Three Dimensional Structure of a Membrane Pore: Electron Microscopical Analysis of Escherichia coli Outer Membrane Matrix Porin

The rare outer membrane protein, OmpL1, of pathogenic Leptospira species is a heat-modifiable porin

The outer membranes of invasive spirochetes contain unusually small amounts of transmembrane proteins. Pathogenic Leptospira species produce a rare 31-kDa surface protein, OmpL1, which has a deduced amino acid sequence predictive of multiple transmembrane beta-strands. Studies were conducted to characterize the structure and function of this protein. Alkali, high-salt, and urea fractionation of leptospiral membranes demonstrated that OmpL1 is an integral membrane protein. The electrophoretic mobility of monomeric OmpL1 was modifiable by heat and reduction; complete denaturation of OmpL1 required prolonged boiling in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), 8 M urea, and 2-mercaptoethanol. When solubilized in SDS at low temperature, a small proportion of OmpL1 exhibited an apparent molecular mass of approximately 90 kDa, indicating the existence of an SDS-unstable oligomer. OmpL1 dimers and trimers were demonstrated by nearest neighbor chemical cross-linking. In order to generate purified protein for functional studies, the ompL1 gene was ligated into the pMMB66 expression plasmid under control of the tac promoter. Although expression in Escherichia coli was toxic, most of the OmpL1 produced was found in the outer membrane, as determined by subcellular fractionation. Purified recombinant OmpL1 was reconstituted into planar lipid bilayers, demonstrating an average single channel conductance of 1.1 nS, similar to the major porin activity of native leptospiral membranes. These findings indicate that OmpL1 spans the leptospiral outer membrane and functions as a porin.

Biophysics of the structure and function of porins

Gram-negative bacteria such asEscherichia coli(E. coli) andSalmonella typhimurium(S. typhimurium) have two layers of membranes in the cellular envelope – the cytoplasmic membrane and the outer membrane (Fig. I). Between these membranes is a periplasmic space in which there is a peptidoglycan layer that provides the cells with mechanical rigidity. In this periplasmic space, there are also a variety of hydrolases and binding proteins. The composition of the outer membrane is somewhat unusual. This membrane bilayer is asymmetric, having an inner (periplasmic) leaflet composed of phospholipids and an outer (extracellular) leaflet formed by lipopolysaccharide (LPS). Unlike phospholipids having two acyl chains, LPS has six or seven saturated fatty acid chains (see reviews, Lugtenberg & Van Alphen, 1983; Nikaido & Vaara, 1985; Nakae, 1986). The head groups of LPS have a strong affinity for divalent cations such as Ca2+, and given a sufficient concentration of these ions the outer membrane can form quite a formidable permeability barrier through this head group/salt bridge network (Nikaido & Vaara, 1985). The function of the outer membrane is to serve as a protective envelope against hostile environments such as those in the intestinal tract of animals where harmful and toxic substances - for example, bile salts and various enzymes - are often found. The outer membrane itself would be impermeable to most hydrophilic solutes were it not for the presence of membrane channels. The presence of a large number of pore-forming proteins provides both specific and nonspecific diffusion pathways across the outer membrane for solutes such as nutrients and waste products to diffuse into or out of the cell.

Polarity-dependent voltage-gated porin channels from Escherichia coli in lipid bilayer membranes

A porin preparation from Escherichia coli 0111:B4 consisting of Omp F and Omp C (with Omp F in excess) was purified by salt extraction procedures and investigated in bilayer lipid membranes formed according to the Montal-Mueller technique. The porin preparation was added to the KCl electrolyte compartment of the Montal-Mueller cell which was connected to the voltage source. As the porin incorporated into the membrane, asymmetric, voltage-gated ion channels were formed. Transmembrane voltages greater than +50 mV (measured with respect to the side of porin addition) caused channel closing, while negative voltages, on the other hand, had no effect on channel behaviour but did increase the rate of porin incorporation at higher voltages. With porin added to both compartments voltage gating no longer occurred. Single-channel conductances corresponded to effective pore diameters of 1.5 nm for opening events and 1.18 nm for channel closing events. The number of charges involved in gating was approximately 2.

