Interhospital failure to rescue after coronary artery bypass grafting

The burden of major complications on failure to rescue after surgery for acute type A aortic dissection: Analysis of more than 19,000 patients

BACKGROUND

The relationship between the number and type of postoperative complications and mortality in the setting for surgery for acute type A aortic dissection (ATAAD) remains underexplored despite its critical role in the failure-to-rescue (FTR) metric.

METHODS

This retrospective study used data from the Society of Thoracic Surgeons Adult Cardiac Surgical Database on ATAAD surgeries performed between January 2018 and December 2022. Patients were categorized based on their number of major complications. The primary outcome was FTR. We used multilevel regression and classification and regression tree models.

RESULTS

We included 19,243 patients (33% females), with a median age of 61 years. Regarding complications, 47.7% of patients had 0, 20.2% had 1, 12.7% had 2, and 19.4% experienced 3 or more. The most frequently reported complications were prolonged mechanical ventilation (30.3%), unplanned reoperation (19.5%), and renal failure (17.2%). Cardiac arrest occurred in 7.1% of cases. FTR increased from 13% in patients with 1 complication to >30% in those with 4 or more complications. Cardiac arrest (adjusted odds ratio [aOR], 10.9) and renal failure (aOR, 5.3) had the highest odds for mortality, followed by limb ischemia (aOR, 2.7), stroke (aOR, 2.6), and gastrointestinal complications (aOR, 2.4). Hospitals in the top performance quartile consistently showed lower FTR rates across all levels of complication.

CONCLUSIONS

The study validates a dose-response association between postoperative complications and mortality in patients undergoing surgery for ATAAD. Top-performing hospitals consistently show lower FTR rates independent of the number of complications. Future research should focus on the timing of complications and interventions to reduce the burden of complications.

Extracorporeal Life Support Organization Center of Excellence recognition is associated with improved failure to rescue after cardiac arrest

OBJECTIVE

The influence of Extracorporeal Life Support Organization (ELSO) center of excellence (CoE) recognition on failure to rescue after cardiac surgery is unknown. We hypothesized that ELSO CoE would be associated with improved failure to rescue.

METHODS

Patients undergoing a Society of Thoracic Surgeons index operation in a regional collaborative (2011-2021) were included. Patients were stratified by whether or not their operation was performed at an ELSO CoE. Hierarchical logistic regression analyzed the association between ELSO CoE recognition and failure to rescue.

RESULTS

A total of 43,641 patients were included across 17 centers. In total, 807 developed cardiac arrest with 444 (55%) experiencing failure to rescue after cardiac arrest. Three centers received ELSO CoE recognition, and accounted for 4238 patients (9.71%). Before adjustment, operative mortality was equivalent between ELSO CoE and non-ELSO CoE centers (2.08% vs 2.36%; P = .25), as was the rate of any complication (34.5% vs 33.8%; P = .35) and cardiac arrest (1.49% vs 1.89%; P = .07). After adjustment, patients undergoing surgery at an ELSO CoE facility were observed to have 44% decreased odds of failure to rescue after cardiac arrest, relative to patients at non-ELSO CoE facility (odds ratio, 0.56; 95% CI, 0.316-0.993; P = .047).

CONCLUSIONS

ELSO CoE status is associated with improved failure to rescue following cardiac arrest for patients undergoing cardiac surgery. These findings highlight the important role that comprehensive quality programs serve in improving perioperative outcomes in cardiac surgery.

Center-Level Variation in Failure to Rescue After Pediatric Cardiac Surgery

BACKGROUND

Although failure to rescue (FTR) is increasingly recognized as a quality metric, studies in congenital cardiac surgery remain sparse. Within a national cohort of children undergoing cardiac operations, we characterized the presence of center-level variation in FTR and hypothesized a strong association with mortality but not complications.

METHODS

All children undergoing congenital cardiac operations were identified in the 2013 to 2019 Nationwide Readmissions Database. FTR was defined as in-hospital death after cardiac arrest, ventricular tachycardia/fibrillation, prolonged mechanical ventilation, pneumonia, stroke, venous thromboembolism, or sepsis, among other complications. Hierarchical models were used to generate hospital-specific, risk-adjusted rates of mortality, complications, and FTR. Centers in the highest decile of FTR were identified and compared with others.

