New insights into the physiologic basis for intermittent pneumatic limb compression as a therapeutic strategy for peripheral artery disease

Personalized intermittent pneumatic calf compression frequency for augmenting foot blood perfusion: The optimized effect and a personalized mode predicting method

Intermittent pneumatic compression (IPC) therapy has been adopted in prevention and treatment of ischemic-related peripheral vascular diseases. The aim of this study is to provide an approach to personalize the compression strategy of IPC therapy for maximizing foot skin blood flow. In this study, we presented a method to predict the optimized compression mode (OCM) for each subject based on biomechanical features extracted from experimental data tested with multiple IPC modes. First, to demonstrate the blood flow enhancing effect by applying the personalized OCM, four IPC modes of different frequency settings were tested on a total of 24 subjects. The frequency settings were adjusted by deflating-waiting time, which was defined as the total time length from the start of cuff deflation to the start of next compression. The foot skin blood perfusion and IPC air cuff pressure were monitored during the experiments. The personalized OCM was defined as the certain IPC mode that has the highest blood perfusion augmentation (BPA). Compared with the rest stage blood perfusion, the personalized OCM settings resulted in >50% of augmentation for 75% of healthy subjects (maximum augmentation at 244%) and >20% augmentation for 75% of patients with diabetes (maximum augmentation at 180%). Second, for predicting the OCM, we establish a random forest model based on the features extracted from the experimental data. The binary classification resulted in acceptable prediction performance (AUC > 0.7). This study might inspire new IPC strategies for improving foot microcirculation.

Compression therapy in peripheral artery disease: a literature review

OBJECTIVE

Our objective is to examine the pathophysiology of oedema in the ischaemic and post-revascularised limb, compare compression stockings to pneumatic compression devices, and summarise compression regimens in patients with severe peripheral artery disease (PAD) without revascularisation, after revascularisation, and in mixed arterial and venous disease.

METHOD

A scoping literature review of the aforementioned topics was carried out using PubMed.

RESULTS

Compression therapy has been shown to increase blood flow and aid in wound healing through a variety of mechanisms. Several studies suggest that intermittent pneumatic compression (IPC) devices can be used to treat critical limb ischaemia in patients without surgical options. Additionally, compression stockings may have a role in preventing oedema after peripheral artery bypass surgery, thereby diminishing pain and reducing the risk of surgical wound dehiscence.

CONCLUSION

Oedema may occur in the ischaemic limb after revascularisation surgery, as well as in combination with venous disease. Clinicians should not fear using compression therapy in PAD.

Non-pharmacological interventions for vascular health and the role of the endothelium

The most common non-pharmacological intervention for both peripheral and cerebral vascular health is regular physical activity (e.g., exercise training), which improves function across a range of exercise intensities and modalities. Numerous non-exercising approaches have also been suggested to improved vascular function, including repeated ischemic preconditioning (IPC); heat therapy such as hot water bathing and sauna; and pneumatic compression. Chronic adaptive responses have been observed across a number of these approaches, yet the precise mechanisms that underlie these effects in humans are not fully understood. Acute increases in blood flow and circulating signalling factors that induce responses in endothelial function are likely to be key moderators driving these adaptations. While the impact on circulating factors and environmental mechanisms for adaptation may vary between approaches, in essence, they all centre around acutely elevating blood flow throughout the circulation and stimulating improved endothelium-dependent vascular function and ultimately vascular health. Here, we review our current understanding of the mechanisms driving endothelial adaptation to repeated exposure to elevated blood flow, and the interplay between this response and changes in circulating factors. In addition, we will consider the limitations in our current knowledge base and how these may be best addressed through the selection of more physiologically relevant experimental models and research. Ultimately, improving our understanding of the unique impact that non-pharmacological interventions have on the vasculature will allow us to develop superior strategies to tackle declining vascular function across the lifespan, prevent avoidable vascular-related disease, and alleviate dependency on drug-based interventions.

