Onset of Frozen Shoulder Following Pneumococcal and Influenza Vaccinations

Shoulder Injury Related to Vaccine Administration (SIRVA) Is Real: A Case Report

This study presents a case of SIRVA-induced adhesive capsulitis and the subsequent physiotherapy intervention. It details the patient's journey using CARE guidelines. The main symptoms included persistent pain and a reduced range of motion for flexion, abduction, and internal and external rotation of the shoulder. Interventions included active and passive mobilisation via capsular stretching, and home exercise programs. At more than two years post-injury, the patient has ongoing pain, restricted shoulder movement, and disability. This highlights the importance of healthcare practitioners' knowledge of SIRVA. Vaccinating practitioners should be aware of the mechanism of injury of SIRVA for preventing such injuries. First-contact practitioners should be aware of SIRVA-induced conditions to ensure timely and correct diagnosis and management of SIRVA-induced conditions.

Atypical progress of frozen shoulder after COVID-19 vaccination: A case report

BACKGROUND

After vaccination was mandated worldwide, various adverse effects associated with the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) vaccination, including shoulder pain, have been reported. Here, we report a case of new-onset shoulder pain after BNT162b2 (Comirnaty, Pfizer-BioNTech) mRNA vaccination.

CASE SUMMARY

A 50-year-old man visited our rehabilitation center with left shoulder range of motion (ROM) limitation that had persisted for more than 5 mo. The history included no specific noteworthy events, except vaccination. The pain in the patient’s left deltoid muscle appeared 1 day after the second BNT162b2 vaccination and intensified to severe pain. The patient self-administered aspirin, with which the pain subsided immediately, whereas ROM limitation persisted. At the first visit, the patient complained of dull pain and ROM restriction of the left shoulder (flexion 130°, abduction 110°, and external rotation 40°). Among the diagnostic studies conducted for the evaluation of the shoulder, magnetic resonance imaging showed a thickened coracohumeral ligament. Nerve conduction studies and needle electromyography showed no electrodiagnostic abnormalities. The patient received comprehensive rehabilitation for 7 mo and had an overall improvement in pain and ROM of the left shoulder.

CONCLUSION

In this case of severe shoulder pain after COVID-19 vaccination that subsided immediately with aspirin treatment, the exact cause and mechanism of pain are unclear. However, the clinical symptoms and diagnostic workups in our report suggest the possibility that the COVID-19 vaccination triggered an immunochemical response that resulted in shoulder pathology.

Shoulder Injury Related to Vaccine Administration: Case Series

Objective  Shoulder pain is a common presentation in the primary care setting, and shoulder pain after vaccination has a growing body of literature. The present study sought to understand how a standardized treatment protocol would aid patients experiencing shoulder injury related to vaccine administration (SIRVA). Methods  Patients experiencing SIRVA were retrospectively recruited between February 2017 and February 2021. All patients were treated with physical therapy and offered a cortisone injection. Post-treatment range of motion (i.e., forward elevation, external rotation, internal rotation) and patients' reported outcomes were collected with the visual analogue scale (VAS), American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES), simple shoulder test (SST), and single assessment numeric evaluation (SANE) scores. Results  A total of 9 patients were retrospectively examined. Among them, 6 patients presented within one month of a recent vaccination event, while 3 patients presented 67, 87, and 120 days after vaccination. Furthermore, 8 of the patients completed physical therapy, and 6 of them underwent a cortisone injection. The follow-up time averaged 8 months. At final follow-up, the mean external rotation was 61° (standard deviation, SD ± 3°) and the mean forward elevation was 179° (SD ± 45°). Internal rotation ranged between L3 and T10. The VAS pain scores were 3.5/10.0 (SD ± 2.4), the mean ASES score was 63.5/100.0 (SD ± 26.3), and the SST scores were 8.5/12.0 (SD ± 3.9). Finally, the SANE scores were 75.7/100.0 (SD ± 24.7) and 95.7/100.0 (SD ± 6.1) in the injured and contralateral shoulders respectively. Conclusion  Shoulder pain after a vaccination treated with physical therapy and cortisone injection ultimately resulted in favorable shoulder range of motion and functional score outcomes. Level of Evidence  IV.

Shoulder Pain and Dysfunction After Vaccination: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Persistent shoulder pain and dysfunction after vaccination are relatively rare but well-known complications after inoculations into the deltoid muscle. The term SIRVA (shoulder injury related to vaccine administration) is frequently used to encompass many of these occurrences; however, multiple distinct pathologies with similar presentations have been reported after vaccination. We performed a systematic review of the literature on vaccine-related shoulder injuries to help guide practitioners in appropriate workup and treatment based on specific diagnoses.

