Rylene Diimide Electron Acceptors for Organic Solar Cells

Emergence of Low-Cost and High-Performance Nonfused Ring Electron Acceptors

ConspectusOrganic solar cells (OSCs) have garnered significant attention in academic and industrial circles due to their advantages such as lightweight, excellent bending performance, and the ability to be fabricated into semitransparent devices. Since the proposal of the bulk heterojunction concept by Heeger et al. in 1995, conjugated polymer/fullerene pairs have gradually emerged as the optimal choice for active layer materials in OSCs. Fullerene derivatives were preferred as electron acceptors in OSCs because of their high electron mobility. However, due to limitations such as insufficient light absorption, limited derivative potential, and poor energy level tunability, the power conversion efficiency (PCE) of OSCs based on fullerene derivatives has encountered a bottleneck of approximately 12%, despite the continuous updates in polymer donor materials over nearly two decades of development, leading to a gradual decline in their importance. By contrast, nonfullerene electron acceptors (NFAs) have gradually gained dominance in this field since first appearing in 2015, thanks to their advantages of tunable absorption spectrum, adjustable energy levels, and modifiable chemical structure. Among nonfullerene acceptors, fused-ring electron acceptors (FREAs) such as ITIC and Y6 have achieved significant progress, boosting the PCE of OSCs to 20%. This milestone achievement indicates the potential of their commercial applications. However, the synthesis process of FREA is complex and often constrained by low-yield ring-closure reactions, resulting in high costs.The molecular backbone of nonfused ring electron acceptors (NFREAs) is composed of single bonds, which enables the adoption of modular synthesis mainly via Stille (based on organotin reactant) and/or Suzuki (based on organoboron reactant) coupling or C-H activation (without prefunctionalization) and avoids low-yield ring-closing reactions, thus making them a potential alternative to fused-ring acceptors. To achieve a planar molecular backbone and minimize energy loss due to conformational rotation, our team innovatively used intramolecular noncovalent interactions as a replacement for traditional covalent bonds. Furthermore, to address the issues of poor solubility and excessive aggregation during film formation for NFREAs, we strategically introduced sterically hindered side groups, such as 2,6-bis(alkyloxy)phenyl and diphenylamino, into the molecular design, effectively mitigating these problems. These innovative design concepts have significantly advanced the development of high-performance NFREAs and have garnered increasing attention from the research community. The PCEs of OSCs based on NFREAs have significantly improved from less than 10% to close to 20% since their initial discovery. By optimizing the device fabrication process, we have achieved a PCE of over 19%, which is comparable to that of FREAs. This article will delve into the evolution and latest research progress of NFREAs, aiming to provide valuable insights and guidance for the design of cost-effective and high-performance NFREA materials.

Design of Chlorinated Indaceno[1,2-b:5,6-b']dithiophene Acceptors toward Efficient Organic Photovoltaics

Chlorinated modifications have been extensively employed to modulate the optoelectronic properties of π-conjugated materials. Herein, the Cl substitution in designing nonfullerene acceptors (NFAs) with various bandgaps is studied. Four narrow-bandgap electron acceptors (GS-40, GS-41, GS-42, and GS-43) were synthesized by tuning the electrostatic potential distributions of the molecular conjugated backbones. The optical absorption onset of these NFAs ranges from 900 to 1030 nm. Compared to the nonchlorinated analogue, the introduction of Cl atoms on the core of indaceno[1,2-b:5,6-b'] dithiophene (IDT) and π spacer results in an upward shift of the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital levels and induces a blue shift in the absorption spectra of the NFAs. This alteration facilitates achieving appropriate energy-level alignment and favorable bulk heterojunction morphology when blended with the widely used donor PBDB-TF. The PBDB-TF:GS-43-based solar cells show an optimal power conversion efficiency of 13.3%. This work suggests the potential of employing chlorine-modified IDT and thiophene units as fundamental building blocks for developing high-performance photoactive materials.