RESULTS

Of an estimated 74,070 patients, 1.9% died before discharge, at least 1 perioperative complication developed in 43.0%, and 4.1% experienced FTR. After multilevel modeling, decreasing age, nonelective admission, and increasing operative complexity were associated with greater odds of FTR. Variations in overall mortality and FTR exhibited a strong, positive relationship (r = 0.97), whereas mortality and complications had a negligible association (r = -0.02). Compared with others, patients at centers with high rates of FTR had similar distributions of age, sex, chronic conditions, and operative complexity.

CONCLUSIONS

In the present study, center-level variations in mortality were more strongly explained by differences in FTR than complications. Our findings suggest the utility of FTR as a quality metric for congenital heart surgery, although further study is needed to develop a widely accepted definition and appropriate risk-adjustment models.

Socioeconomic distress is associated with failure to rescue in cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVE

The influence of socioeconomic determinants of health on failure to rescue (mortality after a postoperative complication) after cardiac surgery is unknown. We hypothesized that increasing Distressed Communities Index, a comprehensive socioeconomic ranking by ZIP code, would be associated with higher failure to rescue.

METHODS

Patients undergoing Society of Thoracic Surgeons index operation in a regional collaborative (2011-2021) who developed a failure to rescue complication were included. After excluding patients with missing ZIP code or Society of Thoracic Surgeons predicted risk of mortality, patients were stratified by Distressed Communities Index scores (0-no distress, 100-severe distress) based on education level, poverty, unemployment, housing vacancies, median income, and business growth. The upper 2 quintiles of distress (Distressed Communities Index >60) were compared to all other patients. Hierarchical logistic regression analyzed the association between Distressed Communities Index and failure to rescue.

RESULTS

A total of 4004 patients developed 1 or more of the defined complications across 17 centers. Of these, 582 (14.5%) experienced failure to rescue. High socioeconomic distress (Distressed Communities Index >60) was identified among 1272 patients (31.8%). Before adjustment, failure to rescue occurred more frequently among those from socioeconomically distressed communities (Distressed Communities Index >60; 16.9% vs 13.4%, P = .004). After adjustment, residing in a socioeconomically distressed community was associated with 24% increased odds of failure to rescue (odds ratio, 1.24; confidence interval, 1.003-1.54; P = .044).

CONCLUSIONS

Increasing Distressed Communities Index, a measure of poor socioeconomic status, is associated with greater risk-adjusted likelihood of failure to rescue after cardiac surgery. These findings highlight that current quality metrics do not account for socioeconomic status, and as such underrepresent procedural risk for these vulnerable patients.

Interhospital variability in failure to rescue rates following aortic valve surgery

Objective

This study evaluated interhospital variability and determinants of failure-to-rescue for patients undergoing surgical aortic valve replacement.

Methods

An observational study was conducted among 28,842 patients undergoing aortic valve replacement with or without coronary artery bypass grafting between July 2011 and June 2017 across 90 hospitals participating in the Society of Thoracic Surgeons Adult Cardiac Surgery Database. Postoperative complications were defined as major (stroke, renal failure, reoperation, prolonged ventilation, sternal infection) and overall (major plus 14 other morbidities). Hospital terciles of observed to expected (O/E) mortality were compared on crude rates of major and overall complications, operative mortality, and failure to rescue (among major and overall complications). The correlation between hospital observed and expected failure-to-rescue rates was assessed.

Results

Median Society of Thoracic Surgeons Adult Cardiac Surgery Database predicted mortality risk was similar across hospital O:E mortality terciles (P = .10). As expected, mortality rates significantly increased across terciles (low O/E tercile: 1.6%, high O/E tercile: 4.7%; P < .001). Failure-to-rescue rates increased substantially across hospital mortality terciles among patients with major (low tercile, 8.8% and high tercile, 20.8%) and overall (low tercile, 3.0% and high tercile, 8.9%) complications. Hospital-level expected failure to rescue had a higher correlation with observed complications for overall complications (R2 = 0.71) compared with Society of Thoracic Surgeons major complications (R2 = 0.24).

Conclusions

Considerable interhospital variation exists in failure-to-rescue rates following aortic valve replacement. Hospitals in the low O/E mortality tercile experience failure to rescue nearly one-third less than those in the high O/E mortality tercile. Efforts to advance quality will benefit from identifying and disseminating optimal rescue strategies in this patient population.