Densely packed beta-structure at the protein-lipid interface of porin is revealed by high-resolution cryo-electron microscopy

Porin is an integral membrane protein that forms channels across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. Electron microscopic studies of negatively stained two-dimensional porin crystals have shown three stain accumulations per porin trimer, revealing the locations of pores spanning the membrane. In this study, reconstituted porin lattices embedded in glucose were investigated using the low-dose technique on a cryo-electron microscope equipped with a helium-cooled superconducting objective lens. The specimen temperature was maintained at 5 K to yield an improved microscopic and specimen stability. Under these conditions, we obtained for the first time electron diffraction patterns from porin lattices to a resolution of 3.2 A and images showing optical diffraction up to a resolution of 4.9 A. Applying correlation averaging techniques to the digitized micrographs, we were able to reconstruct projected images of the porin trimer to a resolution of up to 3.5 A. In the final projection maps, amplitudes from electron diffraction and phases from these images were combined. The predominant feature is a high-density narrow band (about 6 A in thickness) that delineates the outer perimeter of the trimer. Since the molecule consists of almost exclusively beta-sheet structure, as revealed by spectroscopic data, we conclude that this band is a cylindrical beta-pleated sheet crossing the membrane nearly perpendicularly to its plane. Another intriguing finding is a low-density area (about 70 A2) situated in the centre of the trimer.

Molecular design of PhoE porin and its functional consequences

The three-dimensional structure of PhoE porin from Escherichia coli, negatively stained with uranyl acetate, has been determined by electron crystallographic techniques to a resolution of about 18 A. The structure shows that PhoE porin consists of trimeric stain-filled channels as the basic unit. The trimeric channels converge as they transverse the membrane but they do not merge. Our three-dimensional structure of PhoE porin indicates that there is a short, narrower segment of channel, which extends beyond the visible strain-filled portion of the channel. The map of glucose-embedded PhoE porin in projection normal to the membrane has also been determined to a resolution of 6.5 A. The projected map shows trimeric ring-like structures, which are presumably cylindrical domains of beta-sheet. At the 3-fold symmetry axis of the trimer, there is a low density region, which is suggested to be a site of lipopolysaccharide that is required for channel and bacteriophage receptor activities. The structural model of the PhoE monomer consists of a flattened cylinder with a large water-filled vestibule about 35 A long with an elliptically shaped opening that is 27 A along the major axis and 18 A along the minor axis. The vestibule has a narrower extension about 10 A long with an average diameter of about 10 A. The vestibule wall is formed by beta-sheet, which may have a large fraction of the beta-strands oriented normal to membrane. Our structural model provides a clue as to how the surface charges on the outer membrane may regulate the permeation of ionic solutes through the channel.

Naturally crystalline porin in the outer membrane of Bordetella pertussis

The Gram-negative bacterium Bordetella pertussis is the agent responsible for whooping-cough, and much interest has focused on the functions, structures and immunological properties of the molecules exposed at its outer surface. We have found by electron microscopy that cells of two strains of B. pertussis are covered with a crystalline surface lattice. This lattice is not an extrinsic layer of high molecular weight glycoproteins, such as occur on many other bacteria, but is a natural crystal of an intrinsic membrane protein of 40,000 Mr. This molecule has been shown to be an anion-selective member of an extensive family of proteins ("porins") that render Gram-negative outer membranes permeable to solutes of up to approximately 650 Mr. Computer image processing reveals a trimeric channel-like structure that closely resembles other porins visualized in artificial arrays after treatment with detergents, but in a novel (p2) crystal form. This correlation provides a "missing link" between earlier structural studies based on artificial arrays of porins (of undefined physiological status), and membrane-permeabilization experiments with solubilized porins (in undefined structural states). For the strains characterized so far, crystallinity of the porin surface lattice shows an intriguing correlation with nonpathogenicity.

High-resolution electron diffraction of reconstituted PhoE porin

PhoE porin has been reconstituted with phospholipid, forming large membrane patches. Electron diffraction shows that the reconstituted PhoE porin forms highly coherent crystalline arrays, giving structural information to a resolution of 3.4 A. The crystal form is of the orthorhombic space group P2(1)2(1)2, with unit cell dimensions a = 150 A and b = 129 A. Images of negatively stained PhoE crystalline patches show that there are four PhoE porin trimers in a unit cell.

Biomembrane structure and function: recent studies and new techniques

The consensus view of biomembrane structure is outlined. The present model is built upon a fluid lipid matrix, usually two molecules in length, into which the proteins are embedded. The lipid bilayer organization is discussed, such as their phase transition and fluid character and the effect of cholesterol upon the chain organization. The non-lamellar arrangement which some lipids adopt is described. The use of new physical techniques for obtaining information about the structure and dynamics of membrane proteins are described. These techniques include electron diffraction, electron microscopy and FTIR spectroscopy. Models of the structures of the Ca2+-ATPase and the glucose transporter from erythrocytes are shown, indicating the putative helices embedded in the lipid bilayer and the groups of amino acids in the aqueous environment. These models are based upon biochemical methods to obtain amino acid sequences using DNA cloning techniques. Finally, an experimental method using triplet probes is described for the study of the rotational dynamics of membrane proteins. Labelled monoclonal antibodies for studying the dynamics of the glucose transporter have been used.

