Combination of high pressure and heat on the gelation of chicken myofibrillar proteins

Effects of ultrahigh pressure heat-assisted technology on the physicochemical and gelling properties of myofibrillar protein from Penaeus vannamei

This study investigated the changes in conformation and gelling properties of myofibrillar protein (MP) from Penaeus vannamei under various ultrahigh pressure (UHP)-heat assisted technologies. The results indicated that UHP heat-assisted technology enhanced the cross-linking of the gel network by causing a rearrangement of the secondary structure of MP. Microstructural analysis revealed that MP gels treated with UHP heat-assisted technology exhibited a more uniform gel network structure. Additionally, UHP heat-assisted technology improved the binding capacity of water molecules within the gel network, particularly in the two-stage UHP heat-assisted (PBH) condition at 400 MPa. Gels prepared under this condition demonstrated the highest gel strength, measuring 386.4 g·mm. Furthermore, in vitro simulated digestion showed that PBH method significantly improved the digestibility of MP gels, suggesting that the UHP heat-assisted technology had the potential to produce easily digestible MP gel-based aquatic foods.

Effect of different cooking conditions on the quality characteristics of chicken claws

Chicken claw products with their unique texture are loved by consumers, and cooking is a key step to affect the taste of chicken claw consumption, through the moderate hydrolysis of proteins and a series of physicochemical changes, so that the chicken claw gets tender and presents a crispy taste, but the current research on the optimal cooking conditions for chicken claw is still relatively small. In the present work, combinations of time (11, 13, 15, 17, and 19 min) and temperature (82, 86, 90, 94, and 98°C) were applied to the cooking of chicken claws. The effects of different cooking conditions on the quality characteristics of chicken claws were investigated, with special emphasis on the cooking loss rate, color, texture properties, lipid oxidation, myofibrillar fragmentation index (MFI), and total sulfhydryl content. The results showed that the cooking loss rate, lipid oxidation, and MFI value of chicken claws gradually increased, and the total color difference (∆E), puncture force, shear force, and total sulfhydryl content gradually decreased with the increase of cooking temperature and cooking time. Overall, chicken claws cooked at 86, 90, and 94°C for 15 and 17 min had better texture and flavor.

Influence of heat treatment before and/or after high-pressure homogenization on the structure and emulsification properties of soybean protein isolate

This study investigates the effects of heat treatment before high-pressure homogenization (HHPH) and heat treatment after high-pressure homogenization (HPHH) at different pressures (20, 60, and 100 MPa) on the structural and emulsification properties of soy protein isolate (SPI). The results indicate that HHPH treatment increases the surface hydrophobicity (H0) of the SPI, reduces β-fold and irregular curls, leading to the formation of soluble aggregates, increased adsorbed protein content, and subsequent improvements in emulsification activity index (EAI) and emulsion stability index (ESI). In contrast, the HPHH treatment promoted the exchange of SH/SS bonds between protein molecules and facilitated the interaction of basic peptides and β-subunits, leading to larger particle sizes of the soluble aggregates compared to the HHPH-treated samples. However, excessive aggregation in HPHH-treated aggregates leads to decreased H0 and adsorbed protein content, and increased interfacial tension, negatively affecting the emulsification properties. Compared to the HPHH treatment, HHPH treatment at homogenization pressures of 20 to 100 MPa increases EAI and ESI by 5.81-29.6 % and 5.31-25.9 %, respectively. These findings provide a fundamental basis for soybean protein manufacturers to employ appropriate processing procedures aimed at improving emulsification properties.

Effect of Transglutaminase Treatment on the Structure and Sensory Properties of Rice- or Soy-Based Hybrid Sausages

Partial substitution of meat with non-protein sources in hybrid meat products generally leads to a decrease in texture attributes and, consequently, in sensory acceptance. In this study, we investigated the effects of transglutaminase (TG) at two concentrations (0.25% and 0.5%) on the physicochemical, textural, and sensory properties of hybrid sausages formulated with concentrated soy or rice proteins. TG caused a reduction in the heat treatment yield of hybrid sausages, particularly those made with rice protein. pH and color parameters were marginally affected by TG addition. Texture parameters increased substantially with TG, although escalating the TG level from 0.25% to 0.5% did not result in a proportional improvement in texture parameters; in fact, for rice-based hybrid sausages, no difference was achieved for all attributes, while only cohesiveness and chewiness were improved for soy-based ones. TG enhanced the sensory attributes of soy-based hybrid sausages to a level comparable to control meat emulsion, as evidenced by ordinate preference score and projective mapping. Our findings suggest that TG is a viable strategy for enhancing texture and sensory parameters in hybrid sausages, particularly for plant proteins that exhibit greater compatibility with the meat matrix.

