Comparative role of microplastics and microalgae as vectors for chlorpyrifos bioacumulation and related physiological and immune effects in mussels

Plastic pollution and marine mussels: Unravelling disparities in research efforts, biological effects and influences of global warming

The ever-growing contamination of the environment by plastics is a major scientific and societal concern. Specifically, the study of microplastics (1 μm to 5 mm), nanoplastics (< 1 μm), and their leachates is a critical research area as they have the potential to cause detrimental effects, especially when they impact key ecological species. Marine mussels, as ecosystem engineers and filter feeders, are particularly vulnerable to this type of pollution. In this study, we reviewed the 106 articles that focus on the impacts of plastic pollution on marine mussels. First, we examined the research efforts in terms of plastic characteristics (size, polymer, shape, and leachates) and exposure conditions (concentration, duration, species, life stages, and internal factors), their disparities, and their environmental relevance. Then, we provided an overview of the effects of plastics on mussels at each organisational levels, from the smaller scales (molecular, cellular, tissue and organ impacts) to the organism level (functional, physiological, and behavioural impacts) as well as larger-scale implications (associated community impacts). We finally discussed the limited research available on multi-stressor studies involving plastics, particularly in relation to temperature stress. We identified temperature as an underestimated factor that could shape the impacts of plastics, and proposed a roadmap for future research to address their combined effects. This review also highlights the impact of plastic pollution on mussels at multiple levels and emphasises the strong disparities in research effort and the need for more holistic research, notably through the consideration of multiple stressors, with a specific focus on temperature which is likely to become an increasingly relevant forcing factor in an era of global warming. By identifying critical gaps in current knowledge, we advocate for more coordinated interdisciplinary and international collaborations and raise awareness of the need for environmental coherence in the choice and implementation of experimental protocols.

Comparison of biofilm-covered microplastics and sand particles as vectors of PCB-153 to Paracentrotus lividus

The microplastics (MPs) vector effect of environmental contaminants (such as polychlorinated biphenyls-PCBs) to organism tissues is currently one of the major concerns regarding MPs pollution in the marine environment. The relative importance of MPs as vectors for the bioaccumulation of contaminants to marine organisms compared to other naturally occurring particles has been poorly investigated and never by using biofilm-covered particles. The present study compares the role of biofilm-covered microplastics and sand particles as vectors for the transfer and bioaccumulation of ¹⁴C-PCB-153 into various body compartments of the sea urchin Paracentrotus lividus. After 14 days of exposure, similar transfer efficiency of ¹⁴C-PCB-153 from both types of biofilm-covered particles was obtained (t-test, p-val = 0.43). The particle type was not found to affect the concentration (two-way ANOVA, p-valper dry weight = 0.92, p-valper lipid weight = 0.80) and distribution (two-way ANOVA, p-val = 0.85) of ¹⁴C-PCB-153 among the different body compartments of sea urchins. These findings suggest that biofilm-covered MPs located on the seafloor may act as similar vectors for the bioaccumulation of PCB-153 in sea urchin tissues compared to other biofouled natural particles such as sand. Overall, the outcomes of this present work align with the growing consensus among various research groups that MPs-mediated bioaccumulation of co-contaminants would be negligible compared to natural bioaccumulation pathways in relation to their abundance in the ocean.

Comprehensive assessment of multiple biomarker mechanisms in the brackish water clam Corbicula japonica exposed to polystyrene microplastics using structural equation modeling

Using structural equation modeling (SEM), we investigated multiple biomarker mechanisms in terms of biochemical and individual marker responses in the brackish water clam Corbicula japonica following acute exposure to polystyrene microplastic (PS-MP). This study is the first to comprehensively explore multiple biomarker responses in bivalves using SEM. The model revealed that PS-MP accumulation was an independent biomarker, exhibiting significant direct effects on superoxide dismutase (SOD) and catalase (CAT) among the biochemical markers. Although CAT generally interacts closely with SOD, no significant relationship was identified between them, indicating that CAT may have independently responded to PS-MP stress. Among individual markers, significant indirect effects were observed on clearance rate (CR), reflecting feeding activity and valve open rate, indicating excretion activity via SOD and CAT. Finally, the carbon-based scope for growth was significantly influenced by CR. SEM is efficient and useful for identifying significant direct and indirect pathway relationships and for uncovering uncommon relationships in unified multiple biomarker mechanisms in aquatic studies.

