Comparison of effectiveness of an 8-mm versus a 4-mm tip electrode catheter for radiofrequency ablation of typical atrial flutter

The use of a high-power (50 W), ablation index-guided protocol for ablation of the cavotricuspid isthmus

BACKGROUND

High-power (HP) ablation protocols are increasingly used for ablation procedures to shorten procedural times and improve short- and long-term success. The ablation index (AI) combines contact force, power settings, and ablation time. It can be used in combination with HP protocols to guide operators toward standardized lesions. The purpose of this study was to evaluate both a HP and AI-guided strategy for ablation of the cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI) in patients with typical atrial flutter (AFL).

METHODS

In this single-center study, consecutive patients with typical AFL (n = 52, mean age 68.7 ± 8.3 years, 21/52 [40.4%] female) underwent AI-guided HP radiofrequency (RF) ablation of the CTI. Ablation was performed with 50 W and AI target values of 550 with a maximum ablation duration of 25 seconds per lesion. Target interlesion distance was ≤6 mm. Ablation was performed with a 3.5 mm porous tip Smarttouch SF catheter.

RESULTS

Acute CTI block was achieved in 52 of 52 patients (100%), and first-pass conduction block was achieved in 41 of 52 patients (80.4%). Spontaneous reconduction after 30 minutes waiting time occurred in 1 of 52 (1.9%) patient. Average ablation time until CTI block was 3:51 ± 1:40; 2:33 ± 1:01 minutes of bonus ablation pulses were applied after CTI block. An audible steam pop was noted in one patient (1.9%). No major complications occurred. After a mean follow-up of 193.7 ± 152.2 days, no patient showed recurrence of typical AFL.

CONCLUSION

In this pilot study, AI-guided HP ablation of the CTI was fast, safe, and effective.

Who Needs Catheter Ablation And Which Approach?

Catheter ablation therapy for atrial fibrillation (AF) has gained a significant role during maintenance of sinus rhythm compared to anti-arrhythmic medication. Catheter ablation techniques are also improved and progressed over years in parallel to better understanding of disease mechanisms and technological advancements. However, due to invasive nature of the therapy with its pertinent procedural risks, both appropriate patient selection and use of relevant approach should be considered by all electrophysiologists before decide to perform catheter ablation.

Radiofrequency catheter ablation of Type 1 atrial flutter using a large-tip electrode catheter and high-power radiofrequency energy generator

Recent studies have demonstrated a high degree of efficacy of 8 mm electrode-tipped or saline-irrigated-tip catheters for ablation of atrial flutter (AFL). These catheters have a theoretical advantage as they produce a large ablation lesion. However, large-tip ablation catheters have a larger surface area and require a higher power radiofrequency (RF) generator with up to 100 W capacity to produce adequate ablation temperatures (50-60 degrees C). The potential advantages of a large-tip ablation catheter and high-power RF generator include the need for fewer energy applications, shorter procedure and fluoroscopy times, and greater efficacy. Therefore, the safety and efficacy of AFL ablation using 8 or 10 mm electrode catheters and a 100-W RF generator was studied using the Boston Scientific, Inc., EPT-1000 XP cardiac ablation system. There were 169 patients, aged 61 +/- 12 years involved. Acute end points were bidirectional isthmus block and no inducible AFL. Following ablation, patients were seen at 1, 3 and 6 months, with event monitoring performed weekly and for any symptoms. Three quality of life surveys were completed during follow-up. Acute success was achieved in 158 patients (93%), with 12 +/- 11 RF energy applications. The efficacy of 8 and 10 mm electrodes did not differ significantly. The number of RF energy applications (10 +/- 8 vs. 14 +/- 8) and ablation time (0.5 +/- 0.4 vs. 0.8 +/- 0.6 h) were less with 10 mm compared with 8 mm electrodes (p < 0.01). Of 158 patients with acute success, 42 were not evaluated at 6 months due to study exclusions. Of the 116 patients evaluated at 6 months, 112 (97%) had no AFL recurrence. Of those without AFL recurrence at 6 months, 95 and 93% were free of symptoms at 12 and 24 months, respectively. Ablation of AFL improved quality of life scores (p < 0.05) and reduced anti-arrhythmic and rate control drug use (p < 0.05). Complications occurred in six out of 169 patients (3.6%) but there were no deaths. It was concluded that ablation of AFL with 8 or 10 mm electrode catheters and a high-power RF generator was safe, effective and improved quality of life. The number and duration of RF applications was lower with 10 mm compared with 8 mm electrode catheters.