Influence of Multi-Frequency Ultrasound Treatment on Conformational Characteristics of Beef Myofibrillar Proteins with Different Degrees of Doneness

This study evaluated the effect of multi-frequency sonication (20 kHz, 25 kHz, 28 kHz, 40 kHz, 50 kHz) on structural characteristics of beef myofibrillar proteins (MPs) with different degrees of doneness (Rare 52~55 °C, Medium Rare 55~60 °C, Medium 60~65 °C, Medium Well 65~69 °C, Well Down 70~80 °C, and Overcooked 90 °C). The results showed that surface hydrophobicity and sulfhydryl content increased with the increase in degree of doneness. At the same degree of doneness, the sulfhydryl group contents reached the maximum at a frequency of 28 kHz. In addition, the absolute value of ζ-potential was significantly decreased after ultrasonic treatment (p < 0.05). SDS gel electrophoresis showed that the bands of beef MPs were not significantly affected by various ultrasonic frequencies, but the bands became thinner when the degree of doneness reached overcooked. Fourier transform infrared spectrum showed that with the increase of ultrasonic frequency, α-helix content decreased, and random coil content significantly increased (p < 0.05). The results of atomic force microscopy indicated that the surface structure of beef MPs was damaged, and the roughness decreased by sonication, while the roughness significantly increased when the degree of doneness changed from medium to overripe (p < 0.05). In conclusion, multi-ultrasound combined with degree of doneness treatment alters the structural characteristics of beef MPs.

Yam Bean (Pachyrhizus erosus L. Urban) Powder Improves Grass Carp Myofibrillar Protein Gel by Forming Disulfide Bonds, Hydrogen Bonds, and Proper Microstructure

This study aimed to analyze the impact of different additions (0-1.25%) of yam bean powder (YBP) on myofibrillar protein (MP) gel characteristics such as the structure, water-holding capacity (WHC), chemical interaction strength of grass carp MP, and texture. The results showed that the YBP exhibited a strong water absorption capacity and filled in the protein heat-induced polymerization gel network well, which enabled the gel network to capture and retain water effectively, resulting in MP gels containing YBP with excellent WHC and gel strength (0.75%). In addition, YBP induced the formation of hydrogen and disulfide bonds in proteins and inhibited the conversion of α-helices to β-sheets and β-turn structures, facilitating the formation of high-strength gel networks (p < 0.05). In conclusion, YBP can significantly improve the thermally induced gelling properties of grass carp MP. In particular, the addition of 0.75% YBP had the best effect in terms of filling the gel network of grass carp MP, resulting in the formation of a continuous and dense protein network, leading to the composite gel with the best WHC and texture.

Combined Effects of Cold and Hot Air Drying on Physicochemical Properties of Semi-Dried Takifugu obscurus Fillets

The physicochemical properties of semi-dried Takifugu obscurus fillets in cold air drying (CAD), hot air drying (HAD), and cold and hot air combined drying (CHACD) were analyzed based on pH, water state, lipid oxidation, protein degradation, and microstructure, using a texture analyzer, low-field nuclear magnetic resonance, thiobarbituric acid, frozen sections, sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and differential scanning calorimetry. Water binding to the samples was enhanced by all three drying methods, and the immobilized water content of CHACD was between that of HAD and CAD. The pH of the semi-dried fillets was improved by CHACD. When compared to HAD and CAD, CHACD improved the springiness and chewiness of the fillets, especially cold air drying for 90 min (CAD-90), with values of 0.97 and 59.79 g, respectively. The muscle fibers were arranged compactly and clearly in CAD-90, having higher muscle toughness. CHACD reduced the drying time and degree of lipid oxidation compared to HAD and CAD. CAD better preserved protein composition, whereas HAD and CHACD promoted actin production; CHACD had a higher protein denaturation temperature (74.08-74.57 °C). CHACD results in better physicochemical properties than HAD or CAD, including shortened drying time, reduced lipid oxidation, enhanced protein stability, and denser tissue structure. These results provide a theoretical basis for selecting the appropriate drying method for T. obscurus in industrial applications.