Polyethylene microplastic modulates the toxicity of pentachlorophenol to the microalgae Isochrysis galbana, clone t-ISO

Pentachlorophenol (PCP) and polyethylene microplastic (PE-MP) have been designated as emerging and persistent pollutants, respectively. The combined effects of those pollutants are still unknown, especially to organisms like phytoplankton that may adsorb to their surface. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to investigate for the first time the effects of PE-MP alone and in combination with PCP on the microalgae Isochrysis galbana, clone t-ISO following 72 h of exposure. Photosynthetic pigments amounts, carotenoid, protein, carbohydrate and fatty acids have been assessed. Acute toxicity test showed that the 72 h median inhibition concentration (72 h-EC50) was 148.2, 0.66 and 087 mg L-1 for PE-MP, PCP and their mixture. The utmost effects in growth inhibition rates were noted with 0.5 and 1.25 mg L-1 PCP (23% and 85%, respectively), and 100 and 300 mg L-1 PE-MP (49% and 64%, respectively). Moreover, it was found that those concentrations had a major impact on the photosynthetic pigments, protein, carbohydrate, and fatty acids amounts in algal cells. Furthermore, levels of H2O2 and Malondialdehyde (MDA), as well as the activities of catalase (CAT), superoxide dismutase (SOD), and ascorbate peroxidase (APX), indicated the induction of an oxidative stress in algal cells. It appears that adding PE-MP at a no-effect concentration (25 mg L-1) reduces the toxicity caused by PCP due to its adsorption to polyethylene microplastics.

Comparative assessment of microplastics and microalgae as vectors of mercury and chlorpyrifos in the copepod Acartia tonsa

Microplastics (MPs) raise concerns not only as pollutants themselves, but also due to their ability to act as vectors of pollutants adsorbed from seawater, transferring them to marine organisms. However, the relevance of MPs as carriers of pollutants compared to microalgae needs further exploration. This study compared the role of MPs (2-10 μm non-oxidized and 10-15 μm oxidized high-density polyethylene) and natural organic particles (Rhodomonas lens microalgae, MA) as carriers of mercury (Hg, 2.3 μg Hg/L) and chlorpyrifos (CPF, 1.0 μg CPF/L) to adult Acartia tonsa copepods, after 24-48 h exposure. Dose-response experiments were first performed with adult female copepods exposed to oxidized MPs (0.25-4.0 mg/L), waterborne Hg (0.01-10.0 μg/L) and Ox MPs + Hg (0.25-4.0 mg oxidized MPs/L + 0.50-8.0 μg Hg/L) for 48 h, to complement previous studies that focused on the pesticide CPF. Effects were evaluated with four replicates for physiological and reproductive responses (6 females/replicate), biochemical techniques (40 individuals/replicate) and Hg/CPF bioaccumulation measurements (1000 individuals/replicate). Copepods accumulated Hg/CPF similarly from dissolved pollutants (6204 ± 2265 ng Hg/g and 1251 ± 646 ng CPF/g) and loaded MPs (3125 ± 1389 ng Hg/g and 1156 ± 266 ng CPF/g), but significantly less from loaded MA (21 ± 8 ng Hg/g and 173 ± 80 ng CPF/g). After 24-48 h, copepods exposed to MPs + Hg/CPF showed generally greater biological effects than those exposed to dissolved Hg/CPF or to MA + Hg/CPF, although differences were not statistically significant. MA + CPF had significantly lower AChE inhibition (1073.4 nmol min-1 mg-1) and MA + Hg lower GRx induction (48.8 nmol min-1 mg-1) compared to MPs + Hg/CPF and dissolved Hg/CPF (182.8-236.4 nmol min-1 mg-1 of AChE and 74.1-101.7 nmol min-1 mg-1 of GRx). Principal component analysis suggested different modes of action for Hg and CPF.

