Assessing the agromining potential of Mediterranean nickel-hyperaccumulating plant species at field-scale in ultramafic soils under humid-temperate climate

Rhizosphere processes by the nickel hyperaccumulator Odontarrhena chalcidica suggest Ni mobilization

Background and aims

Plant Ni uptake in aboveground biomass exceeding concentrations of 1000 μg g-1 in dry weight is defined as Ni hyperaccumulation. Whether hyperaccumulators are capable of mobilizing larger Ni pools than non-accumulators is still debated and rhizosphere processes are still largely unknown. The aim of this study was to investigate rhizosphere processes and possible Ni mobilization by the Ni hyperaccumulator Odontarrhena chalcidica and to test Ni uptake in relation to a soil Ni gradient.

Methods

The Ni hyperaccumulator O. chalcidica was grown in a pot experiment on six soils showing a pseudo-total Ni and labile (DTPA-extractable) Ni gradient and on an additional soil showing high pseudo-total but low labile Ni. Soil pore water was sampled to monitor changes in soil solution ionome, pH, and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) along the experiment.

Results

Results showed that Ni and Fe concentrations, pH as well as DOC concentrations in pore water were significantly increased by O. chalcidica compared to unplanted soils. A positive correlation between Ni in shoots and pseudo-total concentrations and pH in soil was observed, although plant Ni concentrations did not clearly show the same linear pattern with soil available Ni.

Conclusions

This study shows a clear root-induced Ni and Fe mobilization in the rhizosphere of O. chalcidica and suggests a rhizosphere mechanism based on soil alkalinization and exudation of organic ligands. Furthermore, it was demonstrated that soil pH and pseudo-total Ni are better predictors of Ni plant uptake in O. chalcidica than labile soil Ni.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s11104-023-06161-w.

Soil amendment and rhizobacterial inoculation improved Cu phytostabilization, plant growth and microbial activity in a bench-scale experiment

Mine driven trace elements' pollution entails environmental risks and causes soil infertility. In the last decades, in situ techniques such as phytostabilization have become increasingly important as ways to tackle these negative impacts. The aim of this study was to test the individual and combined effects of different aided phytostabilization techniques using substrate from barren tailings of a Cu mine, characterized by extreme infertility (high acidity and deficiency of organic matter and nutrients). The experiment analyzed the growth of Populus nigra L. planted alone (P) or in co-cropping with Trifolium repens L. (PT), in pots containing mine soil amended with compost (1, 10, compost, soil, w/w) non inoculated (NI) or inoculated with plant growth promoting rhizobacteria (PGP), mycorrhizae (MYC) or a combination of bacterial and fungal inocula (PGPMYC). Non-amended, non-planted and non-inoculated reference ports were also prepared. Plants were harvested after 110 days of plant development and several biometric and phytopathological parameters (stem height, aerial biomass, root biomass, wilting, chlorosis, pest and death) and macro and micronutrient composition were determined. The growth substrate was analyzed for several physicochemical (pH, CEC_e, and exchangeable cations, total C and N, P Olsen and availability of trace elements) and microbiological (community level physiological profiles: activity, richness and diversity) parameters. The use of the amendment, P. nigra plantation, and inoculation with rhizobacteria were the best techniques to reduce toxicity and improve soil fertility, as well as to increase the plant survival and growth. Soil bacterial functional diversity was markedly influenced by the presence of plants and the inoculation with bacteria, which suggests that the presence of plant regulated the configuration of a microbial community in which the inoculated bacteria thrive comparatively better. The results of this study support the use of organic amendments, tolerant plants, and plant growth promoting rhizobacteria to reduce environmental risk and improve fertility of soils impacted by mining.

Nickel Hyperaccumulator Biochar Sorbs Ni(II) from Water and Wastewater to Create an Enhanced Bio-ore