Ultrasound assisted treatment improves the preservation performance of chitosan-grafted-chlorogenic acid on refrigerated sea bass (Lateolabrax japonicus) fillets

BACKGROUND

Ultrasound can increase the mass transfer between preservatives and food, and enhances the effect of preservatives on food. Chitosan-grafted-chlorogenic acid (CS-g-CA) is a new synthetic compound with good antiseptic properties. Therefore, the present study evaluated the preservation performance of ultrasound-assisted CS-g-CA (GUA) coatings on refrigerated sea bass fillets in terms of changes in microorganisms, lipids, proteins, tissue structures, and moisture.

RESULTS

The results showed that GUA treatment effectively inhibited the growth of microorganisms in sea bass fillets. Meanwhile, the changes in total volatile basal nitrogen, thiobarbituric acid reactive substances, and pH values were all slowed down under GUA treatment, indicating that protein degradation and lipid oxidation in sea bass were inhibited. Low-field nuclear magnetic resonance and magnetic resonance imaging results indicated that the GUA retarded the conversion of mobile water to free water. In addition, GUA treatment maintained the flavor quality of fish fillets, and also inhibited the reduction of inosine monophosphate and the production of bitter substances (inosine and hypoxanthine), suppressed muscle tissue degeneration, and maintained better sensory scores.

CONCLUSION

Overall, GUA treatment inhibited microbial growth, protein degradation, lipid oxidation, moisture migration, decomposition of umami substances, and deterioration of sensory quality in sea bass fillets. Finally, the shelf-life of sea bass fillets with GUA treatment was extended by an additional 9 days. The results showed that ultrasonic assistance further enhanced the effect of preservatives on aquatic products. © 2022 Society of Chemical Industry.

Effect of high hydrostatic pressure processing on the structure, functionality, and nutritional properties of food proteins: A review

Proteins are important food ingredients that possess both functional and nutritional properties. High hydrostatic pressure (HHP) is an emerging nonthermal food processing technology that has been subject to great advancements in the last two decades. It is well established that pressure can induce changes in protein folding and oligomerization, and consequently, HHP has the potential to modify the desired protein properties. In this review article, the research progress over the last 15 years regarding the effect of HHP on protein structures, as well as the applications of HHP in modifying protein functionalities (i.e., solubility, water/oil holding capacity, emulsification, foaming and gelation) and nutritional properties (i.e., digestibility and bioactivity) are systematically discussed. Protein unfolding generally occurs during HHP treatment, which can result in increased conformational flexibility and the exposure of interior residues. Through the optimization of HHP and environmental conditions, a balance in protein hydrophobicity and hydrophilicity may be obtained, and therefore, the desired protein functionality can be improved. Moreover, after HHP treatment, there might be greater accessibility of the interior residues to digestive enzymes or the altered conformation of specific active sites, which may lead to modified nutritional properties. However, the practical applications of HHP in developing functional protein ingredients are underutilized and require more research concerning the impact of other food components or additives during HHP treatment. Furthermore, possible negative impacts on nutritional properties of proteins and other compounds must be also considered.

Inhibitory effects of chitosan grafted chlorogenic acid on antioxidase activity, and lipid and protein oxidation of sea bass (Lateolabrax japonicus) fillets stored at 4 °C

BACKGROUND

Sea bass (Lateolabrax japonicus), a marine fish, is prone to spoilage due to its high nutritional value. Preservatives are commonly used for storage for the production of fish fillets. In this work, chitosan (CS) was grafted onto chlorogenic acid (CA) to obtain a new preservative, chitosan grafted chlorogenic acid (CS-g-CA), which could enhance the biochemical properties of chitosan and obtain better antibacterial and antibacterial properties. This study therefore investigated the inhibitory effects of CS-g-CA on antioxidant enzyme activity, and lipid and protein oxidation of sea bass fillets stored at 4 °C.