2012 HRS/EHRA/ECAS expert consensus statement on catheter and surgical ablation of atrial fibrillation: recommendations for patient selection, procedural techniques, patient management and follow-up, definitions, endpoints, and research trial design

This is a report of the Heart Rhythm Society (HRS) Task Force on Catheter and Surgical Ablation of Atrial Fibrillation, developed in partnership with the European Heart Rhythm Association (EHRA), a registered branch of the European Society of Cardiology and the European Cardiac Arrhythmia Society (ECAS), and in collaboration with the American College of Cardiology (ACC), American Heart Association (AHA), the Asia Pacific Heart Rhythm Society (APHRS), and the Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS). This is endorsed by the governing bodies of the ACC Foundation, the AHA, the ECAS, the EHRA, the STS, the APHRS, and the HRS.

The Results of Radiofrequency Catheter Ablation of Supraventricular Tachycardia in Children

BACKGROUND

Radiofrequency (RF) catheter ablation represents a major advance in the management of children with cardiac arrhythmias and has rapidly become the standard of care for the first-ling therapy of supraventricular tachycardias (SVTs). The purpose of this study was to investigate the results of the RF catheter ablation of SVTs in pediatric patients.

METHODS

From December 1989 to August 2005, a total of 228 pediatric patients (age: 9 +/- 7 years, range: 5-18 years; male:female = 117:111) with clinically documented SVT underwent an electrophysiologic study and RF catheter ablation at our institution.

RESULTS

The arrhythmias included atrioventricular reentrant tachycardia (AVRT; n = 140, 61%), atrioventricular nodal reentrant tachycardia (AVNRT; n = 66, 29%), atrial tachycardia (AT; n = 11, 5%), and atrial flutter (AFL; n = 11, 5%). The success rate of the RF catheter ablation was 92% for AVRT, 97% for AVNRT, 82% for AT, and 91% for AFL, respectively. Procedure-related complications were infrequent (8.7%; major complications: high grade AV block (2/231, 0.9%); minor complications: first degree AV block (6/231, 2.6%), reversible brachial plexus injury (2/231, 0.9%), and local hematomas or bruises (10/231, 4.3%)). The recurrence rate was 4.7% (10/212) during a follow-up period of 86 +/- 38 months (0.5-185 months).

CONCLUSIONS

The RF catheter ablation was a safe and effective method to manage children with paroxysmal and incessant tachycardia. The substrates of the arrhythmias differed between the pediatric and adult patients. However, the success rate of the ablation, complications, and recurrence during childhood were similar to those of adults.

Catheter selection for ablation of the cavotricuspid isthmus for treatment of typical atrial flutter

Radiofrequency catheter ablation (RFA) represents the first line therapy of the cavotricuspid isthmus-dependent atrial flutter (CTI-AFL) with a high efficacy and low secondary effects. RFA of CTI-dependent AFL can be performed by using various types of ablation catheters. Recent evaluations comparing externally cooled tip RFA (ecRFA) catheters and large-tip (8 mm) catheters have revealed that these catheters have a higher efficacy for CTI-AFL ablation compared to 4-mm catheters. The reliability of RFA catheters for AFL is variable and an optimal catheter selection may enhance the RFA effectiveness. The main goal of this article is to review the elements that improve the management of CTI RFA. Preliminary examinations of histopathologic and anatomical elements that may interfere with conventional CTI RFA are presented. Experimental studies concerning the electrobiology of large-tip and cooled-tip catheters are compared. The different catheter designs between cooled-tip and 8-mm-tip catheters are examined (size of the deflectable curve, rotation stability, and size of the distal nonsteerable catheter part) because of their critical role in CTI RFA results. A thorough review of clinical trials of each catheter is presented, and comparison of both catheters in this clinical setting is analyzed. In addition, the role of CTI morphology on AFL RF duration is underlined such as the value of right atrial angiography as an adjunct tool for CTI RFA catheter selection. Based on randomized studies, 8-mm-tip catheters seem to be more effective for ablation in case of straight angiographic isthmus morphology. On the other hand, ecRFA catheters appear to be more effective in cases of complex CTI anatomy or difficult CTI RFA. To reduce X-ray exposition and RFA application time, few studies report that CTI angiographic evaluation before RFA allows a catheter selection based on both CTI morphology and length. Moreover, preliminary data of randomized studies showed that an angiographic isthmus evaluation may predict both the effectiveness of a RFA catheter and the risk of an expensive catheter crossover.

