The persistent impacts of polyester microfibers on soil bio-physical properties following thermal treatment

Microplastics in agroecosystems: Commentary on soil-plant dynamics and effective remediation approaches

Increasing microplastic (MP) pollution, mainly by anthropogenic sources such as plastic film mulching, waste degradation, and agricultural practices, has emerged as a demanding global environmental concern. This review examines the direct and indirect effects of MPs on crops, both in isolation and in conjunction with other contaminants, to elucidate their combined toxicological impacts. Organic fertilizers predominantly contain 78.6% blue, 9.5% black, and 8.3% red MPs, while irrigation water in agroecosystems contains 66.2% white, 15.4% blue, and 8.1% black MPs, ranging from 0-1mm to 4-5mm in size. We elucidate five pivotal insights: Firstly, soil MPs exhibit affinity towards crop roots, seeds, and vascular systems, impeding water and nutrient uptake. Secondly, MPs induce oxidative stress in crops, disrupting vital metabolic processes. Thirdly, leachates from MPs elicit cytotoxic and genotoxic responses in crops. Fourthly, MPs disrupt soil biotic and abiotic dynamics, influencing water and nutrient availability for crops. Lastly, the cumulative effects of MPs and co-existing contaminants in agricultural soils detrimentally affect crop yield. Thus, we advocate agronomic interventions as practical remedies. These include biochar input, application of growth regulators, substitution of plastic mulch with crop residues, promotion of biological degradation, and encouragement of crop diversification. However, the efficacy of these measures varies based on MP type and dosage. As MP volumes increase, exploration of alternative mitigation strategies such as bio-based plastics and environmentally friendly biotechnological solutions is imperative. Recognizing the persistence of plastics, policymakers should enact legislation favoring the mitigation and substitution of non-degradable materials with bio-derived or compostable alternatives. This review demonstrates the urgent need for collective efforts to alleviate MP pollution and emphasizes sustainable interventions for agricultural ecosystems.

Effects of microplastics on soil microorganisms and microbial functions in nutrients and carbon cycling - A review

The harmful effects of microplastics (MPs) pollution in the soil ecosystem have drawn global attention in recent years. This paper critically reviews the effects of MPs on soil microbial diversity and functions in relation to nutrients and carbon cycling. Reports suggested that both plastisphere (MP-microbe consortium) and MP-contaminated soils had distinct and lower microbial diversity than that of non-contaminated soils. Alteration in soil physicochemical properties and microbial interactions within the plastisphere facilitated the enrichment of plastic-degrading microorganisms, including those involved in carbon (C) and nutrient cycling. MPs conferred a significant increase in the relative abundance of soil nitrogen (N)-fixing and phosphorus (P)-solubilizing bacteria, while decreased the abundance of soil nitrifiers and ammonia oxidisers. Depending on soil types, MPs increased bioavailable N and P contents and nitrous oxide emission in some instances. Furthermore, MPs regulated soil microbial functional activities owing to the combined toxicity of organic and inorganic contaminants derived from MPs and contaminants frequently encountered in the soil environment. However, a thorough understanding of the interactions among soil microorganisms, MPs and other contaminants still needs to develop. Since currently available reports are mostly based on short-term laboratory experiments, field investigations are needed to assess the long-term impact of MPs (at environmentally relevant concentration) on soil microorganisms and their functions under different soil types and agro-climatic conditions.

Machine learning prediction and interpretation of the impact of microplastics on soil properties

The annual microplastic (MP) release into soils is 4-23 times higher than that into oceans, significantly impacting soil quality. However, the mechanisms underlying how MPs impact soil properties remain largely unknown. Soil-MP interactions are complex because of soil heterogeneity and varying MP properties. This lack of understanding was exacerbated by the diverse experimental conditions and soil types used in this study. Predicting changes in soil properties in the presence of MPs is challenging, laborious, and time-consuming. To address these issues, machine learning was applied to fit datasets from peer-reviewed publications to predict and interpret how MPs influence soil properties, including pH, dissolved organic carbon (DOC), total P, NO3--N, NH4+-N, and acid phosphatase enzyme activity (acid P). Among the developed models, the gradient boost regression (GBR) model showed the highest R2 (0.86-0.99) compared to the decision tree and random forest models. The GBR model interpretation showed that MP properties contributed more than 50% to altering the acid P and NO3--N concentrations in soils, whereas they had a negligible impact on total P and 10-20% impact on soil pH, DOC, and NH4+-N. Specifically, the size of MPs was the dominant factor influencing acid P (89.3%), pH (71.6%), and DOC (44.5%) in soils. NO3--N was mainly affected by the MP type (52.0%). The NH4+-N was mainly affected by the MP dose (46.8%). The quantitative insights into the impact of MPs on soil properties of this study could aid in understanding the roles of MPs in soil systems.