Isolation of the outer membrane and characterization of the major outer membrane protein from Spirochaeta aurantia

The outer membrane of Spirochaeta aurantia was isolated after cells were extracted with sodium lauryl sarcosinate and was subsequently purified by differential centrifugation and KBr isopycnic gradient centrifugation. The purified outer membrane was obtained in the form of carotenoid-containing vesicles. Four protein species with apparent molecular weights of 26,000 (26K), 36.5K, 41K, and 48.5K were readily observed as components of the vesicles. The 36.5K protein was the major polypeptide and constituted approximately 90% of the outer membrane protein observed on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels. Under mild denaturing conditions the 36.5K major protein exhibited an apparent molecular weight of approximately 90,000. This, together with the results of protein cross-linking studies, indicates that the 36.5K polypeptide has an oligomeric conformation in the native state. Reconstitution of solubilized S. aurantia outer membrane into lipid bilayer membranes revealed the presence of a porin, presumably the 36.5K protein, with an estimated channel diameter of 2.3 nm based on the measured single channel conductance of 7.7 nS in 1 M KCl.

Channel-closing activity of porins from Escherichia coli in bilayer lipid membranes

The opening and closing of the ompF porin from Escherichia coli JF 701 was investigated by reconstituting the purified protein into planar bilayer membranes. The electrical conductance changes across the membranes at constant potential were used to analyze the size and aggregate nature of the porin channel complexes and the relative number of opening and closing events. We found that, when measured at pH 5.5, the channel conductance diminished and the number of closing events increased when the voltage was greater than 100 mV. The results suggest that the number of smaller sized conductance channels increases above this potential. There was also an increase in the smaller subunits and in the closing events when the pH was lowered to 3.5, and these changes were further enhanced by increasing the voltage. We propose that both lowering the pH and elevating the potential across the membrane stabilize the porin in a conformation in which the subunits are less tightly associated and the subunits open in a non-cooperative manner. These same conditions also appear to stabilize the closed state of the pore.

In vitro synthesized bacterial outer membrane protein is integrated into bacterial inner membranes but translocated across microsomal membranes

The LamB protein is an integral membrane protein of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. We have now found that, when synthesized in an E. coli cell-free translation system supplemented with inverted vesicles derived from the E. coli inner membrane, LamB protein is integrated into the vesicle membrane as assayed by its resistance to extraction at alkaline pH. These data suggest that the inner membrane is the primary site for integration of LamB protein prior to subsequent sorting to the outer membrane. When synthesized in a wheat germ cell-free translation system supplemented with canine microsomal membranes, LamB protein is glycosylated at one or two cryptic sites, and surprisingly, it is translocated across instead of being integrated into the vesicle membrane. We suggest that the translocation machinery of the microsomal membrane, although able to recognize the signal sequence(s) of LamB, is unable to recognize its stop-transfer sequence(s), thereby yielding translocation instead of integration.

Outer-membrane permeability of bacteria

Gram-negative bacteria evolved to survive under the conditions in which a number of hazardous compounds are abundant. The outer membrane which protects the cell interior acts as a barrier against such hazardous agents, yet the cells must incorporate the chemicals that are essential for the cellular activity. The devices that Gram-negative bacteria developed to incorporate such essence are the transmembrane pores. These pores could be subdivided into three categories: (1) pore made of porins has a weak solute selectivity; (2) pore made of lamB protein and tsx proteins hold intermediate solute specificity. and (3) pores for the diffusion of vitamin B12 and ferric ion-chelator complexes have a tight solute specificity. Porins are identified from a number of Gram-negatives and from the outer membrane of mitochondria of various sources. Studies on the diffusion properties of these outer-membrane proteins provided essential information to understand membrane transports.

Folding patterns of porin and bacteriorhodopsin

Porin spans the outer membrane of Escherichia coli with most of the protein embedded within the membrane. It lacks pronounced hydrophobic domains and consists predominantly of beta-pleated sheet. These observations require the accommodation of polar and ionizable residues in an environment that has a low dielectric constant. Owing to a currently limited understanding of the constraints governing membrane protein structure, a minimal approach to structure prediction is proposed that identifies segments causing polypeptides to reverse their direction (turn identification). The application of this procedure avoids hydrophobicity parameters and yields a model of porin which is in good agreement with all experimental data available. The presence of polar and ionizable residues within membrane boundaries implies a dense (saturating) network of hydrogen bond donor and acceptor groups. Application to a paradigm of hydrophobic membrane proteins, bacteriorhodopsin, reveals a pattern consistent with its alpha-helical folding. The postulated structure includes significantly more polar residues in the membrane domain than have been assumed previously, suggesting that there are also hydrogen bonding networks in bacteriorhodopsin. Extensive networks permeating protein interior and surfaces would explain the extraordinary stability and the tight interactions between functional units in the formation of crystalline arrays of both proteins.