Success rate of catheter ablation in atrial flutter: comparison of a 4- or 5-mm tip electrode catheter with an 8-mm tip electrode catheter

BACKGROUND

Radio frequency (RF) energy is capable of interrupting the reentrant circuit of atrial flutter and curing the arrhythmia. The development of 8-mm tip catheter provides more tissue damage and has offered the promise of improved success. The purpose of our study was to determine if the acute and long-term success with the 8-mm tips were superior to the 4- or 5-mm tips.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The outcomes of the first 20 patients in whom an 8-mm tip catheter was used were compared with the previous 20 patients in whom a 4-or 5-mm tip catheter was used. Procedural (acute) ablation success was defined by creation of bi-directional isthmus block. Long-term success was defined as the prevention of clinically evident atrial flutter (AFl) as determined by the absence of symptoms or maintenance of sinus rhythm on electrocardiogram, six months to one year after the procedure.

RESULTS

Compared to the 4- or 5-mm tip, the 8-mm catheter tip was associated with a reduced ablation duration {22.3 +/- 16 versus 11.5 +/- 5 min (p = 0.0078)}, a lower mean number of ablations {13.5 +/- 9.9 versus 6.8 +/- 2.9 (p = 0.0065)} and a reduced procedure time {1.8 +/- 0.7 versus 1.1 +/- 0.5 h (p = 0.0032)}. Acute success was 95% in the 4- or 5-mm group versus 80% in the 8-mm group (p = NS), but long-term success was higher in the 8-mm group than the 4- or 5-mm group (87.5 versus 63.2%, p = 0.0436).

CONCLUSIONS

Eight-millimeter tip catheters for AFl shorten procedure time, reduce the duration and number of ablations and accomplish bi-directional block when compared with smaller tipped catheters. The long-term success rate is better with the 8-mm tips and should be the preferred catheter for RF ablation of AFl.

Comparison of a Saline Irrigated Cooled-Tip Catheter to Large Electrode Catheters with Single and Multiple Temperature Sensors for Creation of Large Radiofrequency Lesions

BACKGROUND

Several catheter technologies for creating large radiofrequency (RF) lesions are used in clinical practice, but direct comparisons of the pathological lesions created by these technologies are unavailable. The purpose of this study was to compare the safety and efficacy of lesions created by three different large lesion RF ablation technologies.

METHODS AND RESULTS

RF lesions were created in all four chambers of 15 mongrel dogs using 10 mm-tip multiple temperature sensor catheters, 10 mm tip single temperature sensor catheters, and 4 mm cooled-tip catheters. Pathological lesions were bisected, and measured after viability staining. A total of 242 (79 large-tip single sensor, 82 large-tip multiple sensor, and 81 cooled-tip) lesions were created. All atrial lesions were transmural but tended to have larger surface areas with the single thermistor large-tip catheter (73.4 +/- 24.8 mm2) compared to either the multithermistor large-tip (60.9 +/- 28.3 mm2) or the cooled-tip (61.9 +/- 28.5 mm2) catheters (p = 0.07), especially those in the IVC-TA isthmus. Depths and volumes of ventricular lesions created by the multiple-thermistor catheter (5.0 +/- 1.5 mm; 260 +/- 168 mm3) were smaller than either the single thermistor (5.7 +/- 1.5 mm; 428 +/- 290 mm3) or cooled-tip (6.1 +/- 1.8 mm; 403 +/- 217 mm3) catheters (p < 0.05). The difference in the depth and volume of lesions made by large-tip single thermistor and cooled-tip catheters was not significant. Char formation occurred during 11% of ablation with the single thermistor catheter, 6% with multithermistor and 8% of cooled-tip catheter (p = NS). There were no complications of ablation.

