Non-invasive spectroscopic and imaging systems for prediction of beef quality in a meat processing pilot plant

Changing Australia's trading language has enhanced the implementation of objective carcase measurement technologies

In 2016 an Australian project, the Advanced Livestock Measurement Technologies project (ALMTech), was initiated to accelerate the development and implementation of technologies that measure lean meat yield and eating quality. This led to the commercial testing, and implementation of a range of new technologies in the lamb, beef, and pork industries. For measuring lean meat yield %, these technologies included dual energy X-ray absorptiometry, hand-held microwave systems, and 3-D imaging systems. For measuring beef rib-eye traits and intramuscular fat %, both pre- and post-chilling technologies were developed. Post-chilling, a range of camera systems and near infrared spectrophotometers were developed. While pre-chilling, technologies included insertable needle probes, nuclear magnetic resonance, and X-ray systems. Initially these technologies were trained to predict the pre-existing traits already traded upon within industry. However, this approach was limiting because the technologies could measure attributes that were either non-existent in the trading language, were superior as calibrating standards, or more accurately reflected value than the pre-existing trait. Therefore, we introduced IMF% into the trading language for both beef and sheep meat, and carcase lean%, fat%, and bone% for sheep meat. These new technologies and the traits that they predict have delivered multiple benefits. Technology provider-companies are instilled with the confidence to commercialise due to the provision of achievable accreditation standards. Processors have the confidence to invest in these technologies and establish payment grids based upon their measurements. And lastly, it has enhanced data flow into genetic databases, industry data systems (MSA), and as feedback to producers.

Does hyperspectral always matter? A critical assessment of near infrared versus hyperspectral near infrared in the study of heterogeneous samples

Near Infrared spectroscopy (NIR), in combination with Chemometrics, has been used for many years in diverse scenarios, mostly focused on the classification and quantitation of properties in food, pharmaceutical preparations, artwork material, etc. This success has been possible due to their desirable properties: fast, reliable (under certain conditions), non-destructive, easy to implement from a hardware perspective, and able to create robust and transferable multivariate models. For some years now, another modality has been gaining the attention of NIR users, especially in the Food sector. That is the plausibility of using NIR in the hyperspectral (HSI) domain. This adds to the previously mentioned abilities, the benefit of scanning the whole surface of samples, acquiring much richer spatial information and, therefore, assuring the quality of the final product more accurately by including parameters that depend on the surface distribution of certain components. This is especially relevant in heterogeneous samples. While this statement is generally true, there are certain situations where this oversampling feature is not strictly needed, and the problem can be easily solved with a classical NIR spectrophotometer. Besides, NIR-hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI), despite the abovementioned advantages, has several drawbacks that must be highlighted as well, like their measuring speed, instability, or price. This manuscript will demonstrate that for certain situations, tuning the focal distance of a NIR spectrophotometer is a more feasible, reliable, and inexpensive strategy to collect all the needed information of samples with a certain degree of heterogeneity.

Semisupervised Deep Learning for the Detection of Foreign Materials on Poultry Meat with Near-Infrared Hyperspectral Imaging

A novel semisupervised hyperspectral imaging technique was developed to detect foreign materials (FMs) on raw poultry meat. Combining hyperspectral imaging and deep learning has shown promise in identifying food safety and quality attributes. However, the challenge lies in acquiring a large amount of accurately annotated/labeled data for model training. This paper proposes a novel semisupervised hyperspectral deep learning model based on a generative adversarial network, utilizing an improved 1D U-Net as its discriminator, to detect FMs on raw chicken breast fillets. The model was trained by using approximately 879,000 spectral responses from hyperspectral images of clean chicken breast fillets in the near-infrared wavelength range of 1000-1700 nm. Testing involved 30 different types of FMs commonly found in processing plants, prepared in two nominal sizes: 2 × 2 mm2 and 5 × 5 mm2. The FM-detection technique achieved impressive results at both the spectral pixel level and the foreign material object level. At the spectral pixel level, the model achieved a precision of 100%, a recall of over 93%, an F1 score of 96.8%, and a balanced accuracy of 96.9%. When combining the rich 1D spectral data with 2D spatial information, the FM-detection accuracy at the object level reached 96.5%. In summary, the impressive results obtained through this study demonstrate its effectiveness at accurately identifying and localizing FMs. Furthermore, the technique's potential for generalization and application to other agriculture and food-related domains highlights its broader significance.

