AGR); however, the impact of AGR on quantitative sources of groundwater DOM has seldom been reported. This study evaluated the applicability of optical indices combined with mixing stable isotope analysis in R (MixSIAR) in end-member mixing analysis (EMMA) of groundwater DOM. Fluorescent indices, including C1%, C2%, and C3%, were more sensitive to AGR than other absorbance indices, as indicated by the significant difference between the dominant area of artificial groundwater recharged by surface water and the dominant area of natural groundwater recharged by atmospheric precipitation (NGRP). BIX-C1% was selected as the optimal dual index after the screening protocol of groundwater DOM for EMMA. Our results showed that DOM in the aquifer was mainly subject to autochthonous DOM and the contribution of background groundwater to AGRSW and NGRP groundwater accounted for 36.15% ± 32.41% and 55.46% ± 37.17% (p < 0.05), respectively. Therefore, AGR significantly changed the native DOM in the groundwater. In allochthonous sources of DOM, sewage and surface water contributed 29.54% ± 24.87% and 21.32% ± 28.08%, and 24.79% ± 15.56% and 15.21% ± 14.20% to AGRSW and NGRP groundwater, respectively. The contribution of surface water to AGRSW groundwater was significantly higher than that to NGRP groundwater (p < 0.05), indicating that AGR introduced significantly more DOM from surface water to groundwater. This study provides novel insights into the quantitative source apportionment of DOM in groundwater under long-term AGR, which will facilitate the environmental risk assessment of present AGR measures and the sustainable management of clean water.

Innovative approach to reveal source contribution of dissolved organic matter in a complex river watershed using end-member mixing analysis based on spectroscopic proxies and multi-isotopes

Dissolved organic matter (DOM) in river watersheds dynamically changes based on its source during a monsoon period with storm event. However, the variations in DOM in urban and rural river watersheds that are dominated by point and non-point sources have not been adequately explored to date. We developed an innovative approach to reveal DOM sources in complex river watershed systems during pre-monsoon, monsoon, and post-monsoon periods using end-member mixing analysis (EMMA) by combining multi-isotope values (δ¹³C-DOC, δ¹⁵N-NO₃ and δ¹⁸O-NO₃) and spectroscopic indices (fluorescence index [FI], biological index [BIX], humification index [HIX], and specific UV absorbance [SUVA]). Several potential end-members of DOM sources were collected from watersheds, including top-soils, groundwater, plant group (fallen leaves, riparian plants, suspended algae), and different effluents (cattle and pig livestock, agricultural land, urban, industry facility, swine treatment facility and wastewater treatment facility). Concentrations of dissolved organic carbon, dissolved organic nitrogen, NO₃-N, and NH₄-N increased during the monsoon period with an increase in the input of anthropogenic DOM, which have higher HIX values owing to the flushing effect. The results of EMMA indicate that soil and agricultural effluents accounted for a substantial contribution of anthropogenic DOM at varying rates based on seasons. We also found that results of EMMA based on combining spectroscopic indices and δ¹³C-DOC isotope values were more accurate in tracing DOM sources with respect to land-use characteristics compared to applying only spectroscopic indices. The positive relationship between FI, BIX and δ¹⁵N-NO₃ were revealed that nitrate would be decomposed from DOM affected by intensive agricultural activities. In addition, consistent with the EMMA results, the molecular composition of the DOM was clearly evidenced by a large number of CHON formulas, accounting for over 50% of the total characterized compounds, including pesticides and pharmaceuticals used in agriculture farmland and livestock. Our results clearly demonstrated that EMMA based on combing multi-stable isotopes and spectroscopic indices could be trace the DOM source, which is important for understanding changes in the DOM quality, and application of nitrate isotopes and molecular analysis supports in-depth interpretation. This study provides easy and intuitive techniques for the estimation of the relative impacts of DOM sources in complex river watersheds, which can be verified in various ways rather than relying on a single technique approach.