Effects of non-reducible dissolved solutes on reductive dechlorination of trichloroethylene by ball milled zero valent irons

Minor chromium passivation of S-ZVI enhanced the long-term dechlorination performance of trichlorethylene: Effects of corrosion and passivation on the reactivity and selectivity

The corrosion and surface passivation of sulfidized zero-valent iron (S-ZVI) by common groundwater ions and contaminants are considered to be the most challenging aspects in the application of S-ZVI for remediation of chlorinated contaminants. This study investigated the impacts of corrosive chloride (Cl-) and passivation of hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) on the long-term reactivity, selectivity, corrosion behavior, and physicochemical properties during the 60-day aging process of S-ZVI. Although the co-existing of Cl- promoted the initial reactivity of S-ZVI, the rapid consumption of Fe° content shortened the reactive lifetime owing to the insufficient electron capacity. Severe passivation by Cr(VI) (30 mg L-1) preserved the Fe° content but significantly interfered with the reductive sulfur species, resulting in an increase in electron transfer resistance. In comparison, minor passivated S-ZVI (5.0 mg L-1 Cr(VI)) inhibited the hydrogen evolution while concurrently mitigating the further oxidation of the reductive iron and sulfur species, which significantly enhanced the long-term reactivity and selectivity of S-ZVI. Furthermore, the enhancement effect of minor passivation could be detected in the aging processes of one-step, two-step, and mechanochemically synthesized S-ZVI particles with different S/Fe ratios and precursors, which further verified the advantages of minor passivation. This observation is inspirable for the development of innovative strategies for environmental remediation by S-ZVI-based materials.

Reductive dechlorination of trichloroethene by sulfided microscale zero-valent iron in fresh and saline groundwater: Reactivity, pathways, and selectivity

S/mZVI is a promising material for groundwater remediation due to its excellent properties. However, the reactivity and electron selectivity toward target contaminant are critical. Thus, this study investigated the effect of complex groundwater chemistries (Milli-Q water, fresh groundwater and saline groundwater) on the reactivity of S/mZVI toward trichloroethylene (TCE), dechlorination pathway, hydrogen evolution kinetic, electron efficiency and aging behaviors. Results showed that sulfidation appreciably increased the reactivity and electron selectivity. The major degradation product of TCE dechlorination by S/mZVI was acetylene, which was consistent with TCE dechlorination by β-elimination. Moreover, reductive β-elimination was still the dominant dechlorination pathway for the application of S/mZVI in three groundwater conditions. However, the rates and the quantities of major products from TCE degradation varied significantly. S/mZVI in saline groundwater can maintain the reactivity towardTCE due to the protection of Fe0 by Fe3O4 deposited on the surface. Thus, the higher TCE removal efficiency and less hydrogen accumulation resulted in the greatest electron efficiency (4.3-79.2%). Overall, S/mZVI was more effective for the application in saline groundwater. This study proved insight into the comprehensive evaluation and implications for the application of S/mZVI based technologies in saline contaminated groundwater.

Cations facilitate sulfidation of zero-valent iron by elemental sulfur: Mechanism and dechlorination application

The solid-solid reaction of microscale zero-valent iron (mZVI) with elemental sulfur (S0) in water can form sulfidated mZVI (S-mZVI) with high reactivity and selectivity. However, the inherent passivation layer of mZVI hinders the sulfidation. In this study, we demonstrate that ionic solutions of Me-chloride (Me: Mg2+, Ca2+, K+, Na+ and Fe2+) can accelerate the sulfidation of mZVI by S0. The S0 with S/Fe molar ratio of 0.1 was fully reacted with mZVI in all solutions to form unevenly distributed FeS species on S-mZVIs as confirmed by SEM-EDX and XANES characterization. The cations depassivated the mZVI surface by driving the proton release from the surface site (FeOH) and resulting in localized acidification. The probe reaction test (tetrachloride dechlorination) and open circuit potential (EOCP) measurement demonstrated that Mg2+ was most efficient in depassivating the mZVI and therefore promoting sulfidation. The decrease of surface proton for hydrogenolysis on the S-mZVI synthesized in MgCl2 solution also inhibited the formation of cis-1,2-dichloroethylene by 14-79% compared to other S-mZVIs during trichloroethylene dechlorination. In addition, the synthesized S-mZVIs exhibited the highest reduction capacity reported so far. These findings provide a theoretical basis for the facile on-site sulfidation of mZVI by S0 with cation-rich natural waters for sustainable remediation of contaminated sites.

