Oysters for legacy and emerging per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) monitoring in estuarine and coastal waters: Phase distribution and bioconcentration profile

Unveiling the emerging concern of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) and their potential impacts on estuarine ecosystems

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) have become ubiquitous chemicals that pose potentially serious threats to both human health and the integrity of the ecosystem. This review compiles current knowledge on PFAS contamination in estuaries, focusing on sources, abundance, distribution, fate, and toxic mechanisms. It also addresses the health risks associated with these compounds and identifies research gaps, offering recommendations for future studies. Estuaries are essential for maintaining biodiversity and serve as protective natural buffers against pollution flowing from land to sea. However, PFAS, known for their persistence and bioaccumulation potential, are detected in estuarine waters, sediments, and biota worldwide, with varying concentrations based on geographic locations and environmental matrices. Sources of PFAS in estuaries include routine items like nonstick kitchenware, industrial emissions, landfill sites, civilian and military airfields, and runoff from firefighting activities. The fate of PFAS in estuarine ecosystems is influenced by hydrology, biogeochemical interactions, and proximity to pollution sources.

A review of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) removal in constructed wetlands: Mechanisms, enhancing strategies and environmental risks

PER: Polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs), typical persistent organic pollutants detected in various water environments, have attracted widespread attention due to their undesirable effects on ecology and human health. Constructed wetlands (CWs) have emerged as a promising, cost-effective, and nature-based solution for removing persistent organic pollutants. This review summarizes the removal performance of PFASs in CWs, underlying PFASs removal mechanisms, and influencing factors are also discussed comprehensively. Furthermore, the environmental risks of PFASs-enriched plants and substrates in CWs are analyzed. The results show that removal efficiencies of total PFASs in various CWs ranged from 21.3% to 98%. Plant uptake, substrate absorption and biotransformation are critical pathways in CWs for removing PFASs, which can be influenced by the physiochemical properties of PFASs, operation parameters, environmental factors, and other pollutants. Increasing dissolved oxygen supply and replacing traditional substrates in CWs, and combining CWs with other technologies could significantly improve PFASs removal. Further, CWs pose relatively lower ecological and environmental risks in removing PFASs, which indicates CWs could be an alternative solution for controlling PFASs in aquatic environments.

Driving factor, source identification, and health risk of PFAS contamination in groundwater based on the self-organizing map

The complex interactions between groundwater chemical environments and PFAS present challenges for data analysis and factor assessment of the spatial distribution and source attribution of PFAS in groundwater. This study employed spatial response analysis combining self-organizing maps (SOM), K-means clustering, Spearman correlation, positive matrix factorization (PMF) and risk quotient (RQ), to uncover the spatial characteristics, driving factors, sources, and human health risks of groundwater PFAS in the Pearl River Basin. The results indicated that the characteristics of PFAS in groundwater were classified into 16 neurons, which were further divided into 6 clusters (I-VI). This division was due to the contribution of industrial pollution (33.2 %) and domestic pollution (31.5 %) to the composition of PFAS in groundwater. In addition, the hydrochemical indicators such as pH, dissolved organic carbon (DOC), chloride (Cl-), and calcium ions (Ca2+) might also affect the distribution pattern of PFAS. The potential human health risk in the area was minimal, with cluster Ⅱ presenting the highest risk (RQ value 0.25) which is closely related to PFOA emissions from fluoropolymer industry. This study provides a theoretical basis and data support for applying of SOM to the visualization and control of PFAS contamination in groundwater.

Contamination levels of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in recent North American precipitation events. A review

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), known as forever chemicals, have received international attention over the last two decades for their health risks and environmental persistence. One pathway of human exposure to PFAS is by rainwater. This review aims to analyze current studies of legacy and emerging PFAS contamination levels in rainwater in North America. In April 2024, the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) finalized new regulations for PFAS levels in drinking water. This review compares PFAS in rainwater to the latest US EPA regulation for the first time. Our analysis determined that five recent studies' average total PFAS (ΣPFAS) ranged from 2.28 to 92.42 ng/L and had a hazard index (HI) of 0.05-0.30. The average ΣPFAS and HI for all five studies are below the maximum contamination levels (MCLs) recommended by the EPA. However, rainwater samples collected near local point sources often exceeded the MCLs. To better understand the extent of PFAS contamination in the United States, more studies need to be conducted and analyzed throughout North America, testing for both legacy and emerging PFAS and locating local point sources.

