Molecular dynamics simulation of binary betaine and anionic surfactant mixtures at decane - Water interface

Experimental and simulation-based characterization of surfactant adsorption layers at fluid interfaces

Adsorption of surfactants to fluid interfaces occurs in numerous technological and daily-life contexts. The coverage at the interface and other properties of the formed adsorption layers determine the performance of a surfactant with regard to the desired application. Given the importance of these applications, there is a great demand for the comprehensive characterization and understanding of surfactant adsorption layers. In this review, we provide an overview of suitable experimental and simulation-based techniques and review the literature in which they were used for the investigation of surfactant adsorption layers. We come to the conclusion that, while these techniques have been successfully applied to investigate Langmuir monolayers of water-insoluble surfactants, their application to the study of Gibbs adsorption layers of water-soluble surfactants has not been fully exploited. Finally, we emphasize the great potential of these methods in providing a deeper understanding of the behavior of soluble surfactants at interfaces, which is crucial for optimizing their performance in various applications.

Review of the Interfacial Structure and Properties of Surfactants in Petroleum Production and Geological Storage Systems from a Molecular Scale Perspective

Surfactants play a crucial role in tertiary oil recovery by reducing the interfacial tension between immiscible phases, altering surface wettability, and improving foam film stability. Oil reservoirs have high temperatures and high pressures, making it difficult and hazardous to conduct lab experiments. In this context, molecular dynamics (MD) simulation is a valuable tool for complementing experiments. It can effectively study the microscopic behaviors (such as diffusion, adsorption, and aggregation) of the surfactant molecules in the pore fluids and predict the thermodynamics and kinetics of these systems with a high degree of accuracy. MD simulation also overcomes the limitations of traditional experiments, which often lack the necessary temporal-spatial resolution. Comparing simulated results with experimental data can provide a comprehensive explanation from a microscopic standpoint. This article reviews the state-of-the-art MD simulations of surfactant adsorption and resulting interfacial properties at gas/oil-water interfaces. Initially, the article discusses interfacial properties and methods for evaluating surfactant-formed monolayers, considering variations in interfacial concentration, molecular structure of the surfactants, and synergistic effect of surfactant mixtures. Then, it covers methods for characterizing microstructure at various interfaces and the evolution process of the monolayers' packing state as a function of interfacial concentration and the surfactants' molecular structure. Next, it examines the interactions between surfactants and the aqueous phase, focusing on headgroup solvation and counterion condensation. Finally, it analyzes the influence of hydrophobic phase molecular composition on interactions between surfactants and the hydrophobic phase. This review deepened our understanding of the micro-level mechanisms of oil displacement by surfactants and is beneficial for screening and designing surfactants for oil field applications.

Synergistic Effect of Betaines and Dialkyl Chain Anionic Surfactants on Interfacial Arrangement: A Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study

Mixed systems of betaines and anionic surfactants can have a significant synergistic effect and greatly reduce the interfacial tension (IFT), which has attracted an extensive amount of attention. However, this synergistic effect requires an anionic surfactant and betaine molecular size matching, which limits the scope of its application. In this work, we studied three mixed systems of sodium dialkyl sulfosuccinate (AOT) and betaines with different sizes by molecular dynamics simulation and an IFT experiment and explored the interfacial behavior and synergistic mechanism of AOT in single and mixed systems. The hydrophobic tail chain center angle, average rising height of carbon atoms, stretch degree and distance between the terminal carbon atoms of AOT, and tilt angles of betaine were calculated and analyzed in detail. Simulation results showed that the hydrophobic tail chain center angle of AOT in the single system was smaller, and it tended to extend into the oil phase. After being mixed with different betaines, AOT can adjust its size according to the interfacial vacancies of different betaine systems by changing the alkyl chain orientation and forming tighter interfacial films. The IFT experiment showed that betaine/AOT mixed systems achieved a lower IFT value compared with that of the single system, indicating that AOT showed a synergistic effect with betaines with different structures. This study will be importantly instructively significant for the design and research of betaine mixed systems in crude oil exploitation.

Molecular Dynamics Simulation of the Effects of Complex Surfactants on Oil-Water Interaction and Aggregation Characteristics at the Interface

In response to the problem of complex interaction between oil and water in the oil-water interface, especially heavy oil and water, this study investigated the effects of complex surfactants on the interaction of two phases and their aggregation characteristics by molecular dynamics simulation. The results showed that increasing the content of sodium lauryl polyether carboxylate (AEC-9Na) was beneficial to the coordination between it and alkyl glycoside (APG-10), improved the interfacial activity, and enhanced the interfacial stability of the composite system, and the best effect was achieved when AEC-9Na:APG-10 = 8:2. The thickness of the oil and water film on the oil-water interface was irregular. When the concentration of AEC-9Na was lower than that of APG-10, the total thickness of the interfacial film (ttotal) first increased. When the content of AEC-9Na is higher, a large number of sodium ions were adsorbed near the -COO- group of AEC-9Na, which will polarize out of the hydration layer structure and attract water molecules from the second hydration layer on the heavy oil surface to the first hydration layer through electrostatic interaction. Then, the thickness of the interface film was compressed, and the interface film was reduced. When the ratio increased to 10:0, the oil and water phase competed to adsorb surfactant molecules, and the headgroup tended to lay on the interface. Moreover, the hydrophilicity of the surfactant layer was weakened, and the thickness of the water film decreased. The distribution of surfactant was looser than 8:2, the light components of heavy oil molecules (saturated and aromatic hydrocarbons) entered the gap between surfactants in large quantities, and the hydrophobic tail chain tended to be laid on the oil-water interface. The oleophilicity of the surfactant layer increased, and the thickness of the oil film remarkably increased, so the total thickness of the interface film increased again.

