A representative assessment of the management of open fractures of the lower limb within UK orthoplastic centres: A two-centre audit of compliance with national standards

Orthoplastic Management of Lower Limb Traumas: A Retrospective Study on Polytraumas Versus Isolated Injuries

BACKGROUND

Open fractures of the lower limb represent a common challenge for trauma centers. Even where national guidelines are available, these standards are frequently missing. Our study evaluates the influence of polytrauma on the adherence to the timing and management required in an orthoplastic approach.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A retrospective review was performed on 36 patients affected by a Gustilo-Anderson grade IIIA, IIIB, or IIIC fracture of the lower limb between 2018 and 2022. Data related to patient management were analyzed: time to the first evaluation by a plastic surgeon, time to soft tissue coverage, time to definitive osteosynthesis, days in intensive care unit (ICU), days of hospitalization, and total cost of hospital stay. Patient satisfaction was evaluated through the administration of 2 questionnaires: the Enneking and the Foot Function Index (FFI).

RESULTS

In 23 patients (63.9%), a soft tissue reconstruction was required. Of these, 13 were polytraumas (PT) (56.5%) and 10 were affected by an isolated lower limb fracture (ILLF) (43.5%). The median time to wound excision was 7.0 days (IQR, 0-16.0) in the PT group and 12.5 days (IQR, 1-41.0) in the ILLF group, whereas the mean time to soft tissue coverage was 15.0 days (IQR, 4.0-17.0) in the PT group and 38.0 days (IQR, 25.0-65.0) in the ILLF group. Mean time to definitive fixation was 33.0 days (IQR, 6.5-70.0) in the PT group and 16.5 days (IQR, 3.0-26.0) in the ILLF group. Statistically significant difference was reported on mean time to soft tissue coverage, whereas not relevant differences were reported on mean time to plastic surgeon involvement, first debridement, definitive fixation, days of hospitalization, costs, and Enneking and FFI score.

CONCLUSION

This is the first study comparing the effectiveness of the orthoplastic approach between isolated lower limb fractures and polytraumas. According to our study, open lower limb fracture management is paradoxically more effective in polytraumas rather than in isolated injuries because a multidisciplinary approach is mandatory in severely injured and compromised patients.

Stress-Induced Hyperglycemia is a Risk Factor for Surgical-Site Infections in Nondiabetic Patients with Open Leg Fractures

Background

Nondiabetic patients with open leg fractures who have elevated blood glucose levels on arrival in the emergency department have an increased risk of surgical-site infections (SSIs).

Objective

This study evaluates the association between the incidence of SSIs in nondiabetic patients with an open leg fracture and blood glucose levels registered on arrival in the ER. We also analyzed the correlation between patients' days of hospital stay and the incidence of SSIs and the time elapsed between the damage control with external fixation and final fixation and the incidence of SSI.

Methods

We retrospectively studied nondiabetic patients admitted to our emergency unit from 2017 to 2021 with a diagnosis of open leg fracture consecutively treated. Based on the diagnosis of SSIs, all enrolled patients were divided into two groups based on the developed (group A) or not developed (group B) SSIs within 1 year after surgery. All patients enrolled in the study underwent damage control within 24 hours after admission to the ER. At stabilization of general clinical and local wound conditions, all patients underwent definitive surgery.

Results

We enrolled 80 patients. In group A, glycemia on arrival in the ER was on average 148.35 ± 19.59 mg/dl, and in group B, it was 122.61 ± 22.22 mg/dl (p value: 0.0001). In group A, glycemia in the first postoperative day was on average 113.81 ± 21.07 mg/dl, and in group B, it was 99.02 ± 17.60 mg/dl (p value: 0.001). In group A, the average hospitalization was 57.92 ± 42.43 days, and in group B, it was 18.41 ± 14.21 days (p value: 0.01). Through Youden's J, we therefore analyzed the value with the highest sensitivity and specificity which proved to be 132 mg/dl.