CONCLUSIONS

All three catheters reliably created full thickness atrial lesions. For ventricular lesions, depths and volumes were similar for 10 mm-tip single thermistor and cooled-tip catheters. The multithermistor catheter lesions were smaller due to more precise temperature regulated power control. Safety was similar in all 3 groups.

Comparison of the Efficacy of Cooled-Tip and 8-mm-Tip Catheters for Radiofrequency Catheter Ablation of the Cavotricuspid Isthmus: A Meta-Analysis

BACKGROUND

Cooled-tip RFA (cRFA) and conventional 8-mm-tip catheters were found to be more effective and as safe as conventional 4-mm-tip catheters for atrial flutter (AFL) radiofrequency ablation (RFA), facilitating the rapid achievement of bi-directional isthmus block (BIB), but studies comparing cRFA and 8-mm-tip catheters are not randomized or results are discussed. Thus, we performed a meta-analysis of available randomized trials to evaluate the effectiveness in terms of primary success and procedure parameters.

METHODS

Reports of trials were identified through a Medline, Embase, Current Contents, Cardline, and an extensive bibliography search. Trials that met the following criteria were included: (1) prospective, randomized, controlled, and open trials; (2) patients assigned to an 8-mm-tip or a cRFA catheter for AFL RFA; (3) endpoints events related to primary success rate (BIB achievement), and procedure parameters (number of RF applications, x-ray exposure and ablation duration).

RESULTS

Seven trials met the inclusion criteria. They included 603 patients with established AFL randomized to an 8-mm-tip or cRFA catheter group. Comparing 8-mm groups with cRFA groups, the meta-analysis showed similar BIB achievement relative risk (RR) 0.96, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.92 to 1.01, (P = 0.13); total RF application time weighted mean difference (WMD) 0.88, 95% CI: -0.36 to 2.12, (P = 0.16); duration of x-ray exposure (min) (WMD = 1.07, 95% CI: -0.81 to 0.295, (P = 0.26); ablation procedure duration (min) (WMD = 0.68, 95% CI: -3.37 to 4.73; P = 0.74).

CONCLUSION

The present meta-analysis confirms that cooled-tip and large-tip catheters are equally efficient for cavotricuspid isthmus ablation with both similar primary success rates and procedure parameters.

Results of catheter ablation of typical atrial flutter

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the safety and efficacy of radiofrequency (RF) ablation of typical atrial flutter by using an 8-mm electrode catheter and a 100-W RF power generator. A limitation of previous trials of catheter ablation of atrial flutter is that the data were not collected as part of a prospective multicenter clinical trial. The study results associated catheter ablation of typical atrial flutter in a cohort of 150 patients with an 88% acute efficacy rate. At 6-month follow-up, recurrent typical atrial flutter was observed in 13% of patients. Of the 12 patients with typical atrial flutter recurrence, 4 were symptomatic and 8 were asymptomatic. Procedure duration was a significant predictor of typical atrial flutter recurrence. The 12-month rate for development of atrial fibrillation was 30%. Catheter ablation of atrial flutter was associated with significant improvements in 5 of 8 domains of the Short Form 36 Survey (quality of life) and significant decreases in 13 of the 16 symptoms of the Symptom Checklist. The device- or procedure-related complication rate was 2.7%. Skin burns occurred at the dispersive pad site due to stronger RF power in 3 patients. Use of a dual dispersive pad system mitigated this problem. Thus, the results of this study associated catheter ablation of atrial flutter with high acute efficacy, a small risk of recurrent atrial flutter, and an important risk of atrial fibrillation during follow-up.

Radiofrequency catheter ablation of type 1 atrial flutter using large-tip 8- or 10-mm electrode catheters and a high-output radiofrequency energy generator

OBJECTIVES

We studied the safety and efficacy of atrial flutter (AFL) ablation using 8- or 10-mm electrode catheters and a 100-W radiofrequency (RF) generator.

BACKGROUND

Large-tip electrode catheters may be more effective for ablation of AFL.

METHODS

There were 169 patients (age 61 +/- 12 years). Short-term end points were bidirectional isthmus block and no inducible AFL. After ablation, patients were seen at one, three, and six months, with event monitoring performed weekly and for any symptoms. Three quality-of-life (QOL) surveys were completed during follow-up.