RESULTS

Compared with the control group on day 9, the activity of 63% catalase (CAT), 78% superoxide diamidase (SOD), 73% glutathione peroxide enzyme (GSH-Px) and 60% DPPH scavenging activity was retained by CS-g-CA treatment. Changes in thiobarbituric acid (TBA) and conjugated diene (CD) values were delayed by CS-g-CA treatment. The use of CS-g-CA retards protein oxidation by inhibiting the formation of free amino acid and carbonyl groups, and maintaining a higher sulfhydryl content. Regarding myofibril degradation, CS-g-CA could maintain protein secondary structure by increasing the ratio of α-helices.

CONCLUSIONS

Chitosan-grafted chlorogenic acid could protect the activity of antioxidant enzymes and inhibit lipid oxidation by slowing down the production of lipid oxidation products. It also delayed protein oxidation by inhibiting oxidation product generation and stabilizing protein structure. It could therefore be used as a promising preservative for seafood. © 2022 Society of Chemical Industry.

Valorization of Cattle Slaughtering Industry By-Products: Modification of the Functional Properties and Structural Characteristics of Cowhide Gelatin Induced by High Hydrostatic Pressure

This study investigates the effects of different pressures (200, 250, 300, 350, and 400 MPa) and durations (5, 10, 15, 20, and 25 min) on the functional properties, secondary structure, and intermolecular forces of cowhide gelatin. Our results show that high hydrostatic pressure significantly affected the two, three, and four-level structures of gelatin and caused the contents of the α-helix and β-turn to decrease by 68.86% and 78.58%, respectively (p < 0.05). In particular, the gelatin at 300 MPa for 15 min had the highest gel strength, emulsification, solubility, and foaming of all the treatment conditions under study. The analysis of the surface hydrophobicity, sulfhydryl content, zeta potential, and Raman spectroscopy shows that at a pressure of 300 MPa (15 min), the hydrogen bonds and hydrophobic interactions between collagen molecules are strongly destroyed, leading to changes in the tertiary and quaternary conformation of the protein and unfolding, with the electrostatic repulsion between protein particles making the decentralized state stable. In conclusion, moderate pressure and time can significantly improve the functional and structural properties of collagen, which provides theoretical support and guidance for realizing the high-value utilization of cowhide.

Characteristics and Mechanism of Crayfish Myofibril Protein Gel Deterioration Induced by Autoclaving

Crayfish myofibril protein (CMP) gel deterioration induced by autoclaving was investigated. A series of CMP gels were obtained through treating CMP solutions at different autoclaving conditions from 100 °C/0.1 MPa to 121 °C/0.21 MPa, and then characteristics and the mechanism of gel texture deterioration along with the intensification of autoclaving were explored through determining appearance, texture, protein composition, cross-linking forces, degree of hydrolysis, water state, microstructure of the gels, and average particle size of aggregates. When autoclaving was at above 105 °C/0.103 MPa, texture of CMP gel showed a tendency to severely weaken with the intensification of autoclaving (p < 0.05), hydrophobic interaction and aggregation between proteins weakened gradually (p < 0.05), and moderately bound water in the gel decreased and T22 relaxation time significantly increased (p < 0.05). After heating for 30 min at above 105 °C/0.103 MPa, pores in the microstructure of CMP gel enlarged obviously, and myosin heavy chain (MHC) degraded. It can be concluded that CMP gel deterioration induced by autoclaving was associated with the degradation of MHC and 105 °C might be the critical temperature to ensure good texture of crayfish products.

A systematic review of clean-label alternatives to synthetic additives in raw and processed meat with a special emphasis on high-pressure processing (2018-2021)

The meat industry is continuously facing challenges with food safety, and quality losses caused by thermal processing. This systematic review reports recent clean label approaches in high-pressure production of meat. A literature search was performed using Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed, and Springer databases for studies published in 2018-2021. In this regard, 69 articles were assessed out of 386 explored research articles in the identified stage. The findings indicate that most of the earlier work on high-pressure processing (HPP) focused on physicochemical and sensorial meat quality rather than providing nutritional aspects and clean-label solutions. However, few advanced studies report effective and innovative solutions to develop low salt/fat, and reduced nitrite for raw and cured meat products. HPP could help on increasing the shell life by five times in meat products; however, it depends on the formulation and packaging, etc. HPP can also preserve nutrients by using this non-thermal technology and reduce food waste as once the shelf life of products is known, it easily reduces the shrinkage in the marketplace. This review explores the latest trend of experimental research in high-pressure processing alone, or multi-hurdle techniques employed to increase the effect of clean-label ingredients for enhanced meat safety/quality.