METHODS

PubMed was used to search for combinations of multiple keywords (including vaccine, immunization, SIRVA, injury, inflammation, bursitis, Parsonage-Turner syndrome, and neuritis), and all references of each potential article were reviewed. A total of 56 articles were included. Patient demographics, vaccine information, presentation, diagnostic studies, treatment, and outcomes were recorded.

RESULTS

Diagnoses were divided into 3 categories: (1) local inflammatory reaction (SIRVA), (2) brachial neuritis, and (3) direct nerve injury. The included articles reported on 57 cases of SIRVA, 18 of brachial neuritis, and 4 of direct nerve injury. The diagnoses reported for the SIRVA cases included frozen shoulder, pseudoseptic arthritis, subacromial bursitis, rotator cuff injury, and lytic lesions of the humeral head. Various treatments were used, and most patients had resolution of symptoms with conservative treatment including physical therapy, analgesics, and/or corticosteroid injections. Advanced imaging rarely provided information that affected treatment. The brachial neuritis and direct nerve injury cases were typically confirmed with electromyography/nerve conduction studies. Treatment of these 2 categories was nonoperative in all cases, typically with analgesics and/or corticosteroids, and most patients had symptomatic improvement after a few months, with most patients regaining strength. However, some (1 of 3 patients with brachial neuritis and >1 year of follow-up and 2 of 4 patients with direct injury) had residual weakness.

CONCLUSIONS

Medical professionals should be aware of the various pathologies that can lead to prolonged shoulder pain after vaccination. Fortunately, most of these conditions can be treated successfully with nonoperative modalities, although differentiating among the diagnoses can help guide treatment, as some likely benefit from systemic corticosteroids or localized corticosteroid injections. Outcomes for most patients have been good, with the majority recovering without residual pain or deficits.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Prognostic Level IV.

Shoulder injury related to vaccine administration following SARS-CoV-2 inoculation: Case series and review of literature

Introduction

Shoulder Injuries Related to Vaccine Administration (SIRVA), describes those cases of shoulder severe post-inoculation complications, including pain and prolonged disability. Most of the reported cases have been secondary to influenza vaccination. This study retrospectively describes a series of 18 patients following SARS-CoV-2 inoculation and compares the findings with those previously reported for other vaccines.

Materials and methods

Inclusion criteria was onset of symptoms within 48 h after injection, symptoms duration of at least seven days, and restricted range of motion in absence of symptoms prior to vaccination. Average age was 59.4 years old (38-76), and 72.2% were women.

Results

In many cases (58%) the initial diagnosis was not clear, which lead to incorrect treatment. The most common pathological finding was subacromial-subdeltoid bursitis (66.6%). All patients who received depot corticosteroids followed by a gentle rehabilitation program showed strong clinical improvement but did not completely resolve the symptoms at 7.2 months average final follow-up. Surgical intervention was necessary in one of the patients due to the persistence of symptoms despite conservative treatment.

Conclusions

Shoulder injury related to vaccine administration is rare, but when present, its torpid evolution makes it difficult to treat. We have found in our case series a similar pattern to that already described for other vaccines. A high index of suspicion helps to pick up the condition promptly and early treatment can bring satisfactory outcome.

The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on frozen shoulder incidence rates and severity

BACKGROUND

Although there is evidence that the COVID-19 pandemic had profound physiological and psychological effects, there is no research aimed at understanding if the pandemic has had an impact on the incidence or severity of frozen shoulder (FS). The aim of this study was to compare the incidence and severity of idiopathic FS before and during the pandemic.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study was performed to establish the incidence of FS during the pandemic, from March 2020 to January 2021 (pandemic study period), compared to the same time period 1 year earlier, before the pandemic (control group). All patients who were diagnosed with idiopathic FS were included. To assess the severity of the condition, visual analog scale (VAS) for pain score and Subjective Shoulder Value (SSV) on presentation were recorded and the patients were categorized into 5 different treatment groups (0 injections, 1 injection, 2 injections, 3 injections, or capsular release). As the pandemic and public health restrictions could have influenced the availability of appointments, the waiting time between referral and first appointment was calculated as a possible confounding factor. Statistical analysis was performed using the chi-square and Student t test for categorical and continuous variables, respectively.