Polyester microplastic fibers induce mitochondrial damage, apoptosis and oxidative stress in Daphnia carinata, accompanied by changes in apoptotic and ferroptosis pathway

With the widespread utilization of plastic products, microplastics (MPs) have merged as a newfound environmental contaminant in the United States, and the bulk of these MPs in the environment manifest as fibrous structures. Concerns have also been voiced regarding the potential hazards posed by microplastic fibers (MFs). However, research examining the toxicity of MFs, particularly in relation to planktonic organisms, remains severely limited. Meanwhile, polyester fiber materials find extensive applications across diverse industries. As a result, this investigation delved into the toxicology of polyester microplastic fibers (PET-MFs) with a focus on their impact on Daphnia carinata (D. carinata), a freshwater crustacean. Newly hatched D. carinata were subjected to varying concentrations of PET-MFs (0, 50, and 500 MFs/mL) to scrutinize the accumulation of PET-MFs within these organisms and their resultant toxicity. The outcomes revealed that D. carinata was capable of ingesting PET-MFs, leading to diminished rates of survival and reproduction. These effects were accompanied by mitochondrial impairment, heightened mitochondrial count, apoptosis, escalated generation of reactive oxygen species, augmented activity of antioxidant enzymes, and distinct patterns of gene expression. Interestingly, when comparing the group exposed to 50 MFs/mL with the one exposed to 500 MFs/mL, it was observed that the former triggered a more pronounced degree of mitochondrial damage, apoptosis, and oxidative stress. This phenomenon could be attributed to the fact that brief exposure to 500 MFs/mL resulted in greater mortality, eliminating individuals with lower adaptability. Those that survived managed to regulate elevated in vivo reactive oxygen species levels through an increase in glutathione S-transferase content, thereby establishing an adaptive mechanism. Low concentrations did not induce direct mortality, yet PET-MFs continued to inflict harm within the organism. RNA-seq analysis unveiled significant alterations in 279 and 55 genes in the 50 MFs/mL and 500 MFs/mL exposure groups, respectively. Functional enrichment analysis of the 50 MFs/mL group indicated involvement of the apoptosis pathway and ferroptosis pathway in the toxic effects exerted by PET-MFs on D. carinata. This study imparts valuable insights into the toxicological ramifications of PET-MFs on D. carinata, underscoring their potential risks within aquatic ecosystems.

Microplastic pollution on hiking and running trails in Australian protected environments

Microplastics (MPs) are ubiquitous worldwide, present even in remote areas of the natural environment. Hiking and trail running are a source of MPs on recreational trails in protected environments, which are characterised by high biodiversity and natural, ecological or cultural significance. Our understanding of the risks of microplastic pollution is impeded however by a lack of information on MPs present in the soil environment in such areas. This study characterised the quantity and physicochemical characteristics of MPs in two conservation areas in south-eastern Australia: 1) the adjacent Duval Nature Reserve and Dumaresq Dam Reserve, and 2) the Washpool and Gibraltar Range National Parks. We measured atmospheric deposition over a six-month period in the Reserves, and baseline amounts of MPs on recreational trails in the Reserves and National Parks. Atmospheric deposition averaged 17.4 MPs m^-2 day^-1 and was dominated by fibres, comprising 84 % of MPs. Microplastics detected on trail surfaces ranged from 162.5 ± 41.6 MPs/linear metre to 168.7 ± 18.5 MPs/linear metre and exhibited a very wide range of physical and chemical characteristics. The majority of MPs on the trail surfaces comprised polyurethane, polyethylene terephthalate and polystyrene, and 47-71 % were fibres. Microplastics were attributed to clothing, footwear, litter, and diffuse sources. Minimising and preventing MP pollution, however, is complex given there are multiple direct and diffuse sources, and several factors influencing increased MP deposition and retention in the environment.

