Enhanced forensic DNA recovery with appropriate swabs and optimized swabbing technique

From dactyloscopy to the Minimum Surface Requirement (MSR): a metric to assess and obtain suitable human STR profiles

Friction skin ridge (Dactyloscopy) and DNA analyses have both played an essential role in forensic investigations for decades. The simultaneous and successful collection of a latent fingermark ridge pattern and the respective isolation of its human DNA can be a challenging task at a crime scene. Maximizing the quantity and quality of genetic information from this type of physical evidence has become one of the objectives of forensic science. Often, friction ridge impressions may lack discriminatory power due to low visual clarity of ridges and/or insufficient pattern area. In such cases, an optimized human DNA collection and extraction becomes crucial for obtaining a genetic identity from an unsuitable fingermark. Recent studies have proven that complete Short Tandem Repeat (STR) profiles can be acquired from touch DNA specimens. Although the impact of fingermark enhancement techniques on DNA recovery has been explored, no research has yet investigated the potential quantity of DNA that could be isolated per area of a ridge pattern. Here, DNA collection and extraction methods to determine the Minimum ridge Surface Requirement (MSR) to extract suitable human STR genotypes have been studied and optimized. Twelve participants, including biological males and females, provided ink prints of their index, middle, and ring fingers from both hands to calculate an average fingertip size to create a "standard" area for analysis across all donors. A standardized cutout template was created to fit every participant's latent fingermarks on pre-cleaned glass surfaces. Two fingermark "recharging-deposition-collecting" methods (i.e., Original Experiment and Optimized Experiment) and two swab types for DNA collection were compared (i.e., cotton swabs from Delta Lab (Spain) and 4N6FLOQSwabs® from Copan (Italy)). Then, ten participants deposited fingermarks for DNA extraction, quantification, STR amplification, and capillary electrophoresis (CE) for STR genotyping. Results showed that flocked swabs were more effective than cotton swabs at collecting DNA and produced suitable STR profiles with the optimized collection method. This research establishes the first MSR surfaces from which meaningful STR profiles can be acquired. These data provide key knowledge that assists crime investigators in prioritizing dactyloscopy, genotyping, or both analyses concurrently when examining latent fingermarks.

Blown spun fibers-based colorimetric sensor for detecting trace zinc in seminal fluid

Rapid and accurate analysis of zinc in seminal fluid is an important tool for male infertility diagnosis and forensic investigation of sexual assault. Among the traditional techniques employed for this purpose, colorimetric solid-state sensors offer a simple and efficient alternative for screening this analyte. Herein, we evaluated the feasibility of using solution blow spinning as a fast, simple, and cost-effective method to develop porous membranes that can be manufactured as low-cost colorimetric solid-state sensing materials. Specifically, we report a one-step approach to prepare blown spun polylactic acid (PLA)/poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) fibrous membranes modified with 1-(2-pyridylazo)-2-naphthol (PAN) for the quantitative and qualitative screening of Zn2+ in human seminal fluid. The fibrous membranes were fully characterized and then used to prepare discs and swabs. By digital image colorimetry, a spot-like assay was established using PLA/PEO@PAN membrane discs, which under optimized conditions, exhibited a linear range of up to 15 mg L-1, a limit of detection of 0.06 mg L-1 and high selectivity in the presence of several interfering species commonly found in seminal fluid. Additionally, the sensor was successfully applied in the detection of Zn2+ in human semen samples, showing no significant differences compared to the standard method. Furthermore, PLA/PEO@PAN swabs were employed in a naked-eye presumptive test to identify semen stains, showing satisfactory visual response even in the presence of only 0.11 μg of zinc. Moreover, the swabs' color changes were highly unambiguous, revealing a concordance rate of almost 90% in a blind study. This outstanding performance can be ascribed to the high porosity and wettability of the fibrous membrane and the PAN's coordination ability towards Zn2+. Overall, the remarkable advantages achieved with our approach lie in the easy production, on-site, and cost-effective analysis of zinc as a biomarker for clinical and forensic applications.

