Higher-order structure of nucleic acids in the gas phase: top-down analysis of base-pairing interactions

Analyzing RNA posttranscriptional modifications to decipher the epitranscriptomic code

The discovery of RNA silencing has revealed that non-protein-coding sequences (ncRNAs) can cover essential roles in regulatory networks and their malfunction may result in severe consequences on human health. These findings have prompted a general reassessment of the significance of RNA as a key player in cellular processes. This reassessment, however, will not be complete without a greater understanding of the distribution and function of the over 170 variants of the canonical ribonucleotides, which contribute to the breathtaking structural diversity of natural RNA. This review surveys the analytical approaches employed for the identification, characterization, and detection of RNA posttranscriptional modifications (rPTMs). The merits of analyzing individual units after exhaustive hydrolysis of the initial biopolymer are outlined together with those of identifying their position in the sequence of parent strands. Approaches based on next generation sequencing and mass spectrometry technologies are covered in depth to provide a comprehensive view of their respective merits. Deciphering the epitranscriptomic code will require not only mapping the location of rPTMs in the various classes of RNAs, but also assessing the variations of expression levels under different experimental conditions. The fact that no individual platform is currently capable of meeting all such demands implies that it will be essential to capitalize on complementary approaches to obtain the desired information. For this reason, the review strived to cover the broadest possible range of techniques to provide readers with the fundamental elements necessary to make informed choices and design the most effective possible strategy to accomplish the task at hand.

Integrating Internal Fragments in the Interpretation of Top-Down Sequencing Data of Larger Oligonucleotides

In the context of direct top-down analysis or concerted bottom-up characterization of nucleic acid samples, the waning yield of terminal fragments as a function of precursor ion size poses a significant challenge to the gas-phase sequencing of progressively larger oligonucleotides. In this report, we examined the behavior of oligoribonucleotide samples ranging from 20 to 364 nt upon collision-induced dissociation (CID). The experimental data showed a progressive shift from terminal to internal fragments as a function of size. The systematic evaluation of experimental factors, such as collision energy, precursor charge, sample temperature, and the presence of chaotropic agents, showed that this trend could be modestly alleviated but not suppressed. This inexorable effect, which has been reported also for other activation techniques, prompted a re-examination of the features that have traditionally discouraged the utilization of internal fragments as a source of sequence information in data interpretation procedures. Our simulations highlighted the ability of internal fragments to produce self-consistent ladders with either end corresponding to each nucleotide in the sequence, which enables both proper alignment and correct recognition of intervening nucleotides. In turn, contiguous ladders display extensive overlaps with one another and with the ladders formed by terminal fragments, which unambiguously constrain their mutual placement within the analyte sequence. The experimental data borne out the predictions by showing ladders with extensive overlaps, which translated into uninterrupted "walks" covering the entire sequence with no gaps from end to end. More significantly, the results showed that combining the information afforded by internal and terminal ladders resulted in much a greater sequence coverage and nucleotide coverage depth than those achievable when either type of information was considered separately. The examination of a series of 58-mer oligonucleotides with high sequence homology showed that the assignment ambiguities engendered by internal fragments did not significantly exceed those afforded by the terminal ones. Therefore, the balance between potential benefits and perils of including the former makes a compelling argument for the development of integrated data interpretation strategies, which are better equipped for dealing with the changing fragmentation patterns obtained from progressively larger oligonucleotides.

The multifaceted roles of mass spectrometric analysis in nucleic acids drug discovery and development

The deceptively simple concepts of mass determination and fragment analysis are the basis for the application of mass spectrometry (MS) to a boundless range of analytes, including fundamental components and polymeric forms of nucleic acids (NAs). This platform affords the intrinsic ability to observe first-hand the effects of NA-active drugs on the chemical structure, composition, and conformation of their targets, which might affect their ability to interact with cognate NAs, proteins, and other biomolecules present in a natural environment. The possibility of interfacing with high-performance separation techniques represents a multiplying factor that extends these capabilities to cover complex sample mixtures obtained from organisms that were exposed to NA-active drugs. This report provides a brief overview of these capabilities in the context of the analysis of the products of NA-drug activity and NA therapeutics. The selected examples offer proof-of-principle of the applicability of this platform to all phases of the journey undertaken by any successful NA drug from laboratory to bedside, and provide the rationale for its rapid expansion outside traditional laboratory settings in support to ever growing manufacturing operations.