RESULTS

There were 847 new patient consultations during the pandemic study period; of these, 232 were for idiopathic FS. One year earlier, there were 898 initial consultations for a new shoulder problem; of these, 176 were for idiopathic FS. This represents a relative increase of 39.8% (P < .001) in the incidence of patients with FS. The mean SSV in the control group was 50% ± 20% vs. 45% ± 18% in the pandemic group-statistically significant (P = .013) but unlikely to be clinically significant. The VAS pain score was similar in both groups: mean 6 ± 2 and 7 ± 2, respectively (P = .06). There was no significant difference between the control and the pandemic group in the distribution of patients per treatment group (P = .94). The mean waiting time from referral to appointment was not significantly different between the control and the pandemic group: 58 ± 30 days vs. 55 ± 27 days (P = .30).

CONCLUSION

During the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a significant increase in the incidence of patients with FS. No significant difference in severity was observed. Further research is needed to evaluate a causal relationship between the COVID-19 pandemic and FS.

What Do We Know About Shoulder Injury Related to Vaccine Administration? An Updated Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Shoulder injury related to vaccine administration (SIRVA) is postulated to be an immune-mediated inflammatory response to a vaccine antigen injected into or near the subacromial bursae or synovium, leading to shoulder pain and dysfunction. The number of studies on this topic is rapidly increasing. Recent comparative studies have reported conflicting conclusions, which suggests that a systematic review of the best-available evidence may be helpful.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

In this systematic review, we asked: What are the (1) clinical characteristics, (2) diagnoses, and (3) management approaches and outcomes reported in association with SIRVA?

METHODS

A search was performed on October 4, 2021, of the PubMed and Medline databases for studies related to SIRVA. Inclusion criteria were English-language comparative studies, case series, and case reports that involved shoulder pain occurring after vaccination. Studies of exclusively neurologic conditions after vaccination were excluded. Forty-two studies met the eligibility criteria, including three retrospective comparative studies (72 patients and 105 controls), five database case series (2273 patients), and 34 case reports (49 patients). Study quality was assessed for the database case series and retrospective comparative studies using the Methodological Index for Non-randomized Studies tool.

RESULTS

Among patients in the case reports, the median age was 51 years (range 15-90 years), and 73% (36 of 49) were women. BMI was reported for 24% of patients (12 of 49) in case reports, with a median of 23.5 kg/m2 (range 21-37.2 kg/m2). The most common symptoms were shoulder pain and reduced ROM. The most common diagnoses were shoulder bursitis, adhesive capsulitis, and rotator cuff tears. The most frequent management modalities included physical or occupational therapy, NSAIDs, and steroid injections, followed by surgery, which was generally used for patients whose symptoms persisted despite nonsurgical management. Full resolution of symptoms was reported in 2.9% to 56% of patients.

CONCLUSION

The association between inflammatory conditions of the shoulder (such as bursitis) and vaccination appears to be exceedingly rare, occurring after approximately 1:130,000 vaccination events according to the best-available comparative study. Currently, there is no confirmatory experimental evidence supporting the theory of an immune-mediated inflammatory response to vaccine antigens. Although the clinical evidence is limited, similar to any bursitis, typical treatments appear effective, and surgery should rarely be performed. Additional research is needed to determine the best injection technique or evaluate alternate injection sites such as the anterolateral thigh that do not involve positioning a needle close to the shoulder.

Persistent Shoulder Pain After Vaccine Administration Is Associated with Common Incidental Pathology: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Claims of shoulder injury now account for half of all claims to the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program. Reports from databases of claims or potential adverse events note a relatively high mean age and high prevalences of rotator cuff tendinopathy and adhesive capsulitis-common shoulder problems that might be incidental to vaccination. Published case reports provide much more detail about individual patients than is available in databases. A review of published cases provides an opportunity for more detailed review of symptoms, diagnoses, pathology, treatment, and prognosis. Such a review can better assess the relative likelihood that pathologies associated with new persistent shoulder symptoms after vaccination are coincidental or unique to and caused by vaccine.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

Regarding published case reports addressing persistent shoulder pain after vaccination: (1) In what proportion of patients was a specific diagnosis made? (2) What diagnoses were most common? (3) Among patients treated nonsurgically, what proportion resolved, and over what time span did they resolve?

