The ABC in pincer chemistry – From amine- to borylene- and carbon-based pincer-ligands

Synthesis and catalytic activity of heterobimetallic Au/M (M = RhIII, IrIII) complexes with ditopic mono- and triphosphane ligands

A series of heterobimetallic complexes Au/M (M = RhIII, IrIII) were prepared on the basis of two ditopic ligands: a monophosphane ligand L1H and a triphosphane ligand L2H. The complexes were fully characterised, including single-crystal X-ray diffraction studies. Catalytic activity of cationic L1/AuI/IrIII and L2/AuI/IrIII bis(trifluoromethane)sulfonimide was analysed through their capacity to induce allenyl ether rearrangement and cycloisomerisation of N-propargyl benzamide. While cationic L1/AuI/IrIII showed some ability to induce allenyl ether rearrangement, no conversion was observed for cationic L2/AuI/IrIII. Similarly, N-propargyl benzamide could undergo cycloisomerisation in the presence of cationic L1/AuI/IrIII, whereas cationic L2/AuI/IrIII was again inactive. These findings highlight how crucial the surroundings of the metal centre are to the catalytic activity. Catalytic activity is only possible when Au has a free coordination site; the gold complex becomes inactive when the tridentate ligand is present.

On Neutral Unsaturated Ouroboric Borylenes

The search is on for stable isolated borylenes. Potential roles in modern synthetic chemistry for boron analogues of carbenes continue to motivate interest in locating them. Using density functional and ab initio methods, we posit and examine the thermochemistry, and chemical bonding, including aromaticity, of several classes of 5- and 6-membered borylenic rings. In these systems, cyclization relies on dative bonding (ouroboric coordination) and π donation to a monovalent boron center from an adjacent O center. Certain neutral five-membered rings (heterocyclic cyclopentadienyl analogues) in particular are found to exhibit exceptionally strong preferences for the singlet multiplicity, each with singlet-triplet (S-T) gaps in excess of 40 kcal·mol^-1. The singlet five-membered rings with the largest S-T gaps and some of the six-membered rings show evidence of weak aromaticity. Relationships of the form N = A·r^-b, in line with Gordy's and other functions linking bond order, N, and covalent bond length, are identified for dative B←O contacts, r, reinforced in rings by π-delocalization.

A Bis-(carbone) Pincer Ligand and Its Coordinative Behavior toward Multi-Metallic Configurations

Carbones are divalent carbon(0) species that contain two lone pairs of electrons. Herein, we have prepared the first known stable and isolable free bis-(carbone) pincer framework with a well-defined solid-state structure. This bis-(carbone) ligand is an effective scaffold for forming monometallic (Ni and Pd) and trinuclear heterometallic complexes with Au-Pd-Au, Au-Ni-Au, and Cu-Ni-Cu configurations. Sophisticated quantum-theoretical analyses found that the metal-metal interactions are too weak to play a significant role in upholding these multi-metallic configurations; rather, the four lone pairs of electrons within the bis-(carbone) framework are the main contributors to the stability of the complexes.

ChemSpaX: exploration of chemical space by automated functionalization of molecular scaffold

Exploration of the local chemical space of molecular scaffolds by post-functionalization (PF) is a promising route to discover novel molecules with desired structure and function. PF with rationally chosen substituents based on known electronic and steric properties is a commonly used experimental and computational strategy in screening, design and optimization of catalytic scaffolds. Automated generation of reasonably accurate geometric representations of post-functionalized molecular scaffolds is highly desirable for data-driven applications. However, automated PF of transition metal (TM) complexes remains challenging. In this work a Python-based workflow, ChemSpaX, that is aimed at automating the PF of a given molecular scaffold with special emphasis on TM complexes, is introduced. In three representative applications of ChemSpaX by comparing with DFT and DFT-B calculations, we show that the generated structures have a reasonable quality for use in computational screening applications. Furthermore, we show that ChemSpaX generated geometries can be used in machine learning applications to accurately predict DFT computed HOMO–LUMO gaps for transition metal complexes. ChemSpaX is open-source and aims to bolster and democratize the efforts of the scientific community towards data-driven chemical discovery.

This work introduces ChemSpaX, an open-source Python-based tool for automated exploration of chemical space of molecular scaffolds with a special focus on transition-metal complexes.

