Relative affinity constants by electrospray ionization and Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry: calmodulin binding to peptide analogs of myosin light chain kinase

Reviewing the experimental and mathematical factors involved in tight binding inhibitors Ki values determination: The bi-functional protease inhibitor SmCI as a test model

Different methodologies for determining the dissociation equilibrium constant (K_i) of protein tight binding inhibitors are frequently found in the scientific literature. Taking into account that the K_i value is the main parameter characterizing the inhibition strength, its determination often represents the first step during the characterization of a potential drug. The purpose of this review is to summarize the current information related to tight binding inhibitors K_i values determination and discuss about the importance of different factors as the enzyme concentration, the inhibitor concentration dilution series, the enzyme-inhibitor incubation time and the dose-response data mathematical fitting. For this aim, the bi-functional SmCI protease inhibitor is used as a tool for exemplifying the experimental and mathematical steps performed during tight binding inhibitors K_i values determination. In addition, the natural and the different recombinant forms of SmCI were used to go deeply into the comparison of some mathematic approaches that are frequently used in the literature. Finally, other biochemical techniques that could be potentially used for tight binding inhibitors K_i values determination are also commented.

Distinct mechanisms of calmodulin binding and regulation of adenylyl cyclases 1 and 8

Calmodulin (CaM), by mediating the stimulation of the activity of two adenylyl cyclases (ACs), plays a key role in integrating the cAMP and Ca(2+) signaling systems. These ACs, AC1 and AC8, by decoding discrete Ca(2+) signals can contribute to fine-tuning intracellular cAMP dynamics, particularly in neurons where they predominate. CaM comprises an α-helical linker separating two globular regions at the N-terminus and the C-terminus that each bind two Ca(2+) ions. These two lobes have differing affinities for Ca(2+), and they can interact with target proteins independently. This study explores previous indications that the two lobes of CaM can regulate AC1 and AC8 differently and thereby yield different responses to cellular transitions in [Ca(2+)](i). We first compared by glutathione S-transferase pull-down assays and offline nanoelectrospray ionization mass spectrometry the interaction of CaM and Ca(2+)-binding deficient mutants of CaM with the internal CaM binding domain (CaMBD) of AC1 and the two terminal CaMBDs of AC8. We then examined the influence of these three CaMBDs on Ca(2+) binding by native and mutated CaM in stopped-flow experiments to quantify their interactions. The three CaMBDs show quite distinct interactions with the two lobes of CaM. These findings establish the critical kinetic differences between the mechanisms of Ca(2+)-CaM activation of AC1 and AC8, which may underpin their different physiological roles.

The effect of calcium ions and peptide ligands on the relative stabilities of the calmodulin dumbbell and compact structures

A combination of ion mobility and mass spectrometry methods was used to characterize the molecular shape of the protein calmodulin (CaM) and its complexes with calcium and a number of peptide ligands. CaM, a calcium-binding protein composed of 148 amino acid residues, was found by X-ray crystallography to occur both in a globular shape and in the shape of an extended dumbbell. Here, it was found, as solutions of CaM and CaM complexes were sprayed into the solvent-free environment of the mass spectrometer, that major structural features of the molecule and the stoichiometry of the units constituting a complex in solution were preserved in the desolvation process. Two types of CaM structures were observed in our experiments: a compact and an extended form of CaM with measured cross sections in near-perfect agreement with those calculated for the known globular and extended dumbbell X-ray geometries. Calcium-free solutions yielded predominantly an extended CaM conformation. Ca(n)(2+)-CaM complexes were observed in calcium-containing solutions, n = 0-4, with the population of the compact conformation increasing relative to the elongated conformation as n increases. For n = 4, a predominantly compact globular conformation was observed. Solutions containing the peptide CaMKII(290-309), the CaM target domain of the Ca(2+)/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) enzyme, yielded predominantly globular Ca(4)(2+)-CaM-CaMKII(290-309) complexes. Similar results were obtained with the 26-residue peptide melittin. For the 14-residue C-terminal melittin fragment, on the other hand, formation of both a 1:1 and a 1:2 CaM-peptide complex was detected. On the basis of the entirety of our results, we conclude that the collapse of extended (dumbbell-like) CaM structures into more compact globular structures occurs upon specific binding of four calcium ions. Furthermore, this calcium-induced structural collapse of CaM appears to be a prerequisite for formation of a particularly stable CaM-peptide complex involving peptides long enough to be engaged in interactions with both lobes of CaM.