The Society of Thoracic Surgeons Definition of Failure to Rescue Should Consider Including Cardiac Arrest

BACKGROUND

Failure to rescue (FTR) is a new quality measure in The Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) Adult Cardiac Surgery Database. The STS defines FTR as death after permanent stroke, renal failure, reoperation, or prolonged ventilation. Our objective was to assess whether cardiac arrest should be included in this definition.

METHODS

Patients undergoing an STS index operation in a regional collaborative (2011-2021) were included. The performance of the STS definition of FTR was compared with a definition that included the STS complications plus cardiac arrest (STS+). Centers were grouped into FTR rate terciles using the STS and STS+ definitions of FTR, and changes in their relative performance rating were assessed.

RESULTS

A total of 43,641 patients were included across 17 centers. Cardiac arrest was the most lethal complication: 55.0% of patients who experienced cardiac arrest died. FTR after any complication (13 total) occurred among 884 patients. The STS definition of FTR accounted for 83% (735 of 884) of all FTR. The addition of cardiac arrest to the STS definition significantly increased the proportion of overall FTR accounted for (92.2% [815 of 884]; P < .001). Choice of FTR definition led to substantial differences in center-level relative performance rating by FTR rate.

CONCLUSIONS

Mortality after cardiac arrest is not completely captured by the STS definition of FTR and represents an important source of potentially preventable death after cardiac surgery. Future quality improvement efforts using the STS definition of FTR should account for this.

Center-Level Variation in Failure to Rescue After Elective Adult Cardiac Surgery

BACKGROUND

There has been increasing emphasis on evaluation of failure to rescue (FTR) after major inpatient operations. The present study characterized center-level variation in FTR within a national cohort of patients undergoing elective cardiac operations.

METHODS

All adults undergoing elective coronary artery bypass grafting and/or valve operations were identified in the 2016-2019 Nationwide Readmissions Database. FTR was defined as in-hospital death after prolonged mechanical ventilation, stroke, reoperation, acute kidney injury requiring dialysis, sepsis, cardiac arrest or pulmonary embolism. Multi-level, mixed-effects regressions were used to model mortality, complications, and FTR. Centers with high hospital-specific rates of FTR (≥95th percentile) were identified and compared to others.

RESULTS

Of an estimated 454,506 patients included for analysis, 32,537 (7.2%) developed at least 1 complication, and 7669 (1.7%) died before discharge. Overall, 5370 (16.5%) patients experienced FTR. Compared with those who developed ≥1 complication but survived to discharge, FTR patients were significantly older, more commonly female, and had a greater burden of comorbidities as measured by the Elixhauser Comorbidity Index. Risk-adjusted, hospital-specific rates of mortality and FTR were moderately correlated (r = 0.64), mortality and complications were weakly associated (r = 0.16), and complications and FTR exhibited a very weak relationship (r = -0.02). Relative to others, centers with high rates of FTR had lower annual cardiac surgical volume (median 61 [interquartile range 33-133] vs 80 [interquartile range 43-149] cases/y, P = .019).

CONCLUSIONS

The present findings affirm prior work demonstrating a close link between variation in FTR and mortality, but not complications. Further study is necessary to delineate modifiable care pathways that mitigate FTR.

Hospital characteristics associated with failure to rescue in cardiac surgery

Objective

The study objective was to examine the association between hospital processes of care and failure to rescue in a diverse, multi-institutional cardiac surgery network.

Methods

Failure to rescue was defined as an operative mortality after 1 or more of 4 complications: prolonged ventilation, stroke, renal failure, and unplanned reoperation. Society of Thoracic Surgeons data from 20,950 consecutive patients in the Columbia HeartSource network who underwent 1 of 7 cardiac operations-coronary artery bypass grafting, aortic valve replacement ± coronary artery bypass grafting, mitral valve repair or replacement ± coronary artery bypass grafting-were analyzed to calculate failure to rescue rates. Hospital-specific characteristics were ascertained by survey method. Multivariable mixed-effects logistic models assessed the association of these hospital characteristics with failure to rescue while adjusting for patient-related factors known to be associated with mortality.