Multiple blood flow surges during intermittent pneumatic compression: The origins and their implications

Intermittent pneumatic compression (IPC) therapy has been used to enhance peripheral blood flow for prevention and rehabilitation of ischemic-related vascular diseases. A novel phenomenon has been reported that multiple blood flow surges appeared in the skin blood flow signal during each compression, but its mechanism has not been fully revealed. This study aimed to gain insights into the origins of these blood flow surges through experiment and biomechanical modeling methods. Foot skin blood flow (SBF) signals of 13 healthy adults (23.8 ± 0.5 yr old, 7 males) and air cuff pressure signals were recorded during IPC. Lumped parameter modeling and wavelet analysis were adopted to investigate the multiple blood flow surges (named as Peak₁, Peak₂ and Peak₃). The results of the simulated Peak₁ and Peak₂ were in good agreements with the experiment results, suggesting that IPC could enhance foot SBF not only by deflation, but also by inflation. Statistical analysis demonstrated that high frequency compression with more frequent occurrence of Peak₁ and Peak₂ lead to significantly higher (Friedman test, p < 0.001) time-averaged SBF enhancement than the traditional mode. In addition, wavelet analysis showed that the major frequency component of the Peak₃ (0.059 Hz) was within the range of the vascular myogenic activity, suggesting a vascular regulation process triggered by intravascular pressure changes. Our study provide new insights into the mechanism of how IPC enhance foot SBF.

Neither Peristaltic Pulse Dynamic Compressions nor Heat Therapy Accelerate Glycogen Resynthesis after Intermittent Running

PURPOSE

To investigate the effects of a single session of either peristaltic pulse dynamic leg compressions (PPDC) or local heat therapy (HT) after prolonged intermittent shuttle running on skeletal muscle glycogen content, muscle function, and the expression of factors involved in skeletal muscle remodeling.

METHODS

Twenty-six trained individuals were randomly allocated to either a PPDC (n = 13) or a HT (n = 13) group. After completing a 90-min session of intermittent shuttle running, participants consumed 0.3 g·kg-1 protein plus 1.0 g·kg-1 carbohydrate and received either PPDC or HT for 60 min in one randomly selected leg, while the opposite leg served as control. Muscle biopsies from both legs were obtained before and after exposure to the treatments. Muscle function and soreness were also evaluated before, immediately after, and 24 h after the exercise bout.

RESULTS

The changes in glycogen content were similar (P > 0.05) between the thigh exposed to PPDC and the control thigh ~90 min (Control: 14.9 ± 34.3 vs PPDC: 29.6 ± 34 mmol·kg-1 wet wt) and ~210 min (Control: 45.8 ± 40.7 vs PPDC: 52 ± 25.3 mmol·kg-1 wet wt) after the treatment. There were also no differences in the change in glycogen content between thighs ~90 min (Control: 35.9 ± 26.1 vs HT: 38.7 ± 21.3 mmol·kg-1 wet wt) and ~210 min (Control: 61.4 ± 50.6 vs HT: 63.4 ± 17.5 mmol·kg-1 wet wt) after local HT. The changes in peak torque and fatigue resistance of the knee extensors, muscle soreness, and the mRNA expression and protein abundance of select factors were also similar (P > 0.05) in both thighs, irrespective of the treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

A single 1-h session of either PPDC or local HT does not accelerate glycogen resynthesis and the recovery of muscle function after prolonged intermittent shuttle running.

Effect of intermittent pneumatic compression with different inflation pressures on the distal microvascular responses of the foot in people with type 2 diabetes mellitus

Intermittent pneumatic compression (IPC) is commonly used to improve peripheral circulation of the lower extremity. However, its therapeutic dosage for people with type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM) at risk for ulcers is not well established. This study explored the effect of IPC with different inflation pressures on the distal microvascular responses of the foot in people with type 2 DM. Twenty‐four subjects with and without DM were recruited. Three IPC protocols with inflation pressures of 60, 90, and 120 mmHg were applied to the foot. The foot skin blood flow (SBF) responses were measured by laser Doppler flowmetry during and after IPC interventions. Results show that all three IPC interventions significantly increased foot SBF of IPC stage in healthy subjects, but only 90 and 120 mmHg IPC significantly improved SBF in diabetic subjects. IPC with 90 and 120 mmHg showed a greater effect than 60 mmHg in both groups, but 120 mmHg IPC was more effective for diabetic subjects. This study demonstrates that 90 and 120 mmHg are effective dosages of IPC for improving blood flow in healthy people, and 120 mmHg IPC may be more suitable for people with type 2 DM.

