Considering quality of life in end-of-life decisions for severely disabled children

Parental Ethical Decision Making and Implications for Advance Care Planning: A Systematic Review and Secondary Analysis of Qualitative Literature from England and Wales, Germany, and the Netherlands

Background: Clinicians and parents are expected to make medical treatment decisions in the child's best interests. To reach their decisions, clinicians typically apply a principled approach outlined by Beauchamp and Childress. How parents make ethical decisions is an under-researched area. A possible model for parental decision making is the Ethics of Care (EoC) theory. Ethical decision making within this framework aims to preserve the caring relationship. What is right or wrong depends on the circumstances at the time. Objective: To identify the parental ethical values and determine whether parental decision making is consistent with EoC, a systematic review and secondary analysis of qualitative research from England and Wales, the Netherlands, and Germany was performed. As part of a larger project investigating conflicts between parents and clinicians about children's medical treatment, the choice of countries was determined by differences in litigation. Methods: Eight databases were searched for articles published between 2010 and 2020 reporting on at least one medical treatment decision made by parents of a child with any life-limiting condition and analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis. Twelve included articles directly addressing advance care planning (ACP) were reanalyzed to investigate whether this specific decision parents are increasingly being asked to make is also consistent with EoC. Results: Forty-three articles were included. Parents use the same 6 ethical values which, consistent with EoC, are mostly in the context of their relationship with the child. All values contributed to the previously identified theme of "being a good parent/person." Analysis of parental decision making in ACP confirmed consistency with EoC. Conclusion: The parental decision-making process is consistent with EoC. That parental decisions aim to maintain the caring relationship and are dependent on the circumstances at the time has implications for parental decision making in ACP and should be reflected in future policies.

Nursing students' view on their future role and skills regarding euthanasia due to unbearable mental suffering: A mixed-method Study

AIM

To explore final-year bachelor nursing students' view on their future role and skills regarding euthanasia due to unbearable mental suffering (UMS-euthanasia) and to discover possible education needs.

BACKGROUND

Since UMS-euthanasia is legal in Belgium, nursing students will be confronted with this issue during their future internship, or professional career. Graduated nurses believe to have an important role in the process of euthanasia where good communication skills and sufficient legal knowledge are essential.

DESIGN

Mixed-methods sequential explanatory design.

METHODS

First, a questionnaire was administered to all final-year bachelor nursing students at eight university colleges in Flanders (October 2020 and March 2021). Second, qualitative information was collected by organising focus groups with these students to gain more insights into the quantitative results (October 2021).

RESULTS

The final-year nursing students from the survey (n = 249) and from the three focus groups (n = 21) see a clear future role for themselves in the decision-making process, as well as in supporting the patient and family before, during and after UMS-euthanasia, but not in assisting in administering UMS-euthanasia. However, they also indicate they lack knowledge and skills in dealing adequately with UMS-euthanasia. Psychiatric internship alumni perceive a diminished role for themselves in the preparatory acts (p < 0.05). Ever involved in euthanasia shows a statistically significant difference in the demand for simulation.

CONCLUSIONS

Nursing students see an important role for nurses in UMS-euthanasia but feel inadequately prepared to take on this role. A combination of theoretical knowledge, clinical experience, open discussions, reflection and simulation is an opportunity to prepare nurses for their future role.

Pediatric Advance Care Planning: A Scoping Review

To assess current practice and provide a basis for a provincial template, clinicians at a Canadian pediatric hospice reviewed the literature surrounding pediatric advance care planning (pACP) documentation, process, and implementation for children/youth. The scoping review protocol was developed in accordance with the Joanna Briggs Institute methodology for scoping reviews, and was prospectively registered on the Open Science Framework. MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, the Web of Science Core Collection, and Google Scholar, as well as sources of unpublished studies and grey literature, were reviewed. Sixty-four articles met the criteria. Fifteen pACP documentation forms/tools were also identified. Overall, the included articles highlighted that pACP should be a structured, collaborative and iterative process between the family and a trusted or relevant healthcare provider, encompassing medical and non-medical issues. Few articles provided insights into specific elements recommended for advance directive forms. Identified strategies for implementation included a structured, step-by-step pACP interventional tool along with ongoing training, mentorship, and defined organizational structures for the clinician. No single specific ACP tool was acknowledged as the gold standard. Use of a pACP tool, along with ongoing provider education and communication skill development, standardized/accessible documentation, and system-wide quality improvement support, were noted as integral components of pACP.