The particle effect: comparative toxicity of chlorpyrifos in combination with microplastics and phytoplankton particles in mussel

Lately, the role of microplastics (MP) as vectors for dissolved contaminants and as vehicle for their transfer to aquatic organisms has received attention. Similarly to MP, other inorganic and organic particles may act as passive samplers. However, limited comparative knowledge exists at this respect. In the present study we have comparatively investigated the risk for mussel of MP and the pesticide chlorpyrifos (CPF) alone and in combination with MP and phytoplankton particles of microalgae (MP-CPF and MA-CPF, respectively). We selected MP and microalgae of similar size to expose mussel to the same volume of particles (≈1.5 mm3L-1 ≈ equivalent to 1.5 mg MP L-1) and the same concentration of contaminant (CPF, 7.6 μg L-1). MP were virgin HDPE microparticles (≤10 μm) while the microalgae species was Isochrisis galbana (4-8 μm). Mussels were exposed for 21 days to MP, CPF, MP-CPF and MA-CPF. Then, a suite of neurotoxicity, oxidative stress and oxidative damage biomarkers were measured in samples collected at day 7 and 21. Additionally, these biochemical markers were assessed in an integrated manner with others measured at physiological, immune and cell component level in the same organisms, previously published. Overall, MP did not elicit significant alterations on the majority of parameters measured. In contrast, mussels exposed to CPF, MA-CPF and MP-CPF showed evidence of neurotoxicity and oxidant imbalance at day 7, added to a detrimental physiological condition and immune imbalance at day 21. At the latter time MP-CPF mussels showed greater alterations than CPF or MA-CPF mussels. This suggested a synergistic toxicity of MP combined with CPF greater than that produced by the contaminants alone (MP or CPF) or by MA combined with CPF.

The chemical and microbiological safety of emerging alternative protein sources and derived analogues: A review

Climate change and changing consumer demand are the main factors driving the protein transition. This shift toward more sustainable protein sources as alternatives to animal proteins is also reflected in the rapid upscaling of meat and dairy food analogues. Such changes could challenge food safety, as new food sources could result in new and unexpected food safety risks for consumers. This review analyzed the current knowledge on chemical and microbiological contamination of emerging alternative protein sources of plant origin, including soil-based (faba bean, mung bean, lentils, black gram, cowpea, quinoa, hemp, and leaf proteins) and aquatic-based (microalgae and duckweeds) proteins. Moreover, findings on commercial analogues from known alternative protein sources were included. Overall, the main focus of the investigations is on the European context. The review aimed to enable foresight approaches to food safety concerning the protein transition. The results indicated the occurrence of multiple chemical and microbiological hazards either in the raw materials that are the protein sources and eventually in the analogues. Moreover, current European legislation on maximum limits does not address most of the "contaminant-food" pairs identified, and no legislative framework has been developed for analogues. Results of this study provide stakeholders with a more comprehensive understanding of the chemical and microbiological safety of alternative protein sources and derived analogues to enable a holistic and safe approach to the protein transition.

