Spatial heterogeneity and source apportionment of soil metal(loid)s in an abandoned lead/zinc smelter

Metal-bearing airborne particles from mining activities: A review on their characteristics, impacts and research perspectives

The presence of various contaminants in airborne dusts from metal mining sites poses obvious risks to human health and the environment. Yet, few studies have thoroughly investigated the properties of airborne particles in terms of their morphology, size distribution and chemical composition, that are associated with health effects around mining activities. This review presents the most recent knowledge on the sources, physicochemical characteristics, and health and environmental risks associated with airborne dusts from various mining and smelting operations. The literature reviewed found only one research on atmospheric dust associated with hydrometallurgical plants compared to a larger number of pyrometallurgical processes/smelters studies. In addition, there are relatively few works comparing the distribution of metals between the fine and coarse size fractions around mining sites. Our analysis suggests that (i) exposure pathways of metal(loid)s to the human body are defined by linking concentration data in human biosamples and contaminated samples such as soils, drinking water and food, and (ii) chitosan and its derivatives may serve as an environmentally friendly and cost-effective method for soil remediation, with removal rates for metal(loid)s around 70-95 % at pH 6-8, and as dust suppressants for unpaved roads around mining sites. The specific limit values for PM and metal(loid)s at mining sites are not well documented. Despite the health risks associated with fine particles around mining areas, regulations have tended to focus on coarse particles. While some air quality agencies have issued regulations for occupational health and safety, there is no global alignment or common regulatory framework for enforcement. Future research priorities should focus on investigating PM and secondary inorganic aerosols associated with hydrometallurgical processes and dust monitoring, using online metal(loid)s analysers to identify the driving parameters in the deposition and resuspension process.

Pollution characteristics and quantitative source apportionment of heavy metals within a zinc smelting site by GIS-based PMF and APCS-MLR models

The abandoned smelters present a substantial pollution threat to the nearby soil and groundwater. In this study, 63 surface soil samples were collected from a zinc smelter to quantitatively describe the pollution characteristics, ecological risks, and source apportionment of heavy metal(loid)s (HMs). The results revealed that the average contents of Zn, Cd, Pb, As, and Hg were 0.4, 12.2, 3.3, 5.3, and 12.7 times higher than the risk screening values of the construction sites, respectively. Notably, the smelter was accumulated heavily with Cd and Hg, and the contribution of Cd (0.38) and Hg (0.53) to ecological risk was 91.58%. ZZ3 and ZZ7 were the most polluted workshops, accounting for 25.7% and 35.0% of the pollution load and ecological risk, respectively. The influence of soil parent materials on pollution was minor compared to various workshops within the smelter. Combined with PMF, APCS-MLR and GIS analysis, four sources of HMs were identified: P1(25.5%) and A3(18.4%) were atmospheric deposition from the electric defogging workshop and surface runoff from the smelter; P2(32.7%) and A2(20.9%) were surface runoff of As-Pb foul acid; P3(14.5%) and A4(49.8%) were atmospheric deposition from the leach slag drying workshop; P4(27.3%) and A1(10.8%) were the smelting process of zinc products. This paper described the distribution characteristics and specific sources of HMs in different process workshops, providing a new perspective for the precise remediation of the smelter by determining the priority control factors.

Threshold and interaction effects of environmental variables affecting the spatial distribution of Pb

Understanding the spatial distribution of soil Pb and its potential influence mechanism is significant for controlling Pb pollution in tea plantations and guaranteeing food safety. The linear and nonlinear relationships between Pb and environmental variables have been widely studied, but the threshold and interaction effects of its environmental variables are often neglected. In this study, 81 tea plantation soils were collected and determined the thresholds and interaction effects of environmental variables on Pb through the GBDT model. The results revealed that the 10 selected environmental variables together explained 71.01 % of the variation in Pb content, with the top three factors being pH, total phosphorus (TP), and distance from roads (dis_road). Most environmental variable had threshold effects on Pb. By visualizing the interaction of pH, TP, and dis_road on Pb concentration, we show that both two-way and three-way interactions are able to further explain its variation. The interaction between TP and dis_road alone accounts for 5.70 %, between pH and dis_road alone accounts for 7.92 %, and between pH and TP alone accounts for 5.83 % of the variation in Pb concentration. However, the three-way interaction between pH, TP, and dis_road alone explains 11.85 % of the variation in Pb concentration. Understanding these interactions is important for gaining insight into the underlying processes leading to Pb pollution and promoting the tea industry's sustainable development in China and abroad.

