Hindbrain estrogen receptor-beta antagonism normalizes reproductive and counter-regulatory hormone secretion in hypoglycemic steroid-primed ovariectomized female rats

Context-sensitive computational mechanistic explanation in cognitive neuroscience

Mainstream cognitive neuroscience aims to build mechanistic explanations of behavior by mapping abilities described at the organismal level via the subpersonal level of computation onto specific brain networks. We provide an integrative review of these commitments and their mismatch with empirical research findings. Context-dependent neural tuning, neural reuse, degeneracy, plasticity, functional recovery, and the neural correlates of enculturated skills each show that there is a lack of stable mappings between organismal, computational, and neural levels of analysis. We furthermore highlight recent research suggesting that task context at the organismal level determines the dynamic parcellation of functional components at the neural level. Such instability prevents the establishment of specific computational descriptions of neural function, which remains a central goal of many brain mappers - including those who are sympathetic to the notion of many-to-many mappings between organismal and neural levels. This between-level instability presents a deep epistemological challenge and requires a reorientation of methodological and theoretical commitments within cognitive neuroscience. We demonstrate the need for change to brain mapping efforts in the face of instability if cognitive neuroscience is to maintain its central goal of constructing computational mechanistic explanations of behavior; we show that such explanations must be contextual at all levels.

Impact of caudal hindbrain glycogen metabolism on A2 noradrenergic neuron AMPK activation and ventromedial hypothalamic nucleus norepinephrine activity and glucoregulatory neurotransmitter marker protein expression

The brain glycogen reserve is a source of oxidizable substrate fuel. Lactoprivic-sensitive hindbrain A2 noradrenergic neurons provide crucial metabolic-sensory input to downstream hypothalamic glucose-regulatory structures. Current research examined whether hindbrain glycogen fuel supply impacts A2 energy stability and governance of ventromedial hypothalamic nucleus (VMN) metabolic transmitter signaling. Male rats were injected into the caudal fourth ventricle (CV4) with the glycogen phosphorylase inhibitor 1,4-dideoxy-1,4-imino-D-arabinitol (DAB) prior to continuous intra-CV4 infusion of L-lactate or vehicle. Lactate reversed DAB suppression of A2 neuron AMPK protein and up-regulated phosphoAMPK profiles. A2 dopamine-β-hydroxylase expression was refractory to DAB, but elevated by DAB/lactate. Lactate normalized A2 estrogen receptor-alpha and GPER proteins and up-regulated estrogen receptor-beta levels in DAB-treated rats. VMN norepinephrine content was decreased by DAB, but partially restored by lactate. DAB caused lactate-reversible or -irreversible augmentation of VMN glycogen phosphorylase-brain (GPbb) and -muscle type (GPmm) variant profiles, and correspondingly up- or down-regulated VMN protein markers of glucose-stimulatory nitrergic and glucose-inhibitory γ-aminobutyric acid transmission. DAB did not alter plasma glucose, but suppressed or elevated circulating glucagon and corticosterone in that order. Results show that diminished hindbrain glycogen breakdown is communicated to the VMN, in part by NE signaling, to up-regulate VMN glycogen breakdown and trigger neurochemical signaling of energy imbalance in that site. DAB effects on GPmm, VMN glycogen content, and counter-regulatory hormone secretion were unabated by lactate infusion, suggesting that aside from substrate fuel provision rate, additional indicators of glycogen metabolism such as turnover rate may be monitored in the hindbrain.