Effect of physicochemical parameters on the occurrence of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in aquatic environment

Perfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) and their distribution in aquatic environments have been studied extensively, but more information is needed to link these occurrences to their physicochemical characteristics. Understanding how these parameters influence PFAS can help predict their fate, mobility, and occurrences in water. This study reviewed the influence of physicochemical parameters on the occurrences of PFAS in aquatic environment using the relevant keywords to retrieve articles from databases spanning mostly between 2017 and 2024. The result suggests that high pH, turbidity, and dissolved oxygen, give high concentration of PFAS, while high electrical conductivity, temperature and salinity give low PFAS concentration in the water. Therefore, monitoring and safeguarding the aquatic bodies for human and environmental safety is imperative. Future studies should include the effects of the physicochemical properties on PFAS occurrences in the natural environment and focus on an organism's distinctive characteristics to comprehend the bioaccumulation and biomagnification of PFAS in them and environmental matrices.

Effect of Co-exposure to Additional Substances on the Bioconcentration of Per(poly)fluoroalkyl Substances: A Meta-Analysis Based on Hydroponic Experimental Evidence

A consensus has yet to emerge regarding the bioconcentration responses of per(poly)fluoroalkyl substances under co-exposure with other additional substances in aqueous environments. This study employed a meta-analysis to systematically investigate the aforementioned issues on the basis of 1,085 published datasets of indoor hydroponic simulation experiments. A hierarchical meta-analysis model with an embedded variance covariance matrix was constructed to eliminate the non-independence and shared controls of the data. Overall, the co-exposure resulted in a notable reduction in PFAS bioaccumulation (cumulative effect size, CES =  - 0.4287, p < 0.05) and bioconcentration factor (R2 = 0.9507, k < 1, b < 0) in hydroponics. In particular, the inhibition of PFAS bioconcentration induced by dissolved organic matter (percentage form of the effect size, ESP =  - 48.98%) was more pronounced than that induced by metal ions (ESP =  - 35.54%), particulate matter (ESP =  - 24.70%) and persistent organic pollutants (ESP =  - 18.66%). A lower AS concentration and a lower concentration ratio of ASs to PFASs significantly promote PFAS bioaccumulation (p < 0.05). The bioaccumulation of PFASs with long chains or high fluoride contents tended to be exacerbated in the presence of ASs. Furthermore, the effect on PFAS bioaccumulation was also significantly dependent on the duration of co-exposure (p < 0.05). The findings of this study provide novel insights into the fate and bioconcentration of PFAS in aquatic environments under co-exposure conditions.

Insights into PFAS contaminants before and after sewage discharges into a marine protected harbour

Per and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) and their degradation products are a concern to human and ecosystem health. Wastewater treatment plants are not efficient at removing PFAS compounds and are thought to be a major source of these compounds to marine environments. The sewerage infrastructure in the UK, has over 20,000 combined stormwater overflows (CSOs). These CSOs are relief values whereby untreated wastewater can discharge under permit from the Environment Agency with exceptional rain/snowfall conditions. CSOs discharged 3.6 million monitored hours of untreated wastewater into English rivers and coasts in 2023. Concerns have been raised about the proximity of these CSO discharges to highly protected marine habitats. This study is the first to determine that PFAS concentrations are elevated in a highly protected marine bay (Langstone Harbour, England) following recent sewage releases compared to an extended period without discharge. Analysis was carried out into a suite of 54 PFAS compounds of which only one (PFHpA) was detectable above LOD prior to discharges but 8 afterwards. These included banned PFOS (Linear and Branched 8.6 ng/L ∓ 0.90) and PFOA (2.9 ng/L ∓ 0.29) which were above annual average EQS for inland and 'other' surface waters. Most of the PFAS compounds detected doubled in concentration above LODs. These two-fold increases we discuss are likely conservative estimates based on the use of LODs and tidal conditions. Additional Oysters (Crassostrea gigas) and Seaweed (Fucus vesiculosus) were taken revealing high concentrations of the shorter chain PFBA (6.99μg/kg ∓ 2.42 ww) in seaweed samples. These seaweeds were calculated to have conservative bioaccumulation factors (BAF) > 6000 for PFBA indicating these algae might be an important reservoir of some PFAS contamination. We discuss these results in the context of the largescale discharges of untreated wastewater nationally and globally, and call upon a need for a better understanding of the transfer of PFAS contaminants into marine food chains.