Secondary structure of a channel-forming protein: porin from E. coli outer membranes

Porin from Escherichia coli outer membranes has been analysed by high angle diffuse X-ray diffraction, and by attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy. These methods demonstrate independently that the majority of the polypeptide backbone is arranged in anti-parallel beta-pleated sheet structure. The average length of the beta-strands, which are oriented nearly normal to the membrane plane, is estimated to be 10-12 residues, independent of the method used. Although the details of strand arrangement (beta-barrels or stacked sheets) are not as yet known, porin represents the first transmembrane protein for which beta-structure has been established unequivocally.

Secondary structure of a channel-forming protein: porin from E. coli outer membranes

Porin from Escherichia coli outer membranes has been analysed by high angle diffuse X-ray diffraction, and by attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy. These methods demonstrate independently that the majority of the polypeptide backbone is arranged in anti-parallel beta-pleated sheet structure. The average length of the beta-strands, which are oriented nearly normal to the membrane plane, is estimated to be 10-12 residues, independent of the method used. Although the details of strand arrangement (beta-barrels or stacked sheets) are not as yet known, porin represents the first transmembrane protein for which beta-structure has been established unequivocally.

New biophysical techniques and their application to the study of membranes

Images

Projected structure of the pore-forming OmpC protein from Escherichia coli outer membrane

A single-projection structure analysis of a bacterial outer membrane protein, OmpC, has been carried out by electron microscopy of frozen hydrated specimens. Two distinct crystal polymorphs have been observed in the frozen-hydrated samples, and projection structures of both forms have been obtained to a resolution of 13.5 A. Preliminary examination of negatively stained samples revealed the expected, trimeric appearance of pores in the OmpC specimens. Electron microscopy of unstained, frozen-hydrated OmpC reveals the trimeric pore structure with equal clarity. In addition, the overall molecular envelope of the protein is readily discerned, and a major lipid-containing domain can also be seen. Because of the small coherent patch size, mosaic disorder, and unpredictable polymorphism of the presently available specimens, three-dimensional reconstruction of frozen-hydrated OmpC has not been carried out.

Ion selectivity of gram-negative bacterial porins

Twelve different porins from the gram-negative bacteria Escherichia coli, Salmonella typhimurium, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Yersinia pestis were reconstituted into lipid bilayer membranes. Most of the porins, except outer membrane protein P, formed large, water-filled, ion-permeable channels with a single-channel conductance between 1.5 and 6 nS in 1 M KCl. The ions used for probing the pore structure had the same relative mobilities while moving through the porin pore as they did while moving in free solution. Thus the single-channel conductances of the individual porins could be used to estimate the effective channel diameters of these porins, yielding values ranging from 1.0 to 2.0 nm. Zero-current potential measurements in the presence of salt gradients across lipid bilayer membranes containing individual porins gave results that were consistent with the conclusions drawn from the single-channel experiments. For all porins except protein P, the channels exhibited a greater cation selectivity for less mobile anions and a greater anion selectivity for less mobile cations, which again indicated that the ions were moving inside the pores in a fashion similar to their movement in the aqueous phase. Three porins, PhoE and NmpC of E. coli and protein P of P. aeruginosa, formed anion-selective pores. PhoE and NmpC were only weakly anion selective, and their selectivity was dependent on the mobility of the ions. In contrast, cations were unable to enter the selectivity filter of the protein P channel. This resulted in a high anion selectivity for all salts tested in this study. The other porins examined, including all of the known constitutive porins of the four gram-negative bacteria studied, were cation selective with a 3- to 40-fold preference for K+ ions over Cl- ions.

Porin from bacterial and mitochondrial outer membranes

The outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria acts as a molecular filter with defined exclusion limit for hydrophilic substances. The exclusion limit is dependent on the type of bacteria and has for enteric bacteria like Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium a value between 600 and 800 Daltons, whereas molecules with molecular weights up to 6000 can penetrate the outer membrane of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The molecular sieving properties result from the presence of a class of major proteins called porins which form trimers of identical subunits in the outer membrane. The porin trimers most likely contain only one large but well-defined pore with a diameter between 1.2 and 2 nm. Mitochondria are presumably descendents of gram-negative bacteria. The outer membrane of mitochondria contains in agreement with this hypothesis large pores which are permeable for hydrophilic substances with molecular weights up to 6000. The mitochondrial porins are processed by the cell and have molecular weights around 30,000 Daltons. There exists some evidence that the pore is controlled by electric fields and metabolic processes.