Highly specific radiographic marker predates clinical diagnosis in progressive supranuclear palsy

Identification of optimal value of magnetic resonance planimetry and the parkinsonism index for the diagnosis of Parkinson's disease and progressive supranuclear palsy

Objectives

Parkinson's disease (PD) and progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) are neurodegenerative conditions that have overlapping clinical and imaging features, thus making it difficult to distinguish and diagnose PSP from PD. Therefore, in this study, we aimed to investigate the optimal value of magnetic resonance planimetry and the parkinsonism index to differentiate between PSP and PD.

Methods

In this retrospective study, we recruited a total of 84 patients (27 patients with PSP, 27 patients with PD and 27 normal controls) who underwent MRI brain examinations. For each subject, we calculated the corpus callosum area, midbrain area, pons area, middle cerebellar peduncle (MCP) width and superior cerebellar peduncle (SCP) width on MRI brain images. We also calculated the pons to midbrain area (P/M) ratio, MCP/SCP ratio and magnetic resonance parkinsonism index (MRPI).

Results

Receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC) analysis was used to identify the diagnostic value of each biomarker. MRPI had a sensitivity of 70.4%, a specificity of 88.9%, and a diagnostic accuracy of 79.6% with an optimum cut off of 24.3 for differentiating PSP from PD. P/M ratio had a sensitivity of 74.1%, a specificity of 77.8%, and a diagnostic accuracy of 75.9% with an optimal cutoff of 24.3 for differentiating PSP from PD. The MCP/SCP ratio had a sensitivity of 66.7%, a specificity of 77.8%, and an accuracy of 72.2% with an optimal cut off of 4.65 for differentiating PSP from PD.

Conclusions

The study revealed that MRPI and P/M ratio are accurate markers for differentiating PSP from PD. The optimal cut-off values derived from our study can help in the early diagnosis of PD.

Midbrain and pons MRI shape analysis and its clinical and CSF correlates in degenerative parkinsonisms: a pilot study

OBJECTIVES

To conduct brainstem MRI shape analysis across neurodegenerative parkinsonisms and control subjects (CS), along with its association with clinical and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) correlates.

METHODOLOGY

We collected demographic and clinical variables, performed planimetric and shape MRI analyses, and determined CSF neurofilament-light chain (NfL) levels in 84 participants: 11 CS, 12 with Parkinson's disease (PD), 26 with multiple system atrophy (MSA), 21 with progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP), and 14 with corticobasal degeneration (CBD).

RESULTS

MSA featured the most extensive and significant brainstem shape narrowing (that is, atrophy), mostly in the pons. CBD presented local atrophy in several small areas in the pons and midbrain compared to PD and CS. PSP presented local atrophy in small areas in the posterior and upper midbrain as well as the rostral pons compared to MSA. Our findings of planimetric MRI measurements and CSF NfL levels replicated those from previous literature. Brainstem shape atrophy correlated with worse motor state in all parkinsonisms and with higher NfL levels in MSA, PSP, and PD.

CONCLUSION

Atypical parkinsonisms present different brainstem shape patterns which correlate with clinical severity and neuronal degeneration. In MSA, shape analysis could be further explored as a potential diagnostic biomarker. By contrast, shape analysis appears to have a rather limited discriminant value in PSP.

KEY POINTS

• Atypical parkinsonisms present different brainstem shape patterns. • Shape patterns correlate with clinical severity and neuronal degeneration. • In MSA, shape analysis could be further explored as a potential diagnostic biomarker.

Magnetic Resonance Planimetry in the Differential Diagnosis between Parkinson’s Disease and Progressive Supranuclear Palsy

The clinical differential diagnosis between Parkinson’s disease (PD) and progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) is often challenging. The description of milder PSP phenotypes strongly resembling PD, such as PSP-Parkinsonism, further increased the diagnostic challenge and the need for reliable neuroimaging biomarkers to enhance the diagnostic certainty. This review aims to summarize the contribution of a relatively simple and widely available imaging technique such as MR planimetry in the differential diagnosis between PD and PSP, focusing on the recent advancements in this field. The development of accurate MR planimetric biomarkers, together with the implementation of automated algorithms, led to robust and objective measures for the differential diagnosis of PSP and PD at the individual level. Evidence from longitudinal studies also suggests a role of MR planimetry in predicting the development of the PSP clinical signs, allowing to identify PSP patients before they meet diagnostic criteria when their clinical phenotype can be indistinguishable from PD. Finally, promising evidence exists on the possible association between MR planimetric measures and the underlying pathology, with important implications for trials with new disease-modifying target therapies.