Microplastics in soils during the COVID-19 pandemic: Sources, migration and transformations, and remediation technologies

The COVID-19 pandemic has led to a notable upsurge of 5-10 % in global plastic production, which could have potential implications on the soil quality through increased microplastics (MPs) content. The elevated levels of MPs in the soil poses a significant threat to both the environment and human health, hence necessitating the remediation of MPs in the environment. Despite the significant attention given to MPs remediation in aqueous environments, less consideration has been given to MPs remediation in the soil. Consequently, this review highlights the major sources of MPs in the soil, their migration and transformation behaviors during the COVID-19 pandemic, and emphasizes the importance of utilizing remediation technologies such as phytoremediation, thermal treatment, microbial degradation, and photodegradation for MPs in the soil. Furthermore, this review provides a prospective outlook on potential future remediation methods for MPs in the soil. Although the COVID-19 pandemic is nearing its end, the long-term impact of MPs on the soil remains, making this review a valuable reference for the remediation of MPs in the post-pandemic soil.

Characterization of microfibers released from chemically modified polyester fabrics - A step towards mitigation

Synthetic textiles are one of the significant contributors to microfiber pollution, a subclass of microplastics. The impact of microfibers on the environment is irreversible. Several attempts were made to mitigate and control the microfiber release from synthetic textiles by introducing filters and laundry aids in washing machines, whereas some came up with methods to modify the textile materials to release fewer fibers. Studies have related different textile properties with their microfiber release potential. However, moisture properties, one of the essential properties that determine comfort, are not well explored. Hence, this research attempted to mitigate the microfiber release by altering the hydrophilicity of the polyester fabrics through chemical treatment (sodium hydroxide) with the hypothesis that hydrophilicity reduces the microfiber release. Both woven and knitted polyester fabrics were treated with different concentrations of the alkali solution (0.25 M, 0.50 M, 0.75 M, 1.00 M) and evaluated for their microfiber release. Treated fabrics also showed variations in their moisture and physical properties. Woven fabrics showed reduced shedding compared to knitted fabrics due to their compact structure. The results showed that the increase in alkali concentration significantly reduced the microfiber release up to 89.6 % reduction with woven fabric (from 17.37 ± 1.55 fibers/sq.cm to 2.63 ± 0.23 fibers/sq.cm) and a reduction of 68 % was noted for knitted fabric treated with 0.75 M alkali concentration (from 24.38 ± 1.30 fibers/sq.cm to 8.74 ± 1.39 fibers/sq.cm). A higher negative correlation (r = 94 % for woven and 89 % for knitted) was noted between alkali concentration and microfiber release. The alkali treatment significantly reduced the average fiber length from 450 to 230 μm, and 63-93 % of the fibers identified were in size range of 100-500 μm. When the moisture properties of the alkali-treated fabrics are concerned, an increase in moisture properties reduces the microfiber release. Water contact angle and absorbency time positively correlated with microfiber release. However, the study did not show any significant effect of moisture regain percentage and vertical wicking on microfiber shedding. Except for abrasion resistance, the physical properties of alkali-treated fabric did not show any relationship with microfiber release. The study noted the order of factors influencing the microfiber release of polyester fabric as fabric structural parameters (Woven/Knits) > fabric hydrophilicity > fabric physical property.

Responses of bacterial communities to microplastics: More sensitive in less fertile soils

Recently, the potential impact of microplastics (MPs) on bacterial communities has risen enormously attention due to the increasing amount of plastic waste generated nowadays. However, there is a lack of clarity due to limited studies on the responses of bacterial communities to MPs exposures in various soil ecosystems. Here, we conducted a soil microcosm experiment to analyze the potential impact of MPs on bacterial communities in farmland soil, forest soil, and sandy soil. The changes in alpha/beta diversity and co-occurrence network of bacterial communities were more significant in farmland soil amended with PS MPs (5 g kg^-1), forest soil amended with PP MPs (5 g kg^-1), and sandy soil amended with PP MPs (1 g kg^-1). Particularly, the bacterial communities in sandy soil with the least soil organic carbon content were disturbed most significantly compared to other treatments. LEfSe analysis revealed that specific bacterial taxa such as phylum Proteobacteria, Actinobacteria, Firmicutes, and genus Sphingomonas, Candidatus Udaeobacter, Gemmatimonas, were sensitive to MPs exposures. Functional annotation showed that perturbation of bacterial communities was related to organic carbon decomposition, nitrogen fixation, nitrate reduction/respiration, etc. In sum, MPs may potentially affect bacterial community structure and functions relevant to carbon/nitrogen cycles at long-term realistic field exposure.