Nickel (Ni) hyperaccumulators make up the largest proportion of hyperaccumulator plant species; however, very few biochar studies with hyperaccumulator feedstock have examined them. This research addresses two major hypotheses: (1) Biochar synthesized from the Ni hyperaccumulator Odontarrhena chalcidica grown on natural, metal-rich soil is an effective Ni sorbent due to the plant's ability to bioaccumulate soluble and exchangeable cations; and (2) such biochar can sorb high concentrations of Ni from complex solutions. We found that O. chalcidica grew on sandy, nutrient-poor soil from a Minnesota mining district but did not hyperaccumulate Ni. Biochar prepared from O. chalcidica biomass at a pyrolysis temperature of 900 °C sorbed up to 154 mg g-1 of Ni from solution, which is competitive with the highest-performing Ni sorbents in recent literature and the highest of any unmodified, plant-based biochar material reported in the literature. Precipitation, cation exchange, and adsorption mechanisms contributed to removal. Ni was effectively removed from acidic solutions with initial pH > 2 within 30 min. O. chalcidica biochar also removed Ni(II) from a simulated Ni electroplating rinsewater solution. Together, these results provide evidence for O. chalcidica biochar as an attractive material for simultaneously treating high-Ni wastewater and forming an enhanced Ni bio-ore.

The parameters determining hyperaccumulator rhizobacteria diversity depend on the study scale

Soils harbor some of the most diverse microbiomes on Earth and are essential for both nutrient cycling and carbon storage. Numerous parameters, intrinsic to plant physiology, life history and the soil itself, can influence the structure of rhizomicrobial communities. While our knowledge of rhizosphere microbial diversity is increasing, opinion is divided as to whether the factors that most impact this diversity are abiotic, climatic or plant selection. Here we focused on the rhizosphere bacterial diversity of nickel hyperaccumulator plants (28 species from Mediterranean or tropical climates). We showed, by leveraging 16S Illumina sequencing of 153 ultramafic rhizosphere soils, that bacterial genetic diversity was highest in Mediterranean habitats where plant diversity was the lowest. Concerning those parameters driving this diversity, we demonstrated that climate drives bacterial diversity, in particular with the annual temperature variation. Focusing on each region, we underlined the substantial role of soil physicochemical parameters. Our results highlight the importance of considering spatial scale when explaining bacterial community diversity.

Inoculation with the pH Lowering Plant Growth Promoting Bacterium Bacillus sp. ZV6 Enhances Ni Phytoextraction by Salix alba from a Ni-Polluted Soil Receiving Effluents from Ni Electroplating Industry

Soil contamination with Ni poses serious ecological risks to the environment. Several members of the Salix genus have the ability to accumulate high concentrations of Ni in their aerial parts, and thus can be used for the remediation of Ni-contaminated soils. Interestingly, the efficacy of Ni phytoextraction by Salix may be improved by the acidification of rhizosphere with rhizosphere acidifying bacterial strains. Therefore, the aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of bacterial strain Bacillus sp. ZV6 in the presence of animal manure (AM) and leaf manure (LM) for enhancing the bioavailability of Ni in the rhizosphere of Salix alba via reducing the pH of rhizosphere and resultantly, enhanced phytoextraction of Ni. Inoculation of Ni-contaminated soil with strain ZV6 significantly increased plant growth as well as Ni uptake by alba. It was found that the addition of AM and LM resulted into a significant increase in plant growth and Ni uptake by alba in Ni-contaminated soil inoculated with ZV6 stain. However, the highest improvements in diethylene triamine penta-acetic acid (DTPA) extractable Ni (10%), Ni removal from soil (54%), Ni bioconcentration factor (26%) and Ni translocation factor (13%) were detected in the soil inoculated with ZV6 along with the addition of LM, compared to control. Similarly, the enhancements in microbial biomass (92%), bacterial count (348%), organic carbon (organic C) (57%) and various enzymatic activities such as urease (56%), dehydrogenase (32%), β-glucosidase (53%), peroxidase (26%) and acid phosphatase (38%) were also significantly higher in the soil inoculated with ZV6 along with the addition of LM. The findings of this study suggest that the inoculation of Ni-contaminated soils with rhizosphere acidifying bacteria can effectively improve Ni phytoextraction and, in parallel, enhance soil health.