Sulfidated microscale zero-valent iron/reduced graphene oxide composite (S-mZVI/rGO) for enhanced degradation of trichloroethylene: The role of hydrogen spillover

Atomic hydrogen (H*) has long been thought to play an important role in the dechlorination of trichloroethylene (TCE) by carbon-supported zero-valent iron (ZVI), which offers an alternative pathway for TCE dechlorination. Herein, we demonstrate that the reductive dechlorination of TCE by sulfidated microscale ZVI (S-mZVI) can be further enhanced by promoting the formation of H* through the introduction of reduced graphene oxide (rGO). The completely degradation of 10 mg/L TCE can be achieved by S-mZVI/rGO within 24 h, which was 3.3 times faster than that of S-mZVI. The change in the distribution of TCE degradation products over time suggests that the introduction of rGO leads to a change in the dechlorination pathway. The percentage of ethane in the final products of TCE degradation by S-mZVI/rGO was 34.3 %, while that of S-mZVI was only 21.9 %. The electrochemical tests confirmed the occurrence of hydrogen spillover in the S-mZVI/rGO composite, which promoted the reductive dechlorination of TCE by H*. Although the S-mZVI/rGO composite had stronger hydrogen evolution propensity than S-mZVI, the S-mZVI/rGO composite still exhibited higher electron utilization efficiency than S-mZVI thanks to the increased utilization of hydrogen.

Decoupling Fe0 Application and Bioaugmentation in Space and Time Enables Microbial Reductive Dechlorination of Trichloroethene to Ethene: Evidence from Soil Columns

Fe⁰ is a powerful chemical reductant with applications for remediation of chlorinated solvents, including tetrachloroethene and trichloroethene. Its utilization efficiency at contaminated sites is limited because most of the electrons from Fe⁰ are channeled to the reduction of water to H₂ rather than to the reduction of the contaminants. Coupling Fe⁰ with H₂-utilizing organohalide-respiring bacteria (i.e., Dehalococcoides mccartyi) could enhance trichloroethene conversion to ethene while maximizing Fe⁰ utilization efficiency. Columns packed with aquifer materials have been used to assess the efficacy of a treatment combining in space and time Fe⁰ and aD. mccartyi-containing culture (bioaugmentation). To date, most column studies documented only partial conversion of the solvents to chlorinated byproducts, calling into question the feasibility of Fe⁰ to promote complete microbial reductive dechlorination. In this study, we decoupled the application of Fe⁰ in space and time from the addition of organic substrates andD. mccartyi-containing cultures. We used a column containing soil and Fe⁰ (at 15 g L^-1 in porewater) and fed it with groundwater as a proxy for an upstream Fe⁰ injection zone dominated by abiotic reactions and biostimulated/bioaugmented soil columns (Bio-columns) as proxies for downstream microbiological zones. Results showed that Bio-columns receiving reduced groundwater from the Fe⁰-column supported microbial reductive dechlorination, yielding up to 98% trichloroethene conversion to ethene. The microbial community in the Bio-columns established with Fe⁰-reduced groundwater also sustained trichloroethene reduction to ethene (up to 100%) when challenged with aerobic groundwater. This study supports a conceptual model where decoupling the application of Fe⁰ and biostimulation/bioaugmentation in space and/or time could augment microbial trichloroethene reductive dechlorination, particularly under oxic conditions.

Coupled microscale zero valent iron-autotrophic hydrogen bacteria dechlorination system is not always superior to its standalone counterparts: A sustainable remediation perspective