Brainstem Biomarkers of Clinical Variant and Pathology in Progressive Supranuclear Palsy

BACKGROUND

Magnetic resonance brainstem measurements are useful structural biomarkers in the Richardson's syndrome variant of progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP). However, it is unclear how these biomarkers differ across the phenotypic spectrum of PSP and how they relate to underlying pathology.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to compare brainstem imaging measures across clinical variants of PSP and determine sensitivity and specificity based on pathologically diagnosed cases.

METHODS

A total of 153 patients with PSP who represented eight clinical variants were recruited at Mayo Clinic (Rochester, MN, USA) and underwent structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Midbrain and pons area and superior and middle cerebellar peduncle width measurements were performed, and midbrain/pons ratio and Magnetic Resonance Parkinsonism Index (MRPI) were calculated. Among the 43 patients who later died, PSP pathology was confirmed in 29, whereas 14 had other pathology.

RESULTS

Brainstem measurements varied across PSP clinical variants and were most abnormal in PSP-Richardson's syndrome and frontal variants, followed by PSP-corticobasal, PSP-speech/language, and PSP-parkinsonism variants. All these variants showed abnormalities compared with controls. The PSP-gait freezing variant and patients with prominent corticospinal tract signs showed normal brainstem measures. Among cases with confirmed PSP pathology, the midbrain area, midbrain/pons ratio, and MRPI were all more abnormal compared to those with other pathologies, with best differentiation obtained with the MRPI (sensitivity = 83%; specificity = 85%).

CONCLUSIONS

MRI brainstem measures show utility as diagnostic biomarkers across PSP clinical variants and have the potential to be useful in predicting underlying pathology. © 2021 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Investigating the 1-year decline in midbrain-to-pons ratio in the differential diagnosis of PSP and IPD

Background

A reliable measure of PSP-specific midbrain atrophy, the midbrain-to-pons ratio (MTPR) has been reported to support the differential diagnosis of progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) from idiopathic Parkinson’s disease (IPD). Since longitudinal analyses are lacking so far, the present study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic value of the relative change of MTPR (relΔt_MTPR) over a 1-year period in patients with PSP, IPD, and healthy controls (HC).

Methods

Midsagittal individual MRIs of patients with PSP (n = 15), IPD (n = 15), and healthy controls (HC; n = 15) were assessed and the MTPR at baseline and after 1 year were defined. The diagnostic accuracy of the MTPR and its relative change were evaluated using ROC curve analyses.

Results

PSP-patients had a significantly lower MTPR at baseline (M = 0.45 ± 0.06), compared to both non-PSP groups (F (2, 41) = 62.82, p < 0.001), with an overall predictive accuracy of 95.6% for an MTPR ≤ 0.54. PSP-patients also presented a significantly stronger 1-year decline in MTPR compared to IPD (p < 0.001). Though predictive accuracy of relΔ_t_MTPR for PSP (M = − 4.74% ± 4.48) from IPD (M =  + 1.29 ± 3.77) was good (76.6%), ROC analysis did not reveal a significant improvement of diagnostic accuracy by combining the MTPR and relΔ_t_MTPR (p = 0.670). Still, specificity for PSP increased, though not significantly (p = 0.500).

Conclusion

The present results indicate that the relΔ_t_MTPR is a potentially useful tool to support the differential diagnosis of PSP from IPD. For its relative 1-year change, still, more evaluation is needed.

A New MRI Measure to Early Differentiate Progressive Supranuclear Palsy From De Novo Parkinson's Disease in Clinical Practice: An International Study

BACKGROUND

Enlargement of the third ventricle has been reported in atypical parkinsonism. We investigated whether the measurement of third ventricle width could distinguish Parkinson's disease (PD) from progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP).

METHODS

We assessed a new MR T1-weighted measurement (third ventricle width/internal skull diameter) in a training cohort of 268 participants (98 PD, 73 PSP, 98 controls from our center) and in a testing cohort of 291 participants (82 de novo PD patients and 133 controls from the Parkinson's Progression Markers Initiative, 76 early-stage PSP from an international research group). PD diagnosis was confirmed after a 4-year follow-up. Diagnostic performance of the third ventricle/internal skull diameter was assessed using receiver operating characteristic curve with bootstrapping; the area under the curve of the training cohort was compared with the area under the curve of the testing cohort using the De Long test.