Cationic ligands between σ-donation and hydrogen-bridge-bond-stabilisation of ancillary ligands in coinage metal complexes with protonated carbodiphosphoranes

Protonated carbodiphosphoranes are demonstrated to act as σ- or hydrogen-bridge-bond donors in a series of copper and silver complexes.

Chemically robust and readily available quinoline-based PNN iron complexes: application in C-H borylation of arenes

Iron catalysts have been used for over a century to produce ammonia industrially. However, the use of iron catalysts generally remained quite limited until relatively recently, when the abundance and low toxicity of iron spurred the development of a variety of iron catalysts. Despite the fact that iron catalysts are being developed as alternatives to precious metal catalysts, their reactivities and stabilities are quite different because of their unique electronic structures. In this context, our group previously developed a new family of quinoline-based PNN pincer-type ligands for low- to mid-valent iron catalysts. These chemically robust PNN ligands provide air- and moisture-tolerant iron complexes, which exhibit excellent catalytic performances in the C-H borylation of arenes. This feature article summarises our recent work on PNN iron complexes, including their conception and design, as well as related reports on iron pincer complexes and iron-catalysed C-H borylation reactions.

Bimetallic Ru-Pd and Trimetallic Ru-Pd-Cu Assemblies on the Carborane Cluster Surface

The synthesis of well-defined heterometallic complexes remains a frontier challenge in inorganic chemistry. We report an approach that relies on the sequential insertion of electrophilic metal fragments into electron-rich Ru-B bonds of the η²-BB-carboryne complex (POBBOP)Ru(CO)₂ [POBBOP = 1,7-OP(ⁱPr)₂-m-2,6-dehydrocarborane]. Utilizing this synthetic strategy, bimetallic (POBBOP)(Ru)(CO)₂[Pd(P^tBu₃)] and trimetallic (POBBOP)(Ru)(CO)₂[Pd(P^tBu₃)](CuBr) complexes were selectively prepared. Structural and theoretical analysis of the features of chemical bonding within Ru-B-B-Cu and Ru-B-B-Pd fragments is presented.

The Stability of Diphosphino-Boryl PBP Pincer Backbone: PBP to POP Ligand Hydrolysis

Since moisture may frequently be present in many solvents, it is important to know the reactivity of a catalyst against water for catalytic reactions. In order to explore the stability and understand the transformation process of diphosphino-boryl-based PBP pincer platform, [PdCl{B(NCH₂ P^t Bu₂ )₂ -o-C₆ H₄ }] (1) was treated with PdCl₂ , HB(NCH₂ PPh₂ )₂ -o-C₆ H₄ was reacted with [PdCl₂ (cod)] (cod=cyclo-octa-1,5-diene) and [Pd₂ (dba)₃ ] (dba=dibenzylideneacetone), respectively, in the presence of water. Some novel palladium POP complexes, [Pd₂ Cl₂ (μ-Cl){μ-κ³ -P,O,P-OB(NCH₂ P^t Bu₂ )₂ -o-C₆ H₄ }] (2 a), [Pd₄ (μ-Cl)₂ (μ-O)₂ {μ-κ³ -P,O,P-OB(NCH₂ PPh₂ )₂ -o-C₆ H₄ }₂ ] (2 b), [Pd₂ {μ-κ⁴ -P,P,P,P-O(B(NCH₂ PPh₂ )₂ -o-C₆ H₄ )₂ }{μ-κ² -P,P-(NHCH₂ PPh₂ )₂ -o-C₆ H₄ }] (3), were obtained. It was found that the PBP pincer backbone can easily be converted into a POP backbone in the presence of water. From the crystal structures of the resultant palladium complexes, possible pincer backbone transformation pathways were discussed.