The coupling of microscale zero-valent iron with autotrophic hydrogen bacteria (mZVI-AHB) are often believed to show greater potential than the single abiotic or biotic systems in remediating chlorinated aliphatic hydrocarbon-contaminated groundwater. However, our understanding of the remediation performance of this system under real field conditions, especially by incorporating the concept of sustainable remediation, remains limited. In this study, the performances of the mZVI, H₂-AHB, and mZVI-AHB systems in dechlorinating groundwater containing complex electron acceptors were compared by evaluating their removal efficiency (RE), reaction products, and electron efficiency (EE), using trichloroethylene (TCE) as the target contaminant and NO₃^- and SO₄^2- as the coexisting natural electron acceptors. Ultimately, which of these systems had TCE removal superiority was dependent on the coexisting electron acceptor. mZVI-AHB and mZVI resulted in more complete dechlorination, whereas H₂-AHB exhibited higher N₂ selectivity in reducing NO₃^-. Regardless of the coexisting electron acceptor, the mZVI-alone system showed the highest EE. Finally, the sustainability concerns and applicability of the three systems were evaluated on the basis of their TCE RE, complete dechlorination ratio, N₂ selectivity, EE, and cost, which were integrated into a comparison of overall benefits. Our findings provide comprehensive and insightful information on the factors that determine remediation scheme selection in real practice.

Effect of sulfidation on nitrobenzene removal from groundwater by microscale zero-valent iron: Insights into reactivity, reaction sites and removal pathways

While it has been recognized that sulfidation can effectively improve the reactivity of microscale zero valent iron (mZVI), there is limited understanding of nitrobenzene (ArNO₂) removal by sulfidated mZVI. To understand the reduction capacity and pathway of ArNO₂ by sulfidated mZVI, ball-milling sulfidated mZVI (S-mZVI^bm) with different S/Fe molar ratios (0-0.2) was used to conduct this experiment. The results showed that sulfidation could efficiently enhance ArNO₂ removal under iron-limited and iron excess conditions, which was attributed to the presence of FeS_x sites that could provide higher Fe(0) utilization efficiency and stronger passivation resisting for S-mZVI^bm. The optimum ArNO₂ reduction could be obtained by S-mZVI^bm with S/Fe molar ratio at 0.1, which could completely transform ArNO₂ to aniline (ArNH₂) with a rate constant of 4.36 × 10^-2 min^-1 during 120-min reaction. FeS_x phase could act as electron transfer sites for ArNO₂ reduction and it could still be reserved in S-mZVI^bm after reduction reaction. The product distribution indicated that sulfidation did not change the types of reduction products, while the removal of ArNO₂ by S-mZVI^bm was a step-by-step reduction progress along with the adsorption of ArNH₂. In addition, a faster reduction of ArNO₂ in groundwater/soil system further demonstrated the feasibility of S-mZVI^bm in the real field remediation.

A quantitative study of the effects of particle' properties and environmental conditions on the electron efficiency of Pd and sulfidated nanoscale zero-valent irons

Electron efficiency (or electron selectivity, ɛ_e) is an important quantitative criterion for zero-valent iron treatment of organohalide contaminated groundwater. The aim of this quantitative study was the systematic exploration and comparison of the effects of the Pd/Fe and S/Fe molar ratios (i.e., [Pd/Fe] and [S/Fe]), trichloroethylene (TCE) concentrations ([TCE]), pH solution, aging time, and water matrices on the ɛ_e of Pd-nZVI and S-nZVI. To this end, we used TCE as a probe contaminant. The ɛ_e of Pd-nZVI increased and then decreased with [Pd/Fe], while that of S-nZVI increased with [S/Fe], as more hydrophobic FeS₂ was formed on S-nZVI at higher [S/Fe]. The ε_e of S-nZVI and Pd-nZVI increased with increasing [TCE]. Specifically, the ε_e of S-nZVI and Pd-nZVI at [TCE] of 200 ppm increased by 24.9 % and 79.3 %, respectively, compared with that at [TCE] of 10 ppm. As the H₂ evolution reaction (HER) was more sensitive to surface passivation than TCE dechlorination, the ε_e of S-nZVI and Pd-nZVI under alkaline conditions was higher than that under basic conditions, and increased by 11.7 % and 37.8 %, respectively, at pH 10 relative to that at pH 6. The ε_e also increased with the aging time of the S-nZVI and Pd-nZVI particles; the increase was by 27.2 % and 59.6 %, respectively, at aging time of 30 d compared with that of the fresh ones. The ɛ_e of both particles were higher in artificial groundwater (AGW) than in real groundwater (RGW). For all batch experiments, the ε_e of S-nZVI increased over the reaction time and tended to outperform that of Pd-nZVI, even though the ε_e of Pd-nZVI was higher than that of S-nZVI at the initial stage of TCE dechlorination, thereby justifying the longevity of S-nZVI.