Shedding more light on shedders

We report on testing 100 individuals for their shedder status with the aim of demonstrating whether the process of cell staining is reproducible when testing a large number of people. A previous report using the same method was based on 11 donors and indicated that there may be a continuum of shedder types within this small sample set. In this report we also expand the time points post-handwashing to 0, 15, 30, 60, and 180 min. Triplicate samples were collected from both the right and left thumbs. Samples were collected by donors placing a thumb on a clean glass slide and then adding a DNA binding dye. The number of cells were recorded within three separate square millimetre areas (cells/mm2) at 220x magnification. The experiments were conducted in triplicate on three different days, giving a total of 72 thumbprints per individual. Finally, there were 3438 observed frames in the entire dataset. Of the 100 donors, 98 gave consistent and reproducible cell number deposition. There was no difference between the cells deposited by the left and right thumbs in 13 of 15 tested. Males tended to deposit more cells than females. If applying arbitrary boundary to a cell count to definitively determine shedder status, then many of the donors fell within two categories. This study based on 100 individuals strongly suggests that shedder status is a continuum phenomenon.

Impact of swabbing solutions on the recovery of biological material from non-porous surfaces

Cotton swabs are one of the most effective methods of retrieving biological evidence. The efficiency of swab-based DNA recovery is impacted by many factors, such as the swabbing technique, source of DNA and volume and type of wetting solution used to moisten the swab head. This study aimed to evaluate a series of different swab-moistening solutions. The types of swabbing solutions included buffers, detergent-based solutions, and chelating agents. The DNA deposits, including cell-free DNA, cellular DNA, blood, and saliva, were collected from three non-porous surfaces: plastic, glass, and metal. The difference in the performance of the swab-wetting solutions was heavily influenced by the type of biological fluid, with the chelating agents, EGTA and EDTA, being the most suitable for recovering DNA from saliva and blood samples. Conversely, water and detergent-based solutions were more appropriate for cell-free and cellular DNA material likely to be found in trace DNA deposits.

DNA recovery after sequential processing of latent fingerprints on black polyethylene plastic

Latent fingerprints on plastic substrates can be visualized by using sequential treatments to enhance the contrast between the fingerprint residues and underlying substrate; however, the extent to which these processes affect subsequent DNA analysis is mostly unknown. Latent fingerprints deposited on black plastic by one donor were visualized with single-process fingerprint powders (i.e., white powder, bichromatic powder, or bichromatic magnetic powder) or sequential treatments (i.e., laser → reflected ultraviolet imaging system (RUVIS) → CA fuming → RUVIS → Rhodamine 6G, Ardrox, and MBD (RAM) or CA fuming → RAM/laser → bichromatic magnetic powder). Samples were examined after the addition of each treatment. DNA was collected using cotton swabs, extracted, quantified, and amplified. DNA yields, peak heights, number of alleles obtained, and percentage of DNA profiles eligible for CODIS upload were examined. Latent fingerprints processed with the laser and up to three sequential treatments generated DNA profiles with significantly higher peaks heights than those of the untreated samples. Fingerprints processed with the laser and up to two sequential treatments generated DNA profiles with significantly more alleles. All methods beginning with laser enhancement generated more CODIS-eligible profiles. Additional research is needed to determine the extent to which initial laser enhancement impacts the success of downstream DNA profiling results. Although DNA profile development is not guaranteed due to the variable quantities of DNA contained within latent fingerprints, the selection of an appropriate latent fingerprint visualization method could maximize both fingerprint detection and the generation of CODIS-eligible DNA profiles.

Cell counting to monitor swab efficiency

Plastic bags, such as ziplock bags, have been used to transport illicit materials worldwide; however, very few studies have tried to optimize the recovery of DNA from these items. This study reports on the best combination of swabs and moistening solution for the greatest recovery of cellular material from ziplock bags. Five swabs, two different variations of Copan Diagnostics nylon 4N6FLOQSwabs, one Medical Wire rayon DRYSWAB, one IsoHelix rayon swab, and one Livingstone cotton swab, were evaluated with two moistening solutions, Triton X-100 in either distilled water or isopropanol. Fingermarks were deposited on ziplock bags and stained with Diamond™ Nucleic Acid Dye to allow visualization of the cells pre- and post-swabbing to determine the number of cells recovered. Based on cell counting data, swabs moistened with Triton X-100 in distilled water performed better than those moistened with isopropanol. Livingstone cotton swabs had the worst recovery of cellular material, while the other swabs tested had no significant difference in their respective solutions. A comparison of the best three swabs for cellular recovery yielded no differences in the DNA concentration extracted. A linear relationship was observed between the log number of cells recovered by swabbing and the DNA concentration following extraction and quantification. The process of monitoring cell collection using fluorescence microscopy on ziplock bags allowed evaluation of swabbing efficacy. Additionally, this study highlights the ability to evaluate cellular recovery independently of traditional extraction, quantification, or profiling techniques which may unequally affect samples.