The bioaccumulation and ecotoxicity of co-exposure of per(poly)fluoroalkyl substances and polystyrene microplastics to Eichhornia crassipes

Gen X and F-53B have been popularized as alternatives to PFOA and PFOS, respectively. These per(poly)fluoroalkyl substances pervasively coexist with microplastics (MPs) in aquatic environments. However, there are knowledge gaps regarding their potential eco-environmental risks. In this study, a typical free-floating macrophyte, Eichhornia crassipes (E. crassipes), was selected for hydroponic simulation of a single exposure to PFOA, PFOS, Gen X, and F-53B, and co-exposure with polystyrene (PS) microspheres. F-53B exhibited the highest bioaccumulation followed by Gen X, PFOA, and PFOS. In the presence of PS MPs, the bioavailabilities of the four PFASs shifted and the whole plant bioconcentration factors improved. All four PFASs induced severe lipid peroxidation, which was exacerbated by PS MPs. The highest integrated biomarker response (IBR) was observed for E. crassipes (IBR of shoot: 30.01, IBR of root: 22.79, and IBR of whole plant: 34.96) co-exposed to PS MPs and F-53B. The effect addition index (EAI) model revealed that PS MPs showed antagonistic toxicity with PFOA and PFOS (EAI < 0) and synergistic toxicity with Gen X and F-53B (EAI > 0). These results are helpful to compare the eco-environmental impacts of legacy and alternative PFASs for renewal process of PFAS consumption and provide toxicological, botanical, and ecoengineering insights under co-contamination with MPs.

Stereoselective Bioconcentration and Neurotoxicity of Perfluoroethylcyclohexane Sulfonate in Marine Medaka

Perfluoroethylcyclohexane sulfonate (PFECHS) is an emerging per- and polyfluoroalkyl substance used to replace perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS), mainly in aircraft hydraulic fluids. However, previous research indicates the potential neurotoxicity of this replacement chemical. In this study, marine medaka (Oryzias melastigma) was exposed to environmentally relevant concentrations of PFECHS (concentrations: 0, 0.08, 0.26, and 0.91 μg/L) from the embryonic stage for 90 days. After exposure, the brain and eyes of the medaka were collected to investigate the bioconcentration potential of PFECHS stereoisomers and their effects on the nervous systems. The determined bioconcentration factors (BCFs) of PFECHS ranged from 324 ± 97 to 435 ± 89 L/kg and from 454 ± 60 to 576 ± 86 L/kg in the brain and eyes of medaka, respectively. The BCFs of trans-PFECHS were higher than those of cis-PFECHS. PFECHS exposure significantly altered γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) levels in the medaka brain and disrupted the GABAergic system, as revealed by proteomics, implying that PFECHS can disturb neural signal transduction like PFOS. PFECHS exposure resulted in significant alterations in multiple proteins associated with eye function in medaka. Abnormal locomotion was observed in PFECHS-exposed medaka larvae, which was rescued by adding exogenous GABA, suggesting the involvement of disrupted GABA signaling pathways in PFECHS neurotoxicity.

Environmental occurrence, bioaccumulation and human risks of emerging fluoroalkylether substances: Insight into security of alternatives

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) are widely used due to their unique structure and excellent performance, while also posing threats on ecosystem, especially long-chain perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS) and perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA). As the control of conventional PFASs, fluoroalkylether substances (ether-PFASs) as alternatives are constantly emerging. Subsequently, the three representative ether-PFASs, chlorinated polyfluoroalkyl ether sulfonic acid (F-53B), hexafluoropropylene oxide-dimer acid (HFPO-DA), and 4,8-Dioxa-3H-perfluorononanoicacid (ADONA) are discovered and have received more attention in the environment and ecosystem. But their security is now also being challenged. This review systematically assesses their security from six dimensions including environmental occurrence in water, soil and atmosphere, as well as bioaccumulation and risk in plants, animals and humans. High substitution level is observed for F-53B, whether in environment or living things. Like PFOS or even more extreme, F-53B exhibits high biomagnification ability, transmission efficiency from maternal to infant, and various biological toxicity effects. HFPO-DA still has a relatively low substitution level for PFOA, but its use has emerged in Europe. Although it is less detected in human bodies and has a higher metabolic rate than PFOA, the strong migration ability of HFPO-DA in plants may pose dietary safety concerns for humans. Research on ADONA is limited, and currently, it is detected in Germany frequently while remaining at trace levels globally. Evidently, F-53B has shown increasing risk both in occurrence and toxicity compared to PFOS, and HFPO-DA is relatively safe based on available data. There are still knowledge gaps on security of alternatives that need to be addressed.