RESULTS

Short-term success was achieved in 158 patients (93%), with 12 +/- 11 RF applications. The efficacy of 8- and 10-mm electrodes was similar (p = NS). The number of RF applications (10 +/- 8 vs. 14 +/- 8) and ablation time (0.5 +/- 0.4 h vs. 0.8 +/- 0.6 h) were less with the 10- versus 8-mm electrode, respectively (p < 0.01). Of 158 patients with short-term success, 42 patients were not evaluated for success at six months because of study exclusions. Of 116 patients with short-term success evaluated at six months, 112 (97%) patients had no AFL recurrence. Of those without AFL recurrence at six months, 95% and 93% remained free of symptoms at 12 and 24 months, respectively. Ablation of AFL improved QOL scores (p < 0.05) and reduced anti-arrhythmic and rate-control drug use (p < 0.05). Complications occurred in 6 (3.6%) of 169 patients, but there were no deaths.

CONCLUSIONS

Ablation of AFL with 8- or 10-mm electrode catheters and a high-power RF generator was safe and effective and improved QOL. The number and duration of RF applications were lower with 10- versus 8-mm electrode catheters.

Large tip electrodes for successful elimination of atrial flutter resistant to conventional catheter ablation

The most widely accepted criterion for successful radiofrequency catheter (RFC) ablation of typical atrial flutter is the development of bi-directional isthmus block. In a subset of patients, conventional RFC ablation fails to achieve this endpoint because deeper and wider lesions are required. We investigated the efficacy of a long 8-mm tip catheter in these cases. One hundred and seventy-four consecutive patients (137 male; 61 +/- 9 years) with recurrent typical atrial flutter underwent conventional RFC ablation first with a standard 4 mm tip catheter. In resistant cases (n = 52), ablation was continued using a large tip 8-mm catheter when the 4-mm tip catheter failed. Resistant atrial flutter was identified when 21 RFC pulses failed to reach the selected endpoint of bi-directional isthmus block or in cases of transient bi- directional block (at least 3 episodes). In 122 of the 174 patients (70%) conventional atrial flutter ablation was successfully performed with 13 +/- 5 RFC applications. In the remaining 52 subjects (30%), the ablation procedure was completed using the large tip electrode catheter. In 30 of these 52 patients (58%), the catheter was changed because of persistent intra-atrial conduction after 21 RFC pulses and in 22 (42%) because of intermittent conduction block after 11 +/- 5 applications. Using the large tip electrode catheter, the selected endpoint was achieved in all patients of both groups with 3 +/- 2 RFC pulses (power output of 50-60 W, pulse duration of 60 sec). No post-procedure complications were observed. After 15 +/- 5 months of follow-up, 16 patients (9%) had recurrence of atrial flutter. Five of the patients had been in the resistant group. In patients with atrial flutter resistant to conventional ablation therapy, the long tip (8-mm) catheter appears to be a safe and effective alternative to use of the conventional 4-mm tip catheter.

[Ablation of the cavotricuspid isthmus. Randomized prospective study of radiofrequency ablation with irrigated catheters versus standard catheters]

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES

An important limitation of the ablation with standard catheter is the volume and limited depth of the lesions created. The irrigated catheters, due to a larger and deeper lesion could be useful in patients with typical atrial flutter. The aim of this study was to prospectively compare the ablation procedure with an irrigated-tip catheter versus the standard catheter in this group of patients.

METHODS

A total of 37 consecutive patients referred to ablation of the cavotricuspid isthmus for typical atrial flutter were randomized either to be performed by an standard catheter (20 patients with mean age of 62 18 years, 18 males) or an irrigated-tip catheter (17 patients with mean age 71 4 years, 13 males).

RESULTS

With standard catheters, complete ablation of the cavotricuspid isthmus was achieved in 18 patients (90%). With a mean of 19 15 applications. With the irrigated-tip catheters the complete ablation of the isthmus was achieved with a mean of 8 7 applications (p < 0.001). Both mean duration of the procedure (164 56 versus 70 35 minutes) and fluoroscopic time (40 16 versus 16 8 minutes) was significantly less with irrigated catheters (p < 0.001). There were no significant clinical complications during the procedure nor later on. No patient presented ischemic symptoms nor alterations on the ST segment.

CONCLUSIONS

The employment of irrigated-tip catheters achieved a high success rate with safety shortening the procedure time and radiation exposure.