Enhanced elimination of V5+ in wastewater using zero-valent iron activated by ball milling: The overlooked crucial roles of energy input and sodium chloride

The ball-milling technology, a highly efficient and cost-effective method, had excellent application prospects for overcoming passivation issues of normal zero-valent iron (ZVI) to enhance the decontamination efficiency. In this work, we investigated the effects and mechanisms of pH, process control agents (PCA), and main process parameters on the removal of V⁵⁺ using ball-milled zero-valent iron (ZVI^bm). The results showed that ZVI was successfully activated due to mechanochemical action. The enhanced proton conductivity of ZVI^bm leaded to the rapid production of more Fe²⁺, thereby resulting in an order of magnitude higher elimination of V⁵⁺ by ZVI^bm than by ZVI under near-neutral conditions. In addition, the introduction of NaCl in the ball milling process could not only effectively alleviate the agglomeration phenomenon of ZVI^bm, but also effectively enhance its activity. Unexpectedly, due to over-compaction and small size effects, excessive energy input weakened the reactivity of ZVI^bm on V⁵⁺ elimination. Various characterization results confirmed that the removal of V⁵⁺ by ZVI^bm was dominated by reduction and supplemented by adsorption. This work updated the basic understanding of the critical effects of process parameters and NaCl on ZVI^bm in the remediation of vanadium-containing wastewater.

Effects of magnetic field on selenite removal by sulfidated zero valent iron under aerobic conditions

A novel strategy of sulfide modified zero valent iron (S-ZVI) coupled with the magnetic field (MF) is developed for selenite (Se(IV)) removal. The original ZVI particle size (30 μm), S/Fe ratio (1:80), solution pH (5), S-ZVI loading (0.75 g L^-1), and MF intensity (20 mT) can exhibit the optimal enhancement effects of MF on Se(IV) removal by S-ZVI. Common corrosion promoters (Cl^-, PO₄^3-, SO₄^2-, Mg²⁺, and Ca²⁺) and inhibitors (NO₃^-, SiO₃^2-, and CO₃^2-) show positive and negative effects on Se(IV) removal by S-ZVI, respectively. But MF can alleviate promoting or inhibiting effects of coexisting ions on Se(IV) removal by S-ZVI, and well preserve the reactivity of S-ZVI from background ions in water. Furthermore, MF can also enhance the reactivity of S-ZVI towards Se(IV) during consecutive experiments, the promotion factor (the ratio of k_obs with MF to k_obs without MF) increased from 2.57 to 5.83 with the increase of cycles. MF can not only improve the reactivity of ZVI covered with iron oxide or iron hydroxide but also effectively enhance the ability of ZVI covered with iron sulfide. S-ZVI exhibited good stability and recyclability in the presence of MF. XANES analysis of selenium species reveals that the reductive product of Se(IV) with or without MF is primarily Se(0), and Se(IV) removal by S-ZVI can be ascribed to adsorption and reduction. This work indicates that MF may widen the application of S-ZVI for pollutants removal in environmental remediation.

Molecular Structure and Sulfur Content Affect Reductive Dechlorination of Chlorinated Ethenes by Sulfidized Nanoscale Zerovalent Iron

Sulfidized nanoscale zerovalent iron (SNZVI) with desirable properties and reactivity has recently emerged as a promising groundwater remediation agent. However, little information is available on how the molecular structure of chlorinated ethenes (CEs) affects their dechlorination by SNZVI or whether the sulfur content of SNZVI can alter their dechlorination pathway and reactivity. Here, we show that the reactivity (up to 30-fold) and selectivity (up to 70-fold) improvements of SNZVI (compared to NZVI) toward CEs depended on the chlorine number, chlorine position, and sulfur content. Low CEs (i.e., vinyl chloride and cis-1,2-dichloroethene) and high CEs (perchloroethene) tended to be dechlorinated by SNZVI primarily via atomic H and direct electron transfer, respectively, while SNZVI could efficiently and selectively dechlorinate trichloroethene and trans-1,2-dichloroethene via both pathways. Increasing the sulfidation degree of SNZVI suppressed its ability to produce atomic H but promoted electron transfer and thus altered the relative contributions of atomic H and electron transfer to the CE dechlorination, resulting in different reactivities and selectivities. These were indicated by the correlations of CE dechlorination rates and improvements with CE molecular descriptors, H₂ evolution rates, and electron transfer indicators of SNZVI. These mechanistic insights indicate the importance of determining the structure-specific properties and reactivity of both SNZVI materials and their target contaminants and can lead to a more rational design of SNZVI for in situ groundwater remediation of various CEs.

