Impaired heart rate recovery after sub-maximal physical exercise in people with multiple sclerosis

Perceived and physiological strains of societal participation in people with multiple sclerosis: a real-time assessment study

OBJECTIVE

To examine the relationship between perceived and physiological strains of real-time societal participation in people with multiple sclerosis.

DESIGN

Observational study.

SUBJECTS/PATIENTS

70 people with multiple sclerosis.

METHODS

Perceived and physiological strain of societal participation (10 participation-at-location and 9 transport domains) were measured in real time using the Whereabouts smartphone app and Fitbit over 7 consecutive days. Longitudinal relationships between perceived (1 not strenuous to 10 most strenuous) and physiological strains (heart rate reserve) were examined using mixed-model analyses. Type of event (participation-at-location or transport) was added as covariate, with further adjustments for fatigue and walking ability.

RESULTS

Median perceived strain, summarized for all societal participation domains, varied between 3 and 6 (range: 1-10), whereas physiological strain varied between 18.5% and 33.2% heart rate reserve. Perceived strain (outcome) and physiological strain were not associated (β -0.001, 95%CI -0.008; 0.005, with a 7-day longitudinal correlation coefficient of -0.001). Transport domains were perceived as less strenuous (β -0.80, 95%CI -0.92; -0.68). Higher fatigue levels resulted in higher perceived strain (all societal participation domains) (β 0.05, 95%CI 0.02; 0.08).

CONCLUSION

Societal participation resulted in low-to-moderate perceived and physiological strain. Perceived and physiological strain of societal participation were unrelated and should be considered different constructs in multiple sclerosis.

Speed of heart rate changes during postural provocations in children and adolescents

Heart rate is under constant autonomic influence but the development of the influence in children is not fully understood. Continuous electrocardiograms were obtained in 1045 healthy school-age children (550 females) during postural provocations with body position changes between supine, sitting, standing, supine, standing, sitting and supine (in this order), 10 min in each position with position changes within 20 s. Heart rate was measured in each position and speed of heart rate changes between positions were assessed by regressions of rates versus timing of individual cardiac cycles. Supine heart rate was gradually decreasing with age: 82.32 ± 9.92, 74.33 ± 9.79, 67.43 ± 9.45 beats per minute (bpm) in tertile age groups < 11, 11-15, > 15 years, respectively (p < 0.0001), with no significant sex difference. Averaged speed of heart rate changes differed little between sexes and age groups but was significantly faster during rate deceleration than acceleration (e.g., supine ↔ standing: 2.99 ± 1.02 vs. 2.57 ± 0.68 bpm/s, p < 0.0001). The study suggests that in children, vagal heart rate control does not noticeably change between ages of approximately 6-19 years. The gradual resting heart rate decrease during childhood and adolescence is likely caused by lowering of cardiac sympathetic influence from sympathetic overdrive in small children to adult-like sympatho-vagal balance in older adolescents.

Multiple sclerosis-related heat sensitivity linked to absence of DMT prescription and subjective hand impairment but not autonomic or corticospinal dysfunction

OBJECTIVES

Heat sensitivity (HS) describes a temporary worsening of multiple sclerosis (MS) symptoms with increased body temperature. The pathophysiology may relate to central nervous system conduction deficits and autonomic dysfunction. We conducted deep clinical phenotyping of a cohort of persons with MS to identify predictors of HS.

METHODS

We recruited 59 MS participants with HS or No HS. Participants self-reported symptom severity (Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale, Multiple Sclerosis Impact Scale, and fatigue visual analog scale) and underwent maximal exercise and transcranial magnetic stimulation testing to characterize autonomic and corticospinal function. We examined associations with HS using binomial logistic regression.

RESULTS

People with HS (36/59) had significantly greater disability, depression, fatigue, and physical and psychological functional effects of MS. They also had significantly lower corticospinal excitability but not conduction. After controlling for disease-modifying therapy (DMT), disability, and disease type, self-reported difficulty using hands in everyday tasks was significantly associated with a large increase in the odds of HS. Autonomic and corticospinal dysfunction were not associated with HS. Lack of DMT use alone was also associated with a large increase in the odds of HS.