Direct Access to Palladium(II) Complexes Based on Anionic C,C,C-Phosphonium Ylide Core Pincer Ligand

The reaction of readily available imidazolium-phosphonium salt [MesIm(CH₂)₃PPh₃](OTf)₂ with PdCl₂ in the presence of an excess of Cs₂CO₃ afforded selectively in one step the cationic Pd(II) complex [(C,C,C)Pd(NCMe)](OTf) exhibiting an LX₂-type NHC-ylide-aryl C,C,C-pincer ligand via formal triple C-H bond activation. The replacement of labile MeCN in the latter by CNtBu and CO fragments allowed to estimate the overall electronic properties of this phosphonium ylide core pincer scaffold incorporating three different carbon-based donor ends by IR spectroscopy, cyclic voltammetry, and molecular orbital analysis, revealing its significantly higher electron-rich character compared to the structurally close NHC core pincer system with two phosphonium ylide extremities. The pincer complex [(C,C,C)Pd(CO)](OTf) represents a rare example of Pd(II) carbonyl species stable at room temperature and characterized by X-ray diffraction analysis. The treatment of isostructural cationic complexes [(C,C,C)Pd(NCMe)](OTf) and [(C,C,C)Pd(CO)](OTf) with (allyl)MgBr and nBuLi led to the formation of zwitterionic phosphonium organopalladates [(C,C,C)PdBr] and [(C,C,C)Pd(COnBu)], respectively.

Nickel(II)-SNS Thiolate Complexes: Reactivity and Solution Dynamics

Nickel coordination chemistry with a biomimetic thiolate-imine-thioether SNS^Me ligand is accompanied by diverse reactivity and multidentate ligand dynamics. Reaction of Ni(acac)₂ with 2 equiv of 2-(methylthio)-phenyl-benzothiazolidine (MPB) affords the bis(arylimino-phenylene-thiolate) complex Ni(κ²-SNS^Me)₂ (1; acac = acetylacetonate). Thermolysis of 1 in refluxing toluene is accompanied by imine C-C bond formation, yielding [Ni(N₂S₂)] (2) with a redox-active ligand. Protonation of 1 with NHTf₂ at a low temperature released 1 equiv of MPB, yielding crystals of the dimeric dication {[Ni(μ-κ³-SNS^Me)]₂}(NTf₂)₂ (3; Tf = SO₂CF₃) in high yield. In contrast, the same reaction at room temperature gave also paramagnetic complexes {Ni[μ-Ni(κ³-SNS^Me)₂]₂}(NTf₂)₂ (4) and {Ni[μ-Ni(κ³-SNS^Me)₂]₃}(NTf₂)₂ (5) that feature coordination of two or three pseudo-octahedral, paramagnetic Ni(κ³-SNS^Me)₂ units to a central Ni(II) dication via thiolate bridges. Remarkably, dissolution of 3 in a variety of solvents, including weakly coordinating CH₂Cl₂, rapidly generates a mixture of 4 and Ni(NTf)₂. Treatment of this mixture with Lewis bases L gave high yields of dimers {[Ni(μ-κ³-SNS^Me)L]₂}(NTf₂)₂ for L = CNXylyl (6a) and {[Ni(μ-κ³-SNS^Me)]₂(μ-dmpm)}(NTf₂)₂ (6b; dmpm = bis(dimethylphosphino)methane) or monomers [Ni(κ³-SNS^Me)L](NTf₂) for L = PMe₃ (7a) and P(OMe)₃ (7b). Addition of 2 equiv of the strong donor N-heterocyclic carbene ligand, IPr, to 3, however, led to thioether demethylation, affording neutral dithiolate complex Ni(κ³-SNS)(IPr) (8). Reaction products were characterized by NMR and mass spectrometry and complexes 1-5, 6a, 6b, 7a, and 8 by single-crystal X-ray diffraction.

From carbones to carbenes and ylides in the coordination sphere of iridium

The carbodiphosphorane-based iridium pincer complex (2) is demonstrated to rearrange in chlorinated organic solvents under cleavage of a P-C-bond to give a chelating phosphine ylide ligand. A detailed mechanistic investigation reveals that these types of donor groups are prone for P-C-bond cleavage in the coordination sphere of transition metal hydrido complexes. Finally, complex 2 is demonstrated to be an efficient hydrogen-borrowing catalyst.