Nondestructive detection of nutritional parameters of pork based on NIR hyperspectral imaging technique

Nondestructive detection of the nutritional parameters of pork is of great importance. This study aimed to investigate the feasibility of applying hyperspectral image technology to detect the nutrient content and distribution of pork nondestructively. Hyperspectral cubes of 100 pork samples were collected using a line-scan hyperspectral system, the effects of different preprocessing methods on the modeling effects were compared and analyzed, the feature wavelengths of fat and protein were extracted, and the full-wavelength model was optimized using the regressor chains (RC) algorithm. Finally, pork's fat, protein, and energy value distributions were visualized using the best prediction model. The results showed that standard normal variate was more effective than other preprocessing methods, the feature wavelengths extracted by the competitive adaptive reweighted sampling algorithm had better prediction performance, and the protein model prediction performance was optimized after using the RC algorithm. The best prediction models were developed, with the correlation coefficient of prediction (R_P) = 0.929, the root mean square error in prediction (RMSEP) = 0.699% and residual prediction deviation (RPD) = 2.669 for fat, and R_P = 0.934, RMSEP = 0.603% and RPD = 2.586 for protein. The pseudo-color maps were helpful for the analysis of nutrient distribution in pork. Hyperspectral image technology can be a fast, nondestructive, and accurate tool for quantifying the composition and assessing the distribution of nutrients in pork.

Determination of beef tenderness based on airflow pressure combined with structural light three-dimensional (3D) vision technology

The main factor affecting beef quality, consumer satisfaction, and purchase decisions is beef tenderness. In this study, a rapid nondestructive testing method for beef tenderness based on airflow pressure combined with structural light 3D vision technology was proposed. The structural light 3D camera was used to scan the 3D point cloud deformation information of the beef surface after the airflow acted on it for 1.8 s. Six deformation characteristics and three point cloud characteristics of the beef surface depression region were obtained by using denoising, point cloud rotation, point cloud segmentation, point cloud descending sampling, alphaShape, and other algorithms. A total of nine characteristics were mainly concentrated in the first five principal components (PCs). Therefore, the first five PCs were put into three different models. The results showed that the Extreme Learning Machine (ELM) model had a comparatively higher prediction effect for the prediction of beef shear force, with a root mean square error of prediction (RMSEP) of 11.1389 and a correlation coefficient (R) of 0.8356. In addition, the correct classification accuracy of the ELM model for tender beef achieved 92.96%. The overall classification accuracy reached 93.33%. Consequently, the proposed methods and technology can be applied for beef tenderness detection.

Towards the non-invasive assessment of staling in bovine hides with hyperspectral imaging

Microbial spoilage or staling of bovine hides during storage leads to poor leather quality and increased chemical consumption during processing. Conventional microbiological examinations of hide samples which require time-consuming microbe culture cannot be employed as a practical staling detection approach for leather production. Hyperspectral imaging (HSI), featuring fast data acquisition and implementation flexibility has been considered ideal for in-line detection of microbial contamination in Agri- food products. In this study, a linescan hyperspectral imaging system working in a spectral range of 550 nm to 1700 nm was utilized as a rapid and non-destructive technique for predicting the aerobic plate counts (APC) on raw hide samples during storage. Fresh bovine hide samples were stored at 4 °C and 20 °C for 3 days. Every day, hyperspectral images were acquired on both sides for each sample. The APCs were determined simultaneously by conventional microbiological plating method. Leather quality was evaluated by microscopic inspection of grain surfaces, which indicate the acceptable threshold of microbe load on hide samples for leather processing. Partial least squares regression (PLSR) was applied to fit the spectral information extracted from the samples to the logarithmic values of APC to develop microbe load prediction models. All models showed good prediction accuracy, yielding a R_cv² in the range of 0.74-0.92 and standard error of cross validation (SECV) in the range of 0.61-0.76 %. The prediction capability of the HSI was explored using the model developed with SNV + smoothened pre-processing to spatially predict plate count in the samples. Models established in this study successfully predicted the staling states characterised by bacterial loads on hide samples with low prediction errors. Models, visually, showed the differences in microbial load across the storage time and temperatures. Results illustrate that HSI can be potentially implemented as a non-invasive tool to predict microbe loads in bovine hides before leather processing, so that real-time grading of hides based on staling states can be achieved. This will reduce the cost of leather production and waste management and pave the way for allocating material supply for different production purposes.