Nucleophilic Aromatic Substitution of Pentafluorophenyl-Substituted Quinoline with a Functional Perylene: A Route to the Modification of Semiconducting Polymers

A systematic study of the influence of the chemical substitution pattern of semiconducting polymers carrying side chain perylene diimide (PDI) groups is presented. Semiconducting polymers based on perflurophenyl quinoline (5FQ) were modified via a readily accessible nucleophilic substitution reaction. The perfluorophenyl group was studied as an electron-withdrawing reactive functionality on semiconducting polymers that can undergo fast nucleophilic aromatic substitution. A PDI molecule, functionalized with one phenol group on the bay area, was used for the substitution of the fluorine atom at the para position in 6-vinylphenyl-(2-perfluorophenyl)-4-phenyl quinoline. The final product was polymerized under free radical polymerization providing polymers of 5FQ incorporated with PDI side groups. Alternatively, the post-polymerization modification of the fluorine atoms at the para position of the 5FQ homopolymer with the PhOH-di-EH-PDI was also successfully tested. In this case, the PDI units were partially introduced to the perflurophenyl quinoline moieties of the homopolymer. The para-fluoro aromatic nucleophilic substitution reaction was confirmed and estimated via ¹H and ¹⁹F NMR spectroscopies. The two different polymer architectures, namely, fully or partially modified with PDI units, were studied in terms of their optical and electrochemical properties, while their morphology was evaluated using TEM analysis, revealing polymers of tailor-made optoelectronic and morphological properties. This work provides a novel molecule-designing method for semiconducting materials of controlled properties.

Electron Transport in Organic Photovoltaic Acceptor Materials: Improving the Carrier Mobilities by Intramolecular and Intermolecular Modulations

High carrier mobility is beneficial to increase the active-layer thickness while maintaining a high fill factor, which is crucial to further improve the light harvesting and organic photovoltaic efficiency. The aim of this Perspective is to elucidate the electron transport mechanisms in prototypical non-fullerene (NF) acceptors through our recent theoretical studies. The electron transport in A-D-A small-molecule acceptors (SMAs), e.g., ITIC and Y6, is mainly determined by end-group π-π stacking. Relative to ITIC, the angular backbone along with more flexible side chains leads to Y6 having a closer stacking and enhanced intermolecular electronic connectivity. For polymerized rylene diimide acceptors, to achieve high electron mobilities, they need to simultaneously increase intramolecular and intermolecular connectivity. Finally, finely tuning the π-bridge modes to enhance intramolecular superexchange coupling is essential to develop novel polymerized A-D-A SMAs.

Chlorinated Narrow Bandgap Polymer Suppresses Non-Radiative Recombination Energy Loss Enabling Perylene Diimides-Based Organic Solar Cells Exceeding 10% Efficiency

The scarcity of narrow bandgap donor polymers matched with perylene diimides (PDI)-based nonfullerene acceptors (NFAs) hinders improvement of the power conversion efficiency (PCE) value of organic solar cells (OSCs). Here, it is reported that a narrow bandgap donor polymer PDX, the chlorinated derivative of the famous polymer donor PTB7-Th, blended with PDI-based NFA boosts the PCE value exceeding 10%. The electroluminescent quantum efficiency of PDX-based OSCs is two orders of magnitude higher than that of PTB7-Th-based OSCs;therefore, the nonradiative energy loss is 0.103 eV lower. This is the highest PCE value for OSCs with the lowest energy loss using the blend of PTB7-Th derivatives and PDI-based NFAs as the active layer. Besides, PDX-based devices showed larger phase separation, faster charge mobilities, higher exciton dissociation probability, suppressed charge recombination, elevated charge transfer state, and decreased energetic disorder compared with the PTB7-Th-based OSCs. All these factors contribute to the simultaneously improved short circuit current density, open circuit voltage, and fill factor, thus significantly improving PCE. These results prove that chlorinated conjugated side thienyl groups can efficiently suppress the non-radiative energy loss and highlight the importance of fine-modifying or developing novel narrow bandgap polymers to further elevate the PCE value of PDI-based OSCs.

Squarephaneic Tetraanhydride: A Conjugated Square-Shaped Cyclophane for the Synthesis of Porous Organic Materials

Aromatic carboxylic anhydrides are ubiquitous building blocks in organic materials chemistry and have received considerable attention in the synthesis of organic semiconductors, pigments, and battery electrode materials. Here we extend the family of aromatic carboxylic anhydrides with a unique new member, a conjugated cyclophane with four anhydride groups. The cyclophane is obtained in a three-step synthesis and can be functionalised efficiently, as shown by the conversion into tetraimides and an octacarboxylate. Crystal structures reveal the high degree of porosity achievable with the new building block. Excellent electrochemical properties and reversible reduction to the tetraanions are shown for the imides; NMR and EPR measurements confirm the global aromaticity of the dianions and evidence the global Baird aromaticity of the tetraanions. Considering the short synthesis and unique properties, we expect widespread use of the new building block in the development of organic materials.