METHODS

In August 2020, we searched PubMed and Embase between 2006 and 2020 using the following search strategy: Search 1: (shoulder dysfunction OR shoulder pain OR shoulder bursitis OR rotator cuff tendonitis OR adhesive capsulitis OR glenohumeral arthritis AND [vaccine OR vaccination OR immunization]); Search 2: (shoulder injury related to vaccine administration or SIRVA). The search was supplemented by reviewing reference lists of identified studies. Inclusion criteria were any detailed report of three or fewer cases involving shoulder pain after vaccine administration. Twenty published reports of 29 patients were identified and assessed by two reviewers independently. One reported glenohumeral joint infection was excluded because the relationship between this type of relatively uncommon, discrete diagnosis and vaccination raises different considerations. We assumed a high risk of bias, although we are not aware of bias assessment tool for case reports. We recorded and summarized patient demographics, symptoms, examination and imaging findings, surgery findings, diagnoses, treatments, and outcomes. Seventy-five percent (21 of 28) of patients were women, with a mean age of 54 ± 19 years. In search of an underlying pathology, at least one diagnostic study was performed in 82% (23 of 28) of patients including radiographs in seven, ultrasound in seven, and MRI in 16 patients (some patients underwent more than one type of imaging). We distinguished specific pathophysiological diagnosis from shoulder pain and stiffness, counted the most common diagnoses among patients a specific diagnosis, and tracked symptom resolution among patients treated nonoperatively.

RESULTS

A specific diagnosis was made in 57% (16 of 28) of patients. Twelve patients had pain and limitation of motion due to pain but no specific pathological diagnosis. The most common specific diagnoses were rotator cuff tendinopathy (9 of 16) and adhesive capsulitis (4 of 16). Less common specific diagnoses included rotator cuff arthropathy (and rheumatoid arthritis) and suspected septic arthritis with nonspecific synovitis on arthroscopy. One patient had transient MRI signal change in the humeral head, which was interpreted as osteonecrosis that resolved in a manner not typical for that diagnosis. Of the 17 patients treated nonsurgically, 15 reported resolution, and two had incomplete symptom resolution with the mean 6-month evaluation period.

CONCLUSION

The observation that persistent shoulder pain after vaccination overlaps with common shoulder pathology-both in large databases as well as in more detailed reports of specific patients as analyzed in this review-establishes a high probability of a coincidental rather than a causal association. In the absence of high-quality experimental evidence of vaccine-specific shoulder pathology, in our opinion, it seems safest and healthiest to assume that perceived shoulder injury related to vaccine administration (SIRVA) is due to misinterpretation of new symptoms from established pathology rather than a new, vaccine-specific pathology.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, therapeutic study.

Risk for Shoulder Conditions After Vaccination: A Population-Based Study Using Real-World Data

BACKGROUND

Although shoulder conditions have been reported as an adverse event after intramuscular vaccination in the deltoid muscle, epidemiologic data on shoulder conditions after vaccination are limited.

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the risk for shoulder conditions after vaccination and assess possible risk factors.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

Kaiser Permanente Southern California, a large integrated health care organization.

PARTICIPANTS

Kaiser Permanente Southern California members aged 3 years or older who had an intramuscular vaccination administered in the deltoid muscle between 1 April 2016 and 31 December 2017.

MEASUREMENTS

A natural language processing (NLP) algorithm was used to identify potential shoulder conditions among vaccinated persons with shoulder disorder diagnosis codes. All NLP-identified cases were manually chart confirmed on the basis of our case definition. The characteristics of vaccinated persons with and without shoulder conditions were compared.

RESULTS

Among 3 758 764 administered vaccinations, 371 cases of shoulder condition were identified, with an estimated incidence of 0.99 (95% CI, 0.89 to 1.09) per 10 000 vaccinations. The incidence was 1.22 (CI, 1.10 to 1.35) for the adult (aged ≥18 years) and 0.05 (CI, 0.02 to 0.14) for the pediatric (aged 3 to 17 years) vaccinated populations. In the adult vaccinated population, advanced age, female sex, an increased number of outpatient visits in the 6 months before vaccination, lower Charlson Comorbidity Index, and pneumococcal conjugate vaccine were associated with a higher risk for shoulder conditions. Among influenza vaccines, quadrivalent vaccines were associated with an increased risk for shoulder conditions. Simultaneous administration of vaccines was associated with a higher risk for shoulder conditions among elderly persons.

LIMITATION

Generalizability to other health care settings, use of administrative data, and residual confounding.

CONCLUSION

These population-based data suggest a small absolute risk for shoulder conditions after vaccination. Given the high burden of shoulder conditions, clinicians should pay attention to any factors that may further increase risks.

PRIMARY FUNDING SOURCE

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Frozen Shoulder Related to Influenza Vaccine Administration

Shoulder pain is often a transient physical finding after vaccination. We present the case of a 46-year-old woman who presented clinically with frozen shoulder that was progressively worse and temporally related to her yearly influenza vaccination. The patient failed conservative management, and 7 months postvaccination, the patient underwent shoulder manipulation under anesthesia with good results. Vaccination-related shoulder dysfunction after high-deltoid intramuscular penetration and infiltration into the subdeltoid/subacromial bursa can cause a severe local inflammatory response that clinically may present as frozen shoulder. A case report and review of the literature on suspected frozen shoulder injury related to vaccine administration is presented. A greater understanding of the shoulder anatomy and use of the correct intramuscular vaccination administration technique is important to prevent this rare postvaccination complication.