Nickel Hyperaccumulator Biochar as a Ni-Adsorbent and Enhanced Bio-ore

Increasing nickel (Ni) demand may spur the need for creative Ni production methods. Agromining (farming for metals) uses plants that can accumulate high concentrations of metal in their biomass, called bio-ore, as a metal extraction strategy. Furthermore, biochar, produced by biomass pyrolysis under low-oxygen conditions, can be used to remove Ni from contaminated wastewaters. In this work we investigate whether biochar synthesized from the Ni-hyperaccumulating plant Odontarrhena chalcidica (synonymous Alyssum murale) can be used as a Ni-adsorbing biochar. We grew O. chalcidica on soils with varying Ni concentration, characterized the plants and resultant biochars synthesized at different pyrolysis temperatures, and analyzed Ni batch adsorption results to determine the adsorption capacity of O. chalcidica biochar. We found that Ni concentration in O. chalcidica increases with increasing soil Ni but reaches an accumulation limit around 23 g Ni kg^–1 dry weight in dried leaf samples. Pyrolysis concentrated Ni in the biochar; higher pyrolysis temperatures led to higher biochar Ni concentrations (max. 87 g Ni kg^–1) and surface areas (max. 103 m²/g). Finally, the O. chalcidica biochar adsorption results were comparable to high-performing Ni adsorbents in the literature. The adsorption process greatly increased the Ni concentration in some biochars, indicating that synthesizing biochar from O. chalcidica biomass and using it as a Ni adsorbent can produce a Ni-enhanced bio-ore with nickel content higher than all nickel-rich veins currently mined.

Phytoremediation of nickel by quinoa: Morphological and physiological response

The amount of soil contaminated with heavy metal increases due to urbanization, industrialization, and anthropogenic activities. Quinoa is considered a useful candidate in the remediation of such soil. In this pot experiment, the phytoextraction capacity of quinoa lines (A1, A2, A7, and A9) against different nickel (Ni) concentrations (0, 50, and 100 mg kg-1) were investigated. Required Ni concentrations were developed in polythene bags filled with sandy loam soil using nickel nitrate salt prior to two months of sowing and kept sealed up to sowing. Results showed that translocation of Ni increased from roots to shoots with an increase in soil Ni concentration in all lines. A2 line accumulated high Ni in leaf compared to the root as depicted by translocation factor 3.09 and 3.21 when grown at soil having 50 and 100 Ni mg kg-1, respectively. While, in the case of root, A7 accumulated high Ni followed by A9, A1, and A2, respectively. There was a 5–7% increased seed yield by 50 mg kg-1 Ni in all except A1 compared to control. However, growth and yield declined with a further increase in Ni level. The maximum reduction in yield was noticed in A9, which was strongly linked with poor physiological performance, e.g., chlorophyll a, b, and phenolic contents. Ni concentrations in the seed of all lines were within the permissible value set (67 ppm) by FAO/WHO. The result of the present study suggests that quinoa is a better accumulator of Ni. This species can provide the scope of decontamination of heavy metal polluted soil. The screened line can be used for future quinoa breeding programs for bioremediation and phytoextraction purpose.

Ornamental plants for the phytoremediation of heavy metals: Present knowledge and future perspectives

Environmental matrices are polluted with the plethora of contaminants, and among these, the concerns related to heavy metals (HMs) are also included. Due to the low cost in a long-term application and environmental friendliness, the use of biological remediation has gained significant attention in recent decades. The use of ornamental plants (OPs) in the field of phytoremediation is scarcely reported, and the impacts of HMs on OPs have also not been investigated in great depth. The OPs mediated HMs remediation can simultaneously remove contaminants and bring improvement in aesthetics of the site. The biomass of OPs produced after such activities can be used and sold as pot plants, cut flowers, essential oils, perfumes, air fresheners production, metal phytomining, and feedstock in silk production. The OPs also present a lower risk of HMs bioaccumulation compared to crop plants. This review focuses on the current knowledge of HMs toxicity to OPs, their applicability advantages, methods to improve the tolerance of OPs with incremented HMs uptake, challenges in the field, and future application perspectives. The case studies realted to practical application of OPs, from China, Iran, India, Oman, Pakistan, and Turkey, were also discussed. This work fetches the inter-disciplinary features and understanding for the sustainable treatment of HMs in a new novel way, to which no previous review has focused.