Occurrence and transport of novel and legacy poly- and perfluoroalkyl substances in coastal rivers along the Laizhou Bay, northern China

The pollution profiles of 25 legacy and emerging poly- and perfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) in the estuaries along the Laizhou Bay, northern China were investigated to better understand the new structure of PFASs under international regulations and to estimate the mass loadings of PFASs in coastal rivers. About 39.87 kg/d of PFASs were discharged into the Laizhou Bay by the Xiaoqing, Mi and Zhimai Rivers. Total PFAS concentrations in the Xiaoqing River decreased notably in recent years, but were still greater than the levels in 2011. Contribution of replacement substances exhibited an increasing trend in recent years. However, the long-chain chemicals were still the larger contributors of PFASs. Perfluoromethoxypropionic acid (PFMPA) was first detected with high concentrations ranging from 165.3 to 586.3 ng/L in the Xiaoqing River. The results of this study provided baseline data for ecological risk assessment, environmental management and corresponding development of pollution treatment technology.

Legacy per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) especially alternative PFASs in shellfish from Shandong Province, China: Distribution, sources, and health risk

We investigated the distribution of 8 per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) in 321 shellfish samples collected from four coastal cities along the Yellow Sea and Bohai Sea of Shandong Province, China. The concentrations of total PFASs (∑PFASs) were in the range of 0.061-178.259 ng/g wet weight (ww). Two legacy long-chain compounds were dominant. Three emerging compounds and two short-chain alternatives were also observed with higher concentration and detection frequency than in previous studies, whereas 4, 8-dioxa-3H-perfluorononanoate acid (ADONA) was not detected. There were differences in concentrations and composition profiles of PFASs among different species, as well as among different sampling cities. According to scores of principal component analysis, metal plating plants, textile treatments, and fluoropolymer products were considered as the main sources of PFAS contamination in shellfish. Furthermore, a potential health risk of perfluorooctanoic acid should be highly considered for local residents that frequently consume crabs and molluscs.

Legacy and Emerging Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances Surveillance in Bufo gargarizans from Inlet Watersheds of Chaohu Lake, China: Tissue Distribution and Bioaccumulation Potential

Amphibians are sensitive biomonitors of environmental pollutants but reports regarding per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), a class of synthetic organofluorine substances, are limited. In this study, samples of water and Chinese toads (Bufo gargarizans) were collected in Chaohu Lake, China. Tissue-specific bioaccumulation characteristics of 39 PFAS, including 19 perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs), 8 emerging PFAS, and 12 PFAA precursors, were investigated, and the levels of some biochemical indicators were determined. The highest PFAS concentrations were found in the liver [215.97 ng/g dry weight (dw)] of Chinese toads, followed by gonads (135.42 ng/g dw) and intestine (114.08 ng/g dw). A similar tissue distribution profile was found between legacy and emerging PFAS in the toads, and the occurrence of two emerging PFAS, 2,3,3,3-tetrafluoro-2-propanoate (HFPO-DA) and 6:2 hydrogen-substituted polyfluorooctane ether sulfonate (6:2 H-PFESA) in the amphibians were for the first time reported. Field-based bioaccumulation factors of HFPO-DA were higher than perfluorooctanoic acid, indicating the higher bioaccumulation potential of this emerging PFAS than the legacy C8 compound. Males had significantly higher gonad PFAS levels than females while estradiol levels in gonads increased with increasing concentrations of certain PFAS (e.g., 6:2 H-PFESA), implying that PFAS may trigger estrogenic effects in the toads, especially for male toads.