Comparison of the fragmentation behavior of DNA and LNA single strands and duplexes

DNA and locked nucleic acid (LNA) were characterized as single strands, as well as double stranded DNA-DNA duplexes and DNA-LNA hybrids using tandem mass spectrometry with collision-induced dissociation. Additionally, ion mobility spectrometry was carried out on selected species. Oligonucleotide duplexes of different sequences-bearing mismatch positions and abasic sites of complementary DNA 15-mers-were investigated to unravel general trends in their stability in the gas phase. Single-stranded LNA oligonucleotides were also investigated with respect to their gas phase behavior and fragmentation upon collision-induced dissociation. In contrast to the collision-induced dissociation of DNA, almost no base loss was observed for LNAs. Here, backbone cleavages were the dominant dissociation pathways. This finding was further underlined by the need for higher activation energies. Base losses from the LNA strand were also absent in fragmentation experiments of the investigated DNA-LNA hybrid duplexes. While DNA-DNA duplexes dissociated easily into single stranded fragments, the high stability of DNA-LNA hybrids resulted in predominant fragmentation of the DNA part rather than the LNA, while base losses were only observed from the DNA single strand of the hybrid.

Modular calibrant sets for the structural analysis of nucleic acids by ion mobility spectrometry mass spectrometry

This study explored the use of modular nucleic acid (NA) standards to generate calibration curves capable of translating primary ion mobility readouts into corresponding collision cross section (CCS) data. Putative calibrants consisted of single- (ss) and double-stranded (ds) oligo-deoxynucleotides reaching up to ∼40 kDa in size (i.e., 64 bp) and ∼5700 Å(2) in CCS. To ensure self-consistency among reference CCS values, computational data obtained in house were preferred to any experimental or computational data from disparate sources. Such values were obtained by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and either the exact hard sphere scattering (EHSS) or the projection superposition approximation (PSA) methods, and then plotted against the corresponding experimental values to generate separate calibration curves. Their performance was evaluated on the basis of their correlation coefficients and ability to provide values that matched the CCS of selected test samples mimicking typical unknowns. The results indicated that the predictive power benefited from the exclusion of higher charged species that were more susceptible to the destabilizing effects of Coulombic repulsion. The results revealed discrepancies between EHSS and PSA data that were ascribable to the different approximations used to describe the ion mobility process. Within the boundaries defined by these approximations and the challenges of modeling NA structure in a solvent-free environment, the calibrant sets enabled the experimental determination of CCS with excellent reproducibility (precision) and error (accuracy), which will support the analysis of progressively larger NA samples of biological significance.

Bifunctional cross-linking approaches for mass spectrometry-based investigation of nucleic acids and protein-nucleic acid assemblies

With the goal of expanding the very limited toolkit of cross-linking agents available for nucleic acids and their protein complexes, we evaluated the merits of a wide range of bifunctional agents that may be capable of reacting with the functional groups characteristic of these types of biopolymers. The survey specifically focused on the ability of test reagents to produce desirable inter-molecular conjugates, which could reveal the identity of interacting components and the position of mutual contacts, while also considering a series of practical criteria for their utilization as viable nucleic acid probes. The survey employed models consisting of DNA, RNA, and corresponding protein complexes to mimic as close as possible typical applications. Denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) and mass spectrometric (MS) analyses were implemented in concert to monitor the formation of the desired conjugates. In particular, the former was used as a rapid and inexpensive tool for the efficient evaluation of cross-linker activity under a broad range of experimental conditions. The latter was applied after preliminary rounds of reaction optimization to enable full-fledged product characterization and, more significantly, differentiation between mono-functional and intra- versus inter-molecular conjugates. This information provided the feedback necessary to further optimize reaction conditions and explain possible outcomes. Among the reagents tested in the study, platinum complexes and nitrogen mustards manifested the most favorable characteristics for practical cross-linking applications, whereas other compounds provided inferior yields, or produced rather unstable conjugates that did not survive the selected analytical conditions. The observed outcomes will help guide the selection of the most appropriate cross-linking reagent for a specific task, whereas the experimental conditions described here will provide an excellent starting point for approaching these types of applications. As a whole, the results of the survey clearly emphasize that finding a universal reagent, which may afford excellent performance with all types of nucleic acid substrates, will require extending the exploration beyond the traditional chemistries employed to modify the constitutive functional groups of these vital biopolymers.