Conclusion

Our findings show that nondiabetic patients with SIH have a significantly increased risk of SSIs compared to patients without SIH within 1 year after surgery. Patients with open leg fractures with SIH have a significantly higher average hospital stay than patients without SIH. Further studies are needed to confirm 132 mg/dl of blood glucose levels as a value to stratify the risk of SSIs in these patients.

Clinical and Radiological Outcomes of Gustilo-Anderson Type IIIB Open Fractures in 125 Patients

INTRODUCTION

This study describes single-centre outcomes of Gustilo-Anderson type IIIB open fractures in relation to the current standards in the United Kingdom, which aim at performing skeletal fixation and soft tissue coverage at an early stage to salvage the limb and achieve bone union with a minimum infection rate.

METHODS

A total of 125 patients with 134 Gustilo-Anderson type IIIB open fractures, who had definitive skeletal fixation with soft tissue coverage between June 2013 and October 2021, were prospectively followed up and included in this study.

RESULTS

Initial debridement was performed within 12 hours from the time of injury for 62 (49.6%) patients and within 24 hours for 119 (95.2%) patients (mean= 12.4 hours). Definitive skeletal fixation and soft tissue coverage were achieved within 72 hours for 25 (20%) patients and within seven days for 71 (57%) patients (mean= 8.5 days). The mean follow-up duration was 43.3 (6-100) months, and the limb salvage rate was 97.1%. The occurrence of deep infections was associated with time from injury to initial debridement (p=0.049). Three patients (2.4%) developed deep (metalwork) infections, all three had their initial debridement performed within 12 hours from the time of injury. There was no association between time to definitive surgery and the development of deep infection (p=0.340). Bone union was achieved in 84.3% of patients following their primary surgery. Time to union was associated with fixation modality (p=0.002) and type of soft tissue coverage (p=0.028), and was negatively correlated with time to initial debridement (p=0.002, correlation coefficient -0.321). There was a 0.27-month decrease in time to union for every hour delay in time to debridement (p=0.021).

CONCLUSION

Delaying initial debridement or definitive fixation and soft tissue coverage didn't increase the rate of deep (metalwork) infections. The time to achieve bone union was negatively correlated with the time from injury to initial debridement. We advise prioritising surgical technique and availability of expertise over strict adherence to time thresholds of surgeries.

Patient reported outcomes after definitive open tibial fracture management

AIMS

Open tibial fractures are often life-changing injuries and patient outcomes remain poor despite the introduction of national management guidelines. The longer-term impact to the patient can be considerable but this is often overlooked in the literature. This study aims to establish the functional, physical, and psychosocial impact of sustaining an open tibial fracture.

METHODS

We reviewed 69 consecutive Gustilo-Anderson grade IIIB and IIIC open tibial fractures that presented to our Major Trauma Centre (MTC) between September 2012 and April 2018. Each participant was interviewed and sent patient-reported outcome questionnaires, a minimum of 12 months following injury. Our primary outcome was the Lower Extremity Functional Scale (LEFS). Secondary outcomes included the Short-Form 36 Healthy Survey (SF-36), Sickness Impact Profile 128 (SIP) and return to occupation. Subgroups were analysed according to age, Injury Severity Score (ISS) and limb amputation.

RESULTS

The mean follow up was 43 months. 96% were grade IIIB and 4% grade IIIC. The response rate for our study was 72%. The mean LEFS was 42 (IQR 21.5-58.5). All total and sub-domain scores within both the SF-36 and SIP questionnaires were reduced when compared to normative population data. Only 48% of patients returned to full time employment. Subgroup analysis revealed significantly reduced LEFS, SIP and SF-36 subdomain scores for those with a presenting ISS >14 and those undergoing limb amputation.

CONCLUSION

Patients are at significant risk of longer-term functional, physical and psychosocial harm after suffering an open tibial fracture. Those sustaining major polytrauma or amputation demonstrated to have the greatest risk of poor outcome. Early identification of these individuals likely to suffer most from their injury would help direct appropriate resources to those with greatest need at the earliest opportunity.

The Open-Fracture Patient Evaluation Nationwide (OPEN) study : epidemiology of open fracture care in the UK

AIMS

Understanding of open fracture management is skewed due to reliance on small-number lower limb, specialist unit reports and large, unfocused registry data collections. To address this, we carried out the Open Fracture Patient Evaluation Nationwide (OPEN) study, and report the demographic details and the initial steps of care for patients admitted with open fractures in the UK.