Recent advances in pincer-nickel catalyzed reactions

Organometallic catalysts have played a key role in accomplishing numerous synthetically valuable organic transformations that are either otherwise not possible or inefficient. The use of precious, sparse and toxic 4d and 5d metals are an apparent downside of several such catalytic systems despite their immense success over the last several decades. The use of complexes containing Earth-abundant, inexpensive and less hazardous 3d metals, such as nickel, as catalysts for organic transformations has been an emerging field in recent times. In particular, the versatile nature of the corresponding pincer-metal complexes, which offers great control of their reactivity via countless variations, has garnered great interest among organometallic chemists who are looking for greener and cheaper alternatives. In this context, the current review attempts to provide a glimpse of recent developments in the chemistry of pincer-nickel catalyzed reactions. Notably, there have been examples of pincer-nickel catalyzed reactions involving two electron changes via purely organometallic mechanisms that are strikingly similar to those observed with heavier Pd and Pt analogues. On the other hand, there have been distinct differences where the pincer-nickel complexes catalyze single-electron radical reactions. The applicability of pincer-nickel complexes in catalyzing cross-coupling reactions, oxidation reactions, (de)hydrogenation reactions, dehydrogenative coupling, hydrosilylation, hydroboration, C-H activation and carbon dioxide functionalization has been reviewed here from synthesis and mechanistic points of view. The flurry of global pincer-nickel related activities offer promising avenues in catalyzing synthetically valuable organic transformations.

Coordination Flexibility of the Rh(PXP) Complex to NH3, CO, and C2H4 (PXP = Diphosphine-Based Pincer Ligand; X = B, Al, and Ga): Theoretical Insight

The recently synthesized rhodium-aluminum bimetallic complex Rh(PAlP) 1 (PAlP = pincer-type diphosphino-aluminyl ligand Al{[N(C₆H₄)]₂NMe}[CH₂P(ⁱPr)₂]₂) containing a unique Rh-Al direct bond exhibits coordination flexibility because Rh and Al can play the role of coordination site for the substrate. DFT calculations of NH₃, CO, and C₂H₄ adducts with 1 show that the Rh atom is favorable for all these substrate but the Al atom is as favorable as the Rh atom for NH₃ and unfavorable for CO and C₂H₄. NH₃ and CO prefer the coordination at the Rh-axial (Ax) site to the Rh-equatorial (Eq) site, but C₂H₄ prefers coordination at the Rh-Eq site to the Rh-Ax site. Consequently, two CO and C₂H₄ molecules coordinate with 1 at the Rh-Ax and Rh-Eq sites to afford trigonal bipyramidal complexes Rh(PAlP)(CO)₂ and Rh(PAlP)(C₂H₄)₂, which is consistent with the experimental observation of Rh(PAlP)(CO)₂. Energy decomposition analysis reveals that an electrostatic term plays an important role for NH₃ coordination with the Al atom of 1, because Al has a significantly large positive charge and NH₃ has a much negatively charged N atom and exhibits a considerably negative electrostatic potential at the Al position. In B and Ga analogues Rh(PBP) 2 and Rh(PGaP) 3, B and Ga atoms are not good for CO and C₂H₄ like the Al atom in 1. NH₃ adducts with 2 and 3 at the B and Ga sites are less stable than those adducts at the Rh-Ax site unlike the NH₃ adduct with 1 at the Al site. This difference in the NH₃ adduct between Rh(PAlP) and others (Rh(PBP) and Rh(PGaP)) arises from much less positive charges of B and Ga and a smaller atomic size of B than that of Al. These results indicate that the significantly large electropositive nature and appropriate atomic size of Al are responsible for the characteristic coordination flexibility of Rh(PAlP).

Immobilization of an Iridium Pincer Complex in a Microporous Polymer for Application in Room-Temperature Gas Phase Catalysis

An iridium dihydride pincer complex [IrH2 (POCOP)] is immobilized in a hydroxy-functionalized microporous polymer network using the concepts of surface organometallic chemistry. The introduction of this novel, truly innocent support with remote OH-groups enables the formation of isolated active metal sites embedded in a chemically robust and highly inert environment. The catalyst maintained high porosity and without prior activation exhibited efficacy in the gas phase hydrogenation of ethene and propene at room temperature and low pressure. The catalyst can be recycled for at least four times.