Developmental and biochemical markers of the impact of pollutant mixtures under the effect of Global Climate Change

This study investigates the combined impact of microplastics (MP) and Chlorpyriphos (CPF) on sea urchin larvae (Paracentrotus lividus) under the backdrop of ocean warming and acidification. While the individual toxic effects of these pollutants have been previously reported, their combined effects remain poorly understood. Two experiments were conducted using different concentrations of CPF (EC10 and EC50) based on previous studies from our group. MP were adsorbed in CPF to simulate realistic environmental conditions. Additionally, water acidification and warming protocols were implemented to mimic future ocean conditions. Sea urchin embryo toxicity tests were conducted to assess larval development under various treatment combinations of CPF, MP, ocean acidification (OA), and temperature (OW). Morphometric measurements and biochemical analyses were performed to evaluate the effects comprehensively. Results indicate that combined stressors lead to significant morphological alterations, such as increased larval width and reduced stomach volume. Furthermore, biochemical biomarkers like acetylcholinesterase (AChE), glutathione S-transferase (GST), and glutathione reductase (GRx) activities were affected, indicating oxidative stress and impaired detoxification capacity. Interestingly, while temperature increase was expected to enhance larval growth, it instead induced thermal stress, resulting in lower growth rates. This underscores the importance of considering multiple stressors in ecological assessments. Biochemical biomarkers provided early indications of stress responses, complementing traditional growth measurements. The study highlights the necessity of holistic approaches when assessing environmental impacts on marine ecosystems. Understanding interactions between pollutants and environmental stressors is crucial for effective conservation strategies. Future research should delve deeper into the impacts at lower biological levels and explore adaptive mechanisms in marine organisms facing multiple stressors. By doing so, we can better anticipate and mitigate the adverse effects of anthropogenic pollutants on marine biodiversity and ecosystem health.

Laboratory Studies about Microplastic Aging and Its Effects on the Adsorption of Chlorpyrifos

The constant change in microplastics (MP) due to exposure to environmental conditions leads to physical and chemical changes that enhance their ability to transport other pollutants, increasing the concern about their widespread presence in the environment. This work aimed to simulate the aging process of six MP (polyamide 6, unplasticized polyvinyl chloride, low-density polyethylene, polystyrene, polyethylene-co-vinyl acetate, polypropylene) in freshwater and seawater ecosystems at laboratory scale and evaluate its effects through optical microscope observation, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy-Attenuated Total Reflectance (FTIR-ATR), Raman spectroscopy, and thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA). Through a combined experimental study of aged MP, the degradation by UV interaction was evidenced by the appearance of new infrared bands in the FTIR spectra assigned to ketones and hydroxyl groups. While Raman analysis and microscope images reveal the appearance of pores, wrinkles, and roughness in the MP surfaces. Variations in the temperature of the maximum weight loss of the MP were observed in the TGA analysis. The adsorption of chlorpyrifos (CPF), a common pesticide widely used in agriculture, by the pristine and aged MP was also studied. The highest affinity for CPF was observed for pristine LDPE and the lowest for PP. The batch adsorption studies revealed an increase in adsorption capacity as a consequence of the aging process for both MP. These results proved that the weathering effects caused changes in the behavior of MP, namely in the interaction with other pollutants.

Elucidating the consequences of the co-exposure of microplastics jointly to other pollutants in bivalves: A review

The marine environment has numerous impacts related to anthropogenic activities including pollution. Abundances of microplastics (MPs) and other pollutants are continuously increasing in the marine environment, resulting in a complex mixture of contaminants affecting biota. In order to understand the consequences, a review of studies analyzing combined effects of MPs and other types of pollutants in bivalves has been conducted as species in this group have been considered as sentinel and bioindicators. Regarding studies reviewed, histological analyses give evidence that MPs can be located in the haemolymph, gills and gonads, as well as in digestive glands in the intestinal lumen, epithelium and tubules, demonstrating that the entire body of bivalves is affected by MPs. Moreover, DNA strand breaks represent the most relevant form of damage caused by the enhanced production of reactive oxygen species in response to MPs exposure. The role of MPs as vectors of pollutants and the ability of polymers to adsorb different compounds have also been considered in this review highlighting a high variability of results. In this sense, toxic impacts associated to MPs exposure were found to significantly increase with the co-presence of antibiotics or petroleum hydrocarbons amongst other pollutants. In addition, bioaccumulation processes of pollutants (PAHs, metals and others) have been affected by the co-presence with MPs. Histological, genetic and physiological alterations are the most reported damages, and the degree of harm seems to be correlated with the concentration and size of MP and with the type of pollutant.