Results

Failure to rescue rates at affiliate hospitals ranged from 5.45% to 21.74% (median, 12.5%; interquartile range, 6.9%). When controlling for Society of Thoracic Surgeons-predicted risk of mortality with hospital as a random effect, 4 hospital characteristics were found to be associated with lower failure to rescue rates; the presence of cardiac-trained anesthesiologists (odds ratio, 0.41; CI, 0.31-0.55, P < .001), availability of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation mechanical circulatory support (odds ratio, 0.41; CI, 0.31-0.54, P < .001), ratio of intensive care unit beds to intensivists (odds ratio, 0.87; CI, 0.76-0.99, P = .039), and total number of intensive care unit beds (odds ratio, 0.97; CI, 0.96-0.99, P = .002).

Conclusions

In a diverse multi-institutional cardiac surgical network, we were able to identify specific hospital processes of care associated with failure to rescue, even when adjusting for patient-related predictors of operative mortality.

Epidemiology of Postoperative Complications After Esophagectomy: Implications for Management

BACKGROUND

Despite advances in operative techniques and postoperative care, esophagectomy remains a morbid operation. Leveraging complication epidemiology and the correlation of these complications may improve rescue and refine early recovery pathways.

METHODS

This study retrospectively reviewed all esophagectomies performed at a tertiary academic center from 2014 to 2021 and quantified the timing of the most common complications. Daily incidence values for index complications were calculated, and a covariance matrix was created to examine the correlation of the complications with each other. Study investigators performed a Cox proportional hazards analysis to clarify the association between early diagnosis of postoperative atrial fibrillation and pneumonia with subsequent anastomotic leak.

RESULTS

The study analyzed 621 esophagectomies, with 580 (93.4%) cervical anastomoses and 474 (76%) patients experiencing complications. A total of 159 (25.6%) patients had postoperative atrial fibrillation, and 155 (25.0%) had an anastomotic leak. The median (interquartile range [IQR]) postoperative day of these complications was day 2 (IQR, days 2-3) and day 8 (IQR, days 7-11), respectively. Our covariance matrix found significant associations in the variance of the most common postoperative complications, including pneumonia, atrial fibrillation, anastomotic leak, and readmissions. Early postoperative atrial fibrillation (hazard ratio, 8.1; 95% CI, 5.65-11.65) and postoperative pneumonia (hazard ratio, 3.8; 95% CI, 1.98-7.38) were associated with anastomotic leak.

CONCLUSIONS

Maintaining a high index of suspicion for early postoperative complications is crucial for rescuing patients after esophagectomy. Early postoperative pneumonia and atrial fibrillation may be sentinel complications for an anastomotic leak, and their occurrence may be used to prompt further clinical investigation. Early recovery protocols should consider the development of early complications into postoperative feeding and imaging algorithms.

The Emerging Role of "Failure to Rescue" as the Primary Quality Metric for Cardiovascular Surgery and Critical Care

We conducted a thorough literature review on the emerging role of failure to rescue (FTR) as a quality metric for cardiovascular surgery and critical care. For this purpose, we identified all original research studies assessing the implementation of FTR in cardiovascular surgery and critical care from 1992 to 2023. All included studies were evaluated for their quality. Although all studies defined FTR as mortality after a surgical complication, a high heterogeneity has been reported among studies regarding the included complications. There are certain factors that affect the FTR, divided into hospital- and patient-related factors. The identification of these factors allowed us to build a stepwise roadmap to reduce the FTR rate. Recently, FTR has further evolved as a metric to assess morbidity instead of mortality, while being also evaluated in the context of interventional cardiology. All these advances are further discussed in the current review, thus providing all the necessary information to surgeons, anesthesiologists, and physicians willing to implement FTR as a metric of quality in their establishment.

Failure to rescue: A candidate quality metric for durable left ventricular assist device implantation

OBJECTIVE

Failure to rescue (FTR), defined as death after a complication, is recognized as a principal driver of variation in mortality among hospitals. We evaluated FTR as a quality metric in patients who received durable left ventricular assist devices (LVADs) using the Society of Thoracic Surgeons Interagency Registry for Mechanically Assisted Circulatory Support.