Recovery of Scots Pine Seedlings from Long-Term Zinc Toxicity

We studied the recovery of the growth and physiological parameters of Scots pine seedlings after long-term zinc toxicity. The removal of excess zinc from the nutrient solution resulted in the rapid recovery of primary root growth but did not promote the initiation and growth of lateral roots. The recovery of root growth was accompanied by the rapid uptake of manganese, magnesium, and copper. Despite the maximum rate of manganese uptake by the roots, the manganese content in the needles of the recovering plants did not reach control values during the 28 days of the experiment, unlike magnesium, iron, and copper. In general, the recovery of ion homeostasis eliminated all of the negative effects on the photosynthetic pigment content in the needles. However, these changes, along with recovery of the water content in the needles, were not accompanied by an increase in the weight gain of the recovering seedlings compared with that of the Zn-stressed seedlings. The increased accumulation of phenolic compounds in the needles persisted for a long period after excess zinc was removed from the nutrient solution. The decreased lignin content in the roots and needles is a characteristic feature of Zn-stressed plants. Moreover, the removal of excess zinc from the nutrient solution did not lead to an increase in the lignin content in the organs.

A review of phytoremediation of environmental lead (pb) contamination

An estimated one billion people globally are exposed to hazardous levels of lead (Pb), resulting in intellectual disabilities for over 600,000 children each year. This critical issue aligns with the expanding worldwide population and the demand for food security, emphasizing the urgency of effectively addressing heavy metal pollution especially from Pb for sustainable development. Phytoremediation, a highly favoured approach in conjunction with conventional physical, chemical, and microbial methods, is a promising approach to mitigating soil and environmental contamination. In this review, we delve into a range of soil pollution mitigation strategies, with focus on the mechanisms that underpin the phytoremediation of environmental Pb. This detailed exploration sheds light on the efficacy and complexities of utilizing plants for the detoxification and removal of lead from contaminated environments. It also examines strategies to enhance phytoremediation by incorporating microbiology, composting, nanotechnology, and foliar spraying. The potential remediation strategies largely depend on the investigation and incorporation of environmentally friendly catalysts, as well as the utilization of innovative methods such as genetic engineering to improve phytoremediation processes. Studies have also shown that biochar has the capability to lower heavy metal concentrations in plant branches by over 50%, without affecting the pH of the soil. Specifically, magnetic biochar (MBC) has been shown to decrease lead levels in plants by up to 42%. Employing these methods showcases an effective strategy to enhance the efficacy of remediation techniques and fosters sustainable solutions to the pervasive issue of Pb pollution, thereby contributing to sustainable development efforts globally.

Distinguishing the contributions of different smelting emissions to the spatial risk footprints of toxic elements in soil using PMF, Bayesian isotope mixing models, and distance-based regression

Toxic element pollution of soils emanating from smelting operations is an escalating global concern due to its severe impact on ecosystems and human health. In this study, soil samples were collected and analyzed to quantify the risk contributions and delineate the spatial risk footprints from smelting emissions for 8 toxic elements. A comprehensive health risk contribution and delineation framework was utilized, consisting of Positive matrix factorization (PMF), spatial interpolation, an advanced Bayesian isotope mixing model via Mixing Stable Isotope Analysis in R (MixSIAR), and distance-based regression. The results showed that the mean concentrations of As, Cd, Cu, Hg, Pb, and Zn exceeded the background levels, indicating substantial contamination. Three sources were identified using the PMF model and confirmed by spatial interpolation and MixSIAR, with contributions ranked as follows: industrial wastewater discharge and slag runoff from the smelter site (48.9 %) > natural geogenic inputs from soil parent materials (26.7 %) > atmospheric deposition of dust particles from smelting operations (24.5 %). Among the identified sources, smelter runoff posed the most significant risk, accounting for 97.9 % of the non-carcinogenic risk (NCR) and 59.9 % of the carcinogenic risk (CR). Runoff also drove NCR and CR exceedances at 7.8 % and 4.7 % of sites near the smelter, respectively. However, atmospheric deposition from smelting emissions affected soils across a larger 0.8 km radius. Although it posed lower risks, contributing just 1.1 % to NCR and 22.6 % to CR due to the limited elevation of toxic elements, deposition reached more distant soils. Spatial interpolation and distance-based regression delineated high NCR and CR exposure hotspots within 1.4 km for runoff and 0.8 km for deposition, with exponentially diminishing risks at further distances. These findings highlight the need for pathway-specific interventions that prioritize localized wastewater containment and drainage controls near the smelter while implementing broader regional air pollution mitigation measures.