Parent perspectives on the assessment of quality of life of their children with profound intellectual and multiple disabilities in the Netherlands

BACKGROUND

Assessing Quality of Life (QoL) of persons with profound intellectual and multiple disabilities (PIMD) is challenging, yet QoL plays an important role in medical decision-making processes concerning persons with PIMD. The perspectives of parents of children with PIMD on the assessment of their QoL have not been studied.

AIM

To explore the perspectives of parents on the assessment of QoL of their children.

METHODS

We conducted a qualitative study, forming three focus groups with 22 parents of children with PIMD to explore their views on what is necessary to assess QoL of their children and subsequently, who is best suited to assess QoL.

RESULTS

Parents describe a long-term relationship of the assessor with family (child and parents), with trust as an important aspect, as a requirement to assess QoL. Parents consider family members, preferably the parents themselves as the best assessors of QoL, followed by siblings. Professional caregivers, mostly mentioned by name, are considered the next alternative. Most parents thought that physicians do not know the child well enough to assess their QoL.

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, the parents of children with PIMD in our study consider trust and a long-term relationship essential for assessing QoL.

The Impact of Caring for Children With Severe Neurological Impairment on Clinicians

Clinicians face many challenges in caring for children with severe neurological impairment (SNI). This study aimed to understand expert clinician perspectives on the personal impact of caring for children with SNI to highlight the challenges and potential solutions by underscoring the aspects of care that can be sustaining. Twenty-five clinicians participated including physicians (n = 8, 32%), social workers (n = 5, 20%), nurses/nurse practitioners (n = 5, 20%), case managers (n = 3, 12%), developmental therapists (n = 2, 8%), and other psychosocial clinicians (n = 2, 8%). Clinicians represented a variety of specialties including complex care/hospitalists (n = 10, 19%), palliative care (n = 7, 13%), and critical care (n = 6, 12%). Thematic content analysis revealed 3 major themes: (1) worries and challenges; (2) positive impact from being present; and (3) personal growth and meaning-making. Many clinicians described the ways listening, examining biases, learning about family perspectives, and normalizing the need for emotional processing helped them to understand their patients, families, and themselves more deeply.

Relationships and Resources Supporting Children With Serious Illness and Their Parents

OBJECTIVE

Children with complex chronic conditions (CCCs) and their parents benefit from supportive serious illness care when their conditions are severe and impact their quality of life and stress. This includes not only expert medical care but also effective relationships with the clinical team. Existing data suggest that there are opportunities for improvement. This study's aim was to explore important aspects of the relationships and resources that facilitate supportive serious illness care among children with CCCs and their parents.

METHODS

We conducted semistructured interviews with adolescents and young adults (AYAs) with CCCs (aged 13-35 years), and parents of children with CCCs across 2 academic pediatric centers in the United States from December 2018 to April 2019. Transcripts were iteratively coded and analyzed by a team that included a sociologist, pediatric intensivist, and palliative care researcher by using inductive and deductive thematic analysis.

RESULTS

Seven AYAs with CCCs and 9 parents participated (16 total; 1 AYA-parent dyad). Two key categories were identified around relationships with the clinical team: trust and fostering collaboration. Three key categories related to resources are information needs, making sense of life with illness, and supportive community. Many of the key categories and themes identified by participants had both tangible and intangible components and revealed the distinct yet interconnected nature of these aspects of care.

CONCLUSIONS

Awareness and cultivation of relationship and resource support through innovative interventions and attention to those with increased needs in these areas may improve the serious illness care provided to children with CCCs and their parents.

Forming Clinician-Parent Therapeutic Alliance for Children With Severe Neurologic Impairment

OBJECTIVES

Care for children with severe neurologic impairment (SNI) often involves complex medical decision-making where therapeutic alliance between clinicians and families is essential. Yet, existing data suggest that communication and alliance are often lacking. This study aimed to examine aspects important to developing therapeutic alliance between clinicians and parents of children with SNI.

METHODS

A purposive sample of expert clinicians and parents of children with SNI completed brief demographic surveys and 1:1 semistructured interviews between July 2019 and August 2020 at a single tertiary pediatric academic center. Interviews focused on the inpatient experience and transcriptions underwent thematic analysis by a study team of qualitative researchers with expertise in palliative care and communication science.

RESULTS

Twenty-five parents and 25 clinicians participated (total n = 50). Many parents were mothers (n = 17, 68%) of school-aged children with congenital/chromosomal conditions (n = 15, 65%). Clinicians represented 8 professions and 15 specialties. Responses from participants suggested 3 major themes that build and sustain therapeutic alliance including: (1) foundational factors that must exist to establish rapport; (2) structural factors that provide awareness of the parent/child experience; and (3) weathering factors that comprise the protection, security, and additional support during hard or uncertain times. Participants also shared concrete actions that promote these factors in clinical practice.