Sex-specific acclimation of A2 noradrenergic neuron dopamine-β-hydroxylase and estrogen receptor variant protein and 5'-AMP-Activated protein kinase reactivity to recurring hypoglycemia in rat

Hindbrain estrogen receptors (ER) impose sex-dimorphic control of counter-regulatory hormone and hypothalamic glucoregulatory transmitter and glycogen metabolic responses to hypoglycemia. A2 noradrenergic neurons are estradiol- and metabolic-sensitive. Estradiol controls dopamine-beta-hydroxylase (DBH) protein habituation to recurrent insulin-induced hypoglycemia (RIIH) in females. Current research investigated the premise that sex-dimorphic patterns of A2 ER variant acclimation to RIIH correlate with differential A2 DBH and 5'-AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) adaptation to RIIH. A2 neurons were laser-catapult-microdissected from male and female rats after one or four insulin injections for Western blot analysis. A2 pAMPK and DBH levels were increased in males, but suppressed in females after single insulin dosing. ER-alpha (ERα) and -beta (ERβ) protein profiles were unaffected or decreased by acute hypoglycemia in each sex, whereas G protein-linked ER-1 (GPER) reactivity varied by sex. Antecedent hypoglycemia diminished basal A2 ERα/GPER and elevated ERβ content in each sex, yet reduced pAMPK and DBH levels in female rats only. Reintroduced hypoglycemia suppressed A2 ERβ levels in each sex, but altered DBH (↓), ERα (↓), and GPER (↑) levels in males only. Data document sex differences in A2 DBH adaptation to RIIH, e.g. a shift from positive-to-negative response in males versus loss of negative reactivity in females, as well as attenuated AMPK activation in both sexes. Between hypoglycemic episodes, A2 neurons in each sex likely exhibit diminished sensitivity to ERα/GPER signaling, but heightened receptivity to ERβ input. RIIH-induced changes in ERα and GPER expression in male but not female may contribute to DBH suppression (males) versus no change (females) relative to adapted baseline expression.

Hindbrain metabolic deficiency regulates ventromedial hypothalamic nucleus glycogen metabolism and glucose‑regulatory signaling

The catecholamine norepinephrine (NE) links hindbrain metabolic‑sensory neurons with downstream gluco‑regulatory loci, including the ventromedial hypothalamic nucleus (VMN). Exogenous NE up‑regulates VMN expression of glutamate decarboxylase (GAD), biomarker for the gluco‑inhibitory transmitter γ‑aminobutryic acid (GABA). Brain glycogen phosphorylase (GP)‑muscle (GPmm) and ‑brain (GPbb) variants are stimulated in vitro by NE or energy deficiency, respectively. Current research investigated whether lactoprivic‑driven VMN NE signaling regulates GABA and if VMN GPmm and GPbb profiles react differently to that deficit cue. Male rats were pretreated by caudal fourth ventricle delivery of the selective catecholamine neurotoxin 6‑hydroxydopamine (6OHDA) ahead of the monocarboxylate transporter inhibitor alpha‑cyano‑4‑hydroxycinnamic acid (4CIN). Micropunch‑dissected VMN tissue was analyzed by Western blot and ELISA to assess NE‑dependent 4CIN regulation of GAD and GP variant protein expression and NE activity. 4CIN caused 6OHDA‑reversible augmentation of VMN NE content and plasma glucose and counter‑regulatory hormone levels. 6OHDA stimulated basal VMN GAD expression, but prevented 4CIN stimulation of this profile. Neurotoxin inhibited or increased baseline VMN GPmm and GPbb levels, respectively, in non‑4CIN‑injected rats. 6OHDA deterred 4CIN inhibition of GPmm, but did not prevent drug stimulation of GPbb. Results affirm hindbrain lactoprivic regulation of glucostasis. Hindbrain NE exerts opposite effects on VMN GABA transmission during hindbrain lactostasis vs. ‑privation. VMN norepinephrine‑ vs. energy‑sensitive GP variants are subject to dissimilar NE regulation during energy homeostasis, and respond differently to hindbrain lactoprivation.