METHODS

Data on 13,617 patients who received primary durable LVADs from April 2012 to October 2017 at 131 hospitals that performed at least 20 implants were analyzed from the Society of Thoracic Surgeons Interagency Registry for Mechanically Assisted Circulatory Support. Rates of major complications and FTR were compared across risk-adjusted in-hospital mortality terciles (low, medium, high) and hospital volume. Logistic regression was used to estimate expected FTR rates on the basis of patient factors for each major complication.

RESULTS

The overall unadjusted in-hospital mortality rate was 6.96%. Risk-adjusted in-hospital mortality rates varied 3.1-fold across terciles (low, 3.3%; high, 10.3%; P trend <.001). Rates of major complications varied 1.1-fold (low, 34.0%; high, 38.8%; P < .0001). Among patients with a major complication, 854 died in-hospital for an FTR rate of 17.7%, with 2.8-fold variation across mortality terciles (low, 8.5%; high, 23.9%; P < .0001). FTR rates were highest for renal dysfunction requiring dialysis (45.3%) and stroke (36.5%). Higher average annual LVAD volume was associated with higher rates of major complications (<10 per year, 26.7%; 10-20 per year, 34.0%; 20-30 per year, 34.0%; >30 per year, 40.1%; P trend <.0001) whereas hospitals implanting <10 per year had the highest FTR rate (<10 per year, 23.5%; 10-20 per year, 16.5%; 20-30 per year, 17.0%; >30 per year, 17.9%; P = .03).

CONCLUSIONS

FTR might serve as an important quality metric for durable LVAD implant procedures, and identifying strategies for successful rescue after complications might reduce hospital variations in mortality.

Cardiac Surgery Outcomes During the COVID-19 Pandemic Worsened Across All Socioeconomic Statuses

BACKGROUND

Increasing socioeconomic distress has been associated with worse cardiac surgery outcomes. The extent to which the pandemic affected cardiac surgical access and outcomes remains unknown. We sought to examine the relationship between the COVID-19 pandemic and outcomes after cardiac surgery by socioeconomic status.

METHODS

All patients undergoing a Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) index operation in a regional collaborative, the Virginia Cardiac Services Quality Initiative (2011-2022), were analyzed. Patients were stratified by timing of surgery before vs during the COVID-19 pandemic (March 13, 2020). Hierarchic logistic regression assessed the relationship between the pandemic and operative mortality, major morbidity, and cost, adjusting for the Distressed Communities Index (DCI), STS predicted risk of mortality, intraoperative characteristics, and hospital random effect.

RESULTS

A total of 37,769 patients across 17 centers were included. Of these, 7269 patients (19.7%) underwent surgery during the pandemic. On average, patients during the pandemic were less socioeconomically distressed (DCI 37.4 vs DCI 41.9; P < .001) and had a lower STS predicted risk of mortality (2.16% vs 2.53%, P < .001). After risk adjustment, the pandemic was significantly associated with increased mortality (odds ratio 1.398; 95% CI, 1.179-1.657; P < .001), cost (+$4823, P < .001), and STS failure to rescue (odds ratio 1.37; 95% CI, 1.10-1.70; P = .005). The negative impact of the pandemic on mortality and cost was similar regardless of DCI.

CONCLUSIONS

Across all socioeconomic statuses, the pandemic is associated with higher cost and greater risk-adjusted mortality, perhaps related to a resource-constrained health care system. More patients during the pandemic were from less distressed communities, raising concern for access to care in distressed communities.

Implementation of a non-intensive-care unit medical emergency team improves failure to rescue rates in cardiac surgery patients

OBJECTIVE

Failure to rescue (FTR) is an emerging measure in cardiac surgery, defined as mortality after a postoperative complication. We hypothesized that establishing a medical emergency team (MET) reduced rates of FTR in adults undergoing cardiac surgery.

METHODS

All patients (N = 11,218) undergoing a The Society of Thoracic Surgeons index operation at our center (1994-2018) were stratified by pre-MET or MET era based on the 2009 institutional implementation of a MET to respond to clinical decompensation in non-intensive-care patients. Patients missing The Society of Thoracic Surgeons predicted risk of mortality were excluded from all cohorts. Risk adjusted multivariable regression analyzed the association of postoperative complications, operative mortality, and FTR by era. Nearest neighbor propensity score matching utilizing patients' The Society of Thoracic Surgeons predicted risk of mortality was performed to create balanced control and exposure groups for secondary subgroup analysis.