The impact of substrate characteristics on the collection and persistence of biological materials, and their implications for forensic casework

This study assessed the level of nucleic acid persistence on the substrate pre-, and post-swabbing, in order to assess whether biological materials (touch, saliva, semen, and blood) are collected differently depending on the substrate characteristics. A total of 48 samples per deposit and substrate variety (n = 384) were assessed by tracking the persistence of nucleic acid using Diamond™ Nucleic Acid Dye (DD) staining and Polilight photography. The number of DD nucleic acid fluorescent complexes formed post-staining were counted (fluorescent count) and in conjunction with the fluorescence signal intensity (DD nucleic acid complex accumulation) used to estimate the level of nucleic acid persistence on substrates. Touch deposits have shown to be the most persistent deposit with strong adhesion capabilities on both substrate verities. Saliva displayed a higher persistence than semen and/or blood. Semen displayed a high collection efficiency as well as a high fluorescence signal intensity. Blood displayed a low persistence on both substrates with a superior collection efficiency that may also indicate a higher probability to become dislodged from surfaces given a particular activity. Our research has shown that the persistence and recovery of biological deposits is not only measurable but more importantly, may have the potential to be estimated, as such, may build an understanding that can provide valuable guidance for collection efficiency evaluations, and the assessing of the probability of particular profiles, given alternate propositions of means of transfer occurring.

Assessing the consistency of shedder status under various experimental conditions

Shedder status is defined as the propensity of an individual to leave DNA behind on touched items or surfaces and has been suggested as one of the major factors influencing DNA transfer. However, little is known about whether shedder status is a constant property of an individual across multiple measurements or when the environmental conditions are changed. We have assessed DNA depositions of six males on 20 occasions to acquire a reference data set and to classify the participants into high, intermediate, or low shedders. This data set was also used to investigate how the probability of a correct shedder status classification changed when the number of DNA deposition measurements increased. Individual sweat rates were measured with a VapoMeter and data regarding hygiene routines were collected through a questionnaire on each sampling occasion. Next, we investigated how changes in the experimental conditions such as seasonal variation, hygiene routines, the temperature of the touched object, and repeated handling of an object influenced the DNA shedding. Additionally, we assessed DNA collected from the face and from T-shirts worn by the six participants to explore whether shedder status may be associated with the relative amount of DNA obtained from other body parts. Our results indicate that shedder status is a stable property across different seasons and different temperatures of handled objects. The relative DNA amounts obtained from repeatedly handled tubes, worn T-shirts, and from faces reflected the shedder status of the participants. We suggest that an individual's shedder status is highly influenced by the DNA levels on other body parts than hands, accumulating on the palms by frequently touching e.g., the face or previously handled items harboring self-DNA. Assessing physiological differences between the participants revealed that there were no associations between DNA shedding and individual sweat rates.

Comparison of swabbing and cutting-out DNA collection methods from cotton, paper, and cardboard surfaces

Choosing an inappropriate method of sample collection can often have a detrimental impact on DNA recovery. Multiple studies highlight the importance of selecting the recovery method based on the type of surface the DNA sample is located on. This study aimed to investigate the efficacy of sample collection via the single cotton swabbing method in comparison to recovery directly from the material cut from the surface. The three types of surfaces included cotton, paper, and cardboard. DNA sources comprised cell-free and cellular DNA, as well as blood and saliva as examples of body fluids commonly encountered at crime scenes. The data analysis revealed that the cutting-out method resulted in higher DNA recovery from all but cardboard surfaces, making it the more efficient collection method. Despite its limitations, the cutting-out method should be considered as the DNA recovery method of choice when suitable.

Effect of swabbing technique and duration on forensic DNA recovery

Various factors have been shown to affect performance of the conventional wet-dry double and single wet swabbing techniques to recover DNA, such as pressure and angle of application, volume and type of wetting agent, and swab type. However, casework laboratories in some jurisdictions have recently adopted different swabbing techniques that include wet-moist double swabbing and moist-dry single swabbing. Factors affecting the effectiveness of these recent techniques in maximising DNA recovery therefore need to be investigated. Here, the performance of traditional and recent swabbing techniques was compared and the impact of swabbing duration on DNA recovery was investigated. Ten µl aliquots of a known concentration of DNA extracted from human blood were deposited on pre-cleaned DNA-free cotton swatches (porous) and porcelain tiles (non-porous). Five swabbing techniques were used, of which three were double swabbing techniques: wet-moist, wet-wet and wet-dry, and two were single swabbing techniques: wet and moist-dry. For a 'wet' or 'moist' swab, 100 or 50 µL water was added, respectively. For a moist-dry swab, water was applied to one side of the swab, leaving the other side drier. Each swabbing technique was applied for two durations, 15 and 30 s per swab, with 5 reps of each combination (n = 100 plus controls). All samples were extracted and quantified, and a sub-set was profiled. The results showed that the wet-moist double swabbing technique with a swabbing duration of 30 s maximised DNA recovery from cotton. From tile, a single wet or moist-dry swab maximised DNA recovery, but increasing swabbing duration from 15 to 30 s had no impact. These data can be used to inform standardisation of DNA collection protocols across casework laboratories.