Squarephaneic Tetraanhydride: A Conjugated Square-Shaped Cyclophane for the Synthesis of Porous Organic Materials

Aromatic carboxylic anhydrides are ubiquitous building blocks in organic materials chemistry and have received considerable attention in the synthesis of organic semiconductors, pigments, and battery electrode materials. Here we extend the family of aromatic carboxylic anhydrides with a unique new member, a conjugated cyclophane with four anhydride groups. The cyclophane is obtained in a three-step synthesis and can be functionalised efficiently, as shown by the conversion into tetraimides and an octacarboxylate. Crystal structures reveal the high degree of porosity achievable with the new building block. Excellent electrochemical properties and reversible reduction to the tetraanions are shown for the imides; NMR and EPR measurements confirm the global aromaticity of the dianions and evidence the global Baird aromaticity of the tetraanions. Considering the short synthesis and unique properties, we expect widespread use of the new building block in the development of organic materials.

The principles, design and applications of fused-ring electron acceptors

Fused-ring electron acceptors (FREAs) have a donor-acceptor-donor structure comprising an electron-donating fused-ring core, electron-accepting end groups, π-bridges and side chains. FREAs possess beneficial features, such as feasibility to tailor their structures, high property tunability, strong visible and near-infrared light absorption and excellent n-type semiconducting characteristics. FREAs have initiated a revolution to the field of organic solar cells in recent years. FREA-based organic solar cells have achieved unprecedented efficiencies, over 20%, which breaks the theoretical efficiency limit of traditional fullerene acceptors (~13%), and boast potential operational lifetimes approaching 10 years. Based on the original studies of FREAs, a variety of new structures, mechanisms and applications have flourished. In this Review, we introduce the fundamental principles of FREAs, including their structures and inherent electronic and physical properties. Next, we discuss the way in which the properties of FREAs can be modulated through variations to the electronic structure or molecular packing. We then present the current applications and consider the future areas that may benefit from developments in FREAs. Finally, we conclude with the position of FREA chemistry, reflecting on the challenges and opportunities that may arise in the future of this burgeoning field.

Tuning of energy levels, transport properties and device performance of naphthalenediimide derivatives by introduction of Michael addition reaction

NDI derivatives have been synthesized via Michael addition reaction with uplifted HOMO–LUMO energy levels and strong CT interaction in MA products generally not achieved by simple imide-N substitutions.

Domino Dehydrative π-Extension: A Facile Path to Extended Perylenes and Terrylenes

Herein, we report a new method for synthesis of extended perylenes and terrylenes. The technique is based on the cascade dehydrative π-extensions (DPEX) of aryl aldehydes, in which stepwise annulations activate previously "dormant" substituents. Two- and fourfold cyclizations of 3-aryl-biphenyl-2,2'-dicarbaldehydes offer a rapid path to unsymmetrical perylenes and elusive terrylene derivatives, respectively. DPEX of 3,3''-(phenanthrene-1,8-diyl)bis (([1,1'-biphenyl]-2,2'-dicarbaldehyde)) leads to the biradical structure, which proceeds in situ into oxidative electrocyclization at room temperature. The described domino process complements and expands DPEX approach to a large family of fused acenes and related PAHs.

Recent Progress in the Design of Fused-Ring Non-Fullerene Acceptors-Relations between Molecular Structure and Optical, Electronic, and Photovoltaic Properties

Organic solar cells are on the dawn of the next era. The change of focus toward non-fullerene acceptors has introduced an enormous amount of organic n-type materials and has drastically increased the power conversion efficiencies of organic photovoltaics, now exceeding 18%, a value that was believed to be unreachable some years ago. In this Review, we summarize the recent progress in the design of ladder-type fused-ring non-fullerene acceptors in the years 2018-2020. We thereby concentrate on single layer heterojunction solar cells and omit tandem architectures as well as ternary solar cells. By analyzing more than 700 structures, we highlight the basic design principles and their influence on the optical and electrical structure of the acceptor molecules and review their photovoltaic performance obtained so far. This Review should give an extensive overview of the plenitude of acceptor motifs but will also help to understand which structures and strategies are beneficial for designing materials for highly efficient non-fullerene organic solar cells.

Designs and understanding of small molecule-based non-fullerene acceptors for realizing commercially viable organic photovoltaics

Organic photovoltaics (OPVs) have emerged as a promising next-generation technology with great potential for portable, wearable, and transparent photovoltaic applications. Over the past few decades, remarkable advances have been made in non-fullerene acceptor (NFA)-based OPVs, with their power conversion efficiency exceeding 18%, which is close to the requirements for commercial realization. Novel molecular NFA designs have emerged and evolved in the progress of understanding the physical features of NFA-based OPVs in relation to their high performance, while there is room for further improvement. In this review, the molecular design of representative NFAs is described, and their blend characteristics are assessed via statistical comparisons. Meanwhile, the current understanding of photocurrent generation is reviewed along with the significant physical features observed in high-performance NFA-based OPVs, while the challenging issues and the strategic perspectives for the commercialization of OPV technology are also discussed.