METHODS

Any patient admitted to hospital with an open fracture between 1 June 2021 and 30 September 2021 was included, excluding phalanges and isolated hand injuries. Institutional information governance approval was obtained at the lead site and all data entered using Research Electronic Data Capture. Demographic details, injury, fracture classification, and patient dispersal were detailed.

RESULTS

In total, 1,175 patients (median age 47 years (interquartile range (IQR) 29 to 65), 61.0% male (n = 717)) were admitted across 51 sites. A total of 546 patients (47.1%) were employed, 5.4% (n = 63) were diabetic, and 28.8% (n = 335) were smokers. In total, 29.0% of patients (n = 341) had more than one injury and 4.8% (n = 56) had two or more open fractures, while 51.3% of fractures (n = 637) occurred in the lower leg. Fractures sustained in vehicle incidents and collisions are common (38.8%; n = 455) and typically seen in younger patients. A simple fall (35.0%; n = 410) is common in older people. Overall, 69.8% (n = 786) of patients were admitted directly to an orthoplastic centre, 23.0% (n = 259) were transferred to an orthoplastic centre after initial management elsewhere, and 7.2% were managed outwith specialist units (n = 81).

CONCLUSION

This study describes the epidemiology of open fractures in the UK. For a decade, orthopaedic surgeons have been practicing in a guideline-driven, network system without understanding the patient features, injury characteristics, or dispersal processes of the wider population. This work will inform care pathways as the UK looks to the future of trauma networks and guidelines, and how to optimize care for patients with open fractures.Cite this article: Bone Jt Open 2022;3(10):746-752.

Outcomes following the delayed management of open tibial fractures

AIMS

National guidelines set standards for the definitive management of open fractures within 72 h. This study aims to investigate our outcomes where this timeline was unachievable for most cases due to a split-site orthoplastic service.

PATIENTS & METHODS

116 consecutive Gustilo-Anderson grade IIIB & IIIC open tibial fractures presenting to our major trauma centre (MTC) between September 2012 and April 2018 were reviewed. The mean follow up was 46 months (17 to 88). 110 (95%) were grade IIIB and 6 (5%) grade IIIC. The most common injury mechanism included road traffic accidents (59%) and falls (28%). Primary outcomes were recorded according to; timing of initial debridement and definitive cover, rates of superficial and deep infection, non-union and amputation. Subgroups were statistically analysed according to time to initial debridement, definitive soft-tissue cover and injury severity score (ISS).

RESULTS

The mean time to initial debridement was 11.3 h (2.9 to 38.9) and definitive soft-tissue cover 9.9 days (0 to 37). We recorded rates of: superficial infection; 42 cases (36%), deep infection; 14 cases (12%) and non-union requiring revision; 19 cases (16%). There were 20 amputations (17%) with 9 (8.6%) performed early and 11 (9.5%) delayed. Subgroup analysis showed higher rates of superficial infection (50%, p = 0.002) and amputation (26.6%, p = 0.01) for those debrided <12 h. A greater presenting ISS related to a delay to definitive cover >7 days (p = 0.05). Primary outcomes trended worse for those covered >7 days but did not reach significance.

CONCLUSION

Major trauma patients are particularly vulnerable to poor outcomes resulting from the delay in definitive management of open fractures. MTC's need resources and a co-located orthoplastic service to achieve national standards and better outcomes. Current guidelines do not advise for the management of patients where a delay in definitive surgery is anticipated.

Management of Chronic Osteomyelitis by an Orthoplastic Team: 7-Year Experience of a University Hospital

BACKGROUND

Treating chronic osteomyelitis of the lower extremities is challenging. The treatment of acute lower limb trauma by orthoplastic teams has shown good results over the past few decades. This study aimed to characterize surgical outcomes of leg and heel chronic osteomyelitis by an orthoplastic team.