The epidemiology and etiology of adhesive capsulitis in the U.S. Medicare population

Background

Adhesive capsulitis (AC) of the shoulder, also known as frozen shoulder, causes substantial pain and disability. In cases of secondary AC, the inflammation and fibrosis of the synovial joint can be triggered by trauma or surgery to the joint followed by extended immobility. However, for primary AC the inciting trigger is unknown. The burden of the disorder among the elderly is also unknown leading to this age group being left out of therapeutic research studies, potentially receiving delayed diagnoses, and unknown financial costs to the Medicare system. The purpose of this analysis was to describe the epidemiology of AC in individuals over the age of 65, an age group little studied for this disorder. The second purpose was to investigate whether specific medications, co-morbidities, infections, and traumas are risk factors or triggers for primary AC in this population.

Methods

We used Medicare claims data from 2010–2012 to investigate the prevalence of AC and assess comorbid risk factors and seasonality. Selected medications, distal trauma, and classes of infections as potential inflammatory triggers for primary AC were investigated using a case–control study design with patients with rotator cuff tears as the comparison group. Medications were identified from National Drug codes and translated to World Health Organization ATC codes for analysis. Health conditions were identified using ICD9-CM codes.

Results

We found a one-year prevalence rate of AC of approximately 0.35% among adults aged 65 years and older which translates to approximately 142,000 older adults in the United States having frozen shoulder syndrome. Diabetes and Parkinson’s disease were significantly associated with the diagnosis of AC in the elderly. Cases were somewhat more common from August through December, although a clear seasonal trend was not observed. Medications, traumas, and infections were similar for cases and controls.

Conclusions

This investigation identified the burden of AC in the US elderly population and applied case–control methodology to identify triggers for its onset in this population. Efforts to reduce chronic health conditions such as diabetes may reduce seemingly unrelated conditions such as AC. The inciting trigger for this idiopathic condition remains elusive.

Shoulder Injury after Vaccination: A Systematic Review

Adverse reactions to vaccine injections are usually mild and incredibly rare in nature, but multiple cases of shoulder events including bursitis, generalized pain or decreased range of motion have been reported following routine vaccine administrations. These events are known as Shoulder Injury Related to Vaccine Administration or SIRVA. A systematic review of literature was performed to identify all published accounts of SIRVA. Twenty-seven papers reporting one or more accounts of SIRVA were identified. The most common vaccination involved was the Influenza vaccine. The most common symptoms were pain that began in 48 hours or less and loss of shoulder range of motion. The most common treatment modalities were physical therapy, corticosteroid injections and anti-inflammatory medication; but in some patients, surgery was required. Regardless of intervention, the vast majority of outcomes demonstrated improved pain and functional except in the occasions of nerve injury. The etiology of SIRVA injuries has multiple possibilities including needle length, mechanical injury from needle overpenetration and the possibility of an immune inflammatory response from the vaccine components, but a unique definitive test or quantifiably result does not yet exist.

Bilateral adhesive capsulitis following influenza vaccination: A case report

Bilateral shoulder adhesive capsulitis may develop in association with the administration of an influenza vaccine. Vaccine administration should utilize proper technique to avoid injection into the shoulder capsule.

Treatment of Adhesive Capsulitis of the Shoulder

Adhesive capsulitis presents clinically as limited, active and passive range of motion caused by the formation of adhesions of the glenohumeral joint capsule. Radiographically, it is thickening of the capsule and rotator interval. The pathology of the disease, and its classification, relates to inflammation and formation of extensive scar tissue. Risk factors include diabetes, hyperthyroidism, and previous cervical spine surgery. Nonsurgical management includes physical therapy, corticosteroid injections, extracorporeal shock wave therapy, calcitonin, ultrasonography-guided hydrodissection, and hyaluronic acid injections. Most patients will see complete resolution of symptoms with nonsurgical management, and there appears to be a role of early corticosteroid injection in shortening the overall duration of symptoms. Surgical intervention, including manipulation under anesthesia, arthroscopic capsular release both limited and circumferential, and the authors' technique are described in this article. Complications include fracture, glenoid and labral injuries, neurapraxia, and rotator cuff pathology. Postoperative care should always include early physical therapy.