En Route Towards the Control of Luminescent, Optically-Active 3D Architectures

π-Extended systems are key components for the development of future organic electronic technologies. While conceiving molecules with improved properties is fundamental for the evolution of materials science, keeping control over the 3D arrangement of molecules represents an ever-expanding challenge. Herein, a synthetic protocol to replace carbon atoms of π-systems by dissymmetric phosphorus atoms is reported; in particular, it allowed for conceiving new fused phosphapyrene derivatives with improved properties. The presence of dissymmetric phosphorus atoms precluded the formation of excimers. X-ray diffraction revealed that, meanwhile, strong intermolecular interactions are taking place in the solid state. The phosphapyrenes photoluminesce in the visible region with high quantum yields; importantly, they are CD-active. In addition, the unique non-planar features of phosphorus atoms allowed for the control of the 3D arrangement of molecules, rendering lemniscate-like structures. Based on our discoveries, we envisage the possibility to construct higher-order, chiral 3D architectures from larger phosphorus-containing π-systems.

Fused-Ring Electron Acceptors for Photovoltaics and Beyond

ConspectusEmerging solar cells that convert clean and renewable solar energy to electricity, such as organic solar cells (OSCs) and perovskite solar cells (PSCs), have attracted increasing attention owing to some merits such as facile fabrication, low cost, flexibility, and short energy payback time. The power conversion efficiencies (PCEs) of OSCs and PSCs have exceeded 18% and 25%, respectively.Fullerene derivatives have high electron affinity and mobility with an isotropic transport feature. Fullerene-based OSCs yielded superior PCEs to other acceptors and have dominated electron acceptor materials from 1995 to 2015. However, some drawbacks of fullerenes, such as weak visible absorption, limited tunability of electronic properties, laborious purification, and morphological instability, restrict further development of OSCs toward higher PCEs and practical applications. The theoretical PCE of fullerene-based OSCs is limited to ∼13% due to the relatively large energy losses. Many efforts have been dedicated to developing new acceptor systems beyond fullerenes, and some successful systems such as rylene diimides have achieved PCEs up to ca. 11%.In 2015, our group pioneered a new class of electron acceptors, fused-ring electron acceptor (FREA), as represented by the star molecule ITIC. The chemical features of FREAs include: (1) a modular structure, consisting of an electron-donating core, electron-withdrawing end groups, π-bridges, and side chains, which benefits molecular tailoring; (2) facile synthesis, purification, and scalability. The physical features of FREAs include: (1) a broad modulation range of absorption and energy levels; (2) strong absorption, especially in the 700-1000 nm region; (3) high electron mobility. The device features of FREAs include: (1) low voltage loss; (2) high efficiency; (3) good stability. The FREAs boosted PCEs of the OSCs up to 18% and initiated the transformation from the fullerene to nonfullerene era of this field. FREAs can also be used in PSCs as interfacial layers, electron transport layers, or active layers, improving both efficiency and stability of the devices. Beyond photovoltaic applications, FREAs can also be used in photodetectors, field-effect transistors, two-photon absorption, photothermal therapy, solar water splitting, etc.In this Account, we review the development of the FREAs and their applications in OSCs, PSCs, and other related fields. Molecular design, device engineering, photophysics, and applications of FREAs are discussed in detail. Future research directions toward performance optimization and commercialization of FREAs are also proposed.

Synthesis of diverse heterocyclic frameworks using cyclopentadienones via the Diels–Alder strategy

In this review article, we briefly summarize the versatility of Diels–Alder reactions of cyclopentadienones and concise routes to diverse hetero-atom bearing PAHs using cyclones as building blocks.

Comparison of Fused-Ring Electron Acceptors with One- and Multidimensional Conformations

Three fused-ring electron acceptors (FXIC-1, FXIC-2, and FXIC-3) were designed and synthesized. This FXIC series has similar electron-rich central units and the same electron-poor termini. Due to the different steric structures of fluorene, bifluorenylidene, and spirobifluorene, FXIC-1 is a one-dimensional (1D) crystal, while FXIC-2 and FXIC-3 are multidimensional (MD) amorphous materials. The conformations of the FXIC series have a slight impact on their absorption and energy levels. FXIC-1 has higher electron mobility than FXIC-2 and FXIC-3. When blending with different polymer donors (PTB7-Th, J71, and PM7), the FXIC-1-based organic solar cells have efficiencies higher than those of the FXIC-2/FXIC-3-based cells. Meanwhile, the ternary-blend cells based on PTB7-Th:F8IC with FXIC-1, FXIC-2, and FXIC-3 show similar efficiencies, which are all better than those of the binary-blend devices.