Roles of Proteins/Enzymes from Animal Sources in Food Quality and Function

Animal proteins are good sources of protein for human, due to the composition of necessary amino acids. The quality of food depends significantly on the properties of protein inside, especially the gelation, transportation, and antimicrobial properties. Interestingly, various kinds of molecules co-exist with proteins in foodstuff, and the interactions between these can significantly affect the food quality. In food processing, these interactions have been used to improve the texture, color, taste, and shelf-life of animal food by affecting the gelation, antioxidation, and antimicrobial properties of proteins. Meanwhile, the binding properties of proteins contributed to the nutritional properties of food. In this review, proteins in meat, milk, eggs, and fishery products have been summarized, and polysaccharides, polyphenols, and other functional molecules have been applied during food processing to improve the nutritional and sensory quality of food. Specific interactions between functional molecules and proteins based on the crystal structures will be highlighted with an aim to improve the food quality in the future.

Redox Proteomic Analysis Reveals Microwave-Induced Oxidation Modifications of Myofibrillar Proteins from Silver Carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix)

To provide an insight into the oxidation behavior of cysteines in myofibrillar proteins (MPs) during microwave heating (MW), a quantitative redox proteomic analysis based on the isobaric iodoacetyl tandem mass tag technology was applied in this study. MPs from silver carp muscles were subjected to MW and water bath heating (WB) with the same time-temperature profiles to eliminate the thermal differences caused by an uneven energy input. Altogether, 422 proteins were found to be differentially expressed after thermal treatments as compared to that with no heat treatment. However, MW triggered a larger number of proteins and cysteine sites for oxidation. Myosin heavy chain, myosin-binding protein C, nebulin, α-actinin-3-like, and titin were found to be highly susceptible to oxidation under microwave irradiation. Notably, MW caused such modifications at cysteine site 9 in the head of myosin, revealing the enhancement mechanism of MP gelation by excess cysteine cross-linking during microwave processing. Furthermore, Gene Ontology and functional enrichment analyses suggested that the two thermal treatments resulted in some differences in ion binding, muscle cell development, and protein-containing complex assembly. Overall, this study is the first to report the redox proteomic changes caused by MW and WB treatments, thus providing a further understanding of the microwave-induced oxidative modifications of MPs.

Effects of High Hydrostatic Pressure on the Conformational Structure and Gel Properties of Myofibrillar Protein and Meat Quality: A Review

In meat processing, changes in the myofibrillar protein (MP) structure can affect the quality of meat products. High hydrostatic pressure (HHP) has been widely utilized to change the conformational structure (secondary, tertiary and quaternary structure) of MP so as to improve the quality of meat products. However, a systematic summary of the relationship between the conformational structure (secondary and tertiary structure) changes in MP, gel properties and product quality under HHP is lacking. Hence, this review provides a comprehensive summary of the changes in the conformational structure and gel properties of MP under HHP and discusses the mechanism based on previous studies and recent progress. The relationship between the spatial structure of MP and meat texture under HHP is also explored. Finally, we discuss considerations regarding ways to make HHP an effective strategy in future meat manufacturing.

Effect of micro- and nano-starch on the gel properties, microstructure and water mobility of myofibrillar protein from grass carp

This work evaluated the effect of micro- and nano-starch (MS and NS) on the gel properties of fish myofibrillar protein (MP). Both MS and NS could enhance MP gel performance in terms of breaking force, elasticity and water holding capacity (p < 0.05), with more significant effect from NS than MS. The difference between NS and MS in enhancement effect on MP gel is due to nano-size effect and different microstructures of MP/MS and MP/NS gels, with NS rather than MS contributing to the continuity of MP network. Synchrotron FTIR micro-spectroscopic images further verified that NS with large specific surface had good compatibility with MP, while MS was embedded in MP matrix with evident phase separation. Additionally, β-sheet still dominated the secondary structure of all gels, although adding both MS and NS could change molecular interactions, such as weakening ionic bonds and hydrogen bonds, and strengthening hydrophobic interactions.