METHODS

The cases of 113 consecutive leg and heel chronic osteomyelitis patients undergoing soft-tissue reconstruction with an orthopedic procedure were reviewed in this retrospective single-center observational study. The main objective was to assess surgical outcomes of skin healing and gait recovery at the 1-year follow-up. The secondary objective was to evaluate the global success rate at the last follow-up.

RESULTS

The median follow-up was 19.7 months. A free flap was performed for 33 patients (29.2 percent) and a locoregional flap was used in 79 patients (69.9 percent). Seventy-two patients (63.7 percent) had chronic osteomyelitis on continuous bone. The others had a septic pseudarthrosis with a mean bone defect length of 42.9 mm. Forty-four patients (38.9 percent) underwent curettage only, eight (7.1 percent) underwent curettage and cement, 20 (17.7 percent) underwent curettage and bone fixation, and 39 (34.5 percent) underwent the Masquelet technique. At the 1-year follow-up, 72 patients (63.7 percent) had achieved skin healing and had recovered their gait. The success rate at all follow-up time points was 82.3 percent. The median time to achieve skin healing was 6.5 months and that to bone union in cases of septic pseudarthrosis was 7.9 months.

CONCLUSION

Orthoplastic management of leg and heel chronic osteomyelitis patients with combined soft-tissue reconstruction using an orthopedic procedure was a viable strategy that offered good results even though the time to complete healing was long.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Risk, III.

Open lower limb fractures in the UK trauma system: A multicentre prospective audit of current practice

INTRODUCTION

Open fractures represent limb-threatening and life-changing injuries. Clear standards define how patients with these injuries should be managed in the UK. The study of open fractures is, therefore, a key measurable example of major trauma management as a whole. This study was conducted to characterise the demographic, assessment and treatment of patients sustaining lower limb open fractures across UK Regional Trauma Networks.

METHODS

A prospective, multicentre, audit was conducted according to a prespecified protocol against the relevant British Orthopaedic Association (BOA) & British Association of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeons (BAPRAS) standards for Trauma. All UK hospitals treating adults with open fractures were eligible to take part in the study. Patients included were injured during a six month collection period at each site.

RESULTS

3 Major Trauma Centres (MTCs) and 5 Trauma Units (TUs) were enrolled, with data collected by 24 collaborators. 239 patients were included, 11 had bilateral open fractures. There were 38 patient datasets collected from TUs and 201 from MTCs. Patients were predominantly male with high energy injuries. 31.3% of patients from MTCs were transferred in from another facility. Antibiotics were given to 41.7% of patients within 1 hour. 74.4% of limbs with open fractures had a splint applied in the emergency department. 85.8% of patients had a documented orthoplastics plan. 41.7% of patients with a high energy injury had their wound debrided within 12 hours.

DISCUSSION

42.3% of patients with open fractures in our cohort were managed at some point in a TU, indicating triage was required within the trauma network. Due to sampling, we may be under-estimating the number of patients passing through TUs, however, we have demonstrated that this cohort exists. These patients are under-represented in many other studies and registries such as the Trauma Audit Research Network (TARN) due to the funding model for data collection that privileges data collection in MTCs.

CONCLUSION

This study gives extensive new insight into the demographics and management of patients with open lower limb fractures in the UK, demonstrating a widespread involvement of TUs and consistent deviation from national standards.

Smoking and the patient with a complex lower limb injury

Smoking is known to increase the risk of peri-operative complications in Orthoplastic surgery by impairing bone and wound healing. The effects of nicotine replacement therapies (NRTs) and electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes) has been less well established. Previous reviews have examined the relationship between smoking and bone and wound healing separately. This review provides surgeons with a comprehensive and contemporaneous account of how smoking in all forms interacts with all aspects of complex lower limb trauma. We provide a guide for surgeons to refer to during the consent process to enable them to tailor information towards smokers in such a way that the patient may understand the risks involved with their surgical treatment. We update the literature with recently discovered methods of monitoring and treating the troublesome complications that occur more commonly in smokers effected by trauma.