The use of ESI-MS to probe the binding of divalent cations to calmodulin

Proteins have evolved with distinct sites for binding particular metal ions. This allows metalloproteins to perform a myriad of specialized tasks with conformations tailor-made by the combination of its primary sequence and the effect on this of the ligated metal ion. Here we investigate the selectivity of the calcium trigger protein calmodulin for divalent metal ions. This ubiquitous and highly abundant protein exists in equilibrium between its apo and its holo form wherein four calcium ions are bound. Amongst its many functions, calmodulin modulates the calcium concentration present in cells, but this functional property renders it a target for competition from other metal ions. We study the competition posed by four other divalent cations for the calcium binding sites in calmodulin using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). We have chosen two other group II cations Mg(2+), Sr(2+), and two heavy metals Cd(2+), Pb(2+). The ease with which each of these metals binds to apo and to holo CaM[4Ca] is described. We find that each metal ion has different properties with respect to calmodulin binding and competition with calcium. The order of affinity for apo CaM is Ca(2+) >> Sr(2+) approximately Mg(2+) > Pb(2+) approximately Cd(2+). In the presence of calcium the affinity alters to Pb(2+) > Ca(2+) > Cd(2+) > Sr(2+) > Mg(2+). Once complexes have been formed between the metal ions and protein (CaM:[xM]) we investigate whether the structural change which must accompanies calcium ligation to allow target binding takes place for a given CaM:[xM] system. We use a 20 residue target peptide, which forms the CaM binding site within the enzyme neuronal nitric-oxide synthase. Our earlier work (Shirran et al. 2005) [1] has demonstrated the particular selectivity of this system for CaM:4Ca(2+). We find that along with Ca(2+) only Pb(2+) forms complexes of the form CaM:4M(2+):nNOS. This work demonstrates the affinity for calcium above all other metals, but also warns about the ability of lead to replace calcium with apparent ease.

Investigation of calmodulin-Peptide interactions using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry

In this report, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) was used to study the binding interactions between calmodulin and two target peptides (melittin and substance P). Various matrix conditions were tested and the less acidic matrix DHAP and THAP were found to favor the survival of the intact calcium-calmodulin as well as the calmodulin-peptide complexes. However, the application of direct MALDI-MS to detect the intact complexes turned out to be very difficult due to the dissociation of the complexes and the formation of nonspecific aggregates. In contrast, the specific binding of the target peptides to calmodulin could be easily deduced using intensity-fading (IF) MALDI-MS. Compared with the nonbinding control, clear reduction in the ion abundances of the target peptides was observed with the addition of calmodulin. Relative binding affinities of different peptides towards the protein could also be estimated using IF-MALDI-MS. This study may extend the application of IF-MALDI-MS in the analysis of noncovalent complexes and offer a perspective into the utility of MALDI-MS as an alternative approach to study the peptides binding to calmodulin.

Conformational chemistry of surface-attached calmodulin detected by acoustic shear wave propagation

A thickness shear-mode acoustic wave device, operated in a flow-through format, was used to detect the binding of ions or peptides to surface-attached calmodulin. On-line surface attachment of the protein was achieved by immobilisation of the biotinylated molecule via a neutravidin-biotin linkage onto the surface of the gold electrode of the detector. The interaction between calmodulin, and calcium and magnesium ions induced an increase in resonant frequency and a decrease in motional resistance, which were reversible on washing with buffer. Interestingly, the changes in resonant frequency and motional resistance induced by the binding were opposite to the normal operation of the detector. The response was interpreted as a decrease in surface coupling (partial slip at the liquid/solid interface) instigated by exposure of hydrophobic domains on the protein, and an increase in the thickness, and hence effective wavelength, of the acoustic device, corresponding to an increase in the length of calmodulin by 1.5 A. This result is consistent with the literature value of 4 A. In addition, the interaction of the protein with peptide together with calcium ions was detected successfully, despite the relatively low molecular mass of the 2-kDa peptide. These results confirm the potential of acoustic wave physics for the detection of changes in the conformational chemistry of monolayer of biochemical macromolecules at the solid/liquid interface.