Sex differences in forebrain estrogen receptor regulation of hypoglycemic patterns of counter-regulatory hormone secretion and ventromedial hypothalamic nucleus glucoregulatory neurotransmitter and astrocyte glycogen metabolic enzyme expression

The female ventromedial hypothalamic nucleus (VMN) is a focal substrate for estradiol (E) regulation of energy balance, feeding, and body weight, but how E shapes VMN gluco-regulatory signaling in each sex is unclear. This study investigated the hypothesis that estrogen receptor-alpha (ERα) and/or -beta (ERβ) control VMN signals that inhibit [γ-aminobutyric acid] or stimulate [nitric oxide, steroidogenic factor-1 (SF-1)] counter-regulation in a sex-dependent manner. VMN nitrergic neurons monitor astrocyte fuel provision; here, we examined how these ER regulate astrocyte glycogen metabolic enzyme, monocarboxylate transporter, and adrenoreceptor protein responses to insulin-induced hypoglycemia (IIH) in each sex. Testes-intact male and E-replaced ovariectomized female rats were pretreated by intracerebroventricular ERα antagonist (MPP) or ERβ antagonist (PHTPP) administration before IIH. Data implicate both ER in hypoglycemic inhibition of neuronal nitric oxide synthase protein in each sex and up-regulation of glutamate decarboxylase_65/67 and SF-1 expression in females. ERα and -β enhance astrocyte AMPK and glycogen synthase expression and inhibit glycogen phosphorylase in hypoglycemic females, while ERβ suppresses the same proteins in males. Differential VMN astrocyte protein responses to IIH may partially reflect ERα and -β augmentation of ERβ and down-regulation of alpha₁, alpha₂, and beta₁ adrenoreceptor proteins in females, versus ERβ repression of GPER and alpha₂ adrenoreceptor profiles in males. MPP or PHTPP pretreatment blunted counter-regulatory hormone secretion in hypoglycemic males only, suggesting that in males one or more VMN neurotransmitters exhibiting sensitivity to forebrain ER may passively regulate this endocrine outflow, whereas female forebrain ERα and -β are apparently uninvolved in these contra-regulatory responses.

Effects of estradiol on lactoprivic signaling of the hindbrain upon the contraregulatory hormonal response and metabolic neuropeptide synthesis in hypoglycemic female rats

BACKGROUND

Caudal dorsomedial hindbrain detection of hypoglycemia-associated lactoprivation regulates glucose counter-regulation in male rats. In females, estradiol (E) determines hypothalamic neuroanatomical and molecular foci of hindbrain energy sensor activation. This study investigated the hypothesis that E signal strength governs metabolic neuropeptide and counter-regulatory hormone responses to hindbrain lactoprivic stimuli in hypoglycemic female rats.

METHODS

Ovariectomized animals were implanted with E-filled silastic capsules [30 (E-30) or 300 μg (E-300)/mL] to replicate plasma concentrations at estrous cycle nadir versus peak levels. E-30 and E-300 rats were injected with insulin or vehicle following initiation of continuous caudal fourth ventricular L-lactate infusion.

RESULTS

Hypoglycemic hypercorticosteronemia was greater in E-30 versus E-300 animals. Glucagon and corticosterone outflow was correspondingly fully or partially reversed by hindbrain lactate infusion. Insulin-injected rats exhibited lactate-reversible augmentation of norepinephrine (NE) accumulation in all preoptic/hypothalamic structures examined, excluding the dorsomedial hypothalamic nucleus (DMH) where hindbrain lactate infusion either suppressed (E-30) or enhanced (E-300) NE content. Expression profiles of hypoglycemia-reactive metabolic neuropeptides were normalized (with greater efficacy in E-300 animals) by lactate infusion. DMH RFamide-related peptide-1 and -3, arcuate neuropeptide Y and kisspeptin, and ventromedial nucleus nitric oxide synthase protein responses to hypoglycemia were E dosage-dependent.

CONCLUSIONS

Distinct physiological patterns of E secretion characteristic of the female rat estrous cycle elicit differential corticosterone outflow during hypoglycemia, and establish both common and different hypothalamic metabolic neurotransmitter targets of hindbrain lactate deficit signaling. Outcomes emphasize a need for insight on systems-level organization, interaction, and involvement of E signal strength-sensitive neuropeptides in counter-regulatory functions.