Characterization of nucleic acids by tandem mass spectrometry - The second decade (2004-2013): From DNA to RNA and modified sequences

Nucleic acids play key roles in the storage and processing of genetic information, as well as in the regulation of cellular processes. Consequently, they represent attractive targets for drugs against gene-related diseases. On the other hand, synthetic oligonucleotide analogues have found application as chemotherapeutic agents targeting cellular DNA and RNA. The development of effective nucleic acid-based chemotherapeutic strategies requires adequate analytical techniques capable of providing detailed information about the nucleotide sequences, the presence of structural modifications, the formation of higher-order structures, as well as the interaction of nucleic acids with other cellular components and chemotherapeutic agents. Due to the impressive technical and methodological developments of the past years, tandem mass spectrometry has evolved to one of the most powerful tools supporting research related to nucleic acids. This review covers the literature of the past decade devoted to the tandem mass spectrometric investigation of nucleic acids, with the main focus on the fundamental mechanistic aspects governing the gas-phase dissociation of DNA, RNA, modified oligonucleotide analogues, and their adducts with metal ions. Additionally, recent findings on the elucidation of nucleic acid higher-order structures by tandem mass spectrometry are reviewed. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc., Mass Spec Rev 35:483-523, 2016.

Nucleic acid ion structures in the gas phase

Nucleic acids are diverse polymeric macromolecules that are essential for all life forms. These biomolecules possess a functional three-dimensional structure under aqueous physiological conditions. Mass spectrometry-based approaches have on the other hand opened the possibility to gain structural information on nucleic acids from gas-phase measurements. To correlate gas-phase structural probing results with solution structures, it is therefore important to grasp the extent to which nucleic acid structures are preserved, or altered, when transferred from the solution to a fully anhydrous environment. We will review here experimental and theoretical approaches available to characterize the structure of nucleic acids in the gas phase (with a focus on oligonucleotides and higher-order structures), and will summarize the structural features of nucleic acids that can be preserved in the gas phase on the experiment time scale.

Differentiation and distributions of DNA/cisplatin crosslinks by liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization-infrared multiphoton dissociation mass spectrometry

Liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization-infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) mass spectrometry was developed to investigate the distributions of intrastrand crosslinks formed between cisplatin and two oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs), d(A1T2G3G4G5T6A7C8C9C10A11T12) (G3-D) and its analog d(A1T2G3G4G5T6T7C8C9C10A11T12) (G3-H), which have been reported to adopt different secondary structures in solution. Based on the formation of site-specific fragment ions upon IRMPD, two isobaric crosslink products were differentiated for each ODN. The preferential formation of G3G4 and G4G5 crosslinks was determined as a function of reaction conditions, including incubation temperature and presence of metal ions. G3-D consistently exhibited a greater preference for formation of the G4G5 crosslink compared with the G3-H ODN. The ratio of G3G4:G4G5 crosslinks increased for both G3-D and G3-H at higher incubation temperatures or when metal salts were added. Comparison of the IRMPD fragmentation patterns of the unmodified ODNs and the intramolecular platinated crosslinks indicated that backbone cleavage was significantly suppressed near the crosslink.

De novo sequencing of short interfering ribonucleic acids facilitated by use of tandem mass spectrometry with ion mobility spectrometry

RATIONALE

The use of RNAi for new therapeutics is becoming more widespread. To improve the development and quality control of such materials there is a need for rapid, accurate and meaningful analyses. Here, the use of negative ion nano-electrospray ionisation tandem mass spectrometry with ion mobility spectrometry (nESI-MS/MS-IMS-MS) is shown to simplify data interpretation and lead to higher sequence coverage.

METHODS

A set of 20-nucleotide RNA molecules was analysed using nESI-MS/MS and their sequences determined manually with the aid of the Simple Oligonucleotide Sequencer (SOS) program. The RNAs were also analysed using nESI-MS/MS-IMS-MS. This incorporates an extra step involving travelling-wave IMS separation of the product ions into groups according to the number of charges that the ions carry. Following this, the RNA sequences were determined from the separated groups of ions.

RESULTS

nESI-MS/MS collision-induced dissociation of the RNA sequences produced w, y, a-(Base) and c product ions. Sequence determination resulted in incomplete coverage with bases in the centre of the sequences being unidentifiable because of the plethora of overlapping ions. Sequencing carried out from the nESI-MS/MS-IMS-MS data, whereby individual product ion spectra arising only from ions carrying the same charge were generated, gave full sequence coverage for each nucleotide (except y1 ) with assignment confirmation from a minimum of four different product ions.

CONCLUSIONS

Using nESI-MS/MS-IMS-MS to analyse a number of 20-nucleotide RNA molecules produced full sequence coverage with 100% accuracy, in addition to molecular mass confirmation. This method has the potential for automation for higher sample throughput and thus constitutes a robust approach for the quality control of RNAs in therapeutics.