Fertilization regimes affecting nickel phytomining efficiency on a serpentine soil in the temperate climate zone

Phytomining of nickel (Ni) refers to cropping of selected Ni hyperaccumulator plants on Ni-rich serpentine soils. In this study, the effect of different fertilization regimes on the Ni yield of Odontarrhena chalcidica (syn. Alyssum murale) was evaluated within a field experiment on an Austrian serpentine site. Odontarrhena chalcidica was planted in six treatments: control, fertilized by mineral fertilizer, cow manure, pig manure, compost, and planted at higher plant density. A positive fertilization effect was observed: plants treated with NPK and pig manure produced significantly higher biomass (1.9 t ha^-1 for both treatments). Nickel yields showed a clear trend for enhancement upon fertilization (cow manure: 22.7 kg Ni ha^-1, pig manure: 21.3 kg Ni ha^-1, NPK: 20.6 kg Ni ha^-1), but were not significantly different from the control. As a result of Ni accumulation in plants, DTPA-extractable Ni pools were significantly lower after harvesting (average 37.3 mg kg Ni-DTPA^-1) compared to the time of planting (average 45.6 mg kg Ni-DTPA^-1) in organic fertilization treatments and plots of higher plant density. The application of organic fertilizers contributed also to improved soil quality. We conclude that fertilization can increase the phytomining potential of field-grown Ni hyperaccumulator plants in a soil-friendly manner.

Nickel phytomining from industrial wastes: Growing nickel hyperaccumulator plants on galvanic sludges

Nickel (Ni) is used in numerous industrial processes, with large amounts of Ni-rich industrial wastes produced, which are largely sent to landfill. Nickel recovery from waste materials that would otherwise be disposed is of particular interest. Nickel phytomining represents a new technology in which hyperaccumulator plants are cultivated on Ni-rich substrates for commercial metal recovery. The aim of this study was to investigate the possibility of Ni transfer from industrial waste into plant biomass, to support recovery processes from bio-ores. Different industrial galvanic sludges (containing 85-150 g kg^-1 Ni) were converted into artificial substrates (i.e. technosols) and the Ni hyperaccumulator Odontarrhena chalcidica (formerly Alyssum murale) was cultivated on these Ni-rich matrices. A greenhouse pot experiment was conducted for three months including an ultramafic soil control and testing fertilized (NPK) and unfertilized replicates. The results showed that fertilization was effective in improving plant biomass for all the substrates and that O. chalcidica was capable of viably growing on technosols, producing a comparable biomass to O. chalcidica on the control (ultramafic soil). On all technosols, O. chalcidica achieved Ni shoot concentrations of more than >1000 mg Ni kg ^-1 and maximum Ni uptake was obtained from one of the technosols (26.8 g kg ^-1 Ni, unfertilized; 20.2 g kg ^-1 Ni, fertilized). Nickel accumulation from three of the technosols resulted to be comparable with the control ultramafic soil. This study demonstrated the feasibility of transferring Ni from toxic waste into the biomass of Odontarrhena chalcidica and that phytomining from galvanic sludge-derived technosols can provide similar Ni yields as from natural ultramafic soils.

Phytoremediation of Heavy Metal Pollution: A Bibliometric and Scientometric Analysis from 1989 to 2018

This paper aims to evaluate the knowledge landscape of the phytoremediation of heavy metals (HMs) by constructing a series of scientific maps and exploring the research hotspots and trends of this field. This study presents a review of 6873 documents published about phytoremediation of HMs in the international context from the Web of Science Core Collection (WoSCC) (1989–2018). Two different processing software applications were used, CiteSpace and Bibliometrix. This research field is characterized by high interdisciplinarity and a rapid increase in the subject categories of engineering applications. The basic supporting categories mainly included “Environmental Sciences & Ecology”, “Plant Sciences”, and “Agriculture”. In addition, there has been a trend in recent years to focus on categories such as “Engineering, Multidisciplinary”, “Engineering, Chemical”, and “Green & Sustainable Science & Technology”. “Soil”, “hyperaccumulator”, “enrichment mechanism/process”, and “enhance technology” were found to be the main research hotspots. “Wastewater”, “field crops”, “genetically engineered microbes/plants”, and “agromining” may be the main research trends. Bibliometric and scientometric analysis are useful methods to qualitatively and quantitatively measure research hotspots and trends in phytoremediation of HM, and can be widely used to help new researchers to review the available research in a certain research field.