Hindbrain 5'-Adenosine Monophosphate-activated Protein Kinase Mediates Short-term Food Deprivation Inhibition of the Gonadotropin-releasing Hormone-Luteinizing Hormone Axis: Role of Nitric Oxide

Hindbrain-derived stimuli restrain the gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH)-pituitary luteinizing hormone (LH) reproductive neuroendocrine axis during energy insufficiency. Interruption of food intake, planned or unplanned, is emblematic of modern life. This study investigated the premise that the hindbrain energy sensor 5'-adenosine monophosphate-activated protein kinase (AMPK) inhibits reproductive neuroendocrine function in short term, e.g. 18-h food-deprived (FD) estradiol (E)-implanted ovariectomized female rats. Intra-caudal fourth ventricular administration of the AMPK inhibitor Compound C (Cc) reversed FD-induced inhibition of rostral preoptic (rPO) GnRH protein expression and LH release in animals given E to replicate proestrus (high-E dose-, but not metestrus (low-E dose)-stage plasma steroid levels. FD caused Cc-reversible augmentation or diminution of preoptic norepinephrine (NE) activity in high- versus low-E rats, respectively, and AMPK-independent reductions in hypothalamic NE accumulation in the latter. Nitric oxide (NO) and kisspeptin are key stimulatory signals for the preovulatory LH surge. Here, FD inhibited rPO neuronal nitric oxide synthase protein expression in high-, but not low-E-dosed animals. Lateral ventricular delivery of the NO donor 3-morpholinosydnonimine (SIN-1) reversed inhibitory GnRH and LH responses to FD in high-E rats, and normalized rPO Vglut2, anteroventral periventricular KiSS1, and dorsomedial hypothalamic RFRP-3 mRNA and/or protein profiles. Data show that FD curtails reproductive neuroendocrine outflow by hindbrain AMPK-dependent mechanisms in the presence of peak estrous cycle E levels. Results indicate that neural networks linking this sensor to GnRH neurons likely involve NO signaling, which may function upstream of one or more neurotransmitters identified here by SIN-1-reversible inhibitory responses to FD.

Sex Differences and Role of Estradiol in Hypoglycemia-Associated Counter-Regulation

Vital nerve cell functions, including maintenance of transmembrane voltage and information transfer, occur at high energy expense. Inadequate provision of the obligate metabolic fuel glucose exposes neurons to risk of dysfunction or injury. Clinical hypoglycemia rarely occurs in nondiabetic individuals but is an unfortunate regular occurrence in patients with type 1 or advanced insulin-treated type 2 diabetes mellitus. Requisite strict glycemic control, involving treatment with insulin, sulfonylureas, or glinides, can cause frequent episodes of iatrogenic hypoglycemia due to defective counter-regulation, including reduced glycemic thresholds and diminished magnitude of motor responses. Multiple components of the body's far-reaching energy balance regulatory network, including the hindbrain dorsal vagal complex, provide dynamic readout of cellular energetic disequilibrium, signals that are utilized by the hypothalamus to shape counterregulatory autonomic, neuroendocrine, and behavioral outflow toward restoration of glucostasis. The ovarian steroid hormone 17β-estradiol acts on central substrates to preserve nerve cell energy stability brain-wide, thereby providing neuroprotection against bio-energetic insults such as neurodegenerative diseases and acute brain ischemia. The current review highlights recent evidence implicating estrogen in gluco-regulation in females by control of hindbrain metabolic sensor screening and signaling of hypoglycemia-associated neuro-energetic instability. It is anticipated that new understanding of the mechanistic basis of how estradiol influences metabolic sensory input from this critical brain locus to discrete downstream regulatory network substrates will likely reveal viable new molecular targets for therapeutic simulation of hormone actions that promote positive neuronal metabolic state during acute and recurring hypoglycemia.