CONCLUSION

Therapeutic alliance between clinicians and parents of children with SNI consists of at least 3 factors that support communication and medical decision-making. These factors are facilitated by concrete actions and practices, which enhance communication about the care for children with SNI.

The perspectives of professional caregivers on quality of life of persons with profound intellectual and multiple disabilities: a qualitative study

Persons with Profound Intellectual and Multiple Disabilities (PIMD) are supported by professional caregivers for a large part of their lives. However, the perspectives of professional caregivers on good or poor Quality of Live (QoL) of persons with PIMD have hardly been explored. To explore the perspective of professional caregivers on QoL of persons with PIMD, we performed a qualitative study, conducting semi-structured interviews with eleven professional caregivers and thematically analysed them. In the interviews, these professional caregivers described examples of good and poor QoL. Good QoL was mostly described in emotional terms such as happiness, pleasure and enjoying things. Poor QoL was mostly described in physical terms such as pain, sickness and shortage of breath. The capability of persons with PIMD to influence the environment was described as an element of good QoL. Furthermore, these professional caregivers described how they assessed QoL. They 'sensed' QoL, they tested it (trial and error) and discussed QoL of persons with PIMD with colleagues. Participants emphasized the dependency of persons with PIMD on professional caregivers. Furthermore, these professional caregivers described feelings of failure and powerlessness if they could not assess or fulfil the needs of persons with PIMD. We conclude that these professional caregivers use their (tacit) knowledge to understand QoL of persons with PIMD. The relationship between QoL of persons with PIMD and professional caregivers needs more investigation, because of its consequences both for the persons with PIMD and the professional caregivers.

Parents Are the Experts: A Qualitative Study of the Experiences of Parents of Children With Severe Neurological Impairment During Decision-Making

CONTEXT

Parents of children with severe neurologic impairment (SNI) often face high-stakes medical decisions when their child is hospitalized. These decisions involve technology and/or surgery, goals of care and/or advance care planning, or transitions of care.

OBJECTIVES

This study describes the experiences of parents of children with SNI during decision-making.

METHODS

Eligible participants were parents facing a decision for a child with SNI admitted to acute or intensive care units at a single tertiary pediatric center. Parents completed 1:1 semi-structured interviews and brief surveys between August 2019 and February 2020. Demographic information was extracted from the child's electronic health record. A team of palliative and complex care researchers with expertise in qualitative methods used thematic content analysis to formulate results.

RESULTS

25 parents participated. The majority had children with congenital/chromosomal SNI conditions (n = 13, 65%), >5 subspecialists (n = 14, 61%), and chronic technology assistance (n = 25, 100%). 68% (n = 17) were mothers and 100% identified as being their child's primary decision-maker. Responses from parents included 3 major themes: 1) our roles and actions; 2) our stresses and challenges; and 3) our meaning and purpose. Responses highlighted the pervasiveness of parental decision-making efforts and parents' advocacy and vigilance regarding their child's needs. Despite this, parents often felt unheard and undervalued in the hospital.

CONCLUSION

During hospitalizations, when parents of children with SNI often face high-stakes medical decisions, interventions are needed to support parents and ensure they feel heard and valued as they navigate their child's medical needs and system challenges.

From Monochromatic to Technicolor: Parent Perspectives on Challenges and Approaches to Seeing Children with Severe Neurological Impairment Holistically

Background: Children with severe neurological impairment (SNI) commonly receive care in the hospital setting necessitating frequent interactions with clinicians. Yet, parents report that clinicians often have a limited understanding of their child's unique needs and abilities which hinders their care. Objectives: This study aimed to understand the challenges and suggested approaches parents identified to seeing their child holistically. Design: Cross-sectional qualitative study. Setting/Subjects: Parents/legal guardians of children with SNI at a tertiary pediatric academic center in the United States completed 1:1 interviews between August 2019 and February 2020. Measurements: Qualitative researchers with expertise in care for children with SNI, palliative care, and bioethics used thematic content analysis to inductively analyze data for relevant themes. Results: Twenty-five parents/legal guardians of 23 children with SNI participated. Sixty-eight percent were mothers and 24% were fathers; and 68% were white. Thirty-two percent were from other racial and/or ethnic backgrounds. Children predominantly had congenital/chromosomal (n = 15, 65%) and central nervous system static (n = 6, 26%) SNI diagnoses. Four themes emerged regarding both challenges and approaches to understanding children with SNI holistically. These included uniqueness, interdependency, complexity, and universality. Parents felt that by eliciting and incorporating their perspective on these sometimes contrasting but inherently necessary aspects of their child's care, clinicians would understand their children more fully. Conclusion: By viewing the child through the prismed lens of parents, participants described how clinicians could transition from a monochromatic to a technicolor view of their child-including the inherent contrasting needs required for their comprehensive care.