A nickel phytomining field trial using Odontarrhena chalcidica and Noccaea goesingensis on an Austrian serpentine soil

Phytomining of nickel (Ni) is based on the cropping of Ni hyperaccumulators on Ni-rich serpentine soils. The efficiency of this approach is dependent on shoot nickel concentration and harvestable biomass. In a field experiment conducted on an Austrian serpentine site, the phytomining efficiency of the two plant species Odontarrhena chalcidica (syn. Alyssum murale) and Noccaea goesingensis was evaluated. O. chalcidica was planted in three treatments: control, sulphur application (0.46 g S kg^-1 soil) and intercropping with the legume Lotus corniculatus. For N. goesingensis the treatments control, high-density planting (110 plants m^-2) and intercropping were implemented. Given the experimental set-up, shoot biomass, shoot Ni concentration and thus the total amount of harvested Ni were on average higher for O. chalcidica. The highest Ni yield was achieved with O. chalcidica, reaching 55 kg Ni ha^-1 in the sulphur treatment. N. goesingensis showed the maximum yield in the high-density treatment with 36 kg Ni ha^-1. However, high-density planting of N. goesingensis and sulphur application to O. chalcidica plots did not significantly increase the Ni yield compared to the control. Intercropping with L. corniculatus tended to decrease the shoot biomass of both species. Planting of the hyperaccumulators led to a decrease of DTPA-extractable Ni and to an increase of soil pH, with the exception of sulphur-amended plots. Likewise, rhizosphere soil pH was higher than bulk soil values. Our data suggest that in particular O. chalcidica is suitable for Ni phytomining on the tested site. Measures to further increase the Ni yield and to optimise crop management will be evaluated in follow-up experiments.

Community diversity and potential functions of rhizosphere-associated bacteria of nickel hyperaccumulators found in Albania

Ultramafic (i.e. serpentine) soils are widespread in the Balkans and particularly in Albania. They account for a large part of plant endemism in that region and host several hyperaccumulator species, which are characterized by leaf nickel concentrations frequently above 1%. This rich nickel hyperaccumulating flora could serve as candidate to be used in phytoextraction and agromining. Despite recent interest in metal hyperaccumulating plants and agromining, very few studies have investigated the bacterial diversity and the influence of environmental factors on microbial gene profiles in the rhizosphere of hyperaccumulator plants growing on ultramafic soils. Because rhizospheric bacteria could be crucial to the success of phytoremediation, we studied a total of 48 nickel-hyperaccumulating plants which were sampled from four species that are widespread in Albania: Noccaea ochroleuca, Odontarrhena smolikana, O. rigida and O. chalcidica. All samples were taken from the ultramafic regions of Librazhd and Pogradec in eastern Albania in October 2015. Our study shows that Proteobacteria, Actinobacteria and Acidobacteria dominated the soil bacterial communities. Of these three phyla, only Proteobacteria was relatively abundant. This study underlines the influence of soil Cation Exchange Capacity on the bacterial community's diversity and structure. Based on the predicted metagenomes, the genes belonging to amino acid, lipid and carbohydrate metabolisms were identified as major gene families. Our study sheds some light on our understanding of how bacterial communities are structured within and affect the rhizosphere of hyperaccumulator plants from ultramafic soils in Albania.

Phytoremediation of barium-affected flooded soils using single and intercropping cultivation of aquatic macrophytes

Aquatic macrophytes are potentially useful for phytoremediation on flooded areas. A field study in Brazil was conducted to evaluate Eleocharis acutangula (E), Cyperus papyrus (C) and Typha domingensis (T) in monocropping and intercropping, aiming to phytoremediate barium-polluted flooded soils. The treatments were: monocroppings (E, C and T); double intercroppings (EC, ET and CT); and triple intercropping (ECT). The 180-d field trial was performed in a flooded area with high barium content, with a randomized complete block design and three replicates. Plant stand size, biomass yield, and Ba concentration aboveground/Ba concentration in roots (translocation factor - TF) as well as Ba mass aboveground/Ba mass in roots (mass translocation factor - mTF) were determined. Most of the treatments did not differ on dry biomass, except for EC, which showed the lowest yield. Consistently with its biology, E. acutangula in monocropping showed the largest plant stand. Otherwise, intercroppings with T. domingensis achieved the highest amounts of barium absorbed from the soil and transferred most of the barium content from belowground to aboveground (mTF > 1.0), especially ET, which showed the highest mTF among the intercroppings (2.03). Remarkably, TF values did not reflect such phytoextraction ability for CT and ECT. Thus, mTF was more appropriate than TF to assess phytoextraction capacity. Furthermore, it was demonstrated that intercropping can increase barium uptake from flooded soils. Particularly, the intercropping ET constituted the most cost-effective treatment, with the cyperaceous species providing high plant coverage while T. domingensis facilitated barium removal by translocating it to the aboveground biomass.