RESULTS

In the risk-adjusted multivariable analysis, surgery during the MET era was associated with decreased mortality (odds ratio [OR], 0.51; 95% CI, 0.45-0.77; P < .001), postoperative renal failure (OR, 0.57; 95% CI, 0.46-0.70; P < .001), reoperation (OR, 0.75; 95% CI, 0.59-0.95; P = .017), and deep sternal wound infection (OR, 0.16; 95% CI, 0.04-0.45; P = .002). Surgery performed during the MET era was associated with a decreased rate of FTR in the risk-adjusted analysis (OR, 0.46; 95% CI, 0.34-0.70; P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

The development of an institutional MET program was associated with a decrease in major complications and FTR. These findings support the development of MET programs to improve FTR after cardiac surgery.

Advancing Quality Metrics for Durable Left Ventricular Assist Device Implant: Analysis of the Society of Thoracic Surgeons Intermacs Database

BACKGROUND

Patients undergoing left ventricular assist device (LVAD) implantation are at risk for death and postoperative adverse outcomes. Interhospital variability and concordance of quality metrics were assessed using the Society of Thoracic Surgeons Interagency Registry for Mechanically Assisted Circulatory Support (Intermacs).

METHODS

A total of 22 173 patients underwent primary, durable LVAD implantation across 160 hospitals from 2012 to 2020, excluding hospitals performing <10 implant procedures. Observed and risk-adjusted operative mortality rates were calculated for each hospital. Outcomes included operative and 90-day mortality, a composite of adverse events (operative mortality, bleeding, stroke, device malfunction, renal dysfunction, respiratory failure), and secondarily failure to rescue. Rates are presented as median (interquartile range [IQR]). Hospital performance was evaluated using observed-to-expected (O/E) ratios for mortality and the composite outcome.

RESULTS

Interhospital variability existed in observed (median, 7.2% [IQR, 5.1%-9.6%]) mortality. The rates of adverse events varied across hospitals: major bleeding, 15.6% (IQR, 11.4%-22.4%); stroke, 3.1% (IQR, 1.6%-4.7%); device malfunction, 2.4% (IQR, 0.8%-3.7%); respiratory failure, 10.5% (IQR, 4.6%-15.7%); and renal dysfunction, 6.4% (IQR, 3.2%-9.6%). The O/E ratio for operative mortality varied from 0.0 to 6.1, whereas the O/E ratio for the composite outcome varied from 0.28 to 1.99. Hospital operative mortality O/E ratios were more closely correlated with the 90-day mortality O/E ratio (r = 0.74) than with the composite O/E ratio (r = 0.12).

CONCLUSIONS

This study reported substantial interhospital variability in performance for hospitals implanting durable LVADs. These findings support the need to (1) report hospital-level performance (mortality, composite) and (2) undertake benchmarking activities to reduce unwarranted variability in outcomes.

Improving outcomes after low-risk coronary artery bypass grafting: understanding phase of care mortality analysis, failure to rescue and recent perioperative recommendations

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Avoidable adverse events are responsible for up to 50% of deaths after low-risk coronary artery bypass grafting. This article reviews recent quality improvement efforts to improve outcomes after cardiac surgery.

RECENT FINDINGS

Systematic quality improvement methodology in cardiac surgery has improved significantly over the past decade. Contemporary efforts with phase of care mortality analysis (POCMA) focus on identifying and addressing root causes for mortality. Each patient's perioperative course is an interconnected sequence of clinical events, decisions, interventions, and treatment responses occurring across five perioperative phases. A single seminal event within a specific phase of care has been found to often trigger the eventual death of a patient. Several groups have made significant improvements to perioperative outcomes by addressing these avoidable mortality trigger events. Failing that, failure to rescue (FTR) metrics can be used to identify institutional factors responsible for poor perioperative outcomes. This ongoing focus on quality improvement serves to further improve outcomes after low-risk cardiac surgery.

SUMMARY

Modern quality improvement methodology, including POCMA and FTR analysis, has the potential to significantly improve outcomes after cardiac surgery. Larger future studies with multiinstitutional data sharing will be key to facilitate ongoing quality improvement and knowledge translation in this field.