Recent advances in muscle food safety evaluation: Hyperspectral imaging analyses and applications

As there is growing interest in process control for quality and safety in the meat industry, by integrating spectroscopy and imaging technologies into one system, hyperspectral imaging, or chemical or spectroscopic imaging has become an alternative analytical technique that can provide the spatial distribution of spectrum for fast and nondestructive detection of meat safety. This review addresses the configuration of the hyperspectral imaging system and safety indicators of muscle foods involving biological, chemical, and physical attributes and other associated hazards or poisons, which could cause safety problems. The emphasis focuses on applications of hyperspectral imaging techniques in the safety evaluation of muscle foods, including pork, beef, lamb, chicken, fish and other meat products. Although HSI can provide the spatial distribution of spectrum, characterized by overtones and combinations of the C-H, N-H, and O-H groups using different combinations of a light source, imaging spectrograph and camera, there still needs improvement to overcome the disadvantages of HSI technology for further applications at the industrial level.

Spectroscopic Data for the Rapid Assessment of Microbiological Quality of Chicken Burgers

The rapid assessment of the microbiological quality of highly perishable food commodities is of great importance. Spectroscopic data coupled with machine learning methods have been investigated intensively in recent years, because of their rapid, non-destructive, eco-friendly qualities and their potential to be used on-, in- or at-line. In the present study, the microbiological quality of chicken burgers was evaluated using Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy and multispectral imaging (MSI) in tandem with machine learning algorithms. Six independent batches were purchased from a food industry and stored at 0, 4, and 8 °C. At regular time intervals (specifically every 24 h), duplicate samples were subjected to microbiological analysis, FTIR measurements, and MSI sampling. The samples (n = 274) acquired during the data collection were classified into three microbiological quality groups: “satisfactory”: 4−7 log CFU/g, “acceptable”: 7−8 log CFU/g, and “unacceptable”: >8 logCFU/g. Subsequently, classification models were trained and tested (external validation) with several machine learning approaches, namely partial least squares discriminant analysis (PLSDA), support vector machine (SVM), random forest (RF), logistic regression (LR), and ordinal logistic regression (OLR). Accuracy scores were attained for the external validation, exhibiting FTIR data values in the range of 79.41−89.71%, and, for the MSI data, in the range of 74.63−85.07%. The performance of the models showed merit in terms of the microbiological quality assessment of chicken burgers.

Hyperspectral imaging (HSI) for meat quality evaluation across the supply chain: Current and future trends

Meat products are particularly plagued by safety problems because of their complicated structure, various production processes and complex supply chains. Rapid and non-invasive analytical methods to evaluate meat quality have become a priority for the industry over the conventional chemical methods. To achieve rapid analysis of safety and quality parameters of meat products, hyperspectral imaging (HSI) is now widely applied in research studies for detecting the various components of different meat products, but its application in meat production and supply chain integrity as a quality control (QC) solution is still ambiguous. This review presents the fresh look at the current states of HSI research as both the scope and the applicability of the HSI in the meat quality evaluation expanded. The future application scenarios of HSI in the supply chain and the future development of HSI hardware and software are also discussed, by which HSI technology has the potential to enable large scale meat product testing. With a fully adapted for factory setting HSI, the inspection coverage can reliably identify the chemical properties of meat products. With the introduction of Food Industry 4.0, HSI advances can change the meat industry to become from reactive to predictive when facing meat safety issues.

•

HSI has shown promising early signs in the non-destructive analysis of meat quality and safety.

•

Hyperspectral imaging (HSI) is now widely applied in research studies for different meat products with the help of machine learning methods.

•

With a fully adapted factory setting and robust machine learning of HSI, the inspection coverage can reach 100% of the target meat.