Evaluation of self-oxidation and selectivity of iron-based reductant in anaerobic pentachlorophenol contaminated soil

Soil contamination due to chlorinated organics prompts an important environmental problem; however, the iron-based reduction materials and complicated ground environment are the main barriers to implementation and promotion of in situ soil remediation. Therefore, this study aims to evaluate the reductants zero-valent iron (ZVI) and its activated carbon composite (AC-ZVI) in terms of their self-oxidation and selectivity in soil experiments. The results indicated that saturated moisture conditions were beneficial for degradation due to the dispersal of the pollutants from soil particles. Particularly, increasing the water/soil ratio to the over-saturated state would decrease the selectivity of ZVI and AC-ZVI. Meanwhile, increasing the reductant loading decreased the selectivity of ZVI and AC-ZVI, whereas the high initial concentration increased the selectivity of AC-ZVI. In addition, the self-oxidation of ZVI (3.0 ×10^-3 h^-1) is 4.2 times higher than that of AC-ZVI (0.7 ×10^-3 h^-1), and the selectivity of AC-ZVI (48%) is 6.9 times higher than that of ZVI (7%), which confirmed that AC-ZVI is a superior iron-based amendment in saturated moisture conditions. Therefore, this study provides a reliable and feasible evaluation method for in situ remediation process, and deepens the understanding of the effects of moisture contents.

Enhanced dechlorination of trichloroethene by sulfidated microscale zero-valent iron under low-frequency AC electromagnetic field

In this study an electromagnetic heating strategy is proposed for remediation of trichloroethene (TCE) by ball milled, sulfidated microscale zero valent iron (S-mZVI^bm) particles. S-mZVI^bm is ferromagnetic, which generates heat under the application of a low-frequency alternating current electromagnetic field (AC EMF). We found that the temperature reached up to ~120 ℃ during 30-min electromagnetic induction heating of 10 g/L S-mZVI^bm (with S/Fe molar ratio of 0.1), compared with ~55 ℃ and ~80 ℃ for ZVI and ball milled mZVI^bm, respectively. The application of AC EMF accelerated the TCE degradation rate (k_TCE = 5.5 × 10^-1 h^-1) by up to 4-fold without compromising or even enhancing electron efficiency of S-mZVI^bm compared to no-heating. Furthermore, this process halved the generation of chlorinated intermediate, cis-DCE. In contrast, water-bath heating only increased the dechlorination rate 2-fold with unchanged cis-DCE generation and lowered electron efficiency. This is attributed to both rising temperature by induction heating and accelerated ZVI corrosion and surface Fe⁰ exposure caused by AC EMF. In real groundwater, the AC EMF maintained the same promoting effects for TCE dechlorination by S-mZVI^bm. This study shows that combination of filed-scale available AC EMF with S-mZVI^bm provides a promising approach for remediation of chlorinated hydrocarbons in contaminated groundwater.

A review of the new multifunctional nano zero-valent iron composites for wastewater treatment: Emergence, preparation, optimization and mechanism

Nano zero-valent iron (NZVI) with high chemical reactivity and environmental friendliness had recently become one of the most efficient technologies for wastewater restoration. However, the unitary NZVI system had not met practical requirements for wastewater treatments. Expectantly, the development of NZVI would prefer multifunctional NZVI-based composites, which could be prepared and optimized by the combined methods and technologies. Consequently, a systematic and comprehensive summary from the perspective of multifunctional NZVI-composite had been conducted. The results demonstrated that the advantages of various systems were integrated by multifunctional NZVI-composite systems with a more significant performance of pollutant removal than those of the bare NZVI and its composites. Simultaneously, characteristics of the product prepared by the incorporation of numerous methods were superior to those by a simple method, resulting in the increase of the entirety efficiency. By comparison with other preparation methods, the ball milling method with higher production and field application potential was worthy of attention. After combining multiple technologies, the effect of NZVI and its composite systems could be dramatically strengthened. Preparation technology parameters and treatment effect of contaminants could be further optimized using more comprehensive experimental designs and mathematical models. The mechanism of the multifunctional NZVI system for contaminants treatment was primarily focused on adsorption, oxidation, reduction and co-precipitation. Multiple techniques were combined to enhance the dispersion, alleviating passivation, accelerating electron transfer efficiency or mass transfer action for optimizing the effect of NZVI composites.