Cu(I) Complexes of Multidentate N,C,N- and P,C,P-Carbodiphosphorane Ligands and Their Photoluminescence

A series of dinuclear copper(I) N,C,N- and P,C,P-carbodiphosphorane (CDP) complexes using multidentate ligands CDP(Py)2 (1) and (CDP(CH2PPh2)2 (13) have been isolated and characterized. Detailed structural information was gained by single-crystal XRD analyses of nine representative examples. The common structural motive is the central double ylidic carbon atom with its characteristic two lone pairs involved in the binding of two geminal L-Cu(I) fragments at Cu-Cu distances in the range 2.55-2.67 Å. In order to enhance conformational rigidity within the characteristic Cu-C-Cu triangle, two types of chelating side arms were symmetrically attached to each phosphorus atom: two 2-pyridyl functions in ligand CDP(Py)2 (1) and its dinuclear copper complexes 2-9 and 11, as well as two diphenylphosphinomethylene functions in ligand CDP(CH2PPh2)2 (13) and its di- and mononuclear complexes 14-18. Neutral complexes were typically obtained via the reaction of 1 with Cu(I) species CuCl, CuI, and CuSPh or via the salt elimination reaction of [(CuCl)2(CDP(Py)2] (2) with sodium carbazolate. Cationic Cu(I) complexes were prepared upon treating 1 with two equivalents of [Cu(NCMe)4]PF6, followed by the addition of either two equivalents of an aryl phosphine (PPh3, P(C6H4OMe)3) or one equivalent of bisphosphine ligands bis[(2-diphenylphosphino)phenyl] ether (DPEPhos), 4,5-bis(diphenylphosphino)-9,9-dimethylxanthene (XantPhos), or 1,1'-bis(diphenyl-phosphino) ferrocene (dppf). For the first time, carbodiphosphorane CDP(CH2PPh2)2 (13) could be isolated upon treating its precursor [CH(dppm)2]Cl (12) with NaNH2 in liquid NH3. A protonated and a deprotonated derivative of ligand 13 were prepared, and their coordination was compared to neutral CDP ligand 13. NMR analysis and DFT calculations reveal that the most stable tautomer of 13 does not show a CDP (or carbone) structure in its uncoordinated base form. For most of the prepared complexes, photoluminescence upon irradiation with UV light at room temperature was observed. Quantum yields (ΦPL) were determined to be 36% for dicationic [(CuPPh3)2(CDP(Py)2)](PF6)2 (4) and 60% for neutral [(CuSPh)2(CDP(CH2PPh2)2] (16).

Recent Progress with Pincer Transition Metal Catalysts for Sustainability

Our planet urgently needs sustainable solutions to alleviate the anthropogenic global warming and climate change. Homogeneous catalysis has the potential to play a fundamental role in this process, providing novel, efficient, and at the same time eco-friendly routes for both chemicals and energy production. In particular, pincer-type ligation shows promising properties in terms of long-term stability and selectivity, as well as allowing for mild reaction conditions and low catalyst loading. Indeed, pincer complexes have been applied to a plethora of sustainable chemical processes, such as hydrogen release, CO2 capture and conversion, N2 fixation, and biomass valorization for the synthesis of high-value chemicals and fuels. In this work, we show the main advances of the last five years in the use of pincer transition metal complexes in key catalytic processes aiming for a more sustainable chemical and energy production.

NHC Core Pincer Ligands Exhibiting Two Anionic Coordinating Extremities

The chemistry of NHCcore pincer ligands of LX₂ type bearing two pending arms, identical or not, whose coordinating center is anionic in nature, is here reviewed. In this family, the negative charge of the coordinating atoms can be brought either by a carbon atom via a phosphonium ylide (R₃P⁺-CR₂^-) or by a heteroatom through amide (R₂N^-), oxide (RO^-), or thio(seleno)oxide (RS^-, RSe^-) donor functionalities. Through selected examples, the synthetic methods, coordination properties, and applications of such tridentate systems are described. Particular emphasis is placed on the role of the donor ends in the chemical behavior of these species.

Emergence and Applications of Base Metals (Fe, Co, and Ni) in Hydroboration and Hydrosilylation

Base metal catalysis offers an alternative to reactions, which were once dominated by precious metals in hydrofunctionalization reactions. This review article details the development of some base metals (Fe, Co, and Ni) in the hydroboration and hydrosilylation reactions concomitant with a brief overview of recent advances in the field. Applications of both commercially available metal salts and well-defined metal complexes in catalysis and opportunities to further advance the field is discussed as well.