The DNA-Buster: The evaluation of an alternative DNA recovery approach

Touch DNA recovery techniques can have limitations, as their effectiveness depends on the substrate on which the DNA of a person of interest can be found. In this study, an in-house dry-vacuuming device, the DNA-Buster, was compared to traditional methods for its DNA recovery performance from items typically examined in forensic casework. The aim was to evaluate whether this dry-vacuuming approach can recover DNA efficiently, potentially complementing the well-established recovery strategies. For this, the performances of swabbing, taping, wet- (M-Vac®) and dry-vacuuming (DNA-Buster) were investigated quantitatively and qualitatively for touch DNA deposited on carpet, cotton sweater, stone, tile and wood. For the sweater, both vacuuming methods outperformed the other collection tools quantitatively. While the highest DNA amounts for the carpet were yielded by swabbing and taping, dry-vacuuming was equally good in reaching full DNA profiles, whereas less complete profiles were observed for the M-Vac®. For stone and tile, swabbing was optimal, whereas dry-vacuuming clearly underperformed for these substrates. Taping was the best recovery method for wood. Despite applying single donor DNA after thoroughly cleaning the items, undesired DNA mixtures were detected for all recovery techniques and all substrates. The overall research findings show first that the novel dry-vacuuming method is suited for DNA recovery from textiles. Secondly, they indicate that more attention should be paid to the substrate-collection dependency to ensure best practices in recovering genetic material in a precise, confident and targeted manner from the variety of forensic casework material.

The Perfect Match: Assessment of Sample Collection Efficiency for Immunological and Molecular Findings in Different Types of Fabrics

Body fluid identification at crime scenes can be crucial in retrieving the appropriate evidence that leads to the perpetrator and, in some cases, the victim. For this purpose, immunochromatographic tests are simple, fast and suitable for crime scenes. The potential sample is retrieved with a swab, normally a cotton swab, moistened in a specific buffer. Nonetheless, there are other swab types available, which have been proven to be efficient for DNA isolation and analysis. The aim of this study is to evaluate the efficiency of different swab types for body fluid identification as well as DNA isolation and characterization. Fifty microliters of human saliva were deposited in three different types of fabric (denim, cotton, and polyester). After 24 h at room temperature, samples were recovered by applying three different swab types, and the tests were performed. Subsequently, total DNA was recovered from the sample buffer. Cotton swabs performed worse in denim and cotton fabrics in both immunochromatography tests and DNA yield. No differences were observed for polyester. In contrast, and except for two replicates, it was possible to obtain a full DNA profile per fabric and swab type, and to identify the mtDNA haplogroup. In this paper, the impact of swab types on body fluid identification through the application of immunochromatographic tests is analyzed for the first time. This work corroborates previous research related to the influence of swab types in nuclear DNA isolation and characterization.

Calcium-Alginate Tissue Gels (CATG): Proof-of-concept biomaterial development

Hydrogels are desirable materials to the field of forensic science and offer many advantages for use as tissue simulants in research and training scenarios. In this work, we demonstrate a proof-of-concept study for our biomaterial described as the Calcium-Alginate Tissue Gel (CATG). CATG biomaterials integrate functional DNA strands designed to amplify with known human primer sets for genetic profiling. Our range of CATG materials demonstrate successful DNA extraction, PCR amplification and genotyping when both fresh and aged for 21 days. The rheological properties of the CATGs were measured and the incorporation of DNA into the CATGs was assessed. Overall, the CATGs demonstrated increased viscoelastic behavior with the addition of DNA. In addition, two methods of sampling were considered, where it was found that cutting a sample of the dried CATG produced higher allele peak heights in the genotype compared to swabbing. Overall, our CATG biomaterials can be designed for multiple applications in forensic science with tunable properties for various training and research needs.