RESULTS

In both cohorts, third ventricle/internal skull diameter values did not differ between PD and controls but were significantly lower in PD than in PSP patients (P < 0.0001). In PD, third ventricle/internal skull diameter values did not change significantly between baseline and follow-up evaluation. Receiver operating characteristic analysis accurately differentiated PD from PSP in the training cohort (area under the curve, 0.94; 95% CI, 91.1-97.6; cutoff, 5.72) and in the testing cohort (area under the curve, 0.91; 95% CI, 87.0-97.0; cutoff,: 5.88), validating the generalizability of the results.

CONCLUSION

Our study provides a new reliable and validated MRI measurement for the early differentiation of PD and PSP. The simplicity and generalizability of this biomarker make it suitable for routine clinical practice and for selection of patients in clinical trials worldwide. © 2020 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Conventional Magnetic Resonance Imaging in the Diagnosis of Parkinsonian Disorders: A Meta-Analysis

Background

Numerous conventional magnetic resonance imaging (cMRI) parameters were previously found to differentiate parkinsonian disorders with statistical significance, but effect size has not been considered.

Objectives

To quantify effect size of previously identified cMRI parameters that differentiated parkinsonian disorders with statistical significance.

Method

A PubMed search limited to studies assessing cMRI parameters in at least 2 of Parkinson's disease, progressive supranuclear palsy, multiple system atrophy, and corticobasal degeneration/syndrome were selected. Either Cohen's d or positive and negative likelihood (LR+/-) as well as diagnostic odds ratios (DORs) were calculated as appropriate. cMRI parameter was considered useful if Cohen's d > 1.94 (<20% overlap) or if LR+ > 10, LR- < 0.1, or DOR > 20.

Results

Literature search identified 8848 publications and 36 were included for analysis. Putaminal (Cohen's d 2.07; DOR 23-infinity), pontine (DOR 32-infinity), and middle cerebellar peduncle (Cohen's d 2.24; DOR infinity) abnormalities were most useful in differentiating multiple system atrophy while reduced midbrain (Cohen's d 2.33-8.69; DOR infinity) and superior cerebellar peduncle (Cohen's d 2.47; DOR 51-infinity) diameters separated progressive supranuclear palsy. Corticobasal degeneration/syndrome does not have any distinguishing cMRI features, but reduced midbrain diameter may help differentiate corticobasal degeneration/syndrome from Parkinson's disease (DOR infinity). When LR- was calculated, all of these features carried a value of <0.1.

Conclusion

A number of cMRI features consistently demonstrated large effect size in separating parkinsonian disorders. However, it is the presence and not absence of these cMRI features that is most useful in patients with low to moderate pretest probability.

Methods and utility of quantitative brainstem measurements in progressive supranuclear palsy versus Parkinson's disease in a routine clinical setting

Background and Purpose

The clinical diagnosis of progressive supranuclear palsy can be challenging, as the clinical presentation overlaps with that of Parkinson's disease and multiple system atrophy. We sought to examine the practical utility of radiologic markers of progressive supranuclear palsy by investigating whether these markers could distinguish between patients with progressive supranuclear palsy-Richardson syndrome (PSP-RS) and those with Parkinson's disease based on imaging obtained in a typical clinical setting, not in a prospective research environment.

Materials and methods

This retrospective study included 13 patients with PSP-RS and 13 patients with Parkinson's disease who were followed for either condition at our institution at the time of the study and who had MRI records available. Patients were selected without regard to type of imaging obtained. All diagnoses were confirmed by a trained movement disorders specialist using validated diagnostic criteria. Groups were matched for age and disease duration at the time of scanning. MRI records were retrospectively obtained, and image analysis was performed by investigators blinded to disease classification. Midbrain area, midbrain to pons area ratio, midbrain anterior-posterior diameter, and MR parkinsonism index were calculated for each patient.

Results

All established measures of identifying progressive supranuclear palsy (midbrain area, midbrain to pons area ratio, midbrain anterior-posterior diameter, and MR parkinsonism index) were significantly different between patients with PSP-RS and those with Parkinson's disease.