Review of research on migration, distribution, biological effects, and analytical methods of microfibers in the environment

Microplastics have been proven to be one of the critical environmental pollution issues. Moreover, microfibers, the most prominent form of microplastics in the environment, have likewise attracted the attention of various countries. With the increase in global population and industrialization, the production and use of fibers continue to increase yearly. As a result, a large number of microfibers are formed. If fiber products are not used or handled correctly, it will cause direct/indirect severe microfiber environmental pollution. Microfibers will be further broken into smaller fiber fragments when they enter the natural environment. Presently, researchers have conducted extensive research in the identification of microfibers, laying the foundation for further resourcefulness research. This work used bibliometric analysis to review the microfiber contamination researches systematically. First, the primary sources of microfibers and the influencing factors are analyzed. We aim to summarize the influence of the clothing fiber preparation and care processes on microfiber formation. Then, this work elaborated on the migration in/between water, atmosphere, and terrestrial environments. We also discussed the effects of microfiber on ecosystems. Finally, microfibers' current and foreseeable effective treatment, disposal, and resource utilization methods were explained. This paper will provide a structured reference for future microfiber research.

Soil microplastic characteristics and the effects on soil properties and biota: A systematic review and meta-analysis

The soil environment serves as an assembling area for microplastics, and is an important secondary source of microplastics in other environmental media. Recently, soil microplastics have been extensively studied; however, high variability is observed among the research results owing to different soil properties, and the complexity of soil microplastic composition. The present study amassed the findings of 2886 experimental groups, across 38 studies from 2016 to 2022, and used meta-analysis to quantitatively analyze the differences in the effects of microplastic exposure on soil physicochemical properties and biota. The results showed that among the existing soil microplastic research, agricultural soils maintained a higher environmental exposure distribution than other environments. Microplastic fibers and fragments were the predominant shapes, indicating that the extensive use of agricultural films are the primary influencing factor of soil microplastic pollution at present. The results of the meta-analysis found that microplastic exposure had a significant negative effect on soil bulk density (lnRR = -0.04) and aggregate stability (lnRR = -0.085), indicating that microplastics may damage the integrity of soil structure or damage the soil surface. The significant changes in plant root biomass and soil phosphatase further signified the potential impact of microplastics on soil nutrient and geochemical element cycling. We further constructed species sensitivity distribution curves, revealing that invertebrates had a higher species sensitivity to microplastics, as they can pass through the gut wall of soil nematodes, causing oxidative stress and affecting gene expression. In general, soil is an interconnected complex, and microplastic exposure can directly or indirectly interact with environmental chemical processes in the soil environment, potentially harming the soil ecosystem; however, current research remains insufficient with respect to breadth and depth in terms of the comprehensive "source-sink" mechanism of soil microplastics, the hazard of exposure, and the overall toxic effects.

Microplastics from agricultural plastic mulch films: A mini-review of their impacts on the animal reproductive system

Plastic mulch films (PMFs) are widely used to improve crop quality and quantity. Although they provide a range of benefits, they degrade into widespread microplastics (MPs), which can cause an unavoidable risk of environmental problems. The residue of PMFs is a significant source of MPs in soils, which can then spread into various ecosystems and be easily absorbed by organisms due to their small size, and subsequently transported through food chain. Notably, MPs have been found in the human placenta, stool and blood, raising an urgent reminder of the potential dangers of MPs to human health. This review summarizes recent studies concerning the effects of MPs on the reproductive system in soil invertebrates, aquatic animals and rodents of both sexes and the mechanisms by which MPs affect the animal reproductive system. The studies on females demonstrated that MPs decrease oocyte quantity and quality, and induce ovary fibrosis, pyroptosis and apoptosis of granulosa cells. In addition, disrupted integrity of the blood-testis barrier, damaged spermatogenesis and compromised sperm quality have been shown in most studies on male animals. The studies on the mechanisms of these effects have provided evidence that MPs act on the animal reproductive system through reactive oxygen species-related mechanisms by initiating the Wnt/β-Catenin and NLRP3/Caspase-1 pathways in females, and the Nrf2/HO-1/NF-κB, p38 MAPK and MAPK/Nrf2 pathways in males. Taken together, these studies reveal the reproductive toxicity of MPs from PMF on animals and serve as a reminder to properly dispose of PMF waste.

