Enhanced removal of sulfamethoxazole and tetracycline in bioretention cells amended with activated carbon and zero-valent iron: System performance and microbial community

Biochar and zero-valent iron alleviated sulfamethoxazole and tetracycline co-stress on the long-term system performance of bioretention cells: Insights into microbial community, antibiotic resistance genes and functional genes

Antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), known as emerging contaminants, have raised widespread concern due to their potential environmental and human health risks. In this study, a conventional bioretention cell (C-BRC) and three modified bioretention cells with biochar (BC-BRC), microbial fuel cell coupled/biochar (EBC-BRC) and zero-valent iron/biochar (Fe/BC-BRC) were established and two antibiotics, namely sulfamethoxazole (SMX) and tetracycline (TC), were introduced into the systems in order to thoroughly investigate the co-stress associated with the long-term removal of pollutants, dynamics of microbial community, ARGs and functional genes in wastewater treatment. The results demonstrated that the SMX and TC co-stress significantly inhibited the removal of total nitrogen (TN) (C-BRC: 37.46%; BC-BRC: 41.64%; EBC-BRC: 55.60%) and total phosphorous (TP) (C-BRC: 53.11%; BC-BRC: 55.36%; EBC-BRC: 62.87%) in C-BRC, BC-BRC and EBC-BRC, respectively, while Fe/BC-BRC exhibited profoundly stable and high removal efficiencies (TN: 89.33%; TP: 98.36%). Remarkably, greater than 99% removals of SMX and TC were achieved in three modified BRCs compared with C-BRC (SMX: 30.86 %; TC: 59.29%). The decreasing absolute abundances of denitrifying bacteria and the low denitrification functional genes (nirK: 2.80 × 105-5.97 × 105 copies/g; nirS: 7.22 × 105-1.69 × 106 copies/g) were responsible for the lower TN removals in C-BRC, BC-BRC and EBC-BRC. The amendment of Fe/BC successfully detoxified SMX and TC to functional bacteria. Furthermore, the co-stress of antibiotics stimulated the propagation of ARGs (sulI, sulII, tetA and tetC) in substrates of all BRCs and only Fe/BC-BRC effectively reduced all the ARGs in effluent by an order of magnitude. The findings contribute to developing robust ecological wastewater treatment technologies to simultaneously remove nutrients and multiple antibiotics.

The role of water matrix on antibiotic resistance genes transmission in substrate layer from stormwater bioretention cells

Recently, extensive attention has been paid to antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) transmission. However, little available literature could be found about ARGs transmission in stormwater bioretention cells, especially the role of water matrix on ARGs transmission. Batch experiments were conducted to investigate target ARGs (blaTEM, tetR and aphA) transmission behaviors in substrate layer from stormwater bioretention cells under different water matrices, including nutrient elements (e.g., carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus), water environmental conditions (dissolved oxygen (DO), pH and salinity, etc.) and pollution factors (like heavy metals, antibiotics and disinfectants), showing that ARGs conjugation frequency increased sharply with the enhancement of water matrices (expect DO and pH), while there were obvious increasing tendencies for all ARGs transformation frequencies under only the pollution factor. The correlation between dominant bacteria and ARGs transmission implied that conjugation and transformation of ARGs were mainly determined by Firmicutes, Bacteroidota, Latescibacterota, Chloroflexi and Cyanobacteria at the phylum level, and by Sphingomonas, Ensifer, IMCC26256, Rubellimicrobium, Saccharimonadales, Vicinamibacteraceae, Nocardioides, JG30-KF-CM66 at the genus level. The mentioned dominant bacteria were responsible for intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) and cell membrane permeability (CMP) in the substrate layer, where the amplification of intracellular ROS variation were the largest with 144 and 147 % under the condition of TP and salinity, respectively, and the one of CMP variation were the highest more than 165 % under various pollution factors. Furthermore, both increasing DO and reducing salinity could be potential approaches for the inhibition of ARGs transmission in bioretention cells taking into account the simultaneous removal of conventional pollutants.