Source, transport, and fate of perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs) in turbid bay environments: Significant roles of suspended sediment and water column stratification

The coastal area was the major region receiving pollution from land-based sources into the sea. Perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs) in famous bays had aroused wide concern, but the importance of underdeveloped or small bays with notable levels of PFAAs were often neglected. Moreover, the roles of suspended sediment (SPS) and water column stratification on PFAA behaviors were unclear. In this study, PFAAs distribution in multiphase-multilayer in four underdeveloped bays (two urban bays and two island bays) were investigated. The urban bays not only had higher PFAA contamination but also posed a greater threat of short-chain PFAAs in water-SPS-sediment system than the island bays. The major source of PFAAs in water and SPS was domestic sewage in urban bays and was rainfall-runoff in island bays. Water column stratification with higher PFAA partition in water-SPS system in the surface layer than in the bottom layer was only found in the urban bays due to the higher human activity intensity. These provided new perspectives for managing emerging contaminants and establishing water quality criteria in the turbid coastal environment. The key role of SPS as a carrier offered possibilities to accurately differentiate the effects of dissolved and particulate PFAAs on bioavailability.

Identification of key features relating to the coexistence mechanisms of trace elements and per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) in marine mammals

Organic and inorganic substances coexist in the livers of marine mammals and may correlate with one another; however, their coexistence mechanisms and relevant key features remain largely unknown. In this study, temporal variations (2011-2021) in the concentrations of nine trace elements and 19 per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) in the livers of Indo-Pacific humpback dolphins (Sousa chinensis) and finless porpoises (Neophocaena phocaenoides) were investigated. Interannual Cd in dolphins increased significantly whereas Pb concentrations decreased over the past decade (p < 0.05). Interannual levels of seven and four PFASs in dolphins and porpoises decreased significantly with time (p < 0.05). By further extending the timescale to 1993-2021, the sensitivity of trace elements to annual change further increased, whereas the sensitivity of PFASs remained relatively stable. Cu levels, similar to the majority of PFASs, were negatively correlated with the body length of the studied cetaceans, which led to positive correlations of Cu with six long-chain perfluoroalkyl carboxylic acids, perfluorodecane sulfonic acid, and perfluoroethylcyclohexane sulfonic acid. The concentrations of trace elements in the cetacean liver were closely correlated with cetacean sex, species, and body length, whereas PFAS concentration was responsive to time-related features such as stranded season and year. By further employing a machine learning method, we demonstrated that body length and a time-related factor (year) played a crucial role in predicting the concentrations of certain trace elements and PFASs, respectively, particularly Cu and perfluoroheptanoic acid.

Legacy and Emerging Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances in a Subtropical Marine Food Web: Suspect Screening, Isomer Profile, and Identification of Analytical Interference

The ban/elimination of legacy per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) has led to a dramatic increase in the production and use of various emerging PFASs over the past decade. However, trophodynamics of many emerging PFASs in aquatic food webs remain poorly understood. In this study, samples of seawaters and marine organisms including 15 fish species, 21 crustacean species, and two cetacean species were collected from the northern South China Sea (SCS) to investigate the trophic biomagnification potential of legacy and emerging PFASs. Bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide was found in seawater via suspect screening (concentration up to 1.50 ng/L) but not in the biota, indicating its negligible bioaccumulation potential. A chlorinated perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS) analytical interfering compound was identified with a predicted formula of C14H23O5SCl6- (most abundant at m/z = 514.9373). Significant trophic magnification was observed for 22 PFASs, and the trophic magnification factors of cis- and trans-perfluoroethylcyclohexane sulfonate isomers (1.92 and 2.25, respectively) were reported for the first time. Perfluorohexanoic acid was trophic-magnified, possibly attributed to the PFAS precursor degradation. The hazard index of PFOS was close to 1, implying a potential human health risk via dietary exposure to PFASs in seafood on the premise of continuous PFAS discharge to the SCS.

Legacy and novel perfluoroalkyl substances in major economic species of invertebrates in South China Sea: Health implication from consumption

Continuously release of perfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) would pose non-negligible impacts on environment, organisms, and human health. In present study, 18 PFASs in 7 typical economic invertebrates and their habitats were investigated from the South China Sea. The higher concentrations of PFASs in the nearshore water (6.61-15.54 ng/L) and sediment (0.82-8.84 ng/g) obviously due to frequent human activities. Long-chain PFASs have tendency to accumulate in sediment, however, short-chain PFASs dominated in biota. The acute reference dose (%ARfD) and hazard ratios (HR) of major PFASs in biota were all <100 %, and also below 1, respectively, which means that consumption of PFASs from seafood does not pose risk and threat to human health. However, it should be taken into account that the HR of PFHxA in Mimachlamys nobilis reached 0.82. Potential adverse effects toward human health induced by short-chain PFASs (such as <6 C) via invertebrate seafood consumption should be concerned.