Sources apportionments of heavy metal(loid)s in the farmland soils close to industrial parks: Integrated application of positive matrix factorization (PMF) and cadmium isotopic fractionation

Understanding the source identification and distribution of heavy metal(loid)s in soil is essential for risk management. The sources of heavy metal(loid)s in farmland soil, especially in areas with rapid economic development, were complicated and need to be explored urgently. This study combined geographic information system (GIS) mapping, positive matrix factorization (PMF) model and cadmium (Cd) isotope fingerprinting methods to identify heavy metal(loid) sources in a typical town in the economically developed Yangtze River Delta region of China. Cd, As, Cu, Zn, Pb, Ni and Co in different samples were detected. The results showed that Cd was the most severely contaminated element, with an exceedance rate of 78.0 %. GIS mapping results indicated that the hotspot area was located in the northeastern area with prolonged operational histories of electroplating and non-ferrous metal smelting industries. The PMF model analysis also identified emissions from smelting and electroplating enterprises as the main sources of Cd in the soil, counted for 49.28 %, followed by traffic (25.66 %) and agricultural (25.06 %) sources. Through further isotopic analysis, it was found that in soil samples near the industrial park, the contribution of electroplating and non-ferrous metal smelting enterprises to cadmium pollution was significantly higher than other regions. The integrated use of various methodologies allows for precise analysis of sources and input pathways, offering valuable insights for future pollution control and soil remediation endeavors.

Pollution levels and probability risk assessment of potential toxic elements in soil of Pb-Zn smelting areas

Soil pollution around Pb-Zn smelters has attracted widespread attention around the world. In this study, we compiled a database of eight potentially toxic elements (PTEs) Pb, Zn, Cd, As, Cr, Ni, Cu, and Mn in the soil of Pb-Zn smelting areas by screening the published research papers from 2000 to 2023. The pollution assessment and risk screening of eight PTEs were carried out by geo-accumulation index (Igeo), potential ecological risk index (PERI) and health risk assessment model, and Monte Carlo simulation employed to further evaluate the probabilistic health risks. The results suggested that the mean values of the eight PTEs all exceeded the corresponding values in the upper crust, and more than 60% of the study sites had serious Pb and Cd pollution (Igeo > 4), with Brazil, Belgium, China, France and Slovenia having higher levels of pollution than other regions. Besides, PTEs in smelting area caused serious ecological risk (PERI = 10912.12), in which Cd was the main contributor to PREI (86.02%). The average hazard index (HI) of the eight PTEs for adults and children was 7.19 and 9.73, respectively, and the average value of total carcinogenic risk (TCR) was 4.20 × 10-3 and 8.05 × 10-4, respectively. Pb and As are the main contributors to non-carcinogenic risk, while Cu and As are the main contributors to carcinogenic risk. The probability of non-carcinogenic risk in adults and children was 84.05% and 97.57%, while carcinogenic risk was 92.56% and 79.73%, respectively. In summary, there are high ecological and health risks of PTEs in the soil of Pb-Zn smelting areas, and Pb, Cd, As and Cu are the key elements that cause contamination and risk, which need to be paid attention to and controlled. This study is expected to provide guidance for soil remediation in Pb-Zn smelting areas.

Source-oriented risk assessment of heavy metal(loid)s in agricultural soils around a multimetal smelting area near the Yellow River, China

Heavy metal(loid) (HM) contamination in agricultural soils, particularly in areas severely impacted by smelting industries, has attracted worldwide attention. In this study, agricultural soils were collected in a flourishing multimetal smelting area near the Yellow River in central China. By an integrated approach encompassing the positive matrix factorization model, ordinary kriging interpolation and hierarchical clustering analysis (PMF-OK-HC), a total of four major sources and their mass contributions were identified, namely, soil parent material (56.6%), industrial waste and Mo smelting (24.0%), metal smelting and traffic emissions (12.8%), and coal combustion (6.7%). On this basis, the health risk of HMs was evaluated by Monte Carlo simulations and showed that a higher risk, with a higher proportion of exceeding-thresholds risk, was observed for children than for adults in terms of both noncarcinogenic and carcinogenic risks. Exposure pathways of oral ingestion in children could result in a higher attributed risk than other pathways. Furthermore, source-oriented risk assessment (SORA) revealed that the sources of coal combustion, industrial waste and Mo smelting had the highest contributions to noncarcinogenic and carcinogenic risks. Overall, for effective environmental management in agricultural soil, the framework of SORA was verified as an effective tool in the identification of the priority control of HMs and their sources.