Intermittent Sequential Pneumatic Compression Improves Coupling between Cerebral Oxyhaemoglobin and Arterial Blood Pressure in Patients with Cerebral Infarction

This study aims to explore the effect of intermittent sequential pneumatic compression (ISPC) intervention on the coupling relationship between arterial blood pressure (ABP) and changes in oxyhaemoglobin (Δ [O₂Hb]). The coupling strength between the two physiological systems was estimated using a coupling function based on dynamic Bayesian inference. The participants were 22 cerebral infarction patients and 20 age- and sex-matched healthy controls. Compared with resting state, the coupling strength from ABP to Δ [O₂Hb] oscillations was significantly lower in the bilateral prefrontal cortex (PFC), sensorimotor cortex (SMC), and temporal lobe cortex (TLC) during the ISPC intervention in cerebral infarction patients in interval II. Additionally, the coupling strength was significantly lower in the bilateral SMC in both groups in interval III. These findings indicate that ISPC intervention may facilitate cerebral circulation in the bilateral PFC, SMC, and TLC in cerebral infarction patients. ISPC may promote motor function recovery through its positive influences on motor-related networks. Furthermore, the coupling between Δ [O₂Hb] and ABP allows non-invasive assessments of autoregulatory function to quantitatively assess the effect of rehabilitation tasks and to guide therapy in clinical situations.

Vascular function in continuous-flow left ventricular assist device recipients: effect of a single pulsatility treatment session

Vascular function is further attenuated in patients with chronic heart failure implanted with a continuous-flow left ventricular assist device (LVAD), likely due to decreased arterial pulsatility, and this may contribute to LVAD-associated cardiovascular complications. However, the impact of increasing pulsatility on vascular function in this population is unknown. Therefore, 15 LVAD recipients and 15 well-matched controls underwent a 45-min, unilateral, arm pulsatility treatment, evoked by intermittent cuff inflation/deflation (2-s duty cycle), distal to the elbow. Vascular function was assessed by percent brachial artery flow-mediated dilation (%FMD) and reactive hyperemia (RH) (Doppler ultrasound). Pretreatment, %FMD (LVAD: 4.0 ± 1.7; controls: 4.2 ± 1.4%) and RH (LVAD: 340 ± 101; controls: 308 ± 94 mL) were not different between LVAD recipients and controls; however, %FMD/shear rate was attenuated (LVAD: 0.10 ± 0.04; controls: 0.17 ± 0.06%/s^-1, P < 0.05). The LVAD recipients exhibited a significantly attenuated pulsatility index (PI) compared with controls prior to treatment (LVAD: 2 ± 2; controls: 15 ± 7 AU, P < 0.05); however, during the treatment, PI was no longer different (LVAD: 37 ± 38; controls: 36 ± 14 AU). Although time to peak dilation and RH were not altered by the pulsatility treatment, %FMD (LVAD: 7.0 ± 1.8; controls: 7.4 ± 2.6%) and %FMD/shear rate (LVAD: 0.19 ± 0.07; controls: 0.33 ± 0.15%/s^-1) increased significantly in both groups, with, importantly, %FMD/shear rate in the LVAD recipients being restored to that of the controls pretreatment. This study documents that a localized pulsatility treatment in LVAD recipients and controls can recover local vascular function, an important precursor to the development of approaches to increase systemic pulsatility and reduce systemic vascular complications in LVAD recipients.

Compression Therapy Is Not Contraindicated in Diabetic Patients with Venous or Mixed Leg Ulcer

The aim of this study was to investigate if compression therapy (CT) can be safely applied in diabetic patients with Venous Leg Ulcers (VLU), even when a moderate arterial impairment (defined by an Ankle-Brachial Pressure Index 0.5–0.8) occurs as in mixed leg ulcers (MLU). Materials and methods: in one of our previous publications we compared the outcomes of two groups of patients with recalcitrant leg ulcers. Seventy-one patients were affected by mixed venous and arterial impairment and 109 by isolated venous disease. Both groups were treated by tailored inelastic CT (with compression pressure <40 mm Hg in patients with MLU and >60 mm Hg in patients with VLU) and ultrasound guided foam sclerotherapy (UGFS) of the superficial incompetent veins with the reflux directed to the ulcer bed. In the present sub analysis of the same patients we compared the healing time of 107 non-diabetic patients (NDP), 69 with VLU and 38 with MLU) with the healing time of 73 diabetic patients (DP), 40 with VLU and 33 with MLU. Results: Twenty-five patients were lost at follow up. The results refer to 155 patients who completed the treatment protocol. In the VLU group median healing time was 25 weeks for NDP and 28 weeks in DP (p = 0.09). In the MLU group median healing time was 27 weeks for NDP and 29 weeks for DP (p = −0.19). Conclusions: when providing leg ulcer treatment by means of tailored compression regimen and foam sclerotherapy for superficial venous refluxes, diabetes has only a minor or no effect on the healing time of recalcitrant VLU or MLU.