Reactivity of the carbodiphosphorane, (Ph3P)2C, towards main group metal alkyl compounds: coordination and cyclometalation

The carbodiphosphorane, (Ph3P)2C, reacts with Me3Al and Me3Ga to afford the adducts, [(Ph3P)2C]AlMe3 and [(Ph3P)2C]GaMe3, which have been structurally characterized by X-ray diffraction. (Ph3P)2C also reacts with Me2Zn and Me2Cd to generate an adduct but the formation is reversible on the NMR time scale. At elevated temperatures, however, elimination of methane and cyclometalation occurs to afford [κ2-Ph3PC{PPh2(C6H4)}]ZnMe and [κ2-Ph3PC{PPh2(C6H4)}]CdMe. Analogous cyclometalated products, [κ2-Ph3P{CPPh2(C6H4)}]ZnN(SiMe3)2 and [κ2-Ph3P{CPPh2(C6H4)}]CdN(SiMe3)2, are also obtained upon reaction of (Ph3P)2C with Zn[N(SiMe3)2]2 and Cd[N(SiMe3)2]2. The magnesium compounds, Me2Mg and {Mg[N(SiMe3)2]2}2, likewise react with (Ph3P)2C to afford cyclometalated derivatives, namely [κ2-Ph3PC{PPh2(C6H4)}]MgN(SiMe3)2 and {[κ2-Ph3PC{PPh2(C6H4)}]MgMe}2. While this reactivity is similar to the zinc system, the magnesium methyl complex is a dimer with bridging methyl groups, whereas the zinc complex is a monomer. The greater tendency of the methyl groups to bridge magnesium centers rather than zinc centers is supported by density functional theory calculations.

Ligands Based on Phosphine-Stabilized Aluminum(I), Boron(I), and Carbon(0)

A systematic quantum chemical study of the bonding in d⁶ -transition-metal complexes, containing phosphine-stabilized, main-group-element fragments, (R₃ P)₂ E, as ligands (E=AlH, BH, CH⁺ , C), is reported. By using energy decomposition analysis, it is demonstrated that a strong M-E bond is accompanied by weak P-E bonds, and vice versa. Although the Al-M bond is, for example, found to be very strong, the weak Al-P bond suggests that the corresponding metal complexes will not be stable towards phosphine dissociation. The interaction energies for the boron(I)-based ligand are lower, but still higher than those for two-carbon-based ligands. For neutral ligands, electrostatic interactions are the dominating contributions to metal-ligand bonding, whereas for the cationic ligand a significant destabilization, with weak orbital and even weaker electrostatic metal-ligand interactions, is observed. Finally, for iron(II) complexes, it is demonstrated that different reactivity patterns are expected for the four donor groups: the experimentally observed reversible E-H reductive elimination of the borylene-based ligand (E=BH) exhibits significantly higher barriers for the protonated carbodiphosphorane (CDP) ligand (E=CH) and would proceed through different intermediates and transition states. For aluminum, such reaction pathways are not feasible (E=AlH). Moreover, it is demonstrated that the metal hydrido complexes with CDP ligands might not be stable towards reduction and isomerization to a protonated CDP ligand and a reduced metal center.

Palladium(ii) pincer complexes of a C,C,C-NHC, diphosphonium bis(ylide) ligand

The preparation, characterization, and reactivity of Pd(ii) complexes of the C,C,C-NHC, diphosphonium bis(ylide) pincer ligand of LX₂-type are here described.

Carbodiphosphorane-based nickel pincer complexes and their (de)protonated analogues: dimerisation, ligand tautomers and proton affinities

The reactivity patterns of carbodiphosphoranes (CDPs) as ligands are much less explored than those of isoelectronic analogues. In the current manuscript, we investigate the reactivity of the carbodiphosphorane-based PCP nickel(ii) pincer complex [({dppm}2C)NiCl]Cl (1) towards acids and bases, calculate proton affinities, analyse the bonding situation and tautomeric forms with the aim to evaluate whether CDPs can potentially act as cooperative ligands in catalysis (dppm = 1,1-bis(diphenylphosphino)methane). Our investigations show that different tautomeric forms are stable for the coordinated and the uncoordinated ligand. The protonated CDP-based complex 2 represents a rare example of a cationic donor group binding to a cationic metal centre. The continuous arm-deprotonation of 1 leads to the formation of remarkably stable dimers with Ni-C-P-C-metallacycles. In comparison to corresponding boron and amine-based ligands, the coordinated CDP-group exhibits the lowest proton affinity according to DFT calculations, indicating that coordinated CDP ligands can potentially serve as proton relay in cooperative catalysis.