Molecular Dynamics Simulations on the Adsorbed Monolayers of N-Dodecyl Betaine at the Air-Water Interface

Betaine is a kind of zwitterionic surfactant with both positive and negative charge groups on the polar head, showing good surface activity and aggregation behaviors. The interfacial adsorption, structures and properties of n-dodecyl betaine (NDB) at different surface coverages at the air-water interface are studied through molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Interactions between the polar heads and water molecules, the distribution of water molecules around polar heads, the tilt angle of the NDB molecule, polar head and tail chain with respect to the surface normal, the conformations and lengths of the tail chain, and the interfacial thickness of the NDB monolayer are analyzed. The change of surface coverage hardly affects the locations and spatial distributions of the water molecules around the polar heads. As more NDB molecules are adsorbed at the air-water interface, the number of hydrogen bonds between polar heads and water molecules slightly decreases, while the lifetimes of hydrogen bonds become larger. With the increase in surface coverage, less gauche defects along the alkyl chain and longer NDB chain are obtained. The thickness of the NDB monolayer also increases. At large surface coverages, tilted angles of the polar head, tail chain and whole NDB molecule show little change with the increase in surface area. Surface coverages can change the tendency of polar heads and the tail chain for the surface normal.

How to Regulate the Migration Ability of Emulsions in Micro-Scale Pores: Droplet Size or Membrane Strength?

Micro visualization has become an important means of solving colloid and interface scientific problems in enhanced oil recovery. It can establish a relationship between a series of performance evaluations of an oil-water interface under macroscopic dimensions and the actual application effect in confined space, and more truly and reliably reflect the starting and migration behavior of crude oil or emulsion in rock pores. In this article, zwitterionic surfactant alkyl sulfobetaine (ASB) and anionic extended surfactant alkyl polyoxypropylene sulfate (A145) were employed as flooding surfactants. The macroscopic properties of the surfactant solutions, such as the oil-water interfacial tension (IFT), the interfacial dilational rheology and the viscosity of crude oil emulsions, have been measured. At the same time, we link these parameters with the oil displacement effect in several visual glass models and confirm the main factors affecting the migration ability of emulsions in micro-scale pores. The experimental results show that ASB reduces the IFT through mixed adsorption with crude oil fractions. The flat arrangement of the large hydrophilic group of ASB molecules enhances the interactions between the surfactant molecules on the oil-water interface. Compared with sulfate, betaine has higher interfacial membrane strength and emulsion viscosity. A145 has a strong ability to reduce the IFT against crude oil because of the larger size effect of the PO chains at the oil side of the interface. However, the membrane strength of A145 is moderate and the emulsion does not show a viscosity-increasing effect. During the displacement process, the deformation ability of the front emulsions or oil banks is the main controlling factor of the displacement efficiency, which is determined by the membrane strength and emulsion viscosity. The strong interfacial membrane strength and the high emulsion viscosity are not conducive to the migration of droplets in pore throats and may result in low displacement efficiency.

Modeling Micellar Growth and Branching in Mixtures of Zwitterionic with Ionic Surfactants

Zwitterionic surfactants are widely applied as drag-reducing or thickening agents because their aggregation patterns may drastically change in response to variations of the system composition or external stimuli, which provides controllable viscoelasticity. For predicting aggregation behavior of surfactant mixtures, classical molecular thermodynamic models have been widely used. Particularly, the results of modeling have been reported for zwitterionic/ionic surfactant mixtures. However, for solutions containing a zwitterionic surfactant, no molecular thermodynamic model has been proposed for a micellar branch. In this work we extend the classical molecular thermodynamic aggregation model to describe aggregation in the aqueous mixtures that contain a zwitterionic and an ionic surfactant. We derive analytical expressions (1) for the contribution of dipoles to the electrostatic term of the standard free energy of aggregation into micellar branches and (2) for the dipolar contribution to the persistence length of wormlike micelles. The dependence of micellar branching on the surfactant concentration is taken into account by including the population of micellar branches in the material balance equations. This model is applied to predict aggregation equilibrium in aqueous salt solutions of betaine (oleoylamidopropyl-N,N-dimethylbetaine) mixed with sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and the longer tail sodium n-alkyl sulfates. We discuss the predicted properties of the aggregates and micellar networks and compare our predictions with available experimental data.