Wastewater treatment plant effluent and microfiber pollution: focus on industry-specific wastewater

The production, use, and disposal of synthetic textiles potentially release a significant amount of microfibers into the environment. Studies performed on municipal wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) effluent reported a higher presence of microfibers due to the mix of domestic laundry effluent through sewage. As municipal WWTPs receive influents from households and industries, it serves as a sink for the microfibers. However, research on textile industry WWTPs that primarily treat the textile fabric processing wastewater was not explored with the concern of microfibers. Hence, the review aims to analyze the existing literature and enlighten the impact of WWTPs on microplastic emission into the environment by specifically addressing textile industry WWTPs. The results of the review confirmed that even after 95-99% removal, municipal WWTPs can emit around 160 million microplastics per day into the environment. Microfiber was the dominant shape identified by the review. The average microfiber contamination in the WWTP sludge was estimated as 200 microfibers per gram of sludge. As far as the industry-specific effluents are analyzed, textile wet processing industries effluents contained > 1000 times higher microfibers than municipal WWTP. Despite few existing studies on textile industry effluent, the review demonstrates that, so far, no studies were performed on the sludge obtained from WWTPs that handle textile industry effluents alone. Review results pointed out that more attention should be needed to the textile wastewater research which is addressing the textile wet processing industry WWTPs. Moreover, the sludge released from these WWTPs should be considered as an important source of microfiber as they contain more quantity of microfibers than the effluent, and also, their routes to the environment are huge and easy.

Polyethylene microplastics alter the microbial functional gene abundances and increase nitrous oxide emissions from paddy soils

The accumulation of microplastics (MPs) in terrestrial ecosystems can affect greenhouse gases (GHGs) production by changing soil structure and microbial functions. In this study, microcosm experiments were conducted to investigate the impact of polyethylene (PE) MP addition on soil carbon dioxide (CO₂) and nitrous oxide (N₂O) emissions from paddy soils and their associated microbial functional genes. Methane was not considered due to the negligible emissions throughout the incubation. The amendment of both virgin and aged PE MPs did not significantly (p > 0.05) affect soil CO₂ emissions, but significantly (p < 0.05) increased the abundances of microbial functional genes encoding enzymes involved in hemicellulose (abfA) and lignin (mnp) decomposition, indicating plastic particle has potential to stimulate soil organic carbon decomposition. The presence of PE MP significantly increased N₂O emissions by 3.7-fold, which was probably due to PE MP increased the abundances of nirS gene involved in nitrite reductase. In addition, compared with virgin PE MP treatment, artificially aged PE MP did not significantly (p > 0.05) influence soil CO₂ and N₂O emissions. Our results provide evidence that PE MP likely cause a high risk of N₂O emission from paddy soils, this factor should be considered in future estimates of GHGs emissions from rice fields.

Activities of Microplastics (MPs) in Agricultural Soil: A Review of MPs Pollution from the Perspective of Agricultural Ecosystems

Microplastics are emerging persistent pollutants which have attracted increasing attention worldwide. Although microplastics have been widely detected in aquatic environments, their presence in soil ecosystems remains largely unexplored. Plastic debris accumulates in farmland, causing serious environmental problems, which may directly affect food substances or indirectly affect the members in each trophic level of the food chain. This review summarizes the origins, migration, and fate of microplastics in agricultural soils and discusses the interaction between microplastics and the components in farmland from the perspectives of toxicology and accumulation and deduces impacts on ecosystems by linking the organismal response to an ecological role. The effects on farmland ecosystem function are also discussed, emphasizing the supply of agricultural products, food chain pathways, carbon deposition, and nitrogen cycling and soil and water conservation, as microplastic pollution will affect agricultural ecosystems for a long period, posing an ecological risk. Finally, several directions for future research are proposed, which is important for reducing the effect of microplastics in agricultural systems.