Tracking aggregation behaviour and gel properties induced by structural alterations in myofibrillar protein in mirror carp (Cyprinus carpio) under the synergistic effects of pH and heating

The synergistic effect of pH and heating on the structure, aggregation behaviour and gel properties of myofibrillar protein (MP) in mirror carp (Cyprinus carpio) was evaluated. The surface hydrophobicity of the control at pH 5.0 (143.6 ± 0.3 μg) was significantly higher than that of other samples (P < 0.05). Under the same pH conditions, the decrease in total sulfhydryl content of all samples during the heating process demonstrated that covalent/non-covalent cross-linking occurred between proteins due to heat input. Moreover, the decrease in solubility and the increase in turbidity of all samples verified the fact of MP aggregation, and the changes in the elasticity index (EI) and macroscopic viscosity index (MVI) also indicated a decrease in MP fluidity upon heating treatment. Therefore, the aggregation of MP was affected by pH and heating, and the optimal three-dimensional network structure and gel properties could be formed at pH 6.0 and above 70 °C.

Effects of sodium hexametaphosphate, sodium tripolyphosphate and sodium pyrophosphate on the ultrastructure of beef myofibrillar proteins investigated with atomic force microscopy

Myofibrillar protein isolated from beef muscles were treated with 3 phosphates (Sodium Hexametaphosphate, sodium tripolyphosphate, sodium pyrophosphate) with different concentrations of 0.3%, 0.6%, 0.9%, 1.2% respectively. Protein solubility, surface hydrophobicity and reactive sulfhydryl group was determined. Atomic force microscopy was used to observe the microscopic protein surface. SDS-PAGE was carried out to determine the proteolysis of myofibrillar protein. The solubility and surface hydrophobic bond of myofibrillar protein was highly increased and the diameter decreased by SHMP, TSPP, STPP. Reactive sulfhydryl groups increased after SHMP addition, but slightly decreased in STPP and TSPP treated MP. TSPP and STPP had the same effect on myofibrillar microstructure and was different from SHMP. Three phosphates all caused MP unfolding. The MP gel complexity was increased, and roughness was decreased after phosphates addition, indicating phosphates helped to construct a more ordered and smoother gel microcosmic surface.

Applications of nonthermal plasma technology on safety and quality of dried food ingredients

Cold plasma technology is an efficient, environmental-friendly, economic and noninvasive technology; and in recent years these advantages placed this novel technology at the centre of diverse studies for food industry applications. Dried food ingredients including spices, herbs, powders and seeds are an important part of the human diet; and the growing demands of consumers for higher quality and safe food products have led to increased research into alternative decontamination methods. Numerous studies have investigated the effect of nonthermal plasma on dried food ingredients for food safety and quality purposes. This review provides critical review on potential of cold plasma for disinfection of dried food surfaces (spices, herbs and seeds), improvement of functional and rheological properties of dried ingredients (powders, proteins and starches). The review further highlights the benefits of plasma treatment for enhancement of seeds performance and germination yield which could be applied in agricultural sector in near future. Different studies applying plasma technology for control of pathogens and spoilage micro-organisms and modification of food quality and germination of dried food products followed by benefits and current challenges are presented. However, more systemic research needs to be addressed for successful adoption of this technology in food industry.

Effect of ultrasound thawing, vacuum thawing, and microwave thawing on gelling properties of protein from porcine longissimus dorsi

Effect of new thawing methods (ultrasound thawing (UT), vacuum thawing, (VT), microwave thawing (MT)) on gelling properties of myofibrillar protein (MP) from porcine longissimus dorsi was investigated, compared with traditional thawing methods (water immersion thawing, (WT)) and fresh meat (FM). The results showed that a decrease in MP gelling properties of all thawing samples was observed. The increase in roughness of MP gel from all thawing samples explained that the flatter, smoother, and denser surface morphology of that from FM samples was destroyed based on the observation by atomic force microscopy. There was significant difference (P < 0.05) in all gel indicators (particle size, turbidity, whiteness, water-holding capacity (WHC), moisture distribution, rheological characteristics, surface morphology) of MP from MT samples and there was insignificant difference (P > 0.05) in turbidity, whiteness, WHC of MP from VT samples compared with that from FM samples. There was insignificant difference (P > 0.05) in gel properties between UT and VT. The effect of UT and VT (new thawing methods) on MP gelling properties was significantly lower (P < 0.05) than that of WT (traditional thawing methods), and the effect of that from MT was obviously compared with other thawing methods.