Experiences of mothers caring for a child with an intellectual disability during the COVID-19 pandemic in the Netherlands

BACKGROUND

During the first COVID-19 lockdown period, various restrictions led to diminished access to both educational and professional support systems for children with an intellectual disability and their families. The aim of this study was to explore the experiences and needs of parents caring for a child with an intellectual disability during the first lockdown period in the Netherlands.

METHOD

Five mothers caring for a child with an intellectual disability participated in this qualitative study. The participants were interviewed using a semi-structured interview guide. The interviews lasted between 26 and 48 min. The interview recordings were transcribed verbatim, and the transcripts were analysed thematically.

RESULTS

Three overarching themes emerged: (1) We need to stay healthy, which centres on the mother's urge to protect their child's well-being; (2) We make it work, which provides insight into how the mothers were handling the drastic changes in their family; and (3) My child's and family's place in the world, which focuses on the mothers' experienced position in the world around them.

CONCLUSIONS

The current study provides valuable insights into the experiences and needs of mothers caring for a child with an intellectual disability during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Witnessing Quality of Life of Persons with Profound Intellectual and Multiple Disabilities. A practical-Philosophical Approach

Persons with profound intellectual and multiple disabilities (PIMD) cannot speak about their Quality of Life (QoL), which makes it necessary to involve others. In current approaches, these 'others' are seen as assessors trying to describe QoL as objectively as possible, which involves a reduction of their experiences, through which they develop knowledge on the QoL of the person with PIMD. The objective of this paper is to give caregivers' knowledge on the QoL of a person with PIMD a theoretical basis that values these experiences. We will argue that caregivers should be seen as witnesses, not assessors, and their statements on QoL as testimonies, not assessments. Audiences judge the trustworthiness of these witnesses intersubjectively, which implies a relationship characterized by trust and suspicion. Trust supports the witness to tell in her own words about the QoL of the person with PIMD; it demands receptivity, indicating that both the witness and the audience are willing to reconsider their perspective on QoL. Suspicion is necessary too, which helps the witness to critically approach her own interpretations and supports her to create more trustworthy testimonies. We conclude that the concept of witnessing helps to acknowledge caregivers' experiential knowledge of QoL of a person with PIMD, which may also apply to other persons who cannot speak about their own QoL. We hope that our study will empower caregivers to give testimonies on QoL of a person with PIMD, which is crucial when complex decisions about the life of this person have to be made.

Cerliponase alfa changes the natural history of children with neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis type 2: The first French cohort

INTRODUCTION

Neuronal Ceroid Lipofuscinosis type 2 (CLN2) is a neurodegenerative lysosomal disease which leads to early dementia and death without treatment. The recently available therapy consists of intracerebroventricular enzyme substitution: cerliponase alfa. In this report, we describe the evolution of the first French children treated with cerliponase alfa.

METHOD

CLN2 Clinical Rating Scale Motor-Language (CLN2 ML) assesses the motor and language evolution of CLN2 patients. We retrospectively studied patients' medical records: clinical symptoms, MRI conclusions, gene mutation, side effects of infusions, patient's age and CLN2 ML scores at diagnosis, at the beginning of enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) and at the last evaluation. Seven patients were included.

RESULTS

Average age at diagnosis was 50 months ( ±10) with CLN2 ML score equal to 3.6 [1.5-5]. Average age at the beginning of ERT was 56 months ( ±13) with CLN2 ML score equal to 3.1 [1-5]. At the last available evaluation, average age was 82 months ( ±20) with CLN2 ML score equal to 2.8 [0-5]. Thus, in 26 months, the mean CLN2 ML score only decreased by 0.3 points. However, patients with a CLN2 ML score greater than three at the onset of ERT experienced a stabilisation or improvement of clinical signs, whereas patients with a CLN2 ML score less than three at baseline continue to deteriorate.

CONCLUSION

For patients starting ERT at an early stage of the disease, cerliponase alfa changes the natural history of the disease with a halt in disease progression or even a slight improvement in clinical symptoms.