Vascular reactivity of cutaneous circulation to brief compressive stimuli, in the human forearm

PURPOSE

A brief compressive stimulus is known to induce a rapid hyperemia in skeletal muscles, considered to contribute to the initial phase of functional hyperemia. Whether the same mechano-sensitivity characterizes the cutaneous circulation is debated. This study aims to investigate whether a rapid hyperemic response to compressive stimuli is also expressed by skin blood flow in humans.

METHODS

In 12 subjects, brief compressive stimuli were delivered to the forearm at varying pressures/durations (50/2, 100/2, 200/2, 200/1, 200/5 mmHg/s); the sequence was randomized and repeated with the arm above and below heart level. Laser Doppler flowmetry technique was used to monitor skin blood flow. The response was described in terms of peak skin blood flow normalized to baseline (nSBFpeak), time-to-peak from the release of compression, and excess blood volume (EBV, expressed in terms of seconds of basal flow, s-bf) received during the response.

RESULTS

The results consistently evidenced the occurrence of a compression-induced hyperemic response, with nSBFpeak = 2.9 ± 1.1, EBV = 17.0 ± 6.6 s-bf, time-to-peak = 7.0 ± 0.7 s (200 mmHg, 2 s, below heart level). Both nSBFpeak and EBV were significantly reduced (by about 50%) above compared to below heart level (p < 0.01). In addition, EBV slightly increased with increasing pressure (p < 0.05) and duration (p < 0.01) of the stimulus.

CONCLUSIONS

For the first time, the rapid dilatator response to compressive stimuli was demonstrated in human cutaneous circulation. The functional meaning of this response remains to be elucidated.

The long-term arterial assist intermittent pneumatic compression generating venous flow obstruction is responsible for improvement of arterial flow in ischemic legs

Background

There is a large group of patients with ischemia of lower limbs not suitable for surgical reconstruction of arteries treated with the help of external assist by intermittent pneumatic compression devices (IPC). Until recently the generally accepted notion was that by compressing tissues below the knee, veins become emptied, venous pressure drops to zero and the increased arterial-venous pressure gradient enables greater arterial flow. We used a pump that, in contradiction to the “empty veins” devices, limited the limb venous outflow by venous obstructions and in a long period therapy expanded the perfusion vessels and brought about persistent reactive hyperemia.

Aim

To check the toe and calf arterial inflow measured by venous stasis plethysmography and capillary flow velocity during arterial assist IPC in a long-term therapy of ischemic legs.

Material and methods

Eighteen patients (12M, 6F) age 62 to 75 with leg peripheral arterial disease (PAD, Fontaine stage II) were studied. Pneumatic device with two 10cm wide cuffs (foot, calf) (Bio Compression Systems, Moonachie, NJ, USA) inflated to 120 mmHg for 5–6 sec to obstruct the venous flow, deflation time 16 sec, applied for 45–60 min daily for a period of 2 years.

Results

At pump inflation increase in toe arterial pressure, volume, capillary blood flow velocity and one-minute arterial inflow test was observed. Increased toe volume appeared concomitantly with the inflated chamber venous obstruction. Resting pressure in the great saphenous vein increased. The two years therapy showed persistence of the resting limb increased toe capillary flow. Intermittent claudication distance increased by 20–120%. After two years arterial assist TBI increased from 0.2 to 0.6 (range 0.3 to 0.8) (p<0.05 vs pre-therapy). The toe arterial inflow dominated over that in calf skin and muscles, nevertheless, there was prolongation of the claudication distance presumably due to dilatation of exchange vessels also in muscles.

Conclusions

Our arterial assist IPC brought about increase in the toe capillary flow, long lasting dilatation of toe capillaries and extension of painless walking distance. The crucial factor of rhythmic repeated venous outflow obstructions should be taken into account in designing effective assist devices.

Minimising failure in critical lower limb ischaemia intervention: Adjuvant capillary bed recruitment is the missed opportunity

Critical limb ischaemia is the end stage of peripheral arterial disease before limb loss. Contemporary interventions to restore blood flow have high morbidity and mortality and fail to provide sustained restoration of peripheral circulation. Cell-based therapies designed to promote neovascularisation or angiogenesis have been shown in trials to be safe but clinically ineffective. Notwithstanding endless research in the area, no headway has been made in identifying a successful therapy designed specifically to target muscle disease in critical lower limb ischaemia. Thus, the quest to find an effective, lasting solution for critical lower limb ischaemia continues and requires more innovative therapeutic tactics. Our aim is to highlight the crucially interlinked role of the capillary bed, skeletal muscle mass and mitochondria in critical lower limb ischaemia patients and to identify novel therapeutic mechanisms that the vascular interventionalist can add to their armamentarium.