Effects of Simulated Reclaimed Water on Soil Particle Sizes and Cd Adsorption and Migration in Soils at Smelting Sites

This work studied the vertical migration characteristics of Cd in soil profiles from a zinc smelting site under the influence of simulated reclaimed water containing NaCl and Na2SO4. The isothermal adsorption curves of Cd in the soils of miscellaneous fill and weathered slate well fitted the Freundlich and Langmuir models, with R2 ranging from 0.991 to 0.998. The maximum adsorption capacity of Cd in the soils decreased significantly under the salt ion treatments with NaCl and Na2SO4. After leaching, the Cd concentrations in the leachates and Cd contents in the subsoil layers of 10-60 cm followed the order NaCl treatment > Na2SO4 treatment > CK (p < 0.05), suggesting that the salt ions promoted the vertical migration of exogenous Cd. The proportion of coarse particles (> 0.02 mm) decreased, while that of fine particles (< 0.02 mm) increased under salt ion treatments (p < 0.05). The morphological characterization indicated that salt ions accelerated the erosion and fragmentation of coarse particles to form fine particles. The use of reclaimed water to flush smelting sites may increase the risk of Cd migration with small-sized soil particles from the soil to groundwater.

The spatial distribution, health risk, and cytotoxicity of metal(loid)s in contaminated field soils: The role of Cd in human gastric cells damage

The spatial distribution and pollution level of heavy metal(loid)s in soil (0-6 m) from a typical industrial region in Jiangmen City, Southeast China was investigated. Their bioaccessibility, health risk, and human gastric cytotoxicity in topsoil were also evaluated using an in vitro digestion/human cell model. The average concentrations of Cd (87.52 mg/kg), Co (106.9 mg/kg), and Ni (1007 mg/kg) exceeded the risk screening values. The distribution profiles of metal(loid)s showed a downward migration trend to reach a depth of 2 m. The highest contamination was found in topsoil (0-0.5 m), with the concentrations of As, Cd, Co, and Ni being 46.98, 348.28, 317.44, and 2395.60 mg/kg, respectively, while Cd showed the highest bioaccessibility in the gastric phase (72.80 %), followed by Co (21.08 %), Ni (18.27 %), and As (5.26 %) and unacceptable carcinogenic risk. Moreover, the gastric digesta of topsoil suppressed the cell viability and triggered cell apoptosis, evidenced by disruption of mitochondrial transmembrane potential and increase of Cytochrome c (Cyt c) and Caspases 3/9 mRNA expression. Bioaccessible Cd in topsoil was responsible for those adverse effects. Our data suggest the importance to reduce Cd in the soil to decrease its adverse impacts on the human stomach.

Method for establishing soil contaminant discharge inventory: An arsenic-contaminated site case study

The existing method to survey site pollution is generally based on soil-groundwater sampling and instrumental analysis, which enables us to access the detailed soil pollution status while lacking quantitative association with industrial activities. It is urgent to understand contaminant discharge modes and establish a discharge inventory for achieving process-targeted pollution control. This study took a 40-year phosphate fertilizer-sulfuric acid site as an example and constructed a contaminant tracing method based on on-site investigations and detailed industrial data. These investigations and data were combined to determine the characteristic pollutant of this site, arsenic. And the calculation process of four-pathway pollution modes (atmospheric deposition, wastewater, solid waste leaching, and storage dripping) is derived from the existing acceptance criteria and risk assessment guidelines. They are set to calculate the arsenic's factory-to-soil discharge flux. The absent process contaminant release information and parameters, such as discharge coefficient, were obtained from soil-groundwater pollution control standards and discharge handbooks. It was found that the high concentration of arsenic (around 1930 mg g^-1) was preponderantly caused by sulfur-iron slag and tailing leaching (96.19%), while the other pathways accounted for only 0.13% (atmospheric deposition), 3.59% (wastewater) and 0.09% (storage tank). Results were verified by the measured arsenic concentration, and the difference was +16.29%, which was acceptable. Finally, a contaminant discharge inventory was established with high-resolution spatial distribution and time-scale (historical discharge) evolution. The innovation of this study lies in the preliminary construction of a method for formulating soil discharge inventory. This study would contribute to the refined management of site pollution and reduction of source contaminants discharge. In addition, it will help infer the pollution condition of sites that are difficult to sample so as to help the government achieve precise source control.