Pollutant accumulation and microbial community evolution in rain gardens with different drainage types at field scale

Rain gardens play a key role in urban non-point source pollution control. The drainage type affects the infiltration processes of runoff pollutants. The soil properties and microbial community structures were studied to reveal the stability of the ecosystem in rain gardens with different drainage types under long-term operation. The results showed that the soil water content and total organic carbon in the drained rain gardens were always higher than that of the infiltrated ones. With the increase in running time, the contents of heavy metals in rain gardens showed significant accumulation phenomena, especially the contents of Zn and Pb in drained rain gardens were higher than that in infiltrated ones. The accumulation of pollutants resulted in lower microbial diversity in drained rain gardens than in infiltrated rain gardens, but the microbial community structures were the same in all rain gardens. The effects of drainage type on microbial community evolution were not significant, only the accumulation of heavy metals led to changes in the abundance of dominant microorganisms. There were differences in the soil environment of rain gardens with different drainage types. The long-term operation of rain gardens led to fluctuations in the soil ecosystem, while the internal micro-ecosystems of the drained rain gardens were in unstable states.

Application of electrochemical oxidation for the enhancement of antibiotic resistant bacteria removal in stormwater bioretention cells

Recently, increasing attention has been paid to the removal of antibiotic resistant bacteria (ARB) during electrochemical advanced oxidation processes. However, there is still no available literature about the application of electrochemical oxidation (EO) to enhance ARB removal in stormwater bioretention cells. Batch experiments were conducted to investigate target ARB (E. coli K-12 carrying blaTEM, tetR and aphA) removals in bioretention cells with different current densities and ratios of air to water (A/W). ARB removals for bioretention cells with 17.6 μA/m² of current density and 24:1 of A/W ratio was the largest with 5.28 log reduction, which was obviously higher than the one (3.68 log reduction) in the control (without EO). H₂O₂ production could be responsible for ARB removals in the used bioretention cells, where H₂O₂ levels increased at first and then decreased with the increase of current densities and A/W ratios. The evaluation for the application of EO implied that the highest antibiotic resistance (AR) conjugation frequency (3.8 × 10^-3) at 3.5 μA/m² of current density and 48:1 of A/W ratios was 124.5 % of the one in the control, while the largest AR transformation frequencies at 17.6 μA/m² of current density and 48:1 of A/W ratios was 366.9 % (tetR) and 216.2 % (aphA) of the corresponding in the control, and there were still stable for both dominant microflora and metabolic activities in bioretention cells with electricity and aeration, suggesting that EO could be promising for the enhancement of ARB removals in bioretention cells.

Dissecting the roles of conductive materials in attenuating antibiotic resistance genes: Evolution of physiological features and bacterial community

Supplying conductive materials (CMs) into anaerobic bioreactors is considered as a promising technology for antibiotic wastewater treatment. However, whether and how CMs influence antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) spread remains poorly known. Here, we investigated the effects of three CMs, i.e., magnetite, activated carbon (AC), and zero valent iron (ZVI), on ARGs dissemination during treating sulfamethoxazole wastewater, by dissecting the shifts of physiological features and microbial community. With the addition of magnetite, AC, and ZVI, the SMX removal was improved from 49.05 to 71.56-92.27 %, while the absolute abundance of ARGs reducing by 26.48 %, 61.95 %, 48.45 %, respectively. The reduced mobile genetic elements and antibiotic resistant bacteria suggested the inhibition of horizontal and vertical transfer of ARGs. The physiological features, including oxidative stress response, quorum sensing, and secretion system may regulate horizontal transfer of ARGs. The addition of all CMs relieved oxidative stress compared with no CMs, but ZVI may cause additional free radicals that needs to be concerned. Further, ZVI and AC also interfered with cell communication and secretion system. This research deepens the insights about the underlying mechanisms of CMs in regulating ARGs, and is expected to propose practical ways for mitigating ARGs proliferation.