Hazardous effects of road-side soils on the redox and cholinesterasic homeostasis of mound-building termite (Cornitermes cumulans)

For our knowledge, the roadside soils end up being the deposit of various residues discarded by drivers or passengers, plus, that coming from the runoff of rainwater. Basically, we do not know the impacts that this pollution causes on animals which inhabit these environments. Thus, in this study, our objective was to evaluate how the presence of plastic microfibers (MPFs), organic compounds and heavy metals affect the redox and cholinesterase homeostasis of mound-building termite [Cornitermes cumulans (workers) adults]. As a result, we noticed that MPFs were present in all sampled areas, being higher in road area (RA). Regardless of the presence of these pollutants, animals sampled in the RA were those in which we observed greater production of reactive oxygen species (ROS), hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) and nitric oxide (NO) (via nitrite), whose higher activities of antioxidant enzymes, superoxide dismutase (SOD) and catalase (CAT), was not able to counterbalance the oxidative stress suggested by the evaluated biomarkers. Moreover, we observed increase in acetylcholinesterase (AChE) activity in these same animals, which suggests a cholinesterasic effect. Such alterations were positively correlated with the contamination of soil samples by Cd, Pb, Zn, Fe and Cu, as well as with the presence of the 11,10-guaiane-type sesquiterpenoid compound, identified only in the RA. Thus, our unique study reveals that the contamination of roadside soils constitutes an additional environmental stressor to populations of C. cumulans, which reinforces the need for greater attention and further investigation to be given to the pollution of these environments.

Effects of microplastics on soil properties: Current knowledge and future perspectives

Microplastics (MPs) are a type of emerging contaminants that pose a potential threat to global terrestrial ecosystems, including agroecosystems. In recent years, MPs in soil and their adverse effects on soil health and fertility have attracted increasing concern. Based on the current knowledge, this review begins with a summary of the occurrence and characteristics of MPs in various soil environments, and then highlights the impacts of MPs on soil physical, chemical, and microbiological properties. Data show that MPs occur widely in all surveyed soil types, such as agricultural soils, industrial soils, urban soils, and unused soils, but show variation in their abundance, type, shape, and size. In most cases, MPs can change soil physical, chemical, and microbiological properties, but the effects vary, and are dependent on polymer type, shape, dose, and size. MPs-induced changes in soil fertility and the availability of pollutants may pose a potential threat to plant performance and crop productivity and safety. Particularly, MPs influence the emission of greenhouse gases from soil, ultimately leading to uncertain consequences for global climate change. More comprehensive and in-depth studies are required to fill large knowledge gaps.

Effects of microplastics on soil carbon dioxide emissions and the microbial functional genes involved in organic carbon decomposition in agricultural soil

The accumulation of microplastics (MPs) in agricultural fields can not only disguise soil organic carbon (SOC) storage but also affect the production of carbon dioxide (CO₂) by microbial decomposition. However, little is known about the impact of this emerging pollutant on soil CO₂ emissions and the functional genes related to SOC degradation. In the present study, a short-term (30-day) microcosm experiment was performed to investigate the effects of virgin and aged low-density polyethylene (LDPE) MPs on soil CO₂ emissions. We also measured functional gene abundances related to starch (sga), hemicellulose (abfA, manB and xylA), cellulose (cex) and lignin (lig and mnp) degradation through a high-throughput quantitative-PCR-based chip. Compared with the soils without MPs, low doses (0.01% and 0.1%) of both virgin and aged MPs had negligible effects on SOC decomposition, whereas a high dose (1.0%) of these two MPs significantly (p < 0.05) accelerated the production of CO₂ in soils by 15-17%, showing a dose-dependent effect. The presence of MPs did not significantly affect soil dissolved organic carbon or microbial biomass carbon. A higher metabolic quotient at 1.0% MP concentration indicated that the microbes were stressed and needed more substrates and energy during their metabolic process, which could likely explain the increase in CO₂ emission induced by this dose of MPs. Exposure to virgin MPs significantly reduced the functional genes related to hemicellulose (abfA and manB) degradation, whereas increasing the aged MPs concentrations significantly decreased the abundances of functional genes encoding starch (sga), hemicellulose (abfA, manB and xylA), and cellulose (cex) hydrolysis. Overall, we conclude that the low dose (<0.1%) of MPs in the soils has a negligible effect on the production of CO₂, but this factor should be considered in evaluating the global C budget in future research as this contaminant reaches a certain threshold (1.0%).