The formation of a complex between calmodulin and neuronal nitric oxide synthase is determined by ESI-MS

Calmodulin (CaM) is an acidic ubiquitous calcium binding protein, involved in many intracellular processes, which often involve the formation of complexes with a variety of protein and peptide targets. One such system, activated by Ca2+ loaded CaM, is regulation of the nitric oxide synthase (NOS) enzymes, which in turn control the production of the signalling molecule and cytotoxin NO. A recent crystallographic study mapped the interaction of CaM with endothelial NOS (eNOS) using a 20 residue peptide comprising the binding site within eNOS. Here the interaction of CaM to the FMN domain of neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) has been investigated using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). The 46 kDa complex formed by CaM-nNOS has been retained in the gas-phase, and is shown to be exclusively selective for CaM.4Ca2+. Further characterization of this important biological system has been afforded by examining a complex of CaM with a 22 residue synthetic peptide, which represents the linker region between the reductase and oxygenase domains of nNOS. This nNOS linker peptide, which is found to be random coil in aqueous solution by both circular dichroism and molecular modelling, also exhibits great discrimination for the form of CaM loaded with 4[Ca2+]. The peptide binding loop is presumed to be configured to an alpha-helix on binding to CaM as was found for the related eNOS binding peptide. Our postulate is supported by gas-phase molecular dynamics calculations performed on the isolated nNOS peptide. Collision induced dissociation was employed to probe the strength of binding of the nNOS binding peptide to CaM.4Ca2+. The methodology taken here is a new approach in understanding the CaM-nNOS binding site, which could be employed in future to inform the specificity of CaM binding to other NOS enzymes.

Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry studies of noncovalent myosin VI complexes reveal a new specific calmodulin binding site

Among the myosin superfamily, myosin VI differs from all others by a reverse directionality and a particular motility. Little structural information is available for myosin VI. It is known that it binds one calmodulin (CaM) by means of a single "IQ motif" and that myosin VI contains a specific insert located at the junction between the motor domain (MD) and the lever arm, likely to play a critical role for the unusual motility previously observed. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (MS) was used to determine the CaM and Ca2+ stoichiometries in several myosin VI constructs. In particular, the experimental conditions required for the observation of multiprotein/Ca2+ noncovalent assemblies are detailed for two truncated MD constructs (less than 20 kDa) and for three full MD constructs (more than 90 KDa). The specificity of the detected stoichiometries is discussed for each construct and the resolving power of Time of Flight mass spectrometry is stressed, in particular for the detection of metal ions binding to high molecular weight complexes. MS reveals a new CaM binding site for myosin VI and highlights a different behavior for the five myosin VI constructs versus Ca2+ binding. In addition to these stoichiometry based experiments, gas-phase dissociation analyses on intact complexes are described. They reveal that Ca2+ transfer between protein partners occurs during the dissociation process for one construct with a full MD. Charge-transfer and dissociation behavior has allowed to draw structural assumptions for the interaction of the MD with the CaM N-terminal lobe.

The unique insert in myosin VI is a structural calcium-calmodulin binding site

Myosin VI contains an inserted sequence that is unique among myosin superfamily members and has been suggested to be a determinant of the reverse directionality and unusual motility of the motor. It is thought that each head of a two-headed myosin VI molecule binds one calmodulin (CaM) by means of a single "IQ motif". Using truncations of the myosin VI protein and electrospray ionization(ESI)-MS, we demonstrate that in fact each myosin VI head binds two CaMs. One CaM binds to a conventional IQ motif either with or without calcium and likely plays a regulatory role when calcium binds to its N-terminal lobe. The second CaM binds to a unique insertion between the converter region and IQ motif. This unusual CaM-binding site normally binds CaM with four Ca2+ and can bind only if the C-terminal lobe of CaM is occupied by calcium. Regions of the MD outside of the insert peptide contribute to the Ca(2+)-CaM binding, as truncations that eliminate elements of the MD alter CaM binding and allow calcium dissociation. We suggest that the Ca(2+)-CaM bound to the unique insert represents a structural CaM, and not a calcium sensor or regulatory component of the motor. This structure is likely an integral part of the myosin VI "converter" region and repositions the myosin VI "lever arm" to allow reverse direction (minus-end) motility on actin.