Increased tissue oxygenation explains the attenuation of hyperemia upon repetitive pneumatic compression of the lower leg

The rapid hyperemia evoked by muscle compression is short lived and was recently shown to undergo a rapid decrease even in spite of continuing mechanical stimulation. The present study aims at investigating the mechanisms underlying this attenuation, which include local metabolic mechanisms, desensitization of mechanosensitive pathways, and reduced efficacy of the muscle pump. In 10 healthy subjects, short sequences of mechanical compressions ( n = 3–6; 150 mmHg) of the lower leg were delivered at different interstimulus intervals (ranging from 20 to 160 s) through a customized pneumatic device. Hemodynamic monitoring included near-infrared spectroscopy, detecting tissue oxygenation and blood volume in calf muscles, and simultaneous echo-Doppler measurement of arterial (superficial femoral artery) and venous (femoral vein) blood flow. The results indicate that 1) a long-lasting (>100 s) increase in local tissue oxygenation follows compression-induced hyperemia, 2) compression-induced hyperemia exhibits different patterns of attenuation depending on the interstimulus interval, 3) the amplitude of the hyperemia is not correlated with the amount of blood volume displaced by the compression, and 4) the extent of attenuation negatively correlates with tissue oxygenation ( r = −0,78, P < 0.05). Increased tissue oxygenation appears to be the key factor for the attenuation of hyperemia upon repetitive compressive stimulation. Tissue oxygenation monitoring is suggested as a useful integration in medical treatments aimed at improving local circulation by repetitive tissue compression.

NEW & NOTEWORTHY This study shows that 1) the hyperemia induced by muscle compression produces a long-lasting increase in tissue oxygenation, 2) the hyperemia produced by subsequent muscle compressions exhibits different patterns of attenuation at different interstimulus intervals, and 3) the extent of attenuation of the compression-induced hyperemia is proportional to the level of oxygenation achieved in the tissue. The results support the concept that tissue oxygenation is a key variable in blood flow regulation.

[New aspects of compression therapy]

In this review article the mechanisms of action of compression therapy are summarized and a survey of materials is presented together with some practical advice how and when these different devices should be applied. Some new experimental findings regarding the optimal dosage (= compression pressure) concerning an improvement of venous hemodynamics and a reduction of oedema are discussed. It is shown, that stiff, non-yielding material applied with adequate pressure provides hemodynamically superior effects compared to elastic material and that relatively low pressures reduce oedema. Compression over the calf is more important to increase the calf pump function compared to graduated compression. In patients with mixed, arterial-venous ulcers and an ABPI over 0.6 inelastic bandages not exceeding a sub-bandage pressure of 40 mmHg may increase the arterial flow and improve venous pumping function.

A systematic review of intermittent pneumatic compression for critical limb ischaemia

Intermittent pneumatic compression (IPC) is designed to aid wound healing and limb salvage for patients with critical limb ischaemia who are not candidates for revascularisation. We conducted a systematic review of the literature to identify and critically appraise the evidence supporting its use in this population. A search was conducted in Embase, MEDLINE and clinical trial registries up to the end of March 2013. No date or language restrictions were applied. Quality assessment was performed by two people independently. Quality was assessed using the Cochrane risk of bias tool and the NICE case-series assessment tool. Two controlled before-and-after (CBA) studies and six case series were identified. One retrospective CBA study involving compression of the calf reported improved limb salvage and wound healing (OR 7.00, 95% CI 1.82 to 26.89, p<0.01). One prospective CBA study involving sequential compression of the foot and calf reported statistically significant improvements in claudication distances and SF-36 quality of life scores. No difference in all-cause mortality was found. Complications included pain associated with compression, as well as skin abrasion and contact rash as a result of the cuff rubbing against the skin. All studies had a high risk of bias. In conclusion, the limited available results suggest that IPC may be associated with improved limb salvage, wound healing and pain management. However, in the absence of additional well-designed analytical studies examining the effect of IPC in critical limb ischaemia, this treatment remains unproven.