"I Could Never Prepare for Something Like the Death of My Own Child": Parental Perspectives on Preparedness at End of Life for Children With Complex Chronic Conditions

CONTEXT

Children with complex chronic conditions (CCCs) have high morbidity and mortality. While these children often receive palliative care services, little is known about parental preparedness for their child's end of life (EOL).

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to elucidate aspects important to preparedness at EOL among bereaved parents of children with CCCs.

METHODS

In this cross-sectional study, parents of children who received care at Boston Children's Hospital and died between 2006 and 2015 completed 21 open-response items querying communication, decision-making, and EOL experiences as part of the Survey of Caring for Children with CCCs. Additional demographic data were extracted from the child's medical record. An iterative multistage thematic analysis of responses was utilized to identify key contexts, conditions, and themes pertaining to preparedness.

RESULTS

One hundred ten of 114 parents responded to open-ended items; 63% (n = 69) had children with congenital or central nervous system progressive primary conditions for a median of 7.5 years (IQR 0.8-18.1) before death. Seventy-one percent (n = 78/110) had palliative care involvement and 65% (n = 69/106) completed advance care planning. Parents described preparedness as a complex concept that extended beyond "readiness" for their child's death. Three domains emerged that contributed to parents' lack of preparedness: 1) chronic illness experiences; 2) pretense of preparedness; and 3) circumstances and emotions surrounding their child's death.

CONCLUSIONS

Most bereaved parents of children with CCCs described feeling unprepared for their child's EOL, despite palliative care and advance care planning, suggesting preparedness is a nuanced concept beyond "readiness." More research is needed to identify supportive elements among parents facing their child's EOL.

Shared decision-making with people with intellectual disabilities in the last phase of life: A scoping review

BACKGROUND

Shared decision-making (SDM) is the process in which healthcare professionals and patients jointly discuss and decide which care and treatment policy is to be followed. The importance of SDM is increasingly being recognised across health settings, including palliative care. Little is known about SDM with people with intellectual disabilities (IDs) in the last phase of life. This review aimed to explore to which extent and in which way people with ID in the last phase of life are involved in decision-making about their care and treatment.

METHOD

In this scoping review, we systematically searched in the Embase, Medline and PsycINFO databases for empirical studies on decision-making with people with ID in the last phase of life.

RESULTS

Of a total of 281 identified titles and abstracts, 10 studies fulfilled the inclusion criteria. All focused on medical end-of-life decisions, such as foregoing life-sustaining treatment, do-not-attempt-resuscitation orders or palliative sedation. All studies emphasise the relevance of involving people with ID themselves, or at least their relatives, in making decisions at the end of life. Still, only two papers described processes of decision-making in which persons with ID actively participated. Furthermore, in only one paper, best practices and guidelines for decision-making in palliative care for people with ID were defined.

CONCLUSION

Although the importance of involving people with ID in the decision-making process is emphasised, best practices or guidelines about what this should look like are lacking. We recommend developing aids that specifically support SDM with people with ID in the last phase of life.

A mixed-methods systematic review and meta-analysis of barriers and facilitators to paediatric symptom management at end of life

BACKGROUND

Symptom management for infants, children and young people at end of life is complex and challenging due to the range of conditions and differing care needs of individuals of different ages. A greater understanding of these challenges could inform the development of effective interventions.

AIM

To investigate the barriers and facilitators experienced by patients, carers and healthcare professionals managing symptoms in infants, children and young people at end of life.

DESIGN

A mixed-methods systematic review and meta-analysis was undertaken (PROSPERO ID: CRD42019124797).

DATA SOURCES

The Cochrane Library, PROSPERO, CINAHL, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, Web of Science Core Collection, ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Database, Evidence Search and OpenGrey were electronically searched from the inception of each database for qualitative, quantitative or mixed-methods studies that included data from patients, carers or healthcare professionals referring to barriers or facilitators to paediatric end-of-life symptom management. Studies underwent data extraction, quality appraisal, narrative thematic synthesis and meta-analysis.

RESULTS

A total of 64 studies were included (32 quantitative, 18 qualitative and 14 mixed-methods) of medium-low quality. Themes were generated encompassing barriers/facilitators experienced by carers (treatment efficacy, treatment side effects, healthcare professionals' attitudes, hospice care, home care, families' symptom management strategies) and healthcare professionals (medicine access, treatment efficacy, healthcare professionals' demographics, treatment side effects, specialist support, healthcare professionals' training, health services delivery, home care). Only one study included patients' views.

CONCLUSION

There is a need for effective communication between healthcare professionals and families, more training for healthcare professionals, improved symptom management planning including anticipatory prescribing, and urgent attention paid to the patients' perspective.