Influence of ultraviolet-aging and adsorbed pollutants on toxicological effects of polyvinyl chloride microplastics to zebrafish

Microplastics (MPs) undergo various aging processes and interact with diverse pollutants in the environment. In the present study, we investigated the influence of ultraviolet (UV) aging on the adsorption of organic pollutants by polyvinyl chloride microplastics (mPVC) and explored toxicity variations among pristine, aged, and pollutant-loaded mPVCs to zebrafish. Irradiation of UV for 30 d significantly changed the physiochemical properties of mPVC, leading to more oxygen-containing groups and free radicals (¹O₂, ·O₂^-, and ·OH) on mPVC surfaces. The aging process reduced the adsorption of mPVC against a hydrophobic compound chlorpyrifos (CPF) but enhanced the adsorption against a moderately hydrophilic compound erythromycin (ERY). Ingestion of CPF- and ERY-loaded mPVCs resulted in bioaccumulation of the two compounds in zebrafish, suggesting a carrier effect of mPVCs. In toxicity tests, the aged mPVC caused severer gut damages, stronger oxidative stresses, and greater interference with the gut microbiota in zebrafish than the pristine mPVC. The CPF and ERY-loaded mPVCs produced lower oxidative stresses in zebrafish than mPVCs alone, due to fewer radicals on mPVC surfaces after the adsorption of organic contaminants. Notably, the CPF and ERY-loaded mPVCs presented greater effects on fish swimming behaviors and gut microbial compositions, which was associated with the released CPF and ERY from mPVCs within the zebrafish. Overall, the present study demonstrated significant influences of UV-aging and the adsorbed pollutants on the toxicological effects of MPs and highlighted the necessity to perform toxicity studies of MPs using more environmentally relevant MPs.

Short- and Long-Term Effects of Chlorpyrifos on Thyroid Hormone Axis and Brain Development in Xenopus laevis

INTRODUCTION

The extensive use of the insecticide chlorpyrifos (CPF) throughout the world has brought increased scrutiny on its environmental and health impact. CPF is a cholinergic neurotoxicant; however, exposure to low noncholinergic doses is associated with numerous neurodevelopmental effects in animal models. In this study, we aimed to assess CPF for its potential to disrupt thyroid hormone signalling and investigate the short- and long-term effects on neurodevelopment by using Xenopus laevis.

METHODS

The thyroid hormone (TH) disrupting potential of CPF was assessed using TH-sensitive transgenic Tg(thibz:eGFP) tadpoles. The consequences of early embryonic exposure were examined by exposing fertilized eggs for 72 h to environmentally relevant CPF concentrations (10-10 M and 10-8 M). Three endpoints were evaluated: (1) gene expression in whole embryonic brains immediately after exposure, (2) mobility and brain morphology 1 week after exposure, and (3) brain morphology and axon diameters at the end of metamorphosis (2 months after the exposure).

RESULTS

CPF disrupted TH signalling in Tg(thibz:eGFP) tadpoles. The expression of genes klf9, cntn4, oatp1c1, and tubb2b was downregulated in response to CPF. Tadpoles exposed to CPF exhibited increased mobility and altered brain morphology compared to control tadpoles. Early embryonic exposure of CPF affected myelinated axon diameter, with exposed animals exhibiting shifted frequency distributions of myelinated axons diameters towards smaller diameters in the hindbrain of froglets.

DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION

This study provides more evidence of the endocrine and neurodevelopment disrupting activity of CPF. Further experimental and epidemiological studies are warranted to determine the long-term consequences of early CPF exposure on brain development.