Computational Study on the Microscopic Adsorption Characteristics of Linear Alkylbenzene Sulfonates with Different Chain Lengths on Anthracite Surface

In order to explore the influence of different lengths of hydrophobic carbon chains on the diffusion characteristics of surfactants on the surface of anthracite, six linear alkyl benzene sulfonates with different hydrophobic carbon chain lengths were selected (mC, m = 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18; m represents the numbers of carbon atoms in the hydrophobic carbon chain), and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were adopted. Models of surfactant-anthracite, surfactant-graphite layer, and water-surfactant-anthracite were constructed. After analyzing a series of properties such as adsorption energy, diffusion coefficient, radial distribution function (RDF), and hydrophobic tail order parameters, it was found that 12C had the highest adsorption strength on the surface of anthracite; the reason was that 12C had the highest degree of aggregation near the oxygen-containing functional groups on the surface of anthracite. Further studies had found that the hydrophobic tail chain of 12C had the strongest isotropy. The study fills the gap in the systematic study of the diffusion characteristics of linear alkylbenzene sulfonates (LAS) with different chain lengths on the surface of anthracite, enriches and develops the basic theory of coal wettability, and also provides technical ideas for the design of new surfactants and new dust suppression agents.

Interaction quantitative modeling of mixed surfactants for synergistic solubilization by resonance light scattering

In situ flushing through surfactant-enhanced aquifer remediation (SEAR) technology has long been recognized as a promising technique for NAPL removal from contaminated aquifers. However, there have been few studies on the choice of surfactants. In this work, the interaction quantitative model between resonance light scattering intensity and the concentration of binary surfactant mixtures NP-10+SDBS and NP-10+CTAB was established, and the mechanism of binary surfactant interaction was explored through the model by the resonance light scattering method. The relationship between the model constants and NAPL solubilization was also investigated to better address the application of surfactants in practical NAPL-contaminated site remediation. The critical micelle concentrations (CMCs) of nonylphenol ethoxylate (NP-10), dodecyl benzene sulfonate (SDBS), hexadecyl trimethyl ammonium bromide (CTAB), and the binary surfactant mixtures were measured by resonance light scattering (RLS), which were consistent with those obtained from surface tension measurements. In all cases, the RLS signals exhibited similar variations with surfactant concentration. A quantitative calculation model based on the RLS measurement data was established, and the binding constants K_NP-10+SDBS and K_NP-10+CTAB were calculated to be 0.66 and 1.51 L·mmol^-1, respectively, according to the equilibrium equations. The results showed that the binding constants have a significant positive correlation with NAPL solubilization.

Effects of Micellization Behavior on the Interfacial Adsorption in Binary Anionic/Nonionic Surfactant Systems: A Molecular Simulation Study

A surfactant interfacial adsorption process is highly associated with its micellization behaviors in the water phase, which is of great fundamental and practical significance in enhanced oil recovery. In this paper, the typical anionic surfactant 1-dodecanesulfonic acid sodium (DAS) and nonionic surfactants octylphenol polyoxyethylene ether-n (OP-n, n = 1, 5, and 10) are introduced to investigate their micellization behavior and interfacial adsorption process via molecular dynamics simulation. Number density profiles reveal that the additional OP5 molecules in the water phase generate the mixed micelle with DAS molecules and greatly promote its interfacial adsorption. Interaction energy calculation is employed to confirm the interaction of anionic/nonionic surfactants in the mixed micelle. Then, the radial distribution function, solvent-accessible surface area, and solvation free energy are calculated to further explore and verify the adsorption mechanism of the mixed micelle. It is found that the nonionic surfactant obviously decreases the hydrophilicity of the mixed micelle in the water phase, which should be responsible for its intensive tendency of the interfacial adsorption.

Molecular Assembly of Surfactant Mixtures in Oil-Swollen Micelles: Implications for High Salinity Colloidal Stability

Alkylbenzene sulfonates are one of the most important synthetic surfactant families, considering their wide applicability, cost-effectiveness, and overall consumption levels. Nevertheless, their low salt tolerance (especially divalent ion contents) prevented their wider applications such as enhanced oil recovery in high salinity reservoirs. Here, using experiments and atomistic molecular dynamics simulations, we demonstrated that the high salinity colloidal stability of alkylbenzene sulfonates can be dramatically increased by mixing with zwitterionic cosurfactants in oil-swollen micelles. By mixing with cosurfactants we had two important observations. (1) The polydispersity of surfactant mixture oil-swollen micelles were largely decreased due to the less rigid oil/water interfaces with mixed surfactants, which formed fewer but larger uniform micelles. (2) Strong dehydration of sulfonates due to the shielding from protruding more extended zwitterionic cosurfactants at the oil/water interfaces. Both observed molecular assembly characteristics triggered by the cosurfactants effectively reduced the total exposures of sulfonates to water phase that may form divalent ion bridging and large aggregates, and thus increased their high salinity colloidal stability. Lastly, it was observed that the dehydration of sulfonates was the highest at flat oil/water interfaces (very large oil-swollen micelles), which justified that adding trace amount of mineral oils may boost the high salinity colloidal stability even further.