Conclusion

Previously established radiographic markers distinguishing between PSP-RS and Parkinson's disease have practical utility in the clinical setting and not just in well-designed prospective analyses.

Midbrain MRI assessments in progressive supranuclear palsy subtypes

OBJECTIVES

To explore the role of the available midbrain-based MRI morphometric assessments in (1) differentiating among progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) subtypes (PSP Richardson's syndrome (PSP-RS), PSP with predominant parkinsonism (PSP-P) and the other variant syndromes of PSP (vPSP)), and (2) supporting the diagnosis of PSP subtypes compared with Parkinson's disease (PD) and healthy controls (HC).

METHODS

Seventy-eight patients with PSP (38 PSP-RS, 21 PSP-P and 19 vPSP), 35 PD and 38 HC were included in the present analysis. Available midbrain-based MRI morphometric assessments were calculated for all participants.

RESULTS

Current MRI midbrain-based assessments do not display an adequate sensitivity and specificity profile in differentiating PSP subtypes. On the other hand, we confirmed MR Parkinsonism Index (MRPI) and pons area to midbrain area ratio (P/M) have adequate diagnostic value to support PSP-RS clinical diagnosis compared with both PD and HC, but low sensitivity and specificity profile in differentiating PSP-P from PD as well as from HC. The same measures show acceptable sensitivity and specificity profile in supporting clinical diagnosis of vPSP versus HC but not versus PD. Similar findings were detected for the newer MRPI and P/M versions.

CONCLUSIONS

Further studies are warranted to identify neuroimaging biomarkers supporting the clinical phenotypic categorisation of patients with PSP. MRPI and P/M have diagnostic value in supporting the clinical diagnosis of PSP-RS.

CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE

This study provides class III evidence that available MRI midbrain-based assessments do not have diagnostic value in differentiating the Movement Disorder Society PSP subtypes.

PSP-like syndrome after aortic surgery in adults (Mokri syndrome)

Background

A rare progressive supranuclear palsy-like syndrome seemingly triggered by aortic surgery was first described in 2004. This largest case series to date describes the features of this syndrome.

Methods

We searched the Mayo Clinic electronic medical records using the advanced cohort explorer search engine for patients evaluated for neurologic symptoms after cardiac-aortic surgery in the past 30 years. Data were extracted to Microsoft Excel from the identified patients and included clinical and neuroimaging features and outcomes.

Results

Twenty-five patients met the inclusion criteria. All surgeries were performed under thoracic aortic bypass and deep hypothermia. Surgery included aortic aneurysm, aortic valve repair, and/or aortic dissection repair. Surgical records were unavailable, although surgery was documented in the Mayo record as uncomplicated in 60% of cases. In the remaining cases, no particular intraoperative or postoperative complications were documented at a high frequency. A typical triad was documented: supranuclear gaze palsy (SNGP; 100%), gait imbalance (80%), and dysarthria (96%). Part or all of the triad was observed before hospital discharge and stabilized over the course of days-weeks. A second phase of symptom worsening plus new symptoms developed up to a year later; this decline continued for up to several years before stabilization. Delayed epileptic seizures occurred in 32% of patients. Brain MRI revealed only nonspecific findings.

Conclusion

This syndrome following adult thoracic aortic bypass surgery with deep hypothermia remains unexplained. It follows a biphasic course and is characterized by the triad of SNGP, unsteady gait, and a predominantly ataxic dysarthria.

Midbrain atrophy in patients with presymptomatic progressive supranuclear palsy-Richardson's syndrome

INTRODUCTION

In the present study, midbrain atrophy and the pons-to-midbrain area ratio (P/M ratio) were investigated as diagnostic markers for presymptomatic progressive supranuclear palsy-Richardson's syndrome (Pre-PSP-RS).

METHODS

The present study included 27 patients with probable PSP-RS who underwent brain MRI at least twice before and after the development of clinical symptoms, age- and sex-matched participants with Parkinson's disease (PD, n = 27), and healthy controls (n = 27). The midbrain area, pons area, and P/M ratio of the Pre-PSP-RS, PD, and control subjects were measured using midsagittal images from brain MRI, and the parameters were compared among the groups.