The interest of "ortho-plastic" collaboration in management of complex limb injury

Constantly evolving knowledge on fracture management, soft tissue coverage, microsurgery and vasculo-nervous repair now permits salvage of limbs that previously would have had to be amputated. Management of complex limb injuries of which the severity inevitably entails functional and esthetic sequelae calls for mastery of the full spectrum of bone and soft tissue reconstruction. Such mastery is rarely attainable by a single surgical specialty; individually and isolatedly, an orthopedic or plastic surgeon cannot ensure optimal management of the above-mentioned patients. While the orthopedist performs a key function in provisional or definitive fixation, the plastic surgeon's expertise is essential to restoration of the cutaneous envelope. Collaboration between the two specialties from the outset and throughout treatment characterizes the modern-day concept of "ortho-plastic" surgery. Through unification of the theoretical competence and practical skills of orthopedists and plastic surgeons, it provides a patient with the best possible functional and esthetic results in a wide range of clinical situations. In this article, we present a review of the literature illustrating the interest of "ortho-plastic" collaboration in management of complex limb injury; concrete examples will be given through evocation of clinical cases encountered by the team that was put together in August 2015 at the university hospital (CHU) of Lille.

Masquelet technique combined with microsurgical technique for treatment of Gustilo IIIC open distal tibial fractures: a retrospective single-center cohort study

Objective

This study was performed to investigate the clinical effects of the Masquelet technique combined with a microsurgical technique for treatment of Gustilo IIIC open distal tibial fractures.

Methods

Fifteen patients with a mean age of 39.3 ± 7.9 years (range, 21–43 years) with Gustilo IIIC open distal tibial fractures were treated by the Masquelet technique combined with a microsurgical technique from May 2013 to January 2017. The mean length of the bone defect was 6.9 ±2.2 cm (range, 5.2–10.7 cm). The mean area of the wound defect was 129.3 ± 41.4 cm² (range, 83.7–180 cm²). Complications and fracture healing were recorded. At the last follow-up, the functional outcome was measured using the Iowa ankle score.

Results

All 15 patients achieved bone healing, and the median healing time was about 6.1 months (range, 5–8 months). No complications such as infection or nonunion occurred. At the last follow-up, the median Iowa ankle score was 82 (range, 68–88). The rate of an excellent and good Iowa ankle score was 86.6%.

Conclusions

Application of the Masquelet technique combined with a microsurgical technique is an effective strategy for the treatment of Gustilo IIIC open distal tibial fractures.

Principles of Orthoplastic Surgery for Lower Extremity Reconstruction: Why Is This Important?

BACKGROUND

 Regardless of the antecedent etiology, lower extremity salvage and reconstruction attempts to avoid amputation, restore limb function, and improve quality of life outcomes. This goal requires a treatment team well versed in neurovascular pathology, skeletal and soft tissue reconstruction, and physical rehabilitation.

METHODS

 A review was performed of historical milestones that lead to the development of orthoplastic extremity reconstruction, principles of current management and the evidence that supports an orthoplastic approach. Based on available evidence and expert opinion, the authors further sought to provide insight into the future of the field centered around the importance of a multidisciplinary management protocol.

RESULTS

 Historically, orthopaedic and plastic surgeons worked separately when faced with challenging reconstructive cases involving lower extremity skeletal and soft tissue reconstruction. With time, many embraced that their seemingly separate skill-sets and knowledge could be unified in a collaborative orthoplastic approach in order to offer patients the best possible chance for success. First coined by the senior author (LSL) in the early 1990s, the collaborative orthoplastic approach between orthopaedic and plastic surgeons in limb salvage for the past several decades has resulted in a unique field of reconstructive surgery. Benefits of the orthoplastic approach include decreased time to definitive skeletal stabilization/soft tissue coverage, length of hospital stay, post-operative complications, need for revision procedures and improved functional outcomes.

CONCLUSION

 The orthoplastic approach to lower extremity reconstruction is a collaborative model of orthopaedic and plastic surgeons working together to expedite and optimize care of patients in need of lower extremity reconstruction. The implementation of protocols, systems, and centers that foster this approach leads to improve outcomes for these patients. We encourage centers to embrace the orthoplastic approach when considering limb salvage, as the decision to amputate is irreversible.