Accumulation of high-molecular-weight polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon impacted the performance and microbial ecology of bioretention systems

Bioretention has been considered as an effective management practice for urban stormwater in the removal of pollutants including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). However, the accumulation of high-molecular-weight (HMW) PAHs in bioretention systems and their potential impact on the pollutants removal performance and microbial ecology are still not fully understood. In this study, comparisons of treatment effectiveness, enzyme activity and microbial community in bioretention systems with different types of media amendments were carried out at different spiking levels of pyrene (PYR). The results showed that the removal efficiencies of chemical oxygen demand (COD) and total nitrogen in the bioretention systems were negatively impacted by the PYR levels. The relative activities of soil dehydrogenase and urease were increasingly inhibited by the elevated PYR level, indicating the declining microbial activity regarding organic matter decomposition. The spiking of PYR negatively affected microbial diversity, and distinct time- and influent-dependent changes in microbial communities were observed. The relative abundance of PAH-degrading microorganisms increased in PYR-spiked systems, while the abundance of nitrifiers decreased. The addition of media amendments was beneficial for the enrichment of microorganisms that are more resistant to PYR-related stress, therefore elevating the COD concentration removal rate by ∼50%. This study gives new insight into the multifaceted impacts of HMW PAH accumulation on microbial fingerprinting and enzyme activities, which may provide guidance on better stormwater management practices via bioretention in terms of improved system longevity and performance.

Antibiotic resistance genes removals in stormwater bioretention cells with three kinds of environmental conditions

Recently, increasing attention has been paid to antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in stormwater runoff. However, there is still no available literature about ARGs removals through stormwater bioretention cells. Batch experiments were conducted to investigate target ARGs (bla_TEM, tetR and aphA) removals under three environmental conditions, including substrate (weight ratios of sand to soil), hydraulic loading rate (HLR) and submerged area depth. The target ARGs removals were the largest (more than 5 log in the bottom outlets) in bioretention cells with 8:2 ratio of sand to soil, HLR 0.044 cm³/cm²/min and 150 mm of submerged area depth. The proportion for both iARGs and eARGs had little effect on target ARGs removals (expect extracellular bla_TEM), although distributions of target ARGs were different in substrate layers. Adsorption behavior tests indicated that both kinetics and isotherms of target ARGs adsorption by biofilms were more suitable to explain their best removals for bioretention cells with 8:2 ratio of sand to soil than that by substrate. At phylum and genus levels, there were respectively 6 dominant microflora related significantly to target ARGs levels, and their relationships changed obviously under different environmental conditions, suggesting that regulating the dominant microflora (like Verrucomicrobia and Actinobacteria) could be feasible to change ARGs removals.

Assessment on the cumulative effect of pollutants and the evolution of micro-ecosystems in bioretention systems with different media

Bioretention system is one of the most used green stormwater infrastructures (GSI), and its media is a key factor in reducing runoff water volume and purifying water quality. Many studies have investigated media improvement to enhance the pollutant removal capacity. However, the long-term cumulative effect and microbial effect of pollutants in the modified-media bioretention system is less known. This study investigated the cumulative effect of pollutants and their influence on microbial characteristics in conventional and modified media bioretention system. The addition of modifiers increased the background content of pollutants in the media, and the accumulation of pollutants in planting soil (PS) and bioretention soil mixing + water treatment residuals (BSM+WTR) was relatively higher after the simulated rainfall experiment. The accumulation of pollutants led to a decrease in dehydrogenase activity, and an increase in urease and invertase activities. Ten dominant bacterial species at the phylum level were found in all bioretention systems. The relative abundances of the bacteria with good viability under low nutritional conditions decreased, while the species which could live in the pollutant-rich environment increased. The accumulation of pollutants in the bioretention system led to the extinction of some functional microorganisms. The better the effects of modified media on pollutant removal showed, the more obvious effect on the media micro-ecosystem was. To ensure the long-term efficient and stable operation of the modified-media bioretention system, we recommend balancing the pollutant removal efficiency and cumulative effect in modified-media bioretention systems.