Source apportionment and quantitative risk assessment of heavy metals at an abandoned zinc smelting site based on GIS and PMF models

The abandoned smelters have caused serious hazards to the surrounding environment and residents. Taking an abandoned zinc smelter in southern China as an example, a total of 245 soil samples were collected to study spatial heterogeneity, source apportionment, and source-derived risk assessment of heavy metal(loid)s (HMs) in the region. The results showed that the mean values of all HMs concentrations were higher than the local background values, with Zn, Cd, Pb, and As contamination being the most serious and their plume penetrating to the bottom layer. Four sources were identified by principal component analysis and positive matrix factorization, with their contributions to the HMs contents ranked as: surface runoff (F2, 63.2%) > surface solid waste (F1, 22.2%) > atmospheric deposition (F3, 8.5%) > parent material (F4, 6.1%). Among these, F1 was a determinant source of human health risk with a contribution rate of 60%. Therefore, F1 was considered to be the priority control factor, but it only accounted for 22.2% of HMs contents contribution. Hg dominated the ecological risk with a contribution of 91.1%. Pb (25.7%) and As (32.9%) accounted for the non-carcinogenic risk, while As (95%) dominated the carcinogenic effect. The spatial characteristics of human health risk values derived from F1 indicated that high-risk areas were mainly distributed in the casting finished products area, electrolysis area, leaching-concentration area, and fluidization roasting area. The findings highlight the significance of priority control factors (including HMs, pollution sources and functional areas) for consideration in the integrated management of this region, thus saving costs for effective soil remediation.

Cocultivation with Solanum nigrum and inoculation with Rhizophagus intraradices can improve plant photosynthesis and antioxidant defense to alleviate cadmium toxicity to soybean

High Cd pollution can damage plant physiology and seriously threaten ecological security and human health. Therefore, we designed a cropping system, arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) - soybean - Solanum nigrum L., to solve the high Cd pollution problem in an environmentally and economically friendly way. The results showed that AMF were able to break free from the constraints of cocultivation and still promote plant photosynthesis and growth in combined treatments to resist Cd stress. In addition, cocultivation combined with AMF improved the antioxidant defense to scavenge reactive oxygen species by promoting the production of antioxidant enzymes and nonenzyme substances in host plants. The glutathione content in soybean and the catalase activity in nightshade were recorded at the highest values under cocultivation combined with AMF treatment, which were 23.68% and 129.12% higher than those of monoculture without AMF treatments. The improvement in antioxidant defense alleviated oxidative stress, which was manifested by the reduction in Cd dense electronic particles in the ultrastructure and a 26.38% decrease in MDA content. Furthermore, this cropping mode combined the advantages of cocultivation to improve the Cd extraction efficiency and Rhizophagus intraradices to limit Cd accumulation and transport so that Cd was more accumulated and restricted in the roots of the cocultivated Solanum nigrum L., and the Cd concentration in soybean beans was reduced by 56% compared with the soybean monoculture without AMF treatment. Therefore, we suggest that this cropping system is a comprehensive and mild remediation technology suitable for highly Cd-contaminated soil.

Periplasmic space is the key location for Pb(II) biomineralization by Burkholderia cepacia

Phosphate solubilizing bacteria (PSB) induced phosphate precipitation is considered as an effective method for Pb(II) removal through the formation of stable Pb(II)-phosphate compound, but the location of end-products is still unclear. Herein, the PSB strain of Burkholderia cepacia (B. cepacia) coupled with the hydroxyapatite (HAP) was used in this study to investigate the Pb(II) removal mechanism and the biomineralization location. The dissolving phosphate of three particle sizes of HAP and Pb(II) resistant capabilities, and the effect factors such as HAP dosage, initial concentrations of Pb(II), pH, temperature, and different treatments were determined. The results indicated that the highest soluble phosphate could reach 224.85 mg/L in a 200 nm HAP medium and the highest removal efficiency of Pb(II) was about 96.32 %. Additionally, it was interesting that Pb(II) was mainly located in the periplasmic space through the cellular distribution experiment, which was further demonstrated by scanning electron microscope (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Besides, the characterization results showed that the functional groups such as amide, hydroxy, carboxy and phosphate played an important role in Pb(II) biomineralization, and the free Pb(II) in aqueous solution could be transformed into pyromorphite through phosphate dissolution, extracellular adsorption/complexation, and intracellular precipitation.