•

HSI can change the meat industry to become from reactive to predictive when facing issues, this will be translated into fewer recalls, less meat fraud, and less waste.

Next Generation Sequencing of Single Nucleotide Polymorphic DNA-Markers in Selecting for Intramuscular Fat, Fat Melting Point, Omega-3 Long-Chain Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids and Meat Eating Quality in Tattykeel Australian White MARGRA Lamb

Meat quality data can only be obtained after slaughter when selection decisions about the live animal are already too late. Carcass estimated breeding values present major precision problems due to low accuracy, and by the time an informed decision on the genetic merit for meat quality is made, the animal is already dead. We report for the first time, a targeted next-generation sequencing (NGS) of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) of lipid metabolism genes in Tattykeel Australian White (TAW) sheep of the MARGRA lamb brand, utilizing an innovative and minimally invasive muscle biopsy sampling technique for directly quantifying the genetic worth of live lambs for health-beneficial omega-3 long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (n-3 LC-PUFA), intramuscular fat (IMF), and fat melting point (FMP). NGS of stearoyl-CoA desaturase (SCD), fatty acid binding protein-4 (FABP4), and fatty acid synthase (FASN) genes identified functional SNP with unique DNA marker signatures for TAW genetics. The SCD g.23881050T>C locus was significantly associated with IMF, C22:6n-3, and C22:5n-3; FASN g.12323864A>G locus with FMP, C18:3n-3, C18:1n-9, C18:0, C16:0, MUFA, and FABP4 g.62829478A>T locus with IMF. These add new knowledge, precision, and reliability in directly making early and informed decisions on live sheep selection and breeding for health-beneficial n-3 LC-PUFA, FMP, IMF and superior meat-eating quality at the farmgate level. The findings provide evidence that significant associations exist between SNP of lipid metabolism genes and n-3 LC-PUFA, IMF, and FMP, thus underpinning potential marker-assisted selection for meat-eating quality traits in TAW lambs.

Prediction of carcass composition and meat and fat quality using sensing technologies: A review

Consumer demand for high-quality healthy food is increasing,  thus meat processors require the means toassess these rapidly, accurately, and inexpensively. Traditional methods forquality assessments are time-consuming, expensive, invasive, and have potentialto negatively impact the environment. Consequently, emphasis has been put onfinding non-destructive, fast, and accurate technologies for productcomposition and quality evaluation. Research in this area is advancing rapidlythrough recent developments in the areas of portability, accuracy, and machinelearning. The present review, therefore, critically evaluates and summarizes developmentsof popular non-invasive technologies (i.e., from imaging to spectroscopicsensing technologies) for estimating beef, pork, and lamb composition andquality, which will hopefully assist in the implementation of thesetechnologies for rapid evaluation/real-timegrading of livestock products in the nearfuture.

Recent developments in the objective measurement of carcass and meat quality for industrial application

This paper summarises the contents of this Special Edition. The papers cover a range of advanced technologies for the objective measurement of carcass characteristics that influence the yield and potential eating quality of beef and lamb carcasses. All the research has been carried out in Australia and New Zealand and has been centrally funded with collaboration between various groups. This Special Edition is timely since the meat industry is coming under pressure on environmental grounds in addition to health warnings about excessive meat consumption. In this respect it is encouraging that so many of the papers relate to eating quality. The emphasis on objective methods is also important as moving away from traditional subjective grading will improve accuracy and consistency and thereby increase efficiency. Some differences in the approach taken in other parts of the world are discussed.

Objective measurement technologies for transforming the Australian & New Zealand livestock industries

This paper introduces the special edition of Meat Science focused upon the development, calibration and validation of technologies that measure traits influencing meat eating quality, or carcass fat and lean composition. These papers reflect the combined research efforts of groups in Australia, through the Advanced Livestock Measurement Technologies project, and New Zealand through AgResearch. We describe the various technologies being developed, how these devices are being trained upon common gold-standard measurements, and how their outputs are being simultaneously integrated into existing industry systems. We outline how this enhances the industry uptake and adoption of these technologies, and how this is further accelerated by education programs and strategic industry investment into their commercialisation.