RESULTS

The midbrain area decreased and the P/M ratio increased significantly in the Pre-PSP-RS patients compared with both the PD and control subjects (midbrain, Pre-PSP-RS vs. PD = 1.01 cm²vs. 1.29 cm², p < 0.001, Pre-PSP-RS vs. controls = 1.01 cm²vs. 1.29 cm², p < 0.001; P/M ratio, Pre-PSP-RS vs. PD = 5.27 vs. 4.03, p < 0.001, Pre-PSP-RS vs. controls = 5.27 cm²vs. 4.06 cm², p < 0.001). The P/M ratio had high sensitivity (vs. PD, 96.3%, vs. control, 88.9%) and specificity (vs. PD, 81.5%, vs. control, 96.3%) in differentiating Pre-PSP-RS patients from PD and control subjects.

CONCLUSION

Midbrain atrophy precedes the clinical symptoms of PSP-RS and could be a useful diagnostic imaging biomarker for Pre-PSP-RS. Furthermore, this information could play an important role in the development of future treatment strategies.

Radiological biomarkers for diagnosis in PSP: Where are we and where do we need to be?

PSP is a pathologically defined neurodegenerative tauopathy with a variety of clinical presentations including typical Richardson's syndrome and other variant PSP syndromes. A large body of neuroimaging research has been conducted over the past two decades, with many studies proposing different structural MRI and molecular PET/SPECT biomarkers for PSP. These include measures of brainstem, cortical and striatal atrophy, diffusion weighted and diffusion tensor imaging abnormalities, [18F] fluorodeoxyglucose PET hypometabolism, reductions in striatal dopamine imaging and, most recently, PET imaging with ligands that bind to tau. Our aim was to critically evaluate the degree to which structural and molecular neuroimaging metrics fulfill criteria for diagnostic biomarkers of PSP. We queried the PubMed, Cochrane, Medline, and PSYCInfo databases for original research articles published in English over the past 20 years using postmortem diagnosis or the NINDS-SPSP criteria as the diagnostic standard from 1996 to 2016. We define a five-level theoretical construct for the utility of neuroimaging biomarkers in PSP, with level 1 representing group-level findings, level 2 representing biomarkers with demonstrable individual-level diagnostic utility, level 3 representing biomarkers for early disease, level 4 representing surrogate biomarkers of PSP pathology, and level 5 representing definitive PSP biomarkers of PSP pathology. We discuss the degree to which each of the currently available biomarkers fit into this theoretical construct, consider the role of biomarkers in the diagnosis of Richardson's syndrome, variant PSP syndromes and autopsy confirmed PSP, and emphasize current shortfalls in the field. © 2017 The Authors. Movement Disorders published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

The midbrain-to-pons ratio distinguishes progressive supranuclear palsy from non-fluent primary progressive aphasias

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

To determine the clinical utility of the midbrain-to-pons (M/P) ratio as a clinical biomarker of progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) in patients with non-fluent primary progressive aphasia syndromes.

METHODS

Patients with PSP, progressive non-fluent aphasia (PNFA) and logopenic progressive aphasia (LPA) were recruited. Patients were diagnosed clinically, but pathological confirmation was available in a proportion of patients. Midbrain and pons areas were measured using Osirix Lite, a free DICOM viewer. The M/P ratio and Magnetic Resonance Parkinsonism Index were calculated and their diagnostic utility compared.

RESULTS

A total of 72 participants were included (16 PSP, 18 PNFA, 16 LPA and 22 controls). Patients with PSP had motor features typical of the syndrome. Both the M/P ratio and Magnetic Resonance Parkinsonism Index differed significantly in PSP compared with controls. The M/P ratio was disproportionately reduced in PSP compared with PNFA and LPA (PSP, 0.182 ± 0.043; PNFA, 0.255 ± 0.034; LPA, 0.258 ± 0.033; controls, 0.292 ± 0.031; P < 0.001). An M/P ratio of ≤0.215 produced a positive predictive value of 77.8% for the diagnosis of PSP syndrome. Pathological examination revealed Alzheimer's disease in three cases (all LPA), pathological PSP in two cases (one clinical PSP and one PNFA) and corticobasal degeneration in one case (PNFA). The M/P ratio was ≤0.215 in both pathological cases of PSP.

CONCLUSIONS

The M/P ratio was disproportionately reduced in PSP, suggesting its potential as a clinical marker of the PSP syndrome. Larger studies of pathologically confirmed cases are needed to establish the M/P ratio as a biomarker of PSP pathology.