DISCUSSION

Following a comprehensive assessment of plausible contributors to HS, HS was most strongly associated with lack of a DMT prescription and self-reported hand dysfunction. Surprisingly, objective measurement of autonomic and corticospinal integrity did not contribute to HS.

Heart rate variability and fatigue in MS: two parallel pathways representing disseminated inflammatory processes?

BACKGROUND

Fatigue is a disabling symptom of multiple sclerosis. Its biological causes are still poorly understood. Several years ago, we proposed that fatigue might be the subjective representation of inflammatory processes. An important step for a straight-forward evaluation of our model would be to show that the level of fatigue is associated with vagal activation. The heart rate is under partial control of the vagus nerve. Using power spectrum analysis allows to separate, at least partly, sympathetic and parasympathetic impact on heart rate variability.

METHODS

This narrative review summarizes the evidence for heart rate variability changes in MS patients, their relationship with fatigue and disease course. To do this, we conducted a literature search, including 45 articles relevant to the topic treated in this review.

RESULTS

We illustrate that (1) inflammation leads to a change in cardiac behavior during acute and chronic phases, both in animals and in humans; (2) MS patients show changes of heart rate variability (HRV) that resemble those during acute and chronic inflammation due to multiple causes; (3) existing evidence favors a set of specific predictions about fatigue and parallel HRV changes; and (4) that MS-related brainstem lesions or neurological impairments do not completely explain HRV changes, leaving enough place for an explanatory relation between HRV and fatigue.

DISCUSSION

We discuss the results of this review in relation to our model of fatigue and propose several observational and experimental studies that could be conducted to gain a better insight into whether fatigue and HRV can be interpreted as a common pathway, both reflecting activated autoimmune processes in MS patients.

Acute Thermoregulatory and Cardiovascular Response to Submaximal Exercise in People With Multiple Sclerosis

Background

Heat sensitivity occurs in a high percentage of people with multiple sclerosis (PwMS), in response to environmental or exercise-induced increase in body temperature. However, the kinetic and magnitude of adaptation of the internal load and of the core body temperature (CBT) to a submaximal continuous exercise has been poorly addressed in PwMS; this may be relevant for the brief exercise bouts usually occurring in normal daily life. The aim of this work was to evaluate whether multiple sclerosis influences the acute adaptation of the internal load, the CBT and the perceptual load in response to a constant submaximal work step.

Methods

CBT has been continuously monitored (0.5 Hz) by a validated wearable heat-flux sensor and electrocardiography was recorded (250 Hz) by a wearable device during a standard 6-minute walk test (6MWT) in 14 PwMS (EDSS, 4.7 ± 1.2; disease duration: 13.0 ± 10.2 years; m ± SD) and 14 age, sex and BMI-matched healthy subjects (HS). The rate of perceived exertion (RPE) of the lower limbs was assessed during the 6MWT by the Borg scale (6-20).

Results

As expected, PwMS walked a significantly shorter distance (361 ± 98 m) than the HS group (613 ± 62 m, p<0.001 vs PwMS). However, the kinetics of adaptation of CBT and the magnitude of CBT change from baseline did not differ between groups. Similarly, heart rate (HR) kinetics and HR change from baseline were comparable between groups during the 6MWT. Finally, lower limbs RPE gradually increased during the exercise test, but without significant differences between groups.

Conclusion

The internal load, the metabolic heat production, and the perceptive load due to a standard submaximal walking exercise seems to be preserved in PwMS, suggesting a comparable acute heat production and dissipation during exercise. Therefore, it is unlikely that the different distance achieved during the 6MWT may be caused by altered thermoregulatory responses to exercise. Rather, this appears to be a consequence of the known increased energy cost of locomotion in PwMS.