High-Performance Fluorinated Fused-Ring Electron Acceptor with 3D Stacking and Exciton/Charge Transport

A new fluorinated electron acceptor (FINIC) based on 6,6,12,12-tetrakis(3-fluoro-4-hexylphenyl)-indacenobis(dithieno[3,2-b;2',3'-d]thiophene) as the electron-donating central core and 5,6-difluoro-3-(1,1-dicyanomethylene)-1-indanone as the electron-deficient end groups is rationally designed and synthesized. FINIC shows similar absorption profile in dilute solution to the nonfluorinated analogue INIC. However, compared with INIC, FINIC film shows red-shifted absorption, down-shifted frontier molecular orbital energy levels, enhanced crystallinity, and more ordered molecular packing. Single-crystal structure data show that FINIC molecules pack into closer 3D "network" motif through H-bonding and π-π interaction, while INIC molecules pack into incompact "honeycomb" motif through only π-π stacking. Theoretical calculations reveal that FINIC has stronger electronic coupling and more molecular interactions than INIC. FINIC has higher electron mobilities in both horizontal and vertical directions than INIC. Moreover, FINIC and INIC support efficient 3D exciton transport. PBD-SF/FINIC blend has a larger driving force for exciton splitting, more efficient charge transfer and photoinduced charge generation. Finally, the organic solar cells based on PBD-SF/FINIC blend yield power conversion efficiency of 14.0%, far exceeding that of the PBD-SF/INIC-based devices (5.1%).

Indeno[1,2-b]thiophene End-capped Perylene Diimide: Should the 1,6-Regioisomers be systematically considered as a byproduct?

Usually considered as a byproduct, the 1,6-dibrominated PDI has rarely been functionalized for the preparation of electro-active conjugated molecules, particularly in the field of organic photovoltaics. In light of the literature, one can ask oneself: Does a 1,7-isomer based functional molecule systematically perform better than its 1,6-analogue? To answer this question, we report herein the synthesis and direct comparison of two indeno[1,2-b]thiophene (IDT) end-capped perylene diimide regioisomers (PDI) (1,6 and 1,7) used as non-fullerene acceptors in organic solar cells. It turned out that in our case, ie, when blended with the well-known PTB7-Th donor polymer, higher performance was reached for devices made with the 1,6-analogue.

Theoretical and experimental investigation on the intersystem crossing kinetics in benzothioxanthene imide luminophores, and their dependence on substituent effects

Substituent induced distortion effects play a crucial role in enhancing the intersystem crossing kinetics in benzothioxanthene imide derivatives.

Facile Synthesis and Evaluation of Electron Transport and Photophysical Properties of Photoluminescent PDI Derivatives

Perylenediimides (PDIs) have emerged as potential materials for optoelectronic applications. In the current work, four PDI derivatives, substituted at imide nitrogen with 2,6-diisopropyl phenyl, 2-nitrophenyl, diphenylmethylene, and pentafluorophenyl groups, have been synthesized from perylene 3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylic dianhydride using a facile imidization synthesis process. PDI derivatives have been spectroscopically characterized for their structure and optical properties. Temperature-variable absorption and emission spectroscopy study confirmed the H-aggregation property. H-aggregation along with strong emission suggests the slipped π-π stacking of PDI molecules. Electrochemical analysis was performed for their redox behavior and calculation of lowest unoccupied molecular orbital and highest occupied molecular orbital energy levels. Scanning electron microscopy showed the formation of ordered structures. The PDI derivatives showed excellent electron conductivity without doping and 5-10× higher electron mobility than that of state-of-the-art fullerene acceptor phenyl-C61-butyric acid methyl ester (PC61BM). Finally, the charge generation and charge transfer phenomenon was studied by transient absorption spectroscopy (TAS). TAS showed ultrafast charge transfer from the poly(3-hexyl)thiophene (P3HT) donor polymer to PDI and formation of long-lived charge-separated states similar to fullerene derivative PC61BM/P3HT blends. Such PDI derivatives with excellent solubility and photophysical and electronic properties are potential n-type materials to be used in organic electronic devices.