Recent Advances in Sulfidated Zerovalent Iron for Contaminant Transformation

2021 marks 10 years since controlled abiotic synthesis of sulfidated nanoscale zerovalent iron (S-nZVI) for use in site remediation and water treatment emerged as an area of active research. It was then expanded to sulfidated microscale ZVI (S-mZVI) and together with S-nZVI, they are collectively referred to as S-(n)ZVI. Heightened interest in S-(n)ZVI stemmed from its significantly higher reactivity to chlorinated solvents and heavy metals. The extremely promising research outcomes during the initial period (2011-2017) led to renewed interest in (n)ZVI-based technologies for water treatment, with an explosion in new research in the last four years (2018-2021) that is building an understanding of the novel and complex role of iron sulfides in enhancing reactivity of (n)ZVI. Numerous studies have focused on exploring different S-(n)ZVI synthesis approaches, and its colloidal, surface, and reactivity (electrochemistry, contaminant selectivity, and corrosion) properties. This review provides a critical overview of the recent milestones in S-(n)ZVI technology development: (i) clear insights into the role of iron sulfides in contaminant transformation and long-term aging, (ii) impact of sulfidation methods and particle characteristics on reactivity, (iii) broader range of treatable contaminants, (iv) synthesis for complete decontamination, (v) ecotoxicity, and (vi) field implementation. In addition, this review discusses major knowledge gaps and future avenues for research opportunities.

Biosynthesis of vivianite from microbial extracellular electron transfer and environmental application

Vivianite (Fe₃(PO₄)₂·8H₂O) is a common hydrous ferrous phosphate mineral which often occurs in reductive conditions, especially anoxic non-sulfide environment containing high concentrations of ferrous iron (Fe²⁺) and orthophosphate (PO₄^3-). Vivianite is an important product of dissimilatory iron reduction and a promising route for phosphorus recovery from wastewater. Its formation is closely related to the extracellular electron transfer (EET), a key mechanism for microbial respiration and a crucial explanation for the reduction of metal oxides in soil and sediments. Despite of the natural ubiquity, easy accessibility and attractive economic value, the application value of vivianite has not received much attention. This review introduces the characteristics, occurrence and biosynthesis of vivianite from microbial EET, and systematically analyzes the application value of vivianite in the environmental field, including immobilization of heavy metals (HMs), dechlorination of carbon tetrachloride (CT), sedimentary phosphorus sequestration and eutrophication alleviation. Additionally, its potential functions as a slow-release fertilizer are discussed as well. In general, vivianite is expected to make more contributions to the future scientific research, especially the solution of environmental problems. Overcoming the lack of understanding and some technical limitations will be beneficial to the further application of vivianite in environmental field.

Mechanistic role of nitrate anion in TCE dechlorination by ball milled ZVI and sulfidated ZVI: Experimental investigation and theoretical analysis

Mechanistic role of NO₃^- in trichloroethylene (TCE) dechlorination by ball milled, micro-scale sulfidated and unsulfidated ZVI (e.g., S-mZVI^bm and mZVI^bm) was explored through experiments and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Sulfidation inhibited NO₃^- reduction by mZVI^bm as S weakened its interaction with NO₃^-. mZVI^bm reduced NO₃^- within 2 h. This just resulted in a short-term electron competition during the dechlorination process by mZVI^bm and hardly affected its sluggish dechlorination kinetics (complete TCE dechlorination in 11 d). On the contrary, NO₃^- suppressed TCE dechlorination by S-mZVI^bm. This was attributed to that inhibited NO₃^- reduction by S-mZVI^bm (40 % reduction in 6 h) induced continuous electron competition with TCE during the time span of its dechlorination by S-mZVI^bm. NO₃^- reduction was also observed to facilitate formation/crystallization of Fe₃O₄ on both ZVI particles, promoting dechlorination by mZVI^bm after 4 d while not taking effect to the S-mZVI^bm/TCE system, as its dechlorination time was too short for the surface of S-mZVI^bm to transform. This observation has important implication on groundwater remediation by ZVI or sulfidated ZVI PRBs under a